Main Topic: The use of masked law enforcement agents by ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) and its implications on accountability and public trust.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Noelle King
Way back in March, you might remember a Turkish graduate student at Tufts was approached on the street by ICE agents who took her away screaming. It was unsettling and it was made more so by the fact that those agents were wearing masks, which people pointed out was not normal. But it is normal now. We're seeing this more and more often.
Philip Bump
Yeah, so who they are is almost definitionally unknown because they don't identify themselves, right? There's no reason to think they're anyone but federal law enforcement. But one of the things we've seen in the second Trump administration is that a lot of other federal agencies have been looped into these enforcement actions.
Noelle King
Attorney General Pam Bondi was asked about it in a Senate hearing last week, and she was kind of like, oh, no kidding, they're wearing masks. And Senator Peters, that's the first time that issue has come to me about them covering—you're saying the law enforcement officers, when they cover their faces.
Philip Bump
Right. But she recovered very quickly, and she remembered something. They're being threatened. Their families are being threatened. You know, it's—
Noelle King
Again, I get that. But they have to identify themselves as law enforcement. But they don't have to identify themselves, and they're not. And why that concerns so many people is coming up on Today Explained.
Support for Today Explained
Welcome back to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King with Philip Bump, an opinion columnist for The Washington Post. You've been writing about these videos that show masked agents grabbing people. Who are they? What is going on?
Philip Bump
Yeah, so who they are is almost definitionally unknown because they don't identify themselves, right? There's no reason to think they're anyone but federal law enforcement. But one of the things we've seen in the second Trump administration is that a lot of other federal agencies have been looped into these enforcement actions.
Noelle King
So we know that a lot of them are ICE, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. We know, too, that there are other agencies that have been working with ICE. But the question of who the individuals are is an outstanding one.
Philip Bump
We don't know who a lot of these individuals are, which I think is important, right? I mean, it's not just that there are sort of a way things are done and it's not done that way anymore. What we're seeing is a fundamental shift in the compact between the public and law enforcement.
Noelle King
And by shielding their identities, we lose an element of that accountability. Beyond just ICE and the Trump administration having no interest in being held to account on this, these individuals, we don't know who they are. So when we see videos of them assaulting someone, for example, there's no way to adjudicate that.
Philip Bump
There's no way to say this person made these decisions because we don't know who these people are necessarily. And that's a significant shift as well.
Noelle King
This is making people uncomfortable, I've noticed, even people who are pro-deportation of undocumented immigrants. ICE director Todd Lyons has been asked about this, and he recently said People are out there taking photos of the names, their faces, and posting them online with death threats to their family and themselves.
Philip Bump
So he's saying they're doing this because they have to. Does your reporting suggest that ICE agents who are unmasked are facing threats? That is what he's saying. And he is also saying that there has been a 413 or more recently 500 percent increase in the number of assaults on ICE officers.
Noelle King
And I think it's important to recognize he's conflating three different things there. It is the case that people are trying to document who ICE is and where they are so that immigrants can be attentive to the fact that ICE may be in their neighborhoods.
Philip Bump
You know, this is something that we've seen, these sort of grassroots efforts to alert people to ICE's presence. There's a big gap between identifying where ICE is and who ICE officers are and issuing threats against them.
Noelle King
There have been some examples of ICE officers facing threats. When I first wrote about this in May, Lyons actually wrote a response in The Washington Post. And he said, oh, well, look at this case in Texas where someone had made these threats against ICE.
Philip Bump
Now we are turning to a developing story. A North Texas man is now in custody and accused of threatening the head of Homeland Security along with ICE agents. Federal officials say he also threatened several Republicans and even talked to the FBI to come and get him.
Noelle King
What's interesting about that case, as I wrote last week, is that in that case, the person appears to have been responding to the fact that the ICE agents were masked. He was responding to the fact that the ICE agents appeared to be acting without accountability.
Philip Bump
That's no excuse for issuing threats, certainly, but it's important context. But then we get to this number, this 413 percent or 500 percent or whatever they're saying it's now. They refused to give me any sort of rationalization for where those numbers came from.
Noelle King
But when you consider those numbers, it makes sense. It's not good, but it makes sense that if you are engaged in a lot more enforcement actions and you're encountering people and trying to physically detain them, you're going to have more instances in which officers are being struck or assaulted.
Philip Bump
And we've seen that the definition of assault that's being used here is often very loose. The city controller of New York City, Brad Lander, faced potential charges of assault after he was arrested. And if you've seen the video of that encounter, it's very clear he wasn't assaulting anyone.
Noelle King
I'm not obstructing. I'm standing right here in the hallway. I asked to see the judicial warrant.
Philip Bump
But to conflate those incidents in which people who are being detained and, you know, there have been criminal charges filed for assault, but a lot of them are, for example, at ICE detention facilities where, you know, the ICE officers don't need to wear a mask because they're, you know, they're obviously ICE staff at an ICE detention facility.
Noelle King
But to conflate those assaults and that purported increase in assaults with threats and doxing or identification simply is not logically viable.
Philip Bump
Is it legal for law enforcement to wear masks as they're doing?
Noelle King
So this is a fascinating question. And I think people should recognize that it has long been the case that law enforcement is allowed to go undercover.
Philip Bump
We're all familiar with undercover cops, right? So there are circumstances in which people are allowed to mask their identities. And I have not seen anything which suggests they are not allowed to do this by law.
Noelle King
We seen some efforts to try and actually create legislation that would mandate that they have their identities known. But none of that has passed it. Obviously, this is still fairly early on.
Philip Bump
So we have seen, however, some instances in which law enforcement officers who normally have standards about self-identification have been seeing those standards change.
Noelle King
So in Florida, for example, there's an email that went out to state troopers who are participating in raids alongside ICE. They were offered instructions that they did not have to maintain the standard, the uniform standard that they usually maintain that includes having their names.
Philip Bump
They were allowed to not display their names under uniforms when engaged in operations with ICE. So we've seen some changes to standards that are aimed at anonymizing these individuals, which I think is a remarkable shift.
Noelle King
What might accountability look like? How might it look different if we could see an agent's face and know who they worked for?
Philip Bump
Well, it depends on what the agents are doing, right? You know, when I first reported on this, I spoke with Radley Balko, who's long done fantastic work in this accountability space.
Noelle King
And he pointed to an example in which there had been a DEA action that targeted the wrong house. And there were two women that lived in the house that tried to get accountability from the DEA for that. But the DEA, because the agents were not identifiable in that instance, the DEA was able to keep shuffling the cards and prevent them from being able to say, hey, what happened here, and get any accountability on their own accord.
Philip Bump
That's the challenge, right? It's not the case that we need to know who every single ICE officer is necessarily. It is that if something happens where there needs to be accountability, there needs to be a mechanism for that accountability.
Noelle King
And if people are shielding their identities, that mechanism becomes very, very difficult, particularly when you have the institution itself, ICE and the administration, very obviously unwilling to hold themselves to account in any way otherwise.
Philip Bump
I wonder then if there's any evidence that being masked is changing the way that ICE agents are conducting arrests.
Noelle King
No, it's a fair question. And I think that it's very fair for Americans to assume that the understood lack of accountability, because obviously the officers are very aware that by being anonymous, that they have less accountability, whether or not that is leading to some of the heightened tensions that we've seen in these encounters.
Philip Bump
It may simply be the fact that because there are more encounters, we're seeing more of these incidents. But it's a very fair question to ask.
Noelle King
Many of the downsides are predictable. If a person wears a mask, the accountability is lowered. Are there any unexpected downsides here, though?
Philip Bump
Anyone can put on tactical gear, say they're ICE, and go up to people and try and detain them. And we've seen instances of this.
Noelle King
And new at 430, a suspect in jail after police say he robbed a 29-year-old man while impersonating an ICE agent.
Philip Bump
Philadelphia police are looking for a man who they say dressed like a federal agent to commit a crime.
Noelle King
He apparently shouted, immigration, and then zip tied a woman who was working there and took off with about a thousand bucks in cash.
Philip Bump
And it's hard for people to know, like, is this a nice officer that I have to listen to or is it not?
Noelle King
And, you know, I think everyone is worried about an occasion in which someone sees someone approaching with a firearm and responds in kind.
Philip Bump
And, you know, maybe that's a legitimate law enforcement officer and maybe it isn't. But this is what we're setting ourselves up for if these people are not identifiable as law enforcement.
Noelle King
And masking may be legal for the agents, but impersonating a federal law enforcement officer, is that a crime?
Philip Bump
Yeah, that's bad. Don't do that. OK. If there are two messages, don't impersonate law enforcement and don't assault law enforcers. All right.
Noelle King
So the Trump administration has a broad immigration strategy. How does masked agents, how does masked law enforcement fit into that broad strategy?
Philip Bump
Well, I think the strategy broadly is they just want to have as many immigrants out of the country as they possibly can. We often qualify that by saying undocumented immigrants, but I don't think that holds anymore, right?
Noelle King
We're seeing the revocation of temporary protected status for groups, people who came to the country legally, interpreters who worked with our troops in Afghanistan. And people are now facing deportation who were not only not talked about on the campaign trail, but who were presumed to be in the country by following the rules and in accordance with American law.
Philip Bump
So in alignment with that, we are seeing that the people who are engaged in these deportation efforts are feeling completely unbound, right? That they feel as though they have been given a mandate to sweep up as many people as they can.
Noelle King
And there's reporting that suggests they very literally have quotas of who they're trying to target and that they are empowered to do that through any mechanism that they possibly can.
Philip Bump
And that's bad, that it is not good to have a law enforcement body in the United States, which feels as though it can act without account and sweep up as many people as possible, including citizens, including green card holders, including people who are here on legitimate visas.
Noelle King
You know, we have seen lots of people get caught in this dragnet who by no definition deserve to face any threat of deportation whatsoever. But that's the challenge. And that's something that has been made very real by the Trump administration.
Support for Today Explained
Welcome back to Today Explained. I'm Noelle King with a TV critic who started writing about those ICE videos and those bystander videos on what she thinks they tell us.
Catherine Van Arendonk
I like to think of myself as just a culture critic more broadly. So recently you talked an editor into letting you write a piece about ICE raid videos.
Noelle King
Why did you think it was important to write about them?
Catherine Van Arendonk
This is something that I started seeing on my social media feeds early this year. I know lots of people did. And in the beginning of the year, actually, it was one of the Vulture editors who had come to me and said, Hey, have you noticed this kind of ICE propaganda thing that seems to be taking over?
Noelle King
It looks a lot like reality television.
Catherine Van Arendonk
I write a lot about reality TV. I think about it in a lot of different contexts. And so we were talking about the way that ICE and DHS had started producing these videos that really capitalized on how Americans watch shows like Cops and Live PD.
Noelle King
The door's opening. One person. OK, what I want you to get out of here, continue walking towards me, continue walking towards me. Oh, he's running.
Catherine Van Arendonk
And over time, what I started to notice is that there are all of these bystander videos of ICE raids that are capturing exactly the same kind of events, but that look different, notably different from how ICE propaganda presents them.
Noelle King
And so that became a much more interesting way of thinking about what it feels like to be an American on social media scrolling and encountering all of these videos.
Catherine Van Arendonk
There are a lot of differences that are common. In most of the ICE videos, you can see the exact same thing that you would see if you were watching a bystander video. You see guys getting out of a truck and they go to collect someone and they often handcuff them or zip tie them and then lead them off into some kind of van.
Noelle King
However, ICE videos have this sort of broad tonal range, right? Like some of them are very straightforward. They look like news coverage.
Catherine Van Arendonk
Often they do repost local news footage of the ICE raids. An illegal alien from Guatemala charged with raping a child in Massachusetts. An MS-13 gang member from El Salvador accused of murdering a Texas man. A Venezuelan charged with filming and selling child pornography in Michigan.
Noelle King
These are just some of the heinous migrant criminals caught because of President Donald J. Trump's leadership.
Catherine Van Arendonk
But then there will also be these ones that are clearly trolling, like they are meant to be shared by people who think that this is awesome and that this is funny. I'm conducting surveillance for a possible arrest this morning.
Noelle King
They will put the cops theme music under it. There's a video that was posted by DHS about a cartel party. And they're like, we'll bring ice next time, baby.
Catherine Van Arendonk
And it's set to Vanilla Ice's Ice Ice Baby. You know, it's it's memefied. It's it's trolling.
Noelle King
Obviously, bystander videos don't have any of that sort of quality to them because they are records of people being horrified.
Catherine Van Arendonk
Where are you taking them? Where are you taking them? Where are you taking them? You have to tell us. Without identifying yourself, please tell us.
Noelle King
You are kidnapping them. Tell us we are taking them. You cannot do this. Tell us where.
Catherine Van Arendonk
But there is this one really important difference that I have seen that holds true through all of the ICE propaganda, which is that they never post videos where there are people around standing on the streets looking at what's happening and protesting.
Noelle King
Almost every bystander video, often it's the person who's filming themselves. No, I'm going to have to revoke it. No, if it's against me. No. Mommy. You guys cannot take her! Just because you guys want to!
Catherine Van Arendonk
No te preocupe, Karen, no te preocupe. Tranquilla. I been fucked up Tranquilla mama You guys have been fucked up for me Hablale Abulisse You act like you would have fucking kids.
Noelle King
And and they are screaming and they are yelling and they're trying to block traffic. F*** you! Get out of here! Hey, don't hurt him! You don't need to hurt him!
Catherine Van Arendonk
You know what? You were a f***ing immigrant, too. Your family was an immigrant, too, you f***ing old. None of you are f***ing Native. None of you are Native American. You all started out as immigrants. F***ing remember that s***. Remember that.
Noelle King
What part of Europe are you from?
Catherine Van Arendonk
That's what never shows up in the ICE propaganda videos.
Noelle King
I was watching a lot of these videos this afternoon, both the bystander and the official ones. And ICE clearly wants us, the official narrative clearly is, this is happening effortlessly.
Catherine Van Arendonk
Yeah. But then, my gosh, some of these ones that are taken in the streets, you see the fight, you see the person pushed down on the hood of a car, you see the person's kids screaming, somebody's being dragged away.
Noelle King
And notably, the ICE agents have their faces covered. And you think, well, if it was effortless, y'all would not be wearing masks.
Catherine Van Arendonk
What do you take from the attempt to get us to think that this is really simple versus the reality?
Noelle King
Yeah, they really seem invested in this image of deportation where the people who are being taken away are not complaining. They are not fighting it. They seem in most ICE videos, people are led away very calmly. Nobody's weeping. It's not like there are people's family members surrounding them. There aren't children crying.
Catherine Van Arendonk
But there are plenty of other ICE videos where you can see their masks. You can see that this is how they come into spaces. There's one pretty significant raid that happened at the Glen Valley Foods facility in Omaha, where the local news coverage, which was then reposted by ICE and by DHS.
Noelle King
You can see. You can see all of their masks and you can see the vests and you can see how inhuman and how terrifying, frankly, all of the ICE agents look.
Catherine Van Arendonk
But you can also see what they show you in that footage that they reposted is like calm people walking in orderly lines out of this facility.
Noelle King
But there are bystander videos of that exact same event. And they take they begin much earlier. They begin with people in the lunchroom crying, calling their loved ones, shouting at the ICE agents.
Catherine Van Arendonk
So there's a man who's sitting down in one of the bystander videos and an ICE agent says, we have a warrant. And the guy says, here's my bag of fuck.
Noelle King
And like, this is not something that ever shows up in the ICE propaganda because they don't want you to know. They have no interest in displaying how angry people are about this.
Catherine Van Arendonk
I think there's a huge utility. And I was really, I did not feel this at first. As I was watching more and more of these, though, I was so taken with how many of the bystander videos actually don't show anything at all.
Noelle King
Like it will be a guy in a car and he's driving down the block and he has spotted what are clearly ice video, ice trucks parked down the block.
Catherine Van Arendonk
Hey, where's your fucking warrant? Where's your warrant? No, fuck you. Give me your badge and your name. You guys have no warrant, no probable cause. Shame on you guys. Shame on you.
Noelle King
And it's just people trying to say, like, I don't know what this is, but I hate it. And I need everyone to be with me on it, I think.
Catherine Van Arendonk
Are also so powerful because it is so easy to watch how effortless this kind of thing appears to be when ICE posts it and to feel so powerless in response.
Noelle King
And instead, when you watch all these bystander videos, you feel like, all right, this is at least here's a thing I can do. I can be mad about this. I can yell at those guys. Maybe I can try to block their traffic a little bit.
Catherine Van Arendonk
I can tell other people about how I feel about it. And at least I will be less alone. And we will all know that this is a thing that you are not alone in feeling, that this is how people are responding. And you can too.
Noelle King
You had to watch a lot of these videos for your piece. Is there one of them that you're having trouble forgetting?
Catherine Van Arendonk
There are a lot I've been having trouble forgetting. But the one that I really struck on and sort of became the end point of that essay was a video that was not particularly popular yet, although it became much, much popular very shortly.
Noelle King
And it was a bunch of roofers sitting up on a roofline. It was filmed by one of the roofers.
Catherine Van Arendonk
And it's like a beautiful, brilliant day. He's in Lafayette, Louisiana. They're in the middle of building this roof. It's like in pieces around them. And you can see him astride the roof line. He's like way up in the sky and he points the phone down and you can see ICE agents just waiting for them on the ground.
Noelle King
And nothing happens in that video. There's no, we don't see the results of it.
Catherine Van Arendonk
And you actually can go later onto his account and see later videos. And what he says in the later videos is like, we were all okay. They didn't take any of us, but thank you all for worrying.
Noelle King
You can read Catherine Van Arendonk at Vulture.
Closing
Today's show was produced by Hadi Muagdeh, Miles Bryan, and Peter Balonon-Rosen. It was edited by Amina El-Sadi, Andrea Christensdottir, and Patrick Boyd are our engineers, and Laura Bullard and Gabrielle Berbacek, the facts. I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.