Follow the crew:
https://twitter.com/DavidSacks
Follow the pod:
https://twitter.com/theallinpod
https://linktr.ee/allinpodcast
Invest with the Best... ies!:
https://www.thesyndicate.com/allin
Referenced in the show:
NYT - The Rich Kids Who Want to Tear Down Capitalism
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/27/style/trust-fund-activism-resouce-generation.html
Coinbase - An upcoming story about Coinbase
https://blog.coinbase.com/upcoming-story-about-coinbase-2012afc25d27
NYT - 'Tokenized': Inside Black Workers' Struggles at the King of Crypto Start-Ups
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/27/technology/coinbase-cryptocurrency-black-employees.html
Show Notes:
0:00 Besties intro, fashion talk & the All-In Syndicate
3:47 Insights on Slack being acquired by Salesforce for $27.7B - why did they sell, are there any nitpicks, was this a home run for Salesforce?
19:14 Sacks on going up against Marc Benioff and Salesforce Chatter while at Yammer, importance of holding onto winners as long as possible
27:26 Why is DeepMind's AlphaFold a major breakthrough? When will it begin impacting drug discovery? Dangers of AI at scale
47:07 Republican party misfires, Georgia runoff implications, can Trump pre-pardon his family, Biden's effective strategy so far
59:21 Trump's Section 230 gambit, will Trumpism fade away?
1:05:23 Trust Fund socialists
1:26:14 Coinbase vs. NYT round 2, https://www.thesyndicate.com/allin
No summary for this episode yet.
Okay, besties are back. Besties are back going around the horn. Rain man David Sachs calling in from an undisclosed location, suffering through two code 13s in one lifetime. And David Friedberg is here, the queen of quinoa, spacking everything in sight, living the life, calling in from a nondescript Ritz-Carlton room, it appears to be. And of course, the dictator himself, chamath palihapitiya cackling like a fool welcome back everybody this is what you pay for with your subscription to the all-in podcast brought to you by slack uh if you didn't own slack shares raise your hand it's been an incredible uh week um on a number of levels we're going to talk this week about uh salesforce buying slack trump and section 230 uh the coinbase the ongoing coinbase saga uh freeberg found some interesting science that could save humanity and of course the trust fund socialists in the new york times who hate their parents for giving them money uh let's start off let's start with off the most important thing what is that shirt undershirt combo you're wearing I mean, look, you have buttons on buttons.
Did I break the layering rule? You can't. If you're going to layer properly, you can have only one layer of buttons. But to have two layers of buttons. That's not how it works? No, J. Cal went in and got an almond. I don't know. Layers are for players, not me. No, he got like an almond milk cappuccino. And he's like, I like how that barista dress is. And I'm going to wear that from now on. Wait a second. Can I ask a technical question? Can I have buttons? I can't have buttons on buttons, but can I have buttons and then a zipper up like with the... No, you can't do that either. Listen. Chamath has had a weird aversion to buttons ever since he spent the time in Italy.
Was he button shamed in Italy? I was a little button shamed, but I'm looking at Saks has buttons on his collars, which just makes no sense. Saks is wearing the same Brooks Brothers shirt that he graduated high school in. at brooks he owns 17 of brooks brothers at this point from the number of blazers he's bought there all right let's get off to it we've insulted each other i don't think freeberg's taken the brunt of anything yet anybody have any uh chop busting they want to do with freeberg or is that just sort of built in no freeberg took the tablecloth that i use for a picnic in the summertime and made it into a shirt you know you have to be frugal at this time and also freeberg cares about the environment.
He's not going to just land a picnic. What was it? It was a hemp-based tablecloth. And so I knew it was going to get taken and stolen. I love how I choose to spend my time with you guys. It just pays off. Here we go. All right. Can we kick this off? All right. Let's kick it off with our advertisement for nobody because Chabot will not let me make any money off of this podcast. And thanks again for the suggestion that we launch a syndicate with no carry. Now a bunch of dipshits on Twitter are like, hey, when is the all-in syndicate starting? I'm like, never. I need to make a living. I need to get my beak wet.
And this week- I'm sorry, but I think an all-in syndicate would be super, super disruptive and cool. I'm totally fine with running it as long as we can have the 20% carry, and I'll manage the whole thing. We got four people on the call. We each get 5% carry, but we got to make a living here. Not everybody's made it, Chamath. Not everybody's got SPACs A through Z. or had all of their Slack shares bought. I think we'll kick it off with that. Chamath, we saw this week, in fact, just two days ago, Salesforce in a record transaction for a SaaS company, I think it's the highest ever paid for a SaaS company, $27 billion, $27.
7 billion for Slack, which has only been public for just over a year, I think. You were, I think, did the Series B in Slack right after they did the pivot at Social Capital. I don't know if that was in front one or two, but Phil Helmuth keeps talking about it. It was a series B in tiny spec, but it was the series A in Slack. And there's a really important story, which is that myself and Ray Coe, who's my partner at Social Capital, we've worked together now for, my gosh, I think it's probably 15 years, wrote a really great memo justifying the investment in Slack. And it had to do with one thing and one thing only.
We ignored the revenue and ARR. I mean, it was fine and nice and good. But the single biggest thing that we were attracted to was something that we looked at and which was called intercompany edges. And even back in 2015 or 16, when we did this original investment, there was this dynamic where people across companies were communicating via Slack channels. And I was completely stunned by this idea, because that was effectively a substitution for email. Because the only way you communicate across companies today is by email, you know, David is at craft ventures.com. And he emails me at social capital.
com. And I email Jason at inside.com. That's how we communicate across across businesses, except now all of a sudden, you could be messaging and having a much more real time interface. that to me was incredibly disruptive and it justified the entirety of the real forward looking investment thesis now fast forward five years later and these guys have more usage on a daily basis than facebook which is stunning because you know these guys have 10 million dAUs and facebook has 2 billion so it just goes to show you the quantity of traffic and and the the volume of information and theoretically you know productivity that's happening on slack and so So I'm not sure what Salesforce bought.
I actually think that you can make a case why it's a shame that it got bought, a very strong one, in fact. But what they did get, whether they know it or not, is an intercompany edge effect, which is the most disruptive thing to email. And in the hands of Salesforce and that sales team, I think it has the ability to really be a very disruptive force for good in enterprise software. All right. So, Saks, this is a natural passing of the ball to you and the baton because you did Yammer, sold it to Microsoft for a billion dollars. And obviously, Slack was the mobile successor to the desktop version of Yammer.
And you got a lot of your fingerprints all over this. But the fact is, you did a tweet storm about it. Slack is an unbelievable success. Stuart is a great founder. You know, it sold the first company Flickr for $30 million. This one for almost $30 billion. So that's pretty nice. But there was one failure. And you pointed out in your tweet, Storm, explain what the one failure, if you could pick out of the hundreds of things, thousands of things they did right, there was one thing they did wrong that, to Chamath's point, would have resulted in them remaining an independent company that could have become worth more than $27 billion.
Yeah, it was a slowness to embrace the idea of enterprise sales. And by the way, let's put this in context. I mean, Stuart and the Slack team did a phenomenal job, $30 billion exit, seven years of just about flawless execution. so i don't want to and also you know i was an investor in the company so thank you to stuart for letting me invest i'm definitely don't want to sound like an ingrate or a critic i mean they just they did a phenomenal job but if you were to nitpick just one one little thing that i think they could have done faster it would have been embracing enterprise sales the big learning from yammer uh you know we learned this at yammer from 2008 2012 is that enterprises don't self-serve, right?
They don't self-close. Bottom up, SaaS products are phenomenal for generating top of funnel, basically generating leads. But you have to have salespeople close the deals. And enterprises don't just kind of pull out a credit card and self-serve. They need a salesperson. And I think there was something in the DNA of Slack that actually I see really very commonly in the DNA of sort of product-y SaaS companies, product-y SaaS founders, which is they kind of have a reflexive dislike or distaste for sales. And they resist the idea of sales. And they want to believe that they can just be entirely product-driven.
And what I see across the board is they all come to the same realization that we had a Yammer, which is we have to have a sales team. And I do remember, you know, back in 2014, the whole Yammer sales team was basically rolling off because of, you know, Microsoft acquired the company in 2012. And there was an integration period. And by 2013, 2014, they were all looking for jobs. And I remember, you know, my former CRO, I think, was interviewing at Slack, and it would have been such a perfect thing for them because he had just learned all the lessons of how you layer on kind of an enterprise sale on top of a bottom-up product.
And they just weren't ready to make that hire yet. And so, look, if you're going to nitpick, look, $30 billion outcome, no one's criticizing. But if you were to nitpick, you know, it's an A plus regardless. But, you know, this would be the one thing you could say. Well, congratulations all around to everybody involved, especially Phil Helmuth, who was an LP in one of Chamath's funds. So if you need insights on Slack or any of the inside information, you can just follow Phil Helmuth on Twitter at being the greatest or I am the greatest or I'll always be the greatest. One of those Twitter handles is his.
But Jason, I mean, you basically came to the same conclusion in your emergency pod, right? I mean. I did. I hadn't seen your, I think a tweet came after the emergency pod. But yeah, it just seemed to me this company, unlike Zoom, should have been able to grow quicker. And if you look at their numbers, they had 87 companies that were spending over a million dollars. You put a rabid sales team on that product and they go in like Benioff does with his sales team. I mean, he was just hyper aggressive at just putting huge numbers out there and saying, you have to pay us this much money. So much so that I don't know if you remember Elon getting into a public spat with him where he's like, Salesforce is horrible software, get it out of the organization.
He basically banned it because they came to him with the bottom up people using of Salesforce and said, hey, you owe us this amount of money. And Elon was like, F you, banned forever from inside of our organization. We'll build our own software. We don't need it. and they didn't have somebody and Stuart didn't have that DNA, I think, to say aggressively, we need to charge what this product is worth. And you saw that in, I think, one of their strengths and weaknesses, which was they only build you for people who were actively using the product. Now, that's a beautiful, awesome feature. It makes you not scared to use it.
But on the enterprise level, I mean, that seemed to be like maybe one of those non-cutthroat things that maybe were holding them back. David, do you have any insights on this or should we go on to AlphaFold? It's really important to remember the mechanics and the game theory around M&A, especially big game hunting when you're doing $30 billion acquisitions. It's also kind of true at billion-dollar levels, but less so. But the bigger the acquisition gets, you have to remember that there's an asymmetry of information between buyers and sellers. And the question is, who does the asymmetry favor?
Because you could look at this acquisition and say, wow, Salesforce is crazy for spending $30 billion. And somebody else may say, wow, Slack was really stupid for selling it for $30 billion, right? The reality is that I think that there was asymmetries on both sides. I think that what Slack probably saw, and I don't know because I've been off the board now for more than a year, but I think what they saw was, as David said, just a level of sophistication and scale and ability to cross-sell and upsell that was needed for enterprise scale. Either you overcome it with precision and speed, or you overcome it by going the same pace as somebody like Microsoft, but with an equivalent product portfolio.
So that's sort of one realization that Slack had. But in the case of Salesforce, what they probably had was a realization that they couldn't go wall to wall inside of a customer because they didn't really have a product that was useful or usable to every single individual inside of an enterprise. And so both of those two things create asymmetries. There's a level of fear inside of Slack and there's a level of fear inside of Salesforce. Both of them are about the fear of disruption. And then the question is, who gets the better of the other person in the middle of the acquisition, right? So the deal could have probably gotten done at, you know, $22 billion, it probably could have also gotten done at $45 billion.
And that's, again, to a combination of how well you play poker in that moment, right? Who blinks first and the quality of the bankers. This is like two people having top pair on a very textured board. It's like, and they're just raising versus each other. Yeah, it's who upblades them. Because it's similar also to how Microsoft bought LinkedIn, right? Because if you think about what happened in LinkedIn, if you remember when that happened, it was almost to a T very much like Slack. LinkedIn had one bad quarter. They got decapitated by, and I owned it at the time in our public fund. It got decapitated by like 50%, 60%, 70%.
I mean, something insane for missing numbers by like a few pennies, okay? And all of a sudden, it took a lot of the wind out of their sales internally. It didn't change the user momentum at all because the users that were signing up for LinkedIn didn't care what the stock price was yesterday, today, and tomorrow. But it all of a sudden created a fear. And I think Microsoft was able to exploit that fear. And within a year, this company was bought for $25 billion. Not dissimilar. Slack had a hiccup and they got re-rated. The stock bounced back. But I think that if Salesforce was smart, they probably created, you know, sort of like a white knight kind of bid that said, listen, you need enterprise scale and the ability to cross sell and upsell, I can give it to you.
And Slack probably said, listen, you need to go wall to wall. So I understand why you need me. And, you know, the price is what the price is. Go ahead, Freeberg. If you look at the pricing, right? So Slack, normally the way these big M&A, you know, public company M&A deals get done is the board has to approve the price and they have to say, this was the right deal for us relative to other options. And one of the ways you assess that is you look at where the share price has been historically. And if you're getting a premium to where the share price has been historically, let's say 30, 40% higher than it's ever been, then the board says, great, that's a good deal.
We should take it because we've got a long way to grow into that value. In this case, the deal was done not at a very high premium to where Slack traded just in the summer. Is that right, Chimazzo? It looked like it peaked. It's basically, if you look at the fully diluted. It's a 10% premium, right? 10% premium, yeah. 10% premium, yeah. We opened the direct listing at 40 or 41, and then this was at 45. Right. And so there clearly was a sense of weakness from the board, which is, I think, why the Salesforce stock traded down afterwards. Because if they were willing to sell at that small of a premium, the forecast internally is probably feeling not that strong.
And then people translate that into, hey, Salesforce bought something that's not that strong. You know, there's something a little bit amiss. But obviously, to your point, they're missing a lot of the cross selling and the synergy that will arise. I think it's a huge slam dunk acquisition. And I go back to the this idea of intercompany network effects. I think they exist. And I think they're real. And I think that the slack, the slack product teams ability to innovate around that was not as fast as it could have been, but it was still very unique. And I think it was, it was a true moat. and you know the the tragedy is we won't see what the terminal value is if they were left alone to execute and in this weird way like i've always struggled with why microsoft was so overly obsessed with slack because if you looked at the team's product it was much more directly competitive with zoom and to this day still remains much more directly competitive with than slack but you know there we have it and if you look at the revenue um slack was doing 800 million run rates anyway rounded up to a billion and yet salesforce at 20 billion uh so five percent revenue to revenue and then they got 10 of the company so in that way if you look at on a percentage basis which is you know how you might look at the facebook instagram and and whatsapp is what percentage of the existing entity did they get right the size growing size growing about 60 percent a year and salesforce is growing about 22 something like that the other thing is the president of salesforce is uh brett taylor who uh was our cto at facebook who i worked with and so i think brett also understands network effects really well um and you know by the way in in this interesting twist of fate benioff was the underbidder i think for linkedin and so um you know we've uh we've seen mark around the hoop on these you know social network network effect business tool acquisitions before and finally also twitter he was running he was hanging around the basket with twitter and then they also brought his name up for tiktok which made no sense so i think benioff is just looking at this like if if google and microsoft and apple are too scared to buy things because of antitrust well i'm under the radar of the antitrust trillion dollars so i'm the only he's he's under the radar because he doesn't have a play in this sort of communication or collaboration space.
And so therefore, there are no antitrust issues. If Microsoft were to do it, it would definitely be scrutinized because you could argue that they're adding to their existing dominant market share and collaboration. But Benioff's dream has always been, at least since he launched Chatter to compete with us when we were doing Yammer. This is back in 2010, 2011. His dream has always been to have a product that could get him onto every seat in the enterprise. You know, his current product set is departmental. I mean, you've got kind of the CRM product for sales, and they've got the support cloud for customer support, and they've got the marketing cloud for marketing.
And so, he's gone department by department, but he's never really had a sort of pan, like sort of cross company. Yeah, something that the entire company would use. Like a central login system, right? And Slack is that central login system. But when he came up against you, it was very, you know, Benioff, you're friendly with Benioff. Benioff came at you so hard. He threw three or 400 engineers at chatter. He took out full page Wall Street Journal ads. He tried to poach your people. He tried to make the product free. He made it personal against you after you would not sell to him true or false David Sachs.
i don't i don't think he made it personal but uh it was definitely feel personal um no no no no no he did that's i understood what he was trying to do that's your way of saying no i mean if we had sold to salesforce like we ended up so what i would say is yeah we got in like a very it was a very competitive situation he didn't beat us um you know what's that he failed does that product even exist yeah um it's sort of like a feed inside of the the crm product it didn't really succeed as a standalone collaboration product and so we won that battle but it definitely i would say it scared us enough to sell to microsoft um because you know the what did he were about to we were about to enter a new stage of competition so here's what happened is he launched his product to kind of be a clone of yammer inside of salesforce but he was initially charging 15 per seat.
We were charging like five. And so they massively overpriced it. And then they were on this slippery slope where they kept lowering the price to compete better with us. And then finally, they realized that they should just give the thing away for free as a strategic move. And that was when we decided to sell it to Microsoft is we didn't know. We knew we had a better product than Chatter, but we didn't know how it would go if we were up against a free Chatter. Tell us honestly, how much did he offer? What was the meeting like where he made you the offer we yeah so yeah so here's i'll tell you the backstory i mean this hasn't been publicly publicly revealed but um here we go in service of the in service of the all-in podcast in service is trying to get us from number three to number one on the charts um no you know it's funny we launched uh yammer at the tech crunch 40 conference that jason as you know you're the co-founder of and benioff was like a judge he was a panelist and he was raving about it and you could just you know from from the moment we launched he was raving about it you could see the light bulb go off with him and um he realized that like social was going to be it was you know at the time obviously social was big with consumer social networks but he saw the potential of social or collaboration inside the enterprise and so yeah i mean like i think a year later or something they were interested in buying the company for around 250 million dollars the big issue for them though was that benioff had a bunch of like engineers who wanted to build it in-house and so they they they actually i don't know what would have happened if um if they you know didn't want to build it themselves but but basically they vetoed doing a deal and so they ended up building chatter and they threw the 300 engineers at it and they basically spun their wheels for a few years.
And anyway, it turned out to be much better for us because we ended up selling the company for five times as much to Microsoft. You know, if we had sold to Salesforce in like 2010, it would have been a much smaller deal. But yeah, I mean, he was very interested in it from the get-go. All right, folks, here you have a breaking news in the background on what actually happened. Congratulations to Stuart and the team. I want to ask a question, Chamath and Sax. Did you guys keep all of the shares you originally invested in to the exit here? Just to set the context for folks, you invest in a company, it's a small startup, it's exiting for $30 billion.
Yeah. Did you hold it? For every share that I owned, half of it were half, no. yeah for of of of a hundred shares that i owned per every hundred that i owned um 10 of them i sold at 38 right at the direct listing um i want to say 40 of them i sold uh in the mid-20s and uh the rest of it just got taken out at this price so your dollar cost average to the you know whatever high 30s maybe 40 or something yeah i don't know my exact i mean i i i sold some and i still own some so um you know i definitely got my my beak wet from this acquisition um but uh no but look i i think i probably sold you know more than half of them you know um and that was a mistake and you know one of my biggest learnings as an investor has been to let your winners ride you know my biggest mistake as an investor has not been the losers it's all it's been selling the winners prematurely yeah you did that with uber as well david uh and i sold some uber before but i kept a lot of my uber maybe most of it or half of it i think anyway uber facebook i mean facebook you know when they ipo'd it was worth 50 billion we all thought that was like unbelievable i mean because it was over a 50x return but um what's the lesson for your Just never sell anything if you can help it.
I sold all of my Facebook in 2014 and bought Amazon and Tesla. I think that you have to be able to sell for two reasons, liquidity and moral obligation. Yeah, I mean, that's an exaggeration. I mean, you can never, people need to be able to sell, but to the extent you can hold on, just don't sell everything. you know always you keep um you know think about the people who were at apple in the 80s or microsoft in the 80s or amazon in the 90s a lot of those people got frustrated holding the shares for so long and i think keeping at least 20 of your shares forever you know could be amazing there was somebody told me had never sold a single share of i don't know if that's a true story or i told you that you can't be okay okay anyway i didn't know that was a leak more breaking news let's move to alpha fold must credit all in podcast oh my god the same may or may not be true without and his shares you know what we should do is we should do a we should put beeps in there nick i was told had never sold a share of and then we just let everybody react to it this way nobody knows what we're talking about.
I do know that has not sold a single share and it has only sold shares of to fund capital calls, which is an incredible statement to fortitude and vision. Incredible. Lord. Incredible. By the way, it's not always worked out because he did the same with and those didn't go as well. Yeah. I mean, look, you have to diversify when you've got all your eggs in one basket in one company. Obviously, you have to sell some shares, But, you know, one of the things I've just learned over the last 20 years is probably people ask me, what's your biggest regret or learning or whatever? It's just selling too early is like one of the biggest mistakes you can make.
Look at PayPal. PayPal is now a $250 billion company. We sold it in 2002 for $1.5 billion. We thought that was a great deal at the time. And we sold it for less than 1% of what it's worth today. And the product's basically the same. You know, it's just compounding. So never sell is the lesson. Never sell. If it's a winner, ride it. You can pair. Hold on. Hold on. I'm going to put a final nail disc off and then we're going to go to AlphaFold. There's a great quote by Warren Buffett, which is, if you know what you're doing, the best thing you can do is be as concentrated as possible. Nobody ever got rich in their seventh best idea.
And I think that that basically sums it up. But you have to be in a position to have the ability to have that kind of portfolio allocation. And I think that's hard. Freebird, explain AlphaFold, please. Okay. Let's explain. give me two minutes on i'll explain proteins and then um the importance of proteins and then alpha folds so um the numbers to remember are four three and twenty there are four nucleic acids that make up your dna we all learned this in high school biology um sets of three a c t and g combinations define an amino acid there are 20 amino acids um and a protein is a string of amino acids.
So in your body, in every cell, there are these organelles, they make proteins by reading the DNA, taking a copy of it and turning it into amino acid chains. And that's what we kind of call proteins. But what's interesting is when you make a chain of amino acids, so there's 20 of them that you could put in each point in the chain, it doesn't come out as a long chain, what happens is those amino acids, the whole thing collapses, and it turns into a very specific shape. And the shape of that protein is what defines its function. So pretty much every biological function across all life is is undertaken by proteins doing something some proteins like hemoglobin in our red blood cells will has a very specific little pocket where oxygen molecules stick into the pocket, and then it moves the oxygen from your lungs to your cells.
It's a pretty amazing protein to exist. And it specifically is shaped to do that exact function. There are other proteins that can, for example, rip apart other molecules, break a molecular bond. There are other proteins, for example, that can take nitrogen out of the atmosphere and put it into plants, cells that the plants can then use to grow. There's an incredible, you know, a set of potential on the nanoscale of what you can do with proteins. And we see that in life. And we're just shocked and awed and amazed by it every day. But in order to figure out how to create proteins that do specific things, you have to know how do those amino acids turn into the shape that the protein ultimately takes.
And that's what's called protein folding. And so the hard thing is, and, you know, why is this important? It's important because we can easily read DNA. And therefore, we can figure out what amino acid sequence is being made to define that protein. But what we don't know really well is what is the shape of that protein? And therefore, how does it undertake the function that we see it taking in biology. And if you think about the reverse of this, the reverse of this, if you have a function you want to undertake in biology, you can design a protein to do that function for you. For example, bind to a specific point on a cancer cell or take carbon out of the atmosphere or pretty much anything else your mind can kind of imagine on the nanoscale proteins can be designed to do.
The challenge is how do you write the code, which is the DNA, to make the protein that does that thing? well, we don't know how the code turns into the shape. And that's what folding the folding problem is. So the folding problem, there's a data set. And the data set is what's the three dimensional shape of a protein. And then what's the DNA code that defines the amino acid sequence that makes that protein. And how do you figure out how to predict the shape of the protein from the amino acid sequence, it has been an impossibility. And again, if you think about this chain of amino acids, they each have little, you know, electrical spaces and the way that they bind to each other, it's very complicated.
You can't just deterministically define it. You know, we don't have that level of understanding on a quantum scale. So what AlphaFold has done is they have now been able to predict from a sequence of amino acids what the protein shape will ultimately become by learning from a database of hundreds of thousands of structural protein shapes that have been defined through really, really, really difficult, you know, scanning microscopes and other techniques to really try and scan a protein on a microscopic scale. And then looking at the DNA sequence and figuring out, okay, what's the relationship?
And the accuracy of their predictive model now is within the range of error of the microscopes that are being used to actually scan and measure those proteins. So that's incredible because now, theoretically, you could come up with a design for a protein and you could actually build that protein by writing the amino acid sequence. And that protein can do any number of things you want to do. And this has been a difficult problem that's been intractable by humanity. And we've been challenged by it for decades. For this machine learning breakthrough to kind of be realized in literally less than three years.
I mean, these guys were at a score of 40 last year and this year they're at like nearly 90. 90. Incredible. and so now um you know we can now predict what the shape will be from the from the dna sequence and and this is going to unlock this ability everyone's now going to take their model if they license it or whatever they do with it or people are going to go learn using the same techniques that deep mind used um but it just means that it's possible and then scientists will go away and they'll say you know what i want to do this particular thing on a microscopic scale let me design in in three dimensional space a protein to do that thing okay now let me go figure out how to make that protein by writing the DNA code, which is really easy if you can use this algorithm to solve that for you.
And it is literally dollars and pennies to make proteins. We can write DNA on a computer, we can get printed DNA sent to us in 48 hours in a FedEx envelope for a DNA printing facility, we can put it in a microbe, and we can get that microbe to make the protein for us in a day. The lab costs any high school biology class can do this now. So by being able to actually figure out what DNA to write, based on the objective function of what do we want the protein to do, it's going to unlock this universe of things we can do in medicine, in environmental science. We can do things like break apart PET plastics.
We can do things like fixing nitrogen from the atmosphere and getting rid of fertilizer plants. We can create all sorts of new food solutions, health solutions, environmental solutions. Any chance you can make a pizza that doesn't have carbohydrates? Because that's what I'm thinking about here is, is there a way we can make a healthy pasta or pizza or something like that. But in all seriousness, what do you think the early wins will be out of this technology? And is this a theoretical win that will benefit from in 20 years? Or is this a serious breakthrough that we're going to benefit from in the near term, like one to five years?
No, I think both are true. This is an incredibly important advancement in machine learning. But the reality is that Google will still have to spend, and DeepMind will have to spend a lot of time refining it. And then they have some really big ethical challenges ahead of it. How do you expose this technology to whom and under what conditions? And it's the same situation that OpenAI has with GPT-3, although a lot of people, I think, the scale of the computer science challenge maybe was a bigger win in GPT-3 because it was a much more open space. And I think this is a much more specific, sort of almost expert system in a way.
But the downstream commercial implications of this is just enormous um and so just think about this like this is where like you gotta you gotta love companies like google the fact that they exist because from you know page rank in 1999 to cpc ads in 2003 and 4 um we have alpha fold in 2020 and that to me is just that's just an argument against breaking up tech because only a tech company with this amount of resource knowledge can then go spend a billion dollars on deep mine. I mean, Alphabet's burning four to five billion dollars a year on their quote unquote other bets line. And people give them a lot of shit for it.
But I mean, you hit any one of these things and it's a hundred billion dollar payday. I mean, look at YouTube. YouTube's easily a hundred billion dollar payday on a billion dollar bet. Billion six. Oh, no, that's it. That's a 250 to 500 billion dollar. Applied semantics. A lot of people miss this, but applied semantics was a hundred million dollar bet. And that's the entirety of AdSense initially. Android. Android. Um, you know, and is this, is this the first commercial application of deep mind? Because until now, you know, they've had alpha zero. It's been, so there were, there was a period of time.
A lot of people, I don't know if, uh, let me just think about this for a second. Cause alpha zero, alpha zero was really good. I want to be careful about this, but I do think that I do think it was disclosed that they've used DeepMind to improve ads quality and improve YouTube viewing. And as a result of that, you get the number of hours per day of the average user on YouTube to double or triple ad revenue goes by 3x. And I think in one quarter, Google was able to generate something like an incremental 15 billion annualized revenue from DeepMind's algorithm. And you know what that DeepMind actually did on YouTube?
It sent everybody to the alt-right didn't involve wars and Ben Shapiro. Congratulations. Be careful where you send people's minds with artificial intelligence. Maybe you just argued to break them up. Yeah, but I understand, Sachs, that it's being used broadly across the products at Google. Now in a much more careful way is my understanding. Look, I'm a big ally of Alphabet. I'm a big fan and I love- You know, they were- And I used to work there and I'm very close to people there. You know who used to be on the board and was the major backer of that company, DeepMind? Founders fund. Founders fund.
Elon Musk too. And he begged them to not sell to Google. I mean, $400 million exit was a steal for Google. With 40 or 50 scientists, I think. Yeah, absolute steal. No, Elon, I mean, Elon has publicly said that he thinks deep mind is like the greatest threat. Well, he thinks AI is the greatest threat to humanity. And of the people working on AI, deep mind is the furthest along and therefore most dangerous. He tried to stop. I mean, he told me straight up, like he's been very public about this since that he he said i'll give you an unlimited amount of money to not sell to google he's friends with larry page too but he said don't sell i want you to be independent i want you to keep working on this but he said that when he saw the ai there become aware that it was an ai that that was when he was like wait a second no wait deep deep mind is not the alpha alpha fold or alpha zero is not self-aware that's he felt it was becoming self-aware that it knew what it was i don't know if that was just elon you know just sort of no it's not it's not self-aware so i mean i've watched yeah i mean the amazing things that deep mind has released prior to this were games right they had this um chess this chess ai called alpha zero which rapidly became not just the best chess um it not only beat every human in the world it also beat every chess engine because computers became more, you know, better at chess than humans a long time ago because of their sheer computational power.
But Alpha Zero plays like a human, but with kind of that same computational power. And so, that created a whole revolution in chess engines. And then they also did that with a game called Go. They created Alpha Go. And basically, every single game that you can think of, DeepMinds created, you know, an alpha, whatever alpha version that um destroys both humans and computers but this is the first thing they've publicly announced that that seems like it will be available to others eventually that could have tremendous social impact imagine the government trying to understand this can you imagine them being brought before like senators well these are these are these are the new weapons of mass destruction i mean let's be honest like if if somebody else had had alpha fold and probably somebody does and just hasn't said you know i mean google actually values transparency so that's the only reason why we know um imagine what they could do as friedbrook said it's like you know the the opposite of this is basically to design um a specific protein that basically um you know destroys organs or there are proteins called prions which are the scariest thing known in biology, in my opinion, a prion is a protein that it actually finds similar proteins.
And based on its shape, it gets those proteins to change and it becomes like a virus. And prions actually are, there's an extremely sad series of diseases that are related to prions where your body expresses a protein in the wrong way. And then that protein itself gets other proteins to change and creates copies of itself. And it spreads. It is a fascinatingly scary biological phenomenon. But you know, there are extremely scary things you can do with the designer protein capability. Basically, you can make a bioweapon that would be similar to what the aliens and Prometheus and aliens were doing the engineers, even much worse, even much worse.
This is why I think they're going to spend years before. So this is why back to that earlier question, it'll be years before this sees the light of day, because they're they're smart enough to know what they've uncovered. And I think they did they did the right thing by talking about it, because I think there's a lot of really amazing R&D. But the reality is that Google for the next 20 or 30 years will have layers and layers of oversight because, you know, it's not like you're going to allow a company to enrich uranium in Mountain View without oversight. And this is the equivalent. It's just a we're buying time until governments realize that they have to do that they have to do it.
But let's also remember the protein data set they trained on is publicly available. You know, anyone can access this. And with the, you know, catch up in machine learning, you know, capability to DeepMind, infrastructure wise, theoretically, you know, someone could, could, I think it's, it's an inevitability that in the next 24 months, someone else will replicate this. Right now, I think what DeepMind has done is showed that specific techniques of learning can overcome limitations in compute. But to your point, David, like we're accelerating silicon at a fast enough speed where, you know, it's like if you can throw 5, 10, 50, 100, 500 pet ops at a problem, you're, you know, you can run, you know, some really, really old version of TensorFlow and probably get to the same answer.
Yeah, I actually think they published, I'm going to find it while you guys are chatting, but they published what the compute needs were on running this. I'll find it in a second. I'll tell you. let me make one sort of slightly descending point on the whole wmd thing i mean look obviously the you know who has access this technology needs to be controlled um we do have to make sure it doesn't get into the hands of bad actors but the reality is there's plenty of existing wmds out there that have been around for a long time that bad actors could get their hands on they could already make you know extremely dangerous viruses in a lab they could you know take something that's as contagious as smallpox and make it as deadly as a bowl or something like that.
And it's these new technologies that provide a way for us to combat those, those WMDs because, you know, technology has a tendency to become democratized. You know, was it 75 years ago, the U S was the only country that had an atomic weapon. Now what like close to 10 have, you know, nuclear atomic weapons. And so, you know, these sort of nefarious technologies get democratized anyway, and we really need some of these new technologies and new abilities as a way to combat them. So, like last week, we were talking about the ability now to basically print, you know, a vaccine using this mRNA technique within two days.
You know, you can imagine, you know, if someone tried to use a bioweapon, create a new virus, we could print a vaccine the next day. Those are the kinds of capabilities we're going to need to fight the spread of WMD. I think you're right. It's just that you then have a law of large numbers problem, meaning the previous problem before is you had 180, 190, 200 state-sponsored actors. So if you had a 1% rate of people who are just bad, you're talking about two states. Now, when you talk about 5 billion people getting access to code, that's basically running in an AWS or GCP instance someplace, and you have a 1%, you know, bad guy rate, all of a sudden, that 1% really matters.
And I think that's the problem. It's just the law of large numbers, David, applied to very, very small rates of immorality. But I mean, you can already do very scary things with, you know, recombinant DNA, taking DNA from one organism, putting it in another and sending that organism out. And, you know, theoretically, you could have designed a virus that would spread throughout humanity and cause a lot of death right i mean there's a lot of this capability that people would have found that out because like you can't run these labs and you're not going to get you know monkey models or mouse models it's like there's there's a trail of breadcrumbs there that is easier to track wouldn't you agree than just running an instance in a simulation on gcp sending it someplace to then have a protein printed that comes in a fedex envelope to you and you have to hire people as we saw in iran with you know their chief scientist being whacked by whoever accidentally whacked him with 60 people.
Like, you need to have the brainpower to do this. Once you have the brainpower to do it, you can track that brainpower. And we had for the last, I think it's like since we even tested nuclear bombs, we've had these special planes flying around the globe looking for the signature of nuclear detonations or any kind of nuclear fallout. And we've been flying those forever. I think I think I think biodefense is going to become probably one of the biggest industries on planet earth starting in the latter half of this century because you're going to get to a point where digital biology is like a tool just like software was in the 80s where suddenly everyone could access it everyone could use it everyone could do stuff with it you have this ubiquity of scary shit happening hackers everywhere hold on freeberg didn't we have that as well in those same claims about nuclear power and we were been able to for a hundred years with nuclear close to a hundred years nuclear in particular with nuclear in particular there is a material problem You have to source and refine material to do something scary.
With biology, you don't. You can do this anywhere. You can do it on your desktop at home. And, you know, it's getting easier, cheaper, faster. And you can use software and a printer and, you know, a cheap sequencer and do stuff. Do we believe that China has this, Freiburg? Yes. China, for sure. Yeah, I mean, look, this is, yeah. Are they ahead of DeepMind or behind DeepMind? 100%, 100%. So here's the stats that DeepMind put out. It took the equivalent of 100 to 200 GPUs run over a few weeks. to build this model. That is nothing. I don't care how advanced DeepMind is at this point. That's nothing.
So, you know, if that's the model, then someone else can replicate that. You know, someone else will replicate that. That's what happened to AlphaZero, the DeepMind chess engine. After they proved it, now there's a whole bunch of chess AIs. I think we're within one year, J. Cal, of a lot of startups replicating this AlphaFold technique and then using that to go do drug discovery. and you'll see 50 startups getting funded 12 to 18 months from now based on some novel protein idea. And I think that this... We got to get our beats wet on this and the ISAs. Everybody go to... This is getting ridiculous.
Everybody go to thesyndicate.com slash all in. But I will make my... We should create a protein folding syndicate. Yeah, absolutely. Here it is. Everybody go to thesyndicate.com slash all in. If we do this, I'm collecting the emails now. No, but I will make my first series of bets less on the application and more on the protection. I think biodefense 30 years from now is going to be so important. If you want to invest with the best ease. Is there going to be a protein that prevents Rudy Giuliani from farting? I mean, what is going on, Saks? Let's throw to you as our resident right wing. I'm joking, Saks.
Don't take it so personal. We know you didn't vote for Trump. We know you did a write-in vote for Tucker Carlson. Let me ask you this. Have you or have you not had dinner with Tucker Carlson? That's a big pause. I call. Call in. I've actually, yeah. No, I don't think I've had dinner with Tucker. You've been to a party with Tucker Carlson at Peter Tale's house. No. No. But let me get to, here's what's happening is, Well, I feel my dream of gridlock in Washington for the next four years is slipping away. You know, the you know, I described this as sort of like it was kind of a dream scenario that you'd have a divided Congress and the Republicans, you know, they won 50.
They won 50 seats in the Senate in November. And then, you know, because of the stupid rule in Georgia that you have to you can't just win. you have to win by having over 50%. The Republicans would have had 51, but now there's a runoff for these two open seats. And the Republicans were ahead in the polls at the time. They were the more, I think it was mostly it's based on the candidates being more popular than the Democratic candidates. But now because of all these antics around the election, the Democrats have, both Democratic candidates have pulled ahead. What? Yeah, they are now both Democratic candidates.
in the last couple of last week or so um osup is ahead of purdue by about two points which is a stunner because purdue has already beaten him before he beat him in the november election he's i think a better candidate though right and the margin of error but warlock republican right but warnock is seven points ahead of uh loffler so that one is outside the margin of error he's clearly beating her. And now it looks like Purdue's in danger too. The Republicans just need to win one of those in order for us to have divided government in Washington, which I think tends to produce better results than giving one party all the levers of power.
But this is the crazy thing. And so, I think even from Trump's point of view, I think this is a branding exercise to prove that he didn't lose. The problem is how's that going well it's not working and it looks like it's going to cost republicans the senate which is something that i think he won't come back from so if i was advising the president i would tell him to drop this you know these these legal challenges they fired sydney powell from the legal team which i think was a good decision because of her crazy wild allegations but now rudy's out there doing the same stuff juliani the answer that i gave you is they didn't bother to interview a single witness he was adjusting he wasn't waking up the genie he was he was tucking his pants in laying down in the bedroom having a drink with a russian underage i mean rudy is just i mean fresh off his his guest starring appearance in the borat movies i mean it's like uncredited uncredited yeah it's like he's reenacting my cousin vinnie or something in these um in these hearings yeah um how many things am i holding up because the senate Yeah, I think it's so amazing.
The Democrats basically now have a stone-cold free roll because there is a very good chance that these guys are going to win these two Senate seats, which would just be absolutely incredible. Absolutely incredible. So Republicans are definitely figuring this out. Rich Lowry had a great column. He's an editor of National Review. He's on the right, but I think provides very good objective political analysis. He's his last column sounded the alarm bells about what was happening in Georgia. And look, if the if the issue in the Georgia runoffs is are these antics, if it's Rudy and Sidney Powell, the Republicans are going to lose the seat, the both seats.
If the question of the election is whether Democrats should have a free hand to ram through whatever legislation they want, then I think the Republicans win. So the question is, what is that election going to be about? And the longer that Rudy stays on the stage making these crazy wild allegations, the worse it gets for Republicans. When is the Georgia runoff election? I think it's January 5th or 10th. It's one of those two. January 5th, I think. My gosh. Would anybody here, if they had gray hair, and I know we have three gentlemen on the call who have gray hair. Friedberg, somehow you might be, maybe I've answered this question already.
Just not on his head. would any of you dye your hair if you were a 79 87 year old rudy giuliani no my hair is white and getting whiter it's like it is what it is it's a passage of time i would just move on david would you consider just taking that gray right out of your hair because you have the your silver fox as it stands would you ever consider it you can see the decision i've made But look, that's not I mean, it's yeah. I mean, that was just like a meltdown. I mean, a literal meltdown, a literal, literal meltdown. And it was so like representative of the moment. The the congressional Republicans want to use a hook to get Rudy off the stage.
I mean, they cannot wait to get him off the stage. And stand up and just tell Trump to shut this down. I think I think it's coming. It's coming. So, yeah. Oh, wow. So the Republicans are going to stand up to Trump with four weeks left in office. Wow. What a profile in courage. Freeberg, are you dyeing your hair? Do you have gray hair? And are you actually dyeing it? Or have you not hit the gray yet? Just tell us right now. It's an emergency pod. No. What's the truth? David, are you dyeing your hair? Yes or no? This is it. This is all natural, baby. All right. There's so many ways. Does anybody have an opinion on whether Trump is allowed to pre-pardon himself and his kids?
That's exactly where I was going. Yeah, sex. well yes our right wing car you can definitely pardon his kids i don't know that there's an open legal question whether he can pardon himself can you pre-pardon um what does it mean pre-pardon in this definition you mean you can't you can only pardon for a committed crime right i mean that's traditionally no part of the blanket right well you can pardon for things that happened in the past um i don't think you can pardon for things that happen in the future and you can define it you can get a blanket part no i don't think you have to define it i think you could just do a blanket pardon um the i would advise trump not to do it if i were one of his advisors and the reason is that he can only pardon for federal and the big problem the trump family has right now are you know the southern district of new york these mad dog prosecutors who are democrats this is you know i don't approve of it this is this is to me this is the to me this is the criminalization of political differences i don't i think it'd be great if he could pardon because i do think that those guys are again they're trying to criminalize political differences but but pardoning doesn't solve the problem with the southern district of new york and biden has already said that he doesn't believe in having any uh having these uh having like a federal investigation of trump and so i don't think i don't think trump has anything to worry about federally i think the problem is god can i just say is just so fucking decent and classy like isn't it refreshing it's actually boring but isn't it just wait what are you talking about biden is just so decent who's biden like i haven't seen that guy is he work for us oh he's been great no i mean like he's well he disappeared look he doesn't disappear he's just not crazy he's biden biden biden has done a really has done a few really smart things i mean in his acceptance speech he did what churchill advises you to do in victory which is be magnanimous he's made the right sort of sounds towards reconciliation.
I think saying that he didn't believe in going after Trump criminally. I mean, look, I don't think that would have been a good political move anyway, because it would have created a backlash, but it was a smart thing to say. And then I think the other smart thing he's done is, which is very Biden anyway, which is he's gone establishment all the way for his cabinet. He hasn't named any totally crazy progressives to his cabinet yet that the republicans could latch on to for the georgia runoffs and so biden's doing a very good job right now of appearing non-threatening and doing nothing to nothing to blow up his honeymoon he and his advisors have run a perfect perfect flawless flaw it's been flawless i mean david you just nailed it like all of all the things he could have done to potentially put the senate at risk or to potentially give republicans sort of something to hang their hats on.
He has given zero space, right? Like he has not created a single opening. So you would have thought that coming into this election cycle, the way that Trump tried to paint Biden was like this, you know, gaffaholic. And instead, he has just been picture pitch perfect. Well, I think he's a gaff machine when he speaks spontaneously, which he has not done. I mean, every time I've seen him speak since the election, he's been reading off a teleprompter. But I think that his campaign has run a really good, they have run a good strategy. And now look, it helps that the press doesn't really challenge him.
It's like weekend at Bernie's, except it's like presidency at Bernie's. You know, it's like four years. They hit him in a basement. He only reads up the teleprompter, hold him up, put him on the stage. But yeah, the press let him get away with it. I mean, no other candidate could have gotten away with a basement strategy. But the press was so determined to go after Trump that they really gave him a free pass on what Biden believed and what he was going to do. But look, Biden has run a very good campaign and a very good transition. And really, I think the biggest mistake he made during the campaign was not declaring definitively that he would not try to pack the Supreme Court.
That was his big mistake. And what happened? The voters split the ticket to give the Senate to the Republicans so that Biden wouldn't be able to pack the court. And so, he wouldn't be able to do it anyway. And I think maybe his administration has learned from that mistake, which is don't do anything or say anything that's going to give Republicans something to latch onto to say that Biden is really a radical, we got to stop him. And anyway, so now Georgia's in play and Biden could win the Senate. That's a perfect insight, Sacks, because what you haven't seen as well is you haven't seen Kamala Harris out there all that much because that's something Republicans could glom onto and you haven't seen aoc bernie sanders or elizabeth warren they are persona no grata they are not involved in this wow they are mia they're mia and they the democrats won't bring them up and you have bernie sanders like wasn't he supposed to be in charge of like elan omar wants to cancel rent and mortgages i mean they're throwing that was classic and they're throwing everything out there just to see if anything sticks right now yeah but biden biden has really given Bernie Sanders and that wing of the party the high hat in these cabinet choices.
In fact, he just named a woman to be the head of OMB, the budget director, who has a huge Twitter feud with Bernie Sanders. And the Bernie folks are up in arms about it. I don't think she's going to get through. But yeah, I mean, Biden has really stiff-armed a lot of the progressives. he doesn't want to be associated with the hysterical left i mean it's a why would you want to i also i also think it's the hysterical left i think it's an appeal to the right up the right i mean he is he is appealing to the right to some extent right i mean like by by not putting those people in place i think he's never he's never right or he's never going to be able to appeal to the trump base but what he's going to be able to do is prevent the republicans from from sort of labeling him as a radical and therefore and therefore you know win over those independents that he needs.
By the way, back to Trump for one second. I apologize because I wanted to ask you, David. I mean, the other thing that could tip Georgia is this whole craziness where Trump is like, I'm going to veto the defense bill unless we repeal Section 230. And if you're a military person in Georgia, you're like, wait a second. You're going to leave my brothers and sisters in arms, basically lollygagging without any financial support because you don't like Twitter's tweet policy, it's going to seem kind of crazy. Yeah, it was one of these classic Trump moves where you feel like, I think he does have a good point with respect to the social media companies.
I do think they've been engaging in censorship. They've overstepped their bounds. They do deserve of some sort of comeuppance or control. I personally don't think that repealing 280, was it 280? Section 230 is the way to go. For a bunch of reasons that we could get into if you want. But yeah, it was one of these reflexive Trump tweets. And you heard Republicans in the Senate were very, very quick to shoot it down. um and you know there was an article in politico where um republicans were quoted well anonymously saying they're pretty sick of this shit that was the quote and so yeah i mean i think that republicans on capitol hill are kind of ready for for for those types of antics to be over okay should he uh or will he pardon himself and the kids like i mean i guess that's what it comes down to.
And I think we should move on. I don't think so. And I don't think it'll matter because I think Biden will leave him alone and it will not help his biggest risk. And this is, by the way, why they tried to get Jay Clayton to resign from the SEC and move over to the Southern District of New York because they thought maybe he could run some kind of interference. But I mean, I think the state AGs will want a pound of flesh here. And so should they? Or should we move on? Yeah, just if I were advising Trump and advising him on how to maximize his legacy, it would be, you know, pardon, pardon people in the administration been treated unfairly.
There's no need to pardon yourself. I don't I don't think he has federal exposure. And I would and I would tell him that, you know, if Republicans lose these Georgia Senate seats that he will be blamed for among the base for a long time. And that I think will be hard for him to get past in four years. And so it's very important, I think, for him to make sure that that at least Purdue wins his election. Yeah. What do you guys can ask another question? What do you think is going to happen with? So Trump is trying to make his case, but no one's listening. Twitter keeps putting up his fraudulent, you know, this is disputed claims, disputed claims thing.
and he's been pushing Newsmax and OANN. Do you think those become viable in real kind of media businesses now? And are they actually going to steal an audience away from Fox News? 100%. It's already happened. It's just the increasing fragmentation of media, right? The cable networks don't pick them up, do they? The cable companies? I've seen Newsmax. Newsmax has a cable channel. My theory is this entire twisted, like crazy right, alt-right mania. just fades into oblivion and the Republican Party reinvents itself. No, no. Because they can't win. They can't win, David. They can't win with this brand of crazy.
They did win. They did, and they will not in the future because they just lost. The Republicans won like 10 or 12 seats in the House. They've almost got the majority back in the House. They almost certainly will win back the House and retire Nancy Pelosi in two years during the midterm election. I'll put money on that right now. They held the Senate. They can win local elections. they held the senate presidency again with this strategy you think they can win with the demographic shift with trump in 2024 really yeah um you think people want to go back to that level of crazy people don't people don't want the they don't want the crazy but this idea that the issue set that trump ran on and won on is dead i don't i don't agree with that yeah those issues are still there.
You'll have a better branded face and a standard bearer for those issues. And if you say it in a less crazy way, and you're generally less crazy, I think that it will resonate with a lot more people than have already proven that it resonates with. It already resonates with 70 million. Could it resonate with 75 and could they overtake the White House? It's not inconceivable. So I think we can't all of a sudden say this is signed, sealed and delivered. It's a fait accompli. And all of a sudden, it's just Democrats the rest of the way. David's right. The down ballot results for the democrats were not good and it's a sign that moderate centrism is the only winning strategy if you really have a strategy where it's like i really want to win and not just me but my party and generations of people after me you have to run a centrist campaign which is why they're retiring the aoc elizabeth warren bernie bro contingent right so well yeah there's that group of crazy right there was a there was a democratic house member i think elizabeth Spanberger, who almost lost her seat, I think in like a Virginia, like kind of a swing Virginia district.
There was a big call of the Democratic House caucus. And she was just laying into Pelosi and the leadership there, because she was basically saying, don't ever mention defund the police again. You know, if you want me to win my my swing district next time, do not mention this ever again. This was all in the Washington Post. The call was leaked by about a dozen different press outlets, which tells you there was a lot of unhappiness among the House members who almost lost their seat because of these radical ideas. The other thing is, unless all of a sudden, the folks that are in their 20s and 30s are radically different than many, many generations before them, the reality is that they will, as they get older and wealthier, generally speaking, get more conservative.
And we are about to go through, over the next 20 years, $30 trillion of wealth transfer. And so, you know, I mean, you can wear buttons on buttons on flannel. But at the end of the day, when your mom and dad pass away, and all of a sudden, you know, you have four, five, six, seven, eight million bucks, and you have to think about your children and your children's children, I tend to think people generally do very predictably get more conservative. And so, again, another reason why you can't count on a staid interpretation of progressivism. There will be progressivism. I think it just will be a different form of policy, and it'll just be more moderate and centrist, and it'll be normal.
Which is a perfect segue to the New York Times story that came out on the Friday after Thanksgiving, November 27th. the rich kids who want to tear down capitalism, socialist-minded millennial heirs are trying to live their values by getting rid of their money. Lately, Sam Jacobs, and I'll read just a little bit of it, has been having a lot of conversations with his family's lawyers. He's trying to gain access to his trust of his $30 million trust fund. At 25, he's hit the age where many heirs can blow their money on harebrained businesses or a stable of sports cards. He doesn't want to do that but by wealth management standards his plans are just as bad he wants to give it all away i want to build a world where someone like me a young person who controls tens of millions of dollars is possible a socialist's college mr jacob sees his family's extreme plutocratic wealth as both a moral and economic failure his parents must be very proud of first of all sam jacobs sounds like an idiot and he shouldn't have any money so hopefully he gets his wish why did his parents give him 30 million dollars this trust fund should be like given to somebody who deserves it like Yeah, but what Sam Jacobs wants doesn't mean that Sam Jacobs gets to decide for everybody else.
And just because that he wants to live in a communist country, he can go and find one. And the reality is like, you know, we just talked about AlphaFold. Well, guess what? You know, there's four of us on this podcast today that over the next 20 or 30 years are more than likely going to invest hundreds of millions of dollars in protein design. and uh i don't do that with any um sense of um shame um and i'm glad that stewart butterfield made me you know a lot of money because it's going to go go back into the world in positive ways and you know maybe if my children are taught properly um they'll be able to take a small piece of that and they'll decide that you know there's uh something else that's important to them but the reality is that everybody should be allowed to make their own decisions and i don't want somebody like him especially a 25 year old dipshit telling me or my kids who even though they're you know under the age of 15 are probably smarter than him what to do david when you read this article uh if you did read it uh what were your thoughts um especially in regards to parenting and thinking about our own kids because that's what i started thinking about it's like oh my god what if one of my daughters wants to take her trust fund and just throw it into the wind i really don't want Wait, hold on.
I just want to say one more thing. The part that's completely reasonable and that I respect is this 25-year-old seems to have come to a decision. What I find completely unreasonable and just completely lathered with insecurity is his need to then project it and say it has to be true for everybody else as well. and the grand arcing statements of how it should never be just completely betrays, you know, what we've learned and how society functionally works. Like if you want democracy, the only sort of economic philosophy that's been partnered with democracy to work well is capitalism. And so if you want to change one, you're going to have to change the other.
And just the fact that, you know, with all of his education, the hundreds of millions of dollars, you know, didn't get a course in civics to understand that is kind of sad. I just before you go David I have to read one comment because it's so deranged that it almost seems like it was part of a script to like some billions or secession. Heirs whose wealth have come from specific sources sometimes use that history to guide their giving. That's a New York Times saying that. Pierce De La Hunt, a 32-year-old socialist anarchist, Marxist communist, or all of the above, has a trust fund that was financed by their former stepfather's outlet mall empire.
And this is Mr. I'm sorry, MX. I've never seen that before. De La Hunt. How do you pronounce Max Hunt? How do you pronounce MX? mx de la hunt takes non-gendered pronouns has anybody seen mx i've never seen that that was the first time yeah that's the first for me so i guess so you don't have to say mr or miss or miss it's like latinx where you just can group a bunch of people into one thing i got it um this is what uh mx de la hunt says i'm just trying to figure out how it's pronounced Maxis Hunt Dillahunt taking a shot Jason you're not showing respect for his pronouns I don't want to get cancelled it just is kind of hard to pronounce MX I don't mean to laugh but I need somebody to tell me how to pronounce MX.
com but this is the quote that is so insane when I think about outlet malls, and I think this is what we all think about when we think about outlet malls. When I think about outlet malls, I think about intersectional oppression. What's the first thing that comes to mind, Freberg, when you think of an outlet mall? Certainly it's intersectional oppression or a subway. Can I just point out, the New York Times has become a little bit cessationalist. If you were to ask statistically what percentage of people that are inheriting wealth they're going to be stupid like this, the answer would probably be pretty low.
But they find the one or two characters like this, and they build the story around them. And then people extrapolate that as if that is the persona of the entire population of people that are going to inherit some degree of wealth. And that becomes a story. And I'm just so sick of it. Like I don't read the New York Times anymore. And look, I love the New York Times. I would read it every single day. I still have it on my phone. I still pay for my subscription. But I'm so sick of the narrative being written by the author's objective. And then they go and find one or two facts that meet that narrative.
And rather than speaking about it statistically and saying we surveyed 100 people that were wealthy, this is how many. And if it was 60% of them saying, I'm going to go give away all my wealth and do crazy shit, great. Like that's the story. But again, picking an individual and building the narrative around that individual as if that is the whole kind of- But David, and that's the point. Like what they do is they don't even talk about people who want to give their money away. What they do is they create these caricatures around this like judgment it's all about this like judgment it's like I am holier than everybody else because of these decisions that I made and I just find it so offensive now can I just tell you I had my physical last week and I have a doctor in LA who's superb and he's in many ways sort of a philosopher king to me he's been incredibly important in my life and you know Dr.
Agus? I talked to his name is Christian Renna at Lifespan Medicine but anyways And here's what – and I talked to Chris about raising kids, and Chris has seen thousands of people over the course of his journey as a primary care physician, and he's seen the kids of these folks, et cetera. He boiled it down to me. It's like your job as a parent is to make sure that your children have incredible tools, married with incredible habits. And so some of these things are very simple, like food and how to eat and self-care and exercise. But some of these things are really important, which is a worldview, empathy.
And he uses this word, which is called awareness. And awareness is this idea that you understand the world around you. And that's an incredibly difficult thing for parents to be able to teach their kids. But it seems like if you could give them that, that's independent of anything other than time and care, right? It doesn't matter whether you're rich or you're poor. It doesn't really matter whether you're black or you're white. You can really teach the concept of awareness and empathy. And then the other thing that he taught me was, you know, there's a really big difference between folks like you, meaning guys like me, who grew up poor, and who are focused on the generation of money, right, meaning making money.
and some of you make it some of you don't but you're living in this existential threat that you feel is hanging over you and so you go out and you make it and a lot of it is driven by this insecurity you've had since you were young but make no mistake your children's lives is harder than yours and it's about the utilization of money and whether they want to give it away or whether they want to use it you have a responsibility to teach them whether you're given him a dollar, a million dollars or a billion dollars. And this is where I think somewhere along the way, these kids as parents, you know, may or may not have done the best.
Maybe they did the best they could. But somewhere along the way, these gaps are obvious, at least in the telling of the article. And this is where I go back to, if you're really going to talk about something like this, which actually is quite important, because again, we're going to go through the most enormous wealth transfer in the history of the world in the next 20 years, $30 trillion. So talk about that if if enough people took their inheritance and decided to eradicate student debt, it would be 3% of what's going to be inherited over the next 20 years. Think about it. So obviously, you can do some incredible things.
But it's not framed in the right way. It doesn't promote the right kind of discussion. And all it is is salacious reporting that makes these kids look like caricatures. And by the way, remember that money today is invested somewhere. So to pull that 3% out would have a kind of triple kind of rippling and kind of probably deleterious effect on on yeah these are lower no no forget about that it's factories family-owned businesses this is my point also is I think that there's a responsibility to these stewards of capital right they may be you can call them wealthy all you want but they really are the people that pull the strings or where money's moving and there's a I think you know to your point kind of a degree of responsibility that inevitably has to kind of sit with this group.
Here's the problem with it is if they just want to give their money away to a charity that they thought was worthy and they were willing to live like monks or something and not need money, that'd be fine. We could respect that. But the reason why they're in such a hurry to get rid of this wealth is because they feel like money itself is ill-gotten. That wealth itself is by definition ill-gotten. It must have come at the expense of somebody else, right? You only could have gotten that wealth by ripping people off. And that is the thing that that's the idea that's really pernicious about this sort of like socialism movement, is they don't really understand that the way capitalism works, you only get rich by selling something to somebody that they want that makes their life better, right?
I mean, all of us are engaged in the creation of new technologies and new products. And that makes the world better. And people are willing to pay for that. And that's what creates value. And that's what creates wealth. And it's really just kind of sad that people, you know, it goes beyond this article on these trust fund kids, but this whole condemnation of capitalism and this attack on any, you know, on billionaires or whatever. The problem with it is it doesn't recognize the way that value is created for everybody. Can I give you a quote from Walter Williams who just passed away who's a very famous economist?
Prior to capitalism, the way people amassed great wealth was by looting, plundering, and enslaving their fellow man. Capitalism made it possible to become wealthy by serving your fellow man. And that's really true. And somewhere along the way, folks have lost the script and have all of a sudden gone back to prehistoric capitalist times. And I think that we don't have enough good examples of constructive capitalism that prove that this is not a bad word. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I love the Walter Williams quote. Just to give another example, Jeff Bezos just gave $10 billion to climate change. $10 billion.
What's the kid's name? Teddy Schaefer or something like that, the journalist, has been riding him on Twitter. I think he works for Vox or something. They have basically been attacking Bezos since he made the announcement that he hasn't done enough. And it's like $10 billion is the largest contribution ever made to a single cause. I mean, obviously, Bill Gates gave it to his foundation. Right. And how did he do that? Because he created Amazon, which has created enormous value for all of us. Imagine if one of these kids in the article, instead of just giving their money away, by the way, it looks like there's a bunch of organizations that have sprung up to scam these kids out of their trust fund.
It's sort of, you know, a fool and their money are soon parted. There's a whole bunch of scam artists who are trying to scam these kids. But yeah, I mean, they're definitely getting scammed. But imagine if instead of just getting scammed out of their money, they were to use it to create a business that created a new product or technology that served people. then maybe they could turn that 30 million into 10 billion like bezos did and and if they lost it they would have done it in the pursuit of something really grand and so nobody would actually instead of virtue signaling instead of virtue signaling on the new york times yeah like these guys were so glad to be in the new york times to dunk on capitalists and dunk and literally dunk on their own parents think about that you hate your parents so much you have to go to the new york times and tell them how much you hate them i mean i don't know how this changes well by the way speaking of Virtue signaling in the New York Times.
Can we talk about the New York Times writing that hit piece on Coinbase? All right. I mean, if you want to go there, I mean, this is the third rail of the podcast. But we've been talking about Brian Armstrong. Just to set the table here, Brian Armstrong wrote a memo. He said, no politics at work. By the way, J.K.L., I just posted an image for Nick to put up here. Don't tell me it's a code 13 at Sachs again. No, this is not a code 13. it's a reinforce your point about the, you know, the virtue of capitalism, you know, this kind of dates back to these are three, three images, three charts from the year 1500 to today.
And energy use has grown 115 times. Well, so this is basically a measure of population, consumption and production, right? And so the the capitalist incentive has driven the ability while population has grown 14x over the last 500 years, it's driven a nearly 10x increment in what is available for humans to consume per capita during that period of time. I mean, think about that. That was driven entirely by industry. And so industry has enabled and production has increased by 240x. So we have a surplus of goods on planet Earth, and a surplus of access to goods because of the capitalist incentive over the last 500 years.
And who's right is it to say that that was wrong? And all of the people that are employed by it and live within that mechanism and who are no longer living in poverty who are no longer slain all of a sudden 50 000 people can virtue signal because they're sitting in their warm homes in america telling everybody else to fuck off i mean i find it kind of a joke i mean i i would like you to go and live you know where i was supposed to live before i emigrated right sri lanka no heater no roof no food etc that's what these kids should do they should go to north korea you go come to sweet luck i can show you you go to an outhouse okay you sit there you squat to go to the bathroom okay um there's no fucking three-ply you know uh bamboo you know press-free toilet paper to deal with um you know you you literally what you know you clean yourself with your hand you brush your teeth with coal i remember we used to brush our teeth with fucking coal okay we have a well for water and so you you have all these people in these situations where all we wanted was to just have a chance to run the race and the people that were born with a silver spoon in their mouth who had the chance to run the race turns around and tells guys like me no you can't and it fucking infuriates me yeah i want to blow up the racetrack by the way i want to just get rid of the entire i mean honestly fuck you it's a serious fuck you to these to these like they were well profited and they benefited from democracy and capitalism and now they want to revert back to a system where everybody who's in that system is trying to get into this system.
They don't understand what feudalism is because there are so many layers removed through their fucking filtered lenses and, you know, country clubs and bullshit vacations and all this crap that they have no idea what it's like. And I'm telling you, I am first generation of having escaped that shit, and I don't want anything to do with it. But the point is capitalism has allowed not just the US, but many other countries to change their course in life. um steven pickner's for all of the controversy he creates his books on um you know what humans have really achieved during this great kind of era of capitalism and industrialism and how we've changed our course on planet earth uh improved human health improved longevity improved calorie access to calories improved access to shelter to medicine um it's all because of a um an incentive a market based incentive system um and it is very very powerful it is the most powerful force we know as a species.
And it's allowed this incredible acceleration, exponential acceleration of possibility for our species. Also from the article, a great quote, Elizabeth Baldwin, a 34-year-old democratic socialist from Cambridge, Massachusetts. She plans to keep enough of her inheritance to buy an apartment and raise a family, enjoying the sort of pleasant middle-class existence denied to many people of color in the United States. what does i mean that's just i don't know i just i i don't see let's just move on it's so dumb they they they see they see the world in a zero-sum way where you know anything they have means that somebody else must it must have been taken away from somebody else they don't really understand the way that value is created by an exchange and by people creating new things and you know and and that's what technology is all about you know it's creating new things i mean there was a time when everybody didn't have access to clean water now we take that for granted there's a time when everybody didn't have access to affordable food and time and electricity and by the way look at how we started look all of this is driven by capitalism and look at how we started the conversation today alpha fold i think is the realization of one of the greatest capitalist enterprises in history if not the greatest you know alphabet and they're still getting started And the output of that is going to be an incredible new tool for drug discovery that is going to extend human lifespan in an incredible way.
There was a window of time where folks who are really, really good at bitching and complaining had a window of opportunity to bitch and complain. And what happened was they were not able to seize power. And then just in the last few months, literally, I think we are nailing that coffin shut. Because as you said, David, you're going to have to all of a sudden, like look at companies like Google and look at things like AlphaFold and reject them. And I don't know how people do because everyone will need something that that company will create now and that AlphaFold will be responsible for. We are all going to need a vaccine.
These are all coming from for-profit companies that thrived on top of R&D. You know, all of it was funded by past drug profits from other things. And so, you know, we're going to have to really look at ourselves in the mirror and say, did we not want that? Did we want to just die on the street to prove a point? And I don't think anybody actually wants that. I mean, what is the ultimate criticism of Amazon? They made iPhone chargers $5 instead of being $40. You can't have your cake and eat it too. You can't actually complain about Amazon on the one hand, complain about no action on climate change on the other, complain about this, complain about that, complain about the other thing.
Then you're just a fucking whiner. and nobody wants a whiner around because they're not additive they're not useful you don't learn anything from a whiner all right so looking at the uh new york times uh versus coinbase the foul new york times fake news sorry i'm just channeling trump okay foul new york times fake well talk about talk about whining this is more virtue signaling uh whining by the new york times and actually the look this was clearly a hit piece because they don't like brian armstrong's decision to make coinbase an apolitical workplace if any workplace has chosen to be political it's the new york times there's a lot of examples of that the fact that they ran barry weiss out of there they ran barry weiss out of the newsroom i mean this is these are the most editor page out that's right i mean they they ran james bennett out of there for publishing a an op-ed by tom Cotton.
Remember that? He got kicked out. He got forced to resign because he published one op-ed by a Republican senator. Okay. This is the most closed-minded group, the most closed-minded political workplace. And here they are lecturing a Silicon Valley company that in their view, isn't tolerant enough. I mean, it's ridiculous. And it was obvious that it was a hit piece. The stories, the examples in the article were years old. They weren't even reported to HR as violations at the time. So it's people cooking up things that weren't reported as problems at the time. But the really interesting thing about the story, I think, is the way Coinbase reacted to it by preemptively announcing that it was coming, which really made the New York Times reporters really irate.
You know, they called it extremely unprofessional. All the reporters were upset, and they threatened that they would no longer. The journalist said, if you guys are going to front run our stories, we are not going to call you when we have a story. And I responded to that, and I was like, are you serious? Like, you're literally going to lose what little integrity you have left about fact-checking because somebody wrote a preemptive blog post about I'll say this about Brian Armstrong. I have a lot of respect for him for making a stand. I think every CEO has that, right? And I'm glad that at the end of the day, the employees at Coinbase were given a humane way of making a decision to be on the same page with him or not.
I will also say that I thought that essay was not bill-written and that given the chance, I could have rewritten that for him in a much better way. I've maintained this the whole time, but I think he's in the right here. Wrap it up, David. Tell us what you think. Well, okay, that's interesting that Chamath is interesting to hear your support for Brian. So we've talked about it. This has become a recurring topic on the pod. But anyway, I think, you know, the important thing is the way that I think the tech community fought back against this hit piece. And it was, like you said, Jason, the front running of the story.
somebody a wag on twitter had a had a great comment saying you know um he basically said you know i try to walk up you i agree with the new york times on this i try to walk up to somebody and kick him in the nuts and they covered their groin you know how dare they you know uh how how unprofessional of them it was a slow motion kick to the nuts yeah exactly and so coming sunday It's Wednesday, but on Sunday, we're kicking you on the nuts. So yeah, the New York Times, the Coinbase just covered his groin so the New York Times can kick him in the nuts. And of course, the reporters all went hysterical about that.
But it was a really brilliant PR tactic by Coinbase because what it did is it almost like released a spike protein by sort of a pre-announcing New York Times story. It created this spike protein that trained the immune system of Silicon Valley to be ready for this pathogenic New York Times story. And the story just really fell flat. It didn't go anywhere. Yeah, it was. And they did the same thing with the away CEO. She was too hard on people in Slack. All of these stories to go full circle involve some leak from a Slack room. So if you're a CEO or you're managing anybody, don't have any difficult or legal issues discussed on Slack.
Go for a walk with somebody. Talk to them face-to-face because you're going to get destroyed. All right. Listen, everybody. This has been another amazing episode. We had 10 more stories we wanted to get to that we weren't able to get to. But while we were doing this, I asked my crack team. Sorry. At the syndicate. Whoa. What was that? to set up thesyndicate.com slash all in. So I'm not saying we're doing a syndicate. Yes, we are. We're going to figure out how to do something. We're going to do something to let the people who listen invest alongside us. We're going to figure it out in 2021 at some point.
But you have to write a review on iTunes. No, you just got to sign up. Just got to sign up at thesyndicate.com slash all in. If we do a folding protein company or a unicorn in the ISA space, maybe everybody who listens to the All In podcast gets to wet their beak for the Rain Man David Sack. Wet the beak. Wet your beak. Wet your beak. We need to get merch. I can't wet my beak. He's like the merch. The t-shirt guy that listens to us, we love you. There's a code 13, obviously. But wet your beak or wet the beak. We have to figure out which one's better. I think we have a new tagline for the pod.
Wet your beak. Wet your beak. Wet your beak and code 13. These are great merch opportunities for anybody who wants to go do merch. You can go do merch on your own. We don't care. We're not in the merch business. Put it up on your own website. Love you, besties. Love you, besties. So for bestie Rain Man, the dictator Chamath Palihapitiya, and the queen of quinoa himself, Metro Mile founder, spacker, piper, laying pipe and spacks everywhere. I'm Jason Calaghanis for the besties. We'll see you next time, which could be in a week or a month. Who knows? On the All In Podcast. Love you, Bessies.