Show Notes:
0:00 Intro & Dog update
5:48 COVID, Vaccine mandates, public vs. private policy
26:26 Collectivism, comparison to cigarettes, Sacks' latest podcast beef
36:56 Vaccine incentives in France
45:39 Friedberg's science corner: DeepMind's latest breakthrough, Big Tech censorship, free speech infringements
59:40 Capital's role in progress, Bezos' poor press conference, difference in criticism by party, Elon & Bezos as capital allocators
1:10:46 Modern online pessimist psychology & how to fix it
1:21:32 Besties give their tech industry takeaways
Follow the besties:
https://twitter.com/DavidSacks
Follow the pod:
https://twitter.com/theallinpod
https://linktr.ee/allinpodcast
Intro Music Credit:
https://twitter.com/yung_spielburg
Referenced in the show:
NYT - In France, angry protests, rising infections and record vaccinations.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/19/world/france-covid-vaccine-pass-protests.html
NYT - Military and V.A. Struggle With Vaccination Rates in Their Ranks
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/01/us/politics/military-va-vaccines.html
CNBC - Biden on Facebook: 'They're killing people' with vaccine misinformation
Fortune - In giant leap for biology, DeepMind's A.I. reveals secret building blocks of human life
https://fortune.com/2021/07/22/deepmind-alphafold-human-proteome-database-proteins/
The Wizard of Menlo Park - Randall E. Stross
https://www.amazon.com/Wizard-Menlo-Park-Thomas-Invented/dp/1400047633
Tweets:
https://twitter.com/OliviaGoldhill/status/1417446281685966853
No summary for this episode yet.
Saks, I am going to give you $1,000 each to the charity of your choice for every correct answer. Fuck it. $10,000. But you have to answer. You have to answer in real time and you can't fuck around. Okay. No stalling. This is to any charity chooses, including Tucker Carlson 2024. Okay, let's go. You have to give the answers right away. You cannot fucking think about this. Here we go. Three, two, one. First, middle, and last name of your children and their birthdays. Go. first and all the last no dude stalling for time already no I know you're already stalling okay go Dito you can beat these out Nick go ahead go so is January no year what's the year oh 2008 is October 2010.
And then... Little guy, little man. Church name little. You're trying to stop me. You're trying to stop me with the little guy. Little man. The little guy. The little guy. Bubby. He was born October of 2016. Alright, good. He did it. He did it. that was a struggle i got it i got it there he got there that's all that matters is he got there it is so you're gonna give that you're gonna give 10 grand yeah 10 grand each to 10 grand each so it's 30 grand 30 grand to tucker caulson for president desantis 2024 i said charity asshole all in. We'll let your winners ride. Rain Man David Sack. We open source it to the fans and they've just gone crazy.
Love you guys. Hey everybody. Hey everybody. Welcome to your favorite podcast, the all in podcast where we talk about the economy, technology, politics, and well basically anything that's in the news with us today again the queen of quinoa himself david friedberg how are you doing david i'm hanging in there today all right people are looking for the dog where's the dog monty he's sitting here on the floor monty come here come on come here come on monty all right and from a random palace somewhere in the world the dictator himself chamoff palihapiti how you doing see uh i'm doing great you know i got another dog while you were in italy uh i went to um the breeder that i got acci from and uh she had a three-year-old that was not really you know ever gonna become a breeding dog or whatever so i adopted the three-year-old he has a parasite so he's been pooing everywhere everywhere that's great information for the call over the all over the castle all over the castle fantastic liquid poop by the way uh but we finally diagnosed it today and he's going to the to the vet um to get some liquids and to get the parasite expunged from his body uh okay thank you for that information and i don't know nobody cares you nobody cares I mean, I asked you how you were doing.
I thought you were just going to say, great. I didn't know we were going to go straight to diarrhea. We got a new dog too. You did? And it's been kind of a disaster. The kids were like, Dad, we found this, like, I think, you know, golden that is really calm. You know, like, she's just super low energy and calm. It's like perfect for us. I'm like, I don't know. I think that's just like the puppy's kind of asleep, you know? Like, it's going to wake up. They're like, no, no, no, no, no. This is like a special dog. It's like really well behaved, whatever. So anyway, we get it. Sure enough, like a week later, the puppy wakes up and she's eating everything in the house, destroying everything.
It's been, yeah. So now we're. Wait, is that dog number two or three for you? It's dog two. For dog one was a rescue dog, who's great. So dog number two is now getting trained. All right. David Sachs is with us. Of course, the Rayman himself. And in related dog stories, I put all the girls to bed and then I hear screaming. I get up. I run outside. literally the new bulldog who's nine months old maximus went on you know one of his running fits one of my daughters falls out of bed gets like a bruise on her like lower back and she's wailing the other daughter feels terrible about it and then the dog decides that he is going to projectile vomit everywhere all at the same time yeah you guys have had these moments where like it's just complete utter chaos it's chaos chaos it's chaos it's cat dogs plus kids equals chaos uh chaos so but would any of us have it any other way i love the combo of dogs and kids it's just the best it's pretty great it's really dogs are amazing and kids especially when you bring in a new dog or a puppy into the house it's chaos but it's a really beautiful chaos well you know what i think also is like think about how overrated everything in life is people like oh my god this place with the pasta in italy it's the greatest life-changing thing and all this movie was incredible it's the best movie ever made and it's never the best movie ever made or the best pasta ever.
It's great or whatever. But I think kids and dogs are underrated universally. Have as many kids as you can possibly biologically have and can economically afford is my one opinion. And the more dogs, the better. I love dogs, yeah. All right. I think we should start with the COVID cases because this is impacting everything from the economy to people's decisions, touching on people's freedoms. and it's hard to know where to start here but i think facts are always a good place to start here in the united states we had gotten covet cases you know to that 12 000 a day average it was pretty amazing and it looked like it was going to go straight down smooth sailing and we had had deaths down and around uh i saw some seven day averages where we were at 150 200 now the weekends are kind of weird um in terms of reporting but the seven day average today is at 248.
In other words, it's been flat for a month when you do this on this according to the New York Times statistics and Google, you can search for Google and you'll find these have some great data that they'll just put right in the search result. However, cases have gone from this 1215 k a day average, soaring in just 30 days to 62,000 a day and a seven day average of 40,000. So we're basically triple the number of cases, cases trail traditionally deaths by something in the neighborhood of 10 days. I think I'm correct, Friedberg. So what do you think is actually going to happen here? We're gonna we're gonna get up to 10 100,000 200,000 cases a day, and maybe double the number of deaths from the people who are not vaccinated?
Yeah, you know, the current logic on this is that there will be, because of the number of people that are generally infected and are spreading what is now an even more infectious variant of COVID, the people that are not vaccinated are starting to get it at a higher rate. And that's where the deaths are starting to come from. So, yeah, we will see deaths climb. And I think like we talked about last time, we're starting to see even Gavin did an interview yesterday in California talking about how, you know, it's on the table that we may go back to certain restrictions, behavioral restrictions, mask mandates, etc.
So there's going to be a set of reactions. And I think as we talked about last time, we saw the market start to react to the potential of that on Monday. And then very interestingly, kind of reverse course on Tuesday and everything came back when everyone was freaked out on Monday after they saw the weekend's data, which showed that cases are climbing like crazy in the US. But I think the conventional wisdom is not that many people are going to die. Therefore, we're not going to see, you know, political leaders force restrictions that are kind of going to damage the economy. And we're going to start to walk what I think Israel is calling the golden line, which is balancing the economy with the health of the citizenry.
So, so, you know, we'll see, it's going to come down to policy. But I think from a desk perspective, there will absolutely be a rise in depths now as unvaccinated people are the going to be the bulk of those deaths. And, and this thing is spreading again amongst people that haven't been vaccinated. Well, and then Sachs, this becomes now a great raw shock test of what do you see in this data and in this moment, because it's a pandemic, as many people are saying now, I think this is becoming the meme or the catchphrase. It's a pandemic of the unvaccinated. So people have chosen to opt into this pandemic.
And then a group of us have chosen to not be part of it, you were part of it, even as a vaccinated person, but you're feeling great, you're back to 100%. So what do you think should happen in terms of closings or shutdowns or mask mandates? What's your take on the pandemic of the unvaccinated? Well, I think we need to differentiate between public policy and private behavior. So after last week's episode where I said, you know, Delta variant is real, There's going to be a huge spike in cases. Unfortunately, I thought we had this thing whipped, you know, a few weeks ago. Now, I think the data is showing something different.
You know, there's a lot of commenters saying, Saks, you've turned, you've been blue-pilled. No, it's, you know, I think there's a difference between acknowledging what's going on and then having the policy conversation around it. I think that the difference now from last year, I mean, there's a couple of things. One is that we do have vaccines. So, I think for most people, getting vaccinated will take the worst risks off the table. The other is we know so much more about what works and what doesn't work. And so, lockdowns don't work if they ever did. We now know, looking at from what different states did last year, that they don't make a difference.
So, there's no reason to go back to that policy. But also, I mean, I would even say on mass, it should be- Wait, wait, do we know that? I mean, I think so. Are we sure of that? Yeah, I think so. Because the thing that the government planners never take into account is that private citizens are going to adjust their behavior in both directions. So in Florida, they didn't have mandates, but people who are at risk took extreme precautions. They would either lock themselves down or be very fastidious about wearing a high quality mask. By contrast, in California, we had the most severe lockdowns, but they were never really feasible.
So there's 10 pages of exceptions. People didn't really abide by them. And then on top of it, you know, you have all these mass mandates. But if somebody wears like a sock loosely affixed to their face, does that really protect them? You know, so, you know, people, if they're not interested in complying with these mandates, they do it in a half-hearted way. I'm not convinced that the mandates work in the first place. so the smart thing to do here is just to have recommendations and let private citizens decide what their response is going to be we know now so much more about the risks that we all face than we did a year ago and so just let private citizens decide i mean i'd even say on vaccines i mean look i'm pro-vax i don't really understand where the anti-vax people are coming from but i'm kind of done wasting my breath trying to convince people to get vaccinated on this show who don't want to get vaccinated.
If they don't want to send those doses to the developing world where they're desperate for them. Let me ask you, Chamath, do you agree with Sachs' position that, listen, citizens are just going to have to make their own decision here, leave everything open, and let's not have the economy collapse again and people are smart enough to make their own decision? And is this framing of this is a pandemic of the unvaccinated, the correct framing. Wow, I'm really of two minds. There's the part of me that says that you have to give people the right to make their own decision. The problem is that in this specific case, there's so much transmissibility.
And as a result of that, how this thing can mutate, that I think that public health has to take a priority over any individual individual's rights in this very specific narrow, narrow case, because the Delta variant is so transmission transmissible, people are going to have to lose some freedoms is one of those showing a vaccine card when you go to an arena that you wouldn't need that if everybody was vaccinated, or you had to go through a lot of hoops to be unvaccinated as an example. I mean, and the reason is because the longer you allow this thing to float around in the petri dish of the unvaccinated, you're increasing everybody's risk.
And this is where I think individual freedoms, as long as it doesn't trample on collective freedom, then I think live and let live. But I think on this specific issue, I think that it's unconscionable to be in a situation where we are fighting basically a time function, where at a certain amount of time, you're going to have a variant that is, you know, basically will overcome all the vaccines we have, will kill enormous numbers of people, including the vaccinated, will literally shut the economy down. And that's a probabilistic event now. And I don't like the fact that I'm susceptible to that because of a bunch of people who, frankly, aren't doing it for medical or religious reasons.
They're just watching Fox News and just spouting off. I agree that we're at risk there, but we're also at risk from unvaccinated people in the rest of the world. So, Delta variant came from India, the Lambda variant, I think they're on, came from Peru. I mean, the fact of the matter is unvaccinated people everywhere are a potential petri dish for the virus. So, I'd rather, I mean, this is why we need to send those unused doses that, by the way, are at risk of expiring. We now, I mean, there was a tweet about this recently. There's huge stockpiles of vaccine in the US that are going to waste right now.
We should ship those anywhere in the world that people are ready to get vaccinated. Well, specifically to Mexico and Canada, and Canada's, I think, this month going to, even though we got off to a massive head start, going to eclipse us in terms of the percentage vaccinated. Let me ask it more pointedly. Should teachers be, public school teachers be forced to be vaccinated? Should you be forced to have a vaccine card to get on public transportation, airplanes or you know take buses you know long-haul buses long-haul trains and then third should you be forced to show a vaccine card to get on to go to sporting events or concerts let's go through those three so your personal freedom ends you're going to be forced if you want to go to behaviors if you want to participate in a public construct if you want to consume a public resource or if you want to provide a publicly funded good, then it's the broader public's rights that are superior to your individual rights.
Otherwise work at a charter school where it's not required, watch the fucking concert from home or drive your car, use a bicycle or take an Uber. The end. Sacks, what do you think? And then Freeberg. So I understand that argument. I would differentiate between public and private requirements. Because I don't like the idea of giving government the power to forcibly stick a needle in your arm. Well, what you might say, you could stay home or you could take your bicycle. Well, sure. Is that reasonable that you don't get to go to a Warriors game because you're unvaccinated? Yeah, I think the Warriors stadium is privately owned.
The team is private. So I think that private companies should be able to set up their own rules for the benefit of their employees and customers. What about airlines? because that is, you know, there's a limited number of them. Yeah, I think that- So airlines should be able to force it. Now, what about school teachers? Should they be forced? They can't force it, but they can set the requirements for you to board their planes, you know? Okay, now what about public schools? Should, if, let's do teachers and students. Should teachers be forced to get a vaccine if they want to come in? Because you said if they don't come to work in the fall and a couple episodes back, you're fired.
Well, why wouldn't they want to get a vaccine? The whole debate with the teachers unions was that they wanted to be at the front of the line for vaccines, which isn't an issue anymore because we have so many. So I don't think that's a serious issue. Now, requiring the kids to get vaccinated is that that would be the real policy question. And well, let's tackle both. Should teachers be forced to get the vaccine? Yes or no. You just kind of brushed over. Yeah, you forced it. No, I mean, I think it's important to just to just, you know, pinpoint this, like forcing teachers to get vaccinated. in order to, you know, work at the school.
I just want to highlight the precedent it sets, right? Which is, you know, you just said you don't want the government to tell people that they have to go get a shot in their arm. If someone has a personal choice, that they don't want to get that shot. Does that mean then that they, you know, should lose their job as a public servant? Well, no, I mean, no, I'm saying that, look, I think that... You said it's not a big deal, but like, if there's one or two teachers that say, you know what, it is a big deal to me. I have a different, I have a set of reasons why I don't want to get a shot. Well, I think those teachers, that's an assumption of risk.
I mean, if they've decided they're going to assume the risk, then, you know, don't come crying to us when they get sick. Well, the argument is that they're going to be the vector of exposure, right? Yeah, and what if they're the petri dishes as we talked about? They could be the vector that gets kids sick. In all of these situations, there's always a very obvious and justifiable exemption for religious and medical reasons to not be vaccinated, not just for this, but for anything else. So I struggle to understand why all of a sudden people who don't have a fucking clue about science are all of a sudden, these armchair scientists who can judge whether or not a vaccine is appropriate for them, where they probably already gave vaccines of all other kinds to their kids and themselves.
They probably take all other kinds of advice from doctors. But on this one specific issue, they narrowly say, you know what, I'm an expert enough because I'm watching this television show, I've made a decision. That to me makes no sense. Yeah, look, I actually agree with you. I'm in the camp of that everybody barring some, you know, highly specific medical condition that renders you ineligible should be getting vaccinated. So, I agree with you about what the right answer is, but I do think that when it comes to government, it's a more complicated question about how much power you give to government to force people to engage in, you know, behavior they don't want to engage in.
Can you bench them? I think it's a real question. Private organizations are different, right? Okay, we will agree on private organizations, but we do have to make some decisions on public transportation, and we do have to make decisions about teachers, and we're going to have to make decisions on students. so um could you bench the teachers uh who or otherwise penalize them who are not vaccinated you know there are some times where you know a cop or a teacher is put in a you know not in the classroom not on the beat for whatever reasons uh sometimes disciplinary but for other reasons could you just say listen if you're not going to get vaccinated you're going to not be in the classroom you're not going to you'll be a remote teacher and we're just going to create two classes here i don't think i don't i don't think there are many teachers who don't want to get vaccinated but but i um look i think the virus is everywhere now it's just endemic and so to single out like one particular group and saying you're going to lose your job you down on your opinion so you're saying teachers should not be forced i'm saying that i mean if they work at a private school the private school could definitely require it we're talking about public only now we all agree on private look you're saying i think it's a really pin you down on it yeah i think it's a really complicated question because I think there are clear public health benefits to everyone getting vaccinated.
But I also don't really like empowering government to force you. Because, look, it's like everything else. The government may be right in this particular case, but what else is it going to do with that power? And, you know, I don't like giving government that power. So, look, it's a complicated question. I don't, you know, it's not, I would probably err on the side of not letting government force people to do it. But look, I think it's a close call. I do think it's a close call. Chamath, forced the teachers to get vaccinated or not? Yes. And the reason is because these kids are already being left behind, even when school is functioning normally.
And you can see it in the test scores, you can see it in our readiness, you can see it in our ability to actually do the jobs that are required. We are not doing what we need to do as it is in the absence of a pandemic. and now you introduce a reason for folks to basically check out and not appear i what do you guys guess how how many years were lost in these 15 months when kids were at home i would say not 15 months no it's more two years two and a half years three years developmentally academically depending on what grade they are what did the did your kids miss graduation did they miss senior prom?
Did they miss their SATs? I mean, what did they miss in terms of development? Yeah, I mean, Chamath is a good point, which is that when government is the employer, requiring it on their employees because it leads to better outcomes for that institution, that is a little different than government just mandating that you, Jason Calcana's private citizen, have to go get a shot in your arm, right? I mean, so there is a slight difference there, like military, for instance, right? The military probably wants to vaccinate everybody so that if they need to be ready for a combat situation, they're not like, you know, incapacitated by an outbreak of COVID, right?
So, I can, I think there, you know, we're getting into shades of gray here from a public policy perspective. You know, I don't want teachers missing school because, you know, for weeks at a time because they didn't do the obvious thing getting the COVID vaccine. So look, I think there are some really good policy arguments there. But I think, again, the one place where I'd say government is clearly overstepping is if they just said, listen, you private citizen, not an employee of the government has to go get vaccinated. As much as I would like everyone to get vaccinated, I don't want to give government that kind of power.
President Biden could legally require military members to get vaccinated, but so far he has declined to do so July 9th, New York Times. And Friedberg, where do you stand on this? Chamath says he's all in. You're a teacher. You get vaccinated at the end. Sachs is kind of close, but is a little concerned. What do you say, Friedberg? I mean, another way to frame it is that there is a new qualification for a job. Like, you know, there's qualification to be in the military. You have to have certain physical capabilities. Jason, I don't know if you would qualify. I don't think I would. I don't think I can be like...
For totally different reasons. Your inability to fight or throw a punch would be... No, maybe J. Cal could eat the enemy. Trust me, I would be great in the military. I'm a berserker. He'd be like Clemenza. He'd be cooking the meatballs or something. Private joker. Private pile of donut. I think the reason there's sensitivity to it is because there are existing teachers in jobs. And then you're telling them that in order to keep your job, you have to go get a vaccine. Now, if we were to have zero teachers today, and we were starting a public school system from scratch, and you said, here's one of the qualifying criteria to be a school teacher, you have to have an education degree, you have to have maybe a master's degree in education, you have to have appropriate qualifications and training and certification.
Oh, and by the way, you also have to have a vaccine. If that becomes a criteria, I think people find it less offensive. It's the fact that we are now saying that there are people that are being told that you have to go get a shot in order to keep your job. And that's the complicating thing that I think people are trying to wade through. I don't think that if you were to say like, look, it's obvious that the qualifying criteria to be in the military is you have to be able to run and do push-ups or whatever the criteria might be. But if you impose that on people that were already in the military, and then you're going to kick a bunch of them out, people would be up in arms about it.
If you had a BMI requirement. Yeah. And that's the concern I think that arises with, you know, imposing these kind of, you know, personal body criteria upon, you know, specific jobs when people are already employed in that job. And it's, there's absolutely no answer, right? Like, if you're going to do it, you're going to have incredible backlash and trouble and pain. And if you were to, and we're not in a circumstance where we can build these organizations and these institutions from scratch. Look, there's a lot of social issues where, you know, particularly on the liberal side, people do not want the government prohibiting them from getting certain medical procedures, right?
Well, you know, I'd say it's even more invasive. Are you talking about people transitioning? Or, you know, or the issue of abortion, you know, very hot button social issues where people are saying the government should not have the right to legislate what happens with. Or experimental treatments. What happens with my body, right? Well, giving government the power to forcibly inject you with something that is invasive. And so, I do think there are rights implications to that. But I want to be very clear. If you want the services that are offered to you by the collective whole, if you want to consume and be a net drag on the resources that we share, then you need to sign up for the compact that we all sign up for.
That's my overarching argument. But the thing with abortion where I'm on the other side of the issue, just to be very clear, is like it is a woman's body. I don't think I have any right to dictate what she does. I don't understand what she goes through. I don't understand what situation she's in. I don't think I have the judgment to do that. It should be her decision. And it doesn't have an impact on the collective. And her decision to carry or not carry a baby doesn't theoretically come with a probabilistic chance that I may die. It does not. Right. But when you choose to not get vaccinated to a highly transmissible respiratory disease that could kill me or mutate.
Yeah, I'm not saying that I have a say. But I do think I should have a say if you're then all of a sudden going to consume the same resources that I consume, where I've signed up to that compact for public health. Based on all this, here's where I come to what if we gave teachers an off ramp? Listen, if you you need to be vaccinated to be in the classroom. If not, you're going to get a one year buyout or whatever one month or two months for every year of service. So if you've been with us for 20 years, you can get 20 months of pay. And or you could say if the virus is spreading at under this rate, in other words, you know, we've got under 1% of the population infected or whatever the the criteria is, then you can come to work in the classroom.
But if this thing is spreading, you're out. And that's it and there's an off ramp here to david's point unless there's a narrow like look i do think you can be a conscientious objector for legitimate reasons again like we we have these very specific definitions for religious or for health specific reasons that you that you don't get vaccinated i think those should be respected it's not that cohort of people we're talking about it's everybody else that right now wants to not think for themselves and as a result put everybody else and themselves in danger. Yeah, I think the most compelling part of your argument, Jamath, is the health externality, right?
That each person's decision does have an impact on whether they could be transmitting, you know, multiplicative, contagious particles. And this is why I was in favor of a mask mandate at the beginning of the pandemic is it's not just an individual decision. your choice actually does affect whether other people get sick. So, you know, this is why I do think it's a close call. It also wasn't very invasive, correct, Sax? I mean, was your other point? Yes, exactly. Potentially high benefit for very low cost. But the thing that maybe I didn't necessarily take into consideration is, you know, people complied in such a half-hearted way.
I mean, I do think the mask makes a difference. If it's an N95 quality mask that you put on correctly, right? But when people just strap a sock to their face, it's loosely fitting, and they don't give a shit. I mean, does that really make a difference? I mean, I'm very skeptical. Let me ask you a question, Saks, and then we'll go to Freeberg, and then we'll flip to the next topic. If we were on our third pandemic, or let's, God forbid, a second pandemic starts, a totally different one, you know, Ebola type or something, and we're on the fifth variant, and people are dying at a higher rate, does your calculus change, Saks?
Because the economy- the downsides, the costs of not imposing those more restrictive regulations goes up considerably. I mean, definitely my thinking today is highly influenced by the fact that if you're vaccinated, you're call it 95% likely to be taking the most deadly or serious risks off the table. And so the people who are choosing not to get vaccinated are essentially assuming the risk. You know, it's like smoking in a way where when I made the movie Thank You for Smoking, Christopher Buckley told me, you know, he's the author of the book. And he said, look, there's something uniquely American about defending people's right to do something that's manifestly harmful, right?
The main character in Thank You for Smoking is a spokesman for Big Tobacco and he's engaging in political spin. But his argument is, look, people have the right to engage in this behavior, even if it is known to be harmful to them. And maybe America is the only place in the world where people buy into arguments like that. But I do, you know, look, that is, that's freedom, is letting people do stupid things, you know. And so, we have to weigh the benefits of freedom against the costs. And by the way, sorry, can I just say something? Smoking is a perfect example, because as you know, there is now a non trivial amount of law around the liability related to individuals that enabled secondhand smoke, both the smoker, but also other things, condo boards, other places where all of a sudden, you didn't choose to fucking have, you know, tar and nicotine.
bartenders my dad worked in bars where people it was a cloud of smoke for 30 years 30 years right they told him he was essentially a smoker it's not it's not just the detrimental activity at the time remember we've socialized the cost of treatment for people uh through public health systems and because of that it's not just an individual's choice if there is a socialized cost for everyone that's now got to pay the price but the government is so omnipresent all of our lives there's always going to be a social cost to any bad choice people make. And to Tamath's point, I mean, everybody uses government services to some degree.
So, that alone can't be the reason. I do agree that the- Well, no, but there is outrageous behavior, David. What about people speeding on highways at 125 miles an hour? Like, it's the same thing. Well, that's illegal. That's illegal. But I think Tamath is right that the smoking example is a good one because we do regulate secondhand smoke because there's an externality, there's a health externality to everybody else if you smoke in a public place and so we restrict that but we don't make smoking illegal we don't stop you from doing it in your own homes or in private places and the argument is listen if you want to do something that's harmful primarily to you that's your choice as an american you know and i know people a lot of people don't like that actually this is the this i posted a tweet that i got just because an opinion is wrong doesn't mean it should be censored.
Just because the behavior is harmful doesn't mean it should be prohibited. Just because something is beneficial doesn't mean it should be required. Right. It's a completely reasonable tweet. Yeah, I thought it was a pretty inoffensive anodyne tweet just reminding people that just because, again, something is positive doesn't mean you force people to do it. And just because some behavior is harmful, you don't ban it, I think smoking is a great example of that, right? We let people engage in behavior that's harmful to them because freedom is a value in and of itself. For this, I was attacked as a selfish asshole by this other pod.
And I really think- So Kara Swisher and Professor Cold Takes? Exactly. Professor what? Cold Takes. They literally made an index of all of Professor G's, you know, takes that Macy's would be incredible and Amazon would lose its money and yada yada. He's kind of obsessed with you too, Chamath Prof G. Yeah, who just got his show canceled on Bloomberg, but they were a little, Kara Swisher was called Sax an asshole. Well, triggered. It was bizarre that they would get so triggered by this inoffensive tweet. But I think what you see here is an example of the way that the woke mind thinks, which is- Well, hold on.
I don't think Kara's woke. Are you kidding me? She's like the Madame Dufarge of the woke revolution Who's Madame Dufarge? Madame Dufarge Madame Dufarge was this character in the French Revolution Who had knit the names of the next person To be guillotined And she was One of the leaders of the sans culottes No, look, Kara is constantly ginning up the mob To try and guillotine Some non-woke person I don't think that's true I think she's kind of moderate You're trying to curry favor with her so you don't... No, we're not. No, we're not. No, no. I mean, she did get it right. You are an asshole. I mean...
You are an asshole. She got that part. I got that right. But you're not old and failing. Well, you are kind of old. You looked old. You look old. She's effectively saying we're all assholes because I think all of us have talked about the need... We are assholes. I'm an asshole. I love it. Own it. Okay. I'm not a whiner. What's your other choice? Being a whiner on the sidelines? Nothing. What we've said on this show is that we have a moral imperative to get back to normal do we not that is what we've said and for that you're basically saying that that is a let them eat covid position right that we are basically we don't care if people get sick and die because of covid that's not true you know we just have a we have a balance here i think we should make people get vaccinated yeah you're pretty close to getting people vaccinated i asked you sax if there were three more variants and this was an acute situation you said you would force Oh, look, if we had a variant of COVID that was as deadly as Ebola and as transmissible as Delta variant, it 100% changes the game.
There's no question about it. So, you're willing to change the government's ability to put a shotgun on based on reality. It's a benefit-cost. Yes, it's a benefit-cost analysis. That's reasonable. But look, I give freedom a lot of weight, and part of my calculation is the fact that I can get vaccinated to most likely take the most serious risks off the table. So, while I am impacted to some degree by other people's choices, I'm much less impacted now that we have functional vaccines. But you're thinking about this, I still have a problem with the way you're thinking about this, because you're viewing this as a linear problem.
This thing is transmutating, and so you have a… There are still billions of people all over the world who are unvaccinated and we'd be better off focusing on getting them a Marshall Plan for the vaccines. All these unused doses, we're wasting our breath in the United States trying to get these vaccine hesitant or anti-vax people to get vaccinated. Did you guys see that Emmanuel Macron of France, you know, basically tightened all these restrictions around access to public places, going into bars and cafes? They basically put all these rules in place that you have to be vaccinated. And he did it in a public address on TV.
22 million people watched it. Yep. And then after he did this, suddenly the vaccination signups went up to like 20,000 a minute. They got 4 million people sign up to get vaccinated. You can't go to a cafe. I mean, in France, what's the point of being alive? And then let me throw a wet blanket on the framing of this on whether all of this talk about forcing vaccinations even makes sense or is possible. I have been to like three events over the last month or two, where I was required to be vaccinated. And I literally just took a photo of this index card that I got from this person and sent it to them, which I could go make at Kinko's or I could print at home.
It's a lot of effort. My point is, I don't think that there's not a great digital system today to enable the level of restriction that we're actually talking about. How are you actually going to know that people going to the Warriors game are actually vaccinated? How are you actually going to know? They did it at Madison Square Garden. They literally had you pull out your ID and they matched your name to your vax card. And I think printing out a vax card and faking it could be a fine, could be a $10,000 fine. And so you would do it like anything else. You could make a bogus driver's license. My point is that it's not digital, right?
There's no kind of centralized system where we know who's actually been vaccinated and who's not. So, so much of this is just this like analog paper trail thing of like, here's this piece of paper that says I'm vaccinated I think that you're never going to really close the hole on this thing. Now, you certainly will see the sort of psychological behavior that they saw in France, which is you just announced the restrictions, you announced these rules, everyone signs up or some number of people will sign up. But I'm not sure this actually ends up becoming this truly enforceable mechanism of behavior in society over the next short while.
I mean, maybe over time, we digitize all this stuff, but we'll see. Yeah. I mean, the best case scenario is that because Delta is so transmissible, we get to herd immunity because all the people who didn't get vaccinated just get it and get the natural antibodies and hopefully this thing turns out. How close are we to that? Because we have 60% of adults in the United States have had one shot or more, which is why deaths probably aren't going up because that's like 75% in people over 60, I think. So, Freeberg, in your estimation as our science guy, with what we have like 30 million people who've been infected that we know of, you got to triple that number, right?
Because there's people who we don't know. And then you have 65, you have 60%. So we got to be in the range of 70% have been exposed or been vaccinated. So when does it kick in? Or are we experiencing, you know, herd immunity right now with these low deaths? We talked about this before, but there are, you know, there's a spectrum of infection, right? You're, you're, you're, you can have viral replication happening in your body, and then your body clears out the virus before you even know because you've got enough antibodies to that particular strain of a variant of a virus before your body even, you know, you start to feel symptoms.
And there are cases where the virus kind of replicates in an uncontrolled way for a period of time, and you have incredibly bad symptoms, and you have inflammation and all the stuff that follows. And so, you know, in terms of how you measure this stuff, it's really difficult to say that you're going to stop all viral replication by getting a certain number of people to be to have been exposed, as we've seen, even when you have a broad and diverse antibody pool in your body, because you've been exposed to a vaccine, we are still seeing that some of these variants can break through for some period of time, because there's not enough of the antibodies that can actually bind to that specific variant.
And so the rate of transmission slows, the rate of severe infection goes way down, and so on. So it's not as binary as, hey, we hit herd immunity, and now we're done, it seems. This is, you know, as we talked about earlier, and as I think everyone is coming to terms with, this is going to be an endemic virus. And that means that it's going to be circulating in the population in a modest way, causing sometimes severe, sometimes, you know, modest outbreaks for likely a very long time, no matter how many people get it, no matter how many people get vaccinated, because you have different strengths.
At what level should we ignore it? At what level should we just say, listen, that is the steady state? How many cases a day? How many debts a day do you think is the steady state that we should just say, we just go to work and ignore it? I am a brutal, cold hearted libertarian on this point. And I have been since we first talked about this last year. I've always been of the mind that we need to balance the, the follow on life effect and from the economic fallout associated with making certain behavioral changes and restrictions relative to the actual loss of life, right? So you can never go I really think this point about zeroism and this term about zeroism is an important one.
You can never get to zero cases. What is the acceptable number of cases? And what is the cost to keep that case load down? The balance of those two is a very difficult leadership decision. Put a number on it. It's about saving lives, right? So like, there are a certain number of people whose lives are going to be ruined, who are some of them will commit suicide, some of them won't be able to earn an income again, their businesses are going to get shut down. What is the economic cost of that versus the economic cost of the loss of life. What I'm saying is, what is the number? We had an average of 250 death, 250,000 case known cases a day at the peak, we had a peak deaths of 4100 a day, we are now at 200 people dying a day.
And, you know, 30,000 cases, is there a number at which you say, let's just focus on getting back to work? And is that number where we are now? I'm trying to get an idea. Yeah, again, I wouldn't simplify it to those data points. What I would do is, again, I would look at, you know, at what age are people dying? How many life years are we losing? And how can we address the acute populations that are at risk and the acute populations that are potentially going to be exposed? Manage those populations differently than you manage the broader population that has a lower likelihood of death and a lower likelihood of fatality.
And the restrictions that you then impose to, you know, start to manage the risk and the exposure to different populations gets weighed against the saving of life and the loss of life in both circumstances. So it's not easy, right? And everyone wants to sum this whole thing up to like, how many deaths a day is appropriate? That's not the right answer, right? Because- Well, you're saying how many- That part of it is so obvious, right? And we should have known this last summer. The obvious part being that what you want to do is focus your prevention on the part of the population that's the most at risk.
And what do we do with lockdowns? We literally locked down the entire population, every business. It was completely insane. We should have focused it on protecting the most at-risk populations, isolating the sick or the people at greatest risk. Not everybody. It was just insane. And I mean, I can't believe we're still having that conversation a year later. Can I, before we move on to the next topic, can I read the best comment from Sax's tweet? So Sax's tweet, just because an opinion is wrong doesn't mean it should be censored. Just because a behavior is harmful doesn't mean it should be prohibited.
and just because something is beneficial doesn't mean it should be required. The best response goes to Distantly Social Rumpel, whose full name is at Wendell Shirk, who said, this message brought to you by the generic self-serving platitude alert network. We now return you to your regularly scheduled episode of the bland soap opera with the Pablum Sisters. Well, yeah, look, there's an element of truth to that, which is I almost didn't tweet it because I thought it was too much of a platitude. But the fact that people on the other side got so triggered by it shows why it was actually useful to tweet it is they think that if you're calling for any modicum of freedom or return to normalcy, you're basically a selfish asshole.
I mean, it's insane. I mean, they want to stay in this world of zeroes COVID restrictions forever. We got to move on. We're 45 minutes into COVID. So we got to move on. But I think if this is in the influenza, plus or minus 100% zone, we got to pick a number where we decide we're moving forward as a society. And you know, local communities can make decisions if they have outbreaks. But I kind of think if this is within, you know, 2x of our yearly deaths from, you know, influenza and just the normal cold, I think we move forward as best we can. Do we want to go to China, Cuba? I think just real quick, before we move away from this, I really want to just highlight the DeepMind announcement from this morning, because I think it's actually quite relevant to the tracking of variants and what's been going on.
Okay. So this morning, you know, DeepMind, which published AlphaFold, we talked about this a few episodes ago. DeepMind is owned by Google. It's their AI arm. It's an AI arm owned by Google. And they basically took protein structure and tried to predict what a protein looks like physically as a function of the DNA or RNA that codes the amino acids that make up the protein. And so, again, like when you have a string of amino acids, they combine and they fold into a way that's really hard to predict. And that's the shape of the molecule that we call the protein. And then it does something in the body.
And historically, we've had very hard times understanding how genetic code translates into physical structure of protein, which would allow us to predict what that protein can then do in the body. So this morning, DeepMind incredibly published a database with the predicted structure of every protein in the human body and in 10 other species using this capability that they now have. What does it mean in English? And so, you know, what this means is we now have a physical model of every protein that human DNA can make. And that model would allow us to basically now predict what that protein does, how it does it, and how certain drugs can bind to those proteins, and how certain drugs can affect those proteins and how we can alter human health by making new molecules or adjusting the genetic code to change the shape of those proteins in specific and targeted ways.
So it's an incredible data set that was just published. It's almost like, you know, releasing the Rosetta Stone, in my opinion, in terms of we now have this ability to translate human genetic code into the physical form of the molecules that run our body and do things in our body. They did it for 10 other species. And they said that they're going to publish this proteome database and scale it for all other species of life that we have the sort of data set around for which they expect will achieve over 100 million unique proteins in this database over the coming months freely available and searchable.
And let me just explain. And I know I'm on a monologue here. So I'll win the monologue stat. It's a good one. It's a good one. But let me just explain why this is relevant. The Delta variant, what it is, is that, you know, the SARS-CoV-2 RNA sequence is about 30,000 base pairs long. 10% of those, or about 3,000 base pairs, make up the spike protein, which is the protein at the tip of the COVID virus, the coronavirus, that gets into the cells. And, you know, for every 10 people that are infected with coronavirus, there's about one nucleoside mutation. One of those base pairs changes and the virus evolves.
And we don't know how that change in that genetic code translates into a different structure of the protein. And so we suddenly discover empirically and, you know, by looking around, suddenly all these people are getting more infected than we're getting infected before. We look at the genetic code and we're like, oh, here's the changes that happened. But we could have with this capability from AlphaFold predicted what changes make the spike protein do a better job binding to human ACE2 receptors on the cells and getting it to cells. And what other changes could be made in the whole genome of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that could cause this virus to be more transmissible, more deadly, all these sorts of factors, because we can now estimate the physical form of that protein by changing the base pair.
And so this tool that was released today, I think highlights that over the next decade, these sorts of things that are going on with viruses mutating and variants occurring that are affecting our population can be better estimated and tracked digitally. And it gives us the ability to start to prepare tools and defense mechanisms against them with new drugs and new variant models and new vaccines well ahead of the, oh my God, we just got hit with a nuclear bomb. Let's clean up the mess kind of in the future. So it's an exciting day, an exciting moment. Would they have been released this, David, if it hadn't been for COVID coming out?
Do you think DeepMind just pivoted their entire group? Because they have about 1000 people, I understand. And by the way, they pay something in the order of six or 700,000 a year on average. And there's many people there who are getting paid millions of dollars a year. So just think about the scale of what Google is spending on this. You guys know that I probably shifted a large number of people to work on this. You guys know that I have long, deep roots at Google. And I will tell you that the value system of people there, you know, the press and the public will think what they want. But I think that the value system of people there drove them to realize the importance of this work that they're doing with AlphaFold.
And it is important for humanity. And it's important for the health broadly of people. They could have kept it all inside and used it to build therapeutic drug companies and make money from that. And I think the importance of this discovery and this capability was realized and is published for that very reason. There's a lot of work that DeepMind does to optimize ad targeting and ad spending and all this stuff. And they make tens of billions of dollars of incremental revenue for Google per year based on those capabilities. And then there are these things that benefit all of us. And by putting this out publicly, it's a great good for humanity.
And they're making it freely available and searchable. And so I don't think that COVID kind of instigated this because they've been working on this for a very long time since before COVID. And this is a very hard biological problem that is key to understanding biology and how biology works. It's been going on for decades. They've unlocked it with software and they're making it freely available. And, you know, there will be hundreds of drug companies that will now start because of what's in that database. I mean, this is a this is a mitzvah to society, to humanity. does it change the fact that google is spending well over a billion dollars a year on deep mind and doing projects like this does this change any your thinking about breaking them up chamath or you know how we look at big tech that's a good question no because how do you afford this yeah where does it where does this kind of we learned something very disturbing about big tech this week actually um this is quite a bombshell that jen pasaki dropped from the white house press briefing we got to talk about this she just sort of casually mentioned that oh yeah by the way the administration is flagging posts for a social media company for big tech companies to take down to remove accounts they're talking about specific accounts and posts yeah and she just kind of meant just casually mentions oh yeah the big tech companies are very you know eagerly cooperating with the administration to take down these counts accounts she even said that when one of these companies takes down an account, the rest should do it too, implying that the White House is providing the central coordinative role in the censorship.
A global block list. Yeah. Okay, but hold on. Let's take the most charitable view here. I know that it's very easy to make this a left versus right. They're censoring, yada, yada, Trump got banned. But if somebody was saying this was an account that was claiming that microchips were in the vaccine, would it not be how would the and it was hitting scale you know what would be the way for the white house to inform social media that there was an account that was saying falsely that microchips were in there and that that was trending the white house or its officials are free to put out their statements and their position but this is different this is the white house coordinating behind the scenes with big tech companies well they're not behind the scenes they're saying they're doing it right here to everybody correct correct the behavior was behind the scenes but to pasaki just admitted it which is why it's such a bomb show look even the aclu if you were president and there there was an account on facebook youtube twitter that was saying there was a microchip from bill gates this is a this is a blatant violation of the people's first amendment rights tell them how would you you are allowed you're the first amendment gives you the right to say things that are untrue.
It is not the business of government to declare what is true and what is false. Okay. Even the ACLU came out of retirement. We haven't heard from them for the last year during any of these- It's hard to be the ACLU. We haven't heard from them during the past year. During all of this activity that's been going on with accounts being blocked and ghosted, they finally came out of retirement to say that this a dangerous violation of people's First Amendment rights. You cannot have the government saying what is true and what is false and then denying people the right to express their opinions based on what the government thinks is the truth.
And by the way, there's been a very subtle change here in the language that's being used. If you remember, the argument used to be that we have to stop disinformation. Now it's shifted to, we have to stop misinformation. So those two things are very different. It's kind of like the, well, it's kind of like the difference in the term equality versus equity. They sound similar, but they actually mean very different things. So disinformation is actually a campaign of- Purposeful. Purposeful campaign of propaganda and lies usually put forward covertly. So it's the FSB, or some intelligence agency putting out disinformation, usually under false accounts.
So in that case, we can say, no, you can't do that because you can't engage in deception around who you are, right? But misinformation is simply information that's being put out that, frankly, you disagree with, okay? Or it could be discernibly wrong. Wait, you're kind of framing that wrong. It could be you're putting out information like there's a microchip in the vaccine that is explicitly known to be wrong. Look, the lab leak theory was considered misinformation by these same people three months ago. Okay, but let's take the specific example of there's a microchip. If it was the case that they said there's a microchip in the vaccine, would you be okay with the White House contacting social media companies saying, hey, you got these accounts that are saying there's a microchip.
You might want to look into it. They're not saying take it down. They're saying take a look into it. That's not the White House's business. Do I believe in the microchip theory? No, of course not. It's absolutely ridiculous. but it is not the business of government to be telling social media who to ban and who to block list i think they didn't tell him to ban i think they told him to be aware of it go ahead chamath i think your framing's wrong sex no no saki said that when one site takes it down they should all take it down and then biden on top of it comes out and pours kerosene on the fire by saying that social media sites are literally killing people well yeah by allowing by allowing this misinformation So here we have- He's got to see now, let's be honest.
He's a president. This is the president of the United States using the bully pulpit to call social media sites mass murderers by virtue of allowing people to have free speech. Trump never used language that intemperate. I don't remember him ever calling- Oh my God. American companies- Go ahead, Chamath. Mass murderers. Let Chamath speak. Let Chamath speak. This is the exact reason you can't have a stranglehold on distribution because it will get perverted. And then we either have people we like or people we don't like in these positions of power, or people we like or people we don't like regulating, and it's constantly flipping.
And we're all just doomed and bound to get fucked over. So back to the thing that Friedberg brought up before, I think AlphaFold is incredible. I think Google has been an incredible company. They make money hand over fist, they waste an enormous amount of money in all kinds of trash. So it's good that they were actually able to do something useful here. I generally think that companies like Google and Facebook and Amazon, unfortunately, do not allow the constructive form of capitalism that people want in today's society. They're just too big. Tremoth makes a great point, which is we've got these big tech monopolies who've become gatekeepers over content, okay?
And what the administration has done and their allies in Congress is hang a sword of Damocles over the heads of these big tech companies. They've appointed Lena Kahn to be the enforcer at the FTC. They've got their six bills in Congress right now. They've held congressional hearings around taking away Section 230 protection, which is very economically advantageous for these big tech companies. So, they've positioned the sword perfectly over the heads of these big tech companies, threatening to break them up and rein them in. And then Jen Psaki and the White House go to them and say, we want you to take down these accounts that we don't agree with.
This is misinformation. Okay. That is a huge danger to free speech. It's basically like the administration saying to these big tech companies, nice little social network you got there. It'd be a real shame if anything happened to it. Look at what's going on. Wait, don't you want them broken up? I do want them broken up, but what I don't want- So which is it? Do you want them to hold the sword? Or do you not want them to hold the sword? I actually want the sword to come crashing. I actually want the sword to come crashing down. So you want them to swing the sword and not hold it over and then use it for extortion.
Yes. That's actually a great explanation then. Freiberg. Yes. I'm trying to moderate here. Freiberg. Do you give a shit? We've talked about this before. Freiberg has spent all day on his phone. He has not dialed into this podcast. I'm with you guys. I thought we just went over the Alpha Fold stuff way too fast. I mean, the arguing over freedom of speech is happening. And all of this debate, Friedberg, at the same time that we are making incredible life changing moments for humanity, two different companies went to space last week with civilians. And then we are basically defining the blueprint for the human and every other species on the planet and we're fighting over people too stupid to take a goddamn vaccine that would save everybody's life and let us continue on and people are dunking on bezos for not reading the room i don't know if you saw this friedberg but how do you think about the space race in relation to reading the room etc progress technologically um will only arise with capital so you can assume that that progress, you know, it's not like someone stumbles into a cave and discovered a rocket ship or stumbles into a cave and discovered AlphaFold.
There are years of toiling in labs like Edison did making the light bulb. Edison had to raise a ton of money to get that light bulb project off the ground. If you guys haven't read, I'm trying to remember the biography, there's a Wizards of something. It's got Wizards in the title. It's a good biography of Edison. And, you know, and I feel like we're at this moment where... The Wizard of Menlo Park? Yeah, I think that's the Wizard of Menlo Park. That's right. And the amount of capital that it takes to make these breakthroughs at AlphaFold or at Waymo, or what Bezos and Elon are doing is so extraordinary that you have to be in a position where you can fund this work.
You're not going to get a bunch of Kickstarters to fund a SpaceX like project or a, you know, Blue Origin like project. And so I think that the benefit of scale that comes out of some of these businesses is that we can do research and development, and we can progress our capabilities as a species forward in a way that would have never been possible if not for the capitalist system and the ability for these businesses to accumulate a large enough pool of capital to take on multiple billion dollar bets. And like Chamath said, waste a lot of money and lose on 9 out of 10 of them. But if that $1 billion bet works, it's worth $500 billion.
And that money continuously gets reinvested. And look at what Google did with Waymo. They put over a billion dollars in that project before everyone woke up and said, my God, self-driving is real, it's possible. And it kickstarted an industry. And I just feel like the amount of money and not to mention the fact that like, these are free markets. So these businesses, Google, you don't have to search on Google. You don't have to buy from Amazon, but everyone benefits from searching on Google. Everyone benefits from buying on Amazon. And the capability of these businesses is rooted entirely on the fact that consumers are choosing to use their products and their services, because they are so good.
And so I don't feel like these guys are screwing people over. You can consider the small business model as being like, hey, maybe we shouldn't have had small business retailers for as long as we did, because at some point, distribution was going to be economically advantaged by being centralized. And therefore, all consumers are going to benefit by centralizing. Is there really a right to maintain local distribution sites that we call small businesses that should remain in business forever? Maybe there's a way to help them transition into a new business model or a new market. But same with what happened with the taxi industry, technology will force these evolutions, the capital accumulates, and that capital can be invested in things that we would have never imagined on a smaller scale.
But go ahead, yeah. No, I do think sympathetic to what you were saying, I do think that if you look at every platform innovation that's ever happened. So whether it's, you know, we go from no print to print, you know, to newspapers, to radio, to television, you've always first started with a pendulum that was very much firmly in the camp of centralized, monopolistic, or oligopolistic kind of early outcomes. And either through legislation or through innovation, then the pendulum swings to decentralization. That's typically happened, right? And you can look at all of these industries that's gone through that.
So it stands to reason that technology will be not dissimilar to those things. And everybody says the argument is, well, no, because technology has these specific features of network effects and lock-in. But I think that betrays this idea that legislatively, you can come and just basically destroy the China and the China shop, and you have to just start all over. So it's likely that we're going to move to a place that's a healthier outcome for everybody. And obviously, we want things like AlphaFold to exist. We want things like Waymo to exist. The question is, how should they exist? And if they come out of the goodwill of Google, it is just so easily as likely that some other person, let's say it wasn't Sundar and Ruth Peratt, but two other people who didn't like it, these things could have been very different forms and shapes and not existed at all.
And I think that's the arbitrary nature of it, which is not necessarily free market capitalism that doesn't benefit us. Should we, Chamath, be upset that Bezos is going to space and spending tens of billions of dollars that he made from Amazon? He had a bad press conference. Let's just be clear. At the end of the day, he has wanted to do this his entire life. He built an incredible company. He was able to take a lot of that capital and invested in it. He's invested billions of dollars in other things, $10 billion in climate change. His ex-wife has invested $6 billion just last year alone in all kinds of good works.
So those two individuals, because of their success, I think will generally do and have done the right thing. Let's not get that confused with a horrendous press conference where he just put his freedom in his mouth. Why was it horrendous? Well, I think you said it. The thing that he said around, I just want to thank the customers and the employees for paying for this. It sounded flippant. And it didn't really acknowledge the incredible amount of heavy lifting and hard work that he did acknowledge in the clip from 2000 on Charlie Rose. Right? So if you if you actually played those two things back side by side, you'd say, is this the same person?
One was thoughtful, extremely respectful. The other one was now maybe he was just amped up. I mean, I could see how he could be on cloud nine, so to speak you know and so and so he just wasn't thinking about it but you know honestly like look he is smart enough and that team is smart enough to say we're assuming you're coming back so here's some fucking talking points why don't you just look at those on the way down as you float down to earth and let's just make sure we nail this and put our best foot forward that is where i think he probably has some regrets based on how people reacted this bezos space flight was a real rorschach test because he took heat from both the right and the left but the criticism was very different.
You know, the critique I heard from the right was that he's having some sort of midlife crisis and the rocket looked too much like a phallus. Okay, fine, whatever. The criticism from the left was it had much more to do with a real contempt for private initiative and private enterprise. You could almost see them being horrified and dismayed that, you know, why was he doing this with his own money? You know, if this had been a NASA flight, I don't think they would have had a problem with it. And so, you see here that even though Bezos has been so much more effective using his own money to do this, the left just reflexively hates that.
And they kept saying, well, how dare he use this money? The money could have been used on something else so much better. What do you think of that argument? I think it's wrong in a couple of respects. It basically implies that the purveyors of these social programs are better distributors of societal resources than our greatest inventors. And I don't think that's true. You look at these social programs, they want to keep doubling down on, they're not working. These programs, our policies towards homelessness is not failing because of lack of funding. There's a tremendous amount of funding. In San Francisco, they're spending $60,000 per tent per year.
They're spending $300,000 in social services per homeless person per year. Lack of funding is not the problem. The approach is the problem. We spend something like $25,000 per pupil in California schools, the test scores are going down. So, you know, these people who are criticizing Bezos don't know what to do with the money. They don't know how to spend it any better. They're not good at executing. However, Bezos or Elon, these are two of our greatest inventors. Let them go. Let them go because, you know, they are pushing the boundaries and I do believe there will be great engineering and scientific breakthroughs that come as a result of what they're doing with this new space race.
It's also super uninformed, correct me if I'm wrong here, but they were saying that they should have been doing more initiatives on Earth if you actually, and they were kind of talking about climate change and the use of these fuels to get to space. And number one, the rocket ship fuel, my understanding in these is less than what happens in a 747. So put that aside. And then second, Elon has done more for global warming with Tesla than anybody in the in the battery packs, I think in modern society, I can't think of somebody in the private sector who's done more. And then has there ever been a gift?
There's never been a gift of $10 billion to one cause, let alone one cause which Bezos gave, which was climate change. Nobody, nobody has done more. So hasn't you would know, Chamath, I thought Richard Branson had done a lot for global warming. I thought he was very involved in the carbon credits space. I think that we're witnessing something that can best be described as people who have reached a point in their life where they've realized that they're impotent, getting incredibly angry at people who are willing to be wrong, but want to just have a chance to be on the field and try. And have the freedom to do so.
And that just literally infuriates a certain class of people. It proves itself out by what David said, we are not in a funding crisis, we are running 10 $20 trillion deficits, you know, or sorry, 10, you know, hundreds of billions of dollar deficits 10 $20 trillion debt levels that are increasing every year. We have a surfeit of money. We print money whenever we want, we don't have a shortage of money. We have a shortage of capable people who know what to do with that money. And in the absence of people being able to do things, they would rather other people not do things, not because it's not the right thing to do, but because it makes them feel impotent.
Right. And so, what is driving that? I think there is a real contempt for private initiative. And Jason, you're right. You see it in the hatred towards Elon. Nobody has done more to actually reduce carbon emissions than Elon. I mean, even the business- End of story. Period, end of story. I mean, the Bezos gift to some philanthropy, I don't know if that's going to make a difference or not. You're right that he's putting his money where his mouth is on that issue. But it's indisputable that Elon, the electric car industry would not exist without Elon. And yet there is contempt and hatred for the fact that he did this through private initiative.
If the government- Because he does it in a way that is not checking the boxes for this cohort of people who feel incredibly insecure and fragile emotionally. They don't like that he says what he wants. They don't like that he does what he wants. They don't like that he dresses the way he does. They don't like any of it because it's not conformist enough. It's not about the, look, people- Well, it's also about the money that, it's the wealth that's been accumulated too. Well, no, no, no, hold on. I don't think that's what it is at all. No? I actually think what it is is psychological. It is nothing about money.
I think what we are witnessing, and I think social media has just blown the cover off it is a psychological awakening that people have, which is that they were comfortable knowing that there was a class of insiders and a huge cohort of outsiders, and they just believed the world would function as it should. Now you see people migrating through this membrane, achieving enormous amounts of success, basically eclipsing every single insider possible by orders of magnitude, and it breaks people's brains because they don't like it because now they think, Why didn't it happen to me? Why not me? And the thing is, because you're not capable.
And at some world along the way- Or hardworking. You're not dedicated. Or you didn't try. Or you didn't get lucky. They didn't act with agency. I mean, look, every day, every day, the greatest thing that I've learned about the public markets now, having been purely on the early stage technology side, building, running, then investing, is I get a mark every day, right? Now to do both businesses, I get a scorecard every day. and some days i really think to myself maybe i'm just not good enough today and i say to myself that is true today and then the the difference is tomorrow i have a choice which is i wake up and i decide am i going to go back at it or not and i'm not in the game and i'm not going to hate on other people who had a good day today just because i had a bad day and that's what i think we're going through we're going through and social media allows it to happen and it allows you to put it out there you can hide behind a screen name you can basically say whatever you want to vent this pent-up frustration one has journalists doing it too of course of course because these journalists are doing it too where they're just so bitter that they feel dunking on the greatest inventors of our time is a productive use the difference is journalists do it with a real screen name under the guise of journalism everybody else does it with a fake screen name and it's all just a bunch trolling.
In order to do something really great like Bezos or like Elon, you have to believe that you have agency over your own life. You have to believe that you can accomplish great things. You have to act with purpose. And is that really what we're teaching kids today in schools? What we're teaching them is they're either victims or oppressors at some intersectional framework. We're not teaching them about earned success. We're teaching them about privilege, which is presumptively ill-gotten. And it's all about a transference of privilege and basically money from people who are oppressors in this framework to people who are victims.
But no one's talking about how you actually create change and success in the world, right? Abundance. It's all a negative sum. It's always a negative sum game. Freebird, go ahead. I dated all back to the Kim Kardashian sex tape. I think that there was this moment where someone who was, didn't do anything, didn't have a career, wasn't doing anything work-wise, but was kind of a pseudo celebrity for being a celebrity. It's like the Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie era, right? Like, folks who don't really have much to talk about, except that they're the ones that people are talking about. And then that sex tape turned her into a superstar.
And then she became a And so, you know, there is this kind of poignant moment, I think, where folks are like, wait a second, you don't have to do anything to get really rich in this country. You don't have to do anything to achieve all this fame. Therefore, the kind of assumption is, hey, you know what, there are people that just get stuff and get to do what they want to do. And the rest of us don't. and I do think that social media is the magnifying glass that takes those those moments and makes them very big and kind of then that becomes the assumed standard when the reality is I mean all four of us worked really fucking hard all four of us came from nothing I don't know about sacks but I mean the rest of us yeah his dad was an immigrant doctor from South Africa and he moved to the deep south as a Jew I'm just joking 80s but I mean I mean I think all of us graduated college deeply in debt.
And then we all worked our way out of debt. And we all found ways to work really hard and find opportunities for ourselves in this incredible country, and to build value and to build businesses, and to realize those returns. And we don't start out as elites. We were never elite. We were always the struggling, you know, immigrant entrepreneurs that got ourselves to where we are, because we clawed and we pushed and we fought and we had grit and we had determination and we had smarts and we had put in the effort. And I think that that's not really and so did Bezos and so did Elon. And I don't think that there is any standard of elitism that endowed in them like maybe in you know the British the days of the British monarchy these kind of inalienable rights to have the freedom that they have.
And I think that that and I think that that's so important because people miss that point and they think that Kim Kardashian or the random bolt of lightning or the elite is the kind of endowed upon people in a way that's unfair. They're misreading the situation. It's a great point. Everyone else is missing out. Yeah. They misread the situation. So a couple of things. Kim Kardashian may have gotten some initial fame because of her sex tape, but fuck if she's not an incredible business person because from there to now, that's execution. Totally true. There's a lot of toiling, hard work, good decision making.
She fucking nailed it. Was I lucky to have actually joined Facebook versus MySpace? Yes. But when I was there, did I fucking hit the cover off the ball? Goddamn yes. Was I lucky to have started social capital and be able to raise capital? Sure. But then did I have to help find a team, coach that team, work with them, make good investments? That's fucking hard. And I think what people forget is that this takes a lot of hard work, that there's all kinds of levels of success, that you can be proud of all kinds of different accomplishments. What I loved is when Friedberg used us and Elon and Bezos in the same sentence, because I catch myself where I'm ashamed sometimes, where I'm like, I am not as good as those two guys.
So how dare I use my name in the same sentence as their name? And then I think, wait a minute, what the fuck am I quibbling over? Like, this is insane. In any way, shape or form, we've all made it. Sure, there's different degrees, but it's beyond that it matters at this point. and this is what i think we're living in a society where it really distorts you so if how do we change it chamath how do we change people from thinking that it's random and that you can't do it because there are a group of people who are no it is okay but there are a group of people who believe the system is rigged i cannot become chamath and i'm stuck in a rut and i can't get out i can't get out how do we change that belief the whiners and the complainers and the haters are stuck in a massive rut and i think the thing that happened that i said it last pot I'll say it again.
Maybe I'll just say it every fucking pod. It is not about winning and losing. It is about trying and learning. And that is a huge thing. It's about a learning mindset. It's about this idea that things are changing so fucking fast. The only thing that I can do to stay safe is to learn how to learn because things will constantly be changing underfoot. But what do you say to the single mother with three kids who is in a town where the factory is shutting down and she's losing her job and she doesn't have the resources to move? She is not the person that hates Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos. I will fucking bet you dollars.
But what does she do? Because aren't there institutional ruts in the United States? Yeah. I understand. These are two completely different topics. my point is if you go online it is filled with p a small cohort of people that are positive and then a large cohort of people that are silently trying to just gain information grind it out yeah and a small vocal minority of bitter people who can't do shit and all i'm talking about privileged people well who knows if they're privileged but i'm just saying they're getting paid a hundred thousand to work at the alaska i just think i just think that these people had been checkboxers their whole lives.
They tried to play the team sports they were told to they went to the schools, they tried to do the CFA, the NBA, the this or the that. Nothing worked for them. They work in an environment where they don't feel any equity. Actually, this is where equity is important. They feel disenfranchised, and they're angry. And as a result, they just want everything to be different so that nobody wins because they can't win. But if they were winning, they would be the first one to say, shut the fucking door behind me. I'm convinced of it 100%. Yeah, the irony is that the people you're talking about all went to these elite institutions, and they imbibed these ideologies and philosophies.
And I think the people who have been successful went to those, not in all cases, but they went to those places and then rebelled against it or just shut it out. Here's what we should do. Here's what we should do. We should all contribute five or 10 million bucks into an LLC. We should call Pegasus. We should use Pegasus to infiltrate all the fake screen names on Twitter, and then index that to LinkedIn to figure out where they all went to school and what they do and just publish a database of all the haters. Well, I mean, it's... How funny would that be? I, it's very interesting because I'm watching a group of these complainers leave traditional mainstream media because I'm focused on journalists because I was one.
And I'm watching them leave journalism, a small group of them, and become entrepreneurs on Substack or their own products. And I feel like there's a little group of them who are realizing, holy shit, I can make a million dollars if I apply myself and I quit the New York Times and I go start my own publication. Right. And I actually say something interesting and differentiated, not just towing the party line at the New York Times. There's a whole little, there's a little crack here in this. I'll say, I'll say they are just as successful as Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos. The, the financial quantum may be different, but I bet you the personal fucking satisfaction quantum is the same.
And this is the key. This is the key. You could be running a $500,000 a year business and you could feel like a million fucking bucks. Yes, you're king. you're a queen. You have a nice house. You have a nice family. You employ a couple people. You provide a good life. You do what you want to do when you want to do it. The sense of freedom that comes with that and power and agency is the same as them. And maybe in some ways, the super richest guys in the world actually have less agency than these guys would because they're so, you know, scheduled and people are coming after them all the time. One of my big takeaways from being in the tech industry for 20 years is that if you're smart, hardworking, and don't have behaviors that sabotage yourself, you will be successful in this industry.
You know, over two decades. I mean, I've just seen it. How could you not? How could you not? You have such tailwinds at your back. There's so much value being created. We saw over the past year, more money, more LP dollars have gone into venture capital by far than any other year. And more money, more returns is coming out. That's why more money is going in. I'm on the call when you say anybody could be successful just by showing up. Right. But the first part is the critical part. You just said who are not prone to self-sabotage. There is an enormous number of people who are prone to self. I was one.
I am still one. But I work on it every day. How do you self-sabotage yourself? Your ego? He blew up his firm. That's true. But I think he blew it up. There was creative destruction. I think he wasn't enjoying it and he needed to start over. No, he talked about it publicly. He said it. But the blowing up of... How do you reconcile the blowing up of the firm, Chamath? whatever number of years later, I'm rebooting it. This is all old news. It's like, you know, the amount of success and capital and money that we've made is undisputable. And I've made it under all kinds of weather conditions. So, you know, it all kind of speaks for itself.
But the problem is, again, if you ask an average person, I don't think they care. I don't think they know. I don't think they have an opinion. If you ask some, you know, blithering hater. I'm interested in how you reconcile or look back on it. Now it's so much distance. I'll tell you from an outside perspective, how I reconcile Chamath's decision there is, I think that as you become more successful, your tolerance for doing stuff you don't want to do really goes down. Zero. It goes to zero. Of course, Chamath has got to a point where he didn't want to be doing it and he blew it up. Zero. By the way, that is a characterization as well, that, you know, sometimes in your career, you have to make it, and in your personal life, you have to make a tough decision.
And there is no good outcome. There is no good way to frame it. No graceful way to do it. But there are these moments where you got a rock falling on you from one side and a rock falling on you from the other side. And you're going to have to make a tough decision to get out of the way. I said to myself a long time ago that if I was ever lucky to actually be wealthy enough where my wealth would change by meaningful amounts, every order of magnitude, I would do something different. And so, you know, you can do the fucking math. So there it is. I it's interesting being friends with you and watching it and then also I hate to give you know any credit there it is but being friends with Phil Hellmuth and watching him set outrageous goals for himself in poker I just thought you know what you got to set some outrageous goals for yourself and that's how I sort of broke through as I just said the minute I realized one at everything I do I want to be the largest syndicate the most Jason prolific investor the minute i realized that i was basically going to become you know a billionaire because of my facebook stock i fucking quit and the craziest thing about it is i left so much stock on the table it's like two three billion dollars of fucking stock i couldn't care less and then and then you know once i figured out that there was something that you can do with capital that's even more meaningful than just investing in companies at a small scale but now you can control companies and really allocate and shape how economy flows, I made a different set of decisions.
And now I'm here. And if I increase it by another order of magnitude, I'll make a different set of decisions. And that's poorly understood by folks, because again, it doesn't map into a worldview. But the point is, it maps into something that keeps me whole and sane. And it allows me to not be zero sum about everybody else's success. And that's what I think we need to teach people. Try stuff. It's okay to fail. Because as long as you're not self-sabotaging yourself. David said it so well, you will eventually be successful. What have you learned, David, in this next chapter, being an investor capital allocator?
Me? Yeah, David, you. Well, that's what I said. Have you learned anything or are you just, yeah? No, it's what I said. I mean, the thing that's happening right now is just the tech economy keeps getting bigger and bigger. It's just an explosion. There's an explosion in the number of unicorns, an explosion in the amount of funding that's available, explosion in the amount of returns being generated. There are now so many VCs that VCs are literally throwing money at people. I mean, any half-decent idea now gets funded. The idea that somehow this ecosystem is elitist or exclusionary, it's absurd, right?
I mean, you've got micro VCs now who no one has to go to Sand Hill Road anymore, right? I mean, there are so many ways to raise money. There's nobody on Sand Hill Road. It's a ghost town. Remember the traffic jam? I went down there the other day and there was no traffic jam. I was speaking at Stanford and literally I was like, oh, I got to put 15 minutes into my drive to get through that Sandhill Road because it was at 830. I zipped down Sandhill Road to Stanford. There was two cars. The tech ecosystem is so osmotic. It's so permeable in terms of allowing new people in. In fact, it's sucking in all the talent it can find because it can't hire enough people, even in the worst economic conditions.
And yet, when it comes to talking about opportunity in social and political terms, the only thing you ever hear is that the ecosystem is somehow elitist or exclusionary. I think that's old news. That might have been valid 15, 20 years ago. I know when I went to Sand Hill Road for the first time 15, 20 years ago, it was a bunch of white partners who went to Stanford or had MBAs from Harvard, but that's not the case now. It's a bunch of people with rolling funds and micro VCs and syndicates and everything in between. If you're so wrapped up in being a social justice warrior that you've just missed, that there is like basically infinite opportunity, you know, then it's on you.
You're sabotaging yourself. And then five, 10 years later, you're still stuck in that role. And then you become bitter. And then you become bitter to Jamal's point. Freebrook, how hard was it for you to leave Google? And what was that like? I was at Google for two and a half years. I had gone through, I joined before the IPO. I was like a couple hundred employees, just under a thousand employees. And then we went public. I got this huge bonus from Sergey. to stick around when I was thinking about leaving. To find huge. I mean, for me, it was like... Seven figures, eight figures? It was... Yeah, it was a couple thousand shares of stock and like $250,000 of cash.
And I gave it up. You know, it'd be worth a lot of money. But I just felt like I learned so much at Google and I had such an appreciation for the team there and the company. And by the way, I worked at Google and all of a sudden, the company went public and I could buy a house. I mean, it was an incredible moment for me. And I suddenly felt what Chamath talked about, which is this freedom in my life. Suddenly I had hit that next plateau of wealth where I now had a couple hundred thousand dollars of net worth and I could leave or I guess I had over a million dollars of net worth and I could now leave and go do something I wanted to go do with my life.
No, I had a couple hundred thousand dollars and I could go leave and do what I wanted to do, which was to build my own business and have the freedom to make decisions. And so I honestly felt like really fine just leaving all that money behind. I left millions of dollars behind when I left Google after being there for two and a half years to start my company. And it was a struggle, right? Like, I mean, as you guys know, building a business, which I did from 2006 to 2013, was a nightmare. Every day was a nightmare. I say in entrepreneurism, I've said this publicly before, but it feels like every day you're taking a step backwards.
And one out of five days, you take a five-step leap forward. So at the end of a week, you're one step ahead of where you started, but your existential memory is that you're failing every day. Every day. And suddenly you wake up and seven years have gone by and you're like, oh shit, we've got an amazing business and someone wants to buy it for a billion dollars. And if you don't have the grit and the guts and the determination to push through those daily battles and deal with that hardship, you know, and I don't think that being in the comfort of the big system of Google felt right for me. I think being in the playing field and battling it out every day is right for me.
And so it was the right it was the right call for me, obviously, it worked out. But you know, still, I make choices in my life in terms of what do I want to do? Do I want to go live on a yacht or have some luxury or do whatever? And I prefer to just make great businesses and turn science into into commercial opportunity. And that's how I choose to spend my time. And I just want to just send this out to the whole panel. Do you ever think, you know, having hit the home runs and having the cash to literally retire at this age and then just, you know, kiteboard or do whatever. Do you ever think about retirement and not going into work?
Fuck no. Okay. Yeah. You want to do you feel you want to work harder? Yesterday, yesterday, as an example, was an incredible day because I was able to bicycle with Nat and the youngest to go get a gelato. I had a kickoff meeting for I had a kickoff meeting for a startup that's doing something incredible in batteries. Where, you know, starting from scratch, series A, co founders, me and the other end, the other director and we're starting literally starting and i remember the feeling of having done this now 30 or 40 times and it's the best feeling uh and then i and then i had a call because i'm trying to put a you know more than a billion dollars to work in a different battery idea uh and i thought to myself god like i'm so fucking lucky um and it's it was a grindy long day and i had never felt more thankful so why would i you know you could and i don't know i i feel just so blessed sacks you ever think about hanging up um or are you more motivated to go to work every day are you annoyed yeah i mean the thing that's giving me the most energy right now is we're in uh a private beta on call in you're this app that we incubated and um i mean it's it's it's it's good and it's getting better every day and i'm really enjoying tinkering on it and i feel like you know, it's kind of like You're a good tinkerer, by the way.
You're a good product editor. You're good at tickling. You know, we tried to hire Saks as VP of product at Facebook. What? Yeah. What would that have paid him? I used 2,000 Saks. Probably billions. 7 billions probably. 2007 or 8 Saks. Do you regret not taking that gig? No, no, because I did Yammer instead. And, you know, Yammer was successful and I got to be my own boss and that was better, you know. So, I don't know if I probably wouldn't have made as much money. But look, I've done, like you guys, I've made lots of decisions that made me less money. If I just stayed at PayPal for 20 years, my stock would have been worth many, many billions, right?
That's why I tell people, don't sell everything, let your winners ride, at least partially. Yeah. I mean, look, I was an investor in Facebook. If I just kept all of that stock, that'd be worth a billion dollars today. So, I mean, it's pretty crazy. Well, sell some, just don't sell everything. That's my new philosophy. Yeah. But to your point about what gives me enjoyment, I mean, I'm really having fun tinkering with this app. And you know what it's like? It's like a new season. If you were in the NBA or something, it's like, can we make a championship run? Can we get one more ring? Yes. And so, it'd be like saying to somebody, hey, you already got an NBA champion.
Hey, you got three rings. Why do you want a fourth? And it's like, are you kidding me? While I'm still in this league while I'm young enough and healthy enough to make a run at one more ring, how could you not want to do that, you know? You gotta go for it. I can see you're engaged, which is great to see. Alright, listen, this has been an amazing episode. We will see you all next week. If you like the show, thanks. The end. We're not going to bang. Go try something, everybody. Go try something. Go do something. Anything possible. Try and fail. Just try. read a book outside of your comfort zone read something that you wouldn't have otherwise read love you guys but i love you guys love you best see you soon love everybody listening to love everybody i mean literally if you're listening to this and you are buying into this that the system is right troll don't be a troll don't be a douche like the system is not rigged if anything the system is rigged for you to participate and succeed join the party the system is malleable.
What do you mean by this? If you want to change the world, the system is malleable enough that if you pursue it in the right way, you can make a dent. You can. Who is this? Who is this little... Hey, look how happy you are. Who's the best dad? Who's your dad now? Alright, we'll see you all next time on the All In Podcast. Bye-bye. We'll let your winners ride. Rain Man, David Sack. And instead, we open-source it to the fans, and they've just gone crazy with it. Love you, Wesley. I'm queen of kinwad. I'm going all in. Besties are gone. That's my dog taking notice in your driveway. Oh, man. My habbitasher will meet me at the end.
We should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy because they're all just useless. It's like this sexual tension, but they just need to release them out. Wet your feet. Wet your feet. We need to get merch. I'm doing all in. I'm doing all in.