Main Topic: The podcast episode explores the topic of anti-Semitism, its definition, and how to distinguish it from legitimate criticism of Israel. The discussion centers around the recent rise in anti-Semitic incidents and the challenge of balancing criticism of Israel with the need to protect Jewish communities from hate speech and violence.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
Welcome to Today Explained, I'm Noel King.
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
I'm Rabbi Jill Jacobs, and I'm the CEO of TRUA, the rabbinic call for human rights.
Noel King
Rabbi Jacobs, thanks for joining me today.
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
Thanks for having me.
Noel King
So, since October 7th, there's been a lot of debate over what is and isn't antisemitic. Can you tell me a little bit about your work and how you've seen this issue play out?
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
Well, a lot of our work has focused on both supporting the rabbis and cantors who are supporting their own communities and helping them to be able to speak to their communities to hold them pastorally, and also bringing a moral voice that says that it's not only possible, but actually necessary to speak to the humanity of both Israelis and Palestinians.
Noel King
That's really interesting. I want to get into some of the specifics of what you've seen, but first, can you define antisemitism for me? How do you define it?
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
The short definition is that antisemitism is hatred or prejudice against Jews as Jews. And it started more than 2,000 years ago, really with the advent of Christianity and especially with the Roman Empire converting to Christianity and Christianity having power behind it.
Noel King
That's fascinating. I want to get into some of the specifics of what you've seen since October 7th, but first, I want to bring in another guest who's been thinking a lot about this issue. Noah Feldman is a law professor and the director of the Center for Jewish and Israeli Law at Harvard Law School. Welcome to the show, Professor Feldman.
Noah Feldman
Thanks for having me.
Noel King
Professor Feldman, can you tell me a little bit about how the debate over antisemitism has unfolded at Harvard?
Noah Feldman
It has been an exceptionally intense year for Jewish and Israel-related matters at Harvard, going back to October 7. A crucial question on our campus, as on many campuses around the country, has been, When does criticism of Israel, legitimate in itself, cross over into antisemitism that violates university rules and that also violates rules of basic decency?
Noel King
That's really interesting. I want to get into some of the specifics of what you've seen, but first, can you tell me about the Anti-Semitism Awareness Act? What would it do if it passes?
Noah Feldman
It's pretty subtle. Under Title VI, which is part of the civil rights laws, universities cannot discriminate themselves on the basis of race or national origin or sex. But it also says that the university has an obligation to create conditions on campus where no one is blocked from full participation in the life of the university by virtue of those protected categories.
Noel King
I see. And what's the controversy around this law?
Noah Feldman
Some Jewish organizations have spoken out against the Anti-Semitism Awareness Act because the examples given by the IHRA definition of antisemitism are not considered to be antisemitism by some Jews or are considered to be too broad a definition of antisemitism.
Noel King
That's really interesting. Rabbi Jacobs, can you respond to that?
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
I think that's a really important point. The IHRA definition is not perfect, but it's a good starting point for understanding what antisemitism is. And I think it's really important to educate people about the history of antisemitism and how it's been used to justify violence and discrimination against Jews.
Noel King
I see. Professor Feldman, can you tell me a little bit about what you think needs to be done to combat antisemitism beyond just passing laws?
Noah Feldman
The short answer is that laws are really good for interfering with discriminatory conduct. It says to people, you can't do that. Laws are not very good at changing people's hearts and minds. You have to be able to educate people by saying, look, you may not know this, but antisemitism has a long history. And there are certain words, certain attitudes, certain points of view that Jews respond to in a certain way because of that history.
Noel King
That's really interesting. Rabbi Jacobs, can you tell me a little bit about your own approach to combating antisemitism?
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
I think it's really about conversation and education. That's what changes people's hearts and minds over time. And I think it's really important to listen to people and to try to understand where they're coming from, even if we disagree with them.
Noel King
I see. Well, thank you both for joining me today.
Rabbi Jill Jacobs
Thanks for having us.
Noah Feldman
Thanks for having us.
Theme music starts playing
Noel King
That's it for today's show. Thanks for listening.
Theme music continues to play until the end of the episode