Main Topic: The confirmation hearing of Gina Haspel, President Donald Trump's pick to be the next director of the CIA, amidst controversy over her involvement in the CIA's black site in Thailand where torture took place.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Sean Rameswaram
All right, here we are. Here we are at Mattress Firm. I think it's locked. Did you check the hours before we came here? [Sound of doors being checked]
Oh, whoops. Oh, no. Oh, man. All right, well, what should we do now? I don't know. Go to mattressfirm.com slash podcast and use the coupon code podcast10 to get 10% off a mattress. Should we just do that? I mean, but then you never get to try them, right? It's true. I never did get to try them. I just got to watch you enjoy trying them. I do want to do that. Should we try another mattress firm? I know the next one. It's just a few miles down the road. Okay. I guess we're taking a long walk.
Jen Williams
Jen Williams, Deputy Foreign and National Security Editor here at Vox. Welcome. Gina Haspel: [Not explicitly stated, but implied as the guest, Gina Haspel, is being discussed]
Sean Rameswaram
Gina Haspel, not exactly a household name, but about to be one. Who is she? Jen Williams: Right. So she is President Donald Trump's pick to be the next director of the CIA. She's 61 years old. She's a she. She would be the first female director of the CIA.
Haspel has worked at the CIA for 33 years and spent most of her career undercover. Her first day in the agency's counterterrorism center was faithfully September 11th, 2001.
Jen Williams
So almost a second after it was announced that Gina Haspel would be the candidate to replace Mike Pompeo, who's now Secretary of State, this information that she may have presided over this black site in Thailand came up like in 2002.
Sean Rameswaram
What is a black site? Jen Williams: So a black site was this kind of creation during the Bush administration, the war on terror. Right. We, meaning the U.S. military and the U.S. government, needed a place to take prisoners of war that they captured terrorists or suspected terrorists. And they needed a place to put them where they could, put it bluntly, torture people. And they didn't want to do it in U.S. jurisdiction because then they would have to, you know, follow U.S. law.
Jen Williams
I mean, even the existence of these sites was secret for a long time. And she oversaw the probably most notorious of all the black sites, this one in Thailand. And that's where the horrific torture of several individuals, including someone called Abu Zubaydah, occurred.
Sean Rameswaram
Abu Zubaydah was a logistician for al-Qaeda. Even though he did not ever formally join the group and never pledged fealty to Osama bin Laden, he was the group's logistician. If you were an Al-Qaeda fighter and you wanted to go home, you needed a passport, maybe a ticket, Abu Zubaydah was the guy.
Jen Williams
So we're talking waterboarding, we're talking throwing him up against a wall repeatedly, stress positions. At one point, they locked him in a tiny wooden coffin. He couldn't move or breathe barely in for hours at a time.
Sean Rameswaram
So horrific treatment. And there's proof of this? Jen Williams: Oh, yeah, absolutely. So this is all documented in the 2014 Senate Intel Committee report.
The Senate Intelligence Committee report didn't even come out until 2014. Right. So that's just four years ago. So there's all this kind of internal reckoning of who did what and who was to blame and who should be fired and who needs to stay.
Jen Williams
Now, the Senate Intel Committee report that you can go and download the PDF and read online, that is the small redacted version of the real actual report. I see. So we say redacted, right? Like they took a big black marker and crossed out everybody's names.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. Problem is they crossed out everybody's names. So we don't know if Gina Haspel's name is in there or not. But it has been reported in multiple locations, multiple places, independently reported that she was overseeing this black site either on or around the time that Abu Zubaydah or other individuals were tortured.
Jen Williams
Now, there's a whole nother issue we haven't even talked about that's kind of related to the black site and related to the torture, but not about her doing the torture or overseeing it. It has to do with videotapes.
Sean Rameswaram
Videotapes. Actual old school VHS black videotapes that you put in your VCR. And you have to remember, For people who didn't live through, you know, the post 9-11 war on terror, the American military and the CIA had no idea what the hell to do.
Jen Williams
And so they literally were making the stuff up as they went along. They were basically told by the Bush administration, take the gloves off. Seriously, we just got hit on 9-11. Let's just let's just do this.
Sean Rameswaram
And they were videotaping what they were doing. So they were videotaping what they were doing, which, you know, they were like, OK, well, we're going to, you know, have to replicate this. Let's videotape it. We'll go through, look at our techniques, see what happens.
Jen Williams
You know, and again, you have evidence of what they said, what they didn't say. But it's not like this stuff was ever going to be used in a court of law. They knew they were torturing him. So this would never be admissible in any court.
Sean Rameswaram
But they videotaped it. They pretty soon realized hey maybe that wasn't the best idea.
Jen Williams
Yeah. You know all this stuff about black sites and torture started coming out. The CIA has these black sites, secret prison cells around the world in which we are disappearing people in the war on terror. Approximately 100 people have been disappeared, according to The Washington Post story, into these so-called black sites.
Sean Rameswaram
And they were like, shit, we should probably get rid of those tapes. I'm thinking because it's war crimes that we have documented evidence of us doing. That's bad. And we could go to prison in The Hague.
Jen Williams
So they destroyed the tapes of the black site, of the torture of Abu Zubaydah and other people. And by they, I mean Gina Haspel.
Sean Rameswaram
Okay, so they destroy all the tapes. How does all of this come to light then?
Jen Williams
So they declassified and released this 2011 secret disciplinary review. So this kind of internal review they did after the fact, right? So we're out of the Bush administration now, but there's still all this kind of reckoning that needs to be done, right.
Sean Rameswaram
The Senate Intelligence Committee report didn't even come out until 2014. Right. So that's just four years ago. So there's all this kind of internal reckoning of who did what and who was to blame and who should be fired and who needs to stay.
Jen Williams
This review found that the decision to destroy the tapes was not made by Gina Haspel, but by her boss, Jose Rodriguez. So he was to blame. He was the one who issued the order.
Sean Rameswaram
She, being the good soldier, just doing her job, then followed through and made sure those tapes got destroyed. Right. So she's not to blame, according to this internal review.
Jen Williams
Okay. The CIA issued a letter of reprimand to Jose Rodriguez, to her boss. You know, for his behavior, you know, drafting an order to her to essentially destroy these tapes.
Sean Rameswaram
She drafted the cable on his behalf saying, hey, we got to destroy these tapes, right? Yeah. She, according to the CIA officials, is not to blame because she was just a good soldier.
Jen Williams
And in fact, that actually goes to why some people in the CIA still support her and have come out in support of her for CIA director. Right. She's very popular amongst the rank and file.
Sean Rameswaram
I've read. She is among some, right? Not everyone, right? You know, a lot of people in the CIA, this is the darkest kind of era of the CIA or one of the darkest in their history, right?
Jen Williams
But, you know, a lot of them, the people who were involved at the CIA feel like, look, our president, you know, president, vice president at the very top, they told us, they ordered us, you know, we were at war. We had just been hit by 9-11. They ordered us to take the gloves off. We did what we could. You know we did what we were told we asked them is this legal they gave us legal you know briefing saying yes this is legal so some of them see this kind of attack on Gina Haspel you know and and trying to hold her accountable for something that she was just told to do as you know not fair right and they want to kind of rally around her and go no she was a soldier out there fighting and trying to catch terrorists and stop terror attacks yeah you know she's not a monster she's a patriot and
Sean Rameswaram
And that is kind of where the dichotomy is here. Like that's the struggle that we're trying to kind of tease out and that the Senate is going to try to get to the bottom of.
Jen Williams
You mentioned that the country, the government, the intelligence community was still sort of reckoning for torture that happened after 9-11 as late as 2014. Right. Is this Gina Haspel hearing like a continuation of that reckoning or has there been sort of a really pivotal moment where someone owned this and said this was a mistake and we're sorry?
Sean Rameswaram
So at the CIA there never really was that reckoning so the big dramatic American apology reckoning for torture was Obama standing up in front of a microphone and basically shrugging and saying we tortured some folks we did some things that were contrary to our values and that was the first time that the U.S government had openly admitted and used the word torture and said yes we tortured people.
Jen Williams
So that was like the big yes, we admitted it, we took responsibility. But it's not like Obama took responsibility for it himself, right? He wasn't president at the time.
Sean Rameswaram
And, you know, he immediately issued executive orders and did all these things to try to make sure mostly that it couldn't happen again, although it very easily very well could because executive orders can easily just be changed by the president.
Jen Williams
And he didn't actually, like Congress didn't actually pass any special laws to make sure this would never happen again. But at the CIA, there was no single person at all held accountable for this in terms of nobody went to jail. Nobody went to prison. Nobody had a public hearing being prosecuted for terrorism. Nobody was called to the international criminal court in the Hague to stand trial for war crimes for torture You know nobody faced any accountability
Sean Rameswaram
And that the problem So yes this is still like the lingering kind of reckoning that this country is dealing with You know, it was actually kind of shocking when Gina Haspel's name was announced. Whether or not she directly oversaw torture is the big question. But she was the one. Her name is on the cable. We have the cables that show, you know, Gina Haspel issued these cables to destroy evidence of torture. That's not kind of up for debate at all. That's not up for debate.
Jen Williams
Gina Haspel heads to the Senate for her confirmation hearings tomorrow, but it seems like she doesn't really want to go. That's in a beat.
Sean Rameswaram
So here's a thought. I'm just spitballing here. And again, no judgments, no blame for bringing us to a mattress firm really early in the morning. My bad. Okay, fair, fair. Thanks for owning it. If we get to this next mattress firm, they too might still be closed. I mean, I don't want to make any assumptions. I feel like we should just check and see.
Jen Williams
Yeah, it looks like they open at 10 a.m., which is reasonable. We can go there at 10, but we'll have to make it snappier. You got any ideas on how we can get there faster than, let's say, walking a mile?
Sean Rameswaram
Oh, man. Well, I mean, we could take maybe one of these little scooters that are lying around all over Washington, D.C. Oh, snap. There are two scooters right at Logan Circle.
Jen Williams
Do you know where Logan Circle is? Yeah, yeah. I know where that is. Do you want to go get them? Why not? We're not that far away.
Sean Rameswaram
So this almost didn't happen, this Gina Haspel confirmation hearing. I hear she maybe like wanted to pull herself out of Senate confirmation hearings. Right. So it turns out that last Friday she met with some White House officials to kind of talk through some of the issues she might face during her confirmation hearing.
Jen Williams
And it seems from what the Washington Post reported that she proceeded to go back to Langley to the CIA headquarters to her office and freak the fuck out. And basically like, I don't know if I'm going to get confirmed. I don't want to drag my name, the Trump administration or the CIA like through the mud. Maybe I should just withdraw.
Sean Rameswaram
And some senior officials at the White House, including Sarah Huckabee Sanders and Mark Short, who's the head of legislative affairs, they proceeded to haul ass over to Langley and spend several hours talking her back into it. According to The Washington Post, even after that, they weren't entirely sure that she was going to stick with her nomination until Saturday.
Jen Williams
Okay. Trump apparently found out about all this drama on Friday while he was on his trip to Dallas to talk to the NRA. He apparently decided that like at first he'd be like well I'm okay with whatever she thinks but then apparently was like oh I'm just I'm just gonna support her so apparently as of Monday it seems like her nomination is going ahead and then as of yesterday she was on Capitol Hill meeting with like senators for these kind of pre-interview interviews before she actually goes to testify before the Senate Intelligence Committee so it looks like it's happening so how is she going to do tomorrow do we know whether she's actually got a chance of being confirmed so um senator john mccain republican senator from arizona was tortured as a prisoner of war in vietnam right uh obviously has a bit of an issue with torture and people who do it so he has kind of been leading the charge um of hey you need to answer for this right and he He wrote this letter saying, you know, I need you to answer this list of questions.
Did you oversee interrogations at this place? Did you, you know, were you engaged in? Did you oversee, you know, were you involved in waterboarding? You know, enhanced interrogation because that's what the government called it at the time.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's not just him, right? It's Democrats and Republicans. But CIA released some, just recently released some biographical details because everyone is literally scrambling like, who the hell is this lady?
Jen Williams
And if you see her she looks like what you would think the complete unassuming spy woman would look like right I'm gonna look her up right now she has kind of mousy brown hair she looks like she could be you know your sixth graders you know principal I was gonna say she looks just like a random lady who passes on the street and whose face you would forget within a minute ouch no but that's a good thing in what you're doing if you're in clandestine operations You do not want people to know your face.
Sean Rameswaram
Interesting. You want to blend in It a very big asset It one of the reasons why I not a spy because good gut You covered in tats Good luck forgetting me ever
Jen Williams
So yeah and that kind of the problem right that we didn have this information on her And I say we, I don't mean we reporters or we just the American people. I mean the Senate Intelligence Committee, whose literal job is to oversee the activities of the intelligence community. They're the ones requesting this information. And they're really mad because they feel like the CIA is stonewalling them.
Sean Rameswaram
If she's not allowed to say anything about her past and her experiences in the CIA and the work she did, then are senators likely to get any more clarity than they already don't have? That's the big question, right?
Jen Williams
So senators, especially senators on the Senate Intelligence Committee, are given access to classified information. They are representatives of the American people, right? Yeah. They will, you know, ask the questions. And we've seen this in other hearings. Right. And they will say, you know, Gina may say, I can't answer that in a public setting that's classified, but I'd be happy to to address it a little bit more in closed session.
Sean Rameswaram
It's possible they would do that, especially with someone as sensitive as this. But Dianne Feinstein, right? So she was the lead author essentially of the 2014 Senate Intelligence Committee report. She is really, really pushing the CIA to go ahead and declassify stuff. So we don't even have to talk about the classified information. Tell us what she did, where she was, what she was involved in. And so they kind of did.
Jen Williams
So at the end of March, they released some biographical details about Gina Haspel, including that she likes Johnny Cash, which that totally is what everyone needed to know. Give her the job. Yeah, that sold. You torture someone, that's cool. Johnny Cash is the man in black. You're the woman in the black site. Let's do it.
Sean Rameswaram
The sergeant put me in a cell, then he went home for the night. I said, come back here, you so-and-so. I ain't being treated right. Well, they bound to get you.
Jen Williams
But there was not a lot of detail. There's nothing about did she or did she not literally run this black site. Yeah. Considering her background and these murky torture waters that she's in, obviously not the strongest choice. You could find someone who has a less controversial background. Right. So why do we think President Trump chose her?
Sean Rameswaram
When Trump was on the campaign trail, he said, I would bring back waterboarding and I'd bring back a hell of a lot worse than waterboarding. By taking someone who, you know, has. This kind of murky background and someone that many in the CIA see is this official who, you know, was in the trenches fighting in the war on terror and saying, look, I'm going to put this person in charge. Really sends a clear message to the CIA that, like, we're going to really just take the gloves off again.
Jen Williams
It seems like a pretty big boys club. What does it mean that she might be the first ever female executive? I mean, from a straight up, you know, feminist perspective, if you're just looking at the gender selection, it's great. However, that said, to have a female who may or may not have tortured humans, that's not feminism. That's not what feminism was about. It's not, let's get the best woman we can to also do terrible things. I know for a fact there are plenty of qualified women in the CIA who weren't involved in the torture interrogation program. So yes, it's good that a woman is potentially going to head the CIA. It's not great that this woman is going to potentially head the CIA.
Sean Rameswaram
Jen Williams is the co-host of the Worldly Podcast at Vox. I'm Sean Rameswaram from This is Today Explained.
Jen Williams
All right, look, Vanderplug, we're here at Logan Circle. We've found two scooters. We're about to hop on them and head to Mattress Firm. Sounds good to me. I think we'll make it just on time.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm a little worried about your safety holding that microphone and recording these ads. I'm a nimble man.
Jen Williams
All right, dear listener, get ready for the windiest mattress ads you've ever heard. It could have been easier if we had just gone to mattressfirm.com slash podcast. So glad you remembered the website.