Main Topic: The podcast episode explores the history and evolution of the US Constitution's amendments, specifically focusing on the Second and First Amendments, as well as the lesser-known Third Amendment.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Aisha Roscoe
Hey, a quick word before the show. The presidential election is over, but we're still here for reliable information in the next few months and beyond. Across NPR, we explain the biggest stories and fact-check misinformation so you can keep a grip on what's happening. If that sounds valuable to you, please help make it possible. Go to donate.npr.org to support NPR. If you're already a supporter, we're taking this moment to say thank you. That's donate.npr.org.
I'm Aisha Roscoe, and this is a Sunday story from Up First. Every Sunday we do something special. We go beyond the news of the day to bring you one big story. So, I want to tell you about this moment when I discovered something basic about how this country works. I'm in this big hotel in New York, thank you very much, everybody. We've had a great three days at the United Nations in New York. Donald Trump is president, it's his first term, and he's having a concluding press conference. And this is quite a gathering. Wow. It's a lot of people. A lot of media. Just a few days earlier, there had been a big, splashy article with reporting that Trump's Deputy Attorney General, Rod Rosenstein, had talked about invoking the 25th Amendment to remove President Trump from office.
So I raised my hand. Yes, ma'am. Yes, go ahead. Because that's how you got his attention. Mr. President, you have another meeting tomorrow with Rod Rosenstein. Are you planning to fire Rod Rosenstein? I'm talking to him. We've had a good talk. He said he never said it. He said he doesn't believe it. He said he has a lot of respect for me, and he was very nice, and we'll see. So you don't think anyone in your administration has ever discussed using the 25th Amendment against you? I don't think so. Well, yeah, enemies, sure. You use anything you can. Within your administration or your cabinet? It's really remarkable that I was asking a sitting president about use of the 25th Amendment against him.
The 25th Amendment had originally been written after the assassination of John F. Kennedy. It made lawmakers wonder, what if he had been shot and stayed alive? Like, what if he'd been comatose? What if he was brain dead? Who would be president? It made them realize there was no process laid out about how to remove an unfit president from office. So they added it in the 25th Amendment. And now in 2018, those same few words added to the Constitution about how to remove an unfit president were taking on a whole new meaning. And we weren't just talking about health. If you think about it, the U.S. Constitution is really kind of a wild document. It was written over 200 years ago, but it's not stuck in the past. It continues to guide our everyday life. It's the architecture of this country. And the amendments, that's kind of how we remodel, you know, fix up the kitchen or whatever.
In that moment, I felt just how strange that can be. That a few words written decades ago were being applied to a situation so far from their original intent. There's no way that the writers of those words could have imagined it. Right now, we're in a moment of political change. And so I thought it might be grounding and helpful to remind ourselves of our political foundations. Where do the amendments come from and how do they evolve, if they evolve at all? I'm joined by the host of NPR's History Podcast, ThruLine.
Rund Abdel Fattah and Ramteen Arablui are currently doing a series on every single amendment. They're six in, 21 to go. Rund and Ramteam, thank you for being here. Thanks for having us. Thanks for having us. So I understand that you've been making a series with one episode on every single amendment. And that's a big commitment. Why did you want to do that?
Rund Abdel Fattah
To start off, we called the series We the People. And that's a good summary of why we wanted to do it. Those are the first words of the Constitution. But it's also the heart of the series, because really what's behind each of these amendments is people and their stories. And what we're really looking at is how words on the page that were written, in some cases 200 years ago, in some cases more recently, but how they manifest in real life and the struggle, the very real struggle, the difficult struggle that we have faced with each one of these amendments to adapt and understand it as the country and the world changes, you know, sometimes in extreme ways.
Aisha Roscoe
And that's what makes them so relevant right now, right? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think it's easy to think about these things that were some of them written down more than 200 years ago and say, well, that doesn't apply to me or that sounds really boring and dry and abstract. And I think what this series is doing is bringing the amendments to life and making you realize just how relevant they are to us right now in this moment.
Okay, so before we go any further, I want to say, you know, I've covered government for a long time, covered the White House, did a whole bunch of stuff. I know the amendments exist, but if you said, tell me about what's number 22. I don't know. Tell me what number eight is. Baby, don't ask. I don't know. So let's stop right here and say, OK, where do the amendments come from? Why do we have them? Talk to me about how these amendments came about.
Rund Abdel Fattah
So let's go back to 1787. So at this point, the British have been defeated. The U.S. has established its independence, and now the original 13 states have this massive assignment in front of them. They have to write a document that establishes a stronger central government that they can all agree on. And this all happened in Hamilton, right? Yes, Hamilton's going to be a part of the story. Yeah, yeah. He's coming up. Okay. Don't get me started. Don't get me started on this. Yeah, please don't get him started, actually. All right. So the representatives of those states get together. They got their wigs on and and they're arguing a lot. Right. And the kind of key debate that is raging between them is on one side, your guy, Alexander Hamilton and the federalists who he represents are saying the federal government needs power to unify 13 diverse states. So they are in favor of a strong federal government. Right. On the other side, you have anti-federalists, which you can imagine what that means. They don't want a strong federal government because they just fought the Revolutionary War, right, theoretically to get out of the grips of a strong central government.
And finally, the anti-federalists say we will ratify the Constitution if, they put this condition, we can also have a Bill of Rights. And that Bill of Rights explicitly would state the powers of people to protect them from the government. And these rights become the first 10 amendments. So I think it's important to point out here that those first 10 amendments were a political compromise. So there was an ambiguity built into the language. And this is intentional, right? They want it to be able to be open to interpretation and open to change. And today we're still arguing about those interpretations. But it is actually kind of by design that that space, that sort of liminal space of understanding is built into it.
Aisha Roscoe
It sounds like we are in the extension of a debate that's been going on for 200 years. Once you started looking into the histories of these amendments, how does like that shiftiness of interpretation or the ambiguity that you talked about show up? One of the big ones that we talk about a lot today is the Second Amendment, which listeners may know has to do with the right to bear arms. Today, given the major place it has in our discourse, anyone would be forgiven for thinking that this has always been the case. But the reality is the Second Amendment was a big issue in our national discourse for more than 100 years basically after it passed.
Rund Abdel Fattah
There were actually very rarely court cases about it. It was almost never used to challenge laws. And the story of how it went from this kind of sleepy amendment no one really talked about to the political lightning rod that it is today is really, really wild. I want to transport us for a second to the Great Depression era. So on a dusty road in 1934 is where this kind of pivot, this change to the Second Amendment becoming a big issue begins. And actually, here's where we can play a clip from the episode that really paints a picture of what that moment was.
Clip plays
This group of guys with weapons basically go to one bank across the street, rob that bank, then go to another one before the police can get there. Oh my goodness. There's a movie Road to Perdition maybe some people remember with Tom Hanks. It's a good movie. It's right out of that, right? It's right out of a film. And they basically almost got away with it. But eventually, one of the robbers, a guy named Jack Miller, he's caught and he's brought in for questioning. He actually snitches on his fellow bank robbers, the other folks that took part in this, and cut some kind of deal, basically. And he gets off. Like, he's let go. He's released.
Okay. So, okay, he's off right there, but here's where it gets interesting. Joseph Blocher, he's a constitutional law professor at Duke. He actually told us this story. And he says a couple years after that bank heist. Jack Miller, wouldn't you know it, April of 1938, gets pulled over, and it's found to be in possession of an unregistered sawed-off shotgun. He's arrested again. What was he doing with that? Okay, so one note. This is the time, again, Great Depression, gangs, organized large gangs, including the mafia, are really big in the U.S. at this point. And one of the weapons of choice was a sawed-off shotgun. Why? Because it's easy to conceal, it's small, and it packs a really big punch, right? So he had what was generally known as a gang member's weapon. It was used in organized crime.
Was it illegal or it just was unregistered? It was unregistered, which made it illegal. The National Firearms Act from that time required sawed-off shotguns to be registered since they were so popular for criminals. And Jack Miller's, well, that one was definitely not registered. So he gets caught, right? And up to this point, the Second Amendment was generally interpreted, if it was at all, to essentially mean that local militias had the right to bear arms to stand up to the federal army. But Jack Miller decides to fight his case by making a new argument that the Second Amendment doesn't just apply to militias, but it also gives individuals the right to own a gun, which should sound familiar to all of us today.
Here's Joseph Blocher. He says the Second Amendment protects my right to have this sawed-off shotgun. And I think to some people's surprise, a district judge agrees with them and says, actually, yeah, the Second Amendment protects not just the sort of well-regulated organized militia, but even an individual like you, Jack Miller, your right to have a gun. And so the judge orders Jack Miller released. So this is the first time that this idea is tested in court, basically that the Second Amendment also gives rights to the individual. And that's because of this former bank robber?
Yeah, exactly. So this person who had robbed banks, we can assume he was still involved in some level and gang activity or the things he was involved with before. Well, somebody was out to get him because he snitched on him. So he had to carry the saw it off, you know, just in case. Exactly. He was packing for a reason, right? Well, OK, so he gets off. The court agrees with him. So he gets off again. But then the case goes all the way up to the Supreme Court. The judges rule unanimously that Jack Miller did not, in fact, have a right to a sawed-off shotgun. They went with a continuing kind of interpretation that the Second Amendment has to do with a militia. But it didn't stay that way, right? Obviously. No, yeah, and we're going to get to that.
But what I think is really fascinating about this is that it shows that the interpretation of the Second Amendment, or frankly, any amendment, is a living thing. It happens within a context of the moment. So a political, socioeconomic context. And at that time, with gangs being viewed, at least by the federal government, as a big problem in the United States and the U.S. being in the midst of this economic freefall, the idea was that they wanted to kind of put a stop to what they viewed as rampant crime. So perhaps that influenced the ruling. And that is something we really took in from this case.
Aisha Roscoe
After the break, the Second Amendment takes a big turn. This message comes from BetterHelp. President Fernando Madeira describes how BetterHelp online therapy has helped him. For me, sometimes I just need to go and talk to somebody that is not going to judge me, right? It's going to be there and they're going to listen to me. And I can start just saying, look, I'm not feeling right today. And it feels natural. I love it. To get matched with a therapist, visit BetterHelp.com slash NPR for 10% off your first month.
This message comes from NPR sponsor Adobe. Introducing the all-new Adobe Acrobat Studio, now with AI-powered PDF spaces. Need to turn 100 pages of market research into five insights with a click? Templates for a sales proposal that'll close that deal? Or an AI specialist to tailor the tone of your market report? You can do all that with the all-new Adobe Acrobat Studio. Learn more at adobe.com slash do that with Acrobat.
This message comes from NPR sponsor AARP. Where do you see your career in 12 years? What are you doing now to help you get there? The sooner you start enhancing your skills, the sooner you'll be ready. That's why AARP has management, finance, and small business reskilling courses, all to help your income live as long as you do. Because the steps you choose to take today will help you love what you do in the future. Learn more at aarp.org slash skills.
We're back with the host of ThruLine on the surprising past, present, and future of America's amendments. When we left off earlier, you were telling me about the double-crossing bank heist story behind the Second Amendment. Yeah. Let's keep going. Like, where is that story now? Because it didn't end there, right? It did not. But interestingly, it took a very long time for it to change again. So like you said, we left off with Jack Miller. He had this sawed off shotgun and he made the case that he had the right to have this gun. The Supreme Court at the time disagreed and it took all the way until 2008 for it to change again.
Rund Abdel Fattah
And the context of that is that many judges on the court started at that time to interpret these amendments through the lens of something called originalism. And what that means is the originalists believe the Constitution should be interpreted based on the meaning of its words at the time that it was ratified. So basically, whatever they meant then is how we should interpret it now. So then in 2008, a case comes before the Supreme Court called D.C. v. Heller. The Supreme Court, in a very close decision that was authored by Justice, the late Justice Antonin Scalia, looked back at 18th century dictionaries. They even went back to English common law from the 1700s to argue that in the original text, The founders actually intended the Second Amendment to mean that this right isn't just for militias, but for individuals too.
And that ruling ushered in the modern form of the Second Amendment that we know today, which really is just 16 years old, which really affirms the right for individuals to own weapons, for self-defense, for other reasons, and rejects this idea that it has to be for a militia. That's interesting because I think a lot of people would think that, oh, this has been decided you know long ago and not something so recent. That right. And it sounds like with this sort of interpretation this kind of originalism it treats the founders almost as prophets or oracles And you have to like, OK, when they said this word, what did they mean? Like it's treating it as something that is written in stone. That's right.
I would imagine, though, that would be very hard considering a lot has changed since the 1700s and 1800s. Yes. It's a very different world. They didn't know about Facebook or cell phones or. Or frankly, the types of weapons that are available. Yes. Right. You know, that was written during a time where people were using muskets, very basic weapons that, of course, are dangerous. But today we have weapons that are far more lethal and far more effective in killing people. So I will say this. I think the originalists would make the argument that veering too far from the amendments gets away from their original 10. And that basically if the Constitution doesn't fit our present moment, that what we should do is just pass new amendments rather than kind of reinterpret existing amendments to fit the moment.
But I do think it's fair at the same time to point out, like you said, things are changing. Our society is way more complicated than it used to be. And that applying the rule, you know, let's say an amendment from the 1700s in the way that they intended today may miss a lot of the complicating factors. It's something that the court still hasn't worked out in a lot of ways. And our society still hasn't worked out. And I think it's going to be an ongoing struggle for years to come.
Aisha Roscoe
What I find really interesting here is that some amendments seem really clear. And then there are others like the Second Amendment and, of course, the First Amendment that are just the source of endless debates. So moving on, let's talk about the First Amendment. How's the right that it guarantees freedom of speech been interpreted and reinterpreted over the years? Well, first, I mean, there was a disagreement about what it meant from the very beginning. So the amendment says, among other things, Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech. And at first glance, that seems clear, right? But even seven years later, after that was passed, Congress actually passed a law that prohibited speech that criticized the federal government.
And so, as you can see, immediately they started eating away at the idea because it's really tricky, right? On the one hand, you want to protect people from harm. On the other hand, you want to maintain free expression and free exchange of ideas, etc. All the things we hold to be sort of important in the U.S. So the courts have to decide where does potentially dangerous speech become speech that causes real harm? And when is it worth stepping in? And so over the years, their decisions have shifted and shifted again. Let me tell you two pivotal moments, two stories that have shaped free speech rights today.
The first is in 1919, while the Red Scare was in full swing, an activist named Anita Whitney gave a speech for the Communist Labor Party and was promptly arrested. Her case actually later landed in the Supreme Court where the justices upheld her conviction and applied an argument about free speech that would remain the precedent or the standard for decades. And that is basically that speech can be prohibited when it poses a clear and present danger. This test actually gives the government a lot of leeway to limit people's free speech, right? Because it's vague. Like in this case, Whitney wasn't calling for immediate violence, but she was still perceived as a threat by the state because of her relationship with the Communist Party, which obviously did threaten to violently overthrow the U.S. government.
And that was enough to regulate. But then in another story, in 1969, the limits of free speech became a lot more specific. Marianne Franks actually told us this story. She's a law professor at the University of Miami. And it starts when a Ku Klux Klan leader named Clarence Brandenburg held a rally in Ohio. And at this rally, he's in full Klan regalia speaking to all of these other hooded individuals and says, if the white race continues to be oppressed by the president and Congress and the Supreme Court, we may have to take, and he calls it revengeance. And during that rally, they then burn across and they're carrying weapons. They're using anti-Black, anti-Semitic slurs. It's pretty clear that it's meant to be threatening and intimidating.
And the broadcast of the speech is not just played on local news, but it makes national news. So everybody really has the chance to hear it. So Brandenburg is actually convicted in Ohio for that speech. And that case is then challenged and it travels all the way up to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court, in a surprise ruling, essentially says that they're going to introduce a new test, a test that we still use today to determine when speech has gone from free speech to something illegal. Here's Marianne Franks again. It says you can't prohibit people's speech unless the speaker intended really to incite imminent lawless action. That is pretty much has to happen immediately. And it has to be really likely that that lawlessness is going to happen.
Well, that sounds like a very narrow interpretation of what can be prohibited. I mean, the KKK was actually extremely violent. I mean, they were a terrorist organization. I mean, the objective facts totally bear that out, right? Which shows you just how big of a shift this was from the Anita Whitney case. In a period where there was just so much fear about communism, the government decided it could restrict speech that even vaguely threatened violence. But by the time we get to Brandenburg in 1969, the court gives his very threatening speech way more protection. So you can only regulate it if it creates an immediate threat. And that's the standard we actually live with today.
And you see this issue even playing out today. I mean, when you think about Charlottesville, Virginia in 2017, there was a rally that took place. There were white supremacists there carrying flags with Nazi emblems, weapons. Shouting racist chants, and one counter-protester was hit by a car and killed. So even this speech that is hate speech is still protected, though, right? Yeah, I mean, with that example, a clear distinction that the hate speech on its own was constitutionally protected, right? Going out with those emblems, weapons, even the shouting of racist chants. But organizing inciting violence that is not protected under the constitution and and so the Charlottesville organizers were allowed to march but they were ultimately sued for conspiring to commit violence that was the charge against them not for the views and speech itself.
I think it's also really interesting how social media is factoring into the question of free speech right now because it's raising really big questions that are making it even more complicated, right? As it stands, these rules apply online too. But there's a big question that's currently under debate around whether social media companies hold any responsibility. At the moment, they're completely exempt, but new First Amendment cases might change that soon.
After the break, a forgotten amendment makes its case. On the TED Radio Hour podcast, Astro Teller leads Alphabet's secret lab behind successful projects like self-driving cars and high-profile flops like Google Glass. We were too, too early in that case. The CEO of Alphabet's Moonshot Factory on innovation and getting the timing right. Listen on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Peter Sagal. NPR is very serious. Mostly. It treats newsmakers with all due respect, almost all the time. It brings you the most important information about the issues that really matter, usually. And it never asks famous people about things they don't know anything about, except once in a while. Join us for the great exception. Listen to Wait, Wait, Don't Tell Me, the news quiz from NPR.
This message comes from Ritual. What makes Ritual vitamins different? Ritual vitamins are made with bioavailable, clinically studied key ingredients and a patented nutrient delivery system. Thank you nutrients you getting Ritual essential multivitamins are made with you and your body in mind and backed by scientific research filled with key ingredients as well as the essence of mint so you can enjoy taking your vitamins. Get 25% off your first purchase when you visit ritual.com slash NPR.
We're back with the Sunday story talking constitutional amendments. So some amendments, like the First and Second Amendments, they're political lightning rods. You hear about them all the time. But there are other amendments that are rarely mentioned, almost forgotten. Like, did you learn anything surprising about these kind of dustier, less well-known amendments? Oh, yeah, absolutely. I think, you know, while they're not all political firestorms, you realize just how important some of those dustier amendments actually are.
And one example that a lot of it was surprising to me as we were working on this episode was the Third Amendment. If you've heard of it at all, it's probably been as a punchline to a joke. I take the third all the time, every day. And then if somebody tries to call me on it, they go, well, what is the third? That's when I take the fifth. It's the one about quartering troops, two words that have probably been rarely said side by side since about the late 1700s. But here's what it actually says. Amendment number three. No soldier shall, in time of peace, be quartered in any house without the consent of the owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.
So in more modern terms. The army can't live in your house. Yeah. So the army can't live in your house. Nowadays in 2024, right? It feels really out of place because it's like, obviously the army can't live in your house. But when the Bill of Rights was written, Tom Bell, he's a law professor at Chapman University and he's kind of obsessed with the Third Amendment. He said that the Third Amendment was the amendment everyone agreed on. Remember I mentioned the Federalists, the Anti-Federalists, there was a lot they disagreed on. Well, you know, at the time coming off of the Revolutionary War, there was a common practice that the army would stay in people's homes, sometimes forcefully, and they'd eat their food, you know, they'd sleep in their beds.
And so this group of men at the time in the late 1700s looked into the future and thought, this is a critical right. Top three, right? It's the third amendment so clearly at the time it was really important and obviously pretty common um it's it's interesting though even like listening to that language of like quartering in your house it feels like that third amendment is sort of stuck in time and it's you know been barely litigated actually has never made it up to the supreme court and tom bell explained to us that amendments they're not just about the text that's written on paper right what keeps them relevant, as we've been pointing out, is how they get interpreted and applied by the courts.
So it's very easy to look at the third and say, oh, yeah, interesting historical artifact is not relevant now. And I thought that, too. And then I started doing research and I discovered the third has been violated in American history time and again, repeatedly. During the War of 1812, the Civil War, World War II. But to the shame of my profession, no lawyer anywhere seems to have noticed, hey, this is a corner of troops during time of war and Congress isn't telling us how to do it. This is pretty plainly a violation of the Third Amendment. As far as I can tell, no lawyer noticed it then. So, so much for our constitutional rights. I mean, it's wonderful they're written down, but if nobody gets up and defends them, they are not even worth the paper they're written on.
I think that's a powerful, right? If nobody gets up and defends them, they are not even worth the paper they're written on. So he's really saying, you know, unless people take it up and have these debates and talk about them and challenge them, right? That's where the actual power of the amendments comes from. And he says, you know, while it hasn't been applied very much yet, he says it could become relevant again with more National Guard deployments for things like climate disasters, you know, hurricanes and things like that, or government responses to large protests. Knowing this amendment exists could actually be an important backstop to protect citizens from more chaos in times of chaos.
The first 10 amendments, the Bill of Rights, they were ratified shortly after the Constitution. But now, as you know, we've said, we're up to 27 amendments. Do you have a sense of whether more amendments could be added to the Constitution? I don't have a crystal ball, but what I will say is the last time we ratified an amendment was 1992. And actually right now, it seems like we're in a moment where there's a lot of resistance to adding new amendments. I'm thinking about things like the Equal Rights Amendment or an amendment that would secure abortion rights. These are things that people have pushed and these efforts have failed.
And it's also partly because it's very difficult to pass an amendment in terms of numbers. It takes two-thirds of the majority in both houses, House and the Senate, to propose a new amendment. And then it takes three-fourths of the states to ratify something new. And, like, can you think of anything the states in this country right now agree on enough? And if there's one thing it seems like amendments need, it's agreement. Yeah, and, you know, I will say that process often looks messy. It's often not linear. And I think it's tempting to look at that and say, well, the system is broken. But one of the things, you know, in looking at these amendments that's come through for me is that understanding that the questioning, the interpreting, the reinterpreting is part of the design actually makes you realize that maybe this is actually exactly how it's meant to work.
Maybe it's an indication that the system is working and those checks and balances that push-pulls is actually a part of the process. When we think about the fact, though, that we haven't had a new amendment in decades and that there is this conversation right now where some people say we shouldn't amend the Constitution anymore. The thing I'm thinking about is that, you know, as the world continues to change, arguably faster than ever, and looking back over the last 200 or so years, when it seems like the moments that the amendments changed or were added happened at those times of extreme technological and political change, it raises the question, what is going to be the role of amendments, new and old, in the future?
To learn more about the evolution of America's founding document and what it says about us, subscribe to the ThruLine podcast. So far, they've looked at six amendments in their We the People series, with more to come. This episode of The Sunday Story was produced by Kim Naderfane Petersa, with help from Sarah Wyman. It was edited by Jenny Schmidt. Special thanks to Julie Kane, Senior Supervising Editor of ThruLine. Kwesi Lee mastered the episode and Kevin Vocal did the fact-checking. The Sunday Story team includes Andrew Mambo, Justine Yan, and our Supervising Senior Producer, Liana Simstrom. Irene Noguchi is our Executive Producer. I'm Aisha Roscoe. Up First is back tomorrow with all the news you need to start your week. Until then, have a great rest of your weekend.
Hey, it's Rachel Martin. I'm the host of Wildcard from NPR. For a lot of my years as a radio host, silence sort of made me nervous. That pause before an answer, because you don't know what's going on on the other side of the mic. But these days, I love it. Hmm. Ah. Gosh. Give me a minute. Yeah, yeah. Think. Listen to the Wildcard podcast only from NPR.
Here at LifeKit, we take advice seriously. We bring you evidence-based recommendations. And to do that, we talk with researchers and experts on all sorts of topics. Because we have the same questions you do. Like, what's really in my shampoo? Or should I let my kid quit soccer? Or what should I do with my savings in uncertain economic times? You can listen to NPR's Life Kit in the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts.
World news is important, but it can feel far away. Not on the State of the World podcast. With journalists around the world, you'll hear firsthand the effects of U.S. trade actions in Canada and China and meet a Mexican street sweeper who became a pop star. We don't go around the world, we're already there. Listen to the State of the World podcast from NPR every weekday.