Main Topic: The cultural significance of J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Lord of the Rings" in the context of 9/11 and its continued relevance today.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Noel King
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Noel King.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a movie theater
24 years ago, a nation on edge after the attacks of September 11th went to the movies. One does not simply walk into Mordor. To watch The Fellowship of the Ring. Americans saw themselves in J.R.R. Tolkien's tale of good and evil and hobbits.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I don't think he knows about second breakfast, babe. What about the leavensies? Luncheon? Afternoon tea? Dinner? Supper? He knows about them, doesn't he? And why not? A fellowship of good guys and good elves and good dwarves trying to restore peace to the world by destroying the one ring.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a movie trailer
Americans love and love to be the good guys. Then in the great political upheaval of the last decade or so, some people on the right claimed the mantle of the Lord of the Rings as their own. But did they misunderstand the message?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a news report
Coming up on Today Explained from Vox, why those books and those movies still resonate in a nation still on edge.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a commercial
Support for Today Explained comes from Adio. Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management platform that Adio says is built for the next era of companies. A powerful data structure adapts to your business model, sinks in all your contacts in minutes, and enriches your business with actionable data.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Adio says it also allows you to create those email sequences, those real-time reports, those powerful automations, which they claim can help you build what matters most, your company. You can go to adio.com slash todayexplained to get 15% off your first year.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a commercial
That's A-T-T-I-O dot com slash todayexplained. Support for this show comes from strawberry.me. Be honest. Are you happy with your job? Or are you stuck in one you've outgrown? Or never wanted in the first place?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Sure, you can probably list the reasons for staying, but are they actually just excuses for not leaving? Let a career coach from strawberry.me help you get unstuck. Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer. This is the Dance Plant. My name is Constance Grady, and I'm a senior correspondent on the culture team.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Constance Grady
A young hobbit embarks on a journey through a magical but dangerous world in The Lord of the Rings, one of six holiday movies we'll review this week.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
My God, Middle Earth does exist, eh? It's not just a story for kids. It's a story for everyone. So The Lord of the Rings comes out after September 11th. It comes out on December 10th.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
What makes this story so special? By appealing to generation after generation after generation, often for different reasons. So it reaches this audience that's really, really primed to interpret almost everything through the lens of 9-11.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Talking, representing the counterculture, will be quite different from maybe the audience at the moment. particularly in America, at war.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Here's a movie about a grand, sweeping, epic battle between good and evil. Middle Earth stands upon the brink of destruction. None can escape it. You will unite or you will fall.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
That fits really nicely into the narrative that the Bush administration especially had begun building for the country about how we were going to respond to 9-11. We will rid the world of the evildoers. We will call together freedom-loving people to fight terrorism.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Nearly every review makes a mention of 9-11. They say, oh, this is the moment for this kind of epic good and evil battle movie.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
With the world newly obsessed with the clash of good and evil, the time would seem to be ideal for The Lord of the Rings. Tolkien's tale of good people who band together against the Dark Lord and his minions has never been more timely than in our troubled age.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
There was an enormous piece in the New York Times by the film critic Karen Durbin sort of nailing down what she calls the accidental echoes between the Lord of the Rings and the current geopolitical climate.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Evil or evildoers? Sauron or Saddam? And how many towers? The second book and the second film are both called The Two Towers, which had some pretty unfortunate echoes.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
In the current climate, it's impossible not to experience Peter Jackson's Two Towers as war propaganda of unnerving power.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
The movie was very expensive, right? It was like a big risk. And what was the perception at the time of how it would do?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So the savvy take about Fellowship of the Ring when it first comes out is this is probably not going to make its money back.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
These movies were incredibly expensive to film. They had to develop whole new forms of CGI for the battle sequences. We ended up with, you know, upwards of 350,000 characters. For the animation on Gollum.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Smeagol hates nasty horses. For all the kind of optical tricks that they do to make the hobbits and the dwarves small and the elves and the humans big.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I mean, we'll just have a look at the footage, but I think we're not going to notice. It's a really, really expensive movie.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And Peter Jackson, at this point in time, is not really considered that dependable of a director. He has made a couple really well-regarded indie movies. But his big budget movie, they've flopped.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And not to mention, Hollywood hasn't made a successful fantasy series at this point since the Star Wars movies in the 70s.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
The smart money kind of is saying if there's going to be a fantasy movie franchise that does really well, it's probably going to be Harry Potter.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Not me, not Hermione, you. Lord of the Rings is much older and the mythology is so complicated and kind of baroque that it doesn't seem like it's going to lend itself to movies as well.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
But then, dot, dot, dot. Yeah, then it's a huge hit. Breaks all kinds of box office records and famously is nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
This is a point in time when no genre movies are getting nominated for Best Picture. It like a real real big deal when it breaks through there.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Did 9 have anything to do with the success of the movie do you think?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
You know, in a lot of ways, The Lord of the Rings were movies. They're about these peaceful towns that are being menaced by this faceless, almost animalistic other.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I'm the Hamlet! The eye of Sauron now turns to Gondor. We see Sauron as just an eye and the orcs are kind of this mass.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
That becomes really appealing when you're trying to psych yourself up for this idea that you were a blameless, peaceful town. And this enemy just attacked you out of nowhere and they're evil and you're good.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And you are going to go and make them pay for what they've done to you. The bad guys are mostly faceless, mostly don't really talk, kind of this indistinguishable horde that you don't even have to think about whether they're worth sympathizing with, right? They're just the bad guys.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Yeah, that all makes sense. I think, okay, so let's say that the orcs are, you know, our enemies, the attackers, and the United States, we're thinking of ourselves as the hero.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
But the hobbits what about second breakfast the hobbits were like little peaceful guys in their what do they call them in their little hole the shire the shire right yeah who who in the american narrative were the hobbits that's such a good question yeah the hobbits are not necessarily the most compelling characters on screen no no they are not yeah yeah they're the main characters of the books, but when you think of the movies, you think of, you know, like Aragorn opening those two doors really dramatically and striding through, or like Legolas and Gimli having their bed about who can kill more orcs.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
It's really about the military characters. They're who are dynamic. They pop on screen. They're cinematic. And that's who we were paying most attention to at the time.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
All right, let's go back in time, because prior to 9-11, the world had fought wars, including two of them quite famously. How did the post-9-11 interpretation of these books in the war context compare to earlier interpretations?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Yeah, so earlier interpretations of The Lord of the Rings had really been focused on the idea that These are books about the cost of war. They're focused so heavily on the trauma of war and how terrible it is and how it's ruined lives when everyone comes back from the battles at the end.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
One evening, Sam came into the study and found his master looking very strange. He was very pale and his eyes seemed to see things far away. What's the matter, Mr. Frodo, said Sam. I am wounded, he answered. Wounded. It will never really heal.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So there's this strong, strong tradition of using these books as ways to talk about the horrors of war. In the 1960s, there are hippies who are protesting the war in Vietnam, holding up signs that say, like, Hobbits Against the War.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
There's a tradition of reading The Ring as a metaphor for the atomic bomb. The kind of allegory of the H-bomb. What is said somewhere in the book is that the One Ring is a power so enormous that even if a good man were to use it against a bad, it would corrupt the good man.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
No one can be trusted to really use it responsibly. The post 9-11 moment is kind of unique for being the time when people are like, actually, this story is about how war is like kind of cool and rad and like a good thing to do when you're the good guys and you're fighting the evil guys.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
How did that time, 20, 24 years ago now, how did that set up Lord of the Rings, the movies, to have a life today?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I think that 9-11 is no longer really considered part of the Lord of the Rings film legacy. I think it's been kind of memory holed in a lot of ways. And now we just kind of think of them as, you know, the craft. They're well-crafted movies. They introduce all of these cool new film techniques.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And, you know, they're a good adaptation of an epic story. But I think looking back at this moment when this narrative that The Lord of the Rings was about the war on terror was so strong and potent can really help us see how the things we're living through now shape the stories that we are experiencing today.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And whether we'll still think of them the same way 24 years later.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a commercial
Vox's Constance Grady.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a commercial
Noel King
Coming up, what the Lord of the Rings means to the right. Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
That's Chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply Timing depends on submission of payment file Fees apply at out ATMs Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U News and World Report 2023 Chime checking account required.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a commercial
Why shop at Burlington? Maybe it's the deals that are new each time you drop by. Maybe it's the brand names you'll be shocked Burlington has in store. Or maybe it's the quality of the items, the amazing selection, and the newest trends.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
If you like to save but also like to stay in style, Burlington is your answer. And the question you'll be asking yourself is, why go anywhere else? Burlington. Deals. Brands. Wow.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Welcome to Only Murders in the Building. The official podcast. Join me, Michael Ciro Creighton, as we go behind the scenes with some of the amazing actors, writers, and crew from season five.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
The audience should never stop suspecting anything. How can you not be funny crawling around on a coffin? No, that's true. Catch Only Murders in the Building official podcast now streaming wherever you get your podcasts.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And watch Only Murders in the Building streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
One ring to rule them all. One ring to find them. One ring to bring them all. And in the darkness, explain them.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I'm David French. I'm a columnist for The New York Times. And you are a self-described nerd. Yes, yes. I own that. I own that. Absolutely.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
David French
All right. So in The Lord of the Rings, which character do you most identify with? Who are you? You know, that's a really good question.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And I think it evolves over time. So when I first read it, I wanted to be Legolas. You know, the very cool elven warrior that has almost got superhuman powers.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
You know, you imagine yourself like that. And then the older I got, the more I wanted to be the Faramir character, which that is one of, we're going to go deep. It's going to get nerdy.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
The difference between Boromir, his brother, and Faramir is that both of them had the ring of power, in essence, in their grasp. And Boromir grabbed for it, this ultimate weapon, to fight evil. Why not use this ring? He would lend me the ring. Give it to me! so that you could fight strength with strength.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And then Faramir rejects it. He says, absolutely not. I would not take this thing if it lay by the highway. Not were Minas Tirith falling in ruin, and I alone could save her. So using the weapon of the Dark Lord for her good and my glory.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So using the weapon of the Dark Lord for her good and my glory. Two very different views of power and very different views on how to fight evil.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
That Boromir versus Faramir distinction is really central to sort of the Tolkien approach to power and sort of the Tolkien ethos that suffuses Lord of the Rings.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So I've over time aspired to be more like Faramir as opposed to just being wowed by the superhuman capabilities of the elven warrior Legolas.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So what you're pointing to is that there is, in these books, there is enormous depth, right? There are dynamics that are as old as humanity itself.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
You write that the Lord of the Rings today in 2025 has geopolitical implications. What do you mean by that?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Well, it's very interesting that a number of leading figures in sort of the global new right have identified the Lord of the Rings as deeply influential on them.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So when you think of the new right, I think of it as the Trump right or the post-Reagan right that has explicitly rejected those sort of more libertarian view of government in favor of a much more authoritarian view, a much more statist, top-down, dominating, authoritarian version of the role of government in American life.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Lord of the Rings shaped J.D. Vance's worldview. He even named one of his companies after an elven ring, Narya. Gandalf now wore openly on his hand the third ring, Narya the Great.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Peter Thiel is a founder of a company called Palantir, and that's a term from Lord of the Rings. Palantir is a dangerous tool, Saruman.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Vance is also an investor in Anduril Industries, another name from Lord of the Rings. Anduri, the flame of the wist forged from the shards of Narcim.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So full disclosure, unless anyone think I'm condescending about this in any way, I own a replica of the sword Anduril. It's in my house.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So it's been undeniably influential. And the point I was trying to make is it's been influential, but they've taken the wrong lessons.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Yeah, let's talk about that. What is the message and what are they getting wrong about it?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Yeah. You know, there's this sort of underdog story element of it where a lot of movements that feel as if they are counted out or that the establishment is against them or large forces are against them see themselves in kind of the hobbits or the Fellowship of the Ring and Lord of the Rings, this sort of band of brothers and sisters battling a great evil.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And so it really appeals to dissident movements and insurgent movements in that way. But then when you read deeper and deeper and you really begin to understand the underlying ethos of the work, you see that, yes, it is a tale of good versus evil.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
But it's also a tale of how corruptible good can be. Good gets corrupted when it adopts evil's tools to defeat evil, when it yields to sort of this ends justifies the means.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And so consistent in the Tolkien work is that it's unlikely people, it's unlikely events that undo great evil. It is not that you confront power with power.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And so that's the part that a lot of these guys miss is this profound rejection of power as the means of fighting evil.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
What are they missing when they miss that? What are the implications of that?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Oh, they're missing the heart, and they're missing the heart, and they're missing it in a dangerous way.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Go back to what I was talking about earlier about the Boromir versus Faramir contrast, that at a time of great need and a time of great danger, Boromir does the thing that would be natural for humans to do.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
He says to, you know, in the Council of Elrond, Give Gondor the weapon of the enemy Let us use it against him He talks and he is puzzled and stumped by this idea that you would not use this incredibly powerful weapon created by the enemy against the enemy.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
But it's this quest for power that is the most insidious element of it all in the Tolkien universe.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And so Sauron, yes, Sauron is the big bad guy. But there's a more subtle evil at work that is not personified by Sauron. the more subtle evil is that will to power.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So that even if good defeats evil, if good adopts evil's means to defeat evil, then good becomes evil. You get the feeling like a lot of the sort of the new right is a lot of Boromirs. They're the ones that are questing and seeking that will to power, seeking the ring.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
When you're in the pursuit of power, every step you take needs to generate more power. Everything you do needs to make further actions easier.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
The new right wants to seize power. It wants to dominate. And then it says that it's just a better form of domination than the other side because of dominating for virtue, for good, in their construct.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
We don't like the model of the left. We have a different model in mind, and we're going to exert both power and we're going to spend resources in remaking. Fighting itself generates tremendous information, And if you win, it generates more power.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
You really need to be really ruthless when it comes to the exercise of power. But Tolkien says the very quest to dominate is what corrupts you. Even if you have motives to try to do justice, that quest to dominate is ultimately corrupting.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
The new right is essentially a movement and a very interesting one. If we were to look throughout history, the last hundred years or so, what other movements have taken Tolkien and said, We see ourselves here.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Oh, lots, lots. The old right, you know, so like what you might consider me, you know, we use different terms now, but Reagan conservatives, like I would consider myself a Reagan conservative.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Any movement that I would say has seen itself as being sort of against all odds, embattled, minority, underdog. So, for example, environmentalists for a very long time, especially I would say in the 70s and 80s, really latched on to Tolkien.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Because when you read his works, you see this big contrast between kind of the industrialization and destruction of nature by the forces of Mordor and Isengard. The old world will burn in the fires of industry. The forests will fall.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Versus the Shire. Old towing, the finest weed in the south far. And the elves of Rivendell who care for nature and nurture it. Welcome to Rivendell, Frodo Baggins.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
You see evangelical Christians take up the banner, Catholics take up the banner. Lots of different people, especially people who see themselves as underdogs, can connect with the story.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
And that's part of the genius of it. That's part of the beauty of it. But what's even more beautiful about it is that when you really dive into it, it doesn't just teach you about good and evil and a battle between good and evil.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
It also teaches you what good should be and what good should look like. Good is compassionate. It cares for the vulnerable. It preserves and protects natural beauty. It shuns domination and the will to power.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So if you look at Tolkien, it's definitely not a pacifistic tale. I mean, Aragorn is a warrior. Legolas is a warrior. Gandalf, my goodness, very powerful wizard, you know.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So you absolutely have all of this physical courage and this martial courage that you see in Tolkien. It is in this concept of the defense of what's true, the defense of what's good, the defense of what's beautiful, and not appealing to. domination, will to power, to ultimately triumph over evil.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
So to pull back into the present day, the new right here in the United States, let's focus on them. Is the takeaway that they may love Tolkien, but Tolkien likely would not have loved them back?
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I would say that Tolkien would be frustrated and that Tolkien would urge them to read again and give it a bit of a closer read. Because this sort of, especially the way in which the will to power has manifested itself on the Trump right, often accompanied by very vulgar displays of wealth and opulence, that is not very Tolkien-esque.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
That doesn't say that there's not much of that that screams the shire. For example, you know, if you're in the New Rite and you read The Lord of the Rings as we're taking on terrible people and we see ourselves in that role, you can see why they embrace it.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
But when you dig deeper, when you dig deeper, you feel like they need to give it another read.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Noel King
David French is a columnist for The New York Times. Peter Balanon-Rosen produced today's show with help from Ariana Aspuru.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Jolie Myers edited, Patrick Boyd is our engineer, and Laura Bullard checks the facts.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Today Explained is made by Avishai Artsy, Rebecca Ibarra, Hadi Mwagdi, Miles Bryan, Danielle Hewitt, Kelly Wessinger, Denise Guerra, Devin Schwartz, Adrian Lilly, and Amina El-Sadi.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Sean Ramos' firm thinks it's AI at 19 seconds. Miranda Kennedy is our EP.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
We use music by Breakmaster Cylinder. Would you like Today Explained without ads? Try Vox.com slash members.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
Would you like more Vox podcasts? Visit podcasts.voxmedia.com. We are distributed to public radio stations by WNYC in NYC.
Sound effects: a brief clip of a conversation
I'm Noelle King. It's Today Explained. Bye for now.