Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the ongoing debate about gun control in the United States, particularly in the wake of the Parkland shooting. The conversation revolves around the National Rifle Association (NRA) and its response to the movement for stricter gun laws.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Upbeat music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, Sean, where are we right now?
Noel King
We are outside. It's sunny. It's beautiful. Connecticut and Rhode Island, Washington, D.C. Walking down the street, having a great time.
Sean Rameswaram
Do you know where we're going?
Noel King
Oh, you know where we're going. We're going to Mattress Firm.
Sean Rameswaram
Yes! Yes! MattressFirm.com. Podcast 10 gets you 10% off. Before June 5th now. They keep extending it.
Noel King
That's great! It's great for someone.
Sean Rameswaram
The thing about America's gunfight is that it comes and goes in waves. Everything is chill, everyone's just doing their thing, minding their business. And then all of a sudden, there's a mass shooting, and we're at each other's throats.
Noel King
But this weekend, our national conversation about guns was re-energized in two dramatically different ways. Childish Gambino released a new song and video for This Is America. The video features Childish Gambino acting out some casual mass murder and literally singing and dancing away from the violence. It's stunning, it's thought-provoking, and it's already been viewed tens upon tens of millions of times online.
Sean Rameswaram
On the same weekend, over in Texas, the NRA held its 147th annual convention in Dallas. Unlike the previous 146 conventions, this one was held in the shadow of a national movement led by Parkland students to increase gun control to change the relationship between politicians and the NRA.
Noel King
And you could hear that movement in all the big convention speeches, from NRA leader Wayne Lapierre, "Whenever a good guy with a gun runs toward the gunfire, the madness stops quickly."
Sean Rameswaram
To Vice President Mike Pence. "Firearms in the hands of law-abiding citizens makes our communities more safe, not less."
Noel King
To President Donald Trump. "Your Second Amendment rights are under siege, but they will never, ever be under siege as long as I'm your president."
Sean Rameswaram
This is America, where we always seem to be having two very different conversations about guns. And the president seems to be having both of them himself. After Parkland, he was open to expanding universal background checks and raising age restrictions on gun purchases. But this weekend, he doubled down on Second Amendment rights.
Noel King
It seems that if we're going to outlaw guns, like so many people want to do, Democrats, you better get out and vote. Then we will get and you know what I'm going to say we are going to have to outlaw immediately all vans and all trucks which are now the new form of death for the maniac terrorists right this line is really stupid because if we had the same laws for guns that we have for like using and owning a car, our gun laws would be way stricter.
Sean Rameswaram
Herman Lopez reports on Guns for Vox, and I asked him if anyone speaking at the NRA convention made any sort of post-Parkland concessions.
Herman Lopez
No, not really. Mike Pence had this memorable moment where he called for the media to cover more good guys with guns. But too often, many in the national media all but ignore what happens when well-trained, law-abiding gun owners save lives. It's the truth.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's like, well, maybe the media focuses more on the bad guys because there are more bad guys. I mean, if you just look at the statistics, guns are used way more, about 30 times more, for criminal homicides than they are for self-defense, justified homicides.
Noel King
How was the NRA affected by this whole movement in the past few months? Was membership up, down, donations up, down? Is this convention bigger, smaller?
Herman Lopez
The one thing we do know is that donations to the NRA spiked in the aftermath of the shooting, which is typically what happens after mass shootings when there's more discussions about gun control.
Sean Rameswaram
So we haven't really seen the NRA get weaker in that way. What we have seen is at least some politicians more willing to speak out against the NRA.
Herman Lopez
I mean, one of the things that really remarkable about the Parkland protests and March for Our Lives and that kind of thing is that they really emphasize that their enemy was the NRA in a way that previous politicians and gun control advocates, I mean, they always called out the NRA, but this was like making them public enemy number one.
Sean Rameswaram
We cannot move on. If we move on, the NRA and those against us will win. They want us to forget. They want our voices to be silenced. And they want to retreat into the shadows where they can remain unnoticed. They want to be back on top unquestioned in their corruption.
Herman Lopez
But we cannot and we will not let that happen. So maybe in that way, the reputation has been heard.
Sean Rameswaram
And we have seen the reputation heard in terms of polling. What have you seen there? Do you know?
Herman Lopez
An NBC Wall Street Journal poll found that for the first time, Americans have a negative view overall of the NRA. The first time since 2000. 40% of Americans have a negative view and 37% of a positive view.
Sean Rameswaram
Has that changed anything at the NRA or are they sort of continuing to follow their so-called playbook after the shooting?
Herman Lopez
It's pretty much the same old NRA. Their strategy for all these mass shootings has consistently been to just kind of wait it out. And then as time goes on, They like ramp up their typical message like we need good guys with guns. We support the Second Amendment. This is necessary to support your other civil liberties, that kind of thing.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's basically what they've done in the time since.
Noel King
Many in legacy media love mass shootings. You guys love it. Now, I'm not saying that you love the tragedy. But I am saying that you love the ratings. Crying white mothers are ratings gold to you and many in the legacy media in the back.
Sean Rameswaram
What about the rank and file of the NRA? Any difference there? Were there people who were NRA members who were speaking out in favor of expanding background checks or any of these measures that these Parkland kids were proposing?
Herman Lopez
I mean, this is something that you see in general in the great majority of American support, expanding background checks. It's like 80 plus percent of Americans do based on polling. And that applies to gun owners as well. And it applies to NRA members as well. A majority of them support expanding background checks.
Sean Rameswaram
In the end, the NRA as an organization actually pushes against expanding background checks at basically every opportunity at the local, state, and federal level.
Noel King
All right, Sean, we're getting there. We're almost a Mattress Firm. But haven't we already done this? Didn't you and I once go to a Mattress Firm?
Sean Rameswaram
Luke Vanderplug, we did. Yeah, but in that case, You were holding the mic and I was testing the mattresses. Remember that?
Noel King
That's true. So are you just going to flip it on them? Why not? I mean, mattresses are for flipping, right? Are you supposed to flip your mattress? I don't think so. I'm pretty sure it just goes one side up.
Sean Rameswaram
Oh, man. Well, I mean, I'm open to it. If you think it'll be different in some way, will it be different?
Noel King
Well, I mean, here's the thing. We discovered through a series of experiments that a medium firmness mattress was my kind of mattress, right? But that's not everybody's mattress. You think I might be a soft or a medium guy? Maybe a firm. I could be a firm. I do have a pinched nerve from too much podcasting, so firm might be good for me.
Sean Rameswaram
I think the firmer the mattress, the better it is on your orthopedics. Okay, sold. Let's go try this at the Mattress Firm. Mattressfirm.com slash explained. Slash podcast. You need to start listening to our show.
Noel King
I know that Mattressfirm.com. My name is Scott Popolardo. I'm from Orange County, New York. I believe I joined the NRA when I was about 20, and I was a member all through my 20s, probably stopped somewhere about 30.
Scott Popolardo
At that time, there was no particular reason I didn't disagree with their agenda back then. It was just something I didn't renew.
Sean Rameswaram
Scott may have left the NRA years ago, but there was no changing the way he felt about guns. I mean, he has the Second Amendment tattooed on his arm.
Scott Popolardo
But then the shooting in Parkland happened, and he didn't just want to get rid of his AR he wanted to destroy it I mean think about it Is the right to own this weapon more important in someone life I don't think so So I going to make sure that will never happen with my weapon I posted it on my, it was basically my wife's Facebook account. She has 150 friends on it.
Sean Rameswaram
I didn't expect it to obviously hit 30 million people.
Scott Popolardo
When Sandy Hook happened, I said to my wife that I would gladly get rid of it if it would save one child. And I didn't do anything then. And then after Parkland, I just, I sat there pretty much glued to the television, just watching these kids come out of the school and watching their faces.
Noel King
And, you know, it just, like I said, it got to me. And, you know, when I bought that rifle when I was 18, I liked what it represented. that it was cool, it represented the military, and, you know, the gun you saw in the movies, and now it just represents hate and destruction and death.
Scott Popolardo
So to me, the only way to responsibly get rid of it was to destroy it. The outpouring of support that I got was overwhelming. As far as hate goes, you know, I had a lot of people to do good. Now that he doesn't have any guns, let's go to his house and kill him or rob him. You know, that type of thing. But all the hate I didn't really pay much mind to.
Sean Rameswaram
I'd rather focus on the positive part of it. And a lot of people are brave when they're sitting behind a keyboard. People just fear, and the NRA is fairly responsible for this. They put a fear in the people that we're just going to come knock on the door and take all their guns away. And that's not going to happen.
Scott Popolardo
My personal feeling is all firearms should come with a title just like a car does and you have to transfer it from owner to owner so there is a trail of where that gun goes this is in the hands of the young people they have to get out there and vote because that's the only way to change it because the nra's membership is only five million strong and the majority of the people in the united States are not gun owners.
Noel King
So if you want changes, they have to get out there and vote. And the young people is where the vote is going to be the strongest.
Sean Rameswaram
Herman, President Trump and the NRA were clearly towing the line this weekend, but this movement has seen some gains at the state level, right?
Herman Lopez
Yeah, there have been, I think, a few notable moments that were gun control victories. I mean, there have been a few articles just labeling this as like the NRA is on a losing streak.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay. So one is Florida passed tougher gun laws. One of them is boosting the age of people who are allowed to buy rifles. 18 to 21. 18 to 21, that's right.
Herman Lopez
And they also made it easier for the police to take guns away from somebody who's suspicious. And they've already used this ability, according to some reports, to prevent what they thought might have been some really bad shootings.
Sean Rameswaram
Another notable example is Vermont, which is, even though it's generally a democratic state, it's also been very, very friendly to guns. And it passed a suite of gun laws signed by the Republican governor there, basically strengthening background checks.
Herman Lopez
I mean, it was like a really typical package of gun laws aimed at restricting access to guns, particularly for like anybody who's a criminal purchasing a gun and that kind of thing.
Sean Rameswaram
And I think the last example it's worth pulling out is Kansas, which is absolutely not the most liberal state in the country. Very red state. Yeah. Very pro-gun. And it passed a law essentially making it harder for people convicted of domestic abuse from getting a firearm.
Herman Lopez
So, I mean, these are like three examples of notable changes in state laws, at least. And they kind of like set the scene. Like if you talk to gun control activists, they say that there is a lot of energy behind them right now.
Sean Rameswaram
If you look at the polling, that's now dwindling a bit. It always seems different after a mass shooting, but you can't deny that this time is different because you had tens of thousands of people across the country marching back in March in the March for Our Lives and all these walkouts organized throughout the country, which also feels different.
Herman Lopez
Right, but you also can't deny that there are states that are actually loosening their gun laws. Just this past week, the Oklahoma legislature passed a bill that would allow people to carry guns without any sort of license or permit.
Sean Rameswaram
And there are similar laws in place already in a bunch of other states. But this is like something we've seen time and time again. While blue states generally are moving towards tougher gun laws, red states generally are responding toward laxer gun laws.
Herman Lopez
I mean, you see this ideological divide that liberals and Democrats generally believe that guns make things more dangerous. More access to guns equals more gun violence. and conservatives and Republicans generally believe that well when you relax access to guns and more people can defend themselves that reduces gun violence
Sean Rameswaram
One of the most memorable things that happened in the weeks after Parkland was this town hall in Florida where Marco Rubio was answering questions students had and got called out basically Senator Rubio, can you tell me right now that you will not accept a single donation from the NRA?
Herman Lopez
No, the answer to the question is that people buy into my agenda. And that's why I support the things that I have stood for and fought for during my time where. More NRA money? More NRA money? That is the wrong way to look.
Sean Rameswaram
First of all, the answer is people buy into my agenda. You could say no. Well, I said I got the influence of any group. We're going to be here all night. The influence of these groups comes not from money. The influence comes from the millions of people that agree with the agenda.
Herman Lopez
Nothing really came of that, of course, as far as legislation is concerned in D.C. How is this not even like a blip on Congress's radar?
Sean Rameswaram
The simple fact of the matter is that Republicans own every level of government right now. They own Congress and the White House. And they have generally been supportive of gun rights.
Herman Lopez
I mean, one of their biggest backers in terms of a public organization is the NRA. Their base is very, very supportive of gun rights. Basically, if you're a Republican, you have to constantly fear that if you support even the slightest extra restriction on firearms, you will be primaried and you will lose because your very core base is very supportive of the right to bear arms.
Sean Rameswaram
The other thing about this is that if you imagine the typical supporter of gun rights, you're thinking of somebody who's really passionate, really supports their right to bear arms, and will make it a single issue for them. If you try to imagine the equivalent of that on the left, it's just not nearly as common.
Herman Lopez
Like people who are liberal do tend to support stricter laws regarding firearms. That's for sure true. But they generally have a bunch of other issues on their radar that take priority. So health care, the economy, in some cases, national security, racism, like social justice, like all these other things take priority.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's why we see Congress, even when it's controlled by Democrats, this issue just very often does not come to the top of the list for them because the base on the left is much less motivated by guns than the base on the right is.
Herman Lopez
So if a bill comes to Congress that's going to expand background checks, if you're a Republican, you're going to be flooded with calls by people who support gun rights. If you're a Democrat, you might get some calls, but it's not going to be nearly as passionate.
Sean Rameswaram
And you see this in public polling that generally people who support stricter gun laws are much less likely to contact their representative in Congress about it.
Noel King
I wonder, as someone who's been covering this issue for several years now, where do you look to see how this country is sort of progressing or maybe even moving backwards?
Herman Lopez
One is that in the long term, America is moving toward the direction of supporting stricter gun laws. In the short term, though, after mass shootings, we see this up where people support more restrictions on guns and then this down where people, like that just fades away over time.
Sean Rameswaram
People start losing interest in the issue or whatever. So I think keeping that in mind, I think what's important to look at is that there is something sustaining interest in this issue. It's not enough for people to care immediately after a mass shooting. If real change is going to happen, people have to sustain the momentum.
Herman Lopez
Herman Lopez is a senior reporter at Vox. I'm Sean Rameswaram. This is Today Explained.
Upbeat music starts playing
Sean Rameswaram
All right, Sean, we have arrived. Can you tell us, where are we?
Noel King
We are at the friendly neighborhood Mattress Firm location in DuPont Circle, Washington, D.C. Nice. Yeah, should we head inside? Why not?
Sean Rameswaram
And I should point out probably before we enter that there's another option here. You can just visit Mattressfirm.com slash podcast and get 10% off using the coupon code podcast10. Sounds good to me. But why not visit a store sometimes? Why not?