Main Topic: The podcast episode discusses the ongoing controversy surrounding former President Donald Trump's eligibility to run for the presidency in 2024, with two states, Colorado and Maine, disqualifying him from the ballot due to his alleged involvement in insurrection on January 6th, 2021.
Key Participants:
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Theme music fades out
Sean Rameswaram
It's 2024. Happy New Year. A statute of limitations. Things kind of run out on the new year. Three days. Plenty. Three days?
Pause
Sorry, Larry. 2024 is going to be great for lovers of Olympic sport, total eclipses, and people who have been waiting to find out what happens to Paul in Dune. This world is beyond cruelty. 2024 will be less great for people who dread nothing more than a rematch between current president Joseph Robinette Biden Jr. and former president Donald John Trump. But that rematch only happens if Trump is allowed to be on your ballot.
Pause
Breaking news, just in the past few minutes, Donald Trump has asked the Supreme Court to overturn a ruling in Colorado and ensure that he can appear on the ballot there and across the country.
Pause
The states that are trying to cancel Trump, coming up on Today Explained. Support for this show comes from ServiceNow. AI is only as powerful as the platform it's built into, don't you know? That's why it's no surprise that more than 85% of the Fortune 500 use the ServiceNow AI platform.
Pause
Didn't know that. While other platforms duct tape tools together, ServiceNow seamlessly unifies people, data, workflows, and AI, connecting every corner of your business. And with AI agents working together autonomously, anyone in any department can focus on the work that matters most.
Pause
I've never met an AI agent. Learn how ServiceNow puts AI to work for people at servicenow.com.
Pause
Support for this show comes from strawberry.me. Be honest. Are you happy with your job? Or are you stuck in one you've outgrown? Or never wanted in the first place?
Pause
Sure, you can probably list the reasons for staying, but are they actually just excuses for not leaving? Let a career coach from strawberry.me help you get unstuck. Discover the benefits of having a dedicated career coach in your corner. Go to strawberry.me slash unstuck to claim a special offer.
Pause
It's today. Today explains. Lots of big election news over the holidays. Last night, the former president asked the Supreme Court of the United States to keep him on ballots across the country. Today's a big day for that Colorado ruling.
Pause
We've got a lot explaining to do. We asked Zach Montalero to help. He's a state politics reporter at Politico.
Zach Montalero
So there's been a push by a kind of a strange bedfellows group of some liberal activists, some conservative scholars to have the former president disqualified from running for the presidency again under interpretation of a section of the 14th Amendment.
Pause
The 14th Amendment was one of the big amendments post-Civil War. But for our purposes, it focuses on a section that says someone who engaged in insurrection is not eligible to hold an office, political office in the United States.
Pause
Amendment 14, Section 3. No person shall be a senator or representative in Congress or elector of president and vice president or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States or under any state who, having previously taken an oath as a member of Congress or as an officer of the United States or as a member of any state legislature or as an executive or judicial officer of any state to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof.
Pause
But Congress may, by a two-thirds vote of each house, remove such a disability. And we've seen a bunch of lawsuits across the country from activist groups, from some kind of long-shot candidates, all trying to get Trump kicked off the ballot for 2024.
Pause
And the reason we're talking about it is because it's actually been two states that have done that. And it sounds something like a liberal fever dream to prevent Donald Trump from getting on the ballot in the first place, but how did this get to be a serious legal action?
Pause
Yeah, so certainly the two groups that are responsible for the most prominent lawsuits are generally believed to be liberal. That's Crew, a watchdog group that's pretty well known in D.C., especially after the Trump era, and Free Speech for People, which is also another activist group that has kind of burst onto the scene with this, although they've been around for a little bit.
Pause
But it's a real mixture of people advocating for this position. There's those groups, there is some pretty prominent conservative scholars, and I think the one probably most familiar is a former federal judge, Michael Weddick, who, if that name sounds familiar, was integral in then-Vice President Pence's deliberations over how you should count electoral votes on January 6th, 2021.
Pause
The judge advised Pence that his job is, you know, that he didn't have discretion, that he needed to count the legitimate electoral count votes that were put forward.
Pause
The original meaning of Section 3 disqualifies the former president from ever holding the presidency again. They kind of kicked this all off, not in a legal sense, but at least in the public discourse.
Pause
Which I guess sets us up to talk about Colorado. Tell us what happened in Colorado.
Pause
Colorado was the first state to find that the former president, A, did engage in insurrection because of his actions on January 6th, and B, because that he did engage in insurrection, according to the Colorado Supreme Court. He is disqualified from the ballot.
Pause
The state Supreme Court made that ruling in December. They were the first court anywhere nationwide to find both of those holdings. That was a big deal. It's obviously unprecedented.
Pause
We've never had a presidential candidate disqualified in this manner in recent history, certainly in American history. So it was huge. And they did do this pause until today slash tomorrow.
Pause
Why exactly did they make that pause?
Pause
Yeah, so Colorado said, listen, we know that this is unprecedented. So they said, you know what, like we all know this is going to go to the U.S. Supreme Court anyway. So we going to automatically pause our decision until January 4th today to allow people to file an appeal to the Supreme Court to the U Supreme Court Trump has now officially filed his appeal
Pause
And here they asking the court this is a direct quote did the Colorado Supreme Court err in ordering Trump excluded from the 2024 presidential primary ballot
Pause
So really, in practical senses, unless the Supreme Court issues a ruling before the end of day Friday, determining something or lifting the Colorado pause, in practicality's effect, This means that President Trump will be on the ballot in the Colorado Republican primary.
Pause
Another place this is happening is Maine. How similar is the Maine case to the Colorado one?
Pause
Maine is similar in the legal findings, but how we got there is pretty unique. Maine's setup is different from a lot of states that actually requires the secretary of state, which in most states is the state's chief election official, to be that first stop, to make that first proactive determination.
Pause
In Maine, if you want to challenge a candidate's qualifications, you do it directly with the secretary of state who, by state law, has to have a hearing about it.
Pause
So the main secretary of state, the Democrat, Shanna Bellows, had that hearing in December. And she, too, found that A, Trump engaged in insurrection and B, therefore, he is disqualified for running for the presidency.
Pause
That put her in a very different position from a lot of other Secretary of State, Democratic and Republican, and, you know, pretty apolitical election officials, of having to make that determination.
Pause
Many of them said, this is not the role of an election official to make this call, it's the role of the courts. But in Maine, the process requires the Secretary basically to make that first call.
Pause
The events of January 6th were unprecedented and tragic and an insurrection. Those events happened at the behest of and with the knowledge and support of the outgoing president, Mr. Trump.
Pause
The challenge for her was, okay, did Trump engage in it? I found Mr. Trump to have engaged in insurrection under Section 3 of the 14th Amendment. And she said it would have been an easier decision if there had been a criminal proceedings around this, but there hasn't been.
Pause
So she said she was duty-bound to make the call in her state. The legislature did not write into the law an exception for complexity or difficult natures of interpretation.
Pause
They didn't say enforce all of the constitutional qualifications except for the ones that are difficult or complex. I do not have the discretion to choose or to decline to do my duty to hold a hearing and then issue re-rolling.
Pause
So she made that determination, but certainly she's come under a lot of scrutiny for it.
Pause
And perhaps adding to the chaos here is that while Colorado and Maine are saying the former president cannot appear on the ballot, other states are saying he can.
Pause
Yeah. So a couple of states have had state Supreme Courts proactively say, yes, Trump can appear on the primary ballot. And I draw that distinction specifically because Michigan and Minnesota, the state Supreme Courts there both said Trump can appear on the primary ballot.
Pause
But their ruling wasn't, you know, exonerating Trump and saying the 14th Amendment doesn't apply to him or he didn't engage in insurrection or what have you. They were kind of effectively punts saying primaries are different than general elections. He could be on the primary ballot, but we'll see about the general.
Pause
And of course, many, many other states will have Trump on their primary ballot, either because a court case didn't resolve in time. The secretaries thought they didn't have the discretion to take somebody off the ballot.
Pause
Of course, many Republican-leaning states will have Trump on the ballot, but this is also true for California.
Pause
A famous rival of Donald Trump's. A 2,000-mile wall is a monument to stupidity, not just vanity, to stupidity. Yes, famous rival of Donald Trump.
Pause
But, you know, the legal argument with the Secretary of State said that I don't have the ability to make this determination, but there's also the normative argument that setting aside all the legal arguments, is this a good idea?
Pause
And that is what California Governor Gavin Newsom has made saying in paraphrasing him. But, you know, the best way to defeat Trump is at the ballot box, not a procedural move, but we get more votes than him and we win.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Now, nine Supreme Court justices, three of whom the former president himself appointed, will have to figure it out.
Pause
Yes, you know, right now we're waiting to see, will the Supreme Court step into the Colorado case? But most legal experts assume that the Supreme Court will kind of wade into this Colorado decision.
Pause
And it's, again, thrusting the Supreme Court kind of into the center of electoral politics, that something that at least Chief Justice Roberts has said that he kind of wants to, or has projected at least, that he wants to navigate the court out of.
Pause
But there's really no escaping this, especially now that two states have found that Trump doesn't qualify for the ballot.
Pause
Zach Montalero, Politico.com. The Supreme Court calls when we're back on Today Explained.
Pause
Support for Today Explained comes from Chime. Nobody likes fees and complicated banking, says Chime. And Chime gets that, says Chime.
Pause
Chime is a financial technology company that says they understand that every dollar counts. So when you set up direct deposit through Chime, they say you get access to fee-free features, such as free overdraft coverage, getting paid up to two days early with direct deposit, so much more.
Pause
Chime says with qualifying direct deposits, you can be eligible for free overdraft up to $200 on debit card purchases and cash withdrawals. Plus, they say you don't need to worry about monthly fees or maintenance fees.
Pause
You can work on your financial goals through Chime today. You can open an account in two minutes at chime.com slash explained.
Pause
That's chime.com slash explained. Chime feels like progress. Chime is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services and debit card provided by the Bancor Bank N.A. or Stride Bank N.A. Members FDIC.
Pause
Spot me eligibility requirements and overdraft limits apply. Timing depends on submission of payment file. Fees apply at out-of-network ATMs. Bank ranking and number of ATMs according to U.S. News and World Report 2023. Time checking account required.
Pause
Support for this show comes from Macy's. It's almost fall, and that means it's time to cycle your wardrobe to the cold setting.
Pause
Because while everyone loves a breezy summer outfit, let's be real. Layering is even more fun. That's why Macy's Fall Fashion Guide has everything you need to piece together the perfect look for you.
Pause
It's your one-stop shop for fall's latest trends and must-haves, curated by their experts. Add a statement shoe to your collection, like the calf-hair loafers from Steve Madden.
Pause
Or tap into your romantic side with flowy dresses from Cece and sheer pieces from INC. You can even throw in some textural layers for contrast, like a faux fur bomber jacket from Karl Lagerfeld Paris.
Pause
Whether your old favorite sweater or coat is on its last threads, or you're just craving a new vibe to switch things up, Macy's has got you covered this season.
Pause
Find the perfect layering pieces for you by exploring the Macy Fall Fashion Style Guide Shop in or online at Macy's.
Pause
Support for this show comes from Upwork. With more than two decades of experience, Upwork has a simple and ambitious goal to pioneer a better way of working.
Pause
Companies at every stage turn to Upwork to get things done and find more flexibility in the way they staff key projects and initiatives by accessing a global marketplace full of top talent.
Pause
Plus, Upwork makes posting your job easy with no cost to join. You can register, browse, freelance, or profiles, get help drafting a job post, or even book a consultation.
Pause
You can visit Upwork.com right now and post your job for free. That is Upwork.com to post your job for free and connect with top talents ready to help your business grow.
Pause
That's U-P-W-O-R-K.com, Upwork.com. Explained. 2024 Explained. Today Explained is back.
Pause
We're with Ian Millhiser, who covers the Supreme Court for Vox.
Ian Millhiser
It seems like everyone is waiting on the Supreme Court to take up this issue. Is there any chance the Supreme Court won't?
Pause
I mean, there is always a small chance that that could happen. But the effect, if the Supreme Court were to just not take this case, would be that the Colorado decision would stand.
Pause
So Trump would still be off the ballot in the state of Colorado. But that decision wouldn't be binding in the other 49 states.
Pause
So we'd have a kind of chaotic situation where some states he'd be on the ballot, some states he wouldn't be on the ballot.
Pause
You know, you could potentially have red states retaliating against Colorado by removing Joe Biden from their ballots.
Pause
So we really need the Supreme Court to step in because the Supreme Court is the only entity that has the authority to say, here's one rule for the entire nation that will govern who and who does not get to be on every state's ballot.
Pause
Got it. So the Supreme Court doesn't love chaos between the states, even though sometimes they create it themselves.
Pause
Let's just for the fun of it, start with maybe the least likely outcome here. What would that be?
Pause
So the least likely outcome, I think, is just a straight decision affirming the Colorado Supreme Court by the U.S. Supreme Court.
Pause
I mean, that would mean because this would be a decision coming from the U.S. Supreme Court saying that Trump is an insurrectionist and is constitutionally disqualified from serving as president.
Pause
That would potentially mean that he has to be removed from the ballot in all 50 states.
Pause
It would be the end of Trump's career as a politician. It would be the end potentially of his eligibility to serve in any office at all.
Pause
This is a court with a Republican supermajority.
Pause
I think there are some legitimate reasons why the court may want to delay resolution of this case for just a little bit.
Pause
So I don't think that outcome is very likely at all.
Pause
But there is at least the possibility that the Supreme Court could say, yep, Trump's an insurrectionist, can't be president again.
Pause
What's more likely?
Pause
So there's two other possible outcomes to Trump raises or rather the Colorado Republican Party in a document that it filed last week raises a number of rather silly arguments for why this case should be resolved now to say that Trump can stay on the ballot.
Pause
One of their arguments is that the Colorado Republican Party has a First Amendment right to put whoever they want to put on the ballot.
Pause
But that's wrong. No. Like it is well established that states can have – they can have residency requirements. They can require candidates to gather signatures.
Pause
It just happens all the time that someone wants to get on the ballot and they don't comply with some state law, so they aren't allowed to be on the ballot.
Pause
There is no First Amendment right to appear on a ballot.
Pause
So that's not a good argument.
Pause
Um, the second argument is that, and this is going to sound like the stupidest thing you've ever heard, but okay.
Pause
The 14th amendment says that the people who are disqualified from serving as president are people who previously served as quote, an officer of the United States.
Pause
And then after serving as an officer of the United States, then went on to participate in an insurrection.
Pause
And the claim that the Republicans are making is that the presidency is not an office. The president is not an officer of the United States.
Pause
And therefore, Trump is not disqualified because he has not served as an officer of the United States before.
Pause
And therefore, it's fine, I guess, if he does an insurrection.
Pause
Feels a lot like the president is the officer of the United States.
Pause
But but who am I?
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Is there a middle road here that the Supreme could take between these sort of maybe more extreme positions?
Pause
Ian Millhiser
Yeah. I mean, I think that the court is unlikely to accept either of those two arguments I just mentioned or to kick Trump off the ballot, you know, at least right away.
Pause
The middle ground is a punt and there's there's a pretty easy way which they can punt this case.
Pause
And frankly, I think they should punt to this case.
Pause
So the tension that you have in the 14th Amendment, on the one hand, the 14th Amendment says if you commit an insurrection, you can't, you know, and you've previously served in high office, you can't then go on to serve in high office again.
Pause
On the other hand, the 14th Amendment protects the right to due process. You know, before a court is allowed to do something to you, there normally has to be some sort of procedure to determine, like, did you actually do anything wrong? What did you do wrong? Does the thing that you did wrong violate the Constitution?
Pause
And that requires some sort of a trial, some sort of a fact-gathering process.
Pause
The Colorado state court process, which determined that Trump is ineligible, like there was a trial, but it was a pretty truncated proceeding.
Pause
You know, one of the dissenting justices pointed out, like, there wasn't the normal right to what's called discovery, to gather evidence.
Pause
Trump didn't have the ordinary right to subpoena witnesses that you see in a lot of trials.
Pause
The truncated process that the Colorado courts used I don't think that enough to comply with the due process clause.
Pause
But there is another proceeding coming up there Trump is facing a criminal trial in Washington D.C.
Pause
This trial is supposed to happen in March which will determine whether or not he is guilty of committing federal crimes because he tried to steal the 2020 election.
Pause
And so that's the middle ground is that the court says we're not going to decide now whether or not Trump is ineligible to be president.
Pause
But after that criminal trial, if he's convicted, we may very well turn around and say, OK, now that he has been convicted of trying to steal the election, he must be removed from the ballot.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
I want to talk to you in a bit about the mindset of the nine justices going into this new year, this new term and this, you know, wildly unprecedented case.
Pause
The Supreme Court deciding a presidential election seems nuts, unless, of course, You remember the one time they did it.
Pause
Stand by. Stand by. CNN right now is moving our earlier declaration of Florida back to the too close to call column.
Pause
We'll hear argument now number 00949, George W. Bush and Richard Cheney versus Albert Gore et al.
Pause
Bottom line here, the judgment of the Supreme Court of Florida is reversed. That was the judgment that had allowed these broad counts to go forward.
Pause
The president-elect of the United States, the Honorable George W. Bush. The presidency is more than an honor. It is more than an office. It is a charge to keep. And I will give it my all.
Pause
And folks, in the year 2004, please, could you make up your minds a little more conclusively? Because I think we can't take another election like this one.
Pause
Ian Millhiser
What are some of the parallels here between this situation and Bush v. Gore?
Pause
I mean, Bush v. Gore, it was a very different case for many reasons. I mean, one reason why it is different is that the election had already happened and the official count already showed George W. Bush was up when the case reached the Supreme Court.
Pause
And I don't think anyone knows whether that that count was correct, you know, because what Bush v. Gore did is it shut down the recount that would have determined whether or not Bush or Gore actually won the state of Florida and with it the presidential election.
Pause
And so all the Supreme Court had to do there was prevent anything from happening. And Bush just became president.
Pause
In this case, if the Supreme Court does nothing, what will happen is that the Colorado Supreme Court's decision will stand and Trump will be removed from the ballot.
Pause
So like the court actually has to come up with a reason to keep Trump on the ballot if they want to keep him on the ballot.
Pause
Now, that said, I think, you know, the most relevance that Bush v. Gore could have for this case is that three of the justices were on Bush's legal team.
Pause
Three. Three. Yeah. Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett all were on Bush's legal team.
Pause
I don't think the justices care that it's Bush versus Gore or if it were Gore versus Bush.
Pause
What they care about is how to interpret the Constitution. What are the enduring values that are going to stand a generation from now?
Pause
And like the Bush v. Gore decision is not remembered as a paragon of Supreme Court jurisprudence. It was deeply partisan. It was a five to four decision. The five conservatives, the four liberals, right?
Pause
Its reasoning has been widely criticized.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Do you think the fact that it wasn't beloved, even if three of the nine justices were on the Bush legal team, means they might be a little gun shy this time around?
Pause
Ian Millhiser
I mean, I would hope. I mean, one thing that has changed a lot is that the Supreme Court's approval ratings, according to many polls, are at record lows right now.
Pause
I think everyone understands that the Supreme Court has become something very partisan and they start to feel suspicious if the court steps in to do a favor for a Republican presidential candidate.
Pause
But the safest course for the Supreme Court might still look like a favorable decision for the former president, which is saying he gets to stay on the ballot.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
If that is indeed what transpires here, what will this episode between Colorado and Maine and all the rest have taught us about, I don't know, the 14th Amendment insurrections, elections in America ourselves?
Pause
Ian Millhiser
A lot of people, you know, not just Republicans. I mean, the New York Times had an article making this argument. You know, I've heard some Democrats say, like, are we really sure we are comfortable with, you know, someone who has a lot of popular support and a lot of popular support from some people who recently committed an act of violence on behalf of Donald Trump?
Pause
There's no easy way to put this. Like, are we afraid it would lead to political violence? Are we afraid that it would lead to the kind of upheaval that, you know, that we just don't want?
Pause
But this provision of the 14th Amendment saying you can't be president if you engage in an insurrection is in there.
Pause
And it doesn't exist to protect us from people who who are unpopular. You know, if Donald Trump did not have a broad base of popular support, we wouldn't need the 14th Amendment because unpopular candidates lose elections.
Pause
And so if you don't disqualify someone who has popular support, then you might as well not have this provision in the Constitution anyway.
Pause
Because the only thing that we need to worry about is that someone who actually has the popular support that makes them capable of winning an election might win an election despite the fact that they committed an insurrection.
Pause
You know, the insurrectionist who retains a broad base of popular support. And if we're not willing to disqualify them, then we should just admit that, you know, this provision, the 14th Amendment, it doesn't do any work at all.
Pause
Sean Rameswaram
Our program was produced by Isabel Angel. We were edited by Amina al-Sadi, fact-checked by Laura Bullard and mixed by David Herman.
Pause
I'm Sean Ramos for more on this story in the coming weeks, months, year of Today Explained.