Show Notes:
00:00 Cold Open
01:19 Titles
01:01 Intro Banter
04:24 Supply chain, labor shortage,
34:04 Taiwan
43:14 Sacks Desantis
47:00 Dave Chappelle
01:08:24 FDA
01:23:27 Question 1
01:27:08 Question 2
Follow the besties:
https://twitter.com/DavidSacks
Follow the pod:
https://twitter.com/theallinpod
https://linktr.ee/allinpodcast
Intro Music Credit:
https://twitter.com/yung_spielburg
Intro Video Credit:
https://twitter.com/TheZachEffect
Referenced in the show:
Statista - The U.S. Car Models Most Impacted By The Microchip Shortage
Zack Kanter on Twitter - "The "supply chain crisis" is a clever rebrand"
Naithan Jones on Twitter - NFTs
Daily Breeze - No start date for 24/7 operations at Port of LA
LA Daily News - Port of LA to go to 24/7 operations, Biden announces
Nikkei Asia - TSMC announces plans to build first chip plant in Japan
St. Louis Fed - Total Public Debt as Percent of Gross Domestic Product
Forbes - Druckenmiller Blasts Fed's 'Radical' Stimulus Policy
David Sacks on Twitter - Desantis Dinner
Variety - Ted Sarandos Doubles Down
The Light of Other Days by Arthur C. Clarke
CFTC Orders Tether and Bitfinex to Pay Fines Totaling $42.5 Million
No summary for this episode yet.
Yesterday, the game went off the chain. It was, we started off at $500,000, and then we were like, ah, these $500 chips are so annoying. Then we started to play $1,000, $1,000. Then it was $1,000, $2,000. Then it's $1,000, $2,000, $4,000. Then $1,248. Then $1,248, $16. $1,248, $16, $32,000 coming around. Oh, my God. How much did you lose? What was the big winner and big loser? How much? I'm not going to say. Just tell us how much. F*** out $800. I put at minus 800 minus 700 don't say these fucking names bro how'd you do Chamath? I did okay you can tell that Chamath lost because when you ask him how'd you do and it's like just he goes from this super effusive talking about the game to just like one word fine okay fine okay how was your night?
he's like look I shit 42 million dollars for breakfast it was fine Here we go. Three, two. Hey, everybody. Welcome to another episode of the All In Podcast, 50 episodes down. And yeah, we'll definitely get three or four more in before the band breaks up with us today again from an undisclosed location. David Sachs, the Rain Man himself, Chamath Palihapitiya, the dictator and the Queen of Kinoa, David Friedberg. How's everybody doing? How's everybody feeling? How's everybody's week going? Really great. Yours? Just just great. Awesome. i uh i i feel really good i um i feel super grateful oh really despite your poker game last night the stock market's up today he feels grateful i mean it's been a good week it's been a good week i feel so much equanimity market's up four percent uh freeberg how are you doing my wife went to the um hospital three times this week all three times thinking she was in labor hey um are you how how i mean we're two centimeters dilated we're still waiting here i mean we are there too and we're just waiting any day like literally any hour um so we were how do we get action on this can we can we bet who's gonna come first or i think i think freeberg's gonna come first because it's his third it's only nat it's allison's third it's nat second yeah yeah so we can lay odds two to one what do we get i'll take the over under on what day is it today today is the 15th.
We're getting induced on the 26th. That's 11 days from now. I'll take the over-under on the I'll take the over-under on the 21st. That you're setting the line? I'll set the line at the 21st of October. I'm going over. I'll go over for a thou. This is for Nat? Book it. Okay. So you got the over, you got the under. What do you got, Saks? Over-under on the 21st. 26th is the expected date. What are we betting on? So, Saks, some people pay attention when their children are born. And when their children are born, shifts. We're trying to get action. Aren't you guys a little too old to be having kids?
I mean, are you even going to see them graduate? What's going on here? I mean, Saks, some of us are a whole bar mitzvah younger than you. Saks, are you snipped? If anybody was snipped, I would guess it would be Saks. Are you snippy snippy? Is this the type of vital information you think the audience wants to know? Yeah, I think they do, actually. I think that's a yes. I think he's been snipped. Chamath is definitely not snipped. Nope. Freedberg's not snipped. You want to come over here and inspect? Do the procedure? Conduct an inspection? I don't think you can visually understand that. It's not visually understandable.
Yeah, Freedberg's definitely not snipped as proven by his wife being pregnant. I don't think you say snip, bro. I think you just say vasectomy, bro. I'm just, you know. I think you say snip snip. I think Sachs has been snipped. That's actually a good bet. We could book it on Sachs being snipped. Okay, listen, a lot of topics to get to. I think we were trying to get to this topic last week. There's been a supply chain interruption right now. There's some shortages, obviously, of key components like microchips. We all know this. According to Car and Driver, the top three models impacted by the chip shortage were the Ford F-Series pickup trucks, Jeep Cherokee SUVs, and the Chevy Equinox SUVs.
basically a lot of the cars that have advanced driving systems are now removing them i was looking at getting an suv for the winter and i was looking at the cadillac escalade and they took self-driving out of the 2022 model or the autopilot basically because they can't get the chips and we all know why this is happening obviously covid and then also on top of it demand so people are buying second computers, third computers, places like Dell are having an Apple are selling a lot of desktops, a lot of laptops. And there's also a labor shortage. So the labor force, obviously, here in the United States is much smaller than it was.
We all know that people are raising salaries to try to get people to come back to work. They're turning off the bonus unemployment early in some states. We're here in October, this is all supposed to be turned off by now. So I guess I'll start with you, Chamath, in terms of the markets here. What do you think is happening? And is this an acute risk or just something that will pass? I think the well, this is where I think I kind of generally disagree with the market. I think that most people are under the impression that these are short term kind of contractions and expansions and that this is just the thing that needs to get work through the system as we readjust to a post COVID world, blah, blah, blah.
I think it's different. And the reason I think it's different is if you just look at one thing and one thing only, which is that we have a massive labor shortage in America. And there is an incredible stat that I saw, which was the average hourly earnings of non manager people in hospitality and travel. And the average salary, the mean salary was around 20 some odd dollars an hour, and it's now 33 bucks an hour. And so what that to me says is that we are going through a really sustained period where you cannot get people to do the work that needs to get done. Biden had to call the port of LA and try to get these guys to be open 24 hours a day the president of the United States is calling a local port trying to get it to stay open but why can't they stay open because you have long Sherman you have all these unionized folks who will expect to get certain levels of compensation which they deserve in order to do that work 24-7 but then all of that is going to get put through the system and if you still have millions of jobs that needs to get done in order for the economy to function the only efficient way that that's gonna get resolved is by raising salaries and those are consistent and persistent right those things are not just like oh you know what i gave yes i did say 50 bucks an hour but now i'm taking you back you can't take that back that's gonna be that's so and then so i tend to so that that's one thing and then second so there's people right so labor capital i just think it's getting more and more expensive to get folks to do work and then there's the raw materials that you use to make anything and everything that i see is that stuff is going bananas and so i put these two things together and i'm like i think this stuff is here to stay um i'm really kind of a little bit of a you know and i and i had not worried and you you can see in every episode before this i was always consistently like there is no inflation you can fade the inflation trade now i'm kind of positioning myself to uh hedge myself in this situation all right freeberg uh we've seen the pictures uh of the long beach and the los angeles uh ports there's just ships out there like i think 70 or 80 is where it peaked at uh in july i don't know have the latest data here of when it updated um but is there not a silver lining here that if people are making more money then we're going to increase the size of the middle class and we're going to, you know, increase upward mobility.
And that is a double edged sword. It's great that we increased the middle class, but then they're going to want to buy stuff. So people are now making 35 bucks an hour, and they were making 20. Now they got more disposable. Now they're gonna go on Amazon and buy more stuff. And it's going to accelerate this problem. Is it not? The challenge is the rate of change. This is what the Fed tries to manage. And you know, there's a White House economic advisory committee that's involved in trying to figure out what's going to happen here because the current estimate is it's going to take at least a year or probably a year to work through the current log jam and the global supply chains and during that period of time as chamak points out what's happening is the cost for goods is climbing because people have to um charge more because there's limited inventory and people are bidding up the the value of that inventory.
As they do that, the businesses end up needing to get more labor. And so they have to pay more to hire people, if they pay more to hire people, those people end up demanding more. And the cycle can actually go the wrong direction where you have an inflationary spike that persists. How do you taper that inflation? It's not necessarily great for economic growth if you can't produce the stuff. And it can actually cause these runaway kind of effects in the dynamic system of supply and demand when you have these things clogging up the system for supply. So it is a real risk. And it is the biggest thing that, you know, the White House, this economic task force is kind of trying to figure out right now is where's the balance lie where you can, you know, basically try and taper this inflationary effect that's being caused by this logjam in the supply chain without causing economic disruption by raising interest rates.
And so it's a really kind of complicated, you know, second and third derivative formula that needs to kind of be resolved. And that's why so many of these little elements are so important to get right. By the way, rates, by the way, central bankers around the world have raised rates. The only place that hasn't gone up is Europe, ECB, and the United States of Federal Reserve. So, and let's be honest, you know, Europe and the United States, we absorb labor and materials from all around the world, right? We are the net importers. We are the net ultimate buyers of last resort of all of these things.
And so if you're seeing inflation in those other, you know, supply driven economies, they are going to come on shore, they're going to hit us in the face. I think prices are going up. The other free market argument that could be made is that these current trends will accelerate a trend towards more automation of low cost labor, because it now will make sense for businesses to invest in the capital, in the CapEx, in the infrastructure, and ultimately for technology companies to build that tooling to support that infrastructure that will automate jobs like working in fast food, like doing local delivery, like doing factory assembly, like moving things across the country in trucks.
So self-driving trucks, you know, factory automation, biomanufacturing, additive and 3D manufacturing and 3D printing. These are all industries that could benefit from the fact that labor now for kind of, you know, traditionally low income work has gotten so expensive that it starts to make sense to switch to the technology alternative, which historically may have been too expensive, but now starts to make economic sense to businesses. And so there's a number of these automation industries that may significantly benefit. And that ends up ultimately being deflationary and the market comes into balance.
So that's another way to kind of think about the macro on what may play out. There's a bigger risk here than just inflation. I mean, there's also a risk of stagnation or stagflation, because it's not just that prices are going up and workers' wages are going up, which could be a good thing. But goods and services just aren't being produced. so i mean i know like my own experience i recently ordered a tesla when i got a tesla a couple years ago like i got it in two weeks it was like almost instant this time they wanted me to wait two months and it's got an alert that's going to take two more months beyond that so we have no idea and if it if you know tesla doesn't get most of the money i don't think until i actually take delivery of the car right that's when you make final payment so now they can't book that revenue and those earnings and tesla isn't even the car company that's most affected by this.
You know, the big, you know, traditional American auto companies like Ford are even more affected. So if companies cannot deliver their products, that can cause an economic recession. And I think like these are major storm clouds looming on the horizon. Now, what is the cause of this? I mean, I think it's multifactorial. A lot of things that Shema said, I just want to really highlight this port issue. There was a great tweet storm by Zach Cantor earlier in the week where he said, The supply chain crisis is a clever rebrand. It makes it seem like there are grand exogenous forces at work rather than the unions holding ports for ransom while dozens of ships pile up, working just two shifts with a two-hour break in between the country at their mercy.
And he goes on to elaborate on that. And that is why – Sure, but they're allowed to do that. But to Thomas' point, this is why Biden felt the need to get involved. So the problem is, if you read the fine print on this story of Biden announcing that the ports of LA and Long Beach will open 24 hours, which they clearly need to to get the goods to market. If you read the bottom part of the story, everyone's announcing their intention to go 24-7, but there is no date certain for when that's going to be. It's a negotiation with the unions. So, Chamath, to your point, they are going to have to negotiate with the unions.
um you know initially it looked like the story was that biden was going to use his sway his his clout with the unions to basically push them to take a deal but i don't think he's really done that everyone's just announcing their intentions to negotiate well you know if the ports are holding the whole country hostage like this that could cause a recession i think that's gonna rebound very badly on biden i think they're running 24 7 now aren't they sex long beach and la are both running 24 7 well i just posted this article that came out um i mean like yesterday and it says it was published uh two days ago and it said there was not a date certain for when oh it's updated october 14th which is yesterday and if you read the bottom of the article it says they have not determined a date for when 24-7 operations will start they've just merely announced their intention oh yeah i'm just going to go 24-7 the biden administration says it's not really they announced it as if it was a done done look unless biden is willing to listen i mean chamath you're right that they're entitled to negotiate but here's the thing i mean they're holding the whole country hostage now they're holding the economy hostage so at a certain point if their demands are unreasonable it's it's i think proper for the president united states to step in and say guys this is ridiculous you have to go back to work we're going to make you know we're going to help negotiate a deal here that's what reagan did with the air traffic controllers the air traffic controllers union shut down the whole commercial aviation system.
Reagan got involved, said you cannot shut down the economy this way. You must go back to work. Yes, exactly. So I think Biden is probably going to have to get up for a year. Not that these longshoremen are, or the ports, I guess they're not striking, they're just not doing an extra shift. But he could do an executive order. If they're doing two shifts, if they're doing two shifts two hours a day, that's like withholding, that's like a partial strike. Wait, they're doing two two-hour shifts or two eight-hour shifts? They can't be doing two-hour shifts. why would anybody go to work for two hours read what zach canner posted he said that they're working just two shifts with a two-hour break in between okay but those might be two eight-hour shifts with a two-hour break in between is how i read that no no he says but read the the tweet here he says before any changes uh this coming week the long-shore routine at the ports involve two shifts 8 a.
m to 4 p.m and 6 p.m to 3 a.m um an overnight shift to five hours is available but is up to 50% more expensive and rarely used. So basically, you're talking about, yeah, it's an 8 to 4 p.m. shift with a two-hour break or 6 p.m. to 3 p.m. So basically, yes, so it is for that six-hour, that's two six-hour shifts. They should be running it like, you know, Elon runs the Tesla factories when they're building, which is 24 hours a day, overlapping shifts. Just get it done. Yeah, they're going to have to pay them overtime. There has to be a sense of urgency here. They're going to have to pay them some reasonable overtime, but they can't, the unions can't hold the whole country hostage.
And look, if Biden, unless Biden steps in to solve this, we will have a recession. So it will rebound very much. Oh, so we do think that this could be a recession. I think it's bigger than just the ports. I don't think reopening the ports is the entirety of it. I think there's a lot of other things going on. I mean, Jake, out to a point you've made, we had 4 million people drop out of the labor force last month. I mean, that was unbelievable. So yeah, the unemployment rate looks great, but the number of people actually going to work is significantly lower. I mean, that was a huge shock to all the economists seeing that many people drop out.
There's still too many people who essentially are being paid not to work in one form or another, and that is hurting the economy. You also have this issue in China, which is very interesting. This was, I think, covered in the New York Times about how dependent Chinese factories are on coal, which is a bad thing. Obviously, that's not a clean energy source. But because of restrictions on coal, it's actually started to impact manufacturing over there. We can debate whether that's a good thing or a bad thing, but it's contributing to the effect. I suspect that China has woken up to this and they're not going to shut down their economy because of concerns about clean energy.
So I assume this is a very temporary decision. And then, of course, you have the whole issue of COVID restrictions. I mean, there were a lot of international COVID restrictions. It wasn't just in the U.S. where they were shutting down factories or creating a lot of rules that got in the way of keeping factories open. they were doing this internationally and there's a lot of regulations around seafaring as well because of covid restrictions so you have this pile up i would say of of regulations ultimately i'd say with covid as the origin that have now caused this supply chain crisis and unless it gets fixed it could absolutely cause a 1970s style stagflation type recession next year So you buy that?
Do you think we could have this combination of people refusing to go to work or just opting out and saying like, yeah, even if you pay me 35 or 40, I'm just not interested. I have enough NFTs and I don't want to go back to work. I actually think that's exactly what it is. There was this really interesting tweet that I saw on Twitter, hopefully, Nick, you can find it, but it was some kid that basically said, you know, I'm growing up in Atlanta, and there's a bunch of kids that I used to run with, you know, who would otherwise be in the streets, right, causing all kinds of trouble. And these kids are now at home, like speccing NFTs and like, you know, posting on TikTok or whatever.
It's just a completely different reimagination of like labor and time spent. And, and that's just a very small example. And so that maybe touches retail or maybe touches, you know, quick service restaurants. But there's all these different things where now that at the end of this pandemic, people are making very different decisions about their time and how to spend their money. And again, I'll tell you again, there is a lot of people. You got to remember how many people in the United States have died or are dealing now with some reasonably important health issues at the back end of coronavirus.
Half a million people, a million people. I want you to keep in mind what I told you guys before. There is $70 trillion that has to get transferred down from all these baby boomers down to these people in their 20s, 30s, and 40s. And don't think for a second that they're not making different optimization decisions around perceived wealth. So I just think inflation is here. I think the labor shortage is going to get worse, not better. I think we're going to have to pay people more to get out of it. I think prices are going up. Input costs are going up. Energy costs are going up. so this is it I think that probably the Fed and the ECB are really raising this time next year they're probably in a really really tighter posture what do you think Freeberg we should also remember that there are going to be some responses sorry Freeberg, last thing tech stocks in the fucking toilet why?
because of the multiples no bueno for no cash flow growth stocks Yeah. In rising rain. Everyone's going to start buying yield when... Yucky poops. Nobody wants it. Yucky poops. Wait, let's explain this to the audience. Why, Freeberg? Why are you agreeing with your mouth? I mean, once interest rates go up, you'll see that dividend yields will go up, which means stock prices go down because people will expect a higher return. Because if I can buy treasury bonds and make a few points of return on my money, and I'm going to have to buy a stock, I'm going to want to... I'm going to demand a few more points of dividend yield on that stock.
and so so so the price technique you know the the price for stocks will typically go down to match the yield that you're going to get from these more risk-free investments to be more precise a stock is either uh mature note about cash today or effectively a promissory note about cash in the future thing with tech stocks is we tell everybody the same thing your money is going to come 30 years from now because we're going to be a monopoly by then. And every dollar that I have today, I'm going to reinvest into R&D and engineering. And in an environment where interest rates are zero, you're happy to do it because you're like, well, great.
These guys are investing at way better rates than zero, which is what I get from my bank. And so I want Facebook and Google and Amazon and all these startups to be putting all this money in the ground on my behalf. But when interest rates start going up, they say, no, hold on a second. I need more money upfront less money in the future because the future becomes more uncertain and that's the big trade-off for tech companies where they get really pummeled okay well is there a number in terms of interest rate there's a class of tech companies right like amazon sorry like microsoft oracle google where you are actually seeing an apple you're getting dividends and you're getting share buybacks where the cash is coming out of the business and those are the mature businesses that also still happen to have growth attached to them.
And I don't see how portfolios are going to shed those assets. You're going to shed the more speculative, hey, you know, we're not yet at a point of maturity. We're still 2030 or whatever. Yeah, the guys that are investing and there's no kind of line of sight to true cash flow coming back to the shareholders. But look, at the end of the day, the point I was trying to make earlier was that there is going to be a response, right? So we've seen, remember when the pandemic kind of set in and everyone started ordering from home, Amazon rushed out and hired 100,000 local delivery drivers. They bought all these trucks and they built their own supply chain infrastructure for last mile delivery to get products to people's homes.
And we're now seeing on the other side, Walmart, Home Depot, Target and other big retailers integrating their supply chain to get product into stores. And so they're starting to buy trucks, hire people, pay them significant wages to be drivers on staff for them, rather than contracting to these third parties that are saying, oh, we don't have any inventory. we don't have any trucks we don't have any drivers we can't do anything for you now and so the response is think about it your product company your tesla tesla just went out and did this massive deal um in caledonia to source you know some mineral that they need to make batteries or to make their uh their cars i can't remember exactly what it was but you're you're increasingly going to see the businesses that have a balance sheet step up and actually start to integrate their supply chains rather than have this more more resilient kind of this disparate set of service providers, each of which is only kind of is all typically operating at max capacity.
And then they can't kind of respond to these sorts of jolts to the system. And so we're going to see a lot of investment, I think, by businesses that make product or deliver product to the consumer, as they try and integrate the supply chain problem themselves. And that may take some of the strain off the system and some of this inflationary risk out of the equation. We'll see over the next couple of quarters. But certainly in this last earnings report, I saw some statistic, a very large percentage of earnings reports spoke directly about supply chain disruption, affecting the forecast for the business and the ability for the for the business to meet their forecast goals.
And that's just hurting everyone. Okay, so throwing to have to do something about it if they're resource to do it, right? All right. So sacks, though, there are some silver linings here, companies become more resilient, they become more automated, they build a full stack, they build their own factories, we're seeing, you know, the Taiwanese semiconductor company is doing a $7 billion project to build a new factory in Japan, funded by the Japanese government. So we're seeing a lot of redundancy, redundancy. And we're also seeing the middle class grow. If people are making 35 bucks an hour, 40 bucks an hour, and they're getting healthcare, and they're starting to have overtime and other concessions being made, that builds the middle class.
It sounds like we're solving some problems, as well as you know, dealing with this, I guess what you call it. Absolutely. Inflation looks at inflation is a good thing. I know people think it's a it's a like a really bad, terrible thing. There are certain kinds of inflation that are really productive. We, we have had to find a way to fight the bad parts of technology. Technology is great. Nine, you know, nine out of 10 things. It's amazing efficiency, you know, all these great characteristics that it gives you. But one crappy externality of technology is that it's deflationary. You can do more with less.
And that's fundamentally not great for earnings. It's not great for labor participation it's not great for all these things that people you know are really upset about today so it's great for the individual company getting those games i actually think it's kind of like it actually balances out the natural pace of of technology which is like you have the natural ability to just actually have cheaper faster better this inherent efficiency that's building up on one side of the ledger but then what's great is on the other side of the ledger you actually have you know labor being able to balance it out and i think that that's a really good thing because they can demand more to do the rest of the work that's not covered by tech what are your thoughts about this expanding middle class isn't it a great thing that you know people are saying i'll stay home instead of making 12 bucks an hour it's an unfair wage it's not a livable wage and then all these companies are saying you know what okay well they folded so quick the big companies they went to 18 to 35 an hour instantly they always had the money to pay more they just didn't need to increasing wages in real terms is a good thing i think you have to ask why the wages are going up is it going up because of increased productivity which is a good thing or is it going up because of inflation if it's going up in um if it's going up because of inflation then the wage gains are somewhat illusory because all the products that consumers want to buy are also going up in price all we've done is sort of is devalue the dollar so we have to we don't know yet whether these um But we do know that inflation is actually very high.
We don't know exactly if these wage gains are permanent or just a function of that. But let's go back to this inflation point for a second. I think this is actually really important. We're at something like a 5.1% inflation rate. It's just about the highest since the late 70s, early 80s. Now we have this threat of a supply chain crisis. This is, you know, this is potentially- No, we have a supply chain crisis. It's not a threat. I mean, if people can't sell cars- Right. This is a recipe for stagflation 2.0. Now, I think there's an assumption that if inflation persists, the Fed will simply just fight it.
They'll increase interest rates somewhat and they'll control it. But I actually think that the degrees of action that the Fed can take here might be more constrained than people think. I just want to flag. So one of the primary sources I use for the national debt is this website, fred.stlouisfed.org. It's a good website that has a lot of charts by a branch of the Fed. So they have this chart. We've seen that federal debt as a percentage of GDP is at sort of all-time peacetime highs. We were at 100% for a few years, and now because of COVID, we just rocketed up over 120%. We're close to 140%. Now, the argument by mostly liberal economists that the debt didn't matter was because the debt service remained very low on this debt.
So we had a huge increase in debt, but because interest rates were so low, the debt service was still very, very small. They have a good piece on this website about this as well that I'll just post here in the notes. But I think, I don't know if you guys remember back to a pod we did in May where we talked about Stanley Druckenmiller came out swinging against the Fed, and he warned about this very situation. I just want to like, I want to just read this article that we covered back, I think, in May. It feels like an eternity ago. But remember when we just talked about this, what Druckenmiller warned is that if yields on the 10-year treasury rise to the projected level of 4.
9%, which is simply the historical average, the government spending would be close to 30% of GDP each year simply paying back interest expense compared to 2% last year, unless it monetizes the debt, which experts think is unlikely and Druckenmiller believes would have horrible implications for US dollar. So in other words, we now have this enormous debt. The only reason why debt service payments aren't crowding out the entire federal budget is because we've had interest rates at historically abnormal lows, zeros, basically. So how exactly is the Fed going to fight inflation? If they jack up interest rates to where they should be, say 4.
9%, then the entire federal budget will be going to debt service. They're working against themselves, right? It's like you're the bank and taking the loan at the same time. This is like somebody who gets a variable interest mortgage, and they get five, 10 years into their mortgage, and then all of a sudden, they go from interest only and some low interest rate, and then they have to pay market rate, and they realize they can't afford the home. We might not be able to afford the budget we're putting out there is what you're saying, Sachs. Well, I'm saying the Fed may not have the tools, all the tools they want to fight inflation if it comes back.
Or, I mean, it's going to be politically very unpopular. I mean, can you imagine the pressure the Fed will be under not to raise rates if it means that all of these discretionary programs basically have to be cut, that we have an austerity mode in the federal budget? How are we going to pay for all this debt service? yeah and then the first thing to think about is hey maybe we should cut military spending since it's the largest at the time when china is doing sorties in and around taiwan and the south china sea and we've got you know six you know navies doing coordinated uh sailing there which i think is a adjacent issue here historically historically great powers that want to remain great don't owe over 100% of their economy, especially, you know, when a lot of it's held by foreign powers.
I mean, that is a situation that makes us fragile, not anti-fragile, right? Because if we hit a crisis, if there is, you know, some unforeseen military conflict, what glass do we break now in case of emergency? We've already spent, we're already at, we're in peacetime and we have wartime levels of debt. And now inflation is making a return and the Fed is going to have to make some really tough choices about whether to control inflation and essentially impose austerity on government spending or whether they monetize the debt, which will lead to a runaway depreciation of the dollar. Neither one of those things is a good situation.
How would the Fed impose austerity? Well, they can't. But again, if debt service rises to 30% of the federal budget, where's that money going to come from? You have to raise taxes and cut spending. You have to do that. Which is why, and I think this is Joe Manchin's point. If you've been listening to Joe Manchin talk about the current reconciliation bill. And he says, look, $3.5 trillion doesn't make sense. We don't know what situation we're going to confront in the future. We don't know what crises are coming. We're going to reduce our ability to tackle all those future problems by overspending right now.
That's been Joe Manchin's argument. And looking at this risk of stagflation in the forms of the supply chain shortage and this 5.1% interest rate number, you'd have to say that if we want to preserve any flexibility next year to raise interest rates, you better be really careful about how much debt you incur now. Jamal? Agree? Yeah, look, when Druk said that, the 10-year break even was sort of, you know, at a five-year high at the time. We're back there now. Look, I'm just going to, I said this on CNBC, I'll just say it again. I think it's coming. I don't think it's a short-term blip. And I think that we are in a period that will resemble the late 70s.
And I think that, you know, you kind of want to be risk off and not own risk assets. And by the way, it is hard, okay, because like, we are all, all of us, all four of us, both risk all we're both risk on. And all we own are risk assets that are, you know, it's one thing to say, let's take risk, but you could take risk in like lower of all things. this is this is like taking risk in the most risky thing that's what we all do and at a time when people have run up the valuations of private market companies to a level that just nobody can understand i mean look i think you got a year to 18 months to kind of clean this stuff up meaning like as market participants we can you know we can shuck and jive and get everything into a decent place but it's coming um and i hope i'm wrong but i think we'll look back on this and we'll say we said it probably eight to 12 months before it really reared its ugly head but it's coming uh freeberg any thoughts on what's happening in taiwan and what uh you know even a modest conflict there would do to markets given how to sax's point this is the opposite of anti-fragile we are in like full fragility here i mean this is like you know a tray full of champagne glasses on a boat in rough seas at any point we could trip and everything comes crashing down does it feel like that to you, Freberg?
Or do you feel like we're going to be able to navigate this? I mean, I don't know about Taiwan, but I think we're just going to keep inflating our way out of this mess. Remember, that's what we did last year. And it's what we'll do again this year. The biggest losers in that equation are the middle class. Because the middle class actually owns assets that are now going to be worth less. folks who are not in the middle class that are below the middle class don't own assets so it doesn't really affect them they just make higher wages but stuff costs more so they'll be fine and then you know wealthy individuals will end up getting taxed away to fund some of this and i think that's the inevitable kind of way that the equation balances right but i mean think about how much tax rates are about to go up right now in this reconciliation bill we haven't even gotten to like any of these crises by the way we don't know for sure if they're going to happen i think We could describe these things as storm clouds right now that are very much on the horizon.
Multiple storm clouds, right? It's sort of like they're converging. Right. And if they do materialize in the way that we're talking about, what weapons do we have left in order to fight them? What weapons of fiscal policy? What weapons of monetary policy? We're already going to have taxes at an all-time high. Yeah. We're going to have taxes. We're going to print money. No, we're going to print money and we're going to pay ourselves. We're going to go to the central bank. It's what you said. We're going to monetize our debt. And taxes will go up. That is a disaster. Remember, the top marginal tax rate was what, 70, 80% in the 60s and 70s?
I mean, you know, that's likely where we're going to go back to. Well, I think we're already going to be back there as a result of the reconciliation. The spending we've already done, yeah. Right, so we've already broken the glass in case of emergency. We've already done... You're going to see some of these wealth taxes get chased down. You're going to see the top marginal tax rate go up 70, 80%. You know, I mean, I think that's the way the equation balances. It's not like the world's going to end. we're going to solve it by taking assets away from some and we're going to inflate all assets like that sounds pretty bad yeah yeah i mean 78 if you by the way it's not going to affect who's going to most solution freeberg it will affect most people it will affect most people even though they don't think it will because it's going to affect the quality of our economy i'm just trying to predict what's going to happen sax i'm not saying this is the solution to our problem i mean i think the solution to our problem is technology but you know the question is does that come to market fast enough say say more about that i feel like we need a deflationary set of technologies that can like mitigate all of these effects right so software automation self-driving trucks things that take the labor force because people don't want to work low-income jobs factually and you know now that there's a world now that there's in america now that there's a world where people don't have where people have other options because other jobs have been created because we pump so much money into these other industries, we're seeing people migrate away from low income jobs, like driving a truck for $10 an hour, or working at McDonald's for $8 an hour.
And so to fill that gap and avoid the economic collapse that will occur in those sectors of the economy, you need to automate and you need to find solutions that can replace the labor with some alternative technology solution that actually allows the product to be fulfilled to the consumers that demand it. Or you're going to see rates go up, like you're going to be paying $12 for a hamburger because you're gonna have to pay everyone $25 for working with would an easy or tomorrow or actually you can take it. I'm sure you're both gonna have opinions here. But we've been battling over immigration, and nobody's even seems to understand how many people are coming into the country or under what system.
Should we not tie the number of jobs available, you know, over the trailing x number of months, years, quarters, to how many people are bringing to the country? And couldn't we solve this by allowing 5 million people, a million people, whatever it is per year, a half million people in to take those low income jobs, and utilize that group of people to, you know, get businesses back on track? I think it's too convenient to say that these are all low income jobs. I don't think that's necessarily true. And I think that it then starts to introduce a whole bunch of other constraints to the system. These are folks that then need healthcare.
These are folks that need childcare. These are folks that need, you know, that they are also a tax on resources as well, right? We are all taxed on the natural resources and the infrastructure of our country. And so, you know, I don't think that that's the solution necessarily to that specific problem. But what if the jobs that were coming in, we have enough people here to do the work, but then we don't, what we don't have is the market clearing price for that work to get done. And so what I'm just trying to say is, I think that the simpler and more obvious solution is to raise salaries until you get people to fill these jobs.
And I think that it's happening. And so I do think that over the next year or two or three, you're going to see, you know, labor rates basically go back up and employment rates go back down and salaries go back up and inflation go back up. All of these things are going to happen together. That's the solution. I think immigration is a solution to a completely different problem. Which is? Which is that we're not competitive. Like, I really think- Oh, so you're talking about bringing an elite, highly educated technical people. I really think that running a country should really be like running a sports team, you know, and recruit the best talent.
And you should really be recruiting the best talent, you should be looking at game film, you should be coming up with plays, you should be running and testing those plays, you know, you should have different plays that you run in the first quarter versus the fourth quarter different plays when you're on the goal line, you know, and, and I think that like, when you look at professional sports, one thing is that they don't see color, gender, sexual orientation, they see ability to be performant statistics at a task and statistical excellence yeah and then they go seek statistical excellence and and and if you translate that to a country my simple rubric on immigration is every year there's a draft and america is the free place every free agent we're the yankees yeah we're the warriors yeah i fuck the yankees we're like the warriors yankees are trash jesus christ i'm just going with who historically has won the most we're the new england patriots okay cheater we're the chicago bulls we're the you know we we are the team that everybody would want to play for it's up to us to have a good gm and a good president of the team and a good front office that just picks off all these smart geniuses this should be i think your great point here chamath is you're saying let's take the emotion out of this immigration and let's make it a point-based system which by the way the point-based system is what australia new zealand in the UK, Canada, all do.
And Americans don't even know what the point-based system is. Sax, what are your views as somebody who, I've heard, leans a little bit to the right on opening up immigration or maybe sweeping all this amazing talent globally who have the highest statistics? Go. I like Chama's sports team analogy. We want to get the biggest stars from all over the world to come to the US. I mean, I think that makes sense. I think, you know, this so-called immigration issue get so confused with so many different things. I mean, first of all, there's immigration, and then there's border security, right? And immigration or just having a border period.
And so many people think that if you're pro-immigration, you basically can't have a border. I mean, that makes no sense. You know, we need to have a border, and we need to have actual, like, have an actual immigration policy. It shouldn't just be like, okay, you make it across. I like what you're saying. Or if your guy, Ron DeSantis becomes president, what should his, what will you tell Ron? I like what you're saying. I like what you're saying with the point system, having it be skills based. I mean, that makes sense, right? Would the Republicans do that? They've been so emotionally tied to this issue because of Trump.
Can they actually, you know, tie themselves to something performance based and be not emotional about it? Can they change their position? I think Trump actually did endorse like a more skills based immigration system. I think that, and I don't know that Republicans are the ones being emotional about it. I mean, the people who I hear- Well, no, both sides are clearly super emotional about it. The side that I think is insane are the people who don't think we need a border. I mean, you clearly have to have a border. Yes. And even Obama came out recently and made a statement that you have to have a border because the progressive left had gone so far.
It's almost like they wanted to be, whatever Trump was doing, they wanted to do the opposite of. You know, it's like pull the 180. And so it's almost like the Biden administration policy became to stop doing whatever it was that Trump was doing, including finishing the wall. I don't really understand why that was like such a problem. Yeah, building a wall also seemed like ridiculous. We could just put up censors. It's just one piece of the solution, but to stop it in mid-construction. Let me ask you a question. It broke this week that you're hosting a fundraiser for Ron DeSantis. You got a little bit of blowback from that, from the woke, you know, in the San Francisco crowd.
But in terms of your influence with somebody like that, do you think you can actually influence them to get Ron DeSantis to listen to this episode and maybe talk about the point based system and change the framing of that? Do you think you have enough influence to do that? I don't know. I mean, I don't know exactly what his position on immigration is. That's not that that's not like the set of issues that's that I respect him for. I mean, the reason why I wanted to support DeSantis is that he was the first governor to end these insane lockdowns. And I mean, this is back in it should have been obvious to everybody by May of 2020 that the lockdowns didn't work.
And he was the first one to roll them back. And in Florida, did very well, especially considering that they have so many old people in Florida. So, you know, on the whole, not what I have done, everything exactly the way he did it. No, you know, but nobody did it perfect. But is he a Trump supporter and a Trump acolyte, or is he distancing himself from Trump? I think, honestly, I think that point of view is coming from the point of view of somebody who's not in the Republican Party. It doesn't have to deal with the dynamics of winning support in the Republican Party. No, no, no, that's what I'm saying.
Yeah, so you have to basically toe the line with Trump to get the nomination. I don't see it as toeing the line. I just think, look, I think he's his own person. He's the governor of Florida. He's setting policy over there. he can be supported or not based on what he's doing in florida i think like trump is the issue that everybody on the other side will want to talk about but i don't think it's relevant to what he's doing isn't there a civil war inside of the republican party over this and should we support trump i wouldn't say i wouldn't say it's a civil war but there definitely is some some conflict and yeah i mean how does it resolve i hope it resolves and look i think elections are always about the future.
I don't think people want to relitigate the past. And I think that the Republican Party would be wise, I think, to find a candidate of the future and not try to rehash or relitigate the past. Another good reason for me to support DeSantis, I think he is a future-looking, future-oriented candidate. I do think that, look, I'll say it, the stuff I hear trump doing now in these speeches where he's re-litigating what happened last year um and and attacking other republicans like mcconnell because he doesn't because they failed his personal loyalty test um it's a little bit like what he did frankly in georgia with the runoffs where yeah he showed so much chaos that the republicans lost a seat the produce seat that they had won on election night And then they had that runoff.
And you have to say that a huge part of the reason for that was Trump attacking Rafflesberger and all the Georgia GOP because he thought they were insufficiently loyal to him. And then you had the whole tape come out of can you just find 11,000 votes? I mean, I think voters in Georgia punished the Republican Party for that by giving that seat to the Democrats. That margin created the Democratic majority, which will now give us probably an incremental $4 to $6 trillion of spending and tax increases that we wouldn't otherwise have had. So I do think these elections are very important, and it would behoove the Republicans.
Look, I'm not like one of these never-Trumper people who – I'm just not obsessed with Trump, period. I just think the Republicans need to run a future-looking candidate, not a backwards-looking candidate in 2024. And I think DeSantis could be that guy. it's very very early to say i mean the first thing he has to do is run for governor uh for re-election in uh which i think is next year is 2022 so i will support him for that all right you guys anybody read the the ted sarandes memo yeah this is great we should definitely jump into this we talked about uh the chapelle performance uh sax and uh freeberg you haven't seen it did you watch it did you watch it oh god what nerd you haven't watched it oh my god you guys are culturally bankrupt.
What were you guys doing this week? Like fucking beakers and like, you know, sacks, you were just like... Were you like in like some laboratory doing like sacks? Yeah, they were doing their beakers. I haven't watched it yet, but I don't need to watch it to know I support it. Freedom. He's just... He doesn't have to click on the link. There's almost nothing Chappelle could say to make me want to cancel him. I mean, and by the way, I've seen a lot of Chappelle, and I love Chappelle, so I think I understand the gist of what he was doing but i i do need to see it still but look he should not be canceled it's ridiculous i don't think he is he's gonna survive of course here's beyond this um let me uh read you from it so everybody knows that the name of the uh special he did was the closer it was released on october 5th a lot of outcry from glad and uh advocacy groups and actually people inside of uh netflix there's been some resignations there have been some people who contribute content to netflix who are now saying they'll not work with the company and um it's really interesting ted sorrento sent a memo to the entire company on monday and he's this is the second one he sent and he says we know that a number of you have been left angry disappointed and hurt by our decision to put dave chappelle's latest special on netflix very interesting opening uh he's he's addressing their feelings just this is a masterclass in a memo because in that first part he just addresses i understand you feel that way with the closer we understand that the concern is not about offensive to some content but titles which could increase real world harm so now he's framing their argument as it's not because it's offensive it's because of real world harm you brought this up before sax the real world harm concept with um apple and uh antonio while some employees disagree we have a strong belief that content on screen does not directly translate into where we're all harmed it's not exactly true uh we'll get into that the strongest evidence to support this is that violence on screens has grown hugely over the last 30 years especially with first-party shooter games and yet violent crime has fallen significantly in many countries uh and so he goes above and beyond just talking about offensive material adults can watch violence assault and abuse or enjoy shocking stand-up comedy without it causing them to harm other stand-up comedians often expose issues that are uncomfortable because the art by nature is highly provocative as a leadership team we do not believe that the closer is intended to incite hatred or violence against anyone per sensitive content guidelines so basically he says you know if you don't like it change the channel if you're a customer you can cancel your subscription or if you work here and you don't like it you don't need to work here but is this the end of cancel culture this combined with brian armstrong's positioning sax this is your i don't i don't think it's the end of it uh for the simple reason um let's assume that this comic had not signed 60 million dollar deal with with netflix let's say he had signed a 60 000 deal okay or six million or six million or whatever and uh and and he didn't have the legions of fans that that dave Chappelle had.
Do you think that Sarandos was making the same decision? I mean, I think that special by, you know, by a Netflix comedy by Dave Smith would be swept under the rug right now. That would never see the light of day. I think the same thing was true with Joe Rogan and Spotify, right? I mean, Spotify made a $60 million deal with Rogan. Oh, $100 million. The employees all protested and Spotify stood tall for Rogan, but they had every economic incentive to do so. I don't completely trust these companies that if it wasn't massively in their bottom line interest, that they would have stood up for free speech.
I suspect that if it was, you know. They would not have. They would not have. I think we all kind of know that. He said in the email, Sticks and Stones is one of the most watched, you know, pieces of content we have. And this, the closer, was like top four or five in America over like the last few weeks. So there's a huge economic incentive. And Reed Hastings said the same thing when he posted the other co-CEO into a group forum, which said, listen, our job is to please our customers. And all this data says is that we've pleased our customers. Right. And I think in the case of... That is pretty...
Right. That's what they said. To me, that's him putting his foot down and saying we're going to make the content we want to make. I don't think it's a principle. I don't think it's a super... Look, I don't want to look past it because I think that it's so rare to get a memo like Sarandos wrote where he's defending artistic freedom or freedom of speech or what have you. I mean, it's so rare to ever see that, that I don't want to gainsay it too much. But I also do believe that this sort of special treatment is really reserved for the artists, the creators, like a Chappelle, like a Rogan. They're basically too big to cancel.
I mean, these companies have spent too much money on their programs to just summarily cancel them. They also, again, like I said, have legions of fans who would rise up and protest if they were canceled. But I don't think these companies would make the same decision for the mid-level creator. And in a sense, Rogan and Chappelle, they're post-economic, right? I mean, they've made so much money that they're free to do what they want, and they've got a big enough audience to protect themselves from these companies. But it's the little creator who's still on their way up who can never take the kinds of creative risks that Chappelle is taking or that Rogue.
Well, they can take it. They just can't do it on Netflix. But the tone of this to me sounded like a manifesto and the end of the discussion from dad. Like, we're doing this. If you don't like it, get off the ship. But this is the way the ship is going. That's the way I read it. And I think Spotify did a similar thing with Joe Rogan, to your point, which was, hey, listen, there are some content out there from like Alex Jones or some people who are just conspiracy theorists. They took down those episodes and Joe Rogan was like, I don't care. I got paid. But yeah, it does feel to me like this is a tipping point when you put Brian Armstrong, Joe Rogan and Chappelle together that corporations are going to say, you know what?
The mob is fine. You can have your opinion, but your opinion stops where we have to run a business. Freeberg, what are your thoughts? I think Netflix has an appreciation for artistry, certainly evident by the money they've spent and the product they've put out. And I think good artists and good artistry can be provocative. It's designed to make you change your opinion, look at things differently, think about things differently, and be challenged in the norms of your everyday life. And I think that's important in art in all forms. And that means seeing and being exposed to and being engaged by things that you don't normally get exposed to and engaged by.
And I think that's what Chappelle is fantastic at. And I think that's what other great art is great at. And I think that as long as Netflix maintains that ethos, that artistry does that. And the good thing is people appreciate it. And they appreciate that form. And they appreciate being challenged in that way. And I think that as a result, the market will, as Reed Hastings identified, continue to demand it. And as much as some people might be offended, it's the fact that it is offensive that I think makes it good. So let me ask you. And I think that they appreciate that. Let me frame it. Jake, I hope you're right about what this means.
I mean, let me be really clear. I mean, I hope it goes down exactly the way that you're saying, because that is what I want to believe is happening. I'm a little bit skeptical that this is a little bit more of a bottom line motive because they got so much money at stake that they can't afford to cancel Chappelle. But I hope you're right that it's a statement of principle, and they will apply that principle to lesser known artists who can't protect themselves as much. And, you know, hopefully this is kind of like, you know, what it reminds me of is the Jon Stewart, the Wuhan lab leak moment where you had Jon Stewart go on Colbert's show.
And he all of a sudden, he made it okay to talk about the lab leak theory. It was like, you couldn't talk about it before. He cracked the Overton window open. Yes, exactly. And so hopefully Chappelle will do that for this like woke cancellation mob is to finally get everybody to realize, oh, like we can stand up to this. Chamath, is the Overton window on a go forward basis, do you see it closing more, staying where it is, or perhaps even opening? There's a really great philosopher. this is uh this is my maybe my one and only grand tribute to peter thiel but he he is um he's a huge supporter of a philosopher named renee girard and uh i agree with a lot of uh a lot of that uh a lot of renee girard's philosophies and basically it's called mimetic theory and the idea is you're born without preferences and then you kind of just copy what's around you and so what the other person wants is what you want and that's what ultimately leads to a lot of conflict and the only way to resolve conflict is with a huge grand sacrifice of some kind okay um and if you think about it here if you're going to really put you know cancel culture if you're going to kill it there needs to be some just massive escalation and conflict around this idea that allows us to resolve it in one way or the other in one direction or the other and i don't think this is it i think it's not big enough quite honestly i think it's a little bit sort of like you know there's folks like us that love comedy and we're willing to keep it in a very strict box which is let people say what they're going to say be shocked with it and don't take it onto yourself and don't you know and go and reflect it into the world, it's entertainment.
And you can, you know, it's like, I choose not to watch violent stuff, because I don't like it. I find it, I find it very offensive. Or, you know, I don't play first person shooters, I find it really unsettling. You know, Grand Theft Auto, I found it really outrageous. And other people will feel like that about Chappelle. My whole thing is, we should all be allowed to make those judgments, because I think we're all still pretty rational people at the end of the day and do the right thing in the normal world. But this isn't the thing that's going to get this issue to be resolved. So I don't know how it comes.
There needs to be some huge escalation around this thing. I suspect what happens is it actually just dissipates and goes away. And the reason is because everybody who's much younger than us has such a huge digital footprint that they've created through their whole lives. There is so much shit that's out there. God, yes, that they just have no choice but to let everybody else off the hook. we we are in a very different situation because we were doing some fucking shady stuff always on the down low always hidden whoa easy there but that that's how it was if you were not our childhood you were largely anonymous you would you would roll deep and you would just you would pretend you would not you know and now the culture is very different and i think with that comes a lot of acceptance every you know every kid at some point may or may not be on tinder bumble ria you know grinder whatever so there's going to be a body of that content that's up every kid will have said something crazy you know on tiktok and all of this stuff will be there and so you'll have a choice which is if you're going to hold me accountable i'm going to hold you accountable and so it's mutually assured destruction and i think that's what causes cancel culture to go away in time it's the last vestige of very guilty people of our generation fascinating what do you think freeberg is the overton window opening closing or about the next year what samad is saying is right i um i think i've referred to this book called the light of other days before when we talked i think so right yeah um the book is like all about this notion of all information is available to everyone everywhere and societal norms completely change people no longer find things offensive and they no longer and everyone basically shifts to a mode of much more kind of open dialogue because you know keeping things behind closed doors and then positioning one person against the other completely changes when you can see everyone's cards all the time um and so i think yeah generally we're headed that way i don't think we're gonna information wants to be free more information is being generated about each of us all the time i don't think that we're headed in the opposite direction kind of back to a victorian era i think we're going in the other way so there's going to be blips and starts um uh that'll kind of you know, be setbacks on that general trajectory.
So yeah, I do think it's a moment, you know, it's a moment in time right now, where this is happening. I mean, look at the two examples we've discussed, Brian Armstrong and Coinbase, that was about, essentially, Black Lives Matters and talking about social justice at work. And this one is about trans and trans rights. And essentially, I don't want to say poking fun at or, you know uh discussing uh i mean he basically says in it that he's team turf if you were to take two organizations that standing up against would be the most challenging and difficult i think those are the top two no i guess so i mean that's why i think this is the this is the most telling is that you have two different organizations saying hey we're going to put our foot down just for background netflix had a very strange um i didn't see the actual film so i won't make judgment on it uh but it was a very strange uh trailer for a film called cuties which was really over sexualizing young girls like eight nine ten year old girls and they didn't take it down um in the united states uh netflix but uh they did it was in france it was in france it was a french movie yeah and they have a different view of kids and sexuality and yeah i think people found it a little dark uh here in the united states but they survived that one as well uh or they weathered that one as well so i think what people are finding is if you put your foot down at a certain point i think what sax says is right then they've these guys have realized that if we have this very specific message around artistic freedom and we never violate it because that's one of those things where if you take that hill you have to be there forever right you can't have asterisks around that idea but by doing that they basically dominate the content production game in hollywood which then allows them to field the most content at the cheapest average price which then makes churn less and customer acquisition higher and they're already the largest media company in the world and they're only going to get bigger you know they're and netflix has what 200 million subscribers they're going to get to a billion subscribers it's just inevitable and so for them i do think it's a very rational business position to take which is that i have to appeal to a billion people over the next you know seven or eight years you don't have to watch everything on netflix you do not have to listen to every album and like it netflix is a fucking mess i mean they should spend 10 minutes and improve the ui so you can actually find something my god it's so bad and you know he he basically sarandos made the point that you know along with chappelle show they're funding a ton of content by people of color probably more than anybody and trans people it's a big focus of what they're doing at netflix and it's you know it's essentially to sax's point more speech is better than less all right do we want to go tether fda chaos why don't you take uh why don't you do your reverse victory lap because after all your victory lap for me but no bro it was the exact it is not a it's a fucking fraud come on you please stop saying that apparently the cftc went in did the work and is actually now refuting what you thought was the case jason okay why don't you just how about i read you the quote from at least june 1st 2016 to february 25th 2019 tether misrepresented to customers and the market that tether maintained sufficient u.
s dollar reserves to back every usdt in circulation with the equivalent equivalent amount of corresponding fiat currency held by tether and safely deposited in tether bank accounts in other words they told everybody they were one for one they were not they lied to the public and that's why they're getting a 41 million dollar five that's why they're banned from new york and that's why they're banned from trading in canada i think and they're supposedly a department of justice um these guys are shady as f af shady do you have a do you have an economic interest in tether no in crypto he does no no i i can anyone have an economic interest in tether all it is a one for one tokenized dollar well no it's not that's what they claim it is no i know you're you're right that it should be and we need an audit to establish that it is and they won't audit they'll do an attestation and when they did their attestation all they have to do is show a document that says there's money in an account they don't have to show how long that's been in the account certainly this certainly feels like a security to me and i would think the sec should get involved in regulating this stable coins are the number one thing on gensler and the sec's mind right yeah i mean they make a claim of a secured interest in something unlike this is like the easiest part of crypto this is the easiest part of why is it why because because look at a bank account you audit it you're done it's it's a tokenized dollar that's it it is not actually i'm not even sure it's a security it basically is a digital representation of a dollar that should be sitting in a bank account somewhere it's a money market yeah it's a money market fund but money markets are securities and they're regulated as security okay fine but my point is you know there are complicated securities and there's securities that aren't complicated this is definitely the least complicated that this company only has to their own attestations like six percent three to six percent in cash in a bank account and the rest is in highly volatile corporate uh paper here's the point that i was trying to make to you in the group chat oh when a company who's got billions and billions and billions of dollars of some stable coin whatever or something that you think is zero okay it's a multi multi-billion dollar market tens of billions oh sorry tens of billions 70 billion in tether out there and and and could you imagine if they like let's just say there were 70 billion of tether and like you know 1 billion of securities that would be a fraud of gargantuan proportions right we would be beyond talking if they siphon the money out for their own use that would be beyond talking about fines but what i found comical jason is your claims make it seem like bernie made off enron level corruption craziness hold on okay and the fine was 42 million which is like who fucking cares 42 million and it was between them and another firm.
So either the CFTC completely got the fine wrong and they missed a zero or two zeros, or this was not nearly as big as you thought it was. I'm shocked that J-Caw got overly excited about some perceived hoax. Here we go, another hoax. You are a conspiracy theorist, J-Caw. I'm not a conspiracy theorist. I was right about Theranos. Yeah, Jason didn't fully understand something and got very emotional about it. That's it. I'm off the... That's it. I got it. Here's the best case scenario for making sense of J. Cal's points, which is it's possible that Tether, the company behind Tether, has all the money.
They've just not chosen to keep it in dollar reserves. And so they put it in corporate bonds and a whole mishmash of different things. To get the float. To get the float, to make more money. Maybe they were long as an engine. They don't turn on it. I don't. My guess is that Tether is solvent. I don't think it lacks solvency, but I personally would feel better about any stable coin if it was 100% dollar backed. I think it should be. Which is what Jeremy Allaire is doing at USDC and Circle. I had him on the pod this week. I hope they bought the GitLab IPO. Well, I mean, the issue here is they also co-mingled funds, which is what got Fultz in trouble.
The users' accounts with their money in it was mixed with the operating capital. So they were using the deposits to operate the business, which is the biggest no-no. They were co-mingling the funds that people thought were backed. And Bitfinex and Tether were the same company. That's why they both got the fines at the same time. They've also been banned from having any customers in New York, and they've been banned in Canada. And there's apparently a DOJ wire for it. So I think this is the beginning of the end, not the end of the beginning. Okay. That's my personal belief. I was just wanting to get your reaction to what seemed like a really pathetic fine for what could be a $70 billion fraud.
I mean, Facebook got a series of speeding tickets, too. I mean, I think that's a big issue for our government is that the scale of these companies... What's that? They paid like $5 billion or something, right? Yeah, and they're a trillion dollar company. I mean, it's nothing. I understand, but $5 billion is a big number. That's a big number. Not in relation to their market cap and how much cash they throw off every year. $42 million? I mean, that's a tax payment. It's a quarterly tax payment. For you, Tremont, not for us. Or maybe for Sachs. He's doing pretty well, too. Yum, yum. All right. We promised we'd do some questions.
Should we do a couple of questions? Sure. I mean, we could also talk about the FDA. Oh, my God, the FDA. My gosh. Freebird, you want to leave this? Freebird, you want to tell us about the chaos at the FDA? Well, I don't think it's chaotic like you guys think it is. I'll make a counter. Why don't you make your chaos point first, and then I'll make a That's not my point. It's just kind of what people... Yeah, people are perceiving this. So, like, you know, there have been a couple of these changes in recommendations. Now, all of these recommendations and, you know, these statements and approvals that have come out of the FDA are predicated on these independent advisory panels that are put together to look at research data, assess the research data, and make a recommendation on what they think is appropriate.
So, we saw this happen with the Pfizer booster shot a few weeks ago, where initially the advisory panel, which again, is made up of independent doctors and scientists who generally don't have any sort of economic interest in the outcome here. They voted 16 to two against everyone getting a booster shot. And then they voted 18 to zero in favor of everyone 65 and over and those at risk of getting a booster shot. And then recently, there was, you know, similar sort of consternation around the Moderna. And they ended up looking at data that indicated that maybe a half dose, which is 50 micrograms instead of 100 micrograms, would have a reasonable amount of efficacy relative to the side effect risk for people over 65.
And therefore, they made a recommendation to approve that as a booster, which the FDA is now approving. And so again, the way this process is run, and I think it's a good process is independent advisors of doctors and scientists come together. And the one that recently came together was around this generalized use of aspirin as a heart attack deterrent, because it thins the blood and limits the risk of people getting heart attacks. But it turns out that such a large percentage of the population or large enough percentage of the population were having bleeding issues where your stomach bleeds.
I don't know if you guys have this, but you know, you take ibuprofen or NSAIDs, your stomach can bleed. That was causing more of a problem for people than they were seeing in the data in terms of a reduction in heart attack effects for people that were not highly at risk. And so they revised the recommendation and said, hey, let's give people that are only at risk and over a certain age aspirin, not just like it, give it to everyone over 40 or 50. And so it took in account new data. And I think this is an important point. Science is messy, right? By definition, science is about gathering data, forming a hypothesis, testing again, iterating, restating your hypothesis.
And it's designed to be circular, it's designed to be a learning system, not designed to be a system that defines absolute truth and absolute fact. And it's good to see the FDA doing this work. And it's good to see scientists reviewing new data and changing their recommendations and you know we've seen this in in health we've seen this in in the food system and the usda changing their diet guidelines and people used to be told don't eat dietary cholesterol it turns out saturated fat is what causes cholesterol in your blood so there were a lot of changes that that kind of emerged as new data was gathered and you know a lot of carbs remember the all carb diets yeah and then they learned and they made a change in those days yeah wait wait can we bring that back i'm starving I used to eat pasta every day.
First, it was rice in my 10s and 20s. Oh, I've seen you eat rice. Oh, the shoveling of rice. My lord. So, Freeberg, I mean, if we're going to be just intellectually- It's like meeting pizza. If we're going to be intellectually honest about this, the fact that health officials can be wrong about positions they've maintained with, I guess, seemingly total certainty for decades, and now they can revise those positions. I mean, doesn't that lend some credence to some of these like anti-vax arguments when they say, well, gee, I'm skeptical about injecting our mRNA into myself. I think it's a totally, you just got the episode banned on YouTube.
We just got a warning. I'm glad I got the vaccine. I got the Pfizer vaccine. And I think, look, it could have saved my life. I mean, I had a very mild case of Delta. Yeah, I had one of the first breakthroughs. But it was very mild. And I think that was because I got Pfizer. I think the risk return was completely worth it. But I can also see why people with five-year-old, kindergarten-age children might not want to get it for their kids when the upside is absolutely tiny given that it doesn't really affect five-year-olds very much. And the downside is not – there's no proven downside. But how is it any different than the aspirin thing?
I don't know that wishes you had gotten really sick with Delta. Yes, you are. No, but there's a bunch of people on the left. I don't disagree with the framing that here's what typically happens. The scientists or the FDA panel will say, based on the data that we have, this is our recommendation on what should happen. And then the framing that people then assume is, oh, this is what they believe to be absolute truth. And with absolute certainty, this is what we have to do. And I think the translation layer to the general population is such that this is the 10 commandments I came down from Mount Sinai.
And this is what I'm saying has to happen. when the reality is it is based on data and that data changes over time. And I think that your point is right. There is no absolute certainty that the Pfizer vaccine is going to be absolutely perfect for everyone and it's going to absolutely reduce the risk more than it increases the risk for people five years old and younger. And it's a very fair point that like, but the problem, as we've seen on all sides, is that the framing is that these things are binary and they're not, right? There is a probability distribution of which is defined as the risk and the things that might go wrong and the probability distribution of the benefits.
And then people assume that it's just binary. I think you're making an excellent point there. I just want to underscore. Let me kind of translate what you're saying is that the people at the FDA are in these positions who actually understand the science make a cost benefit analysis. And what they're saying in approving it is that the costs outweigh the risk. Sorry, the benefits outweigh the risk. To the broad population. To the broad population. Okay. By the way, that's why I got the vaccine. I don't know for sure that there's no downsides in 10 years. All I know is there's an upside immediately, and I benefited from that.
So I was very happy to take it. But in any event, instead of this complicated cost-benefit analysis, the media translates that into good-bad. It's almost like a moral case. And then the politicians translate that into laws and rules. And if you question the rules, you're now a bad person because you've opposed the quote-unquote good side of the argument. I mean, for example, Gavin Newsom just signed a bill in California saying that if you are a public school child, elementary school, kindergarten, you have to get vaccinated in order to go to a public school, even though the vaccine doesn't even exist for them yet.
I mean, you could be pro-vax, which I guess I would consider myself to be clearly pro-vax. I mean, I got it. My 13 year old got it. I support it. I think it's a smart decision to make, but to require a five year old to get it in order to go to public schools in California. He can also wait until we get the FDA data. Here's a question for you, Friedberg. You know, having this, one of the complaints has been the FDA restricts progress. I mean, I think actually Peter Thiel had this position for a while that we should, you know, just get rid of it and disband it. What do we think about having the FDA being framed as these are recommendations, and then each state gets to make a decision with their local FDA.
So then if Colorado or Texas or Florida had a difference of opinion about psychedelics about vaccines, they could run their own studies. It's a really important matter of ethics. What are your ethics that you believe, you know, should be the guiding principles for how the government plays a role in individuals making choice about their health and their body? And so if you believe that the government, and this is there's no right or wrong here, it's simply a framing of what you believe. If you believe that it's appropriate for the government to make the decision about what's safe and not safe for you as an individual to do, then the FDA should stay in place and they should have their criteria of when they're ready to make a recommendation, there's enough data to define the benefit and the cost of a particular thing that you might put in your body and then telling you, yes, you should or shouldn't do this.
if you and if not they're going to take their time and and figure that out now if you don't believe that then yes the fda should be disbanded and drug companies will go around and they will tell people take this drug it will save your life and people will take it and there will be there will be people that will suffer from that there will be people that will have or maybe something in between there will be people that will die from that federal and and remember like the criteria for the fda is do no harm so you know that that is the criteria for a doctor in general it is a very difficult criteria to meet when there are costs to a drug or costs to a therapy or treatment.
When people get chemotherapy for cancer, there are awful deleterious side effects to their body. But the benefit of saving their life and getting rid of the cancer, having at least a shot at doing that is great enough. And the FDA has made a judgment call that that cost and that benefit kind of create an equation that says this is an approved drug now. And that's really their goal. And if they don't have enough data, and they haven't taken enough time to figure that out, they don't feel comfortable approving a drug and making that recommendation. but then if you let them get out of the way and you let individuals make choice you could see this being a disgusting free-for-all where drug companies will hawk snake oil on people and a lot of harm will be caused and that's that's the counter argument and i'm not saying one is right or one is well i was thinking there might be something it really comes down to what is the role that you want i mean it's really that what is the role that you want any government whether it's states or the federal government to play in deciding what you can and can't do with your body and what you can and can't put in your body and ultimately what companies that are making products for you can and can't say to you about the benefit and the cost of that product.
And there's no simple solution, right? I mean, like, look at Kyrie Irving. I mean, he's basically is not a $200 million. Not every individual is equipped to look at the data and make a judgment call on their own. And so the question then is what authority will they look to? And if the alternative authority that they will look to is not as good as a research team of 18 scientists, then they're probably going to end up getting bad advice. What do you think the ultra Kyrie retires? I think it's 60% right now So wait, he's giving up $200 million He has a $200 million extension He gets paid like $30 or $40 million a year He refuses to get the vaccine He said the reason he's not getting the vaccine Is because of all the people Who don't have a choice The pilots who are being forced to get it Or not go to work So he is a privilege, he says And he wants to make this decision for everybody else He also believes that the Earth is flat stop that was a joke he said i don't think it was a joke where are you getting that from jacob uh typing kairi irving flat earth he talked about how do we know the earth is actually around and he basically was that's a media distortion to me two days later he came out and he was like you guys misinterpret anyways that's that's not the humor there he's oh he's what he's unique and wacky he sounds so i would i wouldn't make that decision why are you so pejorative like i know i know Because it's infuriating that he...
Just because someone disagrees with you, you say that they're... No, because KD wanted to come to the Knicks. These are Taylor Lorenz tactics. And Kyrie convinced him to go to Brooklyn. That's the reason. J. Cal, you're still a member of the media. You have like a vestigial tale here. Is that you just bought in to the framework that Freeberg laid out, which is the media takes complicated issues, cost-benefit analyses, and turns them into right or wrong, good or bad. This is personal. He didn't come to the Knicks. He didn't come to the Knicks. So now he's bad. Now he's bad because... He's bad for not coming to the Knicks.
He sounds to me like a man of conscience. No, a man of conscience who's willing to stand up on principle, turn down $200 million. I got the vaccine for free. I sure as hell wouldn't turn away $200 million not to get it. So, I mean, it's not a decision I would make. If they offered you $200 million to not take it, would you have taken it? Would you have not taken it? Maybe. I think so. I think I'm not taking it for $200 million. There was a – I heard a great story yesterday at the poker table. One of the guys was telling me. uh it's his backgammon teacher and he says his backgammon teacher or is an you know good backgammon teacher and a magician blah blah blah 20 years ago he was asked um to get female breast implants for a year for a hundred thousand dollars he did it and he kept them for 20 years um that's quite a free roll so you know the bar for people to do the bar for people to do things is really not that high uh is really what i took away from that story and what i took away from this story is so let's go around the horn no but kairi is willing to draw the line on something that he believes in and it's going to cost him 200 million dollars there's a lot of things that come with all of that noise um he should be allowed to make that decision in my opinion and i don't i don't like the way that he's characterized because i think this is a good human being he's a phenomenal basketball player there's no doubt it's phenomenal could you imagine how strongly he feels about this if he's willing to walk away from the game that he loves and that's you know been an enormous part of his life why is it so important to foist on kyrie irving the need to get vaccinated i mean it's because in new york city in indoors you have to there's a vaccine requirement and he can't play at home games.
He could play in Texas or Houston. So they've talked about trading him to Houston. But then when he went to New York, and he also can't practice with the team in New York, New Jersey, I guess Massachusetts is a bunch of states where you can't go indoors without a vaccine. They're in close proximity to each other. You get the idea. I just think we're turning a good thing into which is the vaccine. I genuinely think it's a great thing that I got done so quickly. It's a miracle of science. And I think it's helped a lot of people i mean all of us i mean it's the thing that's going to end the pandemic largely already has but we're turning into a bad thing but why are we demanding that these holdouts like every last person must get vaccinated well what about what about a flight attendant should a flight attendant before us if they're on a tiny two or should they be work somewhere at you get so much protection by being vaccinated yourself that i don't think so you don't believe in mandates now well i think private companies have the right to to to nba is a private company i know i get it so but i'm just i'm just starting to really question here whether it's truly necessary to get every single one of these last holdouts i just there's something un-american about imposing on free people this decision they can't just make up their own mind you in a previous episode said you were in favor of it if people were dying at a higher rate if it was more acute no no well hold on you You did say that.
You said if it was killing kids and a lot of people were dying, you were in favor. If it was some sort of like Ebola, like, yeah, of course, it'd be a whole different cost benefit analysis. Right, exactly. But look, what I said, and I think this is still my position, is that government shouldn't require, shouldn't stick a needle in your arm. I think private businesses can do it. Or you don't use that service. How much would it take for you to get B cups implanted for a year? For $1 billion, would you do it? A billion. Only Bs. I'm not saying like a strong D or something, just like a modest B cup.
No. I mean, is that a real story, Chamath? Yeah, send you the link. There's a huge article about it. It's in Wikipedia as well. Yeah, that's an old story. Jason, you've already got B cups. I hope someone's paying you for that. I've lost 16 pounds. I'm good. I'm good. I'm just like a perky A right now. B cups be gone. This show has gone off the rails. We promised the audience we'd take two questions. The first one is for Friedberg, and the first question comes from Daniel Nielis, He says, alpha phone made great progress in predictive protein folding. Is there anything similar for chemical synthesis?
Could a similar system finally predict a less energy intensive pathway to ammonia than the Haber-Bosch process, for example? I don't see. This is a great question. When molecules interact, a molecule is a bunch of atoms stuck together. And there are electrons and protons that make up that molecule. and therefore there's this kind of variable electric potential, energy potential that surrounds that molecule. And it's very difficult today to deterministically model how two molecules might interact with one another in physics. And it turns out that that resolves using quantum physics. And so today, we can't really kind of put two molecules together and say, here's what happens when you put these together and have a computer program very quickly and easily solve that quantum physics is involved.
And we don't have a good way to simulate quantum physics and binary computers. So one of the theories and there's been some work on this in on the research basis, creating the framework for it, is that we can use quantum computers to simulate the quantum states of molecules, and use that to figure out how molecules might interact with one another. And as a result, you could kind of see us creating simulations that resolve certain enzymes or proteins that might break apart molecules or stick molecules together, or other molecule combinations that might cause something to happen. The Haber-Bosch process, which is being referred to, was discovered through trial and error in the early 20th century by a German physicist and engineer.
And they realized that if they compressed atmospheric air to 200 times atmospheric pressure and ran it over an iron catalyst with electricity, it zapped, it broke apart the nitrogen bonds in the atmosphere and the air that was compressed and trickled out ammonia, which is nitrogen and hydrogen. And so this was like this amazing invention and it saved the world and fed the world. There's a great book called The Alchemy of Air, if anyone's interested in hearing about this. But it was through trial and error. And we got so friggin' lucky as a species that we figured this out. Using quantum computing in the next 30 years, hopefully, we'll be able to deterministically model these behaviors on a molecular and atomic level.
And as a result, kind of build new systems to make things. and that'll be an incredible kind of toolkit for humans that'll advance a lot of science and a lot of engineering forward. I'm still really strongly of the belief and this goes back to your point earlier. I'm sorry I'm going on a bit of a rant. No it's great. In 100 to 120 years from now I do think we'll all have a replicator in our room. That replicator will make all the things we want to make nearly instantaneously with very low energy and very low cost. Including an organ, a new brain organ some food the next car you want to make i mean we could see and by the way this is a crazy concept it's not just about oh you know quantum stuff or whatever was described in star trek as in but the general principle that you can locally make things and locally make things cheaply with very little energy and very little input changes the whole supply chain model we're seeing this increasingly with new technologies with 3d printing and biomanufacturing you start to put these all together and you take a non-linear track out in the next couple decades and you get to a point that all this nonsense we're talking about where we're mining stuff in one place and making it another and shipping it and combining it all in another.
I think that solves the Long Beach port. Saks, you're going to be able to print a conscience. It's going to be incredible. I'm so glad. I'm so glad we took this audience question. So glad. Yeah. Alright, here's a question for Saks. Maddie, or I guess me and also Chamath, and I guess all four of us. Maddie Chavez asks between being a VC founder angel corporate employee, which has been the most fun, rewarding, and why? What advice would you give someone early in their career hoping to be like you, multi-channel investor, thought leader when they grow up? Sax? Well, I didn't become a VC until after I had already done a few tours of duty as a founder and operator.
So, I mean, my recommendation would be to get involved in startups first, generally get some operating experience, and that would serve you well. startups or even bigger companies i i just think getting getting some reps inside of an organization is critical i tell everyone that uh that's coming out of college or early in their career it's important you go get that perspective and work at a bigger business i mean i spent a few years at google and you know it was a thousand people when i joined grew to 10 000 by the time i left but like i learned so much just in that role and seeing successful products successful models for operating a business.
It was really impactful for me long term. And then you go and make all the mistakes as a founder building a startup. And a lot of people end up with bad confirmation bias if they work at a startup that didn't work out and they think, and all they can draw from is a failed model for operating. If things didn't work right. Which was your favorite? Which role has been your favorite to date, Freeberg? You know, when I was an executive at Monsanto, it was really nice to have that private jet that would come out and take me places. They had a whole security requirement. I already have that anyway. Oh, wow.
The 1%. I have this impression of 0.1%. Edit that out. We're not editing it out. Do not edit that out. And Henry Bellcaster's making a video. I'm setting the tape. Do not edit it out. You said it. It's in your heart. You own your words, David Sachs. What was your favorite, Sachs? My favorite stint? Yeah. Well, I mean, obviously, what we did at paypal has gone on to become uh legend and then you know paypal i was the founder ceo he led that to a unicorn exit so you gotta say those would be the two best professional experiences being a fan i was i was joking about the private jet thing i honestly like to me and i i'm sure you know and the rest of you guys can feel the same but like making a great product and selling that product and you know working with a customer with that product is is honestly like the most rewarding thing you can do it's like you know getting your hands dirty and actually delivering something of value in the world, there's nothing more rewarding than that.
I mean, all the financial engineering and making money and all the nonsense that goes on is really kind of a zoom out of that. But that's really where reward comes in. Yeah, I feel that way too. I was joking about the private jet too. Which one? Which jet? Which one? I think Nick caught me misspeaking. So yeah, it was the first experience was PayPal. The second experience was Yammer. You may have to do some audio work there. Which is your favorite private jet that you have? Yeah. Yeah. Which, by the way, I just want to defend myself on stealing toiletries on Chamath's plane. No, don't defend yourself.
Don't do it. It was a mini bottle of Scope. I drank half of it. What are you supposed to do? How many did you take? Put it back in the drawer. How many did you take? On your plane or on Sag... Chamath's. On your plane, I took a... True story. I did take the half bottle of Pappy Van Winkle. You took my Pappy Van Winkle? Oh. It was like a half left. That's a $5,000 bottle. It's $2,500. Actually, I'll tell you a funny story, I boosted a half bottle of Pappy. Can you blame me? Yeah. Okay. So here, I got to tell you this funny story. So I was going on, you didn't take it. I was going on a business trip with a couple of, you know, friends, coworkers who they're actually founders now of a company I backed.
Anyway, we were going to like an event in, I think it was in Atlanta. So it was like a four hour flight. So they, they opened the liquor drawer or whatever and saw the Pappy Vavocat and, um, They asked if they could have – I was like, sure, take whatever you want. And then I went in the back and went to sleep. So by the time we land, like four hours later, the entire Pappy Van Winkle stash has been – they've gone through it. And it's like, it's all these different types of Pappy. You've got the Pappy 23. You've got some of these antique ones. So they asked me – they'd never flown on a private plane before.
They asked me, hey, Sax, how much did this flight cost? and I said it costs about $6,000 in jet fuel and about $8,000 in Pappy Van Winkle. Pour the Pappy into the jet. Oh my God. It costs more in Pappy than in jet fuel. I'm from around the way. I'm leaving with something. I'm leaving with something. You know, like if I'm going to be on a PJ I'm going to leave with something. I think we found a way to end this podcast in the most insufferable way possible. Insufferable way possible. Alright, love you, Besties. Alright, Nick, edit it all out. No, edit nothing. highlight it, make it the opening.
All right. For the Queen of Kinoa, David Friedberg. For Rain Man, David Sachs. And the Dick Carter himself, Chamath. And also, we're playing next week at Sachsy Poo's place. Ah! We're playing at Beep. At the Mausoleum. No, we're playing at the Mausoleum. Nobody knows where the Mausoleum is. Nobody knows where the Mausoleum is. I've been docked so many times. We better get security. Chamath is coming. I'll bring his. I'll bring him. All right. We'll see you all next time. Bye-bye. Later. We'll let your winners ride. Rain Man David Sack I'm going all in And it said we open source it to the fans And they've just gone crazy with it Love you besties I'm going all in Besties are gone That's my dog taking an audition Your driveway sex Oh man My abitasher will meet me at what it's like.
We should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy. Because they're all just useless. It's like this sexual tension that they just need to release somehow. Wet your feet. Wet your feet. We need to get merch. I'm doing all in. I'm doing all in.