Main Topic: The affordability crisis in the United States and President Trump's inability to deliver on his promise of lower prices.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Overall, this episode of Today Explained highlights the disconnect between politicians' promises and the reality of inflation, and explores the complexities of the affordability crisis in the United States.
The affordability crisis is not entirely the president's fault. But he promised lower prices, and now it is his problem.
This episode was produced by Hady Mawajdeh, edited by Jolie Myers, fact-checked by Melissa Hirsch and Ariana Aspuru, engineered by Patrick Boyd and Adriene Lilly, and hosted by Noel King.
Shoppers looking at a canned fish display at a store in South Burlington, Vermont. Photo by Robert Nickelsberg/Getty Images.
Listen to Today, Explained ad-free by becoming a Vox Member: vox.com/members. New Vox members get $20 off their membership right now. Transcript at vox.com/today-explained-podcast.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Theme music fades out
Noel King
There are some real signs that President Trump and his economic advisors are starting to freak out over our freak out over the cost of living.
Victoria Guida
First, there was the unprompted lie told during a cabinet meeting in late August. Groceries are down. Energy is way down. Energy is way down. Eggs are way down. Thank you very much. When we came in, the eggs were through the roof. They were four times. That was caused by Biden or whoever was operating the auto pen, actually.
Noel King
Then came the dodge. The reason I don't want to talk about affordability is because everybody knows that it's far less expensive under Trump than it was under Sleepy Joe Biden.
Victoria Guida
Then he started talking about cutting you a check. We're going to issue a dividend to... And then on Friday, Trump removed or lowered tariffs on more than 200 foods, including beef, coffee, tomatoes and bananas.
Noel King
Ahead on Today Explained, President Trump got elected in part because he promised to lower prices. What happens if he can't?
Commercial break
Welcome back to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King. Victoria Guida is here. She's an economics correspondent for Politico. So owing to inflation, prices were a big talking point during last year's presidential campaign. Trump and Kamala Harris both made a lot of promises. Both of them were talking about ways to bring down prices.
Victoria Guida
And President Trump actually said that he would bring down the price of everything. So when I win, I will immediately bring prices down starting on day one. I will end the devastating inflation crisis immediately, bring down interest rates and lower the cost of energy.
Noel King
And Kamala Harris, his opponent, was talking about building an opportunity economy. An opportunity economy where everyone has the chance to compete and a chance to succeed.
Victoria Guida
Ultimately, it seems like voters decided they believed Donald Trump more. Why do you think that is? Why did people think he's going to be the one to bring prices down?
Noel King
So under his first term, inflation was pretty low. And so I think people remembered that the economy was actually quite good. And the Biden years were very turbulent. And, you know, not all of that was his fault. A lot of that was coming out of the pandemic.
Victoria Guida
And people felt sort of whiplash. And so they were sort of looking to that pre-pandemic period. And then, you know, President Trump is also affiliated with business, right? He's a business guy. He's a real estate guy. And so they wanted somebody who, you know, seemed like he knew what he was doing.
Noel King
In January, President Trump takes office. And I think the assumption among a lot of people was he's going to get started right away. What actually did happen beginning in January?
Victoria Guida
So on the economic side, the big thing that he did pretty early was the tariffs. Starting tomorrow, the United States will implement reciprocal tariffs on other nations.
Noel King
It's been a long time since we even thought of that. Which is interesting because he actually did run on tariffs, right? And it was sort of alongside this idea that he was going to bring down prices, even though those things are not totally consistent, right?
Victoria Guida
Like the point of tariffs is, you know, maybe you're more willing to deal with higher prices because you want to bring back jobs. And so he put a bunch of tariffs in place and that has pushed up the prices of some things.
Noel King
I think in the American economy, there are like a couple of big line items in everybody's budget. And maybe the first one we could talk about is energy and gas, people's electricity bills, people's gas bills.
Victoria Guida
What has happened with prices there in the second Trump term? So there's a couple of different stories. So electricity costs have gone up a lot.
Noel King
The state of Maine, you're looking at a 26% increase in residential electricity prices. Millions of New Jersey households could see a rate hike ranging anywhere from roughly 17 to 20%.
Victoria Guida
Economists are saying electricity prices are climbing more than twice as fast as inflation is. And that varies a little bit depending on where you are in the country.
Noel King
There's a whole bunch of different things that contributes to that, like the fact that the electrical grid is aging and it's expensive to upkeep and things like that.
Victoria Guida
But also, I mean, one thing that you do hear people point to that's a policy thing is that President Trump has also been very opposed to green energy.
Noel King
We will drill, baby, drill. We will not allow a windmill to be built in the United States. They're killing us.
Victoria Guida
And we don't want the solar panels that I'm speaking with the secretary about because they take up thousands of acres of our farmland.
Noel King
Whereas, you know, what you hear from a lot of businesses is, you know, we want a kind of all of the above approach, right? Like President Trump wants to be more pro-fossil fuel than Biden was, which, you know, businesses love.
Victoria Guida
But it's also kind of like, but we kind of need energy wherever we can get it.
Noel King
In terms of gas prices, it's roughly where it was a year ago. But I will say gas prices over the course of this year have actually been a bit lower than they were last year.
Victoria Guida
The next big line item for a lot of people is going to be groceries. And here, President Trump has been very interesting because he has talked about groceries.
Noel King
It's not like he's ignoring them. Groceries. It's a very simple word, groceries. It's such an old-fashioned term, but a beautiful term, groceries.
Victoria Guida
The word grocery, it's sort of a simple word, but it sort of means like everything you eat.
Noel King
What has happened with the price of groceries since January?
Victoria Guida
So the price of groceries have gone up. Prices for roasted coffee rising almost 21 in the past year.
Noel King
Brown beef is up 11 and a half percent. Eggs still higher than a year ago. Apples bananas just about everything you can think of is rising here.
Victoria Guida
We continued to see prices go up. And again, with the tariffs, that's the type of thing where we're actually seeing President Trump over the last, just in recent days, starting to soften on these tariffs that are on food products, which is, you know, maybe an implicit acknowledgement that these are pushing up the prices.
Noel King
I mean, I think it is sort of like a gentle acknowledgement that lowering tariffs on things like coffee and bananas will make those things cheaper for consumers.
Victoria Guida
And then the last big one would be housing. Is rent cheaper? Are mortgages, are people paying less on their mortgages since January?
Noel King
Rent is still rising, to answer your question. But I will say that it is actually rising a lot more slowly than it had been.
Victoria Guida
And part of the reason is because you've seen actually at the state and local level a lot of moves to build more housing. And that's been helping.
Noel King
In terms of mortgages, absolutely not. I mean, interest rates are high and the Federal Reserve has actually cut interest rates a bit.
Victoria Guida
The problem is that when you have mortgage rates come down a little bit, what happens is more people want to buy houses, which when you don't have enough housing, just pushes up the cost of houses.
Noel King
So housing overall is still very expensive.
Victoria Guida
OK, so your average American is not unaware that prices mostly are going up and not coming down. Your average American voted for Donald Trump.
Noel King
How has Trump reacted to the criticism that he hasn't managed to do what he said he was going to do?
Victoria Guida
So initially, his message was, you know, the economy is great. The economy is doing great. The stock market's higher now than when I came to office.
Noel King
We have no inflation. The biggest thing is inflation, and it's way down. Everything's going really well. We have the greatest economy right now.
Victoria Guida
A lot of people don't see that. Tariffs are not pushing up prices, although he was a little bit squishy on that one.
Noel King
Tariffs don't cause inflation. They cause success. They cause big success.
Victoria Guida
So we're going to have great success. There could be some temporary short-term disruption, and people will understand that.
Noel King
But he was really upbeat on how the economy was doing.
Victoria Guida
And then we just had an election earlier this month. It was an off-year election. But the results were really striking, where the Democrats did really well in Virginia, New Jersey, in New York City.
Noel King
We saw Zeran Mamdani win the mayoral race on affordability issues. And so it seems like since then, he's sort of softened his tone.
Victoria Guida
I mean, he's still making the argument that, you know, basically they've addressed inflation. but he's also been putting out a lot of ideas of ways that, you know, that they can bring down the cost of living.
Noel King
On Friday, President Trump signed an executive order. This order exempts hundreds of products from the president's so-called reciprocal tariffs, a move aimed at lowering grocery prices.
Victoria Guida
We're going to have some little price reductions and in some cases some pretty good ones. And also softening a little bit, as I mentioned earlier, on sort of tariffs on things like food.
Noel King
What are some of the ideas to bring down the cost of living? What are we hearing specifically from the White House?
Victoria Guida
So one of the ideas that he put out there was the idea of a 50-year mortgage. That is something that it's unclear whether that's actually something they're going to move forward with.
Noel King
There seems to be skepticism even within the White House about this idea. Is that because it's just such a patently bad idea?
Victoria Guida
Well, I don't know that it's like particularly bad. It just wouldn't really help anything. You know, the idea of a 50-year mortgage is you have lower monthly payments, but you probably will pay a higher interest rate.
Noel King
And the real problem is the way that mortgages are structured, even like a 30-year mortgage, right, is you pay much higher interest in the early years than you do principal.
Victoria Guida
So you're not actually getting equity, getting an ownership, like a bigger, bigger ownership stake until you get well into the mortgage.
Noel King
And so if you have a 50-year mortgage, that's going to push that out even more. And so it's kind of like, you know, you might be getting like a little bit of ownership year after year, but at a certain point it becomes like a little bit indistinguishable from just paying rent.
Victoria Guida
Hmm. The president in his first term, he had a lot of success with the American people during the pandemic cutting checks.
Noel King
So he's talked recently about this idea of a tariff dividend is what he's calling it, which I believe where that stands is something like $2,000 checks for people making under $100,000.
Victoria Guida
We're going to issue a dividend to our middle income people and lower income people of about $2,000. No, no, not for this year. It'll be next year sometime.
Noel King
Not a great time for that, given that inflation is still higher than where we want it to be.
Victoria Guida
And you might remember that actually one of the things that people blame for the fact that we had such high inflation under Biden was the fact that they continued to send out these checks even after the economy was strengthening.
Noel King
And that probably allowed inflation to go a bit higher than it would have.
Victoria Guida
How are people responding to the fact that, you know, these big promises haven't been met?
Noel King
On the economy specifically, his numbers have plummeted. On ratings for handling the economy, handling inflation, the president's ratings have been ticking down for the course of his term and continue to do so.
Victoria Guida
More than six in 10 disapprove of how he's handled tariffs, the economy and the federal government.
Noel King
Trump is at his lowest approval rating yet, which is 39 percent of Americans approving of his job as president.
Victoria Guida
And so you really have seen people have increased skepticism. Now, who knows what that will actually mean, right?
Noel King
President Trump is somebody who seems to, you know, engender loyalty in all sorts of circumstances.
Victoria Guida
But it does seem like people are really noticing. And again, that's why the election earlier this month, I think, sort of spooked them a little bit because it might be a sign of what's to come for the Republicans in the midterm elections next year.
Noel King
Victoria Guida covers economics for Politico. Coming up, can any politician really bring prices down?
Commercial break
Welcome back to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King. Catherine Rampell is here. She's the economics editor at The Bulwark, and she's also an anchor at MS Now.
Catherine Rampell
Thanks for having me on the show.
Noel King
I am a very cheap American. I pay very careful attention to prices. And I don't remember prices ever coming down in any significant way in my entire adult life, other than during the great financial crisis where I remember you could like get a house for real cheap.
Catherine Rampell
That feels like that is saying something, that maybe prices don't just come down.
Noel King
Yeah, that's pretty much accurate. To be fair, prices of individual things can fluctuate.
Catherine Rampell
You mentioned housing, when there is a big housing bust, for example. If an oil refinery goes offline, oil prices, gasoline prices might shoot up. And then once that refinery comes back online, the prices might go down.
Noel King
Same thing for other supply shocks like bird flu. Bird flu happens. All the chickens die. chicken prices go up, egg prices go up.
Catherine Rampell
Once those flocks are replenished, then you start to see prices come back down again.
Noel King
So it's not as if there's no such thing as like fluctuation for individual products, particularly really volatile things that are vulnerable to supply shocks, like energy and food.
Catherine Rampell
But the overall price level, so like in aggregate, all of the things across an economy, that basically never comes down.
Noel King
You are spending more today than you did a year ago, than you did 10 years ago, than you did 20 years ago.
Catherine Rampell
And yet, when politicians are out on the campaign trail, the thing that they will say again and again, kind of no matter what level of office they're running from, is I am going to make life more affordable.
Noel King
So when I win, I will immediately bring prices down starting on day one. And when I am president, I will bring down the cost of groceries.
Catherine Rampell
What exactly is the disconnect? Why do we believe a politician who says I'm going to make life more affordable when we also sort of know a year from now things will probably be a little more expensive?
Noel King
I think it's partly that it's just not intuitive. People remember life being cheaper, particularly pre-pandemic life.
Catherine Rampell
They remember it being cheaper. And so it seems like a reasonable thing to ask of your public officials, whether elected officials or those at the Federal Reserve, let's say, that why can't things go back to the way that they were?
Noel King
And if you explain to them, well, actually, the Federal Reserve is targeting an overall price increase of 2% and not a negative, like, none of this is, like, obvious to anyone.
Catherine Rampell
And that's reasonable. And most of the time, Americans don't really care because price growth is so slow that they have time to adjust, right?
Noel King
If we have a 2% average price increase year over year, which we had for many, many years, you know, it doesn't feel that painful, particularly since your wages are probably going up by that much or more.
Catherine Rampell
So life feels about as affordable as it did a year before or two years before or five years before.
Noel King
What's different recently is that we did have this very sudden surge in inflation in the several years following the pandemic.
Catherine Rampell
And so the lower prices that people had recently experienced were still very fresh in people's memories.
Noel King
You remember President Biden telling us that the economy was great. We have the strongest economy in the world. Let me say it again, in the world.
Catherine Rampell
That was not true for a lot of people, for millions of people. President Trump says prices in my administration are going down. That is also not true.
Noel King
Is the president telling us, believe your eyes? Is that part of what is contributing to Americans being so ticked off about prices?
Catherine Rampell
I assume so. You know, you can lie to the American public about a lot of things but they see what happening in their bank account. They see what's happening when they get rung up at the grocery store.
Noel King
So I think it is harder to pull the wool over people's eyes when they are actually paying their own bills.
Catherine Rampell
Now, to be fair, when Biden was saying the economy was good, there were a lot of good things happening in the economy. The job market was really hot.
Noel King
So, you know, the economy contains multitudes, if you will.
Catherine Rampell
But people didn't really care about the fact that there were plentiful jobs to be had because they had a job and their life was still getting less affordable.
Noel King
And the other thing that I want to flag here is that even as wages were going up and prices were going up, I think psychologically people experience those things differently.
Catherine Rampell
When you get a raise, you think it's because you earned that raise, right? You did something really meritorious at work.
Noel King
Your pay went up because your boss recognized it or maybe you even changed jobs and your pay went up when you changed jobs.
Catherine Rampell
And that was due to your own gumption and hard work, whereas inflation is something that happened to you, that robbed you of the full value of that pay raise.
Noel King
And that's partly true, but it's also partly not true in the sense that part of the reason why wages were rising is that employees were demanding higher pay to compensate for higher inflation.
Catherine Rampell
I'm sure that both President Trump and President Biden would have liked to bring prices down, right? It would have been enormously successful.
Noel King
The question is, can any American president really just overall make life cheaper for us?
Catherine Rampell
There is no dial under the Resolute desk that allows them to turn prices down.
Noel King
And although I'm not sure that they would have really wanted to, because, look, when you have prices go down, it has lots of negative consequences, too.
Catherine Rampell
Or oftentimes when you do see some very salient price go down, it might be because something else bad is happening in the economy.
Noel King
So just as an example of this, Donald Trump lately has been promising that he's going to get gasoline prices down to $2 a gallon again.
Catherine Rampell
Which would be quite a big decline from where they are today.
Noel King
Do you know the last time gas was $2 a gallon?
Catherine Rampell
No.
Noel King
When?
Catherine Rampell
When?
Noel King
It was in spring of 2020.
Catherine Rampell
Oh, God. Okay. What else was going on?
Noel King
I don't want to do that again.
Catherine Rampell
Exactly. What was going on in spring of 2020?
Noel King
Well, there was a global pandemic.
Catherine Rampell
People stopped driving to work. Factories shut down. Businesses of all kinds needed less energy.
Noel King
There was a lot less demand for fuel. And because there was less demand for fuel, that meant fuel was cheaper.
Catherine Rampell
Gasoline was cheaper. So if the overall price level is going down, not just one really salient good like gasoline, that often means an economy is very sick.
Noel King
It basically means that everything is on a fire sale. Consumers have stopped spending and everyone, every business out there is trying to cut their prices to lure consumers back in.
Catherine Rampell
And if you are a consumer and you see prices already falling, you don't want to be the chump who is like, I'm going to buy something now only to see it get cheaper tomorrow.
Noel King
So what happens is this becomes a self-perpetuating cycle. People see prices falling. They hold off on spending. Consumer spending grinds to a halt and prices get lower and lower and lower.
Catherine Rampell
This is sometimes called a deflationary spiral. We saw a version of this during the Great Depression.
Noel King
We've seen versions of this in Japan, for example, in the 90s, in Greece, during the Greek debt crisis and thereafter.
Catherine Rampell
So this is really not a good pattern you want the economy to get into where prices are falling or even when they're like just imperceptibly hovering around 0% growth.
Noel King
So that's why the Federal Reserve is targeting a 2 percent pace of inflation rather than 0 percent or, heaven forbid, negative.
Catherine Rampell
Because, again, if you get into that negative price growth, if prices are actively falling across the board, you can really end up in a dark place economically.
Noel King
I was reading an article in The New York Times over the weekend, and there was this couple interviewed. They bought a house. Their interest rate was high. And they were saying, we've had to give up vacations and outings and budget more carefully.
Catherine Rampell
And I thought, is that not just life? Is it not just we constantly wish we had more money and we don't?
Noel King
And should we maybe be changing our mindset a little bit when it comes to the question of prices and affordability?
Catherine Rampell
You know, different people make different choices about what to do with a fixed amount of money.
Noel King
And it's very easy to judge other people's choices.
Catherine Rampell
But yeah, we all live within some constraints.
Noel King
That doesn't mean it's not reasonable to say it feels like everybody else is getting ahead and everybody else can afford a home and a vacation and I can't and that's really frustrating.
Catherine Rampell
But it's also up to policymakers to ensure that people, you know, aside from like, you know, side-eyeing their neighbors and feeling poor and whatnot, that they do feel like they can get the things that we think are the basic needs of humanity. Health care, food, you know, the ability to put clothes on their kids.
Noel King
So, you know, I think there are different ways to look at this.
Catherine Rampell
Catherine Rampell of The Bulwark and MS Now.
Noel King
Khaddi Muagdi produced today's show. Jolie Myers edited. Patrick Boyd and Adrienne Lilly engineered. Ariana Espudu and Melissa Hirsch fact-checked. If you want to take advantage of our membership sale, I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.