0:00 Bestie intros
1:45 First principle politics, analyzing each party's cynicism
48:07 Chaos in China: bank protests, housing protests, slowing economic and population growth, future outlook
1:09:21 Automation and the impact of the information economy
1:16:31 BlackRock loses $1.7T of investor money during H1 2021, state of private and public markets
1:36:36 Amazon acquires One Medical
Follow the besties:
https://twitter.com/DavidSacks
Follow the pod:
https://twitter.com/theallinpod
https://linktr.ee/allinpodcast
Intro Music Credit:
https://twitter.com/yung_spielburg
Intro Video Credit:
https://twitter.com/TheZachEffect
Referenced in the show:
https://twitter.com/pelositracker_/status/1549535561718714368
https://www.politico.com/news/2022/07/20/biden-pelosi-trip-taiwan-china-military-00047031
https://www.tesla.com/blog/tesla-repays-department-energy-loan-nine-years-early
https://housestockwatcher.com/summary_by_rep/Hon.%20Nancy%20Pelosi
https://www.thedailybeast.com/democrats-quietly-try-to-jam-nancy-pelosi-on-stock-trading-ban
https://poll.qu.edu/poll-release?releaseid=3852
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/19/opinion/democrats-far-right-midterms.html
https://twitter.com/micsolana/status/1549868945640914951
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/18/spanish-language-media-disinformation/
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/19/world/asia/china-bank-scandal-protest.html
https://twitter.com/WallStreetSilv/status/1549790086656581640
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/01/17/world/asia/china-population-crisis.html
https://www.ft.com/content/91441aca-1665-4660-843f-9cf7222becff
https://datacommons.org/place/country/CHN
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-06-22/china-housing-market-slowdown-drags-economy
https://www.wsj.com/articles/chinas-economic-distress-deepens-as-lockdowns-drag-on-11652703162
https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20220531-why-chinas-population-is-shrinking
https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/sp.dyn.tfrt.in?locations=cn
https://www.thinkadvisor.com/2022/07/20/how-blackrock-lost-1-7t-of-clients-money/
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/21/business/amazon-one-medical-deal.html
No summary for this episode yet.
two days ago oh here we go in the piazzetta i got into a fight you got into a fight i got into a fight like a physical altercation the physical altercation really this chick shows up wearing a white wife beater talking all kinds of shit and i said listen lady you zip it and she just kept jawing and jawing and here she is again she's back for more and so i was like listen have you ever seen have you ever seen a onesie wife Peter look at that little sweetie aww and you just sit there and then you just sit there and then look there's your cold open everybody that's the good stuff right there say hi to everybody I know I'm not a beagle I know I'm not a beagle but I'm even better I have my own thoughts Sax what you're seeing here is called affection between a parent and a child just let me know when it's over just let me know when it's over You're the worst human being in the world.
I don't need to watch Jamal boost his Q rating by using his kids as props, okay? Oh, Freeberg, where's your puppy that you saved for being tortured with Kim Kardashian's lip gloss? Nick, we got to get this guy in because he hasn't been in the show in a while. There he is. There he is. Oh, Monty. Oh, your belly rub. Get the props out of the shot. Sacks, what's up with J.D. Vance in Ohio? Is he going to pull this thing off or is he getting beat up? I read an article about him getting beat up with the Peter Thiel connection being He got physically beat up? No, no, no. Like in the polls. No, no, no, no.
No, I think JD should win. He's going to win, right? Yeah, I think so. And what about Blake Masters? These are the two guys that TL is backing. Should we start the show? We kind of did, yeah. Can I just ask you a question? If any of us entered porn, wouldn't one of our names be Blake Masters? Like, it's just, wouldn't it be on the list? Like, doesn't it sound like a great... Now you can't see it. Isn't it a great name for porn? It's a great name, Blake Masters. It's a great name. and and jd steel i'm sorry vance yeah go ahead explain what's going on with this uh would you would you accuse him of without any evidence i'm not using anybody of anything i'm just saying tell us about your mentoring candidates go ahead well so jd's already won the primaries and i expect he will win i mean it's gonna be i think a red wave in november and ohio is a pretty red state these days Blake still has to win the primary in Arizona.
That's a little bit more of a toss-up, but I think he'll do well. All right. Well, I had a follow-up question, but I'm not allowed to mention the T word. So let's just get started. Why is it such a big deal that Peter supports candidates? You got all these crazy left-wing radicals. No, no. I think it's interesting. Soros gives unlimited amounts of money to crazy progressives like Gascon in LA and a zillion others. I mean, why is it such an obsession that we have to focus on who Peter supports? No, no. I just think it's fascinating that he— articulated his rationale for supporting these candidates and his objective for, you know, changing government in a way that he thinks would benefit the country.
And Peter's been generally right. What is the thesis, Ray Berg? I think part of if you watch his speech from the RNC during the last Trump cycle, I think he did a good job kind of articulating that there's a lot of inefficiencies in government and there's a lot of call it accumulated fat. And we need someone to go in and we need people to go in and really cut this up because so much of politics is driven by what else I'm going to give you, not about what I'm going to fix that's already being spent in an inefficient way. And as a result, we see debt climb, we see taxes climb, we see efficiency continue to decline of every dollar invested by the government.
And I think that's a really important thesis to see someone actually try and execute against because very few people are in the position that he's in to actually be able to like make that sort of statement. Everyone wants something more from their government versus trying to fix the government. I think his views are more extremely than that. I think his views are more that orthodoxy is ruining in America. And so you need forms of heterodoxy to basically reset the status quo. And I think that's what he believes more than what you just said. I think that you need a wholesale reset. And in order to have a wholesale reset, you need to have these very disruptive candidates that basically start to change the norms.
I mean, if you think about what Trump did in one election cycle, is he's completely sucked an entire cohort of people, Hispanics, and, you know, moderates, and now, you know, a lot of immigrants towards the right, because the Democrats have vacated all of that space in having this massive Trump derangement syndrome and tacking extremely to the left. And even if Peter, we'll never know. Believed in Trump or didn't believe in Trump, it didn't matter. But the process of him getting that candidate elected over the long arc of history may actually serve to pull America back to the center. Pretty good outcome.
Yeah. And look, the reason why I support J.D. and Blake, for that matter, is they represent this more populist, working class wing of the Republican Party. And they're dragging the Republican Party in a more working class direction. I think that's the future of the party. I think that's the opportunity for the party. To Chamaa's point, The Democrats have ceded all the sort of this working class territory by becoming this elite progressive party. And the face of the party right now, the Democratic Party, is Paul Pelosi. You know, let's talk about this. It's blatant and out in the open. He's trading on chip stocks like NVIDIA and Intel and so forth.
Like the week before, the House is going to vote on a $52 billion subsidy for chip companies. No, no, no. Be more precise. the week before his wife decides when critical legislation goes to the floor of the house to be voted upon. So you have the speaker of the house, who's the third most important person in government, introducing legislation on her timetable. Her husband trades in those specific equities days and maybe even the same day of that. They make three times her annual salary just in one day. And then she and her husband decide to then fly, not asked by the United States government or the State Department, to Taiwan to then talk about God knows what, which would have created an international uproar.
The Biden administration and Tony Blinken had to basically call her and say, stand down. You should not go. We are not asking you to go. It is not on the United States agenda for you to go. And all that would have happened is an entire process and loop where she controls the legislative agenda, her husband controls their private stock account, and he traffics in the names. And then they go to Taiwan to whip up the Fuhrer, which would have actually positively impacted those same names even more. It's inexcusable, that kind of behavior. I mean, after 40 years, she is so past the line and she doesn't realize it.
And by the way, sorry, let me just wait, hold on. And then on top of that, Jason, the mainstream media doesn't say shit. Now, by the way, I'm not a Trump supporter. I think he's a complete goofball. But if Trump had tried to pull this stuff in 2016 or 2017 or 2018, could you imagine how much media coverage there would be and today how much of that is covered by the mainstream media zero was it mentioned on msnbc nope was it mentioned in any of the press nope let me just set the stage so people don't know what we're talking about so uh on tuesday the senate advanced a slimmed down version of the original chips bill if you don't know what that is it's basically a bill that's going to provide 52 billion dollars in subsidies to move chip manufacturing here to the united states something we really need to do.
It's a bipartisan bill. Everybody kind of agrees on this. But this is being kind of stuck in committee for a little bit. It comes a year after the Senate first approved the $250 billion bill to reinforce US chip making to compete with China. The reason why this is strategically important is because we have a huge chip dependency on Taiwan, which is under threat from China. So if chips are the new oil, you know, Taiwan is the new Middle East or the new Persian Gulf. And it is a very dangerous situation for us to be completely dependent on Taiwan. Well, not completely, but like for over half our chips.
So on shoring, advanced chip manufacturing makes sense. But I think this is an example of how you start with a legitimate objective in Washington. And very rapidly, it turns into corporate welfare and graft by politicians. I mean, yeah, it's gross. Yeah. I mean, just because we need to onshore manufacturing doesn't mean that you give Intel and NVIDIA giant handouts. And then you got Paul Pelosi making millions trading NVIDIA options. And this is something that is happening. What would you have done, Sachs? To support on-shoring of semiconductor manufacturing, who would you give the money to and how would it be kind of dolled out and what would the terms of it be?
I don't know that you just give these companies money. I mean, I think maybe what you do is you give them tax breaks or various kinds of breaks, but I don't like that. They need capital to support that investment because, you know, if you look at the kind of ROIC on these companies, I haven't looked, but I'm guessing they're in the high teens or something, mid to high teens. And they're not going to be able to invest in some newfangled, you know, fab project that may or may not actually have customers at the end of the day. Their board would never approve that on an independent basis. They need capital.
ROIC, Freeberg? Return on invested capital. So if you're a big industrial business, you know, one of the key metrics that your shareholders look at is the ultimate kind of profits that are generated from a big investment you might make. And so, you know, you kind of look at that over time, you look at the invested money over time and the cash in returned over time, and you come up with this metric. And so it's a key metric for particularly capital intensive businesses. And so a business like Intel or Nvidia, I would imagine is going to have a pretty tough time selling their board on some speculative on shoring fab project, that there really does need to be capital and acceleration of capital who who feeds you this bullshit propaganda intel in 2020 approved a share purchase plan where these guys had a hold of 110 billion dollars and have spent all of it except for 7.
2 billion they have 6 billion left on the balance sheet i get it but they're not going to put that money at risk right like like chumath imagine you're on the board of intel and they're like so the government okay so basically hold on but i make a ton of money yeah this is where it it comes from, right? I make a ton of money. I have no better ideas of how to do it, including theoretically building a chip factory. So I'm going to go to the government for a handout. Meanwhile, I'm going to take all the money that I had, which I could have used to fund this thing. And I'm going to give it away to people who I don't know what they're going to do with it.
I would reframe it. I would say that the government wants to see our industry onshore semiconductor manufacturing. And they are going to the companies, not the companies going to the government, they're saying, we want you to onshore semiconductor manufacturing, do that for us now. Like in World War Two, we went to the automobile manufacturers and said the government said, we want you to make airplanes. Here's a bunch of money, make airplanes. And that's the question is, but who else would you give that money to besides the two best chip makers in the world? David's right. If you just give us a CapEx subsidy, that's a one time effect that helps you in a moment.
It doesn't help your business. Any reasonable investor who can actually use a simple calculator sees through that nonsense. So what David's right is if you had given them sustained tax breaks for being able to build the business line that then supplies things for the duration, you know, tens of years, you're absolutely right. Investors would laud it. It would make a ton of sense. They would be over earning over a long enough period of time where people would have to bake that into their cash flow estimates, where when you discounted it back, it would make the enterprise of Intel and Nvidia worth more.
And then people would then want to own that stock more. Giving a CapEx subsidy is a meaningless way in which you basically hand out good money to organizations who have otherwise misallocated the money that they've already had. Yeah, there's a much simpler solution to Sachs' point of like, how do you do this? And Giving free money is not the way to do it. The best way to do is to give an incredibly low interest rate loan, like a 30, 40, 50 year loan, that maybe has some warrants in it, just like a, you know, a Silicon Valley Bank or a Comerica might give in a venture debt loan, where the government actually could make money from this.
And then you incent them with something that is just too good not to take a 50 year loan of $5 billion to build factories, you have to use it for that. So it's use it or lose it. And then you slowly pay the government back. And then maybe we get some warrants in intel or whoever we give the money to this is something that obama did with solandra solyndra which didn't work out but he also did it with tesla and tesla paid all that money back early so these loans that the department of energy did really did um and you got to give obama a lot of credit for this it really did help drive even though it wasn't perfect by the way when it did drive a lot of ev adoption it did really help tesla become the company it is today Sorry, let me just respond because, you know, I don't know how much we've we've gone through the details of the bill, but there are several components to this bill, including and I just want to highlight if I'm on the board of Intel, I'm not going to make a 10 billion dollar fab investment because, you know, there's there may or may not be profits down the road to justify that size of an investment.
So if the government comes along and says, we will support, we will cover X percent of that investment, I can take on more risk and I'm more willing to make that investment. And theoretically, I can afford to pay people a higher wage or a higher salary because I now have more capital freed up to support to do that. And so there is an effect that arises by having the government come in, put some money into these projects, accelerate their outcomes, and it gives the business more freedom. Should it be, Freeberg, free money or in the form of a loan? So what should the financial device be, I think, is the question that you ask Sachs, if I'm interpreting correctly.
Yeah, I'm not sure that the loan, because the loan doesn't resolve the fact that they're having to put up money, right? And so they're not necessarily going to make this on-shoring investment. The rational capitalist decision is to offshore manufacturing for Intel. It is irrational for them from a business perspective, from a board perspective, from a fiduciary perspective, to on-shore manufacturing. So the reason they're going to do it is not because they're getting a loan where the interest rate is low, that doesn't really solve the problem. It's the government saying we're going to put a $10 billion facility, we want you to build it and manage it for us.
And that's effectively what's happening. And now by building this $10 billion facility, we've created security for the rest of the US industry, it's worth it to the government to put that money up and create security for our economy. No, it won't. Why wouldn't it create security if we if we have more onshoring of chips? I'll say one more thing. There's also an investment tax credit built into this bill sacks which does provide over time a bunch of incentives to continue to support and drive the on-shoring work that's proposed in the bill if you want the united states point of personal privilege can i request that chamath add just one button to his shirt yeah is it too distracting for you first i had to watch jason do the gun show now i gotta watch chamath show us your guns come on pull up that sleeve and show us what you let's move on let's move on i want to say one more thing about the pelosi stuff so here's the data i don't know if you guys have looked at the full history of the pelosi trading data here's the link this is all the trading that's happened over the last couple years so and um over the past year he has bought nvidia four different times each time in the same kind of volume range so the timing certainly may appear suspect and it's certainly a terrible kind of thing to see.
He's also bought Apple in the last month, Microsoft, sorry, he sold Apple, he bought Microsoft. He bought Alliance Bernstein earlier in the year, he's made a few trades this year. But Nvidia, he's actually bought on four different occasions over the past 12 months. For whatever that's worth, right? I'm not not trying to defend it. But I think we should be intellectually honest about the fact that this guy, you know, does take points of view in certain companies, he trades in a handful of companies. Are we willing to be intellectually honest enough to think that a husband talks to his wife and vice versa?
Yeah. Or does that not happen anymore? Depends on the husband and wife, but yeah. I think this is blatant and out in the open. I mean, it looks really, at a minimum, the appearance is of graft and corruption. Yeah. The appearance of impropriety is impropriety. They shouldn't be allowed to trade. They should have to put their stuff into blind trusts, or they should maybe trade once a year and they should have to announce their trades before the trades happen hey here's what i'm planning on doing just like a ceo is planning on doing this stuff it's ridiculous that they can do this and why doesn't the mainstream media cover this they have but jason do you think they think that if trump if this had happened during trump we it would have a lot more coverage than this pelosi you remember a lot of coverage on trump it really doesn't get covered i mean if you just search for it today you'll see basically the only media outlets covering it are like fox news and then uh zero hedge you know that's it i mean that's how i found out about it is like the zero hedge tweets about it me too so daily beast you know headline you can go seven hours ago dems quietly tried to jam pelosi on stock trading ban but if you're asking me you ask me a question chamath is the uh media largely biased against trump and gives a free pass to the dems yes i would say that that is the trend yes i think that is intellectually honest of you well no i i mean i think the media is bankrupt they're just going for clicks and i think, you know, we've talked about this before, they saw Trump as an existential risk, and they just did whatever it took to get him out of office, even putting up Biden as a candidate.
But in doing so, they completely burned all of their credibility. They lost a lot of credibility. And now the Dems are starting to become increasingly detached and out of touch and maybe hated. But then the result is that the mainstream media is just no longer trusted. The media and the Democratic Party both have the same problem, which is they suffer from what the democratic political scientist Roy Tuchera has called professional class hegemony. I mean, they are populated by college graduates with degrees who basically have this very elitist progressive agenda. And that is what is causing the democratic, the working class to defect from the democratic party, their historical base in droves.
Look at Hispanics. Well, first of all, if you go to the latest Biden polling numbers, he's down to 31% approval, 60% disapprove. Okay, so the trends is getting worse there. But you look at Hispanics, it's down to 19% approval, 70% disapproval. It's an even more intense version of the same problem. You had Myra Flores get elected in that Texas seat. This is a district that went, it's basically a predominantly Mexican-American district. They went for Biden by 18 points just two years ago, and now they're voting for her by over 10 points. So, you're Republicans winning that seat for the first time.
So, you have these huge defections. Now, why is that happening? Because the Democrats are appealing to the donor class on issues like border, on issues like crime, and on issues like CRT in schools. I mean, you know, the working class people in this country, they don't want open borders. They want crime to be prosecuted and cracked down on. And they do not want an ideological education for their kids. Okay. It's very simple. But that basically is why the Democratic Party is losing votes. Now, let me give you a couple other examples of the Democrats cynically appealing to this sort of donor class.
So recently, there's an article about the Democrats have spent $44 million this election cycle basically running ads in favor of the crazy MAGA candidate in primaries. There's been a bunch of reports of this where in competitive Republican primaries, the Democrats will actually spend money on behalf of the sort of the more perceived crazy Republican, the MAGA candidate. The crazy Trump, the MAGA candidate. The election denier and so forth. Yeah. Because of the perception that they'll be easier to beat in the general. But I think this is a case of be careful what you wish for because if we have a red wave in November, you're going to end up with more of these candidates basically winning.
So it's a very cynical strategy. The other example I think of a very cynical strategy is you saw there was a vote in the House this past week on gay marriage. And the House voted to repeal DOMA, the Defense of Marriage Act, in support, basically codify Obergefell, right, the Supreme Court's decision on gay marriage. Something like, you know, 60 Republicans voted for it. Look, I would have liked to have seen more Republicans vote for this. I think it should be like, you know, majority of the Republican Party should be voting for this. But the point is that is there any intention of the Democrats to bring this up in the Senate and pass it and codify Obergefell when they have a chance?
I think the answer is no. Why? Because the Democrats would rather fundraise off this issue. The same thing was true about Roe. The Democrats had supermajorities in the Senate under Obama. They could have codified Roe. They never took the chance. Why? Because they would rather fundraise off this issue from progressive elites, the donor class in California and New York. So this is why they're not going to codify. You really think that's the case? Absolutely. Obama said it on the record. Obama was asked, why will you not? He campaigned on codifying Roe v. Wade. And then very quickly into it, he was asked when he had the supermajority and built the House and the Senate, will you act on Roe v.
Wade? He goes, no, it is not a priority anymore. That's a quote. It absolutely could have been codified, just like a Birchfeld could be codified tomorrow. Look, there are 10 Republican votes. There are 10 Republican votes at least for this in the Senate. You have a filibuster-proof supermajority in the Senate who would support this. The same Republicans who supported the gun restriction bill that Biden just signed and that supported the infrastructure bill. You think they could codify abortion rights in this country right now if they wanted to? No, no, no, no, no. That moment has passed. That moment's passed.
I'm not saying- Republicans would never give women the right- No, no, no. Look, there's not a supermajority in the Senate anymore for codifying Roe. There is a supermajority right now for codifying Obergefell. They could do that right now. And they're not. Chamath, you've been a donor to the Democratic Party. Do you believe that- Millions. Do you believe that the abortion issue drove you and others to put more money in and that maybe not? No, because the leadership of the Democratic Party focused on Trump in the last big cycle. It was all Trump, Trump, Trump, Trump, Trump. Do I think that more grassroots fundraising focuses on that or gun rights or abortion?
Do you think what Zach is saying is true? That they actually held off on trying to codify Roe so that they could continue to support that? I'm just going to give you the quote because there's no opinion needed. OK, April 29th of 2009, President Barack Obama says on Wednesday, he favored abortion rights for women, but that passing a law guaranteeing these rights were not his top priority. I believe that women should have the right to choose. Obama told a new conference marking his first 100 days in office again when he had super majorities in both the House and the Senate. But I think that the most important thing we can do to tamp down some of the anger surrounding this issue is to focus on those areas we can agree on.
So you make a promise, you get into the seat of power, you have the decision on what your legislative agenda should be. And he made that calculation. And David is right, sadly, that it was in a moment where we had a clear line of sight to codifying many of these rights. yeah but the question that's not the question that freeberg is asking he's saying do you think that they specifically did this to keep it as an open issue to raise money off it i don't think that's believable oh yeah absolutely no way no way absolutely if you want to talk about cynicism sacks the truly cynical move was you know trump saying i am going to get this evangelical vote to win the primaries to get those 20 who want to take away the right for women to have an abortion and I'm going to stack the Supreme Court to actually achieve that goal.
That's the most cynical of all of this political stuff. Okay, let's define terms. If you want to go political and cynical. Hold on a second, hold on a second. Let's define terms. So you may be opposed to what Trump did, but that wasn't cynical. He stated what he was going to do when he ran for office, and then he did it. He lived up to his promise. Yeah, but somebody who did not believe in that. He did not believe in that. He did it specifically to get those votes. We all know he didn't believe in it. We all know he believes in a women's right to choose. jason he he created a platform to get elected yes that's what i'm saying that cynicism was elected he executed on that platform i think what david sachs is saying is obama had a platform to get him elected and when obama chose had to choice he chose to not execute on the platform and that is also true and all i'm just saying is we owe it to ourselves to be intellectually honest about what happened that is what happened okay both of these two guys made claims hold on one second both of these two guys made claims acting in your own self-interest i understand please i want this on the record both of these two guys made claims to become president it turns out that trump actually did execute on most of his claims as abhorrent as they were to some yeah and obama on some of the most important issues of our time did not look what trump did was just simple coalition politics he thought it was important to win the religious right he basically appealed to them he said that if you vote for me i will nominate these judges he doesn't office he delivered he delivered he didn't believe in it himself right so that's what i'm talking about at a certain point doesn't matter that's not cynical people should have for sure have principles okay look so i know it doesn't matter to you that he doesn't have principles but it matters to me that people have okay but jason what does it mean to have the principle of saying that he's going to he's going to pass and codify roe v wade and not do it what is that then i think he well listen i i the quote you gave doesn't give why he didn't do it.
He didn't make it a priority. It could also, hold on, let me finish. It could also be that he believed that it would not get overturned. So he should spend his time on Obamacare and other things. I'm saying cynicism is when you believe one thing and then you do something to act in your own self-interest. And that's what I think. I think it's off. That's what I think Trump did. Hold on a second. We don't need to go back all the way to the Obama administration because the issue I'm talking about today is that in the past week, they had a vote codifying Obergefell on gay marriage and repealing DOMA, okay?
So now listen, I actually think there were so many Republican votes in the House, even though I would have liked to have seen more. There were enough that this might shame Schumer into bringing up the vote because it's going to be so obvious if he doesn't that he is doing this for a reason, right? Because they have the votes. They can pass this, just like they passed the gun bill a few weeks ago, right? Just like they passed the infrastructure bill. So if Schumer doesn't bring this up, it's a very cynical move. You think it's strategically to have that as an issue to phrase funding? Of course.
And it's really proof. Listen, I think that – Do you think both sides are cynical? Of course. Both sides engage in politics. However, what I'm talking about is the type of cynicism. So I think that there's a lot of issues on which the Democrats would rather appeal to the donor class basically that lives on the coast, New York, California, and be able to keep fundraising on that issue and basically scaremonger on that issue. instead of just winning the issue. They can just win this issue right now. Chamath, do you have less interest in supporting the Democratic Party based on the principle you stated that in the past there have been kind of promises and capital raised against codifying Roe and then it not happening?
Well, they never made those promises to me, so I never felt like they lied to me. I want to be very clear. So then nobody, and I never asked for that to be a precondition of my donation. Again, my capital was focused on one thing, which is I thought that President Trump was not the right person to lead this country. And I thought very clearly that the right Democrat could do a much, much better job. And I am glad that Biden won. And I'm glad that the money that I put in, maybe in any small way, but hopefully in some reasonable, non-trivial way, helped. And I'm glad that that money helped even out the Senate.
I'm glad all of those things happened. And so I want to be clear, they've never made those kinds of promises to me, nor have I ever asked. I make a high level decision on who I think the best candidate should be and support the party that will get that best candidate affected. What I was just trying to make clear to you guys is that sometimes, even a Democrat, it's important for us to be intellectually honest about what has happened. It's very easy to look at the other guy and find all the ways in which they screwed up or tried to screw you or, you know, is in a lack sympathy or lack sympathy, all of these things.
It's much harder oftentimes to look at your own team and say, wait a minute, why didn't X, Y, and Z happen? And the reason I'm bringing up what happened in 2009 is I think David is right. We have a moment in time where the leadership of the Democratic Party can codify rights that should be codified. And they should have in hindsight, they should have done it. And just to be clear, I don't know. It is still open. We can do it. Well, I'm talking about Roe v. Wade. And yes, and for the issue we're talking about now, it should be codified. Absolutely. And just to be clear, I'm an independent. I would vote for a Republican who was socially progressive and fiscally conservative.
As long as they're for gay marriage, as long as they're pro-women's right to choose, and they were fiscally conservative, I would vote for a Republican. I'm a moderate independent. I want to see less government and more efficient government, and I want the government out of people's personal lives. And I think that's where Sachs and I are exactly the same. We both want, I mean, Sachs, do you want the government involved in people's personal lives? You're a classic Republican. By the way, according to the Monmouth poll from a few weeks ago, you represent 4% of the voting base. I do. That's an extreme, yeah, that's an extreme minority.
The lowest self-identifying quadrant of fiscal conservative versus kind of fiscal liberal, social conservative, social liberal is the fiscal conservative, social liberal. what are we all here? I think we all fit this profile. Fiscally, we want the government to be run conservatively, you know, and with less government, and we want progressive social change, right? I mean, I think we all feel that way. Don't put me in a corner. I don't know. I'm just asking. I'm asking you guys if we're all insane. I wouldn't define my cultural positions as progressive social change, because the change that progressives are trying to enjoy right now is radical.
What I favor is social tolerance. I think we need to be a tolerant society. America is a very broad, diverse country. We need to find ways to live together and find accommodation on issues that are very contentious. That includes tolerance for gay marriage. So look, I'm on board with that. But this radical progressive agenda of social change, which includes upending the criminal justice system in favor of not prosecution, what's happening in the schools with CRT and the sort of hyper ideologized education. Look, they should just be teaching the basics, reading, leave it up to parents to do the other stuff.
Yeah, exactly. And so on down the line. Well, maybe progressive is the wrong term, because that now has been co-opted. Less government involved in your personal life and tolerance. I think we all agree on that. Tolerance is a great word. Everybody agrees with tolerance. It's a privileged position to want to have less government involved in your life, right? I mean, many people in the united states have been able to thrive and and survive because of the role that government has played in their lives and there's obviously on one end of the spectrum extreme grift and on the other end of the spectrum extreme need that is being met uh by the wealthiest government in the world and it is a you know it is in that middle where all of where do you stand How would you describe your politics in these two dynamics, right?
Are you also in this 4%? Freeberg? Yeah, yeah, yeah, no, I'm here. I'm trying to be thoughtful about this because... Yeah, no, I think it's the idea, yeah. I think that the government's role is to support those in need, not those in want. And I think that the government should be held accountable for performing that role. And I think that those of us who can, that are sitting in privileged positions and seats, should enable the government to perform that role well. And we should be positive actors, meaning we should support, we should pay taxes, and we should help people and institutions in need.
and that are, you know, kind of for the greater good. And then we should be holding ourselves, our government and our politicians to account for inefficiencies. And the biggest concern I have is less about are the people in need, needs being met as much as are we holding our government to account for the performance of its services and duties to the American people? And I don't think we are. I like this want-need concept here. Can you give an example of where the government, like people need something, but then there's another group that wants something and maybe we're overstretching and, you know, giving into wants when we should be focused on needs and efficiency.
Yeah, I'll give you a pretty example I know reasonably well, which is the farm bill passes every four years. And the farm bill in order to get it passed in both the House and the Senate, it has components that serve both farmers and support the food stamp program. So the food stamp program obviously supports millions of Americans that are in need of food, can't afford food, they get EBD cards, they get support in buying food, and there's a lot of programs and access that are enabled by that program. But that mostly services the needs of urban areas of cities. So that element of the bill is attractive and appealing to the representatives of cities found in the House.
On the other side, in order to get it passed in the Senate, where the majority of senators come from rural states, which have significant farming populations, the farming subsidies are planted in that same bill and as a result because everyone's getting something that bill as a whole has now grown to a multi-hundred billion dollar bill that gets passed every few years because in order for the senate to pass it the house says okay we'll give you all these farm subsidies in order for the house to pass it the senate says well sorry it's and vice versa right we'll give you all these food stamps but but both of them now have incredible what do they call it pork or fat or whatever.
Yeah. The amount of money that's wasted that isn't actually servicing the original intention and need of either of the parties that are represented by that bill is extraordinary. And I've spent a lot of time in the Farm Bill. I actually went with lobbyists years ago to DC and I actually met with the Senate and House Ag Committees. I've gone very deep into the bill and some of the programs in that bill. And it's just shocking to me in the same way that Palmer Luckey shared in our all-in summit how shocking it is how defense spending works in this country. It's shocking to me how some of the programs work in the farm bill, how much money and how much waste there is and how much grift there is.
And so, yes, we are meeting the needs of populations in need in this country, but so much more of the bill now is about people wanting more in order to pass the bill and it's bloated. And who's going to come in and fix it? Because where's the incentive for anyone to come in and cut that bill up? Where's the incentive to fix it? If both sides are barbelling the grift, then there's no incentive. They're in a dance to maximize the grift. So, Shemath, where do you stand now if we were to sort of look at politics without the Biden and Trump derangement syndrome, without the tribalism? Just in terms of first principles, I think what we're seeing here is we all want to see radical competence in the government.
Social issues, you know, and fiscally how we run the country. Where do you stand? How would you describe yourself now? Look, I mean, I think of things in terms of risk. Here's what I see. I see that there are a handful of issues that remain in terms of social policy that just need to get codified. Gay marriage is an example of one. Abortion rights is an example of the other. Then, and I think like those are like really, to my perspective, speak about human individual liberty, which I think should trump everything. So everybody should be allowed to kind of pursue the best version of themselves.
However, that manifests in the person you marry to, in the gender you express, these are like things where what you do to be happy, you should be allowed to do. Period. End of story. Then there are issues where I think are much thornier. And as I get older, I become increasingly ambivalent, or confused actually is a better word. And gun control is a perfect example of that, where I don't know what my right is to go and adjudicate a change to the Constitution that's been there since the founding of this country. That's a much more complicated issue. And so I think we have to basically devolve that right to the states, where individual states will have very different laws, and part of how you choose to express where you live will be defined by some of those rules.
So that's the social side. Extreme tolerance is really how I would sum it up. Economically, but I think the risk to America imploding, quote unquote, because of an issue in that surface area, in my opinion, is extremely limited. If I look on the economic lens, however, I think there are enormous risks to American leadership and exceptionalism. And we need a wholesale reset of how we create incentives, of how government should work, of how regulatory capture should work, of how the capital markets work. These rules are way too perverted. And it's creating enormous stress in a system. And again, I go back to the example I used last episode.
The thing that if you look, for example, like, you know, in that example of Sri Lanka, Singapore, Jamaica, and how there were these three completely different outcomes. Underneath the most successful outcome was an incredibly clear, transparent and simple financial framework. You cannot spend more than you have. You need to invest in long-term programs like education and healthcare. You need to make them broadly available. And then you need to have an absolute free market that gets the best ideas to the top of the funnel. And if you can just incorporate those things, the tax law could be four pages.
You know, the number of regulations could be 50 pages. You know, the simple rule that says to the Federal Reserve, you can't just print free money ad hoc. So I'm much more concerned about the fiscal future of America. I think that there's so much movement and progress on the social side, including the freedom of movement of people to different states. It is an important set of issues. But in terms of what drives the outcome and future success for our kids and our kids' kids, people should not sleep on the economy. Because if we get this wrong, that will be the tinderbox that lights everything on fire.
sax when you hear you know everybody sort of explain their basic uh belief system how far apart do you think we all are on this podcast because i think that's been a an issue we see a lot of the fans discussing you and i discussing it feels like on most of these issues and i think that's people ask me how i'm friends with you all the time and i'm sure you get that question as well yeah and i love you like a brother and i know i love sacks like a brother and anytime we talk about basic issues we're very much in sync and then when we talk about politics it feels like we're super, you know, you know, opposed, you know, in opposition to each other.
When you hear that we all have essentially the same stack of fundamental beliefs, how do you interpret this in terms of politics and America writ large? And how do we get consensus in this country to be more effective in running the country for the citizens? I think the media drives a lot of polarization, right? Because they're feeding us a bunch of bogus narratives. You look at the polling around the trust in the traditional media has absolutely plummeted through the floor. I mean, they basically have, instead of just reporting objectively the facts, they, I think the audience has recognized that they are activists.
They are basically pushing an agenda and they're pushing a bunch of bogus narratives. And I think it does drive the polarization. So that's part of it. To go back to, what are the core issues that motivate me and who I support? Look, I think we could probably agree on a lot of stuff. I want us to pursue more of an internationally cautious, you know, agenda, less interventionist, because it really hasn't worked out for us very well over the last 20 years with all these wars that failed. I want us to be fiscally responsible and promote a healthy economy, to what Jamal said. And then third, I'd like us to be socially tolerant.
Now, why does that lead me in this current environment to support Republicans? Well, Well, on foreign policy, neither party is really very good. Both parties are sort of pushing some version of Bush doctrine light, where we're basically over-involving ourselves in all these countries all over the world. But the Republicans at least have a faction that's in favor of realism and restraint. So I'm trying to help kind of push that direction within the party. The Democrats just are still very much in this liberal interventionist mode. So on fiscal issues, both parties are guilty of overspending and creating this ruinous federal debt and deficits that we have.
However, there's no way to avoid the fact that the Democrats are just worse. I mean, Biden wanted an extra $4 trillion of spending on this whole Build Back Better on top of the $4 trillion he had. So listen, I know the Republicans don't have clean hands on this issue, but the progressives are just worse. And as long as the progressives are calling the shots, the Democratic Party, they're just worse on spending. And then you got social tolerance. Listen, on the issues, on these sort of key rights issues that have been the kind of the old social issues the last 50 years, by and large, not on all these things, but by and large, I'm with you guys, that I'm in favor of sort of the socially tolerant position.
But look at who is pushing social intolerance today. I mean, the progressives are the most intolerant group in America. They're the ones pushing cancel culture. They're the ones trying to shove their positions down the throats of ordinary Americans. This is what's creating the backlash. You look at issues today like CRT, like the progressive approach on crime, on borders. The progressives are trying to promote, I think, a social policy that is fundamentally intolerant and doesn't accord any respect or room for traditional Americans to live their lives the way they want to. And you have to be tolerant of them as well.
We're not going to have peace in our society without some tolerance of traditionalists. Okay, let's wrap on this, Chamath, and then move to China. I sent you guys a, this was a quote by Mike Solana, a tweet from Mike Solana. The caption is, I've been wondering how they were going to spin this. And this builds exactly on what David just said here. When the Quinnipiac poll came out and about approve, disapprove about President Biden, you know, the big outlier was the Hispanic population. 19% approved, 70% disapprove. and the the article in the washington post which tries to kind of sort of like clean this all up and whitewash it says fake news speaks many languages but it's particularly fond of spanish essentially saying that you know the the fake news problem in in the spanish language has basically gotten so bad that you know this sort of explains why hispanics have have moved in droves and it's like a whole race baiting cheap shot article but the point of all of this is just to show that uh the left this is what really does kind of bum me out they are they are probably more intolerant than they've ever been they are there's an intellectual dishonesty like if rachel matter really wanted to increase her standing and position she would just start the next program with nancy pelosi's trades and say listen we all know let's call this what it is.
It's not cool. And here's how it should change. She'll never do it. I know. And I think that's the disappointing part about all this. Okay, so let's shift now. I think we'll just can I say one final thing about this whole thing that we can move on is I think, I think if you are sort of purple and centrist, I think the first two years of the Biden administration were really a missed opportunity, because I think there's sort of this conventional wisdom that the parties are so polarized, they can't get anything done. I think we saw actually, there's enough Republican votes, or there were in the previous Congress, this current Congress, they got the infrastructure bill done, they got the gun bill done, you know, with the red flag laws and so forth that we talked about.
They can get codification of gay marriage done if they want to. They could have gotten the Electoral Count Act reform. So if Biden hadn't gone all the way with his progressive voting rights agenda and just focused on reforming the Electoral Count Act, then you could have prevented a situation like we had on January 6th, what was happening inside the Capitol, not outside. So there was a lot of stuff they could have passed and they didn't. Why? Because in the first half of his administration, Biden's been completely captive to the progressives. There's another thing as well. You could get a child tax credit passed.
You could get Romney would basically be the floor leader on that in the Senate. They could pass a child tax credit. That's the most popular part of BBB. Why don't they peel that off and vote on it? Yeah, no, because they went for the whole thing. That's right. The aggressors are holding it hostage, saying that we're not going to give that to you unless you do the whole enchilada. And of course, there's no votes for that. So I think there's – and so who ultimately is the culprit for allowing this to happen? Well, partly Biden, but also Ron Clay and the chief of staff. I mean they've made – instead of triangulating to the center, they should have realized, hey, we're a 50-50 president, right?
I mean we have a 50-50 Senate. We should be triangulating. we should be building a centrist coalition wrong i agree going moderate the train biden had a clear path to go right to the center pull everybody in pull the working class in that's been his supporting base who he is working class and so he is and and he blew it by going too far to the left if he wants to save this presidency he should go straight to the middle and get all the working class behind him biden isn't the guy that went to some elite you know uh east coast liberal arts school where he got a master's in fine arts and is $400,000 in debt.
That's not Joe Biden, but he's let all these people run over the White House. And it's too late now because I think what's going to happen is... Is it too late? Well, the Republicans are going to win the House at least. How much time did we spend talking about canceling student debt? For who? Yeah. No, for a bunch of elite people with graduate degrees. Yeah. Listen, there's grifters on both sides. it's disgusting and we need to get to a version of politics that maybe is more like our conversations here but let's let's pivot to another society that we thought was going to roll over ours but and that we were in we were behind on in terms of competition china's in chaos right now apparently in terms of slowing economic growth bank protests mortgage protests exactly what i predicted last year when you guys were talking about china was going to dunk on us and i said you know it's very hard to run these authoritarian countries and the citizens like to protest when they get the short end of the stick and here we go.
Chinese economy is growing very slowly. They were going to do five and a half percent this year. They were only 0.4% in Q2. COVID has a lot to do with this, but there's been a series of bank protests and the media has been trying to figure out exactly what's going on here. To just set the stage here, rural banks in China, in a couple of provinces, froze a bunch of people's withdrawals in April. Okay, sounds like the crypto contagion in many ways. They had been offering unusually high interest rates. Also sounding like the DeFi grift going on here. No, no, I think it's more like 2008, Jason. I think it's more like the financial crisis in 2008 that was driven by the real estate bubble.
Yes. They've got their own real estate bubble, which is collapsing there. Correct. And so there's multiple things going on at once. The authorities haven't said how much money is frozen. uh protesters claim it's billions of uh won but it's hundreds of millions in the u.s after weeks without a resolution customers have been began protesting plain clothes thugs have been hitting and kicking the protesters and as of wednesday a video went viral of the ccp bringing in tanks to protect the banks very uh evocative of tiananmen square i have a question so go ahead yeah so china has a very explicit zero tolerance policy on covid why do you guys think they are so extreme in that policy like any any ideas like have they explained why it has to be zero tolerance they have not explained that um and if you believe that they're the origin of covid maybe they have some insider information about long-haul covid and that was something i want to talk to friedberg about if he thinks this you know long-term covid stuff is a really acute issue.
But Freeberg, what do you think? Yeah, I don't, let me, I don't want to answer that question. Can I answer that if you don't want to? Yeah, go ahead. Listen, I think the answer is very simple. But I do want to talk about the Chinese economy. Oh, yeah, yeah. There's a lot going on there. To turn over to, yeah, this is a complex issue. There's a lot more going on there. So on Zero COVID, I think this is coming directly from Xi. This is his policy. And I think that earlier in the pandemic, they were hailing their response, which they saw as orderly and effective at controlling COVID. And they were contrasting that with a chaotic Western response.
And so I think that the credibility of the CCP and Xi himself got tied up in this idea of stopping COVID entirely, of zero COVID. And so I think this is coming directly from the top and it's having a huge impact on their economy. And I think this is one of the dangerous aspects of an autocratic system is you got one guy at the top making the decisions. And if he's wrong, there's not really a great feedback loop for correcting him. And nobody can question him. Yeah. There's no questioning the god king. You know, it sort of recalls a situation in China. I think it was about 500 years ago. There was a Chinese emperor who banned shipbuilding and banning having a navy.
And because of that, China shut itself off from global trade and it fell well behind the West, which then explored and captured the new world. There's this question about, you know, the Chinese culture and civilization was much more advanced than the West, than Europe a thousand years ago. But basically it fell behind. And a big reason is because this unilateral decision by one emperor to basically close themselves off from the rest of the world. So you have to wonder, does this autocratic move by Xi basically doom their economy to a recession? It seems like they're not learning. From our experience, these lockdowns didn't work.
I mean, you can't stop the virus. It's eventually going to get out. Even I saw Biden got the virus this week. I mean, it's out, right? It's endemic now. Everybody's going to get it is basically what's happening. But Xi's been making a bunch of heavy-handed decisions like this. So besides lockdowns, it's also the crackdowns. It's the crackdown on the tech industry and tech entrepreneurs. Funding has plummeted. And so has so LPs are no longer investing in funds there with the exception of Sequoia's, which seems to be struggling, but is still able to raise some money. And then additionally, founders can't raise money and founders are questioning when they meet with VCs, if they can actually if the VCs are just meeting with them theatrically, the story that came out this week in the FT, if they're just meeting with them theatrically, because they want to still hold out hope that there'll be a venture capital industry, but there may not be a VC industry in China anymore.
Let me just give you the housing stuff. And then Freeberg, I know you want to chime in on this. So there's also mortgage boycotts happening at the same time, as this Fugazi bank stuff happened, the bank stuff seems to be not the national banks, these are local banks that apparently could have been running some kind of grift where people deposited money. It looks a lot like the savings and loan kind of behavior in the 90s. And these are regional banks, to be clear. This isn't the national banks. And so at the same time, the mortgage boycotts are happening at 301 unfinished developments in 91 cities.
Homeowners are accusing developers of failing to deliver the apartments they've already paid for. According to Bloomberg, 70% of household wealth in China is tied up in property, much higher than the US. This is downstream of the whole Evergrande thing, right? You got Evergrande basically defaulted, and there were a whole bunch of people who prepaid for their homes. And so they're already paying mortgage, but Evergrande never finished the homes. And now they're rising up because they're saying, why should we pay for a home that was never delivered. Right. I just want to like take a zoom out because I think it's worth, you know, we can focus on any one of these particular things that are happening and try and diagnose them and dissect them.
But if you zoom out a little bit, I think it paints a more interesting picture. Over the last 30 years, right, the Chinese economy grew from 318 billion to in 1990 to 10 and a half trillion in 2020, right? Incredible growth, GDP per capita, you know, grew kind of in a similar ratio, right? Now, from 318 bucks per person to $12,500 in 30 years, I mean, really unprecedented in the history of humanity. China now accounts for 20% of global GDP from less than 2% in 1990. Now, if you look at historically what drove that growth, we all talk about manufacturing, right? Manufacturing accounts for about a third of the economy.
And manufacturing as a sector was growing in China 25% year over year in 2008, and then only grew 6% in 2022. It's like basically, you know, kind of reaching an all time low in recent years. So that's historically been the driver for growth of this economy. And so much of the, you know, the bargain between the people and the Chinese Communist Party has been keep giving us a better life, keep growing our economy, keep giving us more housing, more stuff, more food, more safety, more security, we'll support the CCP. And the challenge that the CCP is having is that a lot of that growth, the core growth engine is starting to slow.
So manufacturing is slowing, then real estate was growing. And so real estate accounts for 7% of the Chinese economy. And I've got a good stat for you guys here. In 2005, 250 million square meters of real estate was sold in China. In 2021, 1.5 billion was sold. Every year it's been incrementing. So the amount of real estate that's being produced and sold was increasing like crazy. This year it's collapsed. So it's down like, you know, forecast to be about 1.25 billion now. So the first decline in real estate building and sales. So that part of the driver of the economy in China is now collapsing.
And then the financial services sector accounts for 8% of the economy. And that's been growing because it's leveraged off manufacturing and real estate and all the capital that's flown in, all of which is slowing down and stopping, you know, this $58 trillion of assets in China, generating about $700 billion of annual profits for the financial services industry, insurance, banking, lending, and so on. So a lot of the conflict and the things that are starting to fall apart, which may just be the tip of the iceberg, is a function of a fundamentally slowing economy. And the forecast and the outlook for an economy that doesn't have the drivers it's had historically, and things are starting to come off, the wheels are starting to come off a bit.
And so, you know, look, the advantage they have is central planning, long term investments, being able to kind of be thoughtful about this. But in order to do that, there's certainly going to be a need for the CCP to keep people in line, as some of the long term bets hopefully play out for them, as they would say. In order to do that, they're going to have lockdowns and other sorts of mechanisms of regulatory control over the people. But really, this could be the beginning of some of the unwinding and real concern about, you know, is there a core economic growth engine in China that can save them?
And what will it be? I think all of this, if we look at what's happening in the economy writ large, Chamath, you know, the global slowdown plus inflation is now causing a stress test on every country. Sri Lanka's stress test, you know, showed us what's happening with their farming issues and with corruption. And here in China, the stress test, I think you would agree, is showing what's going on in terms of, you know, banking, mortgages, real estate, and obviously this surging middle class and what their expectations of life are. So what's your take on what's happening in China? And are they, you know, how does this add up in terms of our rivalry with them as our contemporary?
At a very macro level, China has one massive, massive, massive problem, which is one of population. It's hard to get an accurate count, but it is an aggressively aging population, which was the result of the one child policy for a very long time. China has sort of been on their heels trying to adapt that policy. but really the the last data i saw i tweeted this out it was a little while ago nick so maybe hard for you to find in my twitter feed but it was a projection of china's population which essentially showed it contracting by almost 50 by 2100 so in the so it that's a really really bad situation now when you have a slowing population then the economy has to morph why is that when you have a young population, so for example, take what China was 20 years ago when it entered the WTO, or what India is today, when you have lots of thoughts of young people, you can on ramp them into economically productive activities like manufacturing.
The problem when those folks accumulate middle class income and wealth is that they age out of those kinds of jobs like they did in America. And what we seek are services and service level jobs. And you spend more money, you spend it in a different way. So as populations age, your economy has to turn over unless you have a large bulwark of young people that is constantly growing to take up more of the slack, the economic slack to pay for these folks who have different lifestyles, more savings, and different needs, specifically healthcare. That's China's enormously big problem. So when you see them talking about 6% GDP targets, and you think, how does a country that big even grow at 6%?
It's because they're reverse engineering for what they need to create economic vibrancy in that country. And so when you start to look at 2%, which in America, you'd say 2% is great. We would like high-fiving each other for 2%. That's not a sustainable level of growth for what's happening inside that country. It does not create enough of expansion economically to cover all these folks. That is a really, really big issue. So as that happens, I think what we need to do is figure out how to be competitive. Now, this goes all the way back to our first conversation. Subsidies don't make us more competitive.
Things that governments can do to make us more competitive are long-term, drawn-out tax incentives that change the earnings capacity of companies. Why? Because then the capital markets reward those businesses. Jason, you just mentioned it. Why is the Chinese capital markets in difficulty? Nobody knows what the long-term earnings are. How do you forecast it? It's not simple anymore. It's not a model. It's not an interest rate. It's not a discounted set of cash flows, right? And so that's how they need to refactor themselves. They need to have a much larger population. If you don't have that, you have to figure out how to do it with immigration.
If you don't have that, what China has done is they've tried to go to Southeast Asia and to Africa, and they've tried to create that synthetic form of a growing pyramid, right? Now, that can work as long as the balance sheet of the country supports that because ultimately, you're still talking about moving money offshore, okay? So I think they're in a little bit of a, they're in a pretty difficult spot. The most difficult spot is the one that she put them in. If you get rid of entrepreneurship, If you get rid of high growth companies that create the opportunity on a global scale, and then you, you know, take DD off the public markets, you don't let education companies become public or you basically get rid of their little co-opting of capitalism and venture capital, their whole society is going to become slow growth.
And slow growth in a country that doesn't have safety nets is really dangerous. Saks, your thoughts in terms of competition versus America? Okay, let me get to the competition in a second. just to build on what Jamal said, the birth rate or the fertility rate in China slipped to just 1.15 in 2021, so last year. It takes 2.1 just to maintain your population at replacement level. And this is lower than even Japan, which is also shrinking as it could. Japan's at about 1.3. The US and Australia are at 1.6, but we get above 2.1 because of immigration, and China doesn't have that. So they've got a huge demographic problem.
To Jamal's point, it's going to be something like Well, the population is shrinking by 40% with every generation. That's what these numbers imply. Insane. The numbers are it's going to be under 600 million by the year 2100. But I don't understand how it wouldn't even be less than that if it keeps going at this rate. So the commentator, Peter Zihan has – I don't know if that's the right way to pronounce it. Peter Zihan or something. Anyway, he's pointed out that China is facing demographic collapse in the next decade or so. On top of that, like you're saying, Jason, you've got Xi emphasizing Maoist economics.
He basically says he thinks that the Chinese economy, again, he stresses the need for socialist characteristics. And he seems to be bringing back that sort of communist ideology to their economy. And they've basically really cracked down on entrepreneurship and venture capital. It's really a self-owned. I mean, they've moved away from the policies that have made them so successful economically over the last 40 years. And then on top of that, you got this debt crisis and this housing crisis. So it really looks like the debt is stacked against all of them. And you're asking, what does this mean for us?
Well, I think it depends on whether you look at it economically or geopolitically. I think if you look at it economically, you'd say that it's bad for us because our two economies are economically linked. There's a lot of dependency. They've evolved together for a long period of time. And if China has a collapse, then they're so big now that that's going to have, I think, global repercussions. There's going to be contagion. But the truth is, if you look at it geopolitically, and geopolitics is more of a zero – the balance of power is a zero-sum game. Economics can be a positive-sum game, but the balance of power is definitely not a positive-sum game.
You'd have to say it's good for us because the reason why China has become such a threat is because of its growing economy over the last 40 years. And look, I mean, what they've done and what they've been doing over the last decade or so is translating their economic might into military might. And that has given them the capability to now threaten their neighbors, to become more belligerent, to basically rattle the saber against Taiwan. And if their impressive economic growth continues for the next couple of decades as it has until now, there's no question that they will basically try to assert their hegemony over East Asia.
And Taiwan will be a huge flashpoint, but there's also flashpoints in the East China Sea with Japan over the Tsinghaku Islands. But they're going to need a bankroll to do that. So if their economy is not growing, they don't have the bankroll to do it. They're going to have to look inward and say, hey, we've got to fix these domestic problems. We got to get people stop protesting these streets. We need to, this middle class is demanding of jobs. The great news for what's happened in China, and I think this is why the people there are very happy, is the number of people living in poverty has plummeted.
You know, when they started tracking this data in the 80s, you know, high 90% of people were living in extreme poverty or poverty. 99% of people were in poverty on the global definition of it. And now, you know, it's just plummeted to, you know, a couple of hundred million people. So a couple of charts for you here, but just in the data is obviously it's very hard to understand what's going in China because a lot of it is opaque. But just the number of people on a percentage basis living in poverty has gone. And now the number of people who are in the middle class has surged. That creates another dynamic.
Those people want to have a great life. They want better jobs. They don't want to work in factories. They want to have a more information based economy and a better job than 60 hours a week in a factory. That's why they're moving their factories to Africa and other places. I mean, I don't know if that's absolutely true. I think that China's manufacturing sector is aiming to evolve. So, you know, China has about 3 million factories or manufacturing facilities throughout the country, employing about 112 million people. The US has about 300,000 factories employing about 12 and a half million people.
The output of our factories is about 70% of the output of China's factories in aggregate, sorry, the total production output of all the factories. So we have very high value outputs coming out of our factories and high leverage. China is observing and obviously recognizes that there's an opportunity probably to evolve their manufacturing capacity to be higher leverage, higher value output. And so there is going to be, you know, from the long range perspective, planning and investment in technology that allows those factories to become much more sophisticated and create much more higher value products moving up from what is effectively just cheap labor putting things together in an assembly plant to being things like additive manufacturing 3d printing automated manufacturing biomanufacturing etc and i think this is particularly going to be realized because china announced that they're building 400 nuclear power plants that drops the cost of electricity to under five cents a kilowatt hour in the u.
s manufacturing electricity typically cost around 11 cents per kilowatt hour, 12 cents per kilowatt hour in that range. So if factories become much more automated, they start to become a function of the price of electricity in terms of what they can output. China is going to have a huge advantage as these nuclear power plants come online over the next couple of decades, and these facilities get upgraded. So there is a plan, right? Remember, this is a plan. And the reason they have that There is a question of do they get there fast enough to drive economic growth that actually supports all these other industries like real estate and finance that they become critically dependent on because those industries only work if there's a core economic driver, a core economic engine that's working here.
So this energy infrastructure, this new manufacturing infrastructure, these are things that, by the way, they can do really effectively because they're not working on four-year and six-year political cycles. they can take a 5, 10, and 30-year outlook and make a plan and invest against it. It's what they did from night. So I wouldn't count them out, but there's certainly a lot of challenges they're facing right now. And it's a big question mark right now, what's going to happen? Well, and to your point, factories in China are, you know, factory workers getting paid over $6 an hour now. In Vietnam, three.
In India, even less. And that's why you're seeing a lot of folks, I don't know if you're seeing it in your portfolios, but we've seen a lot of folks looking at India, Vietnam, and moving factories there. And obviously Japan has been incentivizing people to move out of it. China's not gonna just lose their manufacturing edge. They're not just gonna say, hey, we give up, let everyone go to Vietnam. They're gonna try and upgrade the capability of those factories and say, hey, instead of just putting together parts with $6 an hour of human labor, let's start to do the more sophisticated stuff. So then Freebird, the next card that turns is, well, what happens to those factory workers if they've been automated out?
What do you do with hundreds of millions of people working in factories who now have been turned into robots? and then if they're going to be in an info the answer is information economy if it's going to be an information economy you need venture capital and you need new companies to create those jobs and they just killed that so i don't know what strategy she is uh pursuing here but it seems like a bad one we could talk about this one at length but um we were going to bring this up but you know generally speaking technology drives productivity gains but it's deflationary explain what that means on in like a practical sense maybe uh you know that the technology So let's say that you have to pay a bunch of people to make a t-shirt and then a machine is built that makes the t-shirt.
The cost of the t-shirt goes down because one machine can just print out 100 t-shirts an hour, whereas it would take five people, you know, 10 hours to make those 100 t-shirts or whatever it is, right? So a technology kind of emerges and those people are now theoretically out of jobs. But what ends up happening is those people transition into new jobs that didn't exist before. And we end up seeing higher order work take place. Think about the world 200 years ago. Do you think we would have had any concept of people being Uber drivers or people, you know, creating crafts and selling them on Etsy?
YouTubers, content creators. People being yoga teachers. or yoga teachers or psychotherapists. Only fans. Okay, well, there you go, John. Only fans. Only fans or dog walkers or all of these service businesses or industries that simply did not exist before. And so the labor that that percentage of the population was involved in historically has gone away because it's been automated. As that automation has happened, it's allowed higher order services jobs to emerge. And that will be the progression of humanity forever. I will tell you guys, I was going to mention this. Have you guys played with Dolly 2?
Yeah. The other day? Yeah, sure. I got the login. My brother-in-law was visiting. We were playing with Dolly 2 and making funny kind of photos. Explain what it is. Yeah. So Dolly 2 is developed by OpenAI. We all know Sam Altman. He's been leading that organization to great effect over the last couple of years. And what they're doing is they basically scan the web for images, tag them, and then apply, you know, machine learning to, you know, to basically allow natural language creation of images from scratch. So the AI can generate an image. And you can go to, you know, the internet and look at a bunch of these.
But the imagery is incredible. I mean, the creative output, what feels like creative output from the system, where you just say, hey, you know, make me an image of four guys doing a podcast on Zoom in the style of Van Gogh. And it creates this image that is unique, has never been created or seen on Earth before, and is a function of the learning that's been done in these neural networks to develop this AI that can create novel stuff. It's really amazing. And I started to think about, like, what are the implications for this over time? Think about, you know, the original movie Ben-Hur in today's would have cost a billion dollars to make.
They had thousands of people, I think tens of thousands of people on that set. It took years to make. They built giant sets. They could only make one film. It was an incredible feat and an effort. That's what movie making is still today. There's teams of people. Now, what if you could speak to the AI and say, make photorealistic, Jason and Chamath having a battle on a field in the middle of nowhere, and now an airplane flies over, and you can instruct the AI and the AI can generate photorealistic visuals, audio. The AI can even generate scripts and narrative for you. It really starts to change the role of the creator, the director.
The director is no longer doing this thing where they have to get it just right, make the perfect 90 minutes, and then line up all the money and all the people to do that work on that plan, on that program. They can be much more iterative and they can be much more creative on the fly. They can create a two-hour movie by speaking to the AI and then edit the movie by speaking to the AI, change the actors, change the color, change the voices, change the music, just speaking to AI to generate creative output. And people will consume that output. And I think it's amazing to think about what creators will end up doing 10 years from now as AI and these tools proliferate.
And you see version 12 of this, which is version two, and what version 12 might enable. And so the role, the number of people that can do that job goes from Steven Spielberg and Bob Zemeckis and a few other people to suddenly thousands or tens of thousands of people around the world making incredible movies. Here's Dolly's image. Let's pull it up of four guys doing a podcast. So we have a ways to go. But yeah, that is four guys doing a podcast. That's awesome. Yeah, that's awesome. I mean, and to your point, like, you know, this is gonna we're on. So yeah, this is gonna so a lot of people are like, Oh, is this gonna wipe out graphic designers?
Is it gonna wipe out the creative industry? But the reality is, the roles that those people are in today will absolutely be gone, but they will emerge and evolve into new roles that we never even thought imaginable. They'll have really transform that industry and society. And this is going to be true across everywhere that AI touches. Yeah. And I think you'll see this in China. As China steps up their technology in manufacturing, you'll see those, you know, new markets evolve. Sorry, Jamath, go ahead. Designers will have less leverage to ask for all the stupid snacks in offices of startups. Well, I mean, you need only look at like...
The designers are the worst. My God. Oh, they're the best. I love them. But anyway, in the 1940s, I mean, there were literally hundreds of thousands of telephone operators. Totally. And they're all gone now. And not only that. Have you ever met a designer that didn't take themselves incredibly seriously, that didn't have like, you know, tea that they would steep? Only the bad ones. You know, loose leaf tea that they would steep? They'd have like steel straws. Video game designers are a little different. I'm sorry. What did you say about the steel straws? that was it yeah there he is i am by the way on video eliminating waste in my life i mentioned to you guys last year this video game i played over christmas by anna perna pictures and the guy that um runs the studio sent me a dm he loves the pod oh that's nice and they just launched a new video game which i uh started playing a couple nights ago called stray and you literally at you you play the game as a cat lost in some crazy world you're literally a cat that's awesome the imagery on this thing is unbelievable that's actually my favorite game right now sax is i play a cat and i'm a stray cat and it's really amazing the the ai i you know it's really hard you go play the game yeah i'm gonna take a hard pass on that i like to play a game where i'm a stray dog and i meet another dog and then we eat a bowl of pasta but this long string of pasta we each come closer and closer then we end up kissing let's uh move on to do we want to go black rock has lost 1.
7 trillion dollars in six months uh vc funding is down or amazon acquires one medical for 3.9 billion which which one do we want to go to next anybody have a favorite here sacks you've been a little quiet you got one you want to go to uh we can talk about the walk walk thing this is the largest amount of money lost by a single firm over a six month period in history. BlackRock is the world's largest asset manager. And it was the first firm to break $10 trillion in AUM assets under management. Now right now they're at 8.4 trillion. 2022 ranks as the worst start in 50 years for both stocks and bonds, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Larry Fink said on his earnings call at the end of June, only about a quarter of its assets were actively managed to beat a benchmark rather than track it seamlessly as passive strategies are designed to do.
Firms' passive equity holdings are now 10 times larger than its active holdings, although it does operate some active multi-asset and alternative strategies that narrow the gap. Collapse in bond markets this year has shaken money out of active fixed income funds. Listen, I think there's less than meets the eye here with this. I think this was a headline that was trying to grab attention by saying biggest loss ever. Look, the reason why it was the biggest loss ever is because BlackRock is so big. And what is BlackRock? It's basically at this point, they're index funds. They're ETFs, they're index funds.
They just represent market indices. So the reason why it went down $1.7 trillion is because it started with $10 trillion. So the average index is down 17%. That's all it means. We know this. The S&P 500 is down 20%, 22% for the year. The Dow Jones down 15-ish. The NASDAQ is down like 30. So this is just reflecting what we already know, which is that the stock market is down this year. Do you think it's another data point to support the idea that active managers, generally speaking, and maybe holistically speaking over time, the market cannot beat indices? Do you have a point of view on that as an investor, Sachs?
Well, I think you're talking about public market investors. I think it's very hard to beat the public markets over a long period of time consistently. I just think it is. Now, the contradiction, though, is that if you have no active managers, then the indices won't be efficient anymore. So you need the participation of the active managers to help drive the indices and make corrections to it. And the fewer active strategies you have, the more inefficient the markets will become, thereby inviting active strategies. So, you know, I think it's a good question. I think there are some managers who can probably do it, but I think it's a very tough thing to do.
Timoth, what do you think? You're a public investor, active selector of investments. Here's what I hear. I've been thinking a lot about this. I think that I have disproportionately benefited from being at the right place at the right time, backed by enormous amounts of central bank money. And so I think we all have been. I think it is very difficult to be a public market individual stock picker in a world where the central banks are constantly meddling. Because when they do, the best thing that you can do is belong the market beta. And the more concentrated you are, the better returns you would have delivered.
since 2008 when the central banks started to get very aggressively involved. When individual stock pickers reigned the universe was when central banks were largely on the sidelines. And so there was all kinds of dispersion, right? Dispersion, meaning good outcomes, bad outcomes, lots of alpha, right? Meaning your performance was independent of the market. but since 2008 it's largely been beta that's driven the market and the folks that have done exceedingly well were those in tech because we delivered the best beta and every time we confuse alpha and beta we get over our ski tips and there's always some big out you know blow up so i think my my general takeaway is that uh if the central banks stay on the sidelines individual stock picking reins and active management can win if they continue to be involved and do quantitative easing and all of this other stuff index funds that are long concentrated market beta will always outperform in the long run i was watching warren buffett answer some questions and one of the questions and this goes to the law of big numbers like blackrock he was saying listen the reason i did better earlier in my career than later in my career on a percentage basis is because I was placing at a smaller amount of capital, and I was placing it on smaller bets, smaller ideas and themes.
And then as I had a bigger chip sack, I had to find bigger ideas to put more money to work. And therefore, more people were looking at those. And so those assets were not undervalued. And so I found that very like, insightful, in terms of when you participate in the market, if you're trying to pick between very large bets, like KOTU and TPG and Tiger were doing in the growth space sacks. Like, now everybody knows that these companies, everybody knows Stripes a winner, everybody knew Airbnb and Uber were winners, you know, in the late stage of the private, everybody knew Facebook was a winner in the late stage private market.
If you're battling that out, you know, Yuri Milner is going to come over the top and pay 2 billion more than you or Masi Yoshisan is going to pay 5 or 10 billion dollars more than you. Where is the alpha there? You know, where where is the gain? The alpha is in the fees. Okay, there you go. And so they were playing a different game. And that's, you know, I started trading this past two weeks, because I've never traded public stocks. And I wanted to add it as a skill set. So I put a couple million bucks into an account. And I'm just trying to actively figure out how does value work there. And, you know, I'm just starting to make trades that I want to hold for 10 or 20 years.
And we'll see if I can beat the market. That's the other thing is what do you want to spend your life doing? If you can put money in a passive index and not do any work, well, that's attractive as well. So, Sachs, what do you think in terms of active management in these public markets and the size of the bets that have to be there? Like I said, I think it's very hard to beat the market consistently. I think it's a very tough profession. I'm sure there are people who can do it, but I don't know if it's easy to predict who those people are. So look, I think it's something that can be done, but I just think it's a tough, tough game.
I mean, what we do as private investors is a little different, right? Because not everybody is in a position to buy shares, right? Yeah, you're not available to you. You don't even know the company. Access is limited and information is limited. And in exchange for that sort of preferential access that we get, we actually have to do work. A lot of work. When you're a public investor in a company, Disney or whatever, you don't do any work. You're not involved at all. We do a lot of work for the companies, and that's why they choose us. You're not competing against the whole world. I think the public markets are just so competitive.
Are you tempted, though, looking at these prices? Because I was looking at a company that was trading at 50 times revenue last year. They're raising again. They double their revenue. So now they're at 20, 25 times revenue. They're raising at last year's valuation. And then I looked at the public market comps and they're trading at six times. So now I'm like, wait a second. You got to look at the growth rate. You got to look at the growth rate. The growth rate in this example was three times greater than the public market comps. So how would you assess that then? Well, what we're seeing right now is that pretty good SaaS companies that are growing, maybe on a trailing basis, they grew 3x and prospectively they're growing, call it 2.
5x. um they're trading right now not trading but basically deals are getting done at 20 times arr 20 which arr this year's current run rate yeah the current arr you're not getting that like bonus like here's your projected next year we're going to give it based on that this is current no no current arr is about 20 22 23 times arr um down from what last year 100 it was like 100 times was the rule of thumb yeah so now there are some where they're you know deals are getting done in the high 20s, I'd say, or even 30, if you believe that by the end of the year, it'll be more like 20. But I think the new levels are landing at 20, 20-something times ARR.
Now, why does that make sense relative to the public SaaS companies? Well, like you said, the SaaS index is trading at roughly six times, but that's only 20% average growth. Right. And so, you're talking about 10 times the growth, right? Right. And the high growth SaaS companies are trading at like seven times. That's for like a 40% grower. We've talked about this before. So listen, if you're tripling year over year and you pay 20 times, that'll be a seven times next year. But if you're growing two, two and a half, three X next year, that's way faster. So I think there's actually an arbitrage there.
I mean, this is why we like doing private SaaS investing right now. Deals are getting done. I will say that the people who I'm seeing who are really struggling, Freeberg, are the people who didn't turn on, I'm talking about in the very early stage, they didn't turn on revenue. They were making progress in team building and culture and features, but they just weren't focused on the revenue side. And my Lord, people got a lot of credit. I mean, 50 million, $100 million evaluations without the revenue turned on. And now they're faced with not being able to raise money full stop. What are you seeing on your side, Freeberg, in terms of deal flow in the private markets?
Yeah, it's- And raising money, yeah, because you have to raise money for your companies. It's not easy. Okay, unpack it. What's not easy? Well- What are the conversations like? Give us the anecdotal information. I mean, I've seen a number of term sheets get pulled. So I think- Oh, really? Yeah, we've heard a lot about companies that kind of during the Q1, early Q2 timeframe had term sheets, weren't closing, got delayed out. And there's a number of kind of examples of repricing where the investors come back, markets have changed, let's reprice the thing. Or, hey, we're not going to do this deal anymore.
We're going to sit on the sidelines and wait till the market settles. Or our LPs actually aren't going to let us fund new stuff. Uh, so there's a lot of those last one for people. What does that mean? You know, investor, you know, investors have LPs, they have investors themselves and their LPs are coming to them and saying, do not put more money out right now. We are telling you, we are not going to wire our money to you. We need you to wait until even though they're contractually obligated to they're telling theoretically, they may not be contractually obligated to, but obviously these are long term partnerships.
And so when an LP, you know, or a group of LP says, guys, we're not comfortable with you deploying money right now, you know, you're in a 10 year partnership, 15 year partnership with them, you're gonna as an as an investor as a fund, you're gonna say, Okay, I'm going to kind of listen to that right now. Now, the bigger issues in series B, C, and D, where companies, you know, have some traction, have some performance, have raised a bunch of capital, have done a bunch of work, and investors don't know what they're worth. They're like, Hey, is this thing worth 25 million or 125 million or 500 million?
Last year, you could to raise money at 500 million. I mean, look at what happened with one of those crypto things. Those crypto trading platforms, they raised $500 million last July. And they just sold the business for a reported $25 million after being valued at 5 billion a year ago. Yeah. So the whole thing might have been more like 275 million. Yeah, and and so but but series series A people seem to be pretty active again. And so active again, but the prices now for seed runs. Yeah, but it's a lot Three rounds happening six to 15, series A is happening 15 to 25. It's a lot easier to get a deal done in a series A because people say, hey, look, I'm going to give you this.
You say, okay, I'll take it. I need the money. Series B, C, and D is where there's this whole fight because there's existing investors, existing shareholders who are saying, I don't want to take a 50% write down, a 70% write down, a 30% write down over the last round and fighting and then doing inside rounds and bridge notes and all sorts of other shenanigans to not have to take a negative mark on their book. Yeah. One thing that's interesting here is that you think about where the opportunity is in the market right now. And I think one of the things that happened in the boom is that everyone got pushed to go earlier and earlier because deals were so competitive.
And so in the SaaS business, normally $1 million of ARR was considered the rule of thumb for basically graduating to a Series A, that you were ready to go from C to Series A when you had a million of ARR. As we know, during the boom last year, that number kept going down. You know, half a million, $300,000. And then you would see crazy deals get done that were pre-revenue with price at $100 plus. We never did any of those kinds of deals because we just thought they were too crazy, but they definitely happened. Well, think about the dynamic now, which is, let's say that that SaaS startup that has a million of ARR, they can do a Series A at $50.
or we can just wait until they get to 5 million of ARR and then pay 20 times and do it at 100 free, which of those is the better risk-adjusted return? Let me tell you, there's a lot of risk in going from 1 million ARR to 5 million ARR. That's hard. It's hard. There's a lot of things that go off the rails. You need a sales team. You're not doing it through the founders selling the product. Yeah, you need to start scaling a team. You need a real sales capacity. But also, a lot of startups that could sort of hack together and cobble together 1 million of ARR based on non-scalable techniques that various startup incubators teach, like, you know, don't be scalable.
Do things that don't scale. Yes, exactly. It's okay to do that from zero to one, but not one to 10. Right. Well, or it's not that it's not okay. It's just that it doesn't work, right? Like you're not gonna be able to cobble together 5 million of ARR. You can cobble together 1 million of ARR. You can use the cheat code to get there. So what I'm saying is there's a lot of risk in going from one to five. You find out whether the product's really scalable. So what is the better deal? Wait till 100. wait till it's priced at $100 or $120 million pre or doing the deal at $40 to $50. Now, if you love the company, you want to get in as early as possible.
But I think you're going to start seeing a dynamic where in the same way that last year, everyone went earlier and earlier, you're going to see VC start to sit back and go a little later and later. Prove it to us. A dead man's own. Nobody should be putting money into deals right now. Why? What does it do? Unless you're in the business of running a fee generating machine, if you're really trying to generate alpha, you have to have a sense of what's actually happening in the world right now. If you're just trying to deliver the market beta and run an index, then yeah, you're right. You should ignore this idea that there could be more price adjustments.
But if you look at the public markets, which is again, the ultimate terminal buyer, they have more cash than they ever had since 2008, which means that there is no reason to buy. You're talking about private companies. It all ultimately ends up in the public markets. And so if the public markets are saying there is no reason to buy this stuff, it trickles down. So then the crossover investor who has a public private business says, you know what? On the public side, I'm completely de-risked and in cash. And so on the private side, I'll just be a little bit more circumspect and wait. As David said, I'll just wait six months and put even more money in later.
I'll actually have a better IRR and I'll make the same profit dollars. So then the series B and C firm who used to feed those deals to the crossover folks are like, oh, well, if you're waiting, I don't want to have to write a check to support these folks. My whole point was to have you mark up the deal so I could raise a new fund. They slow down. And then that goes back to the series A person who's like, well, wait a minute. You know, the reason I paid it at 50 pre was because I thought you'd step in and buy it at 100 And so then they slow down. So all i'm saying is I think that we are At the point of the cycle where constipation is setting it And this is why you're seeing such a downtick in deal velocity and dollars put to work This is a great advice.
I want everybody to take i'm going to take the opposite advice and i'm going to do twice as many deals in the seed stage as everybody else. But I encourage every venture capitalist and seed fund to take Chamath's advice. I'm doing the opposite because a five person company, this isn't advice. This is just a market observation. I'm just talking about observation. I hope everybody takes that as the truth. Because what I'm seeing is the founders who are raising and who have real businesses are so sharp right now and so focused on costs and profits and what matters. And they have eliminated all the shit that doesn't.
There's a whole contingent. I don't know if you're seeing it sacks i'd say it's one out of five one out of four that are like i understand what's happening here and i'm going to take advantage of this moment in time and i'm going to just drive revenue and profits what happens to the 250 billion dollars that's been put to work in the last two years that need to get up rounds yeah it doesn't matter to me all i care about is meeting young companies that are growing with revenue but i think they're they're just trying to have i'm not trying to have a conversation if you want to yeah no i that's so i'm just that's a lot of indigestion yeah they're gonna have to cut their staffs by half and get to profitability Ultimately, the way that valuations matter or price levels matter is there's an entry price and an exit price.
And ideally, if you can time it right, you want to invest when valuation levels are low and you want to exit when valuation levels are high. If you were a VC last year, you should have been realizing as much as you can because valuation levels are really high. There was a good tweet by one of Brad Gerstner's colleagues at Altimeter basically saying she was talking to LPs and asking what they care about. And what she reported, LPs is saying, is that if you're a fund that's more than five years old and you didn't distribute during the best window ever, which was 2018 or 2021, it's a hard no. We're not going to be re-upping with you.
I'll say it even more. If you're a venture investor who took a longitudinal view on public market stocks and then has now seen 60% to 70% write-downs of those same stocks that you could have distributed, you should still have something to answer to. That makes no sense. It turns out that the skill of private market investing and the skill of public market investing are different. Even if all you're doing is delivering the market beta, it's still different enough. We had this discussion last year. Remember, I was saying, should I distribute the shares of Robinhood? Should I hold them? What should I be doing?
We told you to distribute. And I distributed. I distributed everything. And in terms of secondary, I feel particularly smart. Do you feel like a genius now? Because your LP should say, thank you, Jason. They should be sending you a thank you. Some of them are saying that. What I feel smart about, I'll be honest, is we had, I think, let's just say, I'm making up a number here, four out of five times we were offered the opportunity to trim our positions in secondary with our winners from people who wanted to buy secondary shares. I did it probably four out of five times. And I'm just kicking myself.
I didn't do it the fifth, or I didn't ask if they would take more. Because my God, we were able to clear some positions at very high valuations that are now lower than that in the private markets and send cash to our LPs and get our, you know, get over our hurdles and our first two funds, which, you know, I feel smart about. I think that you should feel so, so good about that. That is, that is really hard what you did. And I think people underestimate how hard it is. it is really hard to actually return more money than you have taken it. Yeah. I mean, that's what I'm focused on. Just that simple statement.
And by the way, it was hard in the last 10 years where we've had basically a massive up market, and the four of us, frankly, benefited from the extraordinary luck of being in tech. Yeah, no, it's super lucky. I think the big thing that's going to happen right now, I'm seeing it all over the place, is M&A, I think, is going to start ticking up. Just today, Amazon acquired one medical for $3.9 billion. One medical operates a network of clinics, if you don't know. $3.9 billion enterprise value for 182 franchises, which is $21 million a franchise. Look at what happened to their stock price. No, I know.
I went from 60 in the peak in February of 2021 to 7 in May. And they bought it at 18. They basically bought it at the same price it was trading at in January. No, my point is you could buy a McDonald's franchise for $2 million, or you could buy the company that fixes the people that needed McDonald's for 21 million. That's why they've got such a good deal. By the way, at McDonald's, you can't make money selling pharmaceuticals and upselling, you know, other stuff that Amazon's going to certainly start to. I think it's super interesting that Amazon's getting into this business. Wow. I mean, that is really interesting.
They clearly have an economic model that shows some significant synergy. Retail footprint. Well, yeah. And there may also be kind of a supplement pharmaceutical kind of upgrade opportunity. There's synergy in this business. And think about the synergy between what they're getting is also not just the physical locations, but a network of doctors that can do telehealth. I don't know if you guys have ever used one medical, but they do really, you know, easy zoom telehealth services. And so you could hop on, get a prescription, have it fulfilled by Amazon. It shows up at your doorstep in under an hour.
It'll be an incredible synergy for that business. and probably a real value driver, not just at the core units, but with respect to other things they're going to sell through. Your one medical doctor will provision a blood test. He or she will analyze those blood tests over a telehealth. They will prescribe a better diet. That will be sent to Whole Foods who will then... No, I'm sorry. I'm serious. And then... That's the synergy. You're right. Preventive medicine is eating at Whole Foods. Amazon, it makes so much sense for Amazon to expand into built-out retail footprints Because that business model now gets more and more complete by the day where you become so ingrained and enmeshed in this loop of Amazon services.
What this is really about at the end of the day is the subscription business. Amazon Prime is the driver of Amazon's business. That's going to be the entry point. And this is yet another Amazon Prime lock-in. So I know it sounds silly, but two-day delivery, two-hour delivery, it's all about your subscription. but i will bet you got i will bet you guys a dollar that within a year after closing the deal they're going to massively expand the telehealth footprint of what medical is doing because one medical had to go out and do customer acquisition to go and acquire customers to make money doing telehealth services and they're spending a thousand dollars probably cpa to acquire these customers amazon wanted to do this why didn't google do this amazon's already got the customers they've got 70 million people in the U.
S. By the way, I think another thing, another thing. Google doesn't know how to do messy things in the physical world. They don't know how to do service. I mean, Amazon's been working warehouses. Okay, what about Apple? Apple knows how to do stores. Why is it Apple service? Apple knows how to do four products in a beautifully designed showroom. Apple has like a $40 billion services business now. Amazon knows how to get in the nitty gritty and the nuts and bolts operations and do messy things. Yeah, real world stuff. The other thing that's really interesting about this Amazon deal is that it was done with Bezos not at the helm.
And I think it really, you know, begs the question and begs an answer around, are these guys going to continue to innovate like this? And I think right now the jury's saying yes, they are going to continue to push the synergies they can drive from this business by expanding it to ancillary services and industry. And it's really impressive to see them doing this without Bezos running the day to day. As a shareholder, I feel that. So really great to see. yeah i mean this is where like they could buy doordash uber lyft those kind of real world services they're buying a cheap asset they're buying it just like they do with whole foods they're buying an asset that they're gonna get tremendous leverage and synergy out of very cheap they're buying this company at the same price it was trading at a few months ago yeah no no it's a great deal they have a great ceo at one medical who's a friend of mine amir rubin congrats shout out congrats yeah all right everybody did you wet your beak sucks no i never i never went my beak in the steel dry beak syndrome no i would i would disclose it by the way i'd be taking a victory lap right now if i was in that company i missed it i'm shocked we haven't seen the jcal victory lap he goes on some podcast tells bloomberg that vcs are going to get pinched for insider trading all these tokens and lo and behold on the wall street journal three guys i guess a guy at coinbase got pinched for basically insider trading these token sales uh front running it by buying them in his wallet and stuff and so but where's your victory lap that would be our recurring joke jaykel what's your victory lap do you want to take your victory lap well no i mean i told everybody like if it's a if it smells like a security and people are buying it for that reason for it to appreciate don't be surprised if the sec you know uh starts having tips dropped on them that different vc firms in cahoots with law firms in cahoots with everybody were liquidating their positions we talked about liquidating positions as being the goal of venture capital they created a shadow economy next to securities law and said we're going to just start liquidating these things but under what they made the rules up under which they could liquidate them i'm not picking on any firm or anybody we'll see over time who gets pinched But, you know, if you decide you're going to talk yourself into this is not a security, even though it kind of feels like one that's on you.
That's on you as the person buying the tokens, issuing the tokens, giving the legal briefs on the tokens. I think people suspended disbelief and talked themselves into thinking that they weren't trading securities. And I think the SEC, now that everybody's lost their money, is going to just tick off one firm after another. And it's going to be massive settlements. It's going to be three or four years of litigation. So it's not a victory lap. It's just, it was such an obvious observation. We all saw it. I mean, how do you liquidate your shares in a company that has no product in the world? Like, come on, come on.
People knew what they were doing. If they get the book thrown out and they deserve it. All right, everybody. This has been another amazing episode, even though Saks is going to say it's the worst one. Saks, you like my background? I like it. I do. That's a lake. Is that real? That's lakefront. Is that a Zoom background? Aaron, can I get that in the Zoom pack? Take a photo so we can all use it. Love you, boys. Love you, besties. All right, we're back in the groove. Back at you. Back at you. We'll let your winners ride. Rain Man David Sack. And it said we open source it to the fans, and they've just gone crazy with it.
Love you, besties. Queen of Kinoa. I'm going to win. Let your winners ride. Let your winners ride. I'm going to win. Besties are gone. That's my dog taking a listen to your driveway sex. Oh, man. My habitasher will meet me at play. We should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy because they're all just useless. It's like this sexual tension that they just need to release somehow. Wet your feet. Wet your feet. We need to get merch. I'm doing all it. I'm going all in