Main Topic: The potential bankruptcy of Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E), one of the largest utilities in the United States, due to billions of dollars in liabilities from wildfires in California.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm Sean Rameswaram.
Sound effects: A brief pause
Today, we're talking about the power struggles facing Pacific Gas and Electric, one of the nation's largest utilities. They're on the brink of bankruptcy, facing billions in potential liabilities from wildfires. Let's start with the basics. Marisa Lagos hosts the Political Breakdown podcast at KQED in San Francisco.
Marisa Lagos
Thanks for having me on the show.
Sean Rameswaram
So, Pacific Gas and Electric, they're a big publicly traded company that's been giving gas and electric power to people in California for 150 years. And this is actually the second time in less than 20 years that this company is filing for Chapter 11 protection.
Marisa Lagos
That's right. It's not bankruptcy, per se, but rather Chapter 11 protection. They're asking a court to come in and be in charge of reorganizing and restructuring the company, deciding who's first in line, who's last in line, and who pays when their bills don't pencil out.
Sean Rameswaram
And why exactly is it doing this? It feels like sort of a last resort.
Marisa Lagos
They're doing this because they're facing really unprecedented potential liabilities because of the wildfires that have hit California over the past two years. To back up just one second, they are a regulated company, so they are guaranteed a rate of return by the state. They make a 10.5% profit no matter what.
Sean Rameswaram
That's right. Historically, utilities have been like really good places to park your money, right? If you're a shareholder, you're guaranteed 10.5%, and everyone needs power and gas, and so they're usually pretty reliable companies to invest in and to be customers for.
Marisa Lagos
But basically in 2017, after years of drought in California, a series of wildfires broke out, mainly in sort of the Napa region, so wine region, and devastated a bunch of communities up there. There are now reports that downed power lines and exploding transformers are being investigated as one possible cause here for at least some of these fires.
Sean Rameswaram
That's right, David. PG&E, that's the utility company here. And you can see them behind me reinstalling downed power lines.
Sound effects: A brief pause
Now, the company says in a statement that there were equipment issues at the time the fire here started caused by, quote, hurricane strength winds. But that's just one possible cause for the 22 fires burning in California right now.
Marisa Lagos
And that alone would have been a really big hit to PG&E. It was. I mean, they spent the last year essentially warning that they could go into bankruptcy if the state didn't change some of its liability laws.
Sean Rameswaram
After a bankruptcy, PG&E will have a hard time borrowing money, and that may mean higher rates for consumers and less money for green energy projects.
Marisa Lagos
PG&E is California's biggest utility. They have about 20,000 workers. And this is a company that's also famous for a neighborhood exploding on its watch once, right?
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah, back in 2010 on a weekday evening, a neighborhood about 5 or 10 minutes south of San Francisco just went up in flames.
Marisa Lagos
Parts of San Bruno, California, were turned into a raging inferno around dinnertime Thursday evening. Flames roared some 60 feet into the air as block after block in this residential neighborhood were engulfed.
Sean Rameswaram
And at the time, you know, we all thought maybe it was a plane crash. It's really close to the airport here. I mean, it was such a big explosion.
Marisa Lagos
It was a high pressure natural gas line that ruptured, caused the explosion and then fueled the spectacular Killer blaze. It leveled a neighborhood, killed eight people.
Sean Rameswaram
I was actually on scene. I worked at the San Francisco Chronicle then. I got there, you know, within the hour, and there were people just standing there, and it was like bare feet and bathrobes, or their slippers, looking down because they had just had to evacuate so quickly.
Marisa Lagos
I live very close to the fire, too. We just ran out with what we had on. Where the hell is the fire department? We're on Claremont in San Bruno. I've been out here for 15 minutes. There's no fire department here.
Sean Rameswaram
The local utility company, Pacific Gas and Electric, says they will be accountable if it's determined they were at fault.
Marisa Lagos
And what ended up coming out through a series of federal investigations and lawsuits was that basically PG&E didn't know what was under the ground. And it also came out that they had basically redirected money that they had told state regulators they needed to charge ratepayers for, to use for safety upgrades, and handed that over in profits to shareholders.
Sean Rameswaram
And through the course of that, the discovery in those lawsuits, we also learned about this very cozy relationship PG&E had with state regulators that was really a black mark on both the state and the utility.
Marisa Lagos
And it was really sort of the beginning of a reckoning for this company and for state regulators that's lasting to this day.
Sean Rameswaram
Is there any sense of how this will shake out if PG&E successfully files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and the court grants it and goes in to assess its liabilities? Will wildfire victims not see any money?
Marisa Lagos
I don't think no money. We're talking still about a multibillion-dollar corporation. It does seem likely that not all wildfire victims will be made whole, or at least the insurance companies won't.
Sean Rameswaram
You know, we're talking about two different things here, which is people are suing them for punitive damages, which is different than filing an insurance claim and trying to get your insurance company to rebuild your house.
Marisa Lagos
But the victims we've talked to are pretty angry and I think feel like this is, if nothing else, going to delay their ability to seek justice, if not prevent it or curb it.
Sean Rameswaram
And there's not any way, you know, in the world that we're ever going to prevent every fire from happening. But I think you do have to ask for a company that has a history of redirecting its safety money into profits, that has a reputation among even some of the people inside the company of sort of valuing shareholders over safety. Don't they hold some responsibility?
Marisa Lagos
Because if that spark never lit, 86 people would still be alive and the town of Paradise would still be standing.
Sean Rameswaram
Fires are just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the climate change challenges utilities face. More in a moment on Today Explained.
Sound effects: A brief pause
Sweet potato and black bean tacos with avocado crema and cilantro. Not many tacos can boast that they're rich in vitamin A, but HelloFresh's are full of it thanks to tender roasted cubes of sweet potato.
Sound effects: A brief pause
They're joined by black beans and a zesty avocado crema for some of the most delectable veggie goodness to be found inside the fold of a tortilla.
Sound effects: A brief pause
You could say they bring their A-game in every single way. If you haven't noticed, support for the show today comes from HelloFresh. They've got pre-measured ingredients that are fresh, and they have easy-to-follow recipe cards that come straight to your door.
Sound effects: A brief pause
They do the planning, the shopping, the prepping. Take advantage of $80 off your first month by going to HelloFresh.com slash Explained80 and entering the promo code Explained80.
Sound effects: A brief pause
That is HelloFresh.com slash Explained80 and the promo code Explained80 for $80 off your first month.
Sound effects: A brief pause
Omer Irfan, you report on energy and the environment for Vox. How exactly does a utility like PG&E work? It's a private company, but it gets a bunch of money from the state, and now the state's going to step in and mediate all its debt?
Omer Irfan
Well, it is a regulated utility. It's regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission. But it's also an investor-owned utility, meaning that stockholders, people on Wall Street, own a share of the company.
Sean Rameswaram
And the company also issues bonds, which other investors can also buy in as well. So you have a lot of different groups that have different slices of the company.
Omer Irfan
The advantage of doing something like that, of course, is that you have that risk distributed among all those people rather than on just the customers.
Sean Rameswaram
So that's the big issue here with the wildfire is who ultimately has to pay. Right now, the investor-owned utility, like they're trying to protect their shareholders and they want to pass that cost off to the customer.
Omer Irfan
But the regulators want to say, no, no, no. You got to actually have your shareholders bear some of this cost. That's the whole reason we're letting you run this as a private company to begin with.
Sean Rameswaram
So it's just a matter of who's actually left holding the bag at the end of the day. And it's a very big bag, upward of $30 billion of liability.
Omer Irfan
Right. Did PG&E do anything to avoid these liabilities? Were they proactive on climate change at all?
Sean Rameswaram
I mean PG&E did have a lot of clean energy initiatives. They were deploying renewable energy and were also investing in the infrastructure to support it.
Omer Irfan
A lot of utilities around the country were doing that, namely because renewable energy is pretty cheap. California also has state renewable energy goals. So a lot of utilities throughout the state were working towards advancing that.
Sean Rameswaram
But the big issue is just in general that you have a lot of infrastructure that's exposed in these high-risk areas. So you're running power lines into these forests that are getting extremely dry.
Omer Irfan
Some of them are neglected. And so it's just kind of a disaster kind of waiting to happen. So it's not a matter of if but when you have a stiff enough breeze or you have an errant spark that triggers a massive fire like this.
Sean Rameswaram
And what happens to PG&E even if their debt is restructured and California and the courts help them figure out what their payouts are, what they owe to people? These fires aren't going anywhere and PG&E needs to stand back up and provide energy, right?
Omer Irfan
Right. That's the balancing act that both the utility and the utility regulators have to maintain. I mean the regulator, they want to make sure that you provide power that is both affordable and reliable.
Sean Rameswaram
And then taking a backseat to that is making sure that it's environmentally responsible. If you don't meet the first two criteria, you really can't worry too much about the other one.
Omer Irfan
And that's difficult when you are facing higher risks. I mean there's an upper limit to how much you can bill a customer for protecting them against future disasters.
Sean Rameswaram
And in essence, you're essentially turning these utility companies into insurance companies because now they have to bear these catastrophic costs into their rate bases as well alongside building new power plants and new power lines.
Omer Irfan
So it's a difficult situation and I talked to a former utility official and he said to me that essentially utility execs haven't really been thinking about this for a long time.
Sean Rameswaram
Like a lot of them are caught flat-footed on this issue and now they have to come up with a way because otherwise they will be liable in ways that they don't want to be.
Omer Irfan
And when we think about the sort of intersection of utility companies and climate change, is wildfires in places like California or even like Oregon, Washington State, is that the biggest concern or are there other things we should be thinking about too?
Sean Rameswaram
There are a lot of other things to be thinking about. One thing to remember is that the utility sector, the energy sector, uses a lot of water.
Omer Irfan
You need to use water to generate the steam to run the turbines and you use a lot of water to cool power plants.
Sean Rameswaram
The Union of Concerned Scientists put it this way, that essentially if you imagine the Niagara Falls at its peak flow rate and triple that, that's how much water per minute the utility sector in the United States uses.
Omer Irfan
Just the United States. Just the United States. Not even thinking about the world. No.
Sean Rameswaram
And it's an immense amount of water. So imagine what happens when your region gets really dry, if you're in a water-stressed region and you can't take in water.
Omer Irfan
Or if that water gets too hot to be used for cooling, that's an issue as well. Or there are also issues with discharging water, that after you use it to cool your power plant, that effluent water is going to be a lot hotter.
Sean Rameswaram
There are limits to how much of that water you can actually dump back into a river. And so there are all these regulations that govern that.
Omer Irfan
And as the climate changes, we're seeing those stresses get worse and worse. In other countries, we've actually seen them shut down nuclear power plants because it got too hot to use the water.
Sean Rameswaram
So there are other kinds of environmental stresses these utilities face. Okay so we got fires we got water shortages I guess we even didn't touch on hurricanes and flooding.
Omer Irfan
With more and more extreme weather on the way what like the worst case scenario for these like for-profit utilities? Government takeover?
Sean Rameswaram
One official told me that bankruptcy judges have godlike powers. So there's a lot that you can do in terms of restructuring the utility.
Omer Irfan
Some California legislators suggested, you know, making this a public utility rather than an investor-owned utility.
Sean Rameswaram
Yeah. The advantage of that, of course, is that you have an incentive for the utility to be much more transparent and upfront.
Omer Irfan
They serve the public interest rather than shareholders. And so when – if you're weighing the costs of doing things like trimming power lines or burying something to make it less vulnerable to sparking a fire, they err on the side of consumer protection rather than on the side of cutting costs.
Sean Rameswaram
The disadvantage of that is that you end up making your customers your shareholders as well. So if you do have a major fire that gets blamed on the utility and they have to pay for it, well, it falls directly back to the customers and there's no investor or bondholder to help share that burden.
Omer Irfan
I mean it's hard to feel bad for the people who send you a bill every month that you don't really want to pay. Right.
Sean Rameswaram
Is the future sort of grim for these companies that are now facing providing energy in the shadow of wildfires and hurricanes and floods and whatever else?
Omer Irfan
The big issue, the reason why that they're facing these problems is that they didn't give it much thought. Now they can't afford not to think about this.
Sean Rameswaram
Climate change is something that has to be integral to their planning over the long term and in the near term as well.
Omer Irfan
I mean ultimately we do need power. I mean I really do count on keeping my lights on and staying warm in the wintertime. But you need to be able to deliver it in a way that doesn't cause more harm than good.
Sean Rameswaram
And that's really the difficult question here. I mean, when I was up in Paradise, California, after the campfire went through there, I mean, one of the things that struck me was that you saw these power lines running right between trees, right? Like really close.
Omer Irfan
Like I was looking at that and I was just like a stiff breeze would knock the power line into a tree. I mean, it's almost an impossible situation.
Sean Rameswaram
I mean, you could trim the trees. You could, you know, try to bury the power lines. But it's a matter of when, not necessarily if, when you see a disaster that would strike.
Omer Irfan
So the question is then you also have to start thinking more broadly about where are people living? Are they living in these high-risk zones? Is the cost of providing them power and the risk of providing them power into these densely forested areas even worthwhile at that point if we're facing the risk of sparking a fire?
Sean Rameswaram
So those are all the different questions you have to weigh. Similarly, in Puerto Rico, we saw 80% of the island's utility poles knocked down after Hurricane Maria.
Omer Irfan
Do you want to even bother to rebuild those utility poles at that point when you know that they're that vulnerable to a storm?
Sean Rameswaram
It's a question that you really have to think about with a big picture mindset. And a lot of people aren't really willing to do that.
Omer Irfan
The big push is to rebuild exactly the way things were, both in Puerto Rico and in California. People want to get back to their homes as soon as possible.
Sean Rameswaram
And that does not reduce the risk. That puts you back in the same situation you started with.
Omer Irfan
Have there been utilities that have done a better job of taking climate change into consideration?
Sean Rameswaram
Well, one big example of that might be Xcel Energy. It's a company headquartered in Minnesota, in Minneapolis, and they have operations in eight states serving 3.6 million customers.
Omer Irfan
At the beginning of 2018, they announced that they wanted to cut their greenhouse gas emissions 60% below 2005 levels by 2030. But then by the end of the year, they up that target to 80% by 2030 and then they want to get to 100% clean energy by 2050.
Sean Rameswaram
They are one of the few utilities in the country that have set a target that aggressive on fighting climate change.
Omer Irfan
And a big reason why is because the cost of renewable energy and clean energy has declined so precipitously. But it's also because their customers are demanding it. It's not just households. It's big businesses. A lot of big companies have their own greenhouse gas targets and they want to buy clean energy.
Sean Rameswaram
And cities, even entire cities want to buy clean energy. And so they're pushing the utilities to deliver and build more power generation assets that are clean that produces zero emissions.
Omer Irfan
And in a way, that company is also insulating themselves from the future costs of climate change because they're saying that they are acting to help mitigate climate change.
Sean Rameswaram
Excel is also an investor-owned utility, and so they also have to answer to shareholders. And so that's kind of their pitch to them, that we're planning for the future, building the generation portfolio of tomorrow in a world where temperatures are going to be rising, where the traditional coal and gas-fired power plants aren't going to be as reliable, and we need other alternatives.
Omer Irfan
Umair Irfan covers the environment for Vox.
Sean Rameswaram
I'm Sean Ramos from This Is Today Explained. Thanks to HelloFresh for supporting the show today. They've got pre-measured ingredients that are fresh, and they have easy-to-follow recipe cards that come straight to your door.
They do the planning, the shopping, the prepping. Take advantage of $80 off your first month by going to HelloFresh.com slash Explained80 and entering the promo code Explained80.
That is HelloFresh.com slash Explained80 and the promo code Explained80 for $80 off your first month.