Main Topic: The conflict between TikTok and Universal Music Group (UMG), the largest record label in the world, over music licensing fees.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
It's been a big week for Taylor Swift and Drake, but they weren't playing on one of their biggest platforms. Not a single one of their songs was on TikTok. Instead, we've got stuff like this. And this. It's like in my mirror, whoa, my mirror's staring back at me, sing it! You're gonna make anything up. And good heavens, this. Come back, baby, please, cause we belong together. Who am I gonna lean on?
On Today Explained, we're looking into why the biggest record label in the world is picking a fight with the app that's constantly promoting their artists, and why we're all caught in the middle. Baby, we belong together.
Support for the show comes from ServiceNow
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at ServiceNow.com.
Support for the show comes from Macy's
Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and, of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves. Curated by their experts. From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look. Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
You're listening to Today Explained. Nilay Patel, editor-in-chief of The Verge, you're on TikTok, right?
Nilay Patel
I'm on TikTok. As a viewer, I have a burner that no one knows about, but then I am on TikTok on The Verge channels all the time.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
As a person with potentially multiple TikTok accounts, can you tell me how important music is to the platform?
Nilay Patel
TikTok is built on music. It came to this country as part of an acquisition. So ByteDance, which owns TikTok, bought a platform called Musical.ly, which was teenagers dancing to music. I'm going to show you how to get it. It go right foot up, left foot slide. And it has built itself on the back of people using music, making music for the platform, creating dance trends, recontextualizing music, bringing back old music.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
But some days ago, things got kind of quiet on TikTok. What happened?
Nilay Patel
So Universal Music, which is the largest record label in the world, one of the most powerful record labels in the world, it represents Taylor Swift and Drake and Bad Bunny, you name it, pulled their music off of TikTok and said TikTok is trying to bully us. They want to pay under the market rate for licensing our catalog. We're not going to accept the low rates. Our music is gone until TikTok can pay us like the major social network they are.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
I care more deeply about real music and real opportunity and real artists than I do algorithms pushing inexpensive things or fake products or fintech. I don't like people cheating. And like these musicians you quote, you know, Bad Bunny, Drake, Taylor Swift, three of the biggest musicians in the world. Are they OK with this? They're good with all their music being ripped off TikTok?
Nilay Patel
I think the big artists are totally OK with this. They all want more money. They know they're the lifeblood of the platform. They know the fans are going to seek them out regardless. It's the up and coming artists who get discovered on TikTok, who become popular on TikTok that are probably the most worried.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And that is an interesting split is this conflict stretches out that has yet to come into the public consciousness. We haven't seen any evidence of that split being real. But over time, if this stretches on, I think that's the split we're going to see.
Who loses more here, Nilay, in the spat? Is it musicians? Is it labels? Or is it TikTok?
Nilay Patel
Far and away, the loser right now is TikTok. You have an entire base of TikTok creators who don't have access to the thing they care about the most, which is music.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
If you look at the bottom of every TikTok video, there's an audio file, right? It tells you what audio is being used. Oftentimes it's songs, most of the times even, maybe it's songs. Those songs, if you click on them, you can see all the other videos that use that audio. That is how TikTok is organized. It is the first order bit of organization on TikTok. And it's gone. It's silent.
Nilay Patel
There are creators complaining that their entire archives of content are just muted because the music isn't there anymore. They took my sound origin videos down. They took my sample videos down. Yeah, I mean, my career is over for sure. I'm never going to have a hit song ever again at this rate.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
You know, so my songs aren't going to be on there anymore. I won't be able to promote my music on TikTok anymore. And, you know, I'll probably be okay, right? I'll land on my feet, right? UMG, just please put Taylor Swift back on the platform.
Nilay Patel
And if you cannot provide that value to your creators as a platform, suddenly they might start thinking that other platforms like Instagram reels or YouTube shorts can provide that audio, can provide that audience, and they might spend time over there.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
That hasn't happened yet. It's not been so many days. I think everyone is assuming that this will get resolved. But one of the main things a platform provides to its creators is licensing, is music licensing, is protection from copyright craziness, is fair use, all of that stuff. Creators don't have to worry about it when they make content for a big platform. And right now in the case of TikTok, they really have to worry about it.
So how did TikTok let this happen? If you're running TikTok, you know that you are the engine of music discovery in America and possibly the world. And not just discovery of new artists. These massive music catalogs that are getting sold and resold for billions of dollars right now, they are becoming more valuable again because of TikTok.
Nilay Patel
So old music is coming back around in style, hitting the charts again because of TikTok, which is wild to consider. That is not a thing that has happened previously in the history of music. That Stevie Nicks is just a superstar again. Because a guy was skateboarding listening to Fleetwood Mac. I'm going to have to call him and thank him. Oh, you mean the TikTok guy? The TikTok guy.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Because you have to understand, I'm not on TikTok. I'm not on Instagram. I'm not on Facebook. I don't have a computer. But I have to call him and tell him, thank you so much. Because you know what you did? You brought this music back to the world all by yourself. That's TikTok. That's TikTok's power in the culture.
Nilay Patel
And I think it is on balance a good thing. TikTok creates new artists. It creates new relationships with artists. It preserves fans' relationships with older artists. It recontextualizes old music. There's a conversation happening about music and its place in culture that is new and I think fresh and interesting that is driven by TikTok.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
TikTok knows that's the value it provides the music industry. And it knows the music industry doesn't have great answers of its own on how to break new artists without social platforms, without TikTok. So I think it's saying to Universal, hey, we're providing you all this value. You can go away. You won't have the ability to break any new artists ever again.
Nilay Patel
And they have run tests in Australia. They ran a test saying, we're not going to show new artists to people just to see what happens. What were they trying to prove? Hey, no new artists are breaking in the Australian market.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
So TikTok is trying to demonstrate this leverage. And I think right now they're trying to say, look, that's the value we provide. It's not just dollars. And I think Universal is saying, yeah, but your whole platform is built on the music that our artists make. You have to pay us for it.
There's going to come a meeting of the minds. There will come a middle point. I don't think it's going to last forever. But that's TikTok's leverage, and I think they're very clear on it.
This is all about money. So let's talk about money. How much was TikTok paying to license Universal's music? And how much does Universal want now?
Nilay Patel
So we don't have hard numbers to go on. We can backtrack the numbers from a clue that Universal put out, and it's a letter saying we're leaving TikTok. Universal said TikTok is 1% of our revenue. Universal is a public company. According to Music Business Worldwide, which is a trade publication, they backtrack the numbers. That means TikTok is paying Universal about $110 million a year.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
That's not a lot of money. Bigger platforms like Meta are in the range of $200 to $300 million a year that covers Instagram and Facebook. The streaming services like Spotify and YouTube pay vastly more money. So TikTok is a drop in the bucket of Universal's revenue.
Nilay Patel
You know, it's not a lot of money. But if you're Universal and you're saying, okay, Cruel Summer by Taylor Swift hit number one again when she went on tour because kids on TikTok were playing the song and dancing the song and thinking about the song, that's worth an awful lot of money to TikTok. That is a cultural moment that TikTok got to profit off of. And we deserve a huge percentage of that money as well.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Do we know who might blink first here, TikTok or Universal? My instinct is that TikTok will blink first. And I have that instinct because I know that Universal won't. Right now, Universal CEO Lucian Grange is pushing very hard against things like generative AI on platforms.
Nilay Patel
They have pushed YouTube into a deal where YouTube is going to allow Universal to take AI-generated copies of artists like Drake off the platform, which is not really in copyright law. There's no legal precedent for doing that. But Universal has so much power over YouTube. They said, give us that power anyway. And YouTube basically caved.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
So I think Universal is riding high in its power. It's riding high in the sort of moral leverage it has with its artists and with the fans of the artists who understand that artists should get paid, that things like social platforms, like AI, are all threats to these big artists, and they're going to use that leverage for everything that it's worth.
TikTok, at the same time, is beginning to squeeze its users, right? It's not up and coming. It's not burning a bunch of money to acquire users anymore. It's saying, we got to make a bunch of money from all the users we have.
Nilay Patel
You see TikTok is pushing sponsored content all over the place. You see that TikTok shop has just appeared in the cultural consciousness because TikTok is constantly showing you TikTok shop live streams, and they put it at the top of the menu bar.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And so there's a real turn for that platform here where the ascendancy of a social platform, when it's new and interesting and free and organic, is beginning to taper into what you might call the top when it is beginning to become ruthlessly monetized.
Nilay Patel
And I think it's an appropriate reaction for the labels to say, OK, you're starting to ruthlessly monetize this platform. We deserve a big cut of that because we allowed you to build on the cheap.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Nilay Patel, he runs TheVerge.com, and if you want to hear from him more often, his podcast is called Decoder.
When we're back on Today Explained, it sure feels like every social media platform eventually just gets worse. There's a term for that. We're going to speak to the guy who coined it.
Support for the show comes from Adio
Support for today's show comes from Adio. What is Adio? Adio is an AI-native customer relationship management system built specifically for the next era of companies. They say it's extremely powerful, adapts to your unique data structures and scales with any business model.
Support for the show comes from Upwork
Support for Today Explained comes from Upwork. If you run a business, you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time. I sometimes wonder how many of you are running businesses out there. I would love to know. Please email me, noelle at king.com.
With Upwork, you can find specialized freelancers in IT, web development, AI, design, admin support, marketing, and more. Experts who they say are ready to help you take your business to the next level.
With more than two decades of experience, Upwork has a simple and ambitious goal to pioneer a better way of working. Companies at every stage turn to Upwork to get things done and find more flexibility in the way they staff key projects and initiatives by accessing a global marketplace full of top talent.
Plus, Upwork makes posting your job easy with no cost to join. You can register, browse, freelance, or profiles, get help drafting a job post, or even book a consultation. You can visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free. That is Upwork.com to post your job for free and connect with top talents ready to help your business grow.
That's U-P-W-O-R-K.com, Upwork.com.
Wake up in the morning feeling like... Today explained Ramos for him. Neelai is gone, but we got Cory Doctorow in his stead. Cory's an author, an activist, an extremely online dude, but he does not use TikTok.
Cory Doctorow
I use TikTok like a Gen Xer. I look at clips that have been uploaded to Twitter. But he gets it. Oh, I get it. No, no, no, I get it. It has a spookily good recommendation engine. And, you know, there is part of the source of all of its mischief.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Because, you know, they spy on you a lot. They acquire third party data sets. They use that data to make predictions about what you're going to want to see. And they show it to you and it's generally pretty good.
Cory Doctorow
But they also abuse that power, right? Because most of TikTok's users are using it as a kind of surprise medium, right? And so that means that you're trusting TikTok not to game the system, right? Not to use the fact that you've said, oh, anything you want to cram into my eyeballs, I'll take a look at.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
So, you know, please don't like sell people the right to cram things into my eyeballs that I'm not interested in seeing or abuse that so that you can trick people into thinking that they're more popular in the platform than they really are so that they put a lot of energy into making content for it.
Cory Doctorow
And that's where it all goes wrong, because so long as it's good enough, we will just keep allowing them to do that non-consensual cramdown of stuff we don't want to hear or see, provided that there's enough of a residue of things that seem good.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And this is why we reached out to Corey, because Corey coined the term for what's going on at TikTok right now.
Cory Doctorow
Well, I think that it's something that I've called in shittification. Colloquially, I think a lot of people just use it to mean things are getting worse. But for me, it's a very technical phrase or a technical word that describes a specific process by which digital platforms use the particular contours of how digital services work to first lure in end users by giving them a good deal and then making that deal worse for them, but better for business customers who pay to access those end users.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And then once everyone is locked in, take away all the surplus from both end users and business customers, give it all to the shareholders and leave everyone in an increasingly worse service that just gets shittier and shittier until it turns into a pile of shit.
Cory Doctorow
Okay, so I want to ask you about TikTok in a moment in greater detail, but before we do that, can you give us the greatest end-shittification story?
Yeah, Facebook's a poster child, right? This is a company that, you know, began its life as a service to non-consensually rate the fuckability of Harvard undergraduates and only got worse after that.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Billy Olson sitting here and had the idea of putting some of the pictures next to pictures of farm animals and have people vote on who's hotter. Good call, Mr. Olson.
Cory Doctorow
But in 2006, Zuckerberg said, okay, well, we're going to open up beyond college campuses. And the pitch that they made to people was, hey, I know that like you're all on MySpace and that's where your friends are. But did you know that MySpace was run by a, you know, crapulent, senescent, evil Australian billionaire named Rupert Murdoch, who spies on you with every hour that God sends.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
If you come over to Facebook, we'll never spy on you. Facebook is the non-spying on you version of MySpace. Wow. I forgot about that.
Cory Doctorow
Yeah, yeah. They made a promise. And in fact, at one point, they let the users vote on whether or not Facebook should start spying on them. And they voted against it. And Facebook did it anyway.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And they said to those users, hey, if you just tell us who matters to you on Facebook, We're just going to show you what they post in reverse chronological order. And then once those users were all locked in, they started to make things worse for them.
Cory Doctorow
They went to publishers and they said, hey, do you remember when we told these rubes, we would only show them the things that they asked to see. That was a lie. If you want to just post excerpts of the content from your website along with a link, we'll just show it to them, even though they never asked to see it. It's a free traffic funnel. Some of those users will subscribe to you and they'll see everything you post. Others will get algorithmically boosted content.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And they went to the advertisers and they said, hey, do you remember we told these rubes that we weren't going to spy on them? Also a lie. We're spying on them from asshole to appetite. We will target ads to them in the most fine-grained, hideous way imaginable. We're not going to charge you very much for this. We have a building full of engineers that are going to fight ad fraud.
Cory Doctorow
And then they just use the characteristics of digital to make that subtly worse over time. They dialed down the quantity of stuff that was in your feed that you'd ask to see bit by bit, dribb by dribb. If you stop going to Facebook as often, they increase the amount of stuff you'd ask to see. But so long as that amount was going down, there was more space they could fill with things people would pay to make you see, whether that was advertisers or publishers.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And then, you know, Facebook and Google had this illegal, collusive arrangement they called Jedi Blue, where they rigged the market. So they charged advertisers more and paid publishers less. So they made things worse for everyone.
Cory Doctorow
And that's where Facebook is now, right? It's this company that has left just this kind of fine residue of things that are useful in the service. And it's trying to surf this wave where they're right at the crest of there being no value at all in the service or just enough value that you don't leave.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Because if they leave any more value than that on the table then that value that their shareholders could be getting And they want to take it for themselves And it a razor thin edge that they walking on
Cory Doctorow
And it takes you know one Cambridge Analytica scandal or whistleblower or live stream mass shooting and people bowl for the exits. And, you know, when that happens on tech platforms, the platforms panic and what tech bros call panicking is pivoting. And so, you know, in Facebook, you get this pivot that is like, all right, stop arguing with your racist uncle in this text chat. From now on, the future is allowing Facebook to convert you into a legless, sexless, low polygon, heavily surveilled cartoon character in a virtual world called the metaverse that we stole from a 25-year-old cyberpunk novel.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Imagine you put on your glasses or headset and you're instantly in your home space. It has parts of your physical home recreated virtually. It has things that are only possible virtually, and it has an incredibly inspiring view of whatever you find most beautiful.
Cory Doctorow
I think you importantly point out though, Corey, that even once a platform or a service is unshittified, people stick around. I stick around on Instagram, even though it upsets me. I'm still on Twitter, even though Elon, what have you.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
What receipts do you have to show that TikTok is currently being in shitified? Because certainly a lot of people are still there.
Cory Doctorow
Well, I think that there's lots of different bits and pieces. You know, you can look at things like the scandal over the heating tool, where it was revealed by a Forbes reporter that in addition to having algorithmic allocation of attention, that the platform was also picking performers.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
One of the ways that TikTok has tried to convince these potential partners that they should be on TikTok is to show them that their content can do really well there. And sometimes that means heating their content to prove, see if you come to TikTok, life will be good for you here. And then when people didn't get the eyeballs that the people who'd been heating tools were getting, they said, oh, you just must be bad at TikTok, try harder.
Cory Doctorow
So, you know, you've got that on the performer side. And then on the user and performer side, you've got the willingness of TikTok to walk away from its license with Universal.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Now, I'm not going to cape for Universal. I mean, this is a company that is a big evil monopolist. But I think that the calculus that TikTok is making is that they would rather inflict pain on their customers than on their shareholders.
Cory Doctorow
And so whatever it is that Universal was asking, their customers could live with that pain, with having the videos that they worked on for hours or days or weeks and put maybe thousands of dollars into suddenly rendered silent. Because TikTok decided not to step up for their interests.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
But TikTok wants people to stick around. Why does TikTok make the experience worse when they want people to stick around?
Cory Doctorow
Well, they don't have to care. They're the phone company, right? Google figured out that spending $25 billion a year on being the default search engine for every single service, platform, portal, site, and device was cheaper than competing with people who might make a better search engine than them.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And so they spent $25 billion a year. They lit a whole ass Twitter on fire every, you know, 22 months to make sure that you never tried another search engine. And so they don't have to care. If the only search engine you ever try is Google, then Google doesn't have to be as good.
Cory Doctorow
Do you believe that there is a way to restore the good in a platform that has become and shittified? Do you think stronger market protection, stronger regulation, stronger employee rights at a tech company, whatever it might be, could actually restore something that has already completely fallen off?
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
I don't think we need to make these platforms better. I just think we need to make it so that when they collapse, they don't take us down with them.
Cory Doctorow
So you know we have companies like google that have made one successful in-house product a 25 year old search engine and then almost with that exception everything else they made in-house was a failure and everything that they've got that's a success their mobile platform ad tech server management collaboration docs maps satellites whatever those are all companies they bought from someone else.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
They're not Willy Wonka's idea factory. They're rich uncle penny bags operationalizing other people's good ideas.
Cory Doctorow
And so, you know, those companies would have just collapsed under their own weight back when we enforced antitrust law and rules against vertical and horizontal mergers.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
We've allowed these companies that would have normally either not gotten off the ground or would have collapsed under their own weight. We've allowed them to grow and take over.
Cory Doctorow
And so now they're on fire, right? Because we stopped the good fire, the controlled burns, and now we have the wildfire of these companies not being able to do the job that we need them to do.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
So everything is on fire all the time. And what we should be doing is not figuring out how to make it safe to live at that place that keeps catching fire. We want to evacuate the fire zone.
Cory Doctorow
We have to make it easy for people to leave the platforms, not try and make the platforms better. Screw the platforms. Let them die, right?
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
What we need is for people to leave the platforms with their data, their relationships, and the value they get from them intact.
Cory Doctorow, he's pretty hardcore. People call him Hard Cory. He's with the Electronic Frontier Foundation. They fight for digital human rights. And he's got a book coming out. It's a Silicon Valley finance thriller about a forensic accountant who runs down high-tech scams. It's called The Bezel.
Find it wherever you read.
Support for the show comes from Strawberry.me
Support for Today, Explained comes from Strawberry.me. Are you happy with your job? Like, really happy? The unfortunate fact is that a huge number of people can't say yes to that.
Far too many of us are stuck in a job we've outgrown, or one we never wanted in the first place. But still, we stick it out. And we give reasons like, what if the next move is even worse? I already put years into this place and maybe the most common one everyone kind of miserable at work.
But there a difference between reasons for staying and excuses for not leaving. It time to get unstuck. It's time for Strawberry.me. They match you with a certified career coach who helps you go from where you are to where you actually want to be.
Your coach helps you get clear on your goals, create a plan, build your confidence, and keeps you accountable along the way. So don't leave your career to chance. Take action and own your future with a professional coach in your corner.
Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer. That's strawberry.me slash unstuck.
Support for the show comes from Upwork
Support for Today, Explained comes from Upwork. If you run a business, you know that scaling your business requires the right expertise at the right time.
I sometimes wonder how many of you are running businesses out there. I would love to know. Please email me, noelle at king.com.
With Upwork, you can find specialized freelancers in IT, web development, AI, design, admin support, marketing, and more. Experts who they say are ready to help you take your business to the next level.
With more than two decades of experience, Upwork has a simple and ambitious goal to pioneer a better way of working. Companies at every stage turn to Upwork to get things done and find more flexibility in the way they staff key projects and initiatives by accessing a global marketplace full of top talent.
Plus, Upwork makes posting your job easy with no cost to join. You can register, browse, freelance, or profiles, get help drafting a job post, or even book a consultation. You can visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free. That is Upwork.com to post your job for free and connect with top talents ready to help your business grow.
That's U-P-W-O-R-K.com, Upwork.com.
Wake up in the morning feeling like... Today explained Ramos for him. Neelai is gone, but we got Cory Doctorow in his stead. Cory's an author, an activist, an extremely online dude, but he does not use TikTok.
Cory Doctorow
I use TikTok like a Gen Xer. I look at clips that have been uploaded to Twitter. But he gets it. Oh, I get it. No, no, no, I get it. It has a spookily good recommendation engine. And, you know, there is part of the source of all of its mischief.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Because, you know, they spy on you a lot. They acquire third party data sets. They use that data to make predictions about what you're going to want to see. And they show it to you and it's generally pretty good.
Cory Doctorow
But they also abuse that power, right? Because most of TikTok's users are using it as a kind of surprise medium, right? And so that means that you're trusting TikTok not to game the system, right? Not to use the fact that you've said, oh, anything you want to cram into my eyeballs, I'll take a look at.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
So, you know, please don't like sell people the right to cram things into my eyeballs that I'm not interested in seeing or abuse that so that you can trick people into thinking that they're more popular in the platform than they really are so that they put a lot of energy into making content for it.
Cory Doctorow
And that's where it all goes wrong, because so long as it's good enough, we will just keep allowing them to do that non-consensual cramdown of stuff we don't want to hear or see, provided that there's enough of a residue of things that seem good.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And this is why we reached out to Corey, because Corey coined the term for what's going on at TikTok right now.
Cory Doctorow
Well, I think that it's something that I've called in shittification. Colloquially, I think a lot of people just use it to mean things are getting worse. But for me, it's a very technical phrase or a technical word that describes a specific process by which digital platforms use the particular contours of how digital services work to first lure in end users by giving them a good deal and then making that deal worse for them, but better for business customers who pay to access those end users.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And then once everyone is locked in, take away all the surplus from both end users and business customers, give it all to the shareholders and leave everyone in an increasingly worse service that just gets shittier and shittier until it turns into a pile of shit.
Cory Doctorow
Okay, so I want to ask you about TikTok in a moment in greater detail, but before we do that, can you give us the greatest end-shittification story?
Yeah, Facebook's a poster child, right? This is a company that, you know, began its life as a service to non-consensually rate the fuckability of Harvard undergraduates and only got worse after that.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
Billy Olson sitting here and had the idea of putting some of the pictures next to pictures of farm animals and have people vote on who's hotter. Good call, Mr. Olson.
Cory Doctorow
But in 2006, Zuckerberg said, okay, well, we're going to open up beyond college campuses. And the pitch that they made to people was, hey, I know that like you're all on MySpace and that's where your friends are. But did you know that MySpace was run by a, you know, crapulent, senescent, evil Australian billionaire named Rupert Murdoch, who spies on you with every hour that God sends.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
If you come over to Facebook, we'll never spy on you. Facebook is the non-spying on you version of MySpace. Wow. I forgot about that.
Cory Doctorow
Yeah, yeah. They made a promise. And in fact, at one point, they let the users vote on whether or not Facebook should start spying on them. And they voted against it. And Facebook did it anyway.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And they said to those users, hey, if you just tell us who matters to you on Facebook, We're just going to show you what they post in reverse chronological order. And then once those users were all locked in, they started to make things worse for them.
Cory Doctorow
They went to publishers and they said, hey, do you remember when we told these rubes, we would only show them the things that they asked to see. That was a lie. If you want to just post excerpts of the content from your website along with a link, we'll just show it to them, even though they never asked to see it. It's a free traffic funnel. Some of those users will subscribe to you and they'll see everything you post. Others will get algorithmically boosted content.
Host (Sean Rameswaram)
And they went to the advertisers and they said, hey, do you remember we told these rubes that we weren't going to spy on them? Also a lie. We're spying on them from asshole to appetite. We will target ads to them in the most fine-grained, hideous way imaginable. We're not going to charge you very much for this. We have a building full of engineers that are going to fight ad fraud.
Cory Doctorow
And then they just use the characteristics of digital to make that subtly worse over time. They dialed down the quantity of stuff that was in your feed that you'd ask to see bit by bit, dribb by dribb. If you stop going to Facebook as often, they increase the amount of stuff you'd ask to see. But so long as that amount was going down, there was more