Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses Merriam-Webster's word of the year, "gaslighting," and its relevance in today's culture. The hosts explore the concept of gaslighting, its origins, and its increasing usage in various contexts, including politics and social media.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Music plays
Sean Rameswaram
Welcome to Today Explained. I'm your host, Sean Rameswaram.
Music fades out
Merriam-Webster's word of the year is gaslighting. Psychological manipulation of a person usually over an extended period of time that causes the victim to question the validity of their own thoughts. It's a bit of an odd choice because it feels like gaslighting might have been a better word of the year in like 2016, 2017.
Pause
One thing I can promise you this. I will always tell you the truth. We called up Merriam-Webster to ask if they're gaslighting us.
Pause
I used to write a monthly report back around 2002, 2003, about which words were looked up the most every month in our online dictionary. So I've been aware of our data, if you will, kind of been working closely with it for more than 20 years.
Pause
A conversation with the dictionary, ahead on Today Explained.
Music plays
Support for Today Explained comes from BetterHelp.
Music fades out
Let me tell you a true story. Last weekend, I got an email from a listener who wanted to discuss their problems with me. And I said, look, I don't think that this is about me personally. At least I hope it's not. Why don't you try BetterHelp.com slash Explained?
Pause
Absolute truth. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Find the one with BetterHelp.
Pause
The one is not me, guys. Our listeners get 10% off their first month at BetterHelp.com slash explain. That's BetterHelp.com slash explain.
Pause
Support for this show comes from Macy's.
Music plays
Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts.
Music fades out
Yo, it's Malachi Lee. I play 11 instruments, and you're listening to Today Explained.
Music plays
Another day, another today explained. But this episode is different because today we're talking to Merriam Webster, or at least Merriam Webster's editor at large, Peter Sokolowski.
Music fades out
Peter Sokolowski
We called him to ask why his dictionary ended up choosing gaslighting as its word of the year.
Sean Rameswaram
It's a statistical measure of what sent people to the dictionary in the past 12 months, because the dictionary does reveal a huge amount about the culture by the sort of spikes that happen on any given day that a certain word in the news or maybe in entertainment, the title of a movie, or the utterance of a newsmaker, or something like the death of Queen Elizabeth, for example, will send people to the dictionary to check words, to check definitions, maybe to check spellings.
Pause
And so we can measure that and then compare the current year with the past years. And doing that, we find which word was looked up this current year that was not looked up in the past. And that gives us a good measure of what sent people to the dictionary. And that's our word of the year.
Pause
Peter Sokolowski
And is that how you landed on gaslighting this year? Absolutely. Yes, indeed. I mean, to be honest, it surprised me as much as anyone, because I do look at this data on a daily basis.
Pause
And we do see the big spikes. For example, the term queen consort was a big spike when Queen Elizabeth II died.
Pause
Once known as the other woman, Camilla is now the queen, kind of. The new king's darling wife has become the queen consort.
Pause
That term, that official term, queen consort, was suddenly really specific and newsy, and so people looked it up.
Pause
A consort supports his or her spouse, the monarch. That normally means going on official trips, appearing in public on behalf of the royal family, and supporting charities.
Pause
In other words, that was a spike in our lookups that we could attach to a very specific story and a date in the news.
Pause
However, with gaslighting, it was a little different. It was a word that kind of rose with the tide and stayed very high.
Pause
It was in our top 20 to 50 lookups on a daily basis. And the raw tonnage of those numbers resulted in its clear victory as word of the year this year.
Pause
In other words, it wasn't attached to any single story. It was the single word that many people looked up.
Pause
Tell us what those people found when they looked up the definition of gaslighting. What is it?
Pause
We have two definitions for gaslighting. I will begin with the older one because it reflects the origin of the term directly.
Pause
Gaslighting, the psychological manipulation of a person, usually over an extended period of time, that causes the victim to question the validity of their own thoughts or perception of reality.
Pause
And that has to do with the characters in the film and the play that preceded it called Gaslight.
Pause
In which, you know, one of the principal characters, the sort of evil husband, attempts to make his wife believe that she's going insane.
Pause
Gregory, are you trying to tell me I'm insane? It's what I'm trying not to tell myself. But that's what you think, isn't it?
Pause
And his mysterious activities in the attic of their home sometimes cause the gas lights of the house to dim, and then he insists to her that the lights are not dimming and that she can't believe what she sees with her own eyes.
Pause
You said I was going out of my mind! You're not going out of your mind. You're slowly and systematically being driven out of your mind.
Pause
But why? Why? Perhaps because you found this letter no too much. Or because then he would have control of your property, of this house.
Pause
And so that resulted in what psychologists call gaslighting.
Pause
Often that's an interpersonal kind of gaslighting when you're being sort of tricked by a partner or a family member or a colleague or a boss.
Pause
But that sense has broadened into, I think, the sense that we encounter more frequently or even most frequently today, which is simply the act or practice of grossly misleading someone, especially for one's own advantage.
Pause
And that kind of just means strategic lying, right?
Pause
And that's the sense that we see in headlines, often in political contexts.
Pause
He continues to gaslight the American people by acting like this pandemic is not a real threat.
Pause
This is one of those words that started with a kind of narrow specific definition and has broadened to a more general definition that being adapted and adopted by many people and many journalists
Pause
This is a favorite word for headlines
Pause
To what can we attribute the resurgence of this word that comes from a movie that no one's seen?
Pause
That's right. You know, I don't know if it was a big hit, but it's a famous movie.
Pause
It starred among other people, Angela Lansbury. My name's Nancy, sir.
Pause
Who just died this year.
Pause
And we did actually see a little bump in lookups for gaslighting after her death because the movie was mentioned in all of the obituaries.
Pause
And that sort of connects us to our own time in a certain kind of way.
Pause
In its narrow psychological sense, this term has been around since mid-century, since the 50s and 60s.
Pause
But we see a big jump in 2017 and then another jump every single year since.
Pause
This is a word that has really, yeah, this is a word that has really jumped into the public domain.
Pause
If we can trace it to any single thing, we can trace it to the Teen Vogue article from December 2016, and the headline of that article is, Donald Trump is Gaslighting America.
Pause
Of course, this isn't the biggest electoral college victory in history. It takes a simple Google search to figure that out, but it's almost like these sort of distractions to divert our attention.
Pause
This was a truly political use, obviously, of this term, but it also sent many people to the dictionary.
Pause
I think it was probably the first time many people encountered this term using this psychological terminology on a kind of macro scale.
Pause
And of course, this is before Donald Trump took office. This is after the election, but before the inauguration.
Pause
And as you might know, that article went viral and it began this sort of pattern of journalists' use of this term.
Pause
The president of the United States is gaslighting you, and you deserve to know.
Pause
If you look up this word in kind of news outlets, you see that this word is used increasingly in places like the New York Times and news websites.
Pause
And I think a lot of people who read Teen Vogue or spend a lot of time online might have thought, you know, gaslighting would have been a better word of the year in 2017.
Pause
How did it become your word of the year five years later?
Pause
First of all, the dictionary acts as a kind of lag indicator of the culture, you know, to use economic terms.
Pause
We don't recommend words. We don't propose words. We don't coin words. We report on the words that are being used by many writers and journalists in many publications.
Pause
And in this case, this is a word that has had this momentum in the past few years.
Pause
And also in the past few years, I think this is a reflection of a broader cultural fact.
Pause
And that is simply that the technology that informs us also deceives us.
Pause
We live in an age of doubt. The whole notion of what people call the big lie, that we can't trust our elections, and a broader cultural conversation about the validity of elections.
Pause
And so the culture has absorbed this doubt that we all have to sort of view with skepticism, whether it's, for example, a hacking problem of your own bank account or email or trolling online.
Pause
In other words, we have become accustomed to the real threats to our identities and to our information.
Pause
And a lot of that has to do with disinformation or misinformation or deceitfulness.
Pause
We have lots of synonyms in English for lying, don't we?
Pause
And this is a new synonym that brings a new idea, which is that strategy, you know, that gaslighting is very deliberate, that it has a very specific goal.
Pause
And I think that goal is almost always understood to be a nefarious goal, you know, that really brings advantage to the teller of the lie.
Pause
These things have to do with whether or not we trust our information.
Pause
And gaslighting has everything to do with trust.
Pause
Do you feel like when you made Gaslighting the Word of the Year that you were going to maybe divide some people or lose some people who look at Merriam-Webster as a neutral player in our wars, in our various divisions?
Pause
Well, you bring up an important point, which is that the dictionary should serve as a neutral and objective arbiter of facts about language.
Pause
And that is our mission. That is our goal.
Pause
I think the dictionary has always represented that, but never more than in an age of information.
Pause
But here's the thing. It's also this word originated in interpersonal communication.
Pause
And this is a word that is used every bit as much on the right as it is on the left.
Pause
The Biden administration is gaslighting America, not only with their ill-conceived agenda, but they are trying to make us believe that what we actually see and are experiencing is not happening at all.
Pause
Take, for example, the border.
Pause
So in many ways, this is a term that is very broad in its application.
Pause
It's kind of universal in its appeal.
Pause
It seems like everybody's got a story about this kind of deception.
Pause
But the fact is the dictionary can't be afraid of reporting the truth about language.
Pause
And if that truth reveals something about our culture and our politics, which it often does, then I think it's up to all of us to interpret that in our own way.
Pause
I mean, the dictionary is in some ways static, and the dynamic part is our interpretation of these facts.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Quick break, and then we'll find out how we were gaslit in 2022, and how social media platforms fared in the fight against disinformation.
Music plays
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime.
Music fades out
Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime.
Pause
And Chime gets that, says Chime.
Pause
Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts.
Pause
So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Pause
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft, up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals.
Pause
Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Pause
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today.
Pause
You can open an account in two minutes at Chime.com slash explained.
Pause
That's Chime.com slash explained.
Pause
Chime feels like progress Chime is a financial technology company not a bank Banking services and debit card provided by the Bank or Bank N or Stride Bank N Members FDIC Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply Timing depends on submission of payment file Fees apply at out ATMs Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Chime checking account required.
Music plays
Why shop at Burlington? Maybe it's the deals that are new each time you drop by. Maybe it's the brand names you'll be shocked Burlington has in store. Or maybe it's the quality of the items, the amazing selection, and the newest trends.
Music fades out
If you like to save but also like to stay in style, Burlington is your answer.
Pause
And the question you'll be asking yourself is, why go anywhere else? Burlington. Deals. Brands. Wow.
Music plays
My name's Nancy, sir. Today Explained is back.
Music fades out
You've heard how gaslighting was chosen as word of the year. But now you're going to hear how we were gaslit in 2022.
Pause
Samantha Bradshaw teaches about new technology and security at American University, and she says when she saw Merriam-Webster's choice, she somehow did not think of the 1944 film Gaslight starring Angela Lansbury.
Pause
Samantha Bradshaw
Instead, the choice evoked all the horrors of social media.
Pause
Over the past year in 2022, we've seen a series of high-profile events that have attracted disinformation campaigns alongside them.
Pause
So Russia's ground invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 was accompanied by large volumes of disinformation on social media.
Pause
And also during the U.S. 2022 midterms, we saw disinformation being spread to undermine trust in the elections process and to polarize American citizens.
Pause
And I think, I guess, we expect disinformation in a war with Russia.
Pause
But tell people what happened during the 2022 midterms, because a lot of people might have had a pretty unremarkable experience.
Pause
Midterm elections aren't as high profile as general elections.
Pause
I have been every four years, but they're still really important.
Pause
And this is where we start to see some disinformation narratives that either kind of continue on larger discussions that have been happening around the general elections or where we start to see actors test and experiment with new narratives.
Pause
One interesting thing that happened during the 2022 midterms was the way that claims around ballot harvesting or this idea that ballot boxes are being filled with large numbers of illegally gained ballots motivated these watch parties.
Pause
A small group of people is gathering, watching and recording as voters return early ballots at this drop box and election workers enter and exit.
Pause
These watch parties were essentially groups of people who would go out and monitor ballot drop boxes around the country for this illegal activity.
Pause
And I think what was really interesting about these narratives was not only how the false and unsubstantiated claims around ballot harvesting fueled this real world action, but also how a small number of really influential accounts on social media participated in this very participatory process with their audiences where an influencer would share a message or a story and the audience would pick that up, share it. retweet it, and organize various kind of support groups on the ground.
Pause
Money is everything. Money is the key in this world.
Pause
This undercover video purports to show a man engaging in the illegal practice of ballot harvesting, paying voters for blank mail-in ballots, filling them out, and mailing them en masse.
Pause
Numbers don't lie. Numbers don't lie.
Pause
There were concerns that having groups of people monitor ballot boxes would lead to voter intimidation and that people wouldn't actually want to go up and drop off their ballots because there was a large group of people who were gathering around them to make sure that people weren't filling them with illegal ballots.
Pause
But we didn't see any actual harm caused by this, nor were any cases of ballot harvesting actually identified by these groups.
Pause
Sad for them.
Pause
In these cases of the Russia-Ukraine war or even the 2022 U.S. midterms, who are the chief propagators of disinformation? Is it regular people? Is it state actors? Do we even know in the case of Russia?
Pause
Different actors have different motivations for spreading disinformation online.
Pause
When it comes to the war in Ukraine, we see state actors investing significantly in different kinds of tools to influence audiences for their own geopolitical ends.
Pause
And, you know, we often I think it's really important here to also make a distinction between overt and covert influence operations, because here we can think about the way that state actors use the entire media ecosystem when they're pursuing foreign influence operations.
Pause
So, you know, state-backed media through broadcasters, in the case of Russia, RT, they can have significant reach not only through television and broadcast, but also on social media where they tend to generate large audiences.
Pause
And this is even despite the fact that there have been several sanctions placed on RT as a broadcaster.
Pause
We look at its reach around the world. It operates in multiple languages and platform companies haven't been as successful at demoting or reducing the spread of non-English state-backed media coverage about the war in other kinds of countries.
Pause
And this is really interesting, too, because if you look at the covert operations of Russia and the way that they create fake accounts and bots to automate the spread of mis- and disinformation to amplify these narratives, they don't often generate as much engagement as they used to.
Pause
We haven really seen recent disinformation campaigns that are using these kind of covert strategies of creating fake accounts generate the same kind of reach
Pause
And is that because social media companies are getting better at dealing with this after let say the 2016 election and the 2020 election and the January 6th uprising
Pause
Yeah, I think social media companies have really stepped up their game when it comes to identifying what they call coordinated inauthentic behavior, the fake accounts and the bots and the foreign influencers who are trying to game social media systems to amplify the reach of their disinformation narratives and their disinformation campaigns.
Pause
What I think we're still struggling with has more to do with coordinated authentic behavior.
Pause
And this is also kind of how we're seeing misinformation change because it's not so much about having fake accounts or bots automate the spread of this harmful content.
Pause
It's more about real people who are pushing these narratives through their own personal social media account.
Pause
But platforms don't have a good way of taking down content that come from authentic users.
Pause
There's an elephant in this gaslighting room, and it's in the shape of a bird, I think.
Pause
And so Twitter's going through this crisis over some of the very issues we're talking about right now.
Pause
Is that just going to be an issue for Twitter to resolve? Or do you think it has broader implications for other social media platforms?
Pause
I think with what's going on right now at Twitter, for me as an academic who uses a lot of social media data to analyze disinformation networks and their effect on democracy more broadly, one of the biggest worries is that we're going to lose access to a lot of the data and tools that make studying this phenomenon possible.
Pause
Because right now we don't have very good insight into the way that social media actually changes people's opinions and behaviors.
Pause
We're only just starting to catch up with digital technologies.
Pause
Academic research can be slow.
Pause
Like a lot of, you know, lawmaking and policy, it takes time to develop studies, to test our hypothesis, to make sure things are robust.
Pause
And one of the big concerns with the Twitter takeover is that we're losing access to such a great resource for measuring and understanding some of the relationships between social media and democracy more broadly.
Pause
And so, you know, going forward, I think this also has broader implications because we're seeing how platforms are changing and how people are moving to platforms that are much more closed, that are much harder to access, encrypted applications, smaller fringe alternative platforms like Gab, Parler, True Social, Telegram to an extent.
Pause
I mean, it makes it much harder to understand how the different affordances of these platforms are changing not only how mis- and disinformation spreads, but the effect that it is having on everyday people and how they're eventually going to formulate their political opinions or how they're going to go out and vote or whether or not they're going to show up at an event like January 6th.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
It sounds almost like you're saying that having everyone in the same place accusing each other of gaslighting is better than having everyone in, you know, 50 different social media platforms where no one feels like they're being gaslit.
Pause
Samantha Bradshaw
That is kind of what I'm saying.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
That was Dr. Samantha Bradshaw, professor in New Technology and Security at American University in Washington, D.C.
Pause
Early in the show, you heard from Merriam-Webster's editor-at-large, Peter Sokolowski.
Pause
Peter's got a podcast. It's called Word of the Day. He's done like 6,000 episodes.
Pause
Nothing but respect, Peter.
Pause
This episode of Today Explained was produced by Haleema Shah.
Pause
We were edited by Matt Collette, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, engineered by Efim Shapiro, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram.
Pause
The rest of the team includes Abishai Artsy, Hadi Mawadi, Amanda Llewellyn, Miles Bryan, Victoria Chamberlain, Siona Petros, Paul Robert Mounsey, and our supervising producer, Amina Alsadi.
Pause
We had extra help this week from Jolie Myers.
Pause
We use music by Breakmaster Cylinder and Noam Hassenfeld.
Pause
I'm Sean Rameswaram. My co-host is...
Music plays
Today Explained is on radio stations across America in partnership with WNYC.
Music fades out
We are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Music plays
Noel, Noel, Noel, Noel, Noel, sing with me, open our own rock on air, born is God's Son so dear. And to Bethlehem town, and shepherds go, and in a sorry place, Thank you.
Music fades out