Main Topic: The COVID-19 pandemic and its current state, with a focus on the Omicron variant and the possibility of the virus becoming endemic.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Halima Shah
Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform. Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most. I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Support for this show comes from Macy's. Layering is an art form. All it takes is a bit of intention, style, and, of course, the perfect cold weather staples. So find the perfect look for you with the help of Macy's Fall Fashion Guide, your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts. From leather to denim to cozy knits, find everything you need to piece together your new fall look. Explore the Macy's Fall Guide for yourself and shop in-store or online at Macy's.com.
It's Today Explained. I'm Halima Shah filling in for Sean Ramas Faram. The year is 2022, but it doesn't feel like it. I'm having all kinds of deja vu. Schools are debating whether to close again. I'm still working from my living room. And an R&B singer who peaked in the 2000s is getting a lot of play. What's up, everybody? It's Omarion, the entertainer. Not the variant. It's all thanks to Omicron and a spike in COVID-19 cases.
Omarion
That's right.
Halima Shah
I'm joined today by Omer Erfan, science reporter at Vox. I know this hits close to home for you because we were both at the same holiday party last month and had a COVID scare. And it turns out that one of the guests tested positive. So I isolated myself at home until I could find a test, which sucked.
Omer Erfan
Well, I had gotten back from the UK a couple weeks earlier, and as a souvenir, I picked up a pack of rapid tests, so I already had some at home. And so I took a test as soon as I found out about that exposure and then followed it up with a PCR test at a testing site near my house.
Halima Shah
Oh, way to share your stash, Amir.
Omer Erfan
I offered you, didn't I?
Halima Shah
I don't think so, but that's okay. Go back to the Slack message. I specifically said that I have a pack of them at the office.
Omer Erfan
Damn! Oh, damn. Okay, fine. I take it back. I take it all back. But how many people weren't as fortunate as we were? How many cases of COVID are there in the rest of the country?
Well, we're seeing a pretty big spike. I mean, with this new wave of COVID infections we're having, cases around the country, new infections have gone up so much that the chart showing our daily case counts, they just look like mistakes.
Halima Shah
In New York City, the virus shredding the ranks of frontline workers. 30 percent of emergency services employees are out. 21 percent of the police department, 18 percent of the fire department.
Omer Erfan
I just felt like here we go again. Here we go again. That's all. But it was inevitable. We knew it was coming. A lot of places throughout the U.S. are reporting record levels of new COVID cases, including where we are in Washington, D.C. It's the worst it's been throughout the pandemic. So it's pretty substantial.
Halima Shah
You know, this is much larger than we saw even in January of 2021. And do we know which variant is causing this? At this point, can we assume that it's Omicron?
Omer Erfan
I think that's fair. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recently reported or estimated that about 95% of new COVID-19 cases are being caused by Omicron. Now, the Delta variant is still present and contributing to some of these cases, but Omicron has seen such a stunning rise and takeover in just a few weeks. And now it is the dominant source of new infections.
Halima Shah
Okay, so we know the caseload is high and that it's almost entirely because of Omicron. Are hospitalizations and deaths spiking too?
Omer Erfan
There is an increase in hospitalizations, but not at the level that we saw with previous waves. And so there has been sort of a decoupling between the number of cases and a number of hospitalizations.
Halima Shah
Now, hospitals are still facing a lot of stress because two years into the pandemic, there is a lot of staff right now that are burned out. Winter is also a major season for other respiratory illnesses. So hospitals are usually stressed in these winter months anyway. And on top of that, they are seeing many new cases.
Omer Erfan
Now, while some of these cases are going to be fairly mild, you know, as they're testing patients as they're coming in, they're finding a lot of COVID cases, among them people being admitted for other reasons. And so then those patients have to be put into isolation protocols. So all of these factors converging to put a lot of stress on the healthcare system, though fortunately we are not seeing the same massive rise in deaths that we would have seen in a previous wave.
Halima Shah
And even with all of the stress on the healthcare system, it doesn't seem like things are really shutting down. I mean, I just went to a restaurant last week and I'm told the airports are still very busy. Are we hearing anything from the Biden administration? Are there any new measures to fight the latest wave?
Omer Erfan
Well, just before the winter holiday, the Biden administration announced a number of different measures that they were putting into place. Three weeks ago, I laid out a COVID-19 action plan for this winter that prepared us for this moment. Today, we're making the plan even stronger.
Halima Shah
First, one was expanding the eligibility for booster doses of the COVID-19 vaccines. These doses, you know, these extra doses do help bolster immune protection against Omicron and other variants, according to some of the research that we've seen so far.
Omer Erfan
I got my booster shot as soon as they were available. And just the other day former President Trump announced he had gotten his booster shot. It may be one of the few things he and I agree on.
Halima Shah
The Biden administration are putting together basically teams of researchers and health workers and other personnel who will go to these hotspots whenever they see, you know, an area with hospitals facing stress and go there to help assist with testing and also providing medical care, administration and other things.
Omer Erfan
And they also put out a large purchase order for these rapid tests that they're going to distribute throughout the country. The federal government will purchase one half billion. That's not million, billion with a B. Additional at home rapid test with delivery starting in January.
Halima Shah
And these rapid tests that they're distributing, is that the same rapid tests that the Biden administration scoffed at handing out for free just weeks ago?
Omer Erfan
Yep. Should we just send one to every American? Maybe. Then what happens if every American has one test? How much does that cost? And then what happens after that?
Halima Shah
We did an episode last month about how there's this big test shortage, and that's for a lot of reasons. But one of them is because the federal government has made it very hard for test manufacturers to get their tests authorized. Is there any sign that that is going to change in 2022?
Omer Erfan
Well, we are seeing a number of new rapid tests being authorized. The Food and Drug Administration has granted emergency use authorizations to more manufacturers and more test designs. So that should increase the availability of different tests on the market.
Halima Shah
But for the most part, the U.S. hasn't really invested in testing as part of its COVID-19 strategy. The U.S. went pretty all in on vaccines and so didn't really deploy the infrastructure, not just having the tests, but like manufacturing them and actually developing an infrastructure for reporting tests.
Omer Erfan
And so without all those other things in place, even having these rapid tests out there, many of them are either going to be too costly or not going to be deployed in the right fashion in order to actually make them useful for containing the virus.
Halima Shah
And to make things more confusing, we got new guidance from the CDC over the holidays. They said if you test positive but are asymptomatic or improving, you only have to isolate for five days instead of 10. What's behind that change?
Omer Erfan
Right. The Centers for Disease Control said that people are most likely most contagious right after their positive tests, and that contagiousness wanes fairly quickly, particularly if you're vaccinated. And so if this is a breakthrough infection and you're asymptomatic, you only have to wait five days from your first positive test before you're free to go.
Halima Shah
Now, this didn't actually follow up with a test out requirement, though some researchers are saying that that should be part of the guidelines. And other researchers are also pushing back on this, saying that even after five days, people with no symptoms can still have enough virus in their airways that they can transmit it to other people.
Omer Erfan
And they're saying that the evidence to support a five-day isolation period compared to the previous guidance of 10 days is not as robust and especially when we're dealing with a massive increase in spread right now the way we are right now they say that it's more prudent to actually increase the isolation guidelines so there's a bit of a tension between what the cdc is doing and what some public health researchers are saying is most optimal.
Halima Shah
I believe that the cdc soon will be coming out with more clarification of that since it obviously has generated a number of questions about at that five-day period, should you or should you not be testing people?
Omer Erfan
Yeah. Interestingly, the producer of this very show, Miles Bryan, is actually recovering from COVID. And he says that when he first started feeling sick, he kept testing negative for days. And it wasn't until his sixth COVID test that he found out he was positive. Huge bummer. That seems to suggest that on top of the issue of availability, these tests aren't very accurate.
Halima Shah
Well, there's a few factors at play. One is that, yes, these rapid tests are not as accurate as the PCR tests that involve a nasal swab and then sending that swab to a laboratory for further analysis. These rapid tests, they look for proteins on the surface of the virus. And so what that means is you really need to have the virus in a very accessible part of the body in order to actually test that.
Omer Erfan
So like basically the virus has to be in your upper airways in your nose at detectable levels in order to show up. And so what that indicates is that, you know, in the early stages of the infection, you may start feeling symptoms, but you may not have enough virus in your airways to actually be detected.
Halima Shah
Whereas once the symptoms pass, you might actually still have virus in your airways that you can transmit to other people. So those are other factors that you have to consider. And then on top of that, yes, these tests, since they are less accurate, you know, you can't use this as just, you know, an absolute guarantee that you are infected or you're not infected.
Omer Erfan
Rather, what you have to do is also keep track of your symptoms and oftentimes using multiple tests to help validate these results. So you can't just look at one test in isolation. If you're trying to, you know, test out of isolation, you have to look at, you know, one or two or three tests in a row to verify that you are or are not infected.
Halima Shah
Well, it seems clear that COVID is going to be with us in the new year, but the way that we're going to handle it will probably be different. At this point, what should we be bracing for? I mean, I think we can still expect that the virus will continue circulating, that we'll still have some degree of precautions in place.
Omer Erfan
We may need to get another dose of vaccines. But on balance, I think what we'll likely see, based on just from the people I've talked to as well, is that overall a lower and lower health burden over time. Essentially, we'll have fewer and fewer people going to the hospital and fewer people dying from this illness, but we may still have people being infected by this for a few more months, maybe throughout the rest of the year.
Halima Shah
But again, hard to predict. And that's part of why it's so hard to come up with a set of guidelines that people will actually adhere to. I mean, there's also a lot of fatigue. We're two years into this, And I think a lot of people really want to get back to school, get back to work, go back on vacation.
Omer Erfan
It'll be difficult. It a balancing act between what people are willing to do what is necessary and also what level of misery we willing to tolerate from this virus For now it looks like we stuck with COVID But we might not be stuck with a COVID-19 pandemic.
Halima Shah
More on that after the break.
Break music plays
Support for Today Explained comes from Built Rewards. These days, it seems like everybody has a rewards program. You swipe your card and you get one cent on the hundred dollars. But with your rent, frequently, you just pay month after month. You never get anything from it other than that roof over your head. Not anymore, says Built Rewards.
Built Rewards says it lets you earn points on your rent. By paying rent through Built, they say you can earn flexible points that can be redeemed toward hundreds of hotels and airlines, perhaps a future rent payment, your next Lyft ride, and so much more.
Your home isn't just where you sleep, it's your community, and Built wants you to go out and do things in the community. You can eat at your favorite local restaurants, then earn more points. You can get VIP treatment at certain fitness studios. You can enjoy exclusive experiences just for Built members every month.
When you're ready to travel, they say Built points can be converted to miles or hotel points all around the world. You can earn points on rent and around your neighborhood wherever you call home by joining built.com slash explained.
Let's be honest. Are you happy with your job? Like really happy? The unfortunate fact is that a huge number of people can't say yes to that. Far too many of us are stuck in a job we've outgrown, or one we never wanted in the first place. But still, we stick it out, and we give reasons like, what if the next move is even worse? I've already put years into this place, and maybe the most common one, isn't everyone kind of miserable at work?
But there's a difference between reasons for staying and excuses for not leaving. It's time to get unstuck. It's time for strawberry.me. They match you with a certified career coach who helps you go from where you are to where you actually want to be.
Your coach helps you get clear on your goals, create a plan, build your confidence, and keeps you accountable along the way. So don't leave your career to chance. Take action and own your future with a professional coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Sigal Samuel, you're a senior reporter for Vox's Future Perfect, and you recently wrote a piece about how COVID-19 will not be eradicated, but it'll at least stop being a pandemic. If it's not eradicated and it doesn't stay a pandemic, what will it be?
Sigal Samuel
It'll go from the pandemic phase to the endemic phase, which basically puts it in the category of something like the flu or the measles.
Halima Shah
So for me, endemicity means a lot more people get vaccinated, a lot more people get boosted. And although you don't eliminate or eradicate, that infection is not dominating your life. That's what endemicity means to me.
Sigal Samuel
You know, it still circulates in parts of the population for years and years, but its impact will come down, its prevalence will come down. It'll become something relatively manageable as opposed to this insane world-stopping disease.
Halima Shah
What requirements does COVID-19 have to meet in order to become endemic, to become something that's seasonal but doesn't shut down the whole world?
Sigal Samuel
Okay, so the basic bare minimum requirement is that the rate of infections has to pretty much stabilize more or less across the years instead of showing these giant unexpected spikes like we're seeing right now.
Halima Shah
And so basically the way an epidemiologist would put this is that the disease's reproductive number has to be stably at one, which means that one infected person on average is infecting one other person.
Sigal Samuel
Right now, we're nowhere near that because we have this extremely contagious Omicron variant, and each infected person is infecting definitely more than one other person.
Halima Shah
Is it possible that we'll keep seeing COVID variants?
Sigal Samuel
If I had to try to make a prediction, I would predict that we will keep seeing more COVID variants. That's largely because we're not vaccinating the globe fast enough to starve the virus of opportunities to keep mutating into something new and serious.
Halima Shah
And so a lot of the experts I talk to say that the key determinant of when the pandemic phase will end is when we will successfully vaccinate the globe, you know, enough of the globe to stop giving the virus just tons and tons of opportunities to mutate.
Sigal Samuel
So if we were to guess when we reach this endemic point, when would that be?
Halima Shah
So it's funny, and by funny, I mean somewhat heartbreaking. When I spoke to experts just a few months ago, they were saying, 2022, we're pretty confident. 2022, we feel like Delta is the last big act of this pandemic, and then it'll become endemic.
Sigal Samuel
And do we get there next year in the United States? I think it's conceivable that we will. I mean, I hope we do. And it might even be likely. That could still be the case. It's just the trajectory is a little more uncertain now with Omicron.
Halima Shah
On the one hand, it could be the case that Omicron slows down or sort of delays our path to endemicity to COVID becoming endemic because it you know going to put a big strain on the healthcare system with so many people getting infected that inevitably some do end up hospitalized et cetera.
Sigal Samuel
On the other hand, it could end up infecting so many people so quickly that it actually speeds up our path to endemicity by just giving us a pretty big layer of natural immunity in the population.
Halima Shah
Experts aren't quite sure yet which way that'll go. It has the potential to either delay or speed up endemicity, but I will tell you that in the past few days, I've been feeling a bit more optimism on this front because there have been a couple of small preliminary studies, one out of Hong Kong, one out of South Africa, that are seeming to suggest that people who recover from an Omicron infection may now have antibodies that can help them fight off Delta and other variants going forward?
Sigal Samuel
Well, I would hope that that's the case. There's no guarantee that that would happen. But if you have a very transmissible virus that replaces another virus and that virus has less of a degree of severity, that would be a positive outcome.
Halima Shah
But you can never guarantee. So that could be a meaningful source of, you know, cross-protective immunity. I should just say those are not yet peer-reviewed studies. They're small and preliminary, but they're giving me a little bit of hope.
Sigal Samuel
And in 2022, we have treatments available that weren't around in spring of 2020. Could those play a role in speeding up the process of endemicity?
Halima Shah
Yes, absolutely. So I think it's really important that we all kind of internalize the fact that even though it's very frustrating to be in this situation right now, we're not back to March 2020. We do have a lot more knowledge about COVID.
Sigal Samuel
Our scientists have designed a rapid COVID-19 test so remarkably simple. It puts the power of a lab in your hands. We have great masks, we have rapid tests, etc. We have antivirals now like Pfizer's Paxlovid pill, which early studies suggest can reduce the chance of being hospitalized or dying from COVID by 90%. So that can make a huge dent in the pandemic phase because moving into endemicity isn't just about whether the rate of infection stabilizes, whether the reproductive number just gets down to this objective one.
Halima Shah
It's also about, you know, what's happening societally. Are we seeing hospitals become totally overwhelmed and in really perilous situations? Are we seeing huge numbers of hospitalizations and deaths?
Sigal Samuel
So in that context, the new antivirals that are coming online can be really, really helpful in us reaching intimacy because that means that even if lots of people are getting sick, not that many are being hospitalized, not that many are dying.
Halima Shah
And does that explain why people who are vaccinated and have a booster shot are getting breakthrough cases of COVID-19 that end up being pretty mild?
Sigal Samuel
We are basically seeing, thanks to vaccinations, thanks to boosters, and maybe thanks to Omicron being inherently less virulent, we are seeing this sort of muted effect, which, best case scenario, you know, could mean that as a population, we're kind of building up this wall of immunity that will help us going forward defend against not only Omicron, but also other variants.
Halima Shah
It's still possible that a new variant could emerge down the road that will evade or that will be able to get around that wall of immunity that we've built up. But these early studies I mentioned earlier are seeming to suggest that we at least have some hope that there will be cross-protective immunity for people infected with Omicron against future variants.
If endemicity is the best we can do, can we at least hope that we won't see more lockdowns or thousands of people won't lose their jobs again or that kids will finally be able to stay in school?
Sigal Samuel
I think so. I mean, I think that in March 2020, when this all first started, lockdowns, shutdowns, you know, they were proposed for a reason. It really, it made sense at the time to slow this virus when we didn't know anything about it.
Halima Shah
We had to learn how this virus works. We didn't have any vaccines. We didn't have, we didn't, we didn't even know that masking was effective and advisable, right? Like it's, it's, we really knew almost nothing.
Sigal Samuel
We're not in that state anymore. And I think we've also learned that those shutdowns really do come at a serious cost, you know, in terms of our mental health, our economic health. And so by and large, experts and politicians aren't saying we should go back into total lockdown now.
Halima Shah
What they are saying is that for the next few weeks, it does make sense to once again be a bit more cautious, right? And I think it's worth it. That's what my personal plan is to be doing, at least.
Sigal Samuel is a senior reporter at Vox. Umair Irfan, who you heard from earlier, is Vox's science reporter. And for the record, he does like to share and is not hoarding COVID tests.
Today's episode was produced by Miles Bryan with help from Hadi Mawajdeh. I'm Halima Shah. It's Today Explained. Thank you.