Main Topic: The European Union's response to the US's withholding of military aid from Ukraine and the potential for Europe to defend itself against Russia.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Other topics covered in the podcast episode:
Steve Inskeep
Europe aims to increase defense spending after the U.S. withholds military aid from Ukraine.
A. Martinez
What would it take for Europeans to defend themselves against Russia?
Steve Inskeep
I'm Steve Inskeep with A. Martinez, and this is Up First from NPR News.
Music fades out
The auto industry gets a reprieve. President Trump pauses new tariffs on cars made in Canada and Mexico.
A. Martinez
U.S. automakers lobbied hard because their car parts cross both borders.
Steve Inskeep
What they said was, look, if you put a 25% tariff on us, you're helping everybody but us. So come on.
A. Martinez
But the relief lasts only a month. So what happens next?
Steve Inskeep
And nearly 6,000 fired Department of Agriculture workers are back, at least for now. A federal board says their firings were likely illegal, but the fight over government jobs is not over.
A. Martinez
Stay with us. We've got all the news you need to start your day.
Music fades in
Steve Inskeep
This message comes from BetterHelp. President Fernando Madeira describes how BetterHelp Online Therapy has helped him.
Audio clip plays
For me, sometimes I just need to go and talk to somebody that is not going to judge me, right? Is going to be there and going to listen to me.
A. Martinez
And I can start just saying, look, I'm not feeling right today. And it feels natural. I love it.
Steve Inskeep
To get matched with a therapist, visit BetterHelp.com slash NPR for 10% off your first month.
Music fades out
This message comes from Lisa. Lisa mattresses are meticulously designed and assembled in the USA for exceptional quality.
Audio clip plays
And each mattress is designed with specific sleep positions and feel preferences in mind.
A. Martinez
Plus, they back it all up with free shipping, easy returns, and a 100-night sleep trial.
Steve Inskeep
Visit Lisa.com for 25% off mattresses, plus get an extra $50 off with promo code NPR.
A. Martinez
That's L-E-E-S-A.com, promo code NPR.
Steve Inskeep
Support for NPR and the following message come from Pete and Jerry's Eggs.
Audio clip plays
Their new organic pasture-raised eggs are the next level of commitment to healthy hens, healthy eggs, and a healthy planet.
A. Martinez
These hens roam outside in nature with over 108 square feet of pasture each and enjoy a USDA-certified organic diet with no GMOs, added hormones, or synthetic pesticides.
Steve Inskeep
Delicious, ethical, healthy eggs as nature intended. Learn more at PeteAndJerrys.com.
Music fades out
Terry Schultz
European Union leaders are gathering for an emergency summit to coordinate support for Ukraine.
Steve Inskeep
They're aiming to protect against Russia and do it with less help from the United States.
Terry Schultz
The U.S., to be clear, remains part of the NATO alliance with troops based in Germany.
Steve Inskeep
But in recent days, the U.S. paused military supplies and intelligence sharing with Ukraine, bidding to force a peace with Russia.
Terry Schultz
Terry Schultz is in Brussels covering the meeting. Terry, what's the mood like there?
Good morning. Well, you can really feel the worry here in a way I haven't seen since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine started three years ago.
Steve Inskeep
And interestingly, that isn't because Moscow is doing anything differently.
Terry Schultz
It's been relentlessly attacking Ukraine since the beginning of the war.
Steve Inskeep
The difference is this rapid deterioration of relations between the Trump administration and Ukraine, the spat between the presidents in the Oval Office last week, and as you mentioned, the subsequent suspension of military assistance and now intelligence sharing, which is essential to Ukraine on the battlefield.
Terry Schultz
So there was an urgent meeting in Paris. There was an urgent meeting in London, now one in Brussels.
Steve Inskeep
So outside of it being all urgent, what are European leaders actually going to do about this?
Terry Schultz
Well, today I expect leaders to move forward. Now, whether they can reach the required unanimity yet is unclear.
Steve Inskeep
But there's a new package of proposals on how they can come up with 800 billion euros.
Terry Schultz
That's more than 860 billion dollars in defense spending.
Steve Inskeep
That would be partly in loans backed up by the EU for buying new weapons and partly by setting aside EU penalties on having too much debt so that governments can now drastically increase their military spending.
Terry Schultz
So are European citizens on board with that?
Steve Inskeep
Well, yeah, going into more debt is popular.
Terry Schultz
But I spoke with former Dutch Defense Minister Kaiser Ollengren about this, and she said that politicians and officials just need to help their people understand that U.S. unpredictability means it's urgent now to mobilize all the tools they have available to scale up both their domestic defense and support for Ukraine.
Steve Inskeep
If you boil it down, I think it comes down to turning the European economy into a war economy.
Terry Schultz
These are difficult choices and you have to explain them to people, but it has to be done.
Steve Inskeep
Now, earlier suggestions to declare a war economy in Europe didn't get traction because many leaders felt it was too drastic and would unnecessarily scare people.
Terry Schultz
So you can see how things have changed.
Steve Inskeep
Yeah, it certainly sounds like Europeans have kind of moved into this worst-case scenario thinking, you know, when it comes to regarding U.S. support.
Terry Schultz
Well, they're at least seriously considering those scenarios, including researcher Giuseppe Spadafora with the EU Institute of Security Studies.
Steve Inskeep
He told me that even the fear of the U.S. disengaging could destabilize the transatlantic relationship further.
Terry Schultz
The U.S. could use the threat of abandonment as a tool to obtain a lot of concessions in areas that weaken Europe.
Steve Inskeep
It could force Europeans to compromise on a lot of other areas, such as trade concessions, changing technology standards, and curtailing certain rights.
Terry Schultz
So Spadafore says Europeans' concern about this possibility may end up leading them to make policy decisions in favor of the Trump administration.
Steve Inskeep
So if the U.S. does indeed step back, as people are worried about, I mean, are there individual European leaders looking to maybe step up?
Terry Schultz
Well, French President Emmanuel Macron has really tried to be that leader.
Steve Inskeep
And as the head of one of two nuclear powers in Europe, he has a lot of weight in defense issues.
Terry Schultz
So in an evening address, he said he'll call together European army chiefs to discuss a potential peacekeeping force and says he's even considering extending the French nuclear deterrent over the rest of Europe.
Steve Inskeep
The future of Europe does not have to be decided in Washington or Moscow, he said.
Terry Schultz
So EU leaders hope to decide some things about their future here in Brussels today.
Steve Inskeep
All right, that's Terry Schultz in Brussels. Terry, thanks.
Terry Schultz
You're welcome.
Music fades in
Steve Inskeep
As 25% tariffs on goods from Canada and Mexico take hold, President Trump has announced another one-month reprieve.
A. Martinez
The president's latest sudden shift is only for carmakers.
Steve Inskeep
They are a huge source of cross-border business.
A. Martinez
It is common for parts to cross the border several times, as American-made cars are assembled.
Steve Inskeep
U.S. automakers warned the tariffs would raise the price of their cars by thousands of dollars.
A. Martinez
NPR's Camila Domenoski covers the auto industry. Camila, so where did this pause come from?
Camila Domenoski
Well, it is no secret. The Detroit automakers, so that's Ford, General Motors, Stellantis, they have been lobbying for this for months.
Steve Inskeep
Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick went on Fox News yesterday, and he said that the big three spoke to the White House.
Camila Domenoski
They made their pitch, and what they said was, look, we're domestic American automakers, and if you put a 25% tariff on us, and you don't put it on the Germans, and you don't put it on the Koreans, And you don't put it on the Japanese.
Steve Inskeep
You're helping everybody but us. So come on.
Camila Domenoski
And specifically, what the big three had asked for was that these tariffs not apply to either cars or parts for cars that meet the strict requirements for the USMCA.
Steve Inskeep
That's the trade agreement between the US, Canada, and Mexico that Trump negotiated in his first term to replace the previous agreement known as NAFTA.
Camila Domenoski
So most cars made in North America meet these requirements, but not all of them.
Steve Inskeep
So it's a reprieve for most vehicles, maybe in Canada, Mexico, or the U.S., by any automaker, but it would particularly help the U.S. automakers.
Camila Domenoski
Okay but Trump says that these tariffs are coming back in April for every car for all cars.
Steve Inskeep
So how much does a 30 pause even help?
Camila Domenoski
Yeah, I mean look it time for companies to figure out some logistics maybe stockpile a few parts but it is not nearly enough time to for instance move an auto plant to the U.S. to avoid tariffs.
Steve Inskeep
I spoke to Angela Gomalski, a trade lawyer who works with the auto industry.
Camila Domenoski
One of the clients that I've been working with is weighing that exact question. How do we reshore? And their best estimate is looking at two years.
Steve Inskeep
Two years.
Camila Domenoski
Meanwhile, this is a policy that was in place for only one day for these vehicles and has been pushed back twice.
Steve Inskeep
And even for the rest of the Mexico and Canada tariffs, which are still in place for all these other goods, there is just so much uncertainty about how long they're going to be in place.
Camila Domenoski
So what does this mean then for the people who sell cars and the people that want to be car buyers?
Steve Inskeep
Yeah, so a one-day tariff, obviously not much.
Camila Domenoski
There's still those smaller number of vehicles that are hit by this tariff.
Steve Inskeep
And if they come back and stick to all of them, they will make cars even pricier.
Camila Domenoski
And, of course, Trump is promising many more tariffs to come.
Steve Inskeep
So these particular tariffs on Canada and Mexico, if they stayed in place a while, we would be looking at new cars going up in price, almost certainly by thousands of dollars.
Camila Domenoski
Car parts get more expensive. Used cars repairs. Insurance get more expensive through ripple effects.
Steve Inskeep
The UAW, the Auto Workers Union, did put out a statement this week acknowledging the pain caused by tariffs.
Camila Domenoski
But also saying the working class felt the pain of NAFTA, and tariffs are a way to bring jobs to the U.S. by making it more expensive to manufacture overseas.
Steve Inskeep
The White House has said that's the ultimate goal.
Camila Domenoski
It's also said the goal is to stop fentanyl at the border.
Steve Inskeep
One's long-term, one's immediate.
Camila Domenoski
It's really confusing, and it's hard for companies to make plans, including plans to move factories.
Steve Inskeep
Camila Domenoski covers cars for NPR. Thanks a lot.
Camila Domenoski
Thank you.
Music fades in
Andrea Hsu
Nearly 6,000 fired employees of the U.S. Department of Agriculture should be heading back to work today.
Steve Inskeep
An independent federal board ordered them reinstated for 45 days while its investigation into the firings continues.
Andrea Hsu
NPR's Andrea Hsu has been following all of this. So, Andrea, how do these workers at USDA get their jobs back?
Yeah, well, in short, the system set up to hear federal employee complaints about things that happened to them on the job worked.
Steve Inskeep
You know, tens of thousands of probationary employees have been fired since last month.
Andrea Hsu
These are people typically in their first or second year on the job.
Steve Inskeep
And some of them filed complaints with the Office of Special Counsel.
Andrea Hsu
That's the watchdog agency set up to investigate such complaints.
Steve Inskeep
And their investigation into the USDA found a pattern.
Andrea Hsu
You know, nearly 6,000 people got basically the same letter telling them that they were being fired because of their performance.
Steve Inskeep
All 6,000 people had performance problems?
Andrea Hsu
No, I mean, A, in fact, many of them had excellent performance reviews.
Steve Inskeep
Investigators found the agency didn't even look at their performance, which is a requirement if you're going to fire workers during the probationary period in the federal government.
Andrea Hsu
Instead, the special counsel said the firings appear to be part of an attempt to shrink the government, which administrations can do, but they have to go through a bunch of procedures, including giving people 60 days notice, which the USDA did not do.
Steve Inskeep
Now, the Merit Systems Protection Board reviewed the findings so far, and the board chair concluded, yes, these firings probably were unlawful, and she ordered the USDA to bring back their probationary workers for 45 days so the investigation can continue.
Andrea Hsu
But then last night, there was yet another twist in this case.
Steve Inskeep
The special counsel Hampton Dellinger, who was leading the investigation, was removed from his position for the second time.
Andrea Hsu
President Trump first tried to fire him about a month ago.
Steve Inskeep
A U.S. district judge reinstated him, but now an appeals court has removed him once again while it considers the arguments in his case.
Andrea Hsu
So then what happens with the investigation?
Steve Inskeep
What about all the workers at the other agencies who were fired?
Andrea Hsu
Yeah, it's not entirely clear.
Steve Inskeep
We know that Dellinger had evidence that what happened at USDA had happened at other agencies.
Andrea Hsu
In fact, yesterday he issued a statement urging all agencies to go ahead and reinstate their probationary employees voluntarily and not wait for an order.
Steve Inskeep
Now, how are USDA workers reacting to the news that they're reinstated?
Andrea Hsu
Well, they're not exactly celebrating.
Steve Inskeep
I spoke with Michelle Kirchner, an entomologist who was helping alfalfa growers manage pests when she was fired last month.
Andrea Hsu
And here's what she said.
Michelle Kirchner
I'm feeling kind of yanked around a little bit. I mean, it's good. I'm glad that like something is coming out that what happened wasn't correct and was potentially illegal.
Steve Inskeep
But she says it's impossible to have any confidence in what's going to happen in the long term.
Andrea Hsu
The Trump administration has made clear it wants to dramatically shrink the federal government.
Steve Inskeep
So she thinks maybe they'll all be brought back only to be fired again.
Andrea Hsu
You mentioned the Trump administration. What is the Trump administration saying about all this?
Steve Inskeep
Well, they maintain that they've done nothing illegal.
Andrea Hsu
They've made this case in federal court where there's a lawsuit over probationary firings.
Steve Inskeep
And there's another hearing next week.
Andrea Hsu
And meanwhile, the administration is moving forward with much deeper cuts to federal agencies that will affect career employees, long-time employees.
Steve Inskeep
So a lot more uncertainty is ahead.
Andrea Hsu
All right. That's NPR's Andrea Hsu. Andrea, thanks.
You're welcome.
Music fades in
Steve Inskeep
President Trump is expected to sign executive action directing Education Secretary Linda McMahon to begin dismantling the very agency that she just started leading as of this past Monday.
A. Martinez
The order could come as soon as today.
Steve Inskeep
It's been in the works for weeks, but actually shutting down the department would require congressional approval.
A. Martinez
And that might be tricky as lawmakers, including some Republicans, have expressed concerns about what would happen to federal education funding.
Steve Inskeep
Now, for now, the agency's 4,200 employees face a lot of uncertainty.
A. Martinez
To get more updates on this story, follow us online or tune in to your local NPR station or find us on the NPR app.
Steve Inskeep
And that's a first for Thursday, March 6th.
A. Martinez
I'm E. Martinez.
Steve Inskeep
And I'm Stephen Scape.
A. Martinez
For your next listen, consider, consider this. from NPR News. Up First gives you three big stories of the day, and Consider This dives into a single news story and what it means to you.
Steve Inskeep
Learn about a big story of the day in less than 15 minutes, and you can listen now on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
A. Martinez
Today's episode of Up First was edited by Rylan Barton, Kira Plutoni, Padma Rama, Alice Wolfley, and Mohamed Elbardisi.
Steve Inskeep
It was produced by Ziad Butch, Nia Dumas, and Christopher Thomas.
A. Martinez
We get engineering support from Nisha Hainas.
Steve Inskeep
Our technical director is Carly Strange.
A. Martinez
Join us again tomorrow.
Music fades out
Announcer voice
This message comes from the Nature Conservancy. Nature is common ground for everyone, and uniting to protect nature can help solve today's challenges and create a thriving tomorrow for future generations.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Discover why at nature.org slash NPR.
Music fades out
Announcer voice
Support for NPR and the following message come from USPS.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
With USPS Ground Advantage Service, it's like your shipment has a direct line to you.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
It leaves the dock, you know about it. It's on the road, you know. And when it reaches your customer, you guessed it, you're still in the know.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Here's the real game changer. It's one journey, one partner, total peace of mind.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Check out USPS Ground Advantage Service at usps.com slash in the know.
Music fades out
Announcer voice
Because if you know, you know.
Music fades out
Announcer voice
This message comes from NPR's sponsor, Odoo Business Management Software.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Some say Odoo is like fertilizer because it promotes growth.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Others say it's a magic beanstalk, scaling with efficiency.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Odoo. Exactly what a business needs.
Audio clip plays
Announcer voice
Sign up today at odoo.com.
Music fades out