Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features a conversation between Ryan Hanley and Mike Crowley, two insurance professionals who share their insights and experiences in the industry. The main topic of the episode is the challenges and opportunities facing independent insurance agencies, particularly in terms of technology adoption and carrier relationships.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Recommendations:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
World-class insurance agency owner, Mike Crowley, joins the podcast to help us define the relationship between agents and carriers. Find more: https://ryanhanley.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Hello everyone and welcome back to the Ryan Hanley show. You won't know this because I've deleted them all, but this is like the seventh time I've tried to start the show and just kept either burping or stumbling over my words. When you podcast, this stuff just happens sometimes.
All right, guys. Let's get into the show. This is a tremendous episode. This is an insurance nerdy deep dive conversation with one of my absolute favorite people in the industry, Mike Crowley, fellow upstate New Yorker, Syracuse guy. What I love about talking to Mike is that there are many aspects of the insurance business that I'm not going to say that we don't agree on, but just how he's building his agency is not how I will build Rogue. We have different opinions, different vantage points, or are interested in building our agencies different ways. But the core of what we believe an insurance agency should be is exactly the same. That's why I love spending time with him. I love talking to him about the business. He's very insightful, very thoughtful. He is a true pro in our space. I love the opportunity to have him on the show.
Okay. Before we get there, got to pay the bills, my friends. We're going to do that by talking just a little bit about The Inside. The Inside documents my journey building Rogue Risk. It is a wide open, transparent, authentic, collaborative effort, a collaborative community of insurance pros talking about what it takes to be successful in this space. We really use documenting my journey of building Rogue Risk as a construct, but it's not what we're talking about every day. We have more than 25 members in the community now. It is a paid community, so you do have to have some skin in the game to be part of it to get this inside look at what's going on.
I feel like the name is almost a little misnomer. I've gotten feedback like, "Oh, these are the insiders and everyone else on the outside." It's not like that. When I came up with the name The Inside, what I was really talking about is, let's talk about the guts of an agency. Let's talk about the inside, about what's actually going on. I wanted it to speak more to the material, to where we're getting our hands into the inside of an insurance business, the struggles, the wins, the losses, and all the things that just don't make sense in the mornings when you wake up stressed as hell because this thing doesn't plug into that thing. How am I going to sell this customer? Oh my God, where'd all the money go? All these different things you have to deal with, and I'm experiencing them for the first time starting my very first scratch agency.
Even though I've been in the space for 15 years, I'm experiencing a lot of these feelings for the very first time. I'm sharing that unique perspective of having been in the space for a long time but going through starting an agency for the first time. It's a wonderful community. We do one-on-ones and all kinds of good stuff. If you want to be part of that community, go to ryanhanley.com/insider. Or just go to my website, ryanhanley.com, and you'll see a button for The Inside. Click that button. You get 14 days free. There's no reason to not check it out. You can cancel at any time. 14 days free. Come in, check it out, watch the videos, be part of the conversations, join the Facebook group, download some of the stuff you have access to. That community helps make this podcast possible as well.
We have great sponsors. Sometimes we do sponsor episodes. Sometimes we talk about The Inside. Today we're talking about The Inside. If you love this show, please subscribe. This promo has been way too long. I apologize for that. I'll cut these down in the future. I love you guys for watching this. Sorry for the long promo, but The Inside is important to me. I think it's important to everyone that's in there. I love you for listening to this. Let's get on to Mike Crowley. Here we go.
The conversation begins
Mike Crowley
The good news is, there are founders, leaders, agency owners in particular, carrier people, and technologists who are really tremendous people. Even if it's from afar, to be able to apprentice for people like Jeff Roy, Chris Paradiso, and Seth, who are probably the three that I watch, I try to watch what they do as closely as I can, the way they connect, the way they interact. What the internet has really given us is the ability to not be so hamstrung by our geographic circumstances. One of those guys lives outside of Toronto, one lives in Connecticut, and the other lives in Ohio, yet I watch what they do, I listen to them, I connect with them, I text with them, and I learn from them every single day. That's the beauty of where we're at in our industry today: we get to learn from such a broader swath of people.
Ryan Hanley
Do you know one thing that those three people specifically do, and they do it differently than most others? They don't shove things down your throat in a way that makes you feel like you need to hurry up and get that shiny object, or you need to do business a whole different way because that's what he's doing. If you don't really pay attention and really dive into their specific agencies, you don't see every little thing that they're doing, but you still want to. There's still that epitome up here where it's like, "All right, I want to run the agency this way. I want to have the tech this way. I want to have all these things." But then I'm not sitting there going, "Ooh, they just signed up for this. I need to sign up for it." It just makes that nice. I don't know. It's different. When you see all this other noise going on, you feel like you're behind because you're not doing this or have this. It's just way too much fluff.
Mike Crowley
I completely understand. I don't know if you saw it or not, but I wrote a LinkedIn post the other day which was basically like, "I'm sorry to the industry for not fully appreciating the technology struggle." I've been talking about it for so long and watching and listening. Now that I'm living it, it's really difficult to not feel like if you don't have this tool or that tool, somehow you're not going to be able to provide this type of service. Then I had this agent on Facebook reach out to me, who is going to remain anonymous because he uses an anonymous Facebook thing. He likes to talk about politics and stuff, but he doesn't want to shove that down anyone's throat.
He sent me an email. He said, "I love all these conversations about technology. But you know how I get Google reviews on Sunday nights? After I put the kids to bed, I open up my email and I copy and paste emails to every account that I wrote that week asking them to send me a Google review. That's my automation. I have a Google doc and I go copy, paste, copy, paste, copy, paste for as many accounts as I wrote that week. That's how I get Google reviews." He said, "So automations are cool, but let's not pretend like they're necessary." It's an interesting vantage point. It's really hard to defend the opposite when we talk about it so much.
Ryan Hanley
Well, it was one of your posts recently about data. I didn't jump in on it. It was a couple days ago. The comments between Cass, Nick, and all sorts of others just exploded. Everyone was agreeing but saying it differently and fighting. What Nick said, I forgot the phrase he used, but it was like, "If people don't change their behavior, it doesn't matter what kind of information we have or what kind of business." I was shocked to see it explode into a 50-comment thing. It's so true. You can implement all these things, but if your clientele — and you know this with your wife's agency — 75% of their clients might not adapt to having a mobile app or this or that. It's great that you can put these things in place, but it doesn't mean that agency or those customers are going to use this stuff.
Mike Crowley
Dude, that post. For those listening at home, that post was newsletter number seven. It was titled "Insurance Has Always Been a Data Business. Now It Matters." The argument I was trying to make, which I think was lost or got morphed in the comments a little bit, was actually building off a conversation Cass had with Chris Burrand. Chris Burrand is brilliant. What he was saying is that the ownership of expirations — and what's funny is Matt Wood, who I adore too, said the ownership of expirations is a contractual term based on between agents and carriers, which I 100% agree. But the core idea of the ownership of expirations is that when someone renews, that's the most important point at which you can retain that business.
At a high level, if we're backing it out, there are other reasons why the ownership of expirations is important. We don't have to get into all those nuances, but at a 30,000-foot view, it's because for a very long time, that was the trigger point at which you could resell that policy and sustain your business and actually grow your business. That's why it was important for the agent to own it and not the carrier, because the carrier could then take that from you, market it, allow someone else to market it. It defined where that data stopped.
Ryan Hanley
Yep.
Mike Crowley
Anyone who's super geeky on this, feel free to hit me up or comment. But at a high level, that's what it was. What Chris Burrand was saying was that because of the access to life moment data that now exists in various different pools, lakes, streams, or whatever water reference you want to use for collections of data, companies can now essentially hop a dry moat. We always want to build moats or lines of defense around our clients in terms of value. Some of that is value to us and value to them, but they're things that keep others from taking our clients or from our clients leaving. Essentially, I was saying the ownership of expirations is becoming a less effective method of defending your client base as your competitors are able to define life moments in your clients' daily activities and market to them in moments of need outside of their expirations.
That's what I was trying to get to. I think I went around it a little too much. I said in there, "There may be a time when the total pool of data that you have is of equal or more value than the actual revenue you generate." That is a bold statement. I'm aware of that. I was being slightly provocative. I wanted to see where it went. But the point is, our ability to mine and use data — our ability to utilize data — is what's valuable. Not just "I'm going to sell my data as a batch thing," but can you take your data and sell that second life insurance policy to the spouse because you know they're about to have another kid?
Can you peel that information out? Can you add additional services through partnerships that really build a trusted advisor relationship? Or is it just, "Oh, Sally's renewing in a month, might want to remarket her"? Those are different things. That's what I was saying. That conversation went so squirrely. It was pretty fun to watch though.
Ryan Hanley
The whole point about expirations — at least on the personal lines sales side, and that's over 50% of our business — I don't care when somebody renews as a new business prospect. I never ask them because I'm not waiting until their renewal. I don't think most of the industry cares. The mindset of "Oh, you're going to renew in July, okay, we're going to re-quote this in June and try to move your home, auto, and umbrella over to our agency" — no. If I have all their information, I'm writing it in the next week, or probably eight to 12 days depending on the carrier, because you get the best pricing that way.
Nobody's waiting to the renewal. Nobody even pays attention as much as they used to of, "Okay, my renewal came out. What's my renewal? What's my bill?" No, they're looking on a month-to-month basis. They're seeing that EFT withdrawal. To the point where they're clueless of what's really going on when it comes to an annual policy period scope. They're looking at their day: "Okay, this just got withdrawn from or charged on my credit card. Why does that seem high?" Oh, it was the same as it was last month and the six months prior to that, but because of whatever their circumstances are in life, they're assuming it's high.
They're assuming it because their buddy or their neighbor just said, "Hey, I only pay $100 a month. Why are you paying $125?" That's good. I was listening to that podcast with Cass, and it's like, yeah, they used to go based off of expirations, but expirations on personal lines in my eyes mean nothing.
Mike Crowley
I think one thing that's important — so we're having this conversation, and the audience is going to hear me say this to you. I've already introduced you, so we don't have to do that whole part. I don't even know where we're recording for a while. I just start from the beginning because a lot of times we get really interesting nuggets that I hate to lose. If you do, "All right, man, are you ready to start?" then you get kind of buttoned up and it changes the whole mood. I'd rather just get right into it. Any trash talking at the beginning, I normally lop off, unless it's about Cass or Nick Ayers, and then I leave it in.
For someone like you, someone like myself, and a lot of the people we talk to on a regular basis, the idea you just referenced is a "duh." Of course. When someone comes in, I help them and we rewrite the policy two weeks out, and bam, we're off to the races. It's easy to lose sight of the fact that there are 36,000 independent agencies in the United States. That number could be, with a standard deviation of about 5,000 one way or the other. Not to mention all the captives, all the quasi captives, all the MGAs. I think that sometimes because of the level and frequency of conversations of the people we tend to hang out with — and I don't mean that as a knock to anyone who doesn't engage as much — I know the groups you're in. I know the people you go to conferences with. You're engaged. You're trying stuff. That ups the bar for what is considered average in your mind. What's average in your mind is much higher than what the average activity would be for most agencies that operate. We just don't ever hear from them, so we tend to not get that perspective as often.
Ryan Hanley
That is 100% true. A good testament to that is probably what you're going through right now. When you're meeting with carrier reps, I heard you talk on your podcast with Bradley Flowers the other day. I listened to it yesterday or whenever it launched. One of the first things you said was that carriers are coming in and questioning, "Am I in this 50%? Am I in this 100%?" The fact that they're even questioning you shows that those carrier people don't pay attention. They don't pay attention to what's going on in the industry. They should have jumped at the chance that, okay, he wants an appointment with us.
We're going to give it to him, whether he's in it 70% or not. Because of what your mindset is, what your experience is, what you're doing, and what your goals are going to be, it's only going to make things easier for the carriers. They come in and meet with me, whether it's on a quarterly or an annual basis, and they leave. They're just sitting there like, "I haven't heard any of this stuff before." I'm looking like I'm so behind the curve because I'm comparing myself against the other people we've been mentioning, and I put myself down at the bottom with them up top. But then when these carrier reps come in, they have no clue.
They're like, "Wow, you're doing this." And I'm like, "Yeah, but I want to do this and this and this, and I'm not really happy with this." But they're comparing it against those 36,000 agents that don't have websites, don't have email, or if they have an email, it's at AOL.com, not at their agency's name. It's tough to always keep yourself in the upper half, or the upper 10th, or that 3% that are actually trying to make the waves and changes for the future. When you get brought down, whether on a local level or state level, and they sit there and say, "Huh, wow, this is what you're doing." When I heard that yesterday, I'm thinking, "Are you kidding me?"
Being another New Yorker, I wanted to be like, "Who are these carrier reps questioning this? Let me call them and yell at them." Because I might know them somehow through the channel. It was crazy to hear that. I can see why they're doing it, but that shouldn't stop them from wanting to give you an appointment. Anybody can get appointments through MGAs or groups or whatever else. Why are you going to limit what you can potentially get when he launches this and puts his foot on the gas and starts writing business? Okay, well, yeah, I missed out the first six months. Well, guess what? He's got a nice rhythm going, and now he might not throw you into the mix, or you're going to be that last choice, and you're done.
Mike Crowley
I want to be fair. I have a three-week span here where I have basically six or seven appointment meetings. I've had two since that episode with Bradley dropped, or since I recorded it. To be fair to at least those two carriers, the focus was a concern going in. I will say that both were very receptive to the business plan that I have. My business plan in a nutshell — there are a lot of different moving parts. An enormous piece of my business plan is the carrier service center. I'm going to leverage carrier service centers. It's part of my business plan. I will take on other agents and VAs before an in-house service rep and push business to service centers.
That means I want to keep a small pool of appointed carriers and only use a wholesaler, which will be Indium. Sareba is part of that, and Chad Eddie runs it. Great people. That will be my wholesale option. When I walk through the business plan with them, this is an interesting thing about agents too. When I told them an enormous part of my business plan is the quality of your service center — and regardless of what you call it, they all call it something a little different — I need to know that it has some integration capabilities, that you're going to be able to cross-sell, upsell, handle the business.
I want to work with the best in class. I can tell that is a hot button item because it immediately changed the conversation for the positive. I don't mean that in a negative way. It immediately changed the conversation because they said, "Wow, we struggle so hard. We put so much time and effort into our service center, and it has such great numbers, but we can't get agents to use it, or at least not as many as we would like." The idea that I was going to build an agency around carrier service centers built into my business model was a game changer for me. I didn't get any no's yet. I have one basically maybe, or basically yes.
I got to go through the process still. Then I have one that's not saying no, which I thought was a win for that particular carrier. For them not to say, "Come back and talk to us in two years," I thought was a big victory as well. I feel like I'm in a good spot. It was interesting to see they were worried about focus, but when I could say, "Look, I get that. Here's how I'm going to address that part. But here's where I want to go." When it started to align with what I think carriers see the future is — leveraging those service centers more — it took down a lot of the obstacles between us. We started having what I thought were very productive conversations.
Ryan Hanley
That's the benefit and the reason the carriers you met with are not seeing the adoption from the independent agent is because you're reversing it. You're building it based off of that versus, "Hey, I'm going to switch my X book into a carrier service center." The problem is I can't switch my A, B, and C book because they don't have one. What they have isn't worth it. Then all of a sudden, I'm 25% in and 75% out. That confuses so much stuff. It's either all or nothing. It's too hard for any agency, let alone established agencies for a long time, to say, "Okay, hold on. We're going to move everything into carriers that have service centers and cut the ties and do that." It's almost impossible.
Mike Crowley
Do you use any carrier service centers?
Ryan Hanley
None. I've told carriers because they come and they push hard. I said, "Listen, you got to stop pushing. I will be the last agent on earth using carrier service."
Mike Crowley
Walk me through besides what you said. Are there other reasons?
Ryan Hanley
The main reason is I see it as a hindrance to the flow that we have. I don't want somebody on my staff to have to be like, "Okay, well, yeah, you need to call this 800 number for a change on your auto policy, but we'll handle your home because it's still in one of these mutual companies where we still handle the service." That mindset, if I bring myself into a customer's mind, is a terrible customer experience. If they don't know exactly where to go, I don't like it. When the carriers came in and said, "We want you guys to stop calling and sending in claims. We want to hear from the client." We said, "No, we're still calling in claims."
Because we want every claim — unless the person can't wait because it's midnight and they can call an 800 number — I want our staff calling in claims because I want to talk to them first. I want to stop the claim from happening when it's something ridiculous and not going to be covered because it's under their deductible. That is one of our value-added processes for our agency. That's why I'm like, the way this industry moves, the way these carriers are, the way my business is kind of separated through them, none of them are all going to have that solution that's going to satisfy us. I'm not going to even entertain the possibility that, "Hey, this one book with a million dollars can get service there, and that's going to free up so much time."
I'd rather pay for more service people. I'd rather do that and instill those processes that makes us better than the service center. That's taking the stuff I'm learning and implementing it and making the experience better because that's the whole focus. 35,100 of those agents in the world aren't doing that yet. We're still in this long-term game where we need to make these changes because of all this stuff around us, but nobody else besides the few hundred or maybe a few thousand are actually looking at doing it. But then again, how many of those 36,000 independent agents are going to be retiring in five years and selling out to somebody else?
And somebody mentioned there's going to be a lot less agents in the future servicing this stuff because of all these different tech stuff coming in. I don't even think it has to do with the tech stuff. I literally think there's gonna be that much less agents because everybody's gonna retire.
Mike Crowley
Yeah. And everyone's gonna consolidate. And now my local town that had five within a mile is going to have one. And then the local town, I mean, so you're going to have maybe a couple small ones, you're going to have a couple medium ones, and you're gonna have a whole bunch of large ones. The only small and medium ones that are going to last are the ones that have those relationships and have the customer experience where they still want to come in and talk to that same agent and work as their advisor.
That's really where I see it. And that's where I am shifting our focus, to make sure we're there. Service centers are never going to get to that point in the state of New York with the carriers that we have. Some of the small ones, you got a lot of domestics. You know the carriers: the New York Central Mutuals of the world, the Adirondacks, the Dryden Mutuals. The nice small carriers that you love doing business with because they write a good product, they take care of claims, they do all these things. We have nice books with them that are always profitable. These carriers aren't going to switch their focus and try and create service centers to offset these things. They're not big enough, and nor are all the agents going to use them.
If half or a quarter of our book is in these handful of five carriers that are never going to do that, we're never going to sway that. We're going to still be that local hometown agency that you can walk in and, hate to say it, still pay cash and pay for your premium. I'm not going to tell the lady that's been here for 55 years, "Hey, I know you've been paying annually every year with cash for your home and auto, and you come in and your hundred dollar bills are starting to fade, but we're not going to do that anymore." You can't come in anymore. That's not the experience we want to give her or any new customer. If that's what is convenient for them, we're not going to force them to do it. We're still going to be here to allow it.
Ryan Hanley
I think that, and I mean this in the most positive sense, I think that is a very noble way to go about handling what's going on. I mean that in the most positive sense, not in a patronizing way. I think there's only a couple of ways that you can go, man.
I think what's going to happen is peak independent agency influence. I think independent agency influence in the marketplace is on the rise. I'm bullish on independent agency influence. I am bearish on independent agencies in terms of their scale. I think the number of agencies is going to go down. I think you're going to see consolidation. And I think you're going to get a barbell effect. You're going to get agencies like what I'm trying to build, which is going to be more sales focused, a smaller force, very sales heavy. I want a service person to be towards the end of my hires. The first couple of hires, I want to be other individuals who are going to be out producing business. A lean, mean fighting machine, I guess you could say.
I think you're also going to have a lot of big, consolidated agencies owned by either PEs or agencies that have scooped up all over the place. I think what's going to be really difficult is that middle-sized agency to exist. Now, I think in towns like where you are, there are pockets where they'll survive. I think New England, they'll do better because there's so many highly populated pocket towns where you can do tremendous work for a community, make a great living, employ people, and be perfectly fine. I think as you spread out West and the towns become farther away from each other, sparser, it becomes much more difficult to have that middle-sized agency where you have all the payroll, but you're also competing as some of the big guys push down into the smaller markets and the little guys are able to extend up a little bit. The middle-sized agencies are the ones that are really going to have to do the most work to survive. That's what I'm seeing and why I made the decisions that I made and how I'm constructing Rogue.
Mike Crowley
That's absolutely the way it's going to be. I see that middle agent. If you're not already making changes, it's either going to hurt the future of your specific agency, or I think it hurts the value of the sale of your agency. I look at that as somebody that will go buy up those small people, that will still take those long-time clients that that person had that still wants a local person. But what I'm willing to pay and what I want to pay in my local community for these things is going to be tied really close to what you've done the last five years. Is your book slowly going upward? Is it staying even? Or is it slowly dying?
There's a lot of those agencies that I think are just slowly dying and barely hanging on. I see them and I hear them and I network with them. It's like, you guys are 65, 70, 73 years old, whatever the case may be, you're just riding this out. And it looks like you're miserable because you have to grind to make ends meet to reach what you did last year because expenses just go up. Try and do something. If you're not going to bring somebody in to help grow the agency, get out of it now. Take top dollar if you can, hang out for a little while, and then just retire.
There are too many that still have a nice comfortable life that they don't think they need to do anything. They made this amount last year and they're going to make 4% less this year, and then 4%, 5% the next year, and just slowly grow. But it's still very comfortable to them. So they're like, "Well, I'm not ready to just sit home." And there are so many of those still here. Either the large big ones, the multiple hundred employee agencies that have their hand all over the place, are going to buy them up and those clients are just going to get thrown in, or you're going to have people like myself or any other middle ground ones that are starting to establish a culture and an experience for clients that people are going to want to come to.
There's a reason captives are going independent. That train is not going to stop. Nationwide started it. Other ones are going to follow suit. I mean, Allstate just sent out that letter. That's very ominous, right? 2021, who the hell knows what's going to happen? I had a question from somebody who called and they're like, "You want to talk to Allstate?" And I'm thinking, I get enough emails or LinkedIn messages from carrier people all the time. "Hey, you want to have a meeting to talk about adding another carrier?" Listen, I don't need any more carriers. If one carrier starts to slack in the state of New York and I need to make some changes, and I have a way to look in, I will definitely look. Or if you're starting to kick butt and you've been kicking butt for a few years and you're still on that train, okay, maybe I got to look at you because I'm not going to miss out on the opportunity to grow a book.
We added one a few months ago. I'd say 50% of our new business has been going to them because they have the product, they have the pricing, they have all the back-end service stuff that is excellent. I did a bunch of research before adding them. I said, "You know what? I'm not losing business to it, but I'm losing prospects because of what you have." And I don't want that. I have the prospect. And like I've said, and I'll continue to say, the customer isn't a customer of the carriers.
Ryan Hanley
This is huge. I will shout this from a rooftop.
Mike Crowley
If I have another product and I tell somebody to jump, we're moving here, they're going to jump. To me, that means we own the customer. I want to make sure that I have the right products so that my customers will keep listening to me and we can move them to what we need to move them based on what their needs are in their life.
It's going to be interesting, but I think that this train is going to take a little bit longer than some of the people that we communicate with on a regular basis are thinking. People are like, "Oh man, it's already started and it's going to be next year and it's going to be in the next..." No. There's going to be still so many agents that aren't doing anything five to seven years from now. The only way is if there becomes a bigger shift in the gap between us and carriers. If us and carriers don't figure a way to improve the partnership and it keeps dividing in certain ways, that's when we start to see some things change.
Ryan Hanley
Can I ask you, I'd love to know what the carrier is that you took on, but you don't have to share that information unless you want to. I'm interested in your research process for choosing them beyond just seeing them in the market. When you're considering that new carrier that you just took on a couple months ago, what is that research process for you? Where are you going? What are you looking at? How are you formulating, "Okay, we're ready to take on another carrier"?
Mike Crowley
Claims. Claims is 100% the only thing that I care about when it comes to the carrier. Obviously, pricing stability makes a nice difference. The problem is over half my carriers don't have pricing stability. We're great for two years, we have a 12% increase. It's this roller coaster of pricing. You can say, "I'm only going to keep these four carriers because their pricing stability is good, and it's going to keep my overhead down because I'm not going to have to remarket and do any of this stuff." But for me, it's, "Okay, once I give you a customer of mine, what problems am I going to have that you cause?"
My number one, number two, and number three in my eyes are claims. If I file a claim for my client that has the coverage, are you fast? Are you reasonable? I'm not expecting Lemonade-type claims, but I'm expecting, do I have to get involved and start following up on your adjusters to make them make a phone call? I've tweeted this before and I tag him all the time. Every claims person needs the John Bachman attitude of claims. I told him before, I'm like, "You need to go train claims people all across the country because people are not doing a good enough job training them." The experience that the client is going through, they need to massage that. Half of that job is bedside manner. You need to make sure that the person feels comfortable. You're walking them through, letting them know this is a process, this is a step. They can't ghost them. They can't just not return their phone call, because then we get the phone call and then we have to get involved. Then I got to stop everything I'm doing to take care of this because this is a big client of mine and I want to make sure their claim gets handled appropriately.
The least amount of work that I have to do after a claim is filed, I want to follow up with a customer and be like, "Hey, I just want to make sure everything's going smooth." And for them to say, "Everything's great. We got our check yesterday." I don't want to have to get so much involved.
So if I talked to other agents and I was finding out, "How's the claim service?" "Oh, claim service is great." "Okay, great. Next agent." Me being so involved in some of the local insurance agency association type stuff has allowed relationships with other agency owners where I can say, "How long have you had this company? Bad experience? Good experience?" I can get their true opinion, off the record, about a certain carrier before I jump on. And it worked.
I probably had about three more since we added that one reach out. They're like, "Hey, we're looking to add you." Again, it's because if their territory is central New York area and they're looking at me like, "Who are we going to add?" I got my job this year is to add five new agents and get them to grow. Who are you going to add that you don't already have? The state of New York probably jumped when they said, "Oh my god, there's another person that wants to start an agency." People aren't starting agencies in New York. These guys are stuck trying to figure out how they're going to get more business because that's their job on the line. So they're reaching out to the people that are actually trying to do something and growing, versus the big shops that have everybody. When you look at the small shops, these ones are not growing or not doing anything. And then there's maybe three in the middle. There's not many things that can separate.
There are so many things that are separating yourself that the carriers are throwing themselves at you. When they've called, I've said, "Listen, you know that, 'Hey, you need $500,000 in three years,' or you need this, all these old school guidelines of, 'We need volume or we need that.'" I'm thinking, I don't do that. I don't go buy any of those. You'll get opportunities. It's up to you to have the product that allows us. We're growing X number of percent a year. You can see that, that's why you're here. But if your product stinks in Syracuse, New York, it might be great 15 miles this way or 20 miles that way. The bulk of our business is here. If you're not competitive, you're not going to get any product. For you to expect us to say, "Okay, yeah, we'll get you $500 in three years," no, that's not going to happen. They might hem and haw, but they're like, "Just quote us. That's all we care about. We just got to show that you're giving us the opportunities."
Ryan Hanley
I got one of the carriers that I talked to. They were very interested in adding me on commercial lines, which is awesome because they were a high target. They were one of the carriers that was high on my target list. So that was very fun. But then when the conversation switched to personal lines, they're like, "Wow, you know, we're $500,000 in three years." I'm just like, "Really? What if I give you $325? What if I do $250 and it's all good, profitable business? Is that a bad thing?" I don't know. That's where you get that old mindset. It's the mindset I talked about of, "Oh, should we add Ryan as a person or as an agency here? Is he doing this full-time or is he still consulting on the side?" Are you kidding me? If you're gonna write $250,000 in good business that's good for the carrier and that's only gonna grow, why wouldn't you take that on? Besides some paperwork and a few other little things, there's no expense to add an agent at all. I understand you don't want to be on every street corner, but that means you should pick the people that are doing the things that are going to help your company grow.
I've had a few conversations with the commercial rating platform that you're signing up for, Tarmika. Awesome guys. The fact that every carrier isn't throwing themselves at them to get on that just shows you their mindset and where things are. I even asked them, "Okay, where's the big expense on this?" They're like, "Well, it just depends on their technology, but we can help them and we'll give it back to them." I'm thinking, why wouldn't any carrier do this? To me, it should be one phone call and every single person should just jump on it, but they don't care.
Mike Crowley
Dude, from my TrustedChoice.com days and Bold Penguin days, I can just tell you that decision doesn't happen because of a thousand... You never hear "death by a thousand cuts." It's death by a thousand decisions. That's why that doesn't happen. It's not that intrinsically any one person isn't like, "We should be there." Or, "Pick the tool." It's that, and some of it just comes down to straight, "No, I'm not going to get my bonus this year because I killed myself to integrate with that tool."
Take Travelers, right? Travelers isn't yet on Tarmika. Hopefully they will be soon. If there's someone listening to this who works for Travelers, please email whoever possible and say, "This is a tool you need to be on." Because I can tell you firsthand, excluding myself, some of the best agents in the entire country are either going to be signing up with Tarmika or are circling around Tarmika right now as a potential resource for them. It is worth your time and effort.
For you and I to sit here, we're like, "Why isn't Travelers on this platform yet? This is silly. Just take your technology, plug it in, go." But you're not dealing with Travelers. You're dealing with John and Harry and Tammy and Sally, who have to all make sure that this doesn't get them fired. Adding a new tool doesn't get anyone a raise. All it does is create risk in their life to get them fired. This is why I've always really... and it's nothing against Travelers, there's great people that work there. It's just very legitimately, and you and I if we worked there would operate the exact same way. Does putting your neck out on the line to integrate with a tool that could help your agents, for sure, how much risk am I creating in my career by doing that? You are expending social and political capital internally in order to say, "Hey, I think we should be on that tool." That's human survival instinct in a company that big.
It's one of the reasons I've always really enjoyed operating with the super regional carriers. Because even though in some cases they're still behind, still slow, it's Sean or it's Kevin or it's Steve. If you can get that person, or it's Sally or Cindy, if you can get that person to believe in what you're doing, they can execute on it and make it happen. Though sometimes that's a harder sell, at the same time, they know that making that decision isn't usually about "will I get fired?" They're usually operating in what they believe is best for agents versus their ability to allocate resources. That's a much different equation than "if I say yes to this project, will I get fired?" Both have challenges when trying to get someone to make an integration, but they're very different.
I started this by saying I wrote this post about apologizing. And I do apologize. I apologize profusely. I am epically sorry for not fully empathizing with the stress and strain that comes with choosing the right technology. But I love the way that you approach the game, man. I'll be honest with you, some of the things you're saying, I don't a hundred percent... I wouldn't build my business that way and won't build my business that way, but I don't think that you're wrong. When I said it's noble, I mean it in the truest and most positive sense. I love that you are going that way because I do believe it is one of the paths to success. I believe there are many, many, many paths. I absolutely positively believe that you are on the right path because you also, and we didn't really touch about this very much so far, and it's kind of where I'd like to go. You do so much. As much as you're taking cash from the 87-year-old woman who's been there for 50 years, you're also crushing the content game. You're working on automations. You're having conversations with different tools to help you automate your business.
So what I'd love to know is, how does an agency like yours, who is on a path that you just described, which is much more high touch, much more in-house, which is amazing, how do you marry that philosophy with all the new tools? When you're looking at them, how are you evaluating them? How are you thinking about integrating them while maintaining the virtues that make your business special?
Slowly. This is the insurance nerd of me. I see these things. I see what's very valuable. I see how it's going to intertwine into the sales process or the service process within our agency, not necessarily what I think the industry is definitely going to do. I think it's awesome that some people are able to automate their agencies to almost nothing. I had this conversation, and I got no problem telling the company's name: Rocket Referrals. Rocket Referrals is a great software program. I signed up for it years ago. But after about 18 months, two years, I stopped it. Why? Because the garbage that we had in our management system at the time basically produced garbage. As Cass says, garbage in, garbage out. I got off of the software. When I talked to them again, I said, "This is the reason I did this." It had nothing to do with their program. It had to do with ours.
I couldn't set their program, which is meant to be fully automated, set it and forget it, and all of a sudden you start getting different things in. I couldn't set it up on automation. I had to manually go in every single day to see what happened, what's going on, and personally send out, "Okay, we're going to send these out. We're going to send this out. We're going to send that out." After a while, I just got tired of it and didn't do it. Did it work? Sure. But that was just one thing.
When you're doing these things, as much as all these systems and things look awesome and everybody's watching it, it's almost like that shiny object. You really got to bring it back to saying, "Okay, how is this going to affect your clients? How is it going to affect your sales process? How is it going to affect this?" If it's not going to make your life easier, your staff's life easier, your client's life easier, it's not worth it right now. Put that in the list of maybe next year or maybe two years from now.
For me, a lot of the stuff that I tried to implement and put in was really initially to help my process. I still handle 90% of our sales. Being still the new business sales, I focus a lot on some of the marketing aspects to make sure that this is going to help me now, and it's also going to help me down the road. It's going to help build a personal brand along with an agency brand. It's going to allow me to do all these different things that are going to help grow the agency without potentially knocking on doors or cold calling. As that started to work and some things started to happen, then it's like, "All right, what tools can I implement in my staff's day-to-day that's going to help offset some things, clean up some things, and make things easier?"
The guy you mentioned earlier, how am I going to get Google reviews without having something like Rocket Referrals set up on automation? Okay, well, why don't you build in your own? So I built in five different layers of where we ask for Google reviews. Some of it's automated, some of it's manual, but everybody knows and everyone's on those systems. It's taken a while, obviously, because you test it and see what's working. If it's not working, you stop it and fix it and relaunch it. It's worked out really well.
In my eyes, as somebody that is a constant studier of the industry and a studier of others in the industry, especially the ones that I respect really highly, I always feel I'm 10 steps behind. So it motivates me to try and catch up. At least that way I can always be testing and thinking about new things, but I'm not driving my staff crazy. I'm not tearing down all our processes and having to rebuild them and tear them down again and rebuild them up again. The goal is to do that once, maybe do some tweaks, and then we're done.
We just had this conversation in our agency over the last few weeks at the end of the year. It was basically, "We're doing this project that we're doing so we never have to do it again." This isn't like, "Hey, we're going to do this every year between Christmas and New Year's when it's a little slow." No, no. We're doing some of this stuff now because we're never going to have to do it again because the process now prevents us from having to do this again. It's just one little aspect and one little layer. We just keep making those steps and moving them forward. But you got to go somewhere. You got to do something. You can't just keep jotting these stuff down and hope that you're going to eventually get there. You got to pick a thing.
A perfect example, and it's great that you're going to be at the conference next week and all that kind of stuff, and seeing some of the questions you probably see within that Facebook community group. One of the questions and one of the topics all the time is, "When you go to a conference, what are you looking to get?" You can't sit there and drink from a fire hose and go back to your agency and let nothing get done. You really have to go and say, "Okay, I'm thinking of two or three things that I want to take out of here, and I'm going to go implement them before the end of February." When that works, then maybe I'll touch base and reach out to a couple of the speakers or people that maybe are doing some other things, but that's not on my list.
I remember the first conference I ever went to about three, four years ago. I came back with all sorts of ideas and I was jacked up and ready to roll. Nothing got done. Nothing for 10 months. I had 15 different projects started, nothing got finished, nothing moved forward. Finally I had to sit there and I was like, "Wow, that's not good." So the next conference I go to, I'm going to start over and this is what I'm going to look to do. I'm going to learn how to do this, where I'm going to figure out this person that I can always reach out to as a contact that's a specialty in this area or whatever. That's kind of been my mindset. It's worked so far. We keep making those steps forward so that someday, whether it's three years from now or five years from now, I feel a lot more comfortable where our tech is and where our marketing is and where our processes are. Maybe you look back and you're like, "Wow, okay, that was good," but I didn't do a full overhaul within 18 months. It's been a fun ride and a fun process. I look forward to learning new things.
The problem is everything you learn and change three years from now, it's going to change again. You always got to stay on your toes, but I like to be on my toes. There's too many people in this industry that just sat back and got comfortable and just coasted. I don't want that. I want to be able to always have my foot on the gas pedal driving forward just because it's going to motivate me to keep going. Hopefully someday, maybe my kids will want to come into the business and turn that third generation into a fourth generation.
Ryan Hanley
It lets you own your future too. That's the part for me. I've lived the opposite life, right?
Like I've worked for other people and I've had some tremendous experiences. But when you're driving forward, you own your destiny. Sometimes people knock you down, but you get back up. When you start to relax and take it easy, it's much easier for life to push you around.
I want to be respectful of your time, so I'm going to wrap it up. I want to share this with you. Dave Iadonzo from Giant Mutual — I talk to him every once in a while. He reached out to me, talking about the domestic market, pitching me on Dryden a little bit because he's a good salesman. I say that in jest — he's a super good guy. We were mostly talking about business.
I said to him, and I'm taking this back to what you were saying about chasing tools and chasing things, I have this martyr syndrome where the decisions I make, I feel like I'm making a decision for the industry. Because I know I'm going to talk about the things I choose or the tools I use. I've had this pressure building inside me the last few weeks. Of course I choose to document my journey because I'm a freaking a-hole and I can't help myself. Some of it is self-imposed, that's fair criticism.
But I've had this pressure because there are certain tools I would love to consider that in our crew would be considered like, "Oh, why would you even think about them? They're part of the evil empire." I was talking to Dave about this frustration. He's got this way — even though we were talking on the phone, I felt like he swiveled in his chair and made eye contact with me. He called me young man. He said, "Young man, it's time you start making decisions for yourself."
I was like a bucket of cold water was dumped over my head. The reason I share that is through this process of mapping out the vision for the agency, then the business plan for launching, then the nuts and bolts of implementation, it is so incredibly easy to want to chase the new, hot, fresh tool that if it hits, you were on the wave at the very beginning. It's very difficult to not get sucked into that mentality when there are tried and true established tools that aren't as sexy. No one's writing InsurTech exposés on them, but they get the job done.
I've had to do soul searching around that idea of how do I make sure I'm making a decision for the right reasons? The right reasons are establishing an agency that takes care of my family for the next decade and a half, which is why I started this agency in the first place. That's been weird to deal with.
Mike Crowley
Well, Trident Mutual is a company that is that. They're not the sexy new tool. But they are so consistent. They are so good at their niche products. We grew 25% with them this year, last year. And we've had them for years. It's just because they're that good. You get the thing that crosses your desk, you're not going to load it into Tarmica and say, "Where is this going to go?" No. You call, go to their online rater, or you know the rates off the top of your head. You're like, "No, this is going to Dryden." That is who they are. That is great for the agency. It's tough because I can see how you would have the mindset of "This is where I'm building, this is where I'm going." But man, that is just so consistent over there.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. The truth is, I look at what Dryden does. I used to write Dryden products when I worked at the group, and I know exactly who they are. I think to myself, does it make headline presses for anybody if I take an appointment with Dryden? No. No one gives two flying shits. Is it going to help my... most people don't even know who they are. It's a single state domestic in New York that mostly writes upstate. But having worked with them before and knowing exactly who they are and what they do, I feel like I would be an a-hole if I didn't have them as part of my product mix. The niches they have are easy to market to — you can create targeted marketing, drive them in, provide good service. There's plenty of opportunity to cross sell those people into other products.
I'm talking through personal experience, but I know other people struggle with these things. It's so easy to want to do that thing that feels like what you should be doing when really, all we should ever be thinking about — I think it's good to think about the industry as a whole, consider it, support the projects that help the industry grow. But at the end of the day, we got to do what's best for the business that puts food on our table. I'm as much speaking to myself as I am to anybody, but that's been a lesson.
Mike Crowley
A great example of this is I tried to partner with the state association because it's so much easier, or at least you think it is, to have associations be the voice of the agent to the carriers. It goes back to that comment you had: "Well, we're not hearing this from our agents." That's because the agents aren't going to be able to call you Steve or Tammy and Sue in this department at this one carrier, especially on a national level, and say the agents in upstate New York have an issue with this.
One of the projects I was working on was basically, "You guys need to improve your online picture." Some of these carriers that we represent that we love, when you go to the general public, they have no clue who they are. They're like, "Oh, wait, this isn't Geico and State Farm and Allstate. I got to go search them." And when they go search them, you find every negative thing possible because that's what you find with every carrier online.
I basically said, "The fact that I have to present your product and then when the customer looks at things, I have to defend your product — you need to take focus off whatever projects you're on and say, for the next three months, we're going to put a little focus on building up our online presence." They can't even do that.
This was 18 months ago that I started to try and push this product. When the association goes and talks, they hear the same thing: "Oh, well, our agents aren't complaining about this." Well, it's because they're too afraid to say anything to you because they think you're the big, bad people that control their destiny. For me, it's like, "Your online presence sucks. Mine is great. I'm not going to let you ruin mine and potentially grow my book of business because I want to present your product to them. Either improve, or I'm not going to present your product anymore."
It goes back to, "Is the claim experience good for me? So it's less work for me. How's the new business process?" The new business process sucks because when they go and search your carrier, nobody's ever heard of them. Some people have never heard of Travelers. Some people have never heard of other insurance carriers we represent because they don't pay attention to insurance carriers. If you don't spend billions on advertising, they don't know who you are. If you're using us to advertise your product, you at least need to improve what your online presence looks like.
Ryan Hanley
One of my favorite carriers that I've used in the example forever is New York Central Mutual. I love them. Great carrier. So steady. Consistency is a hallmark of theirs. They do a good job on claims. Well-run company. But when you push a proposal for New York Central Mutual with that old ass looking train logo across the table to someone, they're like, "What kind of podunk country insurance bullshit are you trying to sell me?" In your mind, you're like, "Holy, these guys qualified for New York Central's preferred program. They don't realize they just hit the freaking jackpot. They're never going to have to switch their insurance again for like a decade." And the client's mind is, "This paper ain't worth to wipe my ass with it." They have no idea. That second sale.
In New York, it's a tough example because they have been in the state for so long that anyone Westchester North, there's a good chance they've bumped into them at some point. They're a single state domestic, so they're only in New York and they don't have the marketing budget to run the campaigns. But the idea that they would — and they have done some branding, which is a good thing — if they just got out ahead of that sale a little bit or gave you a little bit more in terms of frontline branding, when you push that across the table, New Yorkers could go, "Whoa, I qualify for New York Central Mutual. I've seen them. This is pretty cool. Thanks, man. I'm excited for this."
That to me is a ways off, but if that mentality could be grabbed onto a little bit more. And for everyone working at New York Central Mutual, I love you guys. Don't get me wrong. I'm using you as an example out of love. But there's so much opportunity there if the agent doesn't have to do the second sale to write more business because it tears down a whole additional obstacle. They're definitely making strides.
Mike Crowley
I echo everything you said about them. That's where I have all my insurance, personal insurance. But the thing is, and I don't even know if you know this, they are the seventh largest auto insurance writer in the state of New York.
Ryan Hanley
I knew they were high. I didn't know seven.
Mike Crowley
Yeah. If you look at the six above them, you would think Geico or State Farm. They're probably the second when it comes to independent size, Travelers. You look at that and it's like, wow, they write and they're bigger than you think. They are doing a good job starting to brand. There's TV commercials, radio ads. They're doing some social media pushing. They got the JD Power award two years in a row for customer satisfaction. Whatever that really is, they're pushing all those things.
The problem is, what is the 28-year-old buying this first house doing after you present, "Here's your new auto and home for your new house. Here's all your coverages. You're sitting there thinking this is a great preferred product. You're good." He goes and searches them and there's negative reviews online.
I had a personal injury attorney once tell me he did not want to do business with them because they give him a hard time when he's trying to get money from them from other personal injury cases. I said, "You mean because they're actually defending their clients?" He said, "Yeah." I said, "You just gave me the best referral for a review of them that anybody could ever want. They're not just paying people to pay them. They're actually defending their claims and doing the claim process. It's just not good for your bottom line pocket, and that's why you're angry about it." I said, "Thank you. I won't give you this product, but everybody else can get it and be completely satisfied."
It's not that they don't want to do that. The problem is they got a list of 35 things they want to do, like every other business. They put that at number 30.
Ryan Hanley
The truth is, you already said it. I would rather be working with a carrier with stable prices, a great product, and good claims handling than a product where I'd rather have to do the second sale for a carrier and have those other three things be dialed in. It's all about levers again. It's easy for dudes pontificating on a podcast, but I do think trying to do what you've done with your agency step-by-step over time — and I use New York Central Mutual as an example because I know they're working hard and getting their brand out into the space while maintaining. So many other carriers fly into New York State with rock bottom prices. They're there for a year, maybe two. Then all of a sudden, 15, 20, 40% increases on renewal. And then they're gone.
Dude, this has been tremendous. We went so many different places. I didn't give you an agenda. I just said, "Yo, bro, let's jump on the podcast." This has been awesome. I think everyone listening at home will have enjoyed it as much as I just enjoyed having this rap with you.
Mike Crowley
Yeah, that was good.
Ryan Hanley
People want to check you out, connect with you. You're one of the guys in the industry that I think is doing things the absolute right way. I love your mentality. I'm not going to build my agency the same way, but I respect the hell out of the way you're building yours because I know you're doing it from the way you want to build it and with intention. I think that's what's important. There's so many places where we do cross too. Where can people connect with you and get to know you better? Where's the best place to find more?
Mike Crowley
Any social media channel works really well. I'm active on all of them depending on the situation. LinkedIn right now is definitely getting most of my attention because anything you push on there, you're getting huge return on your time. That goes for anyone that wants to create content. There's posts that I put on there that I don't think twice about now, like I used to, of being like, "Is this valuable to anybody?" No, this was valuable to me. So if it was valuable to me, then maybe it'll be valuable to somebody. Where you post it on Facebook or another social media platform, 25 people might see it, or 57 people might see it. All of a sudden you post it on LinkedIn, you could have thousands within a day. There's people connecting from all over the place. That's probably my go-to right now where I can kind of connect with people, but definitely any social media platform works.
Ryan Hanley
Awesome. Well, dude, I appreciate your time. I appreciate you sharing so much of what you have going on with the audience. I look forward to seeing you out in San Diego. We only live two hours from each other and we have to take eight-hour plane rides to see each other in person. We'll remedy that here in upstate New York pretty soon once we get established. When are you flying in?
Mike Crowley
I get in Thursday at 10:30.
Ryan Hanley
What flight? Where are you connecting?
Mike Crowley
I don't know. Delta. I'm Delta. So maybe Detroit.
Ryan Hanley
All right, we might be on the same plane out of Detroit. Oh, booyah.
Mike Crowley
I mean, I'm not flying first class like you, bro. I'm back in steerage.
Ryan Hanley
Come on, you got the Delta miles still.
Mike Crowley
You gotta... I used them all up at the end of the major speaking career. You're like, "No, I'm flying first class everywhere. I got to use up these miles."
Ryan Hanley
Exactly. All right, dude, I'll catch you, man. Later. Everyone listening at home, thank you for watching. Thank you for listening. I love you for listening. We're out of here. Thank you.
End of interview
[Advertisement] Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close System, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today.