Main Topic: The Trump administration's approach to addressing homelessness in Washington D.C. and the controversy surrounding the use of involuntary commitments and encampment sweeps.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram, and I'm here with Kyle Swenson, who reports on D.C. for the Washington Post.
Kyle Swenson
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
Today, we're talking about the Trump administration's efforts to address homelessness in Washington, D.C. We've seen a lot of ICE officers detaining delivery drivers, federal police officers dealing with a drunk woman in DuPont Circle, and a 14-ton military vehicle crashing into a car in Capitol Hill. But amidst all this chaos, the president is also trying to evict D.C.'s homeless population. This has long been an obsession of his.
Kyle Swenson
Yeah, it's been a big focus for him. He's been saying that we can't let homeless people stay in the middle of our magnificent parks under the Washington Monument and other places. We're going to clean up Washington, D.C. and make it a crime-free zone.
Sean Rameswaram
That's right. And we're going to evaluate the job he's doing with the unhoused on Today Explained from Vox. Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into. That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform.
Kyle Swenson
While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most.
Sean Rameswaram
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Kyle Swenson
Support for this show also comes from Strawberry.me. Be honest. Are you happy with your job? Or are you stuck in one you've outgrown? Or never wanted in the first place?
Sean Rameswaram
Wow, Washington, D.C. Today Explained. Kyle, can you help us understand what this administration has been up to as it concerns people without homes in our nation's capital?
Kyle Swenson
Yeah, sure. Beginning on Thursday night was the first night where there was a concerted effort to move to the city through places where homeless people had typically gathered, where they were tents. Under the direction of the federal government, D.C. police led the clearing of homeless encampments. The White House says that people who do not leave could be thrown in jail.
Sean Rameswaram
And what we're seeing is an increase of homeless encampment removals. We're just people. We're normal people out here working, trying to do well.
Kyle Swenson
I remember the passage of, as you have done unto the least of these, you have done unto me. And the idea that he's targeting us and persecuting us feels wrong to me.
Sean Rameswaram
Now, whether those have produced arrests, at this point, we're still trying to figure that out. We don't know. Do we know where people went, or is this part of the mystery here?
Kyle Swenson
We don't necessarily know where they went. I've spoken to a few people who were living out there. A couple of them have just moved on to different parts of the city. A couple just went in the woods.
Sean Rameswaram
Honestly, they just are now trying to get more out of sight and get out of the kind of laser focus of authorities, which is understandable. And the city has increased its shelter capacity. This is also something we're trying to kind of lock down.
Kyle Swenson
But a lot of people don't want to go into a shelter for a lot of understandable reasons. When you kind of get down in the nitty-gritty, they maybe don't feel safe in a shelter. They maybe have too much stuff.
Sean Rameswaram
There's a two-bag rule when you go into a shelter, you can take two bags in. So if your whole life is packed up in six bags, maybe you don't want to go into a shelter.
Kyle Swenson
Some people with animals, some people with health conditions, if they're going in and out of medical treatments like dialysis every day, They maybe don't feel like they have the flexibility in a shelter where you have to be in by a certain time.
Sean Rameswaram
So a lot of people are very skeptical of the shelter system. And that's why they kind of remain on the street.
Kyle Swenson
So if people are indeed just heading into the woods, it isn't like this is a problem that's been solved. Because the second the tension is released or the focus drifts elsewhere, we can assume people are just going to come right back to the services and the neighborhoods that are familiar and we're working for them.
Sean Rameswaram
Can you give us a sense of the, like, at least the recent history around this issue in a city like Washington, D.C.?
Kyle Swenson
Yeah. I mean, one of the things about Trump's kind of picture and the rhetoric around this is that the city he's kind of talking about doesn't seem like the city right now in terms of homelessness. It seems like post-pandemic, I think anybody who was here would note, there were large encampments all over the city of homeless people.
Sean Rameswaram
If you came out from the DuPont metro, DuPont Circle was ringed with tents. From Scott Circle to DuPont Circle, GW to Georgetown, homeless encampments are now nestled across our nation's capital.
Kyle Swenson
McPherson Square, five minutes from the White House, was the district's largest encampment. Many residents say they feel the world has turned its back on them.
Sean Rameswaram
Now the city, Mayor Bowser's administration, they have been very active on this issue. They have both included services going out to people. They have opened up the number of vouchers for people who get long-term housing.
Kyle Swenson
And we open smaller service and rich centers across all eight wards. We opened the new 801E shelter for men. We opened the city's first LGBTQ plus shelter.
Sean Rameswaram
But they also have cleared encampments pretty regularly. So the city has been on it. They've been moving people off these big encampments.
Kyle Swenson
Right now, like, there is a list of encampment clearings that the city schedules. They post it. They try to go through a protocol where they reach out immediately with social workers and people to offer services to people living in that area.
Sean Rameswaram
But last week, I went to a lot of the places that were lined up on upcoming sweeps, and there's just nobody there. The idea that there's tent cities in Washington, D.C. right now is just not accurate compared to other cities that you see out west and stuff like that.
Kyle Swenson
And so when President Trump talks about these large encampments that are kind of like despoiling the city he kind of talking about something that doesn't exist in the city anymore as far as we can tell and as far as the city can tell.
Sean Rameswaram
We still have homeless people, 100%. This is a major American city. We saw big spikes over the past two years, and then this year, during the census of homeless individuals, people unhoused, we saw a drop by about 9%. So that's actually a pretty significant victory for the city.
Kyle Swenson
The Mayor Bowser's administration, you know, is very correct to take credit for that. They've made a lot of inroads and outreach. But then a lot of what we're seeing is also like in the counties surrounding D.C., like Montgomery, the numbers have gone up.
Sean Rameswaram
So does anyone think Donald Trump's going to solve this?
Kyle Swenson
In my opinion, having covered this for a long time, this feels like a show of force in an area where a show of force isn't going to actually solve this issue.
Sean Rameswaram
And one other thing to really point out here is that the White House is taking a stand on a particular kind of philosophical position about how to deal with homelessness.
Kyle Swenson
Right. You've written that some of these approaches the Trump administration would like to take are influenced by this conservative think tank called the Cicero Institute.
Sean Rameswaram
What is their philosophy to deal with homelessness?
Kyle Swenson
So, you know, Cicero is based in Texas and they have lobbied very effectively in a lot of Republican states to pass kind of criminalization efforts.
Sean Rameswaram
What I attempted to accomplish was a ban on illegal camping statewide in Kentucky.
Kyle Swenson
They're usually disguised as camping bans and things like that or loitering bans, but it makes it very aggressive where police can roll up to anybody who doesn't seem to be housed or seem to be sleeping somewhere, and there's a criminal penalty to them.
Sean Rameswaram
They have a bill in place where basically the policeman can say you need to move along to a designated camping area or you need to go to a shelter or rehab or we can take you to jail.
Kyle Swenson
But the idea kind of runs against this wall because, you know, it's even hard to get a bed for like a detox center in this country. It's really hard to get mental health access.
Sean Rameswaram
So they mean well. It's just their philosophy is this kind of like forcing people. They should know what's good for them. They should get into treatment. They should better themselves.
Kyle Swenson
Where studies have shown this other philosophy, which is now the prevailing philosophy. And it's been the prevailing philosophy for the last 20 years, which is housing first.
Sean Rameswaram
Which is if you get somebody in a house, if you get them housed to a permanent place, this is my house. I got my lock on my door. I got my keys.
Kyle Swenson
That actually is the first step to a person stabilizing and being like, maybe I need mental health treatment. Maybe I need drug treatment. But it's the first step. It's just get them in their own place. It's kind of about establishing dignity.
Sean Rameswaram
And that is a very delicate process. It's hard. There's a lot of trial and error there.
Kyle Swenson
But what Cicero has effectively very much so pushed in a lot of states is the opposite. It's to criminalize, to kind of use the stick rather than the carrot around these issues.
Sean Rameswaram
And the Trump administration is very clear about where they stand on this. They very much embrace that same attitude.
Kyle Swenson
And Housing First has even become kind of like, not as much so, but in the same way, like DEI, it's become kind of like one of these buzzwords that is loaded now with the significance of like a failed policy idea.
Sean Rameswaram
And does something called involuntary commitment also factor into this sort of stick instead of carrot approach?
Kyle Swenson
Totally. I mean, that is the most extreme stick that can be used. Involuntary commitment being is that you're deemed by law enforcement to be a danger to yourself or to the community.
Sean Rameswaram
And you literally are removed from the street for a psychiatric hold, it plays out differently in every kind of state and jurisdiction.
Kyle Swenson
That is the most extreme measure that can be used against homelessness. We have not seen it in D.C. so far, as far as we know, play out.
Sean Rameswaram
But that is definitely something that's in the conversation here with people who want to take a harder line on the homeless.
Kyle Swenson
You can read me at WashingtonPost.com. More on the most extreme stick that can be used to deal with homelessness and the surprising corners of this country that agree on using said stick when we're back on Today Explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards. These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars.
Kyle Swenson
But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head. Not anymore, says Built Rewards.
Sean Rameswaram
Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment.
Kyle Swenson
Your next Lyft ride and so much more. Your home isn't just where you sleep, it's your community, and Built wants you to go out and do things in the community.
Sean Rameswaram
You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members every month.
Kyle Swenson
When you're ready to travel, they say Built points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining built.com slash explained.
Sean Rameswaram
Support for Today Explained also comes from Upwork. If you run a business, you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time.
Kyle Swenson
I sometimes wonder how many of you are running businesses out there. I would love to know. Please email me, noelle at king dot com.
Sean Rameswaram
With Upwork, you can find specialized freelancers in IT, web development, AI, design, admin support, marketing, and more.
Kyle Swenson
Experts who they say are ready to help you take your business to the next level.
Sean Rameswaram
With more than two decades of experience, Upwork has a simple and ambitious goal to pioneer a better way of working.
Kyle Swenson
Companies at every stage turn to Upwork to get things done and find more flexibility in the way they staff key projects and initiatives by accessing a global marketplace full of top talent.
Sean Rameswaram
Plus Upwork makes posting your job easy with no cost to join. You can register browse freelancer profiles get help drafting a job post or even book a consultation.
Kyle Swenson
You can visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free. That is Upwork.com to post your job for free and connect with top talents ready to help your business grow.
Sean Rameswaram
So I'm Alex Barnard, and I'm an assistant professor of sociology at New York University.
Alex Barnard
Yeah, I wrote a book about California's involuntary treatment system. I joke that it's a book about Britney Spears, but it's more broadly about how conservatorship functions in California.
Sean Rameswaram
And weirdly, this figures into what's going on right now in Washington, D.C. with the unhoused population.
Alex Barnard
Right. So President Trump has been just issued an executive order that's trying to change the way the U.S. approaches homelessness and mental illness, largely by bringing us back to a more heavy-handed, coercive approach to homelessness through the mental health system combined with greater criminalization of this population.
Sean Rameswaram
And his executive order is not just about the District of Columbia. No, the executive order is nationwide.
Alex Barnard
So it's trying to change policy really around three different issues. So first, it's trying to expand the use of civil commitments. So that's involuntary mental health treatment.
Sean Rameswaram
It's usually reserved for people who are a danger to themselves, danger to others, or unable to meet their basic needs.
Alex Barnard
And he's looking to expand that. It's not totally clear how he's going to do that, because that's determined by state law. But in any case, That's one of his objectives.
Sean Rameswaram
The second is to expand the criminalization of homelessness, so increase the use of things like encampment sweeps to force people who are homeless to move along.
Alex Barnard
It's not really clear where he imagines those people going, but that's certainly what they're doing in D.C.
Sean Rameswaram
There are many places that they can go, and we're going to help them as much as you can help.
Alex Barnard
And then the final piece is a really dramatic change in housing policy. So since George W. Bush, The kind of primary response we have to unsheltered homelessness, for which there's a lot of really robust evidence, is called Housing First.
Sean Rameswaram
And we created this Housing First program in 92, and we began basically to take people from the streets into an apartment of their own.
Alex Barnard
Housing First speaks about immediate access to permanent housing, and it was adopted as federal policy for the first time under President George W. Bush.
Sean Rameswaram
And they want to move away from that towards a system in which housing is not given, it's earned based on your participation in rehab programs or something like that.
Alex Barnard
I think most people are familiar with the idea of like an encampment sweep and it's probably not surprising to people that Donald Trump's push to solve homelessness in D.C. doesn't have a lot to do with like, say, building housing for poor people.
Sean Rameswaram
But the civil commitments thing, I feel like people might not know as much about. So let's focus on that for a second here.
Alex Barnard
What motivated the president of the United States to call for more involuntary commitments?
Sean Rameswaram
So this is one of those things that, for whatever reason, Trump has a bit of a fixation on. So in 2018, in response to the Parkland shooting, rather than talking about gun control, he wanted to talk about bringing back asylums, bringing back large psychiatric hospitals that were really significantly downsized in the 1960s.
Alex Barnard
So, you know, we closed a lot of hospitals, but civil commitment never went away. Over a million Americans are subjected to some kind of involuntary psychiatric treatment per year.
Sean Rameswaram
That often starts with a law enforcement officer seeing somebody in the community who's not doing well and bringing them to an ER for evaluation.
Alex Barnard
And then that person can be placed in a hospital and medicated involuntarily. So that's that's civil commitment. It's a state by state. You know, the laws for that vary by state, but it exists everywhere.
Sean Rameswaram
And his vision is that we should ramp up civil commitments to deal with homelessness. We really don't have robust evidence that civil commitment is a good solution to homelessness, and in fact, there's some recent research that came out that suggests somebody being placed in a psychiatric hospital actually may increase their risk of losing housing because they're in a psychiatric hospital, which means they're not going to their job, they're not connecting to family.
Alex Barnard
If the problem leading to unsheltered homelessness was that there wasn't enough civil commitments, we would see a really different pattern of civil commitments nationwide.
Sean Rameswaram
So Oklahoma and Utah, for example, are two states with very low levels of civil commitments and almost very little homelessness.
Alex Barnard
So the story there is not that we're not forcing enough mentally ill people into treatment. The story is that there's a lot of cheap housing in those states. And as a result, you're not seeing the kind of unsheltered homelessness that you see in New York or California.
Sean Rameswaram
California actually has a much higher rate of civil commitments than the national average and also is home to one half of the unsheltered homeless population.
Alex Barnard
I'm sorry, before we continue, did you just say that half of the nation's unsheltered people live in California?
Sean Rameswaram
That's correct. I did not know that statistic. It makes sense, but also, wow. It's a catastrophic failure.
Alex Barnard
And I think that it does kind of bring disgrace upon the governments of these left-leaning coastal states that, you know, despite, you know, years and years of policy conversations around this, they have not really moved the needle on homelessness.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm glad you brought up California, because I think it gets at something interesting when it comes to involuntary commitments here, which is that it isn't just like a left, right, red, blue issue in the United States.
Alex Barnard
I mean, Donald Trump said this thing, signed this executive order. And then like, I think days later, Almost instantly, it felt like Eric Adams was saying like, we're asking state lawmakers to extend the lifeline of involuntary commitment to those struggling with serious addiction.
Sean Rameswaram
We have already made it easier to use involuntary commitment to help people with untreated severe mental illness get care.
Alex Barnard
Mind you, Eric Adams, I guess, no longer a Democrat, but who agrees with Donald Trump that we could stand to see more of these kinds of involuntary civil commitments, whatever they might be?
Sean Rameswaram
I think Donald Trump is trying to put forward the most cruel possible version of a policy shift that actually has pretty broad support.
Alex Barnard
So with some research assistance here at NYU, we've cataloged 1,900 bills around involuntary treatment that have been introduced in state legislatures in the last decade.
Sean Rameswaram
And of the 10 states that introduced the most bills on this topic nine of them voted for Democrats in the last presidential elections
Alex Barnard
So this has been largely an initiative that is coming from blue coastal states.
Sean Rameswaram
And what we've seen is that there's been an almost a reframing of coercion as a form of compassion, that actually to be a progressive is not to let somebody die in their feces on the street, but to force that person into treatment that they can't necessarily accept.
Alex Barnard
If in fact they're suicidal, if in fact they're unable to care for themselves, this will allow the judge to better assess whether that person should be committed into drug treatment.
Sean Rameswaram
When people get their meds, when people get support, we know we can turn people's lives around.
Alex Barnard
This is eminently solvable. Governors like Gavin Newsom have also embraced encampment sweeps and other kind of criminalization measures as another way to deal with urban disorder and homelessness.
Sean Rameswaram
So in a lot of ways, the blue states have paved the way for this executive order, which is pushing this movement towards a more institutional response to homelessness even further.
Alex Barnard
And is it controversial, like on the left? Is it creating division in progressive circles that we need to solve this problem and to do so we have to do this thing that some of us find distasteful?
Sean Rameswaram
So this has been an area that often puts civil liberties groups and disability rights groups in pretty open conflict with other progressive, sometimes elected officials, mayors particularly, also some clinicians and a lot of families that see their loved ones not able to accept the treatment that we think they need.
Alex Barnard
I think in reality, to really move forward on this policy discussion, we need to realize that people who are experiencing homelessness are a really diverse group.
Sean Rameswaram
And for the vast majority of them, including many of them with severe mental illness, giving them an apartment is the fastest way to solve their homelessness.
Alex Barnard
But there is a subset of people for whom voluntary services and, you know, independent apartment where a case manager checks you once a week, but otherwise you're left on your own, that that actually isn't going to be enough to meet those those individuals needs.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's that group that now the right is really focusing on and treating as the entire homelessness population, these people who need to be coerced into treatment because they're so sick.
Alex Barnard
You joke that your book is about Britney Spears, who, of course, famously had this conservatorship controversy.
Sean Rameswaram
But is there a story that you've come across or that you tell in your book about involuntary commitment that can help people wrap their heads around the issue?
Alex Barnard
One of my favorite stories, and this is a story of somebody who consented for me to tell his story. His name was Serge. He had no hands and was missing one eye as a result of an accident when he was younger and had lived with schizophrenia.
Sean Rameswaram
And he spent a decade homeless in Hollywood.
Alex Barnard
And again, this is one of these people where probably, you know, a thousand times a day, somebody was walking by and saying, why isn't somebody doing anything for this guy?
Sean Rameswaram
And in reality, he was being picked up by the police and either thrown in jail or taken to an ER dozens and dozens of times.
Alex Barnard
And every time they'd just kick him back out and sometimes they'd pay for an Uber to send him back to Hollywood.
Sean Rameswaram
In the end, it was a private citizen, Carrie Morrison, who was charge of the business improvement district there, who said, you know, what is going on here?
Alex Barnard
And she actually convened a meeting of all the stakeholders, everyone who was touching on this person, this person's case, and brought them all together.
Sean Rameswaram
And, you know, the tragic way this panned out was the police came, they stopped him, you know, they tried to handcuff him because that's how we take people to psychiatric hospitals, but he didn't have hands, so they had to use zip ties.
Alex Barnard
And she says, that's how we help people in America.
Sean Rameswaram
In the end, he was taken to a hospital. They kind of shepherded him through the system, so he went on to a conservatorship.
Alex Barnard
Once he was conserved, he was sent to a locked facility with barbed wire all around it, way far out of Los Angeles, where he was there for months.
Sean Rameswaram
And no one even really knew, none of the people who had a connection with him even knew where he was.
Alex Barnard
And then eventually he stepped down out of that and went to live in an unlocked facility and got his GED.
Sean Rameswaram
And when I talked to him, I said, what do you wish the system had done differently?
Alex Barnard
And he said, I wish they had conserved me sooner.
Sean Rameswaram
So that's a story that really sticks with me. It's the happy story of civil commitment, but with a lot of unnecessary pain and suffering along the way.
Alex Barnard
I think in some ways states like California are at least on the right track, which is that we need an all-of-the-above solution.
Sean Rameswaram
So we have to address the root causes of homelessness, which is that housing is too expensive.
Alex Barnard
And when housing is too expensive, the most vulnerable people are going to be the ones who become homeless.
Sean Rameswaram
And at the end of the day, you can put somebody in a psychiatric hospital. But if they're not going to land in an apartment at the end of it and they're going to instead go back to the street, you've just wasted a lot of money and restricted somebody's civil liberties for nothing.
Alex Barnard
I do think we need a targeted use of civil commitments, a thoughtful use of civil commitments for some individuals who have been, frankly, abandoned so long that they're not able to consent to services that might be necessary to save their lives.
Sean Rameswaram
But it wouldn't look at all like this executive order.
Alex Barnard
That was Alex Barnard from NYU. His book about Britney Spears is called Conservatorship Inside California's System of Coercion and Care for Mental Illness.
Sean Rameswaram
Our program today was produced by Rebecca Ibarra and Devin Schwartz. Amin Al-Assadi edited, Laura Bullard fact-checked, Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristinsdottir mixed.
In an upcoming episode of Today Explained, we're going to look at how tough it is to find a job in the United States right now. Reporting suggests it's getting a lot harder.
Kyle Swenson
If you've had a tough time, sent out dozens and dozens of applications and heard nothing back, we want to hear from you, especially, especially if you're in like a white-collar industry that's suddenly all about AI.
Sean Rameswaram
Give us a call at 844-453-4448 or send a voice memo to our Philadelphia Bureau Chief, Miles Bryan, miles.bryan with a Y at voxmedia.com.
That's Miles Bryan at voxmedia.com. He spells it with a Y.
Thank you. Thank you.