Main Topic: The podcast episode is an interview with Ta-Nehisi Coates, author of the new book "The Message," which explores the intersection of politics, culture, and place. Coates discusses his journey to three places: Senegal, the American South, and the Middle East, and how these experiences informed his writing.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Ayesha Rascoe
I'm Aisha Roscoe and this is the Sunday Story from Up First. Every Sunday we do something special, going beyond the news of the day to bring you one big story. A decade ago, writer Ta-Nehisi Coates ignited a national conversation with his article in The Atlantic titled The Case for Reparations. A year later, he released his book Between the World and Me, which explores the realities of being Black in America. Now, in his new book, The Message, he takes readers on a journey to three places, Africa, the American South, and the Middle East. He starts in Senegal, where he visits the Door of No Return, a memorial to the victims of the Atlantic slave trade. Then to South Carolina, where his previous book has been the subject of book bans. And finally, to the West Bank, where he found himself reckoning with his own understanding of the conflict there. Ta-Nehisi Coates joins me today.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
Thank you for having me.
Ayesha Rascoe
You start out talking about this book almost as if it's an overdue writing assignment. You promised an essay for a writing workshop and you never got to it. Instead, it feels like the world got this book. Is that really what happened?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I did have an overdue writing assignment. I definitely did. What it was supposed to be was the chapter on Dakar, actually. That second semester I was at Howard, I traveled to Dakar, Senegal. And I had told them, you know, when I got back that I was working on this thing and they were submitting their essays. And so in the spirit of workshopping, I would submit mine and I never got it done.
Ayesha Rascoe
So when did you know that you would do this book?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I've been meditating for some time on the power of literature and art. And I've felt for some time that people have a very, very narrow view of politics and that literature and art actually influence our politics more than we think. I think we forget that, for instance, the infamous Charlottesville rally began with a statue. You know, you can say statues are not very important, but why were these people so inflamed that you had a situation where it rose to the level of the White House and the president at the time and you had somebody that ended up being killed? What was it about that?
Ayesha Rascoe
When you say politics, like when you were looking for this book, did you look for it to be a message ahead of this specific presidential election?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I would imagine, I guess you might say you wanted it to be bigger than that, but people are thinking about the election. They are. I didn't know. Like, I really didn't know at the time. You know, I didn't know what the situation would be. I certainly did not know we would have, you know, a first black woman and a Howard alum, of all people, you know, actually running for president. So that I was not aware of.
Ayesha Rascoe
But were you thinking about maybe Biden-Trump? Were you thinking about that politics?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
So you were thinking of a—what type of politics? But it is. But, Aisha, ultimately it is that. It's just not just that. Okay. You know, what I maintain is that there is a moment where all of us go into, hopefully, all of us, go into a voting booth and we make a choice between candidates. And oftentimes I find that people are somewhat frustrated by the choices they have. Well, they're choices that are being made even before you go into that booth.
Ayesha Rascoe
You remember when you were writing the case for reparations what you thought about all the time over and over again was this Dave Chappelle skit about reparations, where black people get reparations and they go out and they blow it on a bunch of stuff. And I thought that was funny, obviously. But when I thought about writing, one of the things I thought was, like, I have to move reparations out of that idea in the imaginative space that it's just something, you know, just kind of a cash giveaway to black people, which they will then go and waste.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I was thinking culturally even then, even though I was thinking about a political issue.
Ayesha Rascoe
In the book, it also seems to obviously is about culture, but you you take it into like a kind of politics of place or the art of place, culture of place. And maybe I'm trying to sound deep when I said that. But, you know, place can be very important. You go to Senegal, you go to South Carolina, you go to the West Bank and Eastern Jerusalem, Palestine. What is the connective tissue that you found between those places?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
There's a meta aspect to the message where you know on the one hand it is making an argument but on the other hand it tries to demonstrate that argument also and one of the arguments that's made very early in the book is that I believe that the most powerful writing is that writing that clarifies that writing that makes the world tangible. Writing is an abstract art form. You know what I mean? You're talking about words. So how can you use words to make people feel what you feel, to make them feel like they saw what you saw or experience what you experienced?
Ayesha Rascoe
Now I was very fascinated by your journey to Africa to Dakar. You talk about in that essay you talk about the stories that black people were told about their origins, their inferiority, all of this. And then the stories that we tell ourselves to counteract that, you know, where the descendants of royalty, where, you know, all of these things. But then you kind of reject all of that. But then when you get to Senegal, you get to the door of no return, even though you know kind of the truth of it, that likely few enslaved people actually went through that door. You're moved to tears when you're leaving that place. What happened to you there?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I'm still trying to figure that out. Well, yeah, because I was shocked because as a writer, you kept saying in that essay, you didn't have words. I'm like, how you don't have words? You're a writer. What happened, you know, it's so funny, you know, it's like I always tell my students not to say that. But, you know, the message is in many ways an incomplete work. And I think in Africa and in Dakar, like that is where the incompleteness shows itself the most.
Ayesha Rascoe
You talk about in that essay that to base your self-worth as a people, to base your self-esteem on being black or being part of the African diaspora or part of the black diaspora on the same metrics of the people that enslaved you, on the same metrics of the people that ethnically cleansed and genocided this continent, is a mistake. That the worth of a people do not live or the worth of any people, any people in this world cannot live in stone. It cannot live in monuments. It can't even live in great works of writing. That it is in fact self-evident that it's within the bones. It's within the flesh. And so all of this conversation about who we are the descendants of, I need to put ourselves in the shoes of people that did quote unquote great things or made great works is to, in fact, to repeat the mistake.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
And so once you abandon that, what are you left with? What is your relationship to this country? What is your relationship to this continent? And that was really what I was in pursuit of.
Ayesha Rascoe
Because I think it is so complicated as a black American born in this country to go to Africa and to feel, I think often, I haven't been, but I know people will feel a connection. But then there's this push in the pull because people, you know, will say, but you're not from here. You don't know your home here. And I'm sure you've heard of the diaspora wars. You know this. There are black Americans who say, I'm not African. I've never been there. That's not, you know, that's not me.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
So I guess how do you reckon with all that? And what is it to us? What is Africa to you?
Ayesha Rascoe
Yeah, you know, I can't make anybody feel a certain kind of way, you know, and I wouldn't ask anybody. If you don't feel a connection to Africa, that's certainly, you know, your right, you know, and your ability. There's some of us that are, you know, well, basically all of us who are the descendants of slaves, you know, who have ancestry in the south of this country. And we don't feel that either. You know, some of us. So, you know, I think that'll be up to every individual person.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
And by the same token, I didn't go there looking for acceptance necessarily. Or like a kinship or something like that. Well, maybe kinship, but not necessarily acceptance. You know, I didn't show up, you know, like you had to break out the drums for me and say, welcome home, brother. You know, I didn't need that. I didn't need that. You know.
Ayesha Rascoe
What I will say to you is what I found probably the most concrete thing I found was two things. The first thing is and this is out for one trip you know I do want to say that this is the site of my creation as an African-American. My great great great great great great great great grandmothers were taken from this place and on the water and then in the plantations of this country here, we were genocided and created into a new people. But the process begins there. The great epic that I rooted myself in, the great Black American epic, the great Black diasporic epic, I was at the origin point. That was deeply moving. That was incredibly, incredibly moving.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
So moving that, you know, what I would say is if there was one flaw in the trip I took, I don't know that I saw the people. I certainly didn't see enough of them. What I saw was ghosts. You know what I mean? What I saw was, you know, visions of myself and to some extent America. But by the same token, I mean, it's very, very hard to capture a place or capture the complexity of a place, you know, in one trip in three or four days.
Ayesha Rascoe
You got to go. I got to go one day. I got to go.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
And you also go to South Carolina. You talk about a teacher who risked her job to keep teaching your book Between the World and Me. And this is where you get into book bans and censorship. And I mean, that's kind of like politics having an impact on art, art impacting politics. But you say in one passage that much of the hoopla about book bans and censorship gets it wrong. What do we get wrong?
Oh, so much. I mean, I can't remember what exactly I was talking about in that passage. But I think the first thing I would say off the top is that I, as the writer and the author of the book, I am not the victim. You were saying that. You were saying it's not personal. So you don't take it personally. It's not. You are not being victimized. I don't. And I'm also not the person that's going to suffer. I mean, every time one of these articles come out, I mean, to be frank about it, I sell more books. So I think like my personal offense you know and to make it about me misses the point. The people that are hurt the people that are really hurt are the children and the students there and I and and they're not necessarily hurt because they they they need to be exposed to you know my voice or my books you know or whatever or they need to adopt my politics or my particular view of the world.
Ayesha Rascoe
But you do think that writing catches it more than even other forms of media? Because you would think with the Internet and all these things, that would be much more dangerous than the writing.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
No, the writing is extremely dangerous. And the books in particular are very dangerous. And again, this is like one of the reasons why I wrote the message, because I don't think we perceive this. In fact, I think the people who are in favor of book bans understand the power of books much, much better than those that oppose them. Books are an intimate art form. You know, I write about this in the message. Books are intimate. It's a one-on-one connection. So that kid in South Carolina, that 15-year-old, 16-year-old kid is taking Between the World and Me or whatever other book they're reading. They're taking it into their bedroom and they're having a connection with them that nobody else can actually perceive.
Ayesha Rascoe
Do you fear the book bans and what they are trying to or what is being accomplished through these sorts of actions?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
Do I fear them? Yeah, do you fear them? Do you feel like? I don't know if I fear them. I don't know that I fear them. But I do think people's worlds can be closed. And I guess I fear that. More than I fear the book bans, I fear an effort to close the minds of young people in this country.
Ayesha Rascoe
When we come back, we discuss the part of his book that has everyone talking. Stay with us.
Announcements and sponsor messages
The longest essay in the book is on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. And that's the one that's going to get the most attention. It's likely the one that will have the most impact on you. Why did you choose to delve into this topic, which is one of the most, if not the most, fraught topic of public discourse today?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
Well, the fact was probably my most celebrated work of journalism is the case for reparations. And whether I liked it or not, or whether I thought much about it or not, I had already delved into it. That essay has a section in which it talks about reparations from the state of Germany to the state of Israel as recompense for the survivors of the Holocaust or those fleeing the Holocaust, in fact, fleeing Nazi Germany's existential violence to Israel. Reparations for that is used as an example. And I was roundly and sometimes loudly critiqued for using that as an example. And I had to reckon with that.
Ayesha Rascoe
Do you feel like journalists are naive in their coverage of the conflict?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I think we have a structural problem. I've been able to get these numbers and maybe at some point I would but I would be very interested, for instance, in the number of Palestinians who are working in the bureaus of major newspapers, major magazines, major stations in Jerusalem. I'd be very interested in that. I'd be frankly interested in how many Black people are. I would like to know that. I think we are getting a certain perspective of the world, of that conflict, that originates in people who don't always have direct experience and what it feels like to be deprived of your ability to determine your future while another group of people who only live walking distance away have that power.
Ayesha Rascoe
Ultimately, what do you want the message of this book to be for those that read it? What do you want this to say about you? Because in the book, you said each of your books represent a part of you and a version of you. So what does the—your child. So what is the message? Is the message that child that went out and got kicked out of school because she took it too far? Who is the message?
Ta-Nehisi Coates
I don't know yet. I don't know yet. I mean, that remains to be seen because the book just came out. What I do know is this. It is a book that is concerned with the world that is not here and is not necessarily directly present in our lives. What I mean by that is the message is very, very much concerned with the tradition of black writing and with the black freedom struggle and thus my ancestors who came before me. And it is very, very deeply, deeply concerned with that generation of writers, black, white or otherwise, who have not yet come.
Ayesha Rascoe
That tradition means something. It represents something. It calls on us to do things and to say things and to write things. And those things will not always be convenient. I think about the moment, and I talk about this, I've talked about this before, before I took my trip to Palestine. And I was going with a friend who's a writer also, and I was thinking about how scared I was. Not that anything would happen to me, but I just had this, like, feeling that I'm going to see something, and when I come back, I will not be the same. And I didn't want to go. But I thought about Ida B. Wells with a price on her head going through the South reporting on lynching. And I thought about Frederick Douglass telling his story of enslavement while his own relatives were enslaved at that moment. And he himself had a price on his head. And I said, you know, me and my friend, we said to each other, what right do we have to our fears? We have promises to keep.
And this is a book about my promises that I have to keep to the stories I heard when I was over there. And to, as I said, my ancestors who came before me and to the writers who are yet to come.
Ta-Nehisi Coates
Ta-Nehisi Coates, he is the author of The Message. Thank you so much for joining us.
Ayesha Rascoe
Thank you for having me.
This episode of The Sunday Story was produced by Martin Patience and Andrew Mambo. It was edited by Ed McNulty and Liana Simstrom. The engineer was James Willits. The rest of the Sunday Story team includes Justine Yan and Jenny Schmidt. Irene Noguchi is our executive producer. I'm Aisha Roscoe. Up first, we'll be back tomorrow with all the news you need to start your week. Have a great rest of your weekend.