Follow the besties:
https://twitter.com/DavidSacks
Follow the pod:
https://twitter.com/theallinpod
https://linktr.ee/allinpodcast
Intro Music Credit:
https://twitter.com/yung_spielburg
Intro Video Credit:
https://twitter.com/MikeSylvan
Articles referenced in the show:
The New England Journal of Medicine - BNT162b2 mRNA Covid 19 Vaccine in a Nationwide Mass Vaccination Setting
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2101765
San Francisco COVID-19 Vaccinations
https://data.sfgov.org/stories/s/COVID-19-Vaccinations/a49y-jeyc/
The Art Newspaper - WTAF? Beeple NFT work sells for astonishing $69.3m at Christie's after flurry of last-minute bids nearly crashes website
https://www.theartnewspaper.com/news/beeple-sells-for-christie-s-nft-art-auction-cryptocurrency
CoinDesk - Burnt Banksy NFT Sells for $380K in ETH
https://www.coindesk.com/burnt-banksy-nft-sells-for-380k-in-eth
CNBC - Beeple NFT becomes most expensive ever sold at auction after fetching over $60 million
https://www.cnbc.com/2021/03/11/most-expensive-nft-ever-sold-auctions-for-over-60-million.html
Glenn Greenwald:
https://greenwald.substack.com/p/criticizing-public-figures-including
https://greenwald.substack.com/p/journalists-start-demanding-substack
Tweets referenced in the show:
https://twitter.com/davidsacks/status/1370197389210914817
https://twitter.com/davidsacks/status/1370132006080708609
https://twitter.com/davidsacks/status/1370253867154247684
https://twitter.com/davidsacks/status/1370441843666690050
https://twitter.com/chamath/status/1369328384812093441
https://twitter.com/JTLonsdale/status/1369893590369964032
https://twitter.com/domm/status/1368605017238740994
https://twitter.com/CovidVaccineCA
Show Notes:
0:00 Biden's vaccine mandate, California's mishandling of the vaccine rollout, cancel culture impacting vaccine distribution
11:00 Vaccine efficacy, "inequity" of distribution
19:24 Success vs. privilege, Meghan Markle vs. The Royal Family
33:38 NFTs, speculative markets, blockchain as a ledger
48:00 Impact of inflation on wealth inequality
1:01:20 SPAC/Direct Listing talk
1:07:46 Yung Spielburg's newest track: RED PILLS
No summary for this episode yet.
does anybody have any thoughts on this i mean i think it's incredible um hey everybody hey everybody welcome to another episode of the all in podcast it's been a week it's been a minute with us today of course the queen of quinoa david friedberg and the rain man himself calling in from a nondescript mansion in one of 17 cities the rain man himself david sacks and cackling like a dictator who got his two billy back and he's back in the game chamath polyhapitiya for those of you he's re he's re-billionized he re-billionized is he gonna get a car with doors that go like this doors that go like this doors that go like this let's talk a little bit about the vaccine biden says everybody who's an adult is qualified by may 1st he's instructed the states to do that we are now hitting uh 2.
x million a day we had a 3 million shot day i believe friedberg and uh obviously the 1.9 billion dollar covid slash uh everybody gets a big slice uh bill got passed 1.9 trillion with a t sorry that's what i said 1.9 trillion no somebody put 1.9 billion in the notes yes 1.9 trillion uh 1.9 billion is what the covid as the covid nft went for the covid nft went for 1.9 billion as sacks said in the past a trillion here, trillion there. Soon enough, it's real money. Yeah. Yeah. Well, Biden's speech really kind of begged the question of why we still need this $2 trillion bill if COVID is going to be over in May.
But putting that aside, I think Biden's speech was very welcome in that he called for states to drop all of these crazy eligibility requirements that are actually preventing people from getting vaccinated at this point. He says that every adult Americans should be able to get a dose by May 1st. And he's right. And, you know, there's a sharp contrast with Gavin Newsom in California, who keeps playing political games with the administration of these doses. So, in California, yesterday, just yesterday, we added 250,000 more doses of unused inventory. So, the amount grew to 4.5 million unused doses sitting on a shelf.
only 215,000 people got vaccinated. So we're actually building inventory faster than we're building the population of people getting vaccinated. And it's because of all these crazy rules and requirements, you have to go make an appointment. And that really actually, it's counterproductive, because it discriminates against people who are less computer savvy, don't know how to navigate the website, or communities who don't want to enter their name in a government database, which there's a lot of people in California don't want to put their names in a government database. And so it works against those communities getting vaccinated.
At this point, we should just drop all the requirements, drop the website, let anyone who wants a vaccine just get in line and get vaccinated. It'll go much faster. The problem is that we throw around this word equity, and that we need to do something with equity. And in fact, I think that people who use that word are stupid. I think what they're trying to say actually is we don't want inequity. And the most inequitable thing is to actually take the most impoverished and fragile of the population and prevent them from actually getting the vaccine because they're the ones that actually need to be working and can't afford to actually not work or can't afford to be sick or can't afford to, you know, find solutions to childcare.
It's this weird word that like, you know, the extreme left uses now to describe policies that are just frankly poorly thought out and even more poorly executed. It might even be more pernicious than that. correct, Friedberg, in that anybody who gets a shot is helping everybody else because they are now a blocker in the system. I know this is incredibly simplistic. But I'm a simplistic guy. And it just seems to me that it's a different way of thinking about the benefit of vaccination. And I've said it in the past, but the benefit of vaccination is to get enough people vaccinated that the virus generally stops spreading, and then the pandemic ends.
And that's the objective. It's not about creating equitable protection for individuals. And as Americans, it's interesting, we think about it in terms of an individual benefit. It's like, how much do I get? What do I get from this vaccine? I want to get protected. The other guy's getting protected before me, who gets to go first, yada, yada. And it becomes this kind of competitive, you know, frothing for a vaccination. And the reality is, if we get enough people vaccinated fast enough, the pandemic ends. If we can get 200 million shots in arms, this goes back to I think this tweet I sent in in early January, December, we get 200 million shots in arms, we can be done with the pandemic based on you know, how many the efficacy of transmission rate reduction, combined with the fact that a certain number of people have already developed immunity to this thing, we get to the point that there should be kind of a, you know, think about a network, and you start turning nodes off the network suddenly becomes really hard to see transmission happen across the network.
And, and so the prioritization of, you know, who gets the vaccine over you know how fast we are deploying the vaccine has been a critical error from day one in my opinion um now look all that being said um i feel like we could sit here and criticize and argue about tactics and strategy uh all day long about this and you know make politicians look like idiots and administrators look like idiots but the truth is we are now seeing three million shots a day in biden's speech he said which if you'll remember is what i said we really should be targeting is about 1% of the population every day. And that's roughly where we are.
Biden said in his speech that we are on a war footing, which is effectively what we said the other day, the federal government is operating 600 mass vac sites. And we are right now getting shots in arms for all of the issues with prioritization and nonsense that's going on. I feel very in the United States. I agree that Biden has the correct posture on this, which is war footing. We are not doing that in California. I mean, I just talked about how we're building inventories. faster than we're getting vaccines administered. Newsom just announced that 40% of the vaccines are now going to be basically separated out and reserved for equity zones.
And, you know, it's- What does that even mean? It means that certain communities, only people in certain communities can get those vaccines. And they're going to be distributed out through this complicated system of local community groups. All that does is put money through some no-bid contract to some shitty technical company a bunch of consultants that then take advantage of the system, get paid hundreds of millions or billions of dollars to do nothing. I mean, I tweeted out there's this bot that now scrapes. And by the way, before I tweeted out this thing about this bot, which is I think...
Yeah, I sent it to you. It's the California vaccines available bot. Exactly. And all it does is it scrapes that myturn.ca website. But before that, in our group chat, there was another friend of ours who wrote his own scraper, if you guys remember. And it was really shocking because all it would show is page after page after page of completely open and available vaccine slots at the Moscone Center and other places. And you think all of this stuff is just a bunch of, I'll be blunt, rich white people sitting in a room with their head up their ass. And they come up with these stupid fucking rules and then they try to implement them with words like equity.
And all that happens is that you compound inequality. and let's go back and let's go back to freeberg's first point which is that all these unvaccinated people who can't get vaccinated faster become a giant petri dish for the virus to continue spreading and experimenting and morphing and morphing so maybe we actually do get a vaccine resistant strain the new strains the variants have been popping up so far are not a vaccine resistant but the longer the pandemic goes on the longer there's a chance that one could arise and then we're back to square one on this thing. So it's going to hurt everybody.
And here's the crazy thing is that, you know, I think we all know a lot of people, I know dozens of people who've been vaccinated in California, and they all come to me and tell me they're whispering about it, you know, because they don't want to tell anyone they got vaccinated. They're scared of being canceled. Because, you know, Newsom and the equity people have created this idea that if you get a vaccine, you're taking away from somebody else. In reality, you're not because anybody who's high risk has already gotten the vaccine by now or has had access to get the vaccine. And all you're doing right now, if you get the vaccine is taking a dose off the shelf where there's 4.
5 million doses sitting there and it's increasing by millions every week. And so what we need to do is, well, let me make a PSA actually. Starting on Monday, anyone in California can get the vaccine with a doctor's note. And they're saying that doctors have total discretion to give the note. So let you just make a PSA to everyone out there. If you're in California, just go get a doctor's note starting on Monday and go get the vaccine. Yeah, you know, stop, stop worrying about Newsom stupid rules. Let's also just remember, so two points on that not everyone has the ability to go just get a doctor's note.
It's really hard for people that have to go to public clinics and so on to get a doctor's note. What we are seeing is a lot of people just hacking the website, almost like Soviet Union era breadlines, where they go to the website, they type in something that's not true to get themselves a slot. And that's how a lot of people are kind of filling the void. The reality is, I just want to go back to the point I was making at the beginning. I think we're skating out of this thing. And I think that the inventory surplus, which is absolutely being built up at a staggering rate in the United States right now, if you look at the inventory forecast from J&J, Pfizer and Moderna, relative to the deployment rate of the vaccines right now, you are correct.
We're building up a surplus and inventory surplus And the rate of buildup per day is increasing right now. Is it 1 million extra shots a day? 2 million extra shots a day being put on shelves? Yeah, it's probably half a million to a million. And so we're building up an inventory. And so what happens- On top of the 30 million, we have already an inventory. So what's happening is there are natural market dynamics where what we are all pointing out and saying is starting to play out in terms of people kind of hacking the system. There's so much supply. There are many vac sites now. You can go to any supermarket, any pharmacy in California to get a shot.
And everyone's just clicking the box and saying, yes, I qualify, and they're going in and getting shots. So the market demand is starting to meet the supply, even though there are government and regulatory forces that are trying to inhibit that from taking place. And so I do feel pretty good when you look at kind of the inventory forecast, and you look at how many shots are being given per day, that in 45 days or so, we're going to get to a point that we're starting to skate out of this thing and kind of call it a day. Can I ask you a question? Despite the idiocy of the process that regulators have kind of put in place, yeah.
Freeberg, I just have a quick science question, because I was trying to find the answer to this, but I would love for you to tell us, what is the real efficacy of the vaccine and what is your transmittability, like your carrier status once you've gotten, for example, like, you know, let's just say you take the Pfizer vaccine, right? If you get the Pfizer vaccine, how many days until this is like pretty good? And, you know, like what is really the risk profile between the first shot and the second shot. I'll share this link, and then we can post it on the show notes, and people can take a look at it.
But it's an excellent paper published in the New England Journal of Medicine, showing basically a population of unvaccinated against Pfizer vaccinated with half a million in each population, half a million people. Yeah, and yeah, and they showed basically the accumulated infection rate, severe hospitalization rate and death rate of each of the two populations over time. And that really kind of I think highlights the efficacy of the vaccines and at what time period they become efficacious on each of those metrics. And by the way, even after the first dose across a population of half a million people, the margin of error on death shows that there may even be complete protection against death after the first dose of the Pfizer vaccine, within seven days of getting that shot pretty powerful statistic.
What just to describe the chart for those people listening, you have two populations and one's in blue, one's in red. And it's the time is, you know, in days on the bottom axis. And when you get to day eight, one line goes sideways and the other one goes keeps going straight up. So it's day eight after the Pfizer that you're basically protected according to this chart. And that's on the first shot. And like, I think it adds like one or two cases. Yeah, that's right. There have been zero deaths. So I think day eight is the day. and the second dose seems like to me you know it's just this unbelievable extra another amazing chart which maybe we can dump in the show notes is what's happening in san francisco we hit 10 000 shots a day at the end of february march 1st we're doing now 2 000 shots a day so we literally have dropped 70 or so we're at 3 000 shots i think from the peak yeah so this crazy wokeness is resulting in you know in this this virtue signaling that you know oh we can't give any shots to anybody unless we get this group first or that group first is now leading to everybody hacking the system the hack that i've heard is since teachers are getting it child care people and food service people are getting it people are now starting to get jobs at doordash or saying they're a teacher and if you check that box according to you know the back channel that i've heard you go get the shot and you don't get they don't ask you for anything other than your driver's license no one's checking it's just a driver's license the pharmacies the grocery stores the mass vac sites the sfdph california dph administered sites the federal sites no one's checking you sign up you check a box on the website it says i attest that this is true and then you go and show your id and get your shot and so a lot of people have kind of initially started skirting around the rules by going to be a doordash driver for a day or what have you and then saying i'm a food and ag worker And then now generally, people I think are just clicking on the box and going in and getting a shot.
Now, sorry, just to go back on the previous question, Chamath, I shared it figure two, Nick, in this paper I shared, particularly box E shows the deaths due to COVID-19 of a vaccinated population and non vaccinated population. And then it shows documented SARS-CoV-2 infection. And you'll see that you basically have almost no incremental infections in the vaccinated population starting around 28 days after your first dose. And so, you know, that's really when you could say you've got, you know, really good kind of protection from the vaccine and you're already starting to get the benefits early on.
Antibody studies have also shown that there's this big jump up that happens around that period of time. And so call it three weeks after your first shot and then in particular the fourth week. you're really kind of like locked in with a protective, you know, capacity. Now, your question around transmissibility is one that's still being studied, which is if I've got a vaccine, am I going to be able to pick up the virus and transmit it to someone else? Right now, you know, they're saying, well, we don't have evidence one way or the other. But I mean, generally, the way that the virus is spread is you develop an infection in your body, your body then makes lots of copies of the virus, and then you cough and spit them out in the air.
And that's how people get it. So theoretically, you could carry some virus on your mouth or on your nose where those cells don't have immune protectiveness and, you know, the vaccine, the virus is still alive, but it's not spreading in your body. You're not creating a lot of superfluous virus to spread in the world. So, you know, the basic science of it is you should not be spreading COVID if you've been vaccinated, right? I mean, you may have some on your skin or in your nose or something for a short period of time, but you're not going to develop a systemic infection that you're then going to kind of start exerting everywhere.
So, I think we should start to transition to this world of feeling really good and safe and enjoying ourselves yeah we hit 500 000 shots a day sacks in california and now we're down to 150 000 we've literally gone down two-thirds under the management of governor hair gel it's yeah i mean because because you know and and what was his in his state of the the state speech which went over like a lead balloon the the the most notable quote was we're not going back to normal. Normal was never good enough. Normal accepts inequity. So, because there might be some inequity in the world around the wrong person in line getting these doses, we're never going back to normal.
And he's basically ensuring that result by taking forever with these vaccines. But let me go back to this point about efficacy. So, I think Freeberg gave the stats on, look, the bottom line here is that vaccines work. That is the message we should be getting out to people is that they work. And the thing I've been really surprised by in the reactions that I'm seeing to my own tweets on Twitter about this is how loud the anti-vax voices are and how loud and sort of- When you say anti-vax, you don't mean not take the vaccine. You mean the vaccine doesn't work and we're never getting rid of COVID.
The forever COVID people. Yeah. Well, there's actually a lot of people on Twitter who got really angry. When I just tweeted, something about how it's over. It's over. I tweeted, it's over. Biden says we can all get the vaccine in May. If you decide not to do it, that's on you, the rest of us are moving on. And I got a lot of, all I was really saying is, look, once the vaccine's available, there's no need for any of these COVID restrictions anymore. But a lot of people interpreted that as me saying something that you should be forced to get the vaccine or something like that. Now, look, I don't think you should be forced to get it, but I think it's highly effective.
It works. But I'm surprised at how loud these sort of anti-vax voices are. It's usually like a conspiracy theory around the vaccine. And I think part of the reason why those voices are so loud is because they're unopposed, because all the people who believe in the vaccine are getting it, but they're all afraid of, like you were saying, J. Cal, of being canceled. And so there's a conspiracy of silence around this. You know, what we all need to be saying is, look, go get vaccinated. It works. Take the win. America, take the win. We screwed this thing up for 14 months. Can we just take the goddamn win and move on?
I'll give you a little thing that always pops into my mind in all of these things. Whenever I hear some politician or some like naval gazing intellectual use the word inequity, I think like this is a power grab. Because the word equity is really about ownership. whereas the word equality is about balance right and and power hungry politicians love the word equity and inequity because it's their opportunity to grab power and to tell us how things should be done or to do things differently in a way where you know they can enforce their mandate which is typically ill-formed and not very smart and i would just encourage all of us whenever you hear the word equity or inequity this huge huge red light should be going off in your head saying Whatever this person says next is a crock of horseshit and it's probably a power grab.
Whereas if you hear people really talking about solving inequality, there's really no mechanism to solve inequality through power. Well, I think that's a great point around the language that gets used. And I have a similar concern about the way that the word privilege gets used. We used to have a term in this country called success. People were successful or not. And success had a connotation of being earned. whereas privilege has a connotation of being unearned. Well, I mean, now sometimes privilege is earned success and sometimes it's unearned. But when you start using the word privilege to describe all success, it implies that there's something unjust or unearned about it and it needs to be reallocated.
So that to me is another one of these political words is we shouldn't be confusing success with privilege. They're two very different things. I have an example of this. Oprah Winfrey is successful. Prince Henry has privilege. Has privilege. Has privilege. I shoehorned the Meghan Markle story. I mean, I do want to talk about the Meghan Markle story, actually, at some point before the end of this podcast. But before we do that. Let's do it right now. Okay. Joe Lonsdale actually also had a tweet, a pretty unapologetic set of tweets around, you know, the miscasting of this concept of privilege. And I thought it was really on point.
I really agreed with what he was saying. And it's effectively what you're saying, David. It's like people right now I find are just so – well, not people. The people that take the time to wallow in Twitter mostly, at least as I interact with them, are just so bitter. And I think that there is no magnanimous happiness for other people's success anymore. I think we live in a culture now where everybody feels it is so zero-sum when it's not, in fact, zero-sum. And people just begrudge other people's success, especially, by the way, when it's earned. And the reason is because there's an entire generation of people of all different ages, but this last five or ten years who tapped themselves out.
Now, some were legitimately prevented from success, but there's a lot of people that bought into this narrative of, wow, it's a whole conspiracy that's set up against me, so I'm not even going to try. And they are often the loudest and the most embittered. Absolutely. And the reason is because, you know, everybody wakes up in their 40s and 50s and starts to rationalize their choices in their lives. And what they really feel deep down inside is, oh, my God, I just let an entire decade go by of blaming other people. Yeah. And I think there's a surprisingly large amount of that. This ideology of victimization doesn't teach people the right things because you start to think that, you know, if you're wallowing in your oppression, that you don't have agency over your own life.
You're blaming other people for not being successful, not getting ahead when what you should be doing is focusing on working and improving your own life and getting ahead. Or also just redefining what happiness means. Happiness doesn't mean what that other person has and then saying, because I don't have that, I have nothing. happiness is really like introspectively figuring out like what really makes you complete and i mean not to get too syrupy about it but it's like that's what we've also lost the script on so when you when you put all of these things together there's just a bunch of people that sit on the sidelines they either are too scared to enter the arena or they don't want to enter the arena they don't want the failure that comes from it because they've grown up in a culture where you know they had the kindergarten soccer ball handed to them the gold star in everything they've ever done It's a patient trophy.
And now what we really need are people in the arena more than ever. Folks trying and failing and it's okay. And there's just not enough of them. What instead is there's just a lot of people who just want to bitch and complain. And I think this is the backlash to the Meghan Markle interview is this miscasting that this is an extremely privileged person or, you know, Harry and Meghan both are very privileged. But I think what they're trying to do by making all these sort of accusations of racism against their own family is they're trying to ground that privilege in victim status. And this is the thing about privilege is privilege is a social concept.
It's got nothing to do with success, which is either earned or unearned. And so, the way that people get to maintain their privilege is that, again, they ground it in some sort of victimization. It creates these very perverse incentives. My reaction to the Meghan Markle Prince Harry interview was the following. I had a lot of sympathy for what she was saying. But on the other side, I also thought, you must have known what you were getting into on the way in. and there was it was be and now and look i'll say this as a canadian and a sri lankan so the queen and the monarchy is an increase like it's i can't describe to you guys because you're not part of the commonwealth but it is just a definitional definitional part of who we are as we grow up and i don't know what the equivalent american construct is i guess there isn't one really um and so you know the monarchy is an incredibly important thing but we all know that it's this kind of like anachronistic thing that just kind of i don't look for us it's not bullshit like i mean like if you said to me despite all my bullshit and raging against the machine and society and blah blah blah and stature and whatever if if i could be invited to meet the queen i would be there in eight nanoseconds well i think the equivalent is the presidency we we actually feel that way about the presidency like going to visit the president is a big deal the presidency is not an endowed kind of circumstance there's something about there's something about the queen my point is though we all know a that it's important it's a great symbol of of the commonwealth i'm very proud of all of that but we also know it's anachronistic and it doesn't make much sense and so what what do you uh what do you think you were marrying into and i think you know my perspective was i felt bad for her i can't believe you know it got to the place where like people wouldn't get help for her when she was sick.
And, you know, and then they were questioning Harry's or the kids, Archie's skin color. I mean, this is insanity. Like these people are stuck in the 1800s. But then you realize they are actually stuck in the 1800s, because they're not allowed to have a normal life. They're not allowed to actually interact. So, you know, are they at fault? Or they or is the system that creates these sort of like voyeuristic, you know, exotic animals in a zoo that we call the king, the queen, these princes is the system at fault. I don't know. I was kind of like 50-50 on the interview, but my perspective was the monarchy is in a really tough spot over the next 30 or 40 years because again, so now let me tell you where my belief is.
I'm kind of a little bummed by the whole thing. The monarchy doesn't mean what it used to mean for me. David, what was more enthralling to you this week? Tucker versus Taylor or the queen versus Oprah and Prince Henry. I didn't spend a tremendous amount of time on either one. I mean, look, if I were Harry, I would probably do the same thing, which is to basically leave. Look, the first thing I did in my career was quit the firm, right? Who wants to work for a firm? It's very tracked. So, I don't blame him leaving, going to California. That's what we all did, right? I mean, he was being, that's a very, that's a very entrepreneurial American thing to do.
What I had a problem with was the way that they're attacking their own family because they're being paid $7 million to do this interview. No, no, no. Hold on. They were not paying. There was the first question Oprah asked and they were very clear they were not getting paid. Now, they did sign $100 million. Who made the $7 million then? No, Oprah did. Harpo did. Oh. Well, she's a genius. Yeah, she's a genius. Oprah got paid again? Oprah is our queen. that's the queen of america oprah is the queen oprah figured out a way to get paid it's even worse it's even worse if they did the interview for free and didn't even get a piece of the back end so all they did was attack and besmirch their family uh for for none of that and look i i i guess my my point is so so why would they do it if it's not even about the money i mean it's about this idea of defining their privilege grounding it in victim status and i think there's something very fake and phony about that and i think that's why people had this uh reaction to it where frankly they were i i don't think they're on the side of the royal family because it's it is outdated but i think the there was a lot of skepticism towards what harry i had a little bit of a problem with the like live from our 15 million dollar montecito mansion no jason our victimhood i mean it was that was not for that house that was a friend's house they have a 15 million dollar i know but they also have a 15 million dollar house next to oprah well who paid for that they put 5 million down they no it's public they put 5 million down and they took out a mortgage it's uh someone listed this whole thing no it's an honest question does the do the taxpayers of the uk fund the princes that's the whole point they went and did a deal with netflix and they start and spotify and now they have a salary and they're making money like everybody else so i mean i'm not i'm not i don't have an issue with any of that no i don't have an issue with that i thought the taxpayers were funded the lifestyle they do fund the lifestyle of the other princes right sure yeah so i mean that's the thing we talk about something important yeah okay so a people nft sold for 69 million dollars i mean this week this week was crazy all the dumbest shit happened this week taylor lorenz to this week you know dumb shit slaughtered on well yeah dumb shit so i miss i miss tucker versus taylor but actually that the real uh the person who took on taylor that did a brilliant job was glenn greenwald i don't know i don't know if you guys read his post but that was brilliant savage brilliant and basically what he said is that look you've got these class of reporters out there who their job is to go out and they're like little hall monitors you know trying to bust people for whatever they might say in a clubhouse room not just public figures but private people too they're in the business of destroying lives and reputations you know that that's basically their business model but then the second anyone has any criticism for them they claim it's harassment which is just absolute nonsense and they want to be they want to be immune from criticism the only person that was inoculated against social justice wokeness to write that article is glenn greenwald because he is you know he's gay he's got brown kids he lives in brazil you know with uh i mean it's it's fat it's like you can't well he's not irresistible force moving the immovable object.
He's not completely immune because he was attacked, you know, and people said pretty nasty things about him, but yeah, he definitely has some... I think Greenwald is an unbelievable writer who calls it like he sees it. I don't agree with everything he says all the time, but, you know, he's right to call this stuff out. There was another bunch of social justice nonsense this week as well. This poor guy had to, like, give out this crazy apology tweet because he said he liked to exercise. Oh, you're talking about John. Wait, what is that story? Okay, this is the great. Okay, there's a kid named- Because I've been telling you, Jason, I want you to exercise because I love you.
I lost 20 pounds. Look at me. I'm looking pretty good. And for Saxapoo. I want both of you guys to exercise. I'm feeling good. Tell me about it. By the way, public service announcement. COVID vaccine CA is the bot. So, at COVID vaccine CA. Yeah, at COVID vaccine CA. It just tweets every five minutes, a hundred different places you can go pretend to be a DoorDash driver and get a shot. Sorry. I mean, if you were a DoorDash driver- Check the box and get vaccinated. Check a box. Check the box. Check a box. Check a box vaccinated. Let's go. Let's roll people. Don't let Newsom take away your health.
Yeah. Don't let Newsom put you in a noose. Don't focus on equity. Yeah. Meanwhile, he's at like French Wondries. Jason, tell us about this tweet thing. What happened? There's a kid named Dom. He's an entrepreneur. He's building a company. It's a good company. It's funded by Stripe. You know, it's raised hundreds of millions of dollars. Like, good for this guy. Yeah. But he likes to like, you know, he's kind of like trying to engage on Twitter. And he basically said, I feel so much better. and I'm performing at such a higher level since I got my diet and my exercise right. I mean, people who are not getting their physical right are really underperforming at work.
It's such an opportunity or whatever. And then, you know, the large and in charge, you know, fat is beautiful, you know, contingent basically tried to cancel him. Sorry, wait, wait, but did he say that you have to be skinny? No, he just said you will perform. If you're fat, you're underperforming, basically. He didn't use the word fat, but he said if you're not in shape, you're underperforming at work, which I said, is there science behind this? And yeah, sure. People showed me 100 studies that show if you lose weight, you have better concentration and focus. I mean, it's pretty obvious. But he did the cardinal sin as a here, here, I'll read you the tweet.
An important lesson I learned well into my career, if you are not physically fit and healthy, then you are underperforming at work, pretty basic, probably not a very controversial, but he did what David Sachs always advises and the the the advice he gave to Trump, which is never apologize. And he apologized, Dom apologized and took the tweet down, which then the mob really went after him. And he said, I screwed up. And I'm extremely sorry. I have recently spent a lot of energy focused on my fitness eating and sleep in my enthusiasm for my new fitness regime. i posted a tweet that was meant to celebrate my new healthy lifestyle but that's not how it came across and i see now how incredibly sensitive my original with all the problems that we have that need fixing i mean this is what people were focused on this but no but here's the kicker of the apology this is something i really need to improve on and i will well no i'm not making fun of him i just think it's sad that it came to that what the hell is going on no but i mean don't apologize if you believe being healthier is you know good then you should say it and you know let the chips roll with it people can debate it but i mean can't we have a debate about that because this is in the middle of a covid crisis when the top two vectors are age and obesity period if you're fat you die from covid that's that's how it works and you got both those problems you're old and fat you guys didn't say stupid all right i'm doing good today all right today in uh all in nonsense apparently there's so much money in the system that an nft just sold for 69 million dollars after we talked about the previous one bill lee bought for six million dollars i don't know that he bought it for six million dollars but somebody bought one last week nfts seem like a real thing it's reasonable to trade stuff but 69 million dollars i think it's incredible i mean like like the the i saw the breakdown of like the number of bidders.
Here, let me actually just get this data up, because I think you guys will find it really incredible. My thesis on this, or my theory, rather, is that there are a bunch of people who have stakes in these crypto assets. And then they all premeditate decide to buy up these NFTs to get the market started. And then once it started, like Jason, that's art, right? You know, this, but I've been buying art for a decade plus. And this is exactly how it works in the art market. You know, we go in there, certain people will go and buy. And then what the gallerist says is, oh, did you know that Chamath just bought this piece or such and such a person bought this other piece?
And then all of a sudden the price spins up and then they feed into it. I mean, this is where, you know, an enormous amount of money has been made by gallerists over the last 20 or 30 years. Now it just happens in a different medium. So the bidding breakdown, by the way, of this NFT is incredible. 33 active bidders. 91% of the bidders were new to Christie's. 55% came from the Americas 27% of bidders were from Europe and 18% were in Asia the age breakdown is the most interesting 6% were Gen Z so 97 to 2012 58% of bidders were millennials 94 and between 81 and 96 wow 33% Gen Xers and 3% baby boomers so this is really like a transitional change in you know basically deciding what's valuable and I don't think this I don't think this was any different than you know when you had this transition from you know sort of impressionist in the art world like if you moved from the body of work where you know these impressionist paintings were just going for high tens low hundreds of millions of dollars and i think it peaked around van gogh um and then you know basically it went from there off of a cliff where you can basically give away impressionist paintings uh and everything went to contemporary and you know sort of like this post-modern stuff and that was a decisional change by boomers what is what does giveaway mean to you chamath so i think on the nft stuff and and people he's people is the artist there's there's two things going on right so one is on a technology level nft is non-fungible tokens there they are it's a legitimate technology for creating provenance on a blockchain you know if a piece of art um basically gets put on a blockchain, you have perfect provenance.
But that doesn't mean that all NFTs are valuable. In fact, most of them won't be. It's just a technology. Then you have the other thing that's happening is on an art level, what these sort of prestige galleries and so on, they're saying that Beeple is now a major artist. And the reason someone becomes a major artist is because they usher in or become representative of some new wave of art, Like Jamal is saying, you've got impressionism, you've got modernism. I mean, the reason why Jackson Pollock sells for whatever, $100 million. No, no, no. 300 to 600. Okay. It's because he represents an important wave in art.
And some of those waves fizzle out and they turn into Ponzi schemes and some of them become real. And people are speculating that this digital art will be a major wave. And they're saying that Beeple is the most important artist and they're kind of betting on that. Now, do I think it's going to last? I don't know. I mean, hard to say. You said the key thing, though. The key feature of NFTs, which I think is amazing, is that you can actually have ownership and provenance written into a blockchain. Now, you take that abstraction. You can apply it to all kinds of surface areas, and it makes a ton of sense.
Any kind of other asset would make sense if you own a car, if you own clothes, if you own watches, if you own wine. What happens if you own a house? Now, all of a sudden, if you can prove ownership over this stuff, not only can you trade it, but you can also borrow against it. And I think that that is a really interesting idea where once you financialize all of these physical assets that we own, you do eliminate an enormous amount of inequality in the system because you can actually get real transparent pricing. Yeah, blockchains are a ledger, right? They're a perfect ledger system. And so, like everything, every type of possession that relies on title should eventually be blockchained.
So, Art's a good example. You know, I helped found a company back in 2017 called Harbor, which was a blockchaining real estate. And it ended up getting acquired. Acquired or acquired? No, it got acquired. Don't worry, Tamath. Don't worry, Tamath. We're going to make money. We're going to make money. As an LP, I just wanted a clarification. Yeah, no, we're not going to make like SPAC type money, but we'll make a little bit of money on that deal. So don't worry. But yeah, look, I think we're in the early, early stages of this type of technology. You're going to see eventually blockchaining of every type of asset where title is important.
David, I think that this is such an amazing idea because if you think of all of the opaque lending markets where people can't get access to reasonable cost of capital and they own assets. You end up in these crazy worlds where if you look at the housing crisis or the great financial crisis, there was so much crazy lending, but behind that lending was double, triple mortgages. It's happening right now in the car market. All of that stuff doesn't necessarily need to exist because if you have clear provenance and the ability to price risk, people can borrow a reasonable amount of money at a reasonable rate and pay it back.
You can trade assets, you can sell assets. It's a really big deal, I think. I think if you take a zoom out on the, you know, the notion of what an NFT represents, it's, it doesn't feel too dissimilar from other, what I would argue is like nonproductive assets. Like if you think about where one's capital goes, where an individual puts their capital, the first thing is kind of essentials, right? Things you need like food and medicine and housing and clothing and whatnot. And then you kind of enter into these kind of, you know, non-extend, you know, kind of discretionary spending for a consumer, you know, nice stuff, nice clothes, luxury goods, things that are basically going to diminish.
Then as you think about allocating the leftover capital, you're either going to allocate your leftover capital into investable assets that are either productive or non-productive. A productive asset is something you buy that you expect to return. it produces some value for you as you own it, such as owning a home where you get the value of living in it or owning a car where you get the utility of driving around in it, or owning a bond, which issues a, you know, a, you know, a coupon or a stock that's going to, you know, generate cash flows at some point in the future, theoretically. um the non-productive assets are these assets that are just not designed to do that but they're a store of value that you expect at some point to realize some return um you know because someone else will pay a higher price to you for that non-productive asset this is like a piece of art or you know some piece of gold or something you know something that you kind of hold or you know more increasingly you know digital assets and it seems like the explosion in digital assets is you know, as Jason pointed out at the beginning, like, as we've kind of moved to a highly kind of overvalued segment of productive assets, as things that market is very frothy, it's very difficult to kind of find productive assets that are worth putting capital into, there's continually more interest in nonproductive assets across the board, because there's excess capital in the system.
And it turns out that when that happens, there's enough of a market dynamic that emerges in nonproductive assets, it gives people a reason to put their capital in and expect to have a return on them in the future. As soon as the market starts shrinking, as soon as you start having effects that are deflationary, money will pour out of that market in general. That's always what happens with the art market and has for hundreds of years. And it's the digital means of kind of realizing that same market transition that Shemar talked about. My question is, do you get the rights? I guess this is a dependent on the terms that are set in the smart contract.
But in the case of the Beeple, if I were to buy it for 69 million, do i have the rights to it so that i can print t-shirts and sell hundred dollar t-shirts that's what can i create 10 000 that's a more of these can i monetize it is what i'm asking that's a great great great question i i don't know but that's a fabulous question by the way because the alternative like as you pointed out the artist and and other folks have rights to art um even though the original painting is what's sold you know the original um master of a bruce spring sting song could be sold to a collector but the rights the rights on that track for reproducing it making money off it are owned by a publishing house so you can own the physical magnetic tape but not own the rights to exploit it over time those rights fall away so if you think about what that nft represents it represents that particular chain of electrons and you know this is this is these bite these bits that represent this image um and it's not necessarily make a hundred more and then he could change he could change one pixel theoretically or two pixels and he could go print a bunch of stuff and go not right not really because those images were ones that he had he had this rhythm of creating like one a day i think for a very long period and he contributed them all into this master right exactly so there's a this is a it's a one of one another interesting uh one of one that just happened was these uh performance artists or i guess like underground digital artists uh bought a bank seat for 125 or 125 000 i get thousands and millions confused um just that's a joke everybody that's a that's a douche joke you want to use for this episode is hashtag cancel chamath go ahead uh yeah good luck good luck uh anyways these four guys bought this Banksy for $125,000.
They brought it to a warehouse in Brooklyn. They took a high res image of it. Okay, so they took a picture of it. And they created a one of one NFT, right? Okay, then they created a YouTube video of them burning the original Banksy. so now all you had was the digital manifestation of this physical thing wait for it and then they sold it for three hundred and like fifty thousand dollars so they three x their money it's the most incredible story um i can find the link and i'll put i'll put it in the show notes as well but it just shows you what's happening and then i also think last thing on nfts i saw that i think it It was like Kings of Leon just put out an album and it was like, it's like 50 bucks for a song or something like that.
And it comes with like a bunch of interesting content. So it's the beginning of something, guys. I just think that you need sort of like popular content to get this movement going. But it seems to me like this is what people want to do. They want to own digital assets. They want to have provenance. They want to have custodial relationships with it. They want to basically. But it's just like art and posters, right? Anyone can put the poster up in their room. Anyone can buy a copy for five bucks, but who owns the original and owning the original may be visually identical, maybe graphically identical.
But it is truly about that notion of that theoretical human mind construct of ownership that creates that distinction. And you just effectively have to count on other human minds believing the same thing in the future for you to be able to reclaim that value, that monetary value, or you're going to take a loss on it. I mean, Chamath, have you ever sold art that you bought? You know, I've sold very little. I tend to buy and accumulate with this idea of eventually endowing something with just because it's like, you know, I think there are two ways to buy art. One is speculatively and the other one is to tell a story.
I took the second path. And so, you know, it's stuff that means a lot to me. So, it's hard for me to part with it, even though it sits in a freeport in Delaware. So, it's not exactly, you know, out and about. with this idea that at some points people will get to really enjoy it once by the way i mean one of the things that happens in the art world and correct me if i'm wrong on this but you buy this art and you don't ever a lot of art doesn't get resold so everyone kind of buys it under the notion that it's going to be worth more in the future and they can sell it for more but very few people actually do end up selling it no no no this is so here's in the trading market right but like i mean generally like a lot of collectors end up endowing art or or gifting it and when you gift it you get an appraisal done and you get a deduction on the appraised value right and so you can definitely do it that way so uh one one interesting story is that um one of the large auction houses has a financial arm and uh the most incredible thing is like over like the last 50 years um their cumulative default rate was 30 basis points on their book like cumulatively not like a year or a month but ever nobody defaults but because they borrow money for the purposes of maybe buying other things or whatever and then they will very you know trade out of things and trade up to things and trade across things but it's a very vibrant market of buying and selling it just happens to be very informal and a little bit closed and very much for insiders.
And, you know, another reason that I think that NFTs will will change because it'll will change this is that it just makes it available to everybody. Because you put all art on a very level playing field. And really, at the end of the day, what is art? It's a commentary on society. And I think that having that level of transparency on that kind of stuff is, I think is going to be really valuable because you don't want one or two people who you fundamentally disagree with as being a tastemaker for a kind of art that you think is fundamentally flawed. right you'd rather it's just it's no different than being able to go to 95 different media sites to read the content you want or you know being able to listen to a thousand different kinds of music all of it in its totality is a commentary on society and i think what society says is we want transparency and we want choice and this is where i think like that's why so i think this is a good a good dovetail into what's happening with the stimulus bill and where we started which was is this even necessary um we have uh stimulus checks going out in the amount of two thousand dollars per individual in households with under 150k i believe is um the income level which means people who were not impacted by financially in any way by what's happened under covid are going to get in a family of five ten thousand dollar checks uh even if nobody was laid off or that's only that's only like nine percent of the bill jason yeah i mean so it's it was 450 million out of 1.
9 trillion so what do we think the impact we sort of have two questions i have a working theory oh sorry go ahead jason what are your general thoughts on this is it necessary and then two what's the what are the second order effects that we each predict will happen over the next 18 months when all of this capital gets injected so the latter is what i've been focused on trying to figure out. And I saw some really interesting data, which basically, I'll ask you guys the question, because maybe you guys know the answer. But if you measure wealth inequality, when do you guys think was the most recent period where there was the least wealth inequality, the least?
Sorry, how do you define that? You can measure it like the Gini index, or you can measure it as like, you know, the gap between the top decile and the bottom decile, in terms of wealth and accumulated assets. Well, would it be before the robber barons? No, it was the- Or between the robber barons and now? The period of the least inequality in recent history was in the late 70s, which is an incredible stat to say where the gap between the top decile and the bottom decile was like, you know, kind of like on an index, like 60, 65, whereas today it's sort of like at 100. Now, what happened then? And this is really interesting.
Wasn't that an inflationary period? There you go. So what happened? And as it turns out, inflation is a phenomenal way to decrease levels of playing field. Absolutely. It decreases people's richness. So it makes rich people poorer. That's really the most effective tool that you have to recalibrate. It's very, very hard to redistribute money. And I think every attempt at doing that has largely failed. But the one consistent way, and if you go back periods before that, you know, into the beginning of the... But in an inflationary environment, borrowing costs go up. So, you know, businesses and people that rely on borrowing to grow their net worth or investing assets to grow their net worth kind of suffer more than people that have a home, have a, you know, wages go up in an inflationary environment, right?
Wages go up, which actually, if you think about like what you said before, like, you know, as people get wealthier, they move their money into, you know, essentially financial assets and away from sort of like working assets. And when, you know, interest rates go up and the risk-free rate goes up, then the attractiveness of those assets go down. Yeah. And so what happens is shares in technology companies go down. But what actually also happens is that your cost of capital for a traditional business, because it's higher, they have to then charge more, which means that they're paying their employees more.
And those folks, on a marginal basis, tend to then take those dollars and spend those dollars. So inflation is this very productive mechanism of actually redistributing wealth. And homeowners benefit. Homeowners benefit as well. But it shrinks the wealth. inequality. Mild inflation. Mild inflation is probably good. It's better than probably deflation. But if it tips over into hyperinflation, then it destroys everyone's savings, right? And rich people have the ability to protect their assets against inflation a lot better than middle class people do. So, you know, you look at like Venezuela, Weimar, Germany, hyperinflation.
People got out. Yeah, people just hyperinflation destroyed the value of, of, of, where are we seeing inflation? Where do we anticipate we'll see inflation? I saw today Tesla's Tesla raised the price on all their cars except for two. Well, they have to because the inputs of, you know, if you think about like, if you break down a Tesla and you look at where the money goes, the money really is in the batteries. And if you break down the batteries, it goes into three critical inputs, lithium, nickel and cobalt. And the prices are highly suspect and they're very poorly predicted. And so the cost of Tesla's are going to go up by 20 or 30%.
And there's nothing that there's nothing that Tesla could do. And by the way, you'll see this across all commodity products if inflation takes hold in a meaningful way. including, you know, food products, ag products, you know, all commodities, you know, metals, but the businesses that will benefit the most, and this is really interesting from a technology perspective, and I think it played in part, my understanding is speaking to a number of PMs about this portfolio managers at funds, is that, you know, technology companies don't have a lot of hard assets. And so they have less kind of, you know, value accretion, and they don't play in a commodity supply chain.
So it's much more difficult for a technology company to say raise rates by 30%, whereas a food company can raise rates by 30%. One of the ways to look at this is to look at the, you know, the book value or the capex, you know, property, plant and equipment of a business and businesses that have a lot of pp&e are generally going to do better in an inflationary environment, they're going to have more throughput on that pp&e, they're going to have higher dollars per unit of pp&e. And so you'll see, you know, this is why there was a shift of dollars into what are traditionally called kind of value stocks, or, you know, kind of bigger industrial companies, away from, you know, softer kind of tech companies, which don't really, really benefit from this inflationary trend.
And so there's going to be, you know, some sort of play out in those sorts of products, probably more J. Calvin. I think, David, do we see it in SaaS? Because I've noticed that SaaS prices are going up, and that people are just keep adding to the price of these sas products i was pricing out all the virtual conference you know stuff like hop in and all that air meet and whatever and i was just shocked at how much they wanted to charge you know 15 50 100 000 a year and i was like but can i use like zoom and this for that you know in a chat room slack room and are we going to see it happen in sas where people are going to start raising the prices and just increase their profit margin because their employees are going to demand more money because they're part of this cycle i i think that's a function of pricing power going up for SaaS companies, they become more established and entrenched.
Those companies are very profitable. I don't think they're experiencing wage pressure in any way. I think that they're just becoming more successful. Their pricing power is going up. As they become not necessarily monopolist, but as they have more market share and they dominate their categories, they can increase prices. But I want to go back to this idea of the 1970s. I want to challenge the idea that the US economy was doing well in the 1970s. So, Chamath mentioned the Gini Index. There was a different kind of metric called the Misery Index that was a much more popular index that was used around that time.
And the Misery Index, it was defined by a Brookings economist, and it was basically the sum of the unemployment rate and the inflation rate. And in 1980, the misery index was 19.7%. This is why Ronald Reagan got elected is because you had a CPI, which the inflation rate of 12.5%. And then you had unemployment of another 7.2% on top of that. And, you know, the 1970s were, especially the late 70s, were an economic disaster for the country. So, maybe things were more nominally equal, but everyone was equally, more equally poor. And what you saw in the 1980s is that they got inflation under control.
Paul Volcker at the Fed broke inflation. That lowered interest rates enormously that allowed people to buy homes. The stock market went up and it was an economic boom. So, I don't know that this idea that we want to introduce a lot of inflation into the system is a good idea. Like I said, I think mild inflation of say, 2% is better than 2% deflation the other way. But I think we should be very careful here about inflation and making sure it doesn't get out of control. And the other index to look at is the quality of life index, which is typically, you know, healthcare, and then the property price to your income ratio, commuting, pollution, safety and those kind of things and you know the united states is 15th on that list with obviously the nordics and australia germany new zealand just being at the top of those rankings in america we've never really thought about that right we don't really even discuss happiness you know and that and that quotient we don't index for that happiness and low stress i think we're talking a lot about quality of life in san francisco now because that's a community that's very rich and And yet it's a miserable city to live in because crime is out of control.
You know, Jason, you and I have been focusing on this DA, Jason Budin, who's had an enormous impact on people's quality of life because he's simply not prosecuting theft in the city. There was actually a crazy tweet where a city council member was inside City Hall calling for a hearing on the rampant rise in theft in the city. And meanwhile, his car was broken into right outside City Hall. I mean, you can't make this stuff up. And then the other thing that came out were a whole series of statistics about crime in San Francisco showing – or sorry, trials and convictions. Basically, Chesa has not been conducting any trials.
He hasn't been convicting anyone. It turns out that the number of trials and convictions that he's gotten in the 14 months he's been DA is one-tenth of what Gascon got when he was DA. And by the way, Gascon's not the model DA or anything. I mean, Gascon is facing a recall in LA for dereliction of duty, and he's still 10 times more productive than Chesa Boudin. Just a quick update. Many of you, when I mentioned the GoFundMe to put a journalist on Chesa, if you just type in GoFundMe Chesa, C-H-E-S-A into the Google, we added $8,000 since last week. So we have $58,000. That's going to a journalist and a data journalist to cover this exact issue.
So thanks to the folks who donated. I'm not taking any money from it. I'm donating, obviously. Other than a small finder's fee. No, $0. I'm donating to it. I basically said I'll be 1% of it, whatever the final number is. I think the Marina Times has done a great job with this. Yeah. And there have been a couple other sources as well. But how dishonest was it? I mean, this has been a recurring theme on the pod, so I just want to touch on it. Chase has sent his little mouthpiece, his little minion, the high school friend, to go out and challenge us writing that blog post saying that it was a lie that chaser wasn't prosecuting anybody and lo and behold the numbers have come out he tried to claim that chaser had the same rate of charging that goes gascon did and that was true but the problem is he's been pleading down all these charges he's not taking anyone to trial he's not convicting anyone he's certainly not locking anybody up so i mean what what a lie that was well and criminals are just so savvy that they actually understand what the chances are of them actually getting convicted, and they shape their grift and their crime to whatever the environment they're in is.
Just like people who deal drugs, just like people who take these hardcore fentanyl drugs, they just pick the market where they're going to be most welcome. So they're not going to do it down in Palo Alto or San Mateo or Mill Valley, they're going to do it on Turk Street. Yeah, so I think that's how it starts. But I got to tell you, you know, I'm in LA right now. And there was an episode like last week at Il Pestao. Oh, yes. It's on Cannon Street in downtown Beverly Hills. The number one Italian place where all the celebrities go. It's a great Italian place. There's a lot of outdoor seating. There was basically a mugging of someone just sitting at a table.
Apparently, they were wearing a really nice watch. And they were robbed at gunpoint in the middle of the restaurant. Lunchtime, yeah. lunchtime and then there was a struggle over the gun i don't know why the guy just didn't hand over the watch but anyway he struggled over the gun four shots went off one of them bounced off the concrete and hit a woman in the leg oh my god so this is like it's getting i mean it's getting out of hand sounds like san paulo where they chop people's arms off for the watch i mean they literally will drive by apparently and just cut your arm off if they can't if you don't give them the watch well i just you know the criminals are starting to feel emboldened because gascon and Boudin are not, they're not having trials, they're not prosecuting, they're not locking people up.
And so, they're graduating to more and more serious offenses. I'm sure they probably didn't want to shoot anybody, or maybe that wasn't their intention. They just want to steal the watch, but it resulted in a shooting, just like the deaths of Hannah Abe and Elizabeth Platt, when you had, you know, Troy McAllister, you know, hit them with the car. So, I mean, the fact that we're not locking people up is resulting in people dying and a lot of risky, very risky behavior all right as we wrap here a lot of spacks going out we obviously saw another i guess roblox was a direct listing um i'm just curious only only underpriced by 50 percent same same problem as the ipo just so basically what you're saying is bill gurley's on his headset walking around el camino real no what i'm saying journalists what i'm saying is irrespective of what the goals of the direct listing were, the result is the same as a traditional IPO.
There you go. Can I give a shout out to a company that David Sachs? Sure. Oh, Pipe? Yes. Congrats. Which is an incredible company that basically like helps you capitalize your contracts with your customers. And it's basically this incredible thing that I'm seeing. And there's a couple of others that do it as well. ClearBank is another one. but you can fund your company non dilutively. And at some point, I think we should actually talk about the state of the union in venture, maybe we can do that in a couple of next episodes, I have a lot of thoughts on where I think venture capital is going. And when I see things like pipe, I'm just like completely so happy, because I just think it's, it's, it's, it's going to change the the way in which venture investing is done.
It's a very brilliant idea. You can go to pipe.com slash twist to get 12 months free. Pipe.com is a two sided marketplace. If you have reoccurring SaaS revenue, or any kind of reoccurring revenue, somebody did it with the sub stack. So I think pomp Liano, the guy who pumps Bitcoin, he has a newsletter that makes whatever quarter million dollars a year. He sold for 95 cents on the dollar his forward looking subscriptions for the year and bought Bitcoin with it when it was at 35. So he's like doubling down. But if you're a SaaS company, and we have many of them in our portfolios, you could take all of your monthly contracts, sell them on the marketplace to somebody else, not pipe pipe doesn't buy it.
It's some other financial person who says, I'll give you 94 cents on the dollar, give you 92 cents on the dollar, give you 85 cents on the dollar. And so if you were if you have a $10 million book of business paying monthly, you can get that 10 million now and deploy it. But Jason, I think this is a good, this is a good way to end. But I think let's agree that the next pod, let's start, let's start with the future of venture capital. 100%. I mean, it's changing dramatically. It's changing dramatically. And I think these non dilutive ways of growing a company will completely impact pricing, you know, pre money, post money, the amount of equity that employees can and should own in these businesses.
You know, what is the value of brands? Like, you know, it like people will know who David Sachs is, who Harry Hurst is, people necessarily don't even care anymore. Like, you know, hey, if I'm calling from Sequoia, what does that mean anymore? They're going to say who from Sequoia is called. So these are all really interesting topics that I think are worth talking about. Another path is just the public markets, you know, right? I mean, public markets are becoming the new late stage private market. And it's really, you know, both the SPAC and early stage IPO and direct listing models are changing dramatically.
And there's more speculative risk seeking in the public markets in a way that I don't think we've ever seen. And it's creating an opportunity for companies that are still, you know, what in a traditional kind of sense might be called, you know, early stage or still businesses with a lot of risk, being able to go public and, you know, kind of take their companies out and let the public markets wager on how well they're going to execute and how well they're going to be able to develop their product or their market. And it's, by the way, it's something we've seen historically with biotech where there's kind of very binary kind of bets that happen and binary outcomes because the markets are known and you don't need to kind of productize or build a business around it.
But now we're actually taking both business risk, market risk, technology risk, product risk to the public market. At all stages. At all stages. And I think you're going to see these scenarios where people will build public portfolios, public company portfolios that will perform a lot like venture portfolios, right? you'll have one or two businesses that'll have a 10 bagger and you know, a chunk that'll go to zero and a chunk that'll have some modest return on them. And it's going to be, yeah, it's going to be this, this tremendous learning experience because a lot of people will put all their money into one stock that they think has already been made.
It's already, it's already done thing. It's Netflix. It's Netflix. It's, you know, their promise of the future is a hundred percent certain. And the reality is their promise of the future is 5% certain. And so depending on the price you're entering and how many of these things you buy, you could build a portfolio that could have a good return. But it's, it's going to be a lot of speculative betting and a lot of losses. And if you don't diversify, you're going to lose a lot of money. And you know, so the question is also, how does it evolve regulatory wise? Chamath, how are you communicating that to the market?
Because you'll have some SPACs that go out, I would think Virgin Galactic is in that more like they're a deep tech researching phase. And then you have other ones that are already, you know, churning the, the ringing the register, right? So how do you communicate that to retail investors or the audience or that's up to them to do the research how do you think about that i mean there's as well as the bad inventory that's getting added no look yeah i do a tweet storm i do a one pager i have a multi-hour detailed investor presentation that's taped and then we have a typically a 100 to 300 page s4 so you can ingress into finding out the true story of a business at whatever point you want it really just does come down to doing your work i mean a lot of the folks on Twitter, when you see the market straight down and they complain, my reaction is stop crying and do your own work.
And we have complete transparency in this process. So it is up to people to do their job. And the thing that I think is happening right now is people think that they don't have to do a job and that money is free. And it's not. It's hard to make it. It's hard to make good investments. It's hard to build a company. Everything is hard. Nothing is really easy. Because if it was easy, everybody would be doing it all the time. And so that's what I would love to leave people with. I really got to go, guys. I love you guys. Love you. But let's start with Venture Capital next week. Yeah. Love you, boys.
Free Davids. Love you. Love you, Davids. Love you, David. Oh, my God. Okay. Love you, guys. Love you, Jekyll. I love you. I love you, Chumath. I love you, too. I do love you. I mean, we love each other. And we can say it. And then the guys on this side, they're working on it. Bye, guys. Look at Jekyll dragging it out. Stop dragging everything out. We're dragging it out because we love you, David. We'll see you all next time. Bye-bye. Red pills got me get lit I've been on a bender on these red pills I've been on a bender on these red pills I've been on a bender on these red pills. I've been on a bender on these red pills.
I've been on a bender on these red pills. Man, I thought that road was good, but God, these Miami, I need more red pills. What a joke. Get me those red pills from Miami. David gave me just a huge bag of red pills while we're off this week. I've been on a bender on these red pills. But stocks blow up me and play the phone. Back, back, back, back up the truck. I see chips, I stack them all Back, back, back, back up the truck You see me, you see the norm NFTs take me out the mud NFTs never on the trunk Red pill, blue pill, Persian drug I don't know what's good, but God, these Miami Chief for a boy Peter Keele Stanford Red Pill's got me lit I'm ready to go I'm ready to go Alright, anybody give a shit about NFTs I've been on a ponder on these rentals.