0:00 Jason's big night out, bestie intros, All-In Summit update and more
8:01 Layoffs and shutdowns: Fast, Better.com, GoPuff; Chamath gives a macro- and micro- overview for startups
14:09 Preventing layoffs, culpability in Fast's shutdown, VC diligence strategy, VC/founder model
41:51 Elon buys a 9% stake in Twitter and joins the board: what does this mean for Twitter, free speech online, evolution of deplatforming
1:03:24 Food shortage update, ideal US objectives going forward
Follow the besties:
https://twitter.com/DavidSacks
Follow the pod:
https://twitter.com/theallinpod
https://linktr.ee/allinpodcast
Intro Music Credit:
https://twitter.com/yung_spielburg
Intro Video Credit:
https://twitter.com/TheZachEffect
Referenced in the show:
https://www.theinformation.com/articles/live-fast-die-young-behind-the-fall-of-a-one-click-wonder
https://www.theinformation.com/articles/gopuff-plans-hundreds-of-layoffs-to-cut-40-million-in-costs
https://articles.sequoiacap.com/rip-good-times
https://sacks.substack.com/p/the-saas-board-meeting
https://medium.com/craft-ventures/blitzfail-how-not-to-go-off-the-rails-24ccaf92c410
https://twitter.com/paraga/status/1511320953598357505
https://twitter.com/jack/status/1511329369473564677
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1507259709224632344
https://twitter.com/micsolana/status/1511360061670662149
https://twitter.com/micsolana/status/1511674851202945024
https://www.cnn.com/2022/04/06/tech/pinterest-climate-change-misinformation-policy/index.html
https://gro-intelligence.com/insights/gro-predicts-us-corn-stocks-will-drop-sharply-in-2022-23
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey everybody, welcome to another episode of the All In Podcast, your favorite podcast. And a lot of topics on the docket, including, well, we'll get to that in a minute. Tons of stuff to talk about, not just politics, but a lot of tech news. You do sound really hungover today, J. Cal, you sound like an old man that's been smoking cigarettes for three weeks. You sound wrecked. How big was your night last night? Admit it. I didn't go that big. On a scale of one to Charlie Sheen, it was like a six. There was like a Martin Sheen in his 30s. What does that mean? One to Charlie? We had a couple of beverages.
I'm sorry. On a scale of one to Charlie Sheen, I don't think I've ever been past the one in my life. So what is a six? A six is like, you know, Paris Hilton, you know, in her heyday or like Lindsay Lohan in Hollywood in the 90s. It's like, you know, like a good time, but not crazy. Didn't they have to go to rehab? Yeah, exactly. I'm super high-functioning. Let me tell you something. Charlie Sheen cannot do six. Oh, it was just like Lindsay Lohan. Wait, Lindsay Lohan, the one who went to rehab like five times? like what are you talking about yeah that's a six i don't want to know what seven is joining us of course the queen of quinoa is here the thriller from amila valley puts the eye in anxiety.
He got his degree from his Google pedigree, the Sultan of Science, David Freeberg, with us again. Alright, next up, of course, the czar of ARR. He perfected the flywheel with his boy, Peter T.L. LPs, don't be nervous, because he's only investing in software as a service. The world's biggest sasshole, the rain man himself, David Sachs. Wait, you call me a sasshole? A sasshole. That might stick, I don't know. I feel like this might be heading towards kind of like a high school talent show kind of episode, but yeah, go ahead. And finally, the king of SPACs himself, the guru of growth, he puts the dick in dictator.
He's going to upset her with his sweater. Jamath Palihapitiya. Alright, boys. I'm just letting the audience know, I can't keep this up every week. Yes, yes, it's become a very anticipated new feature of the show. It's a new feature. I forgot we had wet your beak and all this stuff and all these... and flows we come up with new things we come up with new things um all right listen uh just a quick programming update all in summit sold out um basically and it's going to be a great show we got about a dozen speakers lined up uh all kinds of great folks and uh three great parties i want to highlight monday a sunday night will be the poker tournament that's going to be our good fellas godfather kind of theme dressed to impress the family night number two monday night is going to be our havana white party wear your best linens and whites and then closing night party on tuesday night is going to be our miami vice big 80s party neon and t-shirts under suits it's going to be a hell of a party two million nine hundred ninety nine thousand seven hundred people don't give a shit about what you're talking about right now there's like maybe three hundred people that are going to go to this party that you're throwing and no it's going to be 700 tickets i think there's gonna be 700 tickets issued and there'll be probably 400 people at the party so They'll be pretty good parties.
Uh-huh. We're in the party business here at the All In Pod. Well, I mean, the world needs some good parties, in my opinion. It's going to be three back-to-back great parties. And the theme of the conference is the problem I most want to solve in the world or the problem I most want to see solved in the world. So we're asking every speaker to think about that. And we're going to kind of talk about the world's biggest problems and then who actually wants to solve them. The world needs more parties. Well, that's what I'm doing. That's going to be my 10-minute talk, my TED Talk. I've been watching the WeWork show.
Have you guys been watching it? Oh, fabulous. On Apple TV Plus? Yeah. It's great. Elevating the world's... Jared Leto is so freaking good as that character, by the way. Yeah, it's incredible. He's got to get an Emmy. The whole like elevating the world's consciousness as the mission and then just throw parties is the way to do it. I feel like you really fit that vibe. Like, yeah. It's aspirational for me. You can elevate the world's consciousness with your summits. I told Bill... While pocketing millions of dollars. It's not going to make a profit. Whatever profit it makes is going to go to chamat star chamber 50 person conference he's doing with the all-in brand so everybody gets to leverage the brand yeah first you did it sacks with your call-in now i'm doing it with the summit chamat's gonna do it his think tank and i'm not gonna do it coming soon from friedberg the all-in munique special lose weight like your besties he's gonna it's it's it's the all-in brand that allows you to lose weight in the following way he brings his best vegan chef to you oh yeah spins up some fucking tempeh garbage tempeh and vegan shakes your favorite it's double fucking yuck right yes you vomit after you eat it you're you're in a caloric deficit for the month that that person refuses to leave your house boom you lose everything's soft you lose weight they're like hey want some quinoa you're like no and then you lose weight no that's pretty give me avocado shake give me give me my olive infused beef please the olive infused beef.
No, I'm sorry, not olive infused. Olive fat. These beef only ate olives, guys. Right, and then we murdered them and ate them. You know what you guys are going to do? You're going to have a great life. You guys need to elevate your consciousness, okay? And have a party. Let's go. We need to get some morels and some chickens and make some chicken with morels. Yesterday we had morels. Sean made morels. White asparagus with morels for you. So good. So good. The morel season has started. Everybody enjoy it. lots of different news this week you guys appeal you guys appeal to the common man the morel season has started morels aren't that expensive tempeh is more expensive than quinoa and morels 100 that vegan bullshit is way more expensive than normal people all right listen we have to elevate the world's consumption of steak and meats um i think a good place to start is we've been talking by the way by the way have you guys ever looked and on the back of any carton of oat milk how much chemical nonsense is in that stuff yeah can that really be can that really be good for you no you know what i want oh my god give me where's the oat milk that's just oats and water doesn't exist it doesn't exist it's like soy lexithin xanthan gum like is that stuff can't be good for you you know sacks drinks and a 12 ounce glass of milk with every dinner they just tricks by the way the almond the almond milk at like the whole foods riddled with sugar and all this other nonsensical chemicals as well man i mean i mean people trash milk i get it but like and as if you're lactose intolerant i understand you're in a pinch but why go to an alternative milk that is just riddled with just all of this terrible terrible stuff you know sacks used to love to eat bree cheese so much that whenever we'd have a party somebody would bring a wheel.
Do you remember the brie blocks with the wheel of brie? He would literally eat an entire brie wheel on his own. And brown sugar. No, they would put the brown sugar on top. They would belt it. And Saks, Freebrook, Saks is eating an entire brick of brie in front of us. What was the origin of your brie obsession, Saks? Stanford. I've been at Stanford. You just at some point became a Francophile. He's the guy that eats brie. He's the last guy I would think that would eat brie. What's the matter? You just don't have, I mean, what about cheddar? A great American cheese? No, you just prefer the french huh yeah you know you still got that fetish for great or no start the show i gotta go yeah we got shit to do let's go i got 45 minutes sacks sacks is that fermented kombucha stop stop this is just plain iced tea sometimes it's just good to be norm core oh oh you're back on trying to catch up trying to catch up okay here we go listen we've been talking a little bit about the contraction in tech, the growth stocks having their multiples lowered.
And we knew this was coming. But it's been a horrible week for large companies starting the layoffs. We knew this was coming. We predicted it probably six months ago. Fast.com is a one click checkout startup. Fast.co, they announced they're shutting down on Tuesday, this after the company grew to 450 employees and generated reported $600,000 in revenue. I think that their employees could have made more money if they did one DoorDash a day delivery. At its peak, Fast was burning $10 million a month, according to reports. I think the information got most of this information while only generating about 50k a month in revenue.
their 102 million dollar series b was led by stripe in january of 2021 company raised 124 million dollars in total also better.com which we talked about you remember they had their horrific cringe-worthy founder lay off a bunch of employees over zoom um and they laid off 900 people december refers 3,000 people on March 8, according to TechCrunch. For the 5,000 remaining employees on April 5, better.com offered corporate and product design and engineering employees the opportunity to voluntarily resign in exchange for 60 days paid severance and health insurance coverage. Better CEOs, Vishal Garg, hopefully I'm probably not correct, noted the uncertain mortgage market conditions of the last couple of weeks have created an exceedingly challenging operating environment for many companies in our industry.
and then going to go puff which you know i had the founder on uh this week at startups and he's a pretty good um you know like pretty realistic about the margins in that business they're making a modest cut of three percent of their 15 000 staff seems like a reasonable thing to do given how the market has changed but again their valuation was absurd 1.5 billion at 40 had a $40 billion valuation in December. Shamath, you predicted a lot of this and that people would have to sharpen their pencils. We had a discussion about this, the good times are RIP. What's your take? Is this the beginning of the end, the middle?
Where are we at in this cycle? And what's the reasonable thing for founders to do here? I think, so we probably should take the macro and then boil it down to the startup. So at the macro level, I think that we're playing a very dangerous game of chicken with the Fed. And you can kind of summarize it in the following way, which is that, you know, three or four months ago, we only thought that there was going to be a handful of interest rate increases. And increasingly, what has happened, the market has remained so resilient that the Fed has sort of put out more and more data as the data has justified them being a lot more aggressive.
And it kind of crescendoed this past week where they basically said, listen, you know, we're going to move by 50 basis point increments for the foreseeable two or three rate hikes, and we're going to start quantitative tightening. What does that mean? That means that instead of basically printing money and coming in and buying securities from the market, right? So what happens when they enter the market with money that they literally do print and buy your bonds, they're giving you cash in return. And typically, what that has led to is the inflation of all assets, right? Equity assets have gone up, bond assets have gone up, because there's just nothing else to buy.
When quantitative tightening happens, they reverse that. And what they're going to do is about $95 billion a month of the opposite action, which means they're taking money out of the system, right? Or in this case, what they're going to do is they're going to let a bunch of maturities roll off and not renew them. Okay, so why is this important? Well, it's important because we're still 4% from the highs. So we have 7% inflation, we have all this crazy stuff happening, we have a war going on, we have massive price issues, we have supply-demand issues, and the market keeps shaking it off. So I think what the Fed's going to do is get even more aggressive.
You're going to probably see a lot of 50s, maybe even a 75-point hike. you probably are going to see them, you know, even ratchet up quantitative tightening, until there is a bit of a bloodletting in the equity market. They need to see that the markets crack. And so they literally need to see what percentage drawdown or just to go sideways, what do they need to see in order to look? Or is it inflation coming down a couple of points? Well, the problem that we suffer from is that they're going to look at the highest level indexes, right? They're not looking at single stocks. And so when they like when you and I think this market is down 4%, we don't feel that because some of our companies are down 50 and 60%.
Right? But that's because we're all focused on high tech growth. But they look at the broad indices and the broad indices have held up really well. And mostly, it's because, you know, if you look inside the S&P 500, 40% of every dollar is, you know, Apple, Amazon, you know, Microsoft, etc, Tesla. So we're in a situation where I think until the Fed see that there's a massive trading of liquidity, which means like you see these indices crack big time, 35, 3600 in the S&P, they're just going to keep ratcheting things up. As it comes all the way down to our companies in Silicon Valley and tech, what that means is like you have to start planning for the worst.
And I think the worst means that there's an 18 month period where you cannot raise money on your terms, you have to raise money on the market terms. And so if you're not in a position to show good growth over these next two years, I would encourage you to just get your balance sheet in order to wait it out. Saks, nuclear winner is a possibility here. Markets for startups, raising money, again, as you're not saying, could be on the terms of the capital allocators. What's your advice to founders? What are you seeing in the boardrooms that you're on the board of? And if you were running one of these high growth companies for the past year, what are the first two or three things you do?
I mean, the first thing you got to do is look at your burn multiple. I mean, how much are you burning relative to how much incremental ARR are you generating? You look at FAST, they raised $120 million, what, like a year ago. They're out of money now. So they burnt $10 million a month, like you said. Here's the crazy thing. If they just slammed on the brakes three or four months ago, when we were talking on this pod about the coming downturn, they could still have $30 million in the bank. That's a lot of money. The only reason it doesn't seem like a lot of money is because they've been burning 100 million over the past year.
But objectively, $30 million is a gross series B, which is actually a lot of money for a company that only has 100,000 in revenue. So they could have saved that company if they had slammed on the brakes three months ago and rationalized the cost structure. And they didn't. So they hit the wall at 100 miles an hour. Who's responsible when something like that happens, David? Because we've all seen it. What is the suspension of disbelief that creates this kind of stupidity? I mean, that's what it is. I mean, you've got people who are kind of drinking the Kool-Aid, and there's nobody advising them to stop, or if there is, they're not listening.
I mean, look, PayPal had this situation back in 2000, the year 2000, right after the dot-com crash. We were burning $10 million a month, like fast. We had no revenue and no business model. Okay. We had said the service would be always free. we had four months basically of life and we pulled up on the throttle and what we did is we basically introduced paid accounts we started charging transaction fees and we caught the we cut the cost structure of the company and we made that last 40 million dollars last a lot longer than four months it lasted until we could then do another fundraise the following year and we were able to then raise with good numbers real revenue a business model etc so you know and that was because we were just paying attention to the changing environment.
The world had changed from sort of the pre-dot-com crash, you know, 1999, your business model didn't matter, your margins didn't matter, revenue didn't matter, none of that stuff mattered. All that mattered was growth. But by mid-2000, everything had changed. So you have to be attuned to what the fundraising environment is looking like. And if you're a high burn company right now, that's not generating a lot of revenue to go along with it, you better slam on the brakes and rationalize your cost structure before it's too late. David, tell me, like, what do you think is going on in this board meeting?
I mean, like, this is a group of incompetent incompetence. I don't even know who's on the board because Stripe led two rounds, I think. And so is that part of it, David, that you and listen, we all love Stripe. It's a great company. It's a legendary company. But one of the reasons we don't like to have strategics is maybe they're not thinking the same as a proper capital allocator. And for them, this is peanuts. Right. Exactly. No, look, the reason why a strategic investor... Sorry, go ahead. I think the reason why a strategic investor invests is because it's strategic for them. I mean, it was in Stripe's interest to try and back a winner in the whole e-commerce checkout line sort of payment space.
And so they did that. And I don't even know if they had a board seat. And so no one was really... But I don't understand that strategic decision because I suspect the rationale somewhere internally in Stripe, which is pretty flawed, is, hey, we can't do it ourselves because if we did, we would be competing with our customers. But picking a winner and putting $120 million is tantamount to the same thing. So I don't understand. I mean, it doesn't make any sense. Right. And Stripe raised money at a $9,500 billion valuation. So look, it all flows down from the frothiness at the peak. No, I'm saying I think it would have been much more credible for Stripe to say this is a critical piece of the infrastructure and value chain and payments that we want to own.
So we're just going to go and put some of our better engineers as like a side project and see if we can tack away at something that works. I mean, I think a lot of people would have adopted it. To be clear, Stripe was on the board. Index was on the board. Okay, that's interesting. I mean, those are some good investors. There's a couple of people. Who was on the board? Index and who else? According to Crunchbase, Stripe was on the board, a business development person from there. Index was on the board. And Dom, the founder, and looks like Brian Sugar, who I know, who's an angel investor and a founder.
But who knows if that's outdated information in Crunchbase. Do you guys remember when Philip Kaplan used to run a website called Fucked Company? Absolutely. A friend of mine, yeah. Do you want to tell the Fucked Company story, Jake, Al, for all the people that have no Well, I mean, basically what happened was .com, the .com world was imploding. All the employees didn't have a voice. There was no social media at the time. There was no blogs at the time. The only thing you could really publish in the world was like a GeoCities page. You could put up a homepage if you knew how to do HTML. It was even pre-MySpace.
And so a friend of mine, Phil Kaplan, who does a very successful company called DistroKid now, started Fuck Company. And it was a message board. And what he basically let people do was he would write three headlines, one sentence each, kind of like before Reddit existed, where you just put a one line hit. And then there was comments underneath them. They'd say, this company, we just got an email. This company's laying off people. And he would beat all the news stories to the layoffs because he would just run with any email that came in. And then people would detail and savage the management of those companies underneath it for malfeasance and explain exactly how ridiculous the spending was in that era where people were burning money like drunken sellers.
I think this time around, it's probably important for employees to understand a couple things. One is like, who doesn't know what they're doing, right? So like companies that are making layoffs, those are happening, they shouldn't get punished for that. But you got to think like the fiduciaries that are ripping this money in, I mean, do you really want to be the person that goes to work at a company that's backed by these folks in round two? I mean, that's not a signal. Like, the opposite has always been a signal, right? Meaning, when Mike Moritz makes an investment, we all pay attention. Because we all think, wow, there's a picker, you know, and he did that with Stripe and with so many other, you know, great companies.
And so the likelihood of an employee wanting to work for a Mike Moritz back company or Mike Moritz governed company is very high. Right. Same thing with Gurley's, you know, same thing with a lot of a lot of really, really good investors, John Doerr. door. But the opposite should also be true then. Because if it if you really want to work for a Peter Thiel back company, you should probably not work for one of these companies, where these folks were just completely absent are also governing the board. Because that just means like nobody knows what's going on. We haven't had proper governance for a long time in Silicon Valley.
So I mean, I think that's what we're we crashed, we crashed and the dropout were in some ways about incompetent boards, both of those TV shows. No, I mean, I definitely see this. You know, I think you guys know the incentive for a traditional venture capitalist that maybe isn't motivated by improving their craft, but they're motivated and incentivized primarily by making money is to raise more capital and getting more deals. And as you guys know, every venture firm has maybe one or two superstars, and then they fill out the ranks and hire a bunch of folks who maybe not superstars, or they don't pay as much attention.
It used to be maybe a VC would sit on a handful of boards. And now it's like you're the board representative for 12 companies. And you're not going to be able to provide quality time and service and support to the CEO and the company. And more importantly, as you guys point out, not provide good governance. And governance isn't just about, are you signing the docusigns as they come in to approve stuff? But it's about actually critiquing the business strategy with the CEO at the board discussion, critiquing the spending, reviewing the financial plan, making sure that everyone's aligned, that this makes sense in this funding environment to continue to do this work.
And I don't see that a lot. I don't know about you guys, but I see a lot of VCs either handering to the CEO because we have founder culture, hysteria in Silicon Valley, where it's true, the best founders make the 1000x returns, and that's it. But that doesn't necessarily mean that the rest of the businesses should be left to their own vices, just because there are a few ultra successful founders that there are a lot of businesses that actually need governance in order to achieve outcomes. And I see that lacking heavily in Silicon Valley, because the VCs are more incentivized to raise more money, to make more investments, and then pay less attention and just go raise the next fund.
Well, I think I think you said the key thing, there are really very few star pickers in our business. It takes decades to really prove that out. And, and those people, but those people that are real pickers, I don't think put up with bullshit from they're not just pickers, like, so john door was deeply involved in Google in the early days, like, you're right, I'm simplifying our job. But what I'm saying is, our job, okay, at the end of the day is we're picking, okay. And then once you pick, you got to do the work. If you pick poorly, and you do the same amount of work, it doesn't matter. Nobody's going to remember you.
Yeah, what ends up happening is the VC flushes the deal because it's not going to be the 100 bagger. They don't pay as much attention, they let the thing ride into the sunset. And they're moving on to the next thing. But there is still a duty and a responsibility, I think, to the shareholders and the employees of that company, to, you know, do what Sachs mentioned, which is can you reduce burn under these circumstances? And can you actively engage as a board member to encourage leadership to do that? And that doesn't happen. But you said the key thing, there are few practitioners that really have the gravitas to actually enforce those decisions.
So, you know, there's a reason why in during the great financial crisis, there was only one organization that even had the courage, forget whether it was right or wrong at the time to even write the RIP Good Times deck, right? It was Sequoia. Nobody else dared to even put that on a page, let alone give it to all of their companies, knowing that it would leak lest they be wrong. The reason Sequoia could do it is they're looking at a 40-year franchise and saying, the integrity of our franchise is at stake. We need to keep doing what we've done before. What it did, I think, in that case was pulled along a bunch of folks that were not as good as the top few folks, and it helped reorganize.
Because if you see the three or four years after that GFC deck, Sequoia flushed that whole business. There's an entire turnover of that team. I think what it speaks to is, and we talked about this in a few episodes ago, if you're seeking out AUM, you're going to hire a very different kind of person than if you're trying to help build companies. And the difference is that when you're trying to raise AUM, your customer is not the company, your customer is the LP. And what the LP wants to do is be able to write their investment memo and not get fired. And the way that you do that is by pointing to the team and saying, well, this person worked at this company, this person was a VP of that company.
and it seems credible but between but being able to invest and being able to actually be a good operator is so different look i'll also say one thing that's important you know i don't like this celebration or sorry the mockery and the entertainment that comes from failure i i thought fuck company like i was young when it when it was out and you know i would read it and kind of giggle at the stupid companies that got funding you know but to me it's not like the kind of thing that could should kind of be funny or laughed at, or even to mock failed companies. I mean, it's cynical. I think the capital that's available in the markets today to support the building.
That wasn't that that's not what fuck company was. I don't think it was people taking potshots as much as it was a lot of that. Oh, yeah, there was a lot of that. And because yeah, there was a thing. But would you admit in fairness that there was a lot of people telling the truth? Oh, yeah, yeah, totally. No, no, no. But but but a lot of it was like this mockery, like, can you believe this shit even existed? Yada, yada. And the cynicism, I think, you know, kind of, you know, it stales out the opportunity for capital to support, you know, new ventures, new initiatives like this. You know, I also think that these businesses that today are looking to raise capital that are, you know, let's call them good businesses, they have a good opportunity, they're going to be challenged in a marketplace where everyone is cynical.
And I'll say like, scarcity breeds success. When there wasn't a lot of venture money, and there were only a, you know, kind of a few investments that could be made each year. There was a decision making process that says, you know, look, how valuable could this be? Versus this other opportunity that I could invest my capital into that says, okay, the best opportunity wins and gets picked and gets capital. In a world where everyone was raising a billion dollar second fund, or a $3 billion fourth fund, and you suddenly had an influx of $100 billion of venture money in a year, it's a lot like what we saw in crypto markets, which is an extraordinary explosion in highly speculative bubble assets.
And a lot of these businesses maybe shouldn't have existed in the first place. Too much demand for the stock of private companies. and all the hedge funds that came into it all the mutual funds not enough supply of great founders and serious teams that are working hard on this i think with the case of fast i agree with your general sentiment about dunking in the case of fast what you had was a founder who was on twitter every day tweeting about how great the company wasn't giving startup advice while he was taking none of it and should not have been giving any of it because they didn't even have product market fit lesson learned you know you know you know who should be criticized the next person that backs that guy that's it you know that guy he's got a very interesting history actually as well i think if they had done a little colorful they didn't do any diligence on him apparently he had two companies that were kind of major red flags and i think the diligence issue sacks is one maybe you are having a similar experience to me on the early stage we were seeing deals last year close in a week.
We normally have 30 days to vet a deal and maybe a week or two to get our diligence wrapped up. Sometimes these things overlap. But it's what was it, you know, historically, a four to six week process, and then it went down to a four to six day process. And then people were meeting with you one day and saying they're closed the next. Were you did you feel like over the last couple years, people were doing proper diligence or not? And what impact did diligence have on any of this? You know, certainly, I can't speak to what our competitors were doing. I don't think our diligence process changed much.
We would just have a mentality of when there was a deal that was urgent, we would drop everything and focus on that deal and get our work done. And it can be done quickly. Although it's easier for SaaS companies because the metrics that you're looking at are so standardized. It's an easier process. What's the most important thing in diligence? In your mind, what is the bullet that people can't, the silver bullet thing people can't fake? Probably offsheet customer references. So the first thing we do is focus on the metrics, right? And the financials, the SaaS metrics, all that kind of stuff. But then you want to talk to customers and you want to understand the value they're getting out of the product.
And ideally, they're offsheet customers. Explain what offsheet means. Offsheet just means that you frequently ask a founder to give you customer references. Those are onsheet references. The offsheet references are the ones that you find yourself that they never gave you. So like the easiest off sheet references to do are when your own portfolio companies are using some other like piece of software, and they tell you about it. So no, you know, it's a totally non-conflicted situation. So that's what you're looking for. So one of your companies is using Stripe, they tell you how great Stripe is, they tell you what's good about it, what's bad about it.
But references you're giving, so it's sort of like backdoor references. If somebody tells you, here's my references. And you can do the same thing on founders too. You can have on sheet and off sheet references for founders. And you can do it for VCs. Yeah. But look, I think it's probably a little bit unfair to blame the board of this company too much because the reality is that VCs don't have the leverage or the power in this business. I mean, this whole construction of the industry is set up around founders. And at the end of the day, it's up to the founder to run the company and they get to do what they want.
unless they do something criminal. Otherwise, they're going to be able to do whatever they want. And I disagree. Hold on. Boards generally are very deferential to founders. And if the founder is not willing to listen to advice, what are you going to do about that? Well, but this is the point you're making, I think, is not right. You think that if Peter Thiel gave some advice to slow the company down, that this guy would have not taken it? Of course, he would have taken it. I don't know. I don't know about that. And we would have had to consider it. If Mike Moritz actually said it, he would have had to consider it.
I think what you're actually speaking to is in the rush to put so much money to work, we've elevated people who don't understand what the job is to do the job. And if they're not credible, of course, they're going to be ignored. We all have ignored stupid board members. You've done it too, David. But even, you know, let's actually look at Yammer as an example. There were one or two of us that you would talk to pretty consistently. You didn't talk to all of them. I would always seek out advice. Look, a great founder, a good founder always seeks out advice. No question about it. But look, this idea that it's governance versus advice, I mean, the problem with it being governance is all the institutional incentives for VCs are to be pro-founder.
So no one wants to jam a founder by making them do something they don't want to do. Well, I'm just saying that's the way it is now. No, to be clear, that became a competitive tactic that emerged as more venture capital funds were raised and more venture capital was raised from LPs. Prior to that, there was a scarcity of venture capital. And VCs could have good governance and not have to have this whole pro-founder model that became the thing that Founders Fund and Andreessen and others kind of proclaimed as being core to their advantage and the reason to pick them over some other VC who's going to medal in your affairs.
And by the way, both are true. There are most VCs, as Vinod has said, publicly add negative value. And I totally agree with him on this. Because many VCs, particularly the ones who aren't valuable and don't really have much to add, try to add stuff, try to say stuff, and they just create negative value in the process. But on the other hand, the whole pro-founder model led to the WeWork and Ubers of the world that I think we all can see There's a trade-off. I mean, look, I remember in the 1990s, the default was that the founder just got replaced, right? Like, as soon as the company's successful, you hire a professional CEO.
That was just like rule of thumb. Eric Schmidt. I mean, even the mighty Google did that. Yeah, no, I mean, that was, by the way, that was a point I was trying to make, which was like, so much of John Doerr's influence was in getting Larry and Sergey to take Eric on as CEO. And I really do think that that was like, you know, a critical move that created probably the that created the most valuable company in history. Right. And, you know, it was an important... Imagine if you had one of these founders fund... And by the way, you know, as you guys know, I'm very close to the guys at Founders Fund.
But imagine if you had a Founders Fund type approach where you said, look, Larry and Sergey are the founders. They know what they're doing. Let them do it. As opposed to the John Doerr nuance of, let's make sure that we think about the development of this company successfully over time. And then convince Larry and Sergey through a bunch of meetings and riding bikes and whatever else they did with Eric. you know to like and then and then what about jim breyer didn't he bring cheryl over to facebook i mean like there's a lot of these stories of the really um you know the vcs that really change the trajectory of the business through their work right and but look all i'm saying is the the good vcs can still have that influence but it's in the form of advice rather than governance right look we just don't call the shots you're right you're right it's it is it is advice but but for example governance as an example in in in every board that i take the first thing that i say is here's a template I want.
I'm not going to ask you a bunch of stuff, but I just want some transparent reporting. And the first page is always, how much money at the beginning of the month? How much money did you burn? You know, how much equity did we give out? How much is left in the pool? Simple, basic checks and balances, right? Where you're not asking all kinds of crazy questions. You're just like, all right, how much money are we burning? How much dilution did we take? Now tell me what we've done. And those are simple elements of governance. Way before you get into advice. level setting what's the speed of the plane what's what's the elevation where are we at what's the altitude and when you ask people for this today we actually do that too yeah i don't know anyone that doesn't do that i'll be honest like yeah anybody that doesn't do it honestly is being that's not what we're talking about i don't know anyone that doesn't do that i mean i'm talking about i would love to see i would love to see a little bit of that going on there's a little bit i would love to see a fast board deck and to see if that first page is that page the first page and And by the way, you know where I learned that from?
From Sequoia and Kleiner Perkins. Because back in the day, what I saw from founders was, oh, this is the first thing I have to report on. I was taught by founders when I was a principal at Mayfield. They're like, this is how you do the job. And I was like, great, thanks. I was sitting beside these guys that were old hands at doing it. And that's how I learned this business through that apprenticeship. But there was governance and advice. And the governance is just about being transparent about how much money are you burning. And so you can't, you know, to David's point, if you had just seen that data, even if you take those board decks, by the way, because you have these information rights, I don't know about you guys, but we did it, we did it as well.
You take the board deck, you circulate it to your other partners. There's lots of times where I see board decks and companies where one of my partners are on the board, and I send them an email of like, hey, here's some bullet points of things to think about that I've seen before, etc, etc. You don't think nobody at Striper Index could have said, you're burning $10 million a month and there's no revenue? So the point is that data was not there. And there's only $30 or $40 million in the bank. Give me a break, guys. So this was a cataclysmic failure at the advice level and at the governance level.
And all I'm saying is it's a good lesson for folks to learn. Absolutely. Yeah. So let me point people's attention to two articles I wrote that I think are relevant. So first, we actually published an article on the SaaS board meeting deck that we would like people to use. And obviously, they're free to use it or not. To Tamas' point, right up at the top as a context center, we need to know what's your monthly burn and how much money is in the bank. And then we just divide those things to create runway. We don't like looking at projections for runway. Totally. We just look at how much you burned last month and how much money you got in the bank.
Months to cash out. Right, exactly. When they were down to $30 or $40 million burning $10 million a month, somebody should have thrown up a red flag and said, you better slam on the brakes right now because you're going to be out of business in three or four months. So that's sort of piece number one. The other piece was an archive I wrote a couple of years ago called Blitz Fail, which is how not to go off the rails. Because there's a lot of literature out there about blitz scaling. And a lot of startups think they need to scale as rapidly as humanly possible. And I wrote this piece about how fast-growing companies that raise lots of money at high valuations basically go off the rails and they end up imploding.
And there's like 11 reasons why this happens. I sort of categorize them. One of the biggest ones is founder psychology. You have a founder who believes that things are always going to be up and to the right. It's funny. They're always described the same way, described as visionary, charismatic. And the word crazy is often used, but it's crazy good. And then when everything goes to shit, all of a sudden, the word crazy means something pejorative and bad. And the problem is that these characteristics of being highly visionary and charismatic, they also can be combined with an unwillingness to listen to advice.
And so founders who have those qualities, they can be a good thing, but they have to seek out advice from people who've had experience. Otherwise, they're going to make a mistake and hit the wall. Being delusional is, you know, what you need to start these companies. Like, I'm going to beat these incumbents, I'm going to change the world. A little bit of delusion is good, but not when you're looking at the runway, right? Like, that's when you need to be pragmatic. I think, you know, there's a term of coachability, you know, how coachable is this person as a CEO, as a leader. And I do think that coachability goes hand in hand with intellectual curiosity.
I mean, if you look at the Collison's, Patrick Collison, and how much breadth he has and some of the topics he's interested in and the things he writes about, it indicates to me a high degree of intellectual curiosity. And people who are intellectually curious generally are very humble because they're constantly seeking things they don't know. And they recognize that they don't know a lot of things. And in that same kind of mentality, they are willing to recognize that other individuals can have good points of view that can inform their perspective. And they're willing to change their perspective.
And I think that's a really key thing that if you look across the range of successful founders, CEOs that scale to $100 billion plus valuations for their businesses, that to me is one of the more common threads is this kind of intellectual curiosity, which translates into a coachability, which translates into an adaptability as and being willing to take advice. And so your board is a tool, not kind of a governance structure sitting over you. I think the less you are like that, the more you are likely to feel like your board is a governance structure, an umbrella sitting over you telling you what you can't do.
I don't think that's what governance means, by the way. Well, governance meant to it's meant to look out for the shareholders. That's the job. right but to act as a fiduciary doesn't mean to like tell the ceo what to do this is my point like yeah i'm just saying it's not i think i think he's right about i think freeberg's right about how boards are often perceived by founders i think there is an increasing uh let's call it a hollywood director a hollywood auteur mentality towards vcs jay cal and the all-in podcast right well it's it's basically it's basically look there there are certain incubators out there accelerators and whatever, who teach these young founders that it's all about their vision and anyone who stands in the way of it is basically interfering with them.
And they are the auteur, like a Hollywood director, and you got to stay away from those suits, the studio guys, right? That's the mentality they're teaching them. An adversarial mentality. An adversarial mentality. And look, there are, to Jamal's point, there are plenty of VCs who don't know what they're doing. They have no useful advice to offer. But the better mentality to teach a founder would be like, look, the world is so complicated and building a company is so complicated. It's going to be 10 times more difficult if you don't seek out advice. So go find board members who will let you ultimately do what you want, but will still give you the advice if something's going wrong.
And what was true at one point in time, when Paul Graham gave this advice and he set up Y Combinator, you don't want to say their name, but it is Paul Graham had a terrible experience in his company with venture capitalists. So he set up that wartime stance between founders and the investment community. And founders fund became the antithesis of the traditional venture funds, and they were going to be founder focused. But that advice then might have been true. And now it's not. Now we've sung the pendulum too far the other way. We did two things because we saw this 10 years ago when I started seed investing.
And then when I started building positions of over 5%, I just said to founders, if we own over 5% or 10%, we should have an option of a board seat. And we'll do board training with you. where we'll just teach you. We'll take like, here's some decks that we've seen from other, you know, here's some decks that are available and we'll show you what a board is like. And then I would have three founders come, two would sit on one's board meeting and I would do three back-to-back board meetings, bring your council, bring your founders and sit in on the other two board meetings. And we'll have a little Socratic discussion about what was good about each board meeting.
We did board meeting training as a proxy for venture worthiness later on. And when those companies did go out to get venture and they had an ESOP and they had board minute meetings, they just looked more impressive to the venture community so i know people say don't do a board it's not cool it actually turns out doing a one hour board meeting four times a year six times a year even as a seed stage company it's it does differentiate you to the venture community i find all right moving on and speaking of boards elon bought a uh chunk of twitter last week a nine percent stake and he's joining the board that makes him the largest individual or the largest shareholder, individual or institutional.
He bought the shares in March, Twitter CEO Prague, Agarwal tweeted, I'm excited to share we're appointing you on must to our board. And then Jack tweeted in support. I'm really happy. Elon is joining the Twitter board exclamation point just to give some level setting here. In q four of 2021, Twitter had 1.5 billion in revenue up 22% year over year, they've really been starting to ring the register over there. Daily active users are solid but modest 217 million daily active users 38 million of which in the US 179 million are international. And their stated goals for q4 of next year 2023. So in a year and a half, they want to have 315 million.
And they want revenue in 2023 to hit 7.5 billion. Again, they're on a $6 billion run rate. So I guess that would be an increase of 25%. Just general thoughts on uh and elon obviously has been making uh some twitter suggestions uh for the product sax you worked with elon at paypal thoughts on what this does for that wasn't why you're laughing it's like such a funny transition sax you work with elon at paypal work for i'm sure i'm sure he's gonna have some great product ideas but what this is really about is free speech you know right before Elon announced this, he was doing polling, asking the Twitter user base whether Twitter was succeeding or failing in his mission to be an open town square, an open marketplace of ideas.
Something like 70% said they were failing at it. Elon, on many occasions, has spoken up for free speech. He believes that Twitter's historic mission is as an open town square. And I think he's going to bring that emphasis to the board. And it's a great thing. Now, I think the person who had the best take on the reaction to this was Mike Solana. And he had a few funny tweets about this. Who is Mike Solana? Who does he work for? Is he a Founders Fund guy? I think, yeah, I think he works for Peter, a Founders Fund. But he's got a... He also writes a great sub-stack newsletter, kind of like a blog post called Pirate Wires.
It's worth checking out. He's a pretty... In addition to being a pretty sharp analyst, he actually says a lot of funny things too. He's iconoclastic and yeah, he'll swing the sword. Yeah. So the way he put it is that Elon joining the board has all the worst people on Twitter furious. They think that this guy might actually say free speech. And for authoritarians, that is an existential threat. And then he added, I don't get what the problem is, guys. If you want censorship, you can just go build a new social media company and do censorship there. It's a free market. thereby turning on its head everything they've been saying, which is, you know, when the people who the authoritarian, the authoritarian people who love censorship, whenever anyone complained about censorship, they would always say, well, just go create your own social network.
You know, we're free to do whatever. Exactly. Well, this is the free market acting in a way they don't like, which is finally somebody who believes in free speech is one to stand up by the largest stake in Twitter, join the board. I mean, this is fabulous. I think it's really fabulous. I think it's pretty amazing. Yeah. And the stock went up 30%. What do you think, Shemath? I texted you guys in the group chat. I think that if he is able to make free speech cool again, he'll actually do more doing that than potentially through SpaceX and Tesla. And that's already saying a lot. Because free speech really is this fundamental principle of democracy, and it's been decaying.
We don't know the implications of a large technology company keeping free speech as a principled pillar of their reason to exist, right? Because we have seen free speech kind of decay, and we've seen sort of, you know, random decision making that seems arbitrary by a lot of these technology companies and, you know, the payments companies, Freebrook was mentioning Visa and MasterCard earlier in the group chat. But all of these things can change on a dime if Elon makes free speech cool again and figures out a way to make that a principle that everybody can embrace. Because then if you really believe in that, then you go to the next logical conclusion, which is what David has said for forever, which is the only solution to, you know, speech you don't like is more speech.
And then that creates a surface area that I think you can technically maneuver around. So meaning, what are the real problems in all of this speech creates, it creates a, you know, content moderation issue, right? It creates a spam issue, and it creates a sort of wisdom of the crowds ranking rating issue. So misinformation comes to mind. But that's a wisdom of the crowd's ranking rating issue in my book. So I guess the point is that, you know, if he can get the Twitter employee base, fundamentally on side of this idea of free speech as a principle, that's, I think, is enormous, because you know that none of the other big tech companies will ever even do that.
And the capital structures of those companies will never allow a single strong voice like his to enforce that idea. Yeah. So this is the only company where that could happen. And I think, you know, we want to see what this how this plays out. I think it's a really, really big deal. All right, Freeberg. Yeah, I'll tell you what I think changes. Facebook, Twitter, even Google all acquiesced to significant external pressure over the years. I've said this in the past. I believe the founders of those companies are all philosophically, fundamentally philosophically aligned with the notion of free speech and absolute freedom of information, you know, enabling truth finding over time.
And the edge cases of those platforms ultimately identify and uncover ways that they can be used against what many would consider kind of the betterment of society. And as a result, they acquiesce to external pressure that drives some of these censorship decisions and drives some of these behavioral changes by management. But I think that if you concentrate the ownership of those businesses, and rather than have kind of a distributed shareholder base, meaning the public markets where the largest single shareholder in Twitter to date, has been Jack Dorsey at 2.3%. He actually serves the shareholders.
And the shareholders ultimately want to see the stock price go up. And they ultimately want to see the business make more money. And as a result, they don't have the same sort of, you know, the stakeholders there have kind of a different set of alignments over time. You know, they're not necessarily the same long term or focus, meaning does the philosophy come before the money? And I think as you kind of concentrate ownership, you have the opportunity and the option now to, you know, make make those sorts of decisions that you can't make when you're a broadly owned stock. But Facebook and Google are concentrated.
They have a dual class structure. Dual class. Yeah. So what are you talking about? The issue, Chamath, is in those companies, they're scared to death that they'll lose their employees and have chaos at work. Government. No, the issue is government. it's both also it's also your employees it's both it's pressure from above and below it's yeah it's shareholders it's shareholders and government regulators right and so in both cases you acquiesce to the pressure and employees it's a good point yeah i understand but i'm not sure how twitter changes any of that there it does i'll tell you why because if we look what's happened is sometime last year i think it happened around chappelle and i think it happened because of coinbase we saw a group of folks say you know what enough's enough yeah we told you to bring your whole self to work we told you we would do your laundry and then at some point netflix was like listen you don't have to agree with every comedian on our platform there's a range of comedians and if you disagree with this one you can do a walkout you can protest you can make your feelings hurt or you can choose to not work here and then daniel leck kind of did the same thing he said listen at spotify we're gonna put labels on it if you don't like joe rogan don't work here and then of course we know coinbase did it and toby from shopify did it and now you have twitter doing it and when you apologize and you start listening to this very vocal minority when they're upset and they want to cancel people or they want to de-platform people what do they do they double down you've shown that you're going to listen to them they're not doing it at coinbase anymore they're not going to do it at spotify anymore they're not doing it at netflix and apple acquiesced right they're like we don't like you know antonio's book chaos monkeys and he said these three things in an award-winning book that we find are, we're going to fire him.
I think at some point, Apple's going to have to say, you know what? Leave your feelings at work. And this is a company. Leave them at home. Thank you. This is why Elon is so dangerous to these people is because he won't be pushed around. The fact of the matter is that this whole woke mob thing, it's a paper tiger. They don't have the support of most of the population. It's a handful of very noisy voices on Twitter and social media who insist on having a monopoly on the right to shape all of our narratives. They want a monopoly on moral outrage. They want a monopoly on moral outrage. They want a monopoly.
But they also want a monopoly on the ability to basically to define what is acceptable and what the narrative on any topic is going to be. And all it takes is one strong person to stand up to the mob, as we saw Brian Armstrong do at Coinbase. And the mob dissipated. he took you know brian has to find another target they find another exactly so yeah elon doing this is a really big deal because again he cannot be pushed around and he is showing leadership here and all it will take to end this woke censorship is for other founders to stand tall the way that elon has and let's let's go into the nuance i don't think he'll care what um employees kind of gripe about i don't think he'll care what regulators gripe about and i don't think he'll care what other shareholders gripe about.
He'll talk about the long term opportunity, the philosophical alignment with mission, and and plow forward. And I think that that level of leadership is what separates some, you know, great businesses from others. But this is a very there were moments of de platforming that were earned by people like Alex Jones, who was saying that the, you know, families of Sandy Hook were false flags, and their children weren't murdered. There are, you know, Milo Yiannopoulos and some of these alt-right Nazi sympathizing people throwing up swat stickers, you know, people promoting violence or brigading on these services to attack people and to dox people.
Those people, those were just cancellations, deplatformings from YouTube. In your opinion? Well, I mean, anybody inciting violence, I think we would all agree should be deplatformed. Jason, look at how it's evolved. We start with isolated cases like in Alex Jones, like a Milo that nobody likes and nobody supports. The next thing you know, the president of the United States is being deplatformed. But again, that's supposedly based on him inciting a crowd. Then what's happening today? Now we have entire categories of opinion being banned. It starts with COVID. I agree. That's exactly my point. There were valid ones and now there is invalid.
I agree. 100% agree with you. Anyone who has a dissenting opinion on COVID gets banned. Now, anybody who has a dissenting opinion on climate change can be banned. There's a story this week on CNN where Pinterest of all... Look, Pinterest is a photo sharing site. I don't know. No one's talking about climate change on Pinterest. And yet. I was, but then I got. I mean, it just shows this censorship now is on autopilot. I mean, even sites where the conversation is not taking place are banning entire categories of thought and opinion because it disagrees with, you know, what the experts say. And J.
Cal, you could point out your Alex Jones case to make the case that deplatforming should be allowed. The problem is, as soon as you make that case, it's only a slight degree away from the next case, and then a slight degree away from the next case. And then fast forward three years, and you're banning entire topics of conversation that ultimately may end up being proven to be a topic of conversation we should have had. And if you look back, by the way, great movie, Woody Harrelson, The People vs. Larry Flint. Larry Flint was a pornographer. It was easy for everyone to chastise him. And for everyone to say, you know what, Let's go ahead and de-platform this guy back then and ban him and charge him by the government.
And at the end of the day, he fought for his rights for free speech. Now, all that being said, Larry Flint was publishing using his own printers and selling on the street in a very legally compliant way. There is a difference in having someone else's platform be the mechanism that you use to promote your voice. If they choose like Pinterest and Twitter and YouTube and Facebook and Google to change how their platform operates, Saks, I actually think that's a commercial decision. made by a private company, they should have the right to do that, but they're going to lose users over time. They're going to end up looking like idiots when they're wrong by banning certain topics that we should be having conversations about over time.
And I do think that there are other mechanisms for us to use the free and open internet. This is why I think the free and open internet is more important than anything to have conversations using other platforms. Absolutely. I mean, and I mean, I mean, hold on, I just want to respond to David since he did, you know, counter my point. I agree with you. I think it went overboard. And I think there are more reasonable solutions i think a time-based a ban would have been better for somebody like trump and maybe waiting to see what happens with the january 6 commission putting that aside i know it's very controversial um you know when you just look at what spotify did to our podcast i don't know if you've looked at us in spotify every other episode says covid19 information here i think this is one of the best things if people want to talk about ivermectin and it's an open science and freeberg you know more about it than any of us and people want to debate it why not link them to the most credible sources.
I think that's a great solution. I have a question. Yeah. Is there an oat milk tag on Spotify? Yes. Because if there is... Oat milk, oat milk, oat milk. Wait, when you listen to the All In Pod on Spotify, there's a tag that says there's COVID... COVID-19. Yeah, get COVID-19 information here. Yeah. Can I get to Freeberg's argument about these companies should be free to do it whatever they want? So I know that Freeberg... I want to make two points about this. First of all, I know Freeberg is sincere and genuine in that belief. However, most of the people making that argument are completely disingenuous about it because on the one hand, they say that these companies should be free to limit speech when they like the outcome of that censorship.
But meanwhile, in Congress, they're pushing six bills forward to regulate these companies as monopolies. So they don't believe that they should be free to do whatever they want. They believe that they're monopolies. And indeed, many of them are monopolies. And even the ones that aren't monopolies act the same as all the other ones. They act as a cartel to limit speech. So that's point number one is that nobody believes this argument that these companies should be free to do whatever they want. The second point is that, listen, the founding document of our country is the Declaration of Independence.
It says that all of us have rights. They're inalienable. That means they cannot be taken away, okay? And in the first couple hundred years of this country, it meant that those rights meant that the government couldn't take away your right to free speech. But now today, where does speech occur? It occurs on these giant social networks that are privately owned, they're owned by these large corporations. And the fact of the matter is, if they take away your right to free speech on these platforms, if they censor you, if they do not have a right to free speech in this country, that right needs to be protected.
The founding fathers did not anticipate that four people would be mitigating the majority of conversations online. It's, you know, like if you're if you're taken off, if you look what happened to Milo and Alex Jones, like they don't exist in the public sphere anymore right like they've been literally personed when these big tech companies all get together as a cartel to deprive you of your free speech rights you have been depersoned you've been digitally depersoned and they're not just doing it on speech they're also taking away your right to engage in payments in transactions to earn a living and unless we stop this now it'll keep going we have to address the giant elephant in the room huge uh which is trump uh i think a lot of this uh you know he hit its pinnacle when people were saying the the The sitting president of the United States could not be on Twitter.
That was, I think we all agree, ridiculous and absurd that the president who was duly elected couldn't have a Twitter account. But then with the January 6th and the inciting of the violence and all the stuff that's coming out, and obviously we'll see where that all winds up. I'm curious what everybody thinks here about should Trump or is Trump being put back and reinstated on Facebook or Twitter? And it's supposed to be a lifetime ban on Twitter. But if corporate governance changes and people lobby for that, do we think that there is any kind of situation where Trump has his Twitter handle or Facebook accounts reinstated?
And should he have them reinstated? I think, Jason, what you suggested is probably the most reasonable thing, which was there is a time-based penalty. You know, we're getting through, we're probably, what, a third or two-thirds of the way through the January 6th stuff. So that's going to come and go. And I think all roads will probably lead to a conclusion that after three years, it's probably okay to let this guy back and be able to tweet. I mean, it's not, this is not, you know, controversial stuff at this point. You know that the current thing is moving on from Ukraine when the topic all of a sudden is January 6 all over again and Trump, which it is on MSNBC.
It's all January 6 all the time again. So, listen, I mean, this is not a justification for the widespread censorship that we've seen. Like I mentioned, we've gone so far beyond isolated cases. Now it's entire categories of thought. And this has to be stopped. Well, what's your feeling on Trump? Should he be reinstated? If you were running Twitter, would you have done a time-based? If you don't like Trump, just don't follow him. I mean, but but frankly, it's it's listen, I don't miss the tweets at all. My thoughts. I don't miss the tweets at all. I really don't. They were damaging your party. That's how you felt.
My thoughts have evolved. Before, when he first got banned, I was really supportive of it. And there was part of me which was just afraid that he would get reelected, etc, etc. Now, come two years later, and to see all of the stuff and the escalation of deplatforming, I think the problem is exactly what you guys have just talked about, which is the person that does it today points to the person that does it yesterday, who points to the person that did it the day before as the justification. And so even though we don't want to draw a straight line between an Alex Jones and a Trump and climate change, unfortunately, there is this line.
And so in general, now, a much more free speech, because I think it's much more fragile than I thought it was before. So your opinion has evolved and intelligent people should respond to new data. I appreciate that. And I was a person that, you know, as David said, was a little disingenuous in the sense that I kind of was for free speech as long as it was stuff that I agreed with. But two years later, I'm much more on David's original camp now, which is we just need to establish this as a pillar of society, and not deviate and find credible voices on both sides. and then algorithmically and through people power, meaning through crowd, you know, wisdom of the crowds type stuff, help people figure out what is truthful and how much truth there is, because that's a tractable problem.
But the minute you start canceling stuff, today, as I sit in 2022, what I would tell you is I think it's very, very bad, because it's going in a really bad place. Freber, what are your thoughts on Trump specifically? Because it does seem like that's a part of the undercurrent here of you know he's going to be coming back possibly going to be running again and january 6th is considering he's got the truth social network download the app listen to what he's got to say it's rocking and rolling over there on the the truth app i heard they took it down like it wasn't even working right the uh the new thing he built but what is that what is that smack trading at was it at 20 billion or something still doing well um but look they had, you know, obviously a reaction, a market driven reaction to the fact that he was taken off Twitter and he said, I'm going to go make an alternative.
And that's, you know, certainly proving to be technically difficult, but as we all know, it's not technically impossible. He's just got probably the wrong people working on it. But if they wanted to have an alternative platform for hearing that voice, you know, have at it. I don't know what else to say. I mean, it's Twitter's decision. They're, they're curating their audience. All these guys want to be free speech advocates, but at the end of the day they're all editorializing and that's just the world we found ourselves in i hope elon takes a sledgehammer to that yeah i mean it's exactly what shama said is they're all they all believe in free speech and free markets when it produces the outcome they like but when the outcome is not what they like all of a sudden they're like whoa these companies are monopolies well and here's another opportunity if you're not libertarian and believe in like you know free speech and you know constitution like you could buy shares you could lead a group start a dow start a hedge fund whatever build a block to buy a bunch of shares and then you can get a board seat on twitter and you can have this debate on the board of twitter and it's absolutely right you are absolutely right and you can see by the way you know small hedge funds with small amounts of capital like engine number one you know they were able to go up against it exxon and beat them so to your point jason for the people that actually want to censor more if they can organize the capital they absolutely have the right to do that and i and i think that they if they if they're able to do it they should win that's that's that's what mike solano was kind of getting at it's like look if you don't like if you don't like the the free speech that's happening on twitter go create your own social network because that's what they were saying before buy the shares and have influence that's how corporations work the shares are the votes yeah friedberg update us on you know the Ukraine is in month two now.
I'm sorry. Ukraine is in month two. Sorry for putting the thumb before it. It's a tough habit to break. Freeberg, tell us the second order, third order effects of fertilizer and food at this point. We've had this back and forth. And now I think the world is starting to realize, hey, Freeberg was right. These downstream effects are going to be significant. I asked you a question about these, which is, can the world not mobilize? if these are about 1% of the calories, 20 or 30% of the calories in a certain country, could the world not mobilize to find other caloric sources, rice, fish, soybeans, whatever, or is our system so fragile that we can't rally around sending food to anywhere on the planet, despite the fact that we can fly anywhere and go on vacation for two weeks anywhere on the planet?
No, the food system is complex and efficient, but it does not have strong redundancy or malleability. So take for example, you know, how do you get flour? You get flour in your food from a food company that bought the flour from a miller. There are mills around the world that process wheat into flour. You can't take that same mill and process corn into flour. There's different technology, different equipment that's used. Same with soybeans and so on. So when you look at how the food supply chain is constructed, you know, there's a local point of consumption, which is a store, then there's a food processor, and you work your way kind of up the supply chain.
And there's a certain input that's required to make the output that people consume. And so calories, while they might be fungible, practically speaking, or philosophically, or fundamentally speaking, they're not necessarily fungible, practically speaking, on the ground, when you actually try and plug in, let's say, soybeans into the milling supply chain. to make the pasta or the bread that everyone consumes in Tunisia, it's not going to work. And the same is true with rice. And then the more important dynamic force that's underway is that these markets for food and commodities globally are not controlled by government.
They're controlled by private businesses. And there's a market for these products. And so what happens is, as the food supply chain threat hit, countries like China and others started to stockpile. They started to buy lots and lots of supply, drive up their stocks and their reserves, you know, for fear of the famine that's about to hit us in about nine months. And when they did that, there was now less food available to Tunisia, to Eritrea, to Egypt, and so on. And so we're starting to see the effect of that dislocation, driving dynamic market forces where certain buyers stock up, and then the folks that can't afford to step in, not being able to acquire product and being left.
So not only do we have a local production differential that makes it hard to have all calories be fungible, we're also seeing this dynamic where there's a bifurcation where the haves have more and the have nots have less. And that's going to really make this famine kind of hit home in a really, really sad way in the months to come. We're already seeing, as I mentioned two weeks ago, yeah, as I mentioned a few weeks ago, the fertilizer problem driving acreage down. So the USDA farm report comes out they survey farmers and figure out how much they're going to plant every year and they just downgraded the number of corn acres that are going to get planted this year which is happening starting this month from 93 million acres to 89 million that doesn't sound like a lot but four million acres yeah four million acres coming out of production of corn in the u.
s is an incredible amount of calories that are not going to be planted to corn and so that has all these downstream effects and again this this crop doesn't come to harvest till you know september October, then it's going to get processed and it turns into food. So by the time the effect of this decision making hit the marketplace, the availability of calories and the stockpiling that's going on, it's like, boom, some countries are going to be, you know, they're going to have a limited budget, they're only going to be able to access so much food, and they can't access any. And other countries are going to be fine.
The United States is going to be fine. Western Europe will be fine. China will be fine. Sri Lanka is going to be a mess. Northern and Eastern Africa is going to be a mess. I mean, there's like places around the world that we are going to have to scramble. I don't have a real easy answer. There's no simple plug and play here. It's going to be a really complex set of problems that are going to need to be solved. Well, Sri Lanka does grow a lot of its own food. So they may be okay, because they're a net importer, right? I mean, they're pretty big net importer. So they make a lot of food, but they rely on imports a lot for calories there.
So yeah, I mean, that's the case with a lot of places around the world. A lot of people think oh we have farmers but most countries you know particularly in the developing world are net importers they they rely on third-party supplies of food so sure but but a lot of what you're talking about though are not um they're they're processed foods that come into the country sax anything to add here well i mean i think that the ukraine war is kind of entering a chronic phase i mean this is sort of entering a new phase the first phase you'd have to say that the Ukrainians won. Russia wanted to topple Zelensky's regime, maybe take Kiev.
They obviously failed in that. Now, we're in this phase where the fighting is over in the Donbass. It's basically the civil war that's been going on there since 2014. And really, that's what it's now about. Zelensky has acknowledged that Ukraine will not be part of NATO. So, that issue is kind of off the table. And so, what they're really fighting over now is the status of these disputed territories in Eastern Ukraine. And I think it's going to go on for a long time. That's what General Milley testified, it could go on for years. I think it's going to become a sort of permanent feature in the background of Biden's presidency.
And I mean, I think the good news is that hopefully the World War III aspect is off the table. It seems like the calls for us to impose a no-fly zone or to put boots on the ground, which you were hearing a lot of a few weeks ago. Seems like that's off the table. So now it's just going to be a protracted, I think, civil war going on in the Donbass with between Ukraine and Russia and their proxies. Which would mean, Sachs, correct me if I'm wrong, that Putin will be hobbled forever. They're not going to be a world power. And his power is going to deprecate because he's going to be busy fighting this non-winnable war for some period of time, which is in a way saying Biden did it perfectly and checkmated him.
I'm saying that's going to be your assessment. If this actually does go down this way, that there's like a civil war going on and Putin is crippled, that would be checkmate or no? I think that clearly the State Department's strategy here is to make Putin bleed in eastern Ukraine and to protract this thing and make it go on as long as possible. I think that's a risky strategy because this thing could always spin out of control. It's risky, but could it be effective? Is there a chance it could be effective? Well, I mean, if the goal is to bleed Putin, yes, it could be effective bleeding Putin. However, I don't know that that needed to be the key geostrategic objective of the United States right now.
I don't know. I don't know because look, China is our main threat. China is a peer competitor to the United States. Russia is not. Our economy is 15 times bigger than Russia's. China's economy is about the same size as ours. That is a real threat. So, you know, there are costs to us as well. There are clearly costs to Putin of this, but there are huge costs to us as well. Freebird described the risk to the supply chain. We've had to now spend a lot more money building up the defense in Europe. We're going to be pinned down in Europe. We should really be moving some of those resources from Europe to East Asia.
I mean, that's really where the pivot to Asia is what we thought we were supposed to be doing until quite recently. Now we're going to be bogged down there. And there's still risks of inflation and recession in the US. And I think if we are in a recession later this year, I think a lot of people in the US will be asking, what was this all for? And if you go read my article that just came out yesterday, that was based on my speech, it was published in the American Conservative. Look, this war was easily avoidable. I mean, the State Department could have avoided this war very easily i thought you're i listened to your speech i thought your points that you were very clear on hey putin started this he is the aggressor it's his responsibility but you know we do need to think about our foreign policy as a country and regime change is probably not a winning strategy for us although in this case it might it seems like it's a possibility now so who knows uh i don't i don't think we're gonna get regime change but if we do there's no reason to believe that we're gonna get something much better in every case where we push for regime change, we've actually gotten the same or worse.
So yeah, I don't think that should be our objective. You know, I look, I think we have a bunch of bad options. Now that the war's already started, the best option would have been to avoid this war in the first place. And if this thing drags on for years, and the US economy tips into recession, people will look back and say, why didn't Joe Biden State Department in the year 2021 do a much more effective job preventing this war let me ask let me ask this follow-up question as we wrap here um chamath uh i've been thinking about what what should a strategic objective be for america and the number one strategic objective i could think of was uh or one of the top ones would be to build a strong relationship with india which obviously uh you know it has an adversarial relationship with china already on the border of Pakistan, and then obviously, you know, has relations with Russia.
What would be on the top of each of your lists, Saks and Chamath, Chamath, you go first, on priority here, if we're thinking fresh, looking at the world, with China in retreat, sort of disengaging from the West, with Russia on their heels, what could the United States and the West do as a preemptive measure to really solidify democracy and, you know, the world order, a peaceful world order? I'll answer it slightly differently, which is we need to put ourselves in a position to not be dependent on any country. Because then we can actually dictate what we think the right approach and solution is from first principles and have the courage to stick it through to get to the other side of it.
So there are really two things we need to do. The first, which we've kind of perverted unnecessarily is energy independence. And we've allowed too many people to conflate and muddy the water on what energy independence means. You know, nobody's, nobody was ever advocating for coal. But you know, the amount of coal that we could have burned as a bridge fuel to LNG, which could have been a bridge fuel to things like nuclear and wind and solar. that path was pretty clear, but we got in our own way. We have to get out of our own way. Okay. So energy independence, I think beyond anything else, strategic, probably an order of magnet, it is the most important thing.
And then secondarily, there are certain areas for the future of those future economies, where we need to have complete capability and know how. And the most important ones there are the specialty chemicals that we need, specialty chemicals that we need to basically support climate change writ large to support battery production writ large, and then semiconductors. Get those two things completely under US control, on top of energy independence, and honestly, we would be a dominant world power for the next 200 years on our terms. So the road to resiliency. Sachs, you're now the Secretary of State, what are your key priorities?
The US grand strategy has always been to prevent the rise of a pure competitor who can dominate their region and then challenge us for global hegemony. There's only one country in the world that can do that right now to us, which is China. So the pivot to Asia, as Obama said, was fundamentally correct, but we have not followed through and executed it. And now our attention is distracted and bogged down by what's happening in Europe. I would seek and negotiated settlement to this war. Now that the Zelensky government has survived, Putin has been unable to take Western Ukraine. And furthermore, that Zelensky has given up being part of NATO.
The only thing left is this fight in the Donbass. There's an agreement already on the table called the Minsk Accords that can allow us to settle that. Meanwhile, pivoting to Asia. Wrap it up. Meanwhile, pivot to Asia, create a strong alliance of countries in East Asia who are threatened by China. We already are friends with many of them. You've got Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, you've got Vietnam. Create a balancing alliance of those countries to prevent China from rising to the point where it can threaten us for global hegemony. That should be our main priority geopolitically. Great. All right, there you have it, folks.
For the Rain Man, David Sachs, the dictator, Jamath Palihapitiya, and the Sultan of Science, David Freeberg. I'm your boy, J. Cow, and we will see you all in Miami, May 15th, 16th, and 17th. Love you, boys. Bye-bye. Love you, besties. Bye-bye. Bye-bye. We'll let your winners ride. Rain Man, David Sachs. And instead, we open-source it to the fans, and they've just gone crazy with it. Love you, Wesley. I'm queen of kinwaf. I'm going home, baby. What, what are winners why? What are winners why? Besties are gone. That's my dog taking a notice in your driveway. Sex. Oh, man. My habbitasher will meet me at what it's like.
We should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy because they're all just useless. It's like this sexual tension that they just need to release somehow. Wet your feet Wet your feet We need to get Merchies are back I'm going all in I'm going all in