Main Topic: The episode explores the story of Kumiko Ninomiya, a biochemist and researcher known as the "Umami Mama," who dedicated her life to promoting the scientific understanding of umami as a basic taste.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noelle
Support for Today Explained comes from the FIFA World Cup, of all things. The FIFA World Cup 26 is coming to North America next summer. It is the ultimate celebration of sports and culture. You can get closer to the beautiful game with a hospitality package, closer to the action, the best seats, the best suites, closer to match day and that world-class food and that world-class entertainment, closer to the experience of a lifetime. Book a hospitality package at fifaworldcup.com slash hospitality.
Today Explained listeners, hi, it's Noelle. We're doing something a little different today. We have an episode from our friends at the Unexplainable podcast. This one is part of a series they are doing on the senses, sight, smell, touch. And today, we have taste for you. The sixth and final episode of that series is going to air next Wednesday. In the meantime, here we go. Unexplainable senior producer Meredith Hadenot with the story of the umami mama.
Meredith Hadenot
The science behind how things taste has been an organizing principle in my life. It's led me to chemistry labs and test kitchens and science podcasts. But I've never met anyone as devoted to the science of a single taste as Kumiko Ninomiya. My nickname is Umami Mama. Many people don't know about my exact name, but they know Umami Mama.
Kumiko Ninomiya
I am always talking about umami, umami, umami. The umami that Kumiko is always talking about has always been a part of food. But it wasn't identified until 1908. That year, a Japanese chemist, Kikunae Ikeda, distilled pure glutamate salt from big sheets of a seaweed called kombu, a foundational ingredient in Japanese cuisine.
This salt, monosodium glutamate, or MSG, was more than just salty. But it wasn't exactly sour or bitter or sweet either. Ikeda believed that MSG had a totally distinct taste and that it was the basis of deliciousness, or umai in Japanese, and so he called it umami.
If you eat long-cooked stew or slapping chicken soup or biting a slice of pepperoni and mushroom pizza, you feel a long-lasting and very comfortable aftertaste. And that's umami. Umami is like a baseline. In a dish, you might not even notice it, distracted by the harmonies of sweet and sour and salty and maybe a discordant note of bitter. But umami is there. It's rich. It's deep. It builds over time.
In some ways, umami is the taste of cooking itself. It's the taste of proteins blasted apart through heat or fermentation. And at the heart of umami is one of those protein pieces, glutamate. And while MSG is a pure, concentrated form of glutamate, glutamate and the umami it evokes occur naturally in foods all over the world.
Cheeses, cured meats, anchovies, tomatoes, mushrooms, seaweeds, they're all high in glutamate and all full of umami. Ikeda was the first to really give umami a name and to sell it. He founded Ajinomoto, which became one of the biggest MSG companies in the world.
Meredith Hadenot
But in the 1970s, Ajinomoto encountered a problem. We have a big problem about anti-MSG groups around the world, especially in the United States. A letter to the editor in the New England Journal of Medicine suggested that MSG caused weakness and dizziness, chest pain, and all these other vague symptoms they called Chinese restaurant syndrome.
Kumiko Ninomiya
People say no MSG. MSG is but for health, and MSGs are just chemical. This sparked a xenophobic panic across the U.S. and demonized MSG. It's a neurotoxin. Chinese food is packed with MSG. MSG. MSG-laden Chinese food gives you headaches. Migraines. Allergies. Dizziness. And learning disabilities. I had MSG poisoning. I know.
Meredith Hadenot
Ajinomoto and other MSG companies poured tons of research dollars into proving that their products were safe. Private institutions, public government research, it all came back with the same conclusion. MSG is safe. You know what causes Chinese restaurant syndrome?
Kumiko Ninomiya
But a dark cloud of bad press still hung over the MSG industry. They wanted to change the conversation entirely. And so Ajinomoto hired Kumiko. My mission was to promote studies on glutamate and umami around the world.
Ajinomoto tasked Kumiko with getting the scientific community to accept umami as its own basic taste. When I started working for research and study on umami taste, I was not so interested in the umami taste. My boss just say, you are in charge of this work. And it's a kind of my life work.
Meredith Hadenot
Did you know that it was going to be your life work when you were first given that assignment? No. At that time, I was always thinking how to quit my job.
Kumiko Ninomiya
She didn't quit. Instead, she launched a multidisciplinary, international, decades-long campaign that changed the field of sensory science forever. That was my big challenge. and in the process of pushing for worldwide recognition of umami, her work raised more questions.
Meredith Hadenot
How many tastes are out there, waiting for the scientific establishment to recognize? And how do we even define a taste to begin with? All knowledge must come through the senses, all that we perceive, and all of the awareness of our daily existence.
Kumiko Ninomiya
Light. Double rainbow. Oh, oh my God. Sound. Listen to me, listen to me. Touch. Squishy. Odors. Ew. And tastes. Mmm. What are your thoughts concerning the human senses?
Meredith Hadenot
As meat and wine are nourishment to the body, the senses provide nutriment to the soul. All that we perceive, see, all the awareness, hearing, all knowledge must come through the senses.
Kumiko Ninomiya
I have an incredible sense of touch. All that we perceive, tasting, all of the awareness, smelling, all knowledge must come through the senses. Doesn't make sense. Sine weevil. Please, sine weevil.
Meredith Hadenot
So what was Kumiko trying to achieve here? What does it mean for something to be a taste? For thousands of years, it was a pretty exclusive club. Traditionally, it's been believed that there are four basic tastes that are built into us.
Gary Beauchamp
He's the former director of the Monell Chemical Census Center, a nonprofit research institute. Gary's interested in the big four tastes, but also the evolutionary narrative of how each taste helped our ancestors answer the question, what should I put in my mouth?
So first off, there's sweet. Sweet, that is supposedly a signal for calories and sugars. Next up is salty, a signal for sodium, which is an essential mineral for life. And so animals are built to be able to detect it and to like it. Then there's bitter. Bitter presumably helps us spit out poisons. But also many poisons at low levels are medicinal. And so it's been used actually as a way to identify medicines as well. And finally, sour. Sour is this response to unripe foods. The exact function of that sensory system is not so clear.
Meredith Hadenot
So the big four, sweet, salty, bitter, and sour. Those were the ideas that went back thousands of years. The Chinese, the Indians, the Greeks, many, many societies all through the world. Name those four as the basic part of taste.
Gary Beauchamp
In the 80s, when I started hearing about the campaign to make umami a basic taste, I was intrigued, to a point. There was certainly a lot of skepticism in the U that this was really maybe something that was not a real taste or it certainly a basic taste the same way sweet, sour, salty, bitter is.
Kumiko Ninomiya
My mission is not to sell MSG. My mission is to let people understand umami.
Meredith Hadenot
Kumiko knew that scientists were wary of her motives, but she had a clear goal ahead of her. The goal is to make a network with scientists who are interested in umami research for glutamate in our body and food.
Kumiko Ninomiya
Glutamate is an amino acid, a building block for proteins. It's important in food science, nutrition, physiology, but it's also a neurotransmitter, like one of the most abundant chemicals in the brain.
Meredith Hadenot
So there was a lot of research interest in glutamate across a lot of fields. And Kumiko wanted these researchers to communicate with each other. Usually the food scientists make a conversation with food scientists. But it was very difficult to make a good communication between food scientists and brain scientists, food scientists and nutritionists.
Kumiko Ninomiya
That was very hard work to make good communication among all the research area's scientists. Kumiko thought that good communication could get these scientists excited about studying umami as a taste. And that excitement was the key to her plan.
Sarah Tracy
Everyone talked about the brain in the 90s and the Human Genome Project, and then it was all about the gut and the aughts, you know? So I think umami is an interesting example of a very conscious and careful investment in the creation or fostering of scientific excitement.
Meredith Hadenot
The idea of whether umami was a taste had the potential to be the next cool thing to study. Like, how do you even define a new taste? There hadn't been one for thousands of years. We've had the basic four for millennia.
Kumiko Ninomiya
That's why I think that tasting is the most important part to let them understand the taste quality of umami. Because we are talking about taste of umami.
Meredith Hadenot
So through the symposium, I tried to make an opportunity to have a tasting session about umami taste and how to find umami in the tomato or cheese. And they gradually understand what umami is.
Gary Beauchamp
There was not just a taste, but a feel. It was almost like it was thick, and it was mouth-watering. It was delicious.
Meredith Hadenot
Gary and other scientists understood that umami was a unique sensory experience. But did that make it a taste? Scientists scoured everything they knew about taste. How chemicals in food interact with the tongue. How the tongue sends signals to the brain. How the brain processes those signals.
Camilla Andel Anderson
So that's where the kind of science I do comes into play, where we actually look at the brain and look at, do we see a neuroactivation to this taste? All taste is hard to isolate from the other senses, but fat is particularly tricky.
Meredith Hadenot
Fat is an incredible solvent, so it's this great vehicle for aromatic compounds, the smell part of flavor. I mean, just think about garlic-infused olive oil. Fat also plays a fundamental role in the texture, the touch of foods.
Camilla Andel Anderson
We know that we smell fat, and we know that we sense the texture of fat. But the next question is whether we also taste fat.
Meredith Hadenot
To test taste and taste receptors in isolation, Camilla rigged up some pretty wild experiments. Participants had to sit with their heads completely still. Strapping them onto a headrest. They wore these EEG caps with sensors all over them to measure their brain activity. And they were told to hold their breath.
Camilla Andel Anderson
So we saw was that we were able to discriminate the response, the brain response to the skim milk and the cream. There was something we were registering that was different between these two.
Meredith Hadenot
So some promising evidence of a signal of fat taste being processed in the brain. But what exactly is going on, we're not sure.
Paul Breslin
In 20 years from now, we'll probably have come to some kind of a consensus on it, but we're not there yet. All of the potential six tastes are in this position. Calcium, starch, metallic. Labs around the world are trying to build the narrative, build the case of whether these should be considered tastes.
Meredith Hadenot
It's intriguing to say, like, we can taste fat or we can taste potassium or we can taste calisthenia, we can taste water. Those are all interesting stories. But collectively what is taste is really the more interesting question.
Sarah Tracy
To me, I don't think that we would have umami without that industry influence. But I mean, this is also the way so much of our understanding of taste and smell work comes to us by virtue of corporate research.
Meredith Hadenot
Taste is big business. It's an industry. And a lot of what we know about sensory science has its roots in the modern industrial food system.
Kumiko Ninomiya
Our current understanding of umami as a taste was part of a larger campaign to change the conversation about MSG. And it worked.
Meredith Hadenot
Without a name for the thing, how can you think with it or live with it? Our names and our language do, in a way, forge our reality.
Kumiko Ninomiya
And so whether we call it umami or not has real effects in the world. It's certainly a fantastic branding proposition. And that brand was painstakingly built over decades, first within the scientific community and then beyond.
Meredith Hadenot
An enormous amount of science communication and promotion went into popularizing umami among chefs and food writers and tastemakers.
Kumiko Ninomiya
So the taste is very important for chefs to create the good meals and excellent dishes. That's why I decided to make a conversation with chefs.
Meredith Hadenot
Top chef. When Kimiko says top chefs, she means the most famous, the most influential chefs in the world at the time.
Kumiko Ninomiya
Because top chefs have a big voice, and maybe the young chefs try to follow the top chefs. So that was very, very challenging for me. That was very hard work.
Meredith Hadenot
The popularity of Japanese cuisine exploded at the same time that food science and molecular gastronomy took hold of the culinary imagination. And suddenly, umami was everywhere.
Kumiko Ninomiya
Umami is one of the very fashionable world in the United States. And people are very interested in umami. So it's a very good opportunity for us to promote more about umami.
Meredith Hadenot
Where we draw the line on how to define a taste may be kind of arbitrary, but it has real-life effects. Ultimately, we live in a different scientific and culinary world because of the Umami Taste Campaign and the Umami Mama.
Kumiko Ninomiya
My nickname was given by Nobu. Nobu Matsuhisa is a very famous Japanese chef around the world. And when I first met him, he told me, don't come to me, you will start talking about MSG. And I never use MSG because I have many restaurants in the United States. And there are so many people who hate MSG. Don't waste your time.
Meredith Hadenot
I every month visit him to talk about umami. And then he gradually understand what I want to do. And after that, he started talking about umami by himself. And he introduced me to the guest in the restaurant. She is world famous umami mama.
Kumiko Ninomiya
I was so surprised. What did he say?
Theme music starts playing
Meredith Hadenot
This is the fourth episode of our Making Sense series. Next week, sight and the limitations of the mind's eye. And, you know, I'd always read about things like picturing your loved one's face and this and that. And I was like, why can't I picture anyone's face?
Theme music continues to play
This episode was reported and produced by Meredith Hodinot. It was edited by Catherine Wells, Noam Hassenfeld, Brian Resnick, with help from Mandy Nguyen and Bird Pinkerton.
Theme music continues to play
Real team effort. Music by Noam, Christian Ayala handled the mixing and sound design. Research and fact-checking by me, Richard Seema, and Tori Dominguez is our audio fellow.
Theme music continues to play
Special thanks to Nancy Rawson, Johnny Drain, Eliza Barclay, Nicola Twilley, and Emily Hanselman.
Theme music continues to play
If you want to learn more about the history of umami, keep an eye out for Sarah Tracy's upcoming book, Delicious! A History of Monosodium Glutamate, Umami, and the Dysphoric Sublime.
Theme music continues to play
And that awesome umami song is called Umami by Noishne.
Theme music continues to play
To read more about some of the topics we cover on our show or to find episode transcripts, check out our site at vox.com/todayexplained.
Theme music continues to play
And if you have thoughts about the show, you can always email us at unexplainable at vox.com. Or you can leave us a review or a rating, which we would love as well.
Theme music continues to play
Unexplainable is part of the vox media podcast network and we will see you next week for episode five of making sense.
Theme music continues to play
End of episode