Main Topic: The January 6th committee hearings and their significance in uncovering the events surrounding the 2021 US Capitol attack.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
It's Today Explained. I'm Noel King.
Pause
The January 6th committee wants access to deleted text messages that members of the U.S. Secret Service sent to each other on January 5th and 6th. If you have them, we need them. The Secret Service says those messages were lost during a pre-planned system migration.
Pause
What may be the last hearing of the Jan 6th committee is scheduled for this week. No one knows, though, if it will be the real finale.
Pause
There have been surprises before, like in late June. Benny Thompson says, OK, we're done for June. We'll see you after the 4th of July. Many of us were sort of packing up our bags to go when we got word. Oh, no, there is another hearing coming, a surprise hearing, and we don't know anything about it.
Pause
We don't know who's testifying. We don't know why it's coming up. And then we learn who is going to testify. What happened at the surprise hearing and what's going to be done with all this information? Coming up.
Pause
Support for Today Explained comes from Saks Fifth Avenue. Fall is here. Might be time to find some nice new pieces you can wear again and again.
Pause
With Saks Fifth Avenue, it can be a breeze to shop for your personal style, like maybe a relaxed Prada blazer or Gucci loafers that are great for both work and the weekend.
Pause
This is very Sean-coded. Gucci loafers. Saks says Saks makes shopping feel totally customized to you, whether that's from an in-store stylist or a visit to Saks.com, where they can show you just what you want to see.
Pause
They say they'll even let you know when arrivals from your favorite designers are in or when something you've been eyeing is back in stock. You can find inspiration for your personal style every day at Saks Fifth Avenue.
Pause
We all have moments where we could have done better, like cutting your own hair. Oh, yikes. Or forgetting sunscreen so now you look like a tomato. Ouch. Could have done better.
Pause
Same goes for where you invest. Level up and invest smarter with Schwab. Get market insights, education, and human help when you need it. Learn more at schwab.com.
Pause
Today Explained, we're back. Andrea Bernstein, co-host of the podcast Will Be Wild, about the attack on the Capitol, and author of the book American Oligarchs, the Kushners, the Trumps, and the Marriage of Money and Power.
Pause
Andrea Bernstein
Benny Thompson makes that announcement, and the surprise witness was 26-year-old Cassidy Hutchinson.
Pause
And there seems to be broad agreement that this is a huge moment, a watershed moment in these hearings.
Pause
She was, you know, a young person in the White House, but because of the way the White House is organized, she was in the room with all of these immensely powerful people.
Pause
And, you know, it's also someone who had gained their trust. And they said many things to her. You know, she was texting with people, she was speaking to people, she had a direct relationship with the former president.
Pause
And, you know, it was this extraordinary moment when this 26-year-old woman comes out and just answers questions.
Pause
Thanks to the courage of certain individuals, the truth won't be buried. The American people won't be left in the dark.
Pause
Our witness today, Ms. Cassie Hutchinson, has embodied that courage.
Pause
And, you know, what had happened with her, interestingly, was that she had been supplied a lawyer by the Trump team.
Pause
She became increasingly uncomfortable with that lawyer and switched attorneys to a man named Jody Hunt.
Pause
After she hires him, she calls up the committee and she says, I have more to say.
Pause
They take a fourth deposition and they realize that they need to get her out in the public right away.
Pause
Both this luck in her testimony and also because they begin to hear that she's being intimidated by people close to the former president and they don't want anything to change.
Pause
So that's when they spring this testimony on us.
Pause
And it is dramatic, not only because she's describing all of these interactions with the former president, but because she's telling us things that we just didn't know.
Pause
For example, that he wanted so badly to go to the Capitol that he had a confrontation with his security team after the infamous speech at the Ellipse.
Pause
The president said something to the effect of, I'm the effing president, take me up to the Capitol now.
Pause
To which Bobby responded, sir, we have to go back to the West Wing.
Pause
The president reached up towards the front of the vehicle to grab at the steering wheel.
Pause
Mr. Engel grabbed his arm, said, sir, you need to take your hand off the steering wheel. We're going back to the West Wing. We're not going to the Capitol.
Pause
Mr. Trump then used his free hand to lunge towards Bobby Engel.
Pause
And when Mr. Renato had recounted this story to me, he had motioned towards his clavicles.
Pause
He was aware that the crowd was armed. And knowing that, knowing the kinds of weapons they had, pepper spray, spears attached to the end of flagpoles, body armor, directed them to go to the Capitol.
Pause
That was extraordinary evidence.
Pause
And that was just one part of the testimony that she delivered to the committee that was so revealing.
Pause
That was one part. What else about her testimony stood out to you?
Pause
Well, I think that, you know, she sort of starts out by talking about interaction she has with Rudy Giuliani, the former attorney for the former president.
Pause
And it's on January 2nd and she's walking him out to the parking lot and he says to her, Cassie, are you excited for the 6th? It's going to be a great day. We're going to the Capitol. It's going to be great.
Pause
The president's going to be there. He's going to look powerful. He's going to be with the members. He's going to be with the senators.
Pause
And she is really not sure what that's about.
Pause
And she goes and she asks Mark Meadows, who is sitting on the couch in his office looking at his phone.
Pause
I remember leaning against the doorway and saying, I had an interesting conversation with Rudy, Mark.
Pause
It sounds like we're going to go to the Capitol.
Pause
He didn't look up from his phone and said something to the effect of, there's a lot going on, Cass. But I don't know. Things might get real, real bad on January 6th.
Pause
So she begins to get worried because this is several days beforehand.
Pause
She doesn't know what's happening.
Pause
And she in on these meetings where the White House is warned that there may be violence where on January 6th itself she accompanies the former president to the speech at the Ellipse.
Pause
When we were in the offstage announced tent, I was part of a conversation. I was in the vicinity of a conversation where I overheard the president say something to the effect of, you know, I don't effing care that they have weapons.
Pause
They're not here to hurt me. Take the effing mags away. Let my people in. They can march to the Capitol from here. Let the people in. Take the effing mags away.
Pause
Well, she tries to talk to Mark Meadows, the former chief of staff, and he's in his car and he slams the car door on her.
Pause
And he does this twice.
Pause
And this is really an extraordinary moment of what is going on with the former chief of staff, that he won't take this information about the gathering attack on the Capitol at this crucial moment in history.
Pause
So, you know, that was something that really, really struck me about her testimony.
Pause
And, you know, then all of these details about, for example, the former White House counsel, Pat Cipollone, being aware that there might be violence at the Capitol, that the president has legal liability if he goes to the Capitol because of incitement to riot.
Pause
And she really sort of lays the broad outline of this last desperate attempt by the former president to hang on to power.
Pause
The most recent hearings centered some extremist groups, including the Proud Boys and the Oath Keepers.
Pause
Was there anything notable about the testimony from members of these groups or ex-members of these groups?
Pause
I think for most people it was quite shocking news to have a description from a former Oath Keepers insider of, you know, what the group was, which was, as he described it, a militia group who wanted to sow chaos and violence and bring about civil war.
Pause
I think we need to quit mincing words and just talk about truths.
Pause
And what it was going to be was an armed revolution.
Pause
I mean, people died that day. There was a gallows set up in front of the Capitol.
Pause
This could have been the spark that started a new civil war.
Pause
The other, you know, sort of person who basically had come to hear the president's speech and sort of rode the wave of the crowd to the Capitol was basically talking about he was following the former president's orders.
Pause
No, we didn't actually plan to go down there. You know, we went basically to see the Stop the Steal rally and that was it.
Pause
So why did you decide to march to the Capitol?
Pause
Well, basically, you know, the president, you know, got everybody riled up, told everybody head on down.
Pause
So we basically would just follow on what he said.
Pause
So if you really had no sort of exposure before to the Oath Keepers or the Proud Boys, I think this was a very effective testimony for some people.
Pause
Can you tell us about the December 18th meeting?
Pause
The startling conclusion is this. Even an agreed-upon complete lack of evidence could not stop President Trump, Mark Meadows, and their allies from trying to overturn the results of a free and fair election.
Pause
So let's return to that meeting at the White House on the evening of December 18.
Pause
Just to set this in context, so December 14th is the Electoral College vote.
Pause
And on December 14th, obviously, Joe Biden is declared the president of the United States.
Pause
And this is the point at which Mitch McConnell, then the Senate majority leader, who, you know, really has not been saying anything, he's been avoiding saying anything about Trump losing, says, you know, we have to recognize that Joe Biden is the president.
Pause
Many millions of us had hoped the presidential election would yield a different result.
Pause
The Electoral College has spoken.
Pause
According to the former White House counsel, Pat Cipollone, he told Trump the same thing. Basically, it's over.
Pause
Well, what does Trump do?
Pause
For Trump, it's not over.
Pause
So he doesn't like the fact that his attorney general, his new acting attorney general, his White House counsel, his other lawyers, even people on his campaign are telling him he lost.
Pause
So he takes a meeting with this fringe group and they go to the White House and they present this really extraordinary plan.
Pause
And, you know, credit to The New York Times and others who had reported on this meeting in real time.
Pause
But who is there? Sidney Powell, a lawyer who has espoused conspiracy theories so fringy that her own lawyer has disavowed them in court records.
Pause
Rudy Giuliani is there at some point.
Pause
General Michael Flynn, who was convicted of lying to the FBI, had only been recently pardoned by Trump.
Pause
And they are discussing with the president what is really clearly an extra-legal plan of getting his Department of Defense to seize voting machines.
Pause
And Pat Cipollone is telling the president this is a terrible idea.
Pause
And he is annoyed in his deposition with the committee when they say, well, why did you think that was a terrible idea?
Pause
I don't understand why we tell you why that's a bad idea. I think it's a terrible idea.
Pause
That is the wee hours after midnight on December 18th.
Pause
So early the morning of December 19th.
Pause
At 1.42 a.m., the president sends out this infamous message, which starts with a restatement of the big lie that it was, as he said, statistically impossible for him to have lost.
Pause
And then he says, big protest in Washington, D.C., January 6th. Be there. We'll be wild.
Pause
What we don't know as we go into the final hearing of the committee is whether the idea of a large rally of summoning a mob to Washington was discussed in that unhinged meeting.
Pause
And that's one of the big questions that I have.
Pause
Was this something that General Michael Flynn and Sidney Powell were saying he should do?
Pause
Or was this something that he came up with on his own?
Pause
But what happens, and I think is what a very underplayed aspect of hearing number seven.
Pause
It's according to an employee of Twitter who we don't know who it is because that person's voice was disguised.
Pause
He said what really scared me was that the president was now speaking directly to extremist groups.
Pause
And we know from what happened that people like Alex Jones, the Oath Keepers, the Proud Boys immediately get together and they start talking about working together, deploying people to Washington.
Pause
There was actually an encrypted chat group with Roger Stone sort of the devil who been on Trump's shoulder since the 1980s advising him on how to get around things for lack of a better way of describing it.
Pause
So this is someone who's very close to the president, who he's in phone contact with, who Cassidy Hutchinson, in fact, testified that Trump wanted Mark Meadows to speak to Roger Stone on the evening before the rally.
Pause
He is in a chat group with the leaders of these extremist groups who are basically saying, you know, come to Washington, come armed. January 6th is going to be a big day where we are going to change the course of history.
Pause
Noel King
Support for today's show comes from Adio.
Pause
What is Adio?
Pause
Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies.
Pause
They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Pause
According to Adio, Adio takes less than a minute to set up.
Pause
And within seconds, you will have your email and calendars synced.
Pause
You'll see all your relationships in a fully fledged platform, they say, all enriched with that actionable data.
Pause
And they say you can build AI-powered automations and use its research agent to tackle some of your most complex processes to seize so that you can focus on what matters. building your company.
Pause
You can join industry leaders such as Flatfile, Replicate, Modal, and so much more.
Pause
You can go to attio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
Pause
That's attio.com slash todayexplained.
Pause
Let's be honest. Are you happy with your job? Like, really happy?
Pause
The unfortunate fact is that a huge number of people can't say yes to that.
Pause
Far too many of us are stuck in a job we've outgrown, or one we never wanted in the first place.
Pause
But still, we stick it out, and we give reasons like, what if the next move is even worse?
Pause
I've already put years into this place, and maybe the most common one, isn't everyone kind of miserable at work?
Pause
But there's a difference between reasons for staying and excuses for not leaving.
Pause
It's time to get unstuck.
Pause
It's time for strawberry.me.
Pause
They match you with a certified career coach who helps you go from where you are to where you actually want to be.
Pause
Your coach helps you get clear on your goals, create a plan, build your confidence, and keeps you accountable along the way.
Pause
So don't leave your career to chance.
Pause
Take action and own your future with a professional coach in your corner.
Pause
Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Pause
That's strawberry.me slash unstuck.
Pause
Every one of these elements of the planning for January 6th is an independently serious matter.
Pause
They were all ultimately focused on overturning the election.
Pause
And they all have one other thing in common.
Pause
Donald Trump participated in each substantially and personally.
Pause
Today Explained, we're back with Andrea Bernstein, host of the podcast will be wild.
Pause
Andrea Bernstein
One of the things that I think has been so effective about these hearings is that right after January 6, there was still a spin on the part of some supporters of the former president.
Pause
Look, this was a protest rally that got out of hand, and there was no intent for the president to launch a violent attack on law enforcement.
Pause
And, you know, had the law enforcement people not been there, potentially on members of Congress.
Pause
I mean, we know from videotape that members of Congress were seconds away.
Pause
Mike Pence was, you know, sort of 40 paces away from the mob that was saying, hang Mike Pence, and that had erected a gallows outside the Capitol.
Pause
So there was a sense of, well, maybe, you know, he didn't know what he was unleashing or what he was trying to do.
Pause
But one of the things that these hearings have done is almost made that question irrelevant because we know how hard he worked to subvert the lawful transfer of power.
Pause
We know from some of this very dramatic testimony by the top officials at the Justice Department right before January 6th that he had tried to install someone at the Department of Justice who was going to tell state legislatures to not send up their slates of electors to Washington.
Pause
He said, so suppose I do this. Suppose I replace him, Jeff Rosen, with him, Jeff Clark.
Pause
What would you do?
Pause
And I said, Mr. President, we resign immediately. I'm not working one minute for this guy.
Pause
I'm telling you what's going to happen. You're going to lose your entire department leadership.
Pause
We know that he tried to influence the secretary of state in Georgia to recount the votes.
Pause
We know that he was pressuring state legislatures all around the country directly and that he was putting extraordinary amounts of pressure on his vice president, including a meeting that his own daughter described as heated in the White House.
Pause
The conversation was pretty heated.
Pause
Where, according to the top aide to Ivanka Trump, who was senior White House advisor at the time, where he called Mike Pence.
Pause
The P word.
Pause
This was 1120 on the morning of January 6th.
Pause
So less than two hours before the vote count, he was screaming at Mike Pence that he had to not go ahead and certify the votes.
Pause
So we know that he was trying up to the last minute to block the transfer of power.
Pause
We know that he directed a violent mob that he knew was armed to the Capitol.
Pause
So at this point, it's sort of, well, does it matter if he picked up the phone and called someone the Oath Keepers or call the cutout to get them to stir up the crowd.
Pause
We know he was communicating with extremists in a language that he often deployed and we know that they responded.
Pause
And as Representative Cheney said in the seventh hearing, he's a 76-year-old man responsible for his actions.
Pause
He is not an impressionable child.
Pause
As our investigation has shown, Donald Trump had access to more detailed and specific information showing that the election was not actually stolen than almost any other American.
Pause
So it's almost irrelevant exactly what Trump said, because we know he said to a violent mob, march up to the Capitol.
Pause
So what I do think these hearings have done is shifted our frame of reference so it is crystal clear that Trump did not want to leave office, that he wanted to block the transfer of power and that he did so after being advised over and over again by his campaign team, by his government officials, that he had no basis for doing so.
Pause
And that is an extraordinary thing.
Pause
Noel King
Let's talk about what happens next. What is the January 6th committee building toward? What are they going to do with all this information?
Pause
Andrea Bernstein
I think one thing that people ask me over and over and over again as well, is anybody going to be indicted? Is Trump going to be indicted?
Pause
And that's a real question.
Pause
And I think it's a really, really difficult question for the Justice Department at this point because, you know, we do see people like Stephen Ayers, the protester who basically said my life was ruined because I just sort of rode along to the Capitol on January 6th.
Pause
Six. And for me, I felt like I had, you know, like horse blinders on. I was I was locked in the whole time.
Pause
Biggest thing for me is take the blinders off, make sure you step back and see what's going on before it's too late.
Pause
You see people like that who have been convicted of crimes, who've, you know, many of whom have gone to prison, many of whom are in jail awaiting their trials for their violent crimes, some 800 people's lives have been affected, but not yet President Trump or any of his top advisors.
Pause
Now, you know, that yet, I realize, is a sort of pregnant word. They may never indict President Trump. We just don't know.
Pause
But I think that one of the things that these hearings have done is made it very difficult for the Justice Department to explain why all these other people are paying, but not the top officials.
Pause
And I think that was one of the goals of the committee.
Pause
They have no law enforcement power. They cannot indict people.
Pause
The question of will this be referred to the Justice Department is sort of a misdirection because the Justice Department can investigate anybody it wants at any time.
Pause
What might the Justice Department do? Why does it seem like they've been so quiet?
Pause
So, I mean, I do think that, you know, the Justice Department, you know, to be fair, has to do its investigations in quiet.
Pause
Otherwise, they would appear to be tainted and, you know, they might tip off witnesses into what they were looking for and they could change their story.
Pause
They could hide documents.
Pause
But there are alarming things that have emerged.
Pause
For example, there was a story in The New York Times that they were taken by surprise by Cassidy Hutchinson's testimony.
Pause
Well, why was that? They're the Justice Department.
Pause
I mean, we've seen the Congressional Committee go all the way to the Supreme Court to fight to get documents.
Pause
But the Justice Department, you know, they can stage early morning raids.
Pause
Now, they've done some. For example, they've searched the records of Jeffrey Clark, who was the former Justice Department official who was willing to go along with Trump and try to get state legislators to not participate in the certification of the election.
Pause
There was John Eastman.
Pause
So John Eastman revealed six FBI agents approached him in New Mexico last Wednesday when he was leaving a restaurant with his wife and a friend.
Pause
They patted him down. They found an iPhone, his iPhone, on him.
Pause
They were able to obtain access to it through biometrics, his facial recognition.
Pause
And then they were able to obtain his email communications that were on that phone.
Pause
There is certainly an effort to look at this question of false electors.
Pause
Representative Benny Thompson said in a press availability with reporters after the seventh hearing that the Justice Department had been talking to them about this fake elector scheme.
Pause
But he said only that.
Pause
So it's unclear if they're going to be looking at, you know, some of these other things like incitement.
Pause
A lot of defendants, January 6th defendants, have been convicted of disrupting an official proceeding or conspiring to disrupt an official proceeding.
Pause
So, you know, that is a sort of easier charge to make out than seditious conspiracy or something else.
Pause
I mean, I think what they're wrestling with, and I don't disagree with them, is that in a democracy, there is a danger if somebody takes office and then indicts their political opponent.
Pause
That is exactly the kind of system that the U.S. prior to 2016 went around the world trying to stop because it does undermine confidence in the rule of law.
Pause
On the other side, when you have this extraordinary, unprecedented situation, when you know that a former president tried to use his government, tried to use his bully puppet to overturn the peaceful transfer of power, And when none of that work said to a mob he knew was highly armed, go to the Capitol and fight like hell, it becomes hard to say that is not something that we should do something about.
Pause
And that is what I think one of the reasons behind these committee hearings is to lay out that whole story so that it becomes clear this is not about political retribution.
Pause
This is about upholding the rule of law.
Pause
Noel King
Today's show was produced by Hari Mawagdi.
Pause
It was edited by Matthew Collette.
Pause
It was fact-checked by Laura Bullard and engineered by Paul Mouncey.
Pause
I'm Noel King. It's Today Explained. Thank you.