Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features a conversation between Ryan Hanley and Matt Namoli, co-founder of GNN Insurance. The main topic of the conversation is what it means to sell an insurance agency and dispelling myths around the process. Matt shares his experience of selling GNN Insurance to The Hill Group in 2019, and the lessons he learned throughout the process.
Key Points
Participants
Takeaways
Additional Insights
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Matt Naimoli, the co-founder of G&N Insurance and Bobble On, joins the podcast to dispel the many myths surrounding selling an agency.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Thank you. Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the show. My name is Ryan Hanley. I am your host, and today I have a tremendous conversation with Matt Naimoli, one of the co-founders of G&N Insurance. Matt came on the show to talk about a bunch of things. It takes me a while to get there, but most importantly, he wanted to talk about what it means to sell your agency and dispel some myths around what that looks like, what your life looks like on the other side of a sale, and how you can sell your agency in a way that allows you to still be connected and motivated and inspired by the work going on there beyond the purchase, beyond transitioning out of being the owner of that agency.
This is deep stuff that I think is going to open your eyes to a whole new world of potential for what it means to be an insurance professional. I'm incredibly honored that he would come on the show and share that. Before we get there, I want to talk about my friends at Tarmica real quick. My Tarmica portal is dropping this week. I'm going to be talking about that. So you're going to see me posting some pictures and I'm going to be running a ton of traffic into that thing and really beating it up. I think Tarmica gives independent insurance agents the competitive advantage that they've always needed, but never been able to have. It is a one of a kind, best in class technology and I am honored to be part of it at such an early stage. I think it's something you should give a look to as well. Go to Tarmica.com. That's T-A-R-M-I-K-A.com to check it out. Get a demo. It's worth knowing about this tool even if it's not the right time for you right now. Go to T-A-R-M-I-K-A.com today.
All right, let's get to Matt. So what's going on, man?
Matt Naimoli
We're hustling, trying to do our best to keep the team pretty jazzed up and unified and just connected as much as possible virtually. Business is good. I mean, we are definitely busy right now. I think we'll probably see a little bit of a lag in a few weeks, but right now things are kind of moving along. But I feel for a lot of people. A lot of our clients are calling up just asking about bill plan deferment and if they can reduce coverage, stuff like that. So on a professional front, we're doing the best we can. Obviously there are benefits for being in the insurance space, but no one's immune to it. I think we're all just a little bit on edge, just kind of waiting to see the impact it has on a lot of people.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I think there are direct financial implications. There are obviously health implications, lifestyle implications for sure, implications in how we relate to one another, our relationships. I don't know if you've been to the store. I'm still not mixing with people, but obviously you still got to go to the store and get stuff. And when you do that, there is a level of... paranoia is not completely the right word. Scrutiny, skepticism. I don't know that any of those are the exact right word I'm looking for, but people look at you like, "Are you sick?" You know what I mean? That's the look you're getting from people.
Matt Naimoli
Yeah, you're nervous to sneeze.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. And I think I'm worried about that because in general, I don't know that our culture is at its friendliest moment in history. Not that it's the unfriendliest, but certainly people feel isolated. I have a general cynicism I think a lot of people face every single day. And this is not helping with that in any regard. When we come out of this, I think it's only going to be worse because one of our mutual buddies, Grant Botma, had a really good... I'm sure he posted other places, but I saw it on Twitter, a little stream of tweets talking about how once we're kind of getting let out of our homes, which has to happen in some regard or the country just isn't going to exist anymore from an economic standpoint, how when we start engaging with each other, we have to be cognizant of each other's fears. I thought that was a really interesting thought because I don't know that we've ever dealt with anything like this before.
Matt Naimoli
Yeah, man, you bring up a really good point. I guess maybe it's just the optimist in me, but I almost feel the opposite. We both live in the Northeast, right? I think the summers to me, I love living in the Northeast in New England because I think the summers are so much sweeter because of the winter. I feel like we're in the winter right now in this type of environment. I think people will come out and appreciate connection and community a lot more because they've been without it. So I'm hopeful that people look at interconnectedness and community and companionship in another light.
Ryan Hanley
I would like to say I'm hopeful as well for that. I am normally a tremendous optimist, but my gut is telling me that that's not what's going to happen without real leadership and cultivation of those activities. Speaking to the audience that we're talking to today, in particular insurance agents, I think that we're in a unique position to be those community leaders. It's not a role that I think many of us would ask for, but I do think that the sustainable nature of our business removes one primary stress. At least to a relative level, we have less financial stress than most industries. There's no massive insurance carrier or agency layoffs.
People who work in restaurants or construction workers or some of these other industries are literally can't pay the bills. These people are out on the streets. I think that creates a responsibility for us to help nurture people back into the world. Because I don't think people are just going to come out of their house and be like, "Oh, let's all get together and kumbaya." I think people are still going to be scared shitless when they come out of their house. They're going to do it because they're so sick of being stuck in their house, but I'm very worried about what the temperature of our communities are going to be when people aren't working and they're nervous as hell.
Matt Naimoli
I hear you. Time will tell. I think you're right though. I think local leadership will take on another form. It'll take on an importance that it hasn't in the past. I think that's kind of what I heard from you: local leadership is really important. You never have too small of a company, too small of an organization, too small of a community to be an effective leader. Sometimes when there's a vacuum, people fill that. I've seen a lot of the governors, the state governors who have really stepped up, some of the mayors that have been really positive, transparent, extremely candid, honest with the community. I think people really like that. They're consistent with the messaging. They don't sugarcoat anything. They're being very straightforward with the population. We're going through some tough times. It might get worse, but if we stick together and we continue to move forward, we take care of one another, and we stay separate for now, we'll be able to come together in the future. So it's been somewhat inspiring to see local leadership step up.
Ryan Hanley
I would agree with that point wholeheartedly. I can't speak for other governors, but our governor here in New York, Andrew Cuomo, who I have not been a tremendous fan of because in general he trends towards socialist tendencies, which is probably the number one no-no in Ryan's political book, his handling of this crisis has been as good as he could, all things considered. I think that's an exciting part of this: people are reengaging with their local governments. They're reengaging with some of these local leaders that often get overshadowed when everything is good. I don't want to spend too much time on this particular topic. I think we've probably already spent too much, but I did think it was important here at the beginning of our conversation just to address what's going on.
Matt Naimoli
Yeah, your thoughts, because it's not one of those things that you can just say, "We're not going to talk about that."
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, you can't ignore it.
Matt Naimoli
You can't ignore it. Just with our teams, in our weekly meetings or our check-ins in the morning or our huddles, whatever virtual huddles with our team, we're never going to just jump in and be like, "Okay guys, you had 13 sales last week or 47 service calls." We're going to address the elephant. "How is everyone doing? How are we feeling? What struggles and challenges are we running into? Any fears, any uncertainties, concerns you guys want to address?" Okay, cool, and then we can get into it. But without doing that, it just loses the human touch.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, it's not appropriate. So I appreciate you bringing that up and chatting about it a little bit.
Matt Naimoli
Yeah, cool.
Ryan Hanley
So agents take a leadership role. You don't know how lucky you are. You probably do, but if you don't, we're all very lucky. So take a leadership role. I think that's an unasked for responsibility, but a responsibility that I do believe we should take on if we can. Obviously, everyone's situation is different.
Dude, all right. Let's get off the somber topics and let's talk about some fun stuff. It's funny because between you and I, that's probably about as somber as I've been in three years and probably you have been in five. You combine the two and people are probably like, "Whoa."
Matt Naimoli
Yeah, this is what we signed up for. This is really inspiring me.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, we didn't know that's what we were going to get when we click play on the podcast. But maybe that's where your editing finesse comes in.
Matt Naimoli
No, you know, it's funny. I tend to just let things go the way they go out because I find that there tends to be magic in things. This goes for all content. There tends to be magic moments that you will cut that others would capture. I always tend to edit less.
Ryan Hanley
I love it. Because I never know. It goes for videos that go out. I actually just today, of recording this, I put out this video I did last night. It was snowing here in Albany. It was snowing really bad. Here it is the end of March, we're stuck inside with coronavirus, now we're getting gut punched with six inches of heavy wet snow. You want to pretend it's beautiful, but really it just feels like there's nothing about it that I enjoy. I'm walking the dog and my wife always says jokingly, "Bad things come in threes." So once we can weather that third thing, we'll be fine. There's never going to be a fourth bad thing, right?
Only three. So I did this video about cyber liability, cyber attacks. Don't let a cyber attack be the third bad thing. It's snowing and I got this hat on and I look like I'm in Alaska. It looks crazy. I did the video on a whim. It was a minute and 30 seconds. I got home and I watched it and I was like, was it perfect? Very far from perfect. Snow's in my face, holding the camera, I'm walking the dog. I just said, you know what, maybe there's magic in here for somebody. Maybe somebody watches this and buys a cyber liability policy either from me or from someone else and doesn't have some horrible DNS attack be the third thing.
Or someone rips all their data because they have some remote worker who doesn't know what they're doing and this doesn't end their business. You survive Corona, you survive the winter, and then a cyber attack ends your business. I just was like, I don't think it's beautiful. I don't even really think it's that good, but maybe there's some magic in there. So I'm just going to put it out.
Matt Naimoli
Hey man, I think it's a great call. I think the more rugged and real you can be, especially in those types of videos, the better. Ultimately people are going to trust you more if they feel like they're really not trying to be sold. If it's more rugged and real and unedited, they're just like, "This guy is walking his dog in the middle of a snowstorm and he's filming in the middle of a global pandemic. Kudos to him. I'll listen to what he has to say." It breaks down the barriers or any defense mechanisms. When I watch a professionally done video that has a call to action, I sometimes just avoid it like a plague because I'm like, "Well, this person's putting so much effort to get me to do that call to action." I would rather it just be a one-take wonder and appreciate the content. I'd probably be listening to it more.
Ryan Hanley
So outside of the craziness of the world that we're living in, it hasn't always been this way. It won't always be this way moving forward. What's going on with you, man? You guys have had a really big last 12 months. You personally, I know you're still very much involved in G&N, but I know you have other things going on. What's blowing your skirt up right now? What's got you excited? You obviously have new chapters that you're writing.
Matt Naimoli
I feel like it's the first page of a new book in a lot of different ways. Like a volume of Harry Potter books, maybe a lot of them at the same time. You can probably relate to this, but one of my biggest fears, actually probably my only real fear, is never achieving or accomplishing what I can be, what I can become. That's for personal, professional, as a companion, as a husband, as a father, as a professional, as a leader, as a mentor, et cetera. For me, I feel fulfilled and excited and happiest when I've got a lot of different projects going on. The challenge of that is you've got to see them all to the finish line and sometimes one or two can drop because you've got multiple things you're carrying. But I feel most alive when I've got a lot of different projects working, both personal and professional.
Even though the last year was pretty tumultuous from a transitional period, I probably took 10 years and consolidated into one. Sadie and I, we got Belle, our dog, and she was a puppy in March of last year. We moved in together. We got engaged. We got pregnant. We had our first baby, Parker. All while Zach and I launched Bobble On and traveled around the country to health agencies. We helped over 50 agencies implement the Bobble On system in person. So we had probably 75 different flights last year. In the behind the scenes, we were going through the process of determining if we ever wanted to sell our business. I put it that way because we didn't go into 2019 with any idea that we'd ever consider selling G&N and bringing on a partner and merging and leveling up. We looked at it as we had plenty of advisors who said, "You guys should know what your worth is. You should know what your value is. So you should go through the process and just figure out some market yield." We really wanted to do that from an educational standpoint, understand a little bit more because we had never purchased an agency.
Not to be too long-winded, but our goal was to try to figure out what we are worth and what kind of deal structures are even out there. We felt like veterans in the insurance space, but novices when it came to M&A, whether we ever wanted to purchase or sell. Ultimately, going through the process, if you want to dive into it later, I'm happy to talk more about it because I learned so much from it that I think a lot of other agency owners could benefit from. Whether they sell tomorrow or 70 years from now, they could benefit from it. At the end, we knocked down all the concerns and barriers that we had and realized that selling was not what we thought it was going to be.
We realized that it was completely different than our concerns and anticipation of what selling would look like. They were all positives, no negatives. So we pulled the trigger in the final days of 2019. It was a crazy year, a lot of transition, personally and professionally, and tons of fulfillment, tons of impact. We really enjoyed the mentorship and the guidance standpoint from Bobble On, the challenging new process of M&A, due diligence, figuring out negotiating that. And then personally, a ton of transitions that were all really happy and exciting for me after a couple of years of just difficult times.
So thanks for asking.
Ryan Hanley
That's wonderful. I'm very happy for all of your personal successes. That's a tough word to think about, but navigating, finding a relationship that's fulfilling and makes you happy. You need that on the back end. Having your first child. A dog is like a child. My third child is sleeping upstairs on a couch right now. She's been with us from before we had the two goons. Half the time, my wife would trade her for me and the two goons just about any day.
Matt Naimoli
Real cute.
Ryan Hanley
No, I think you need that. It's funny. I had a birthday a few weeks ago and you start to hit a certain point in your life. That number is different for everybody. You start to think about the word legacy. What do you want your legacy to be? Especially when you have a child, you really start to think about that, or at least I have. You mentioned one of your biggest fears is never achieving what you thought you could become. I would say that is a tension that I hold inside me almost every single day. This idea that I know I was blessed with certain gifts. I'm relatively healthy. I was born in the United States.
I was born into a lower middle class family, but I wasn't born into poverty. So I had opportunity to rise up. I went to a decent enough public school. I see myself all the time like if I don't achieve something, and I'm not always positive what that something is, I think that's a struggle. I'm interested in your take on how you figure out what that something is. But if I don't achieve something, then I've wasted a lot. There are a lot of people that do not have the gifts that I've been given that I'm aware of. I mean that not in a "look at me how great I am" way. I understand that there have been certain things that I've been given.
If I don't execute and provide the world or my community or just my family with something in return for being given them, then what an asshole I am. The thing that I've struggled with for a long time, and this is where I'm really interested in your take, is how do you figure out what that something is? I'm not asking for advice for me. I'm interested in your take. How do you figure out what that something is that you become?
Matt Naimoli
It's a great question. I've been challenged with this for many years. But I think what I've narrowed it down to is there is no end, there's no goal, there's no finish line. Part of me is frustrated that that's the realization I've come to, but part of me is also empowered and kind of relieved. What I mean by that is, I think because you and I are similar in this sense, where we are always reaching to create more challenges for ourselves so that we can overcome a set of challenges to feel successful and impactful in this world, to create a better legacy, to create more impact and influence. It goes to the root of why we are here and the purpose that we have on this planet. But because we're like that, we're never going to feel completely fulfilled by an accomplishment or a goal that we achieve. But if we can live with that and say, "You know what, we're going to continue to do so anyways. We're going to continue to challenge ourselves every single year, every month, every week, every day, different frequencies, different levels, magnitudes." Ultimately, that's a life worth living because we know we're going to create a lot of impact possibly.
For me, long term, meaning 10, 20 years, I want to help as many freaking people as possible achieve their goals. I think that's where I've transitioned from in the last 12 years. Early on, it was very self-centered. It was kind of rooted in a little bit of fear because I was coming out of college with a sales job and no experience, no money. I just needed to prove myself and create enough money to cover my expenses and then some. So it was very self-centered in that sense. But as we've gone on and created a company and grown the company and coached a ton and been coached a ton and read a ton, I've realized that for me, at this stage, if I can help a lot of people achieve their goals through mentorship, through coaching, through support, through being a founding board, just through inspiration and motivation, and they win, I feel best.
I feel best about that. It goes back to just knowing that it's a leveraged level of impact that really matters. So a long-winded way of answering that question. For me, it's much more about continuing to try to impact as many people as positively as possible. As I continue to create more resources and freedom for myself, I'll be able to do that even more. Does that make sense?
Ryan Hanley
No, it does. I think that you've gone about it the right way. In many regards, I am envious of the way that you guys took control of your lives. I know that you had many struggles and it wasn't an easy path. That's not what I'm trying to say. But you took control of your lives early on so that you could focus on helping people in this next iteration of your life. I find by far the most joy and fulfillment in my life is helping other people, not helping myself. The speaking, I don't love consulting because people just don't do the shit you tell them to do and it drives me nuts. But I definitely like helping.
I love inspiring people, connecting people. I love being a connector. So we share that source of fulfillment. It is definitely outside of probably my family and their health and happiness, my number one source of fulfillment. But what I would say, and this is where I think you guys have gotten it right, you've put yourself in a position where you can be of service to them now. If you haven't taken care of your home front, then you can't be of service. That was really what I found in my career. One of the reasons why I started Rogue was that I needed to have a solid foundation in order to be able to help others.
If you're trying to help others with a wobbly foundation, it just doesn't work. You can't create real impact. I think that's a really important thing, especially as people are in transition and flux.
Insurance is going to become much harder to sell. I've been trying to sell for a month now. I can't get anyone to answer the phone. People aren't interested. Traffic's way down. I'm efforting 10 hours a day plus on Rogue and I'm just getting a trickle of business coming in. It's difficult. I know a lot of people are facing that, even established agencies. My point in this little diatribe is to say, stay true to the mission that you're on today. If that foundation isn't solid, don't go looking for other places. If you're not getting Facebook likes on your local business posts, but you're getting them from agents, don't go rushing towards being that consulting person, that thought leader person. That's not a path you want to go on until you're ready.
Matt Naimoli
I think that's really good advice, Ryan. One of the things that I didn't really take into account when we were in transaction of the business was obviously there's a part of you that says, "I can finally take some chips off the table from building a company for 10 years and the fruits of your labor are finally met." That provides some security for the family, for your future family, your generations, etc. But for me, what I was really excited about day one after we transacted was that I finally had resources to help other budding entrepreneurs achieve their vision. I never really thought that would come. I didn't know that would be such an exciting component of the next phase. I'm not saying I'm going to invest in every possible thing out there, but just the ability to have some resources to invest in really exciting entrepreneurs and what their visions are is a byproduct of the sale that I didn't really seek out. It came to me afterwards.
Ryan Hanley
So when you're looking at an investment opportunity, you see a startup, someone comes to you. What are you looking for? What are some of the things that get you excited? Is it the product? Is it the person? We've all read these articles on entrepreneur.com or whatever, but for you personally, what gets you going?
Matt Naimoli
There are really three filters. I've spoken to probably seven to ten different startups, entrepreneurs, meaning just starting or within the first year or two, looked at pitch decks, all different types of companies, different industries. My three filters have been: One, I've got to understand it. Maybe in 10 years from now, if I'm investing a lot more and I have more experience, I can be investing in other industries. But for me, I have to kind of understand the world that they're in for me to feel comfortable. The financials can look great. The modeling can look great. Forecasting can look great. But if I don't really understand it, I don't think it should be something I'm investing in. So I've turned down anything that's been outside the industry.
Two, the leader. Is the leader someone who I walk away from a conversation jazzed up and inspired about? And, not or, but and, do they have a work ethic that can rival mine or better? If I can answer yes to both of those things, that passes the second filter test.
The third is, is the company truly removing pain that is existing currently?
Because there's a lot of companies that are doing things that are opportunistic, where their product or service is, "Oh, wow, that's cool. I like that. I can see how that can create value." But I really think the companies that I'm most interested in are those that are saying, "There's already existing pain right now and our solution removes that pain immediately." I think those are the companies that are going to see traction much faster and weather any type of storms like we're in right now.
Ryan Hanley
You know what, starting Rogue has been a game changer from my perspective in many ways. My perspective on the organizations, the tools, the ideas that actually add value to the flow, particularly of an independent insurance agent, but I think of the customer journey as well, the customer experience has had a dramatic course correction. I won't say it's like 180 degrees, but I look at how agencies operate and I'm looking at building Rogue and I'm saying to myself, there are cool pieces of technology that I wrote down on a piece of paper that said, "Geez, this seems like something I'm going to need." That once I got to this point, I'm like, "Meh, it's cool." Don't get me wrong. It's flashy. It's shiny. I like what I'm reading on the homepage. I like the guy running the company. But it just doesn't add enough into my flow that it makes it worth the deal.
For everyone listening, this is where we get nickel and dimed on the $50 to $200 a month tool. We just have to be careful about that kind of stuff because there are game-changing technologies. There are companies that are really working in the best interest of independent agents. But there are also people doing really cool things that just aren't that valuable to the everyday flow of an agency. And I think it's very easy to get sidetracked.
Matt Naimoli
Yeah, I think I wrote about this a few weeks ago. If the technology that you are adopting reduces or removes something you're already doing, it could be really helpful. If it's adding something that you weren't doing before, it's not essential. If you're a tenured, experienced agency that wants to level up and you see opportunity in that, great. But most people aren't in that position. Most people are still running into a ton of challenges and roadblocks and need to overcome them. Adopting things to get you more reviews, for example, or sending something to your clients that's kind of cool but doesn't give you the feedback and data you really need—it's not something you were doing beforehand. It's just adding more chaos and commotion and another variable that's going to create potential anxiety or bandwidth reduction when you really should be focused on removing stuff that you're already doing.
Ryan Hanley
So are you at liberty to talk about any of the companies that you've invested in? Or maybe just talk about some of the ideas that have you excited for insurance agents if you're not able to talk about any particular companies?
Matt Naimoli
I want to stay away from naming specific companies.
Ryan Hanley
That's fine. I just wouldn't be doing my job as an interviewer if I didn't ask.
Matt Naimoli
I love you, man. In general, companies that have established—going back to what I said—they've figured out, "Hey, this is something that agency principals, salespeople, service reps, or processors are doing right now that they really shouldn't be doing, and we can remove that from them." I think those are the companies that are going to win big time. There's low barriers to entry. It's really easy to present your value to the buyer, and the return is a lot easier to justify. You can look at it and say, "This is going to easily save me quantifiably 20 hours a week, 10 hours a week, 50 hours a week." Then you can relate that to the payroll associated with that time and say, "Wow, this is a 10x return or 20x return. Why would I not do this tomorrow?" Those are the companies I think are going to win in our space. There are a lot out there, and hopefully there will be more.
Ryan Hanley
Let me ask you a couple of questions that I've always had. I want to ask you a particular question about GNN. Why did you guys consider—and why or why not—ever make a major move into commercial?
Matt Naimoli
We definitely did consider it a number of times, and it was hard to turn down. We had a $100,000, $200,000 account early on that we tried to go after, and we closed a few, but it wasn't in our wheelhouse. We didn't have any experience. It was hard to not want to run after that. A lot of guidance and coaches and consultants that we had hired early on advised us to stay in our lane, saying that the more you scatter and go elsewhere, the less of an expert you're going to be in one thing. In a time when you have to compete with billions of dollars of advertising, you need to be an expert at one thing. So we always stayed within our lane.
I think we would have been successful in commercial, but the last four or five years, we've insured between five and seven percent of all homes purchased in Massachusetts. We would have never gotten there if we had gone lateral. We just went vertical for 10 years. That's a huge market share of people who are ideal clients. Granted, we have to sell a hundred policies in a week to cover what some people do in one sale. But if you can do that every single week, it's a nice hedge against disruption. It's a nice hedge against major changes like we're having right now. You're also known as the expert. You're known as the one that everyone should go to because your entire business is built around what they need, not just an agency that can service XYZ.
Ryan Hanley
I think a lot of people probably see what you guys have built and ask themselves, "Geez, if they can create such an amazing system for home in particular and then cross-sell it to some of the other personal lines, why not small commercial or life or whatever?" I think it's a great answer. I think it's the right answer. I'm just interested in some of the decision-making process.
Matt Naimoli
When we talked about it, I think ultimately we came to the point where we said, "If we're going to ever do this, it has to be a separate company." Because then that company, we could brand around that. We could build process and teams and systems and experience around that. But if you have 20, 30 people and they're all experts at one thing and then you're bringing in a different type of risk, a different type of sales process, a different type of service and renewal and midterm process, it's pretty disruptive for the team. More so than it would be for us or for the frontline salesperson.
Ryan Hanley
I think that's a great way to think about it. A concept that has really helped me, and it actually played a fairly large role in how I've set up Rogue—oh, I'm going to forget it. It was in James Clear's book, *Atomic Habits*, about the loss of cognitive ability that you have when you switch topics in your brain. If you're thinking about home insurance related topics all day, you can go from account to account to account and you keep your cognitive functionality at a top level. But if you're thinking home insurance and now all of a sudden you're thinking life insurance, as much as they both have "insurance" in the name, we're talking two totally different products. That person has to stop what they're thinking about, pivot the focus of their brain, and now try to pull up all the knowledge that they have around a completely separate topic—different questions, different indicators. There's a hangover in that switch. When your brain switches topics of focus, there's a hangover.
The generalist agency customer service representative deals with that all day long, and it drastically reduces their overall output. It's one of the reasons why my business is a hundred percent service center. I can just send people to the expert all day long at the carrier. I think that's something that a lot of agency owners miss. Just because Sally falls in the A's doesn't mean that she should be taking every single business, personal lines, life insurance, and health insurance account that comes in that starts with that letter. It just shouldn't work that way.
Matt Naimoli
It's why we've really made a huge effort to push all new business and enroll a lot of business to service centers. But it's also why we've tried to pare down some of our carriers. The first five years, we thought it was a huge advantage to have 20 companies and to quote 20 companies. It was one of our pitches: "Hey, we can quote and sell 20 different companies." We thought that was a huge value proposition. It mattered to one or two people, but most people don't care about that. They just said, "Can you get me a great solution that helps serve my needs? Okay, awesome. Can you make it really easy and quick? Okay, cool. Can you be pretty friendly about it and educate me? All right, that's enough."
We had the privilege and honor to coach a ton of different agencies, actually a lot of nationwide agencies—probably a dozen in the last year—as they're approaching this transition to going independent. One of our big asks of them is, "Be cautious with the number of carriers you bring on right away. You're going to go independent from running one company for 20, 30 years. Now you're going to have access to a ton. Try to just bring on two or three. Just get really good at two or three to fill different niches or different segments. Know that you can close most of the business with those two or three. Long-term, you're going to thank yourself so much for not bringing on eight or nine at the same time." The team needs to know eight or nine different quotes, eight or nine different endorsements, eight or nine different billing requirements, eight or nine different underwriting guides. It goes on and on. Eight or nine different underwriters to build relationships with. It is nine different usernames and passwords to log in. It compounds and adds and adds. People don't recognize how much time and effort and payroll goes into those hours spent on diversion.
Ryan Hanley
For everyone listening, I'm going to give a shout out to my peeps at Indium, which is a market access company that I use here at Rogue. This is an unpaid shout out. I just think that these guys are the best. If you're looking for market access and you don't want to have to worry about taking on direct appointments, give my peeps at Indium a call. Again, I'm not getting paid for that. I just like them. I think they have an agent-friendly contract, which is what I think all of our vendor partners in every regard should be considering moving forward.
Matt Naimoli
Is now the time for me to say that I'm getting paid by them for you saying that? If you are, I got to give Chad a call because that's messed up, man.
Ryan Hanley
Wouldn't that be great though? We just do podcasts every week where we interview each other and the other person throws a shout out and says, "Yeah, unpaid, unpaid." Actually, we shouldn't have said that live. That is a great strategy. That's a great idea.
Matt Naimoli
I know, I know.
Ryan Hanley
All right, man. We've been a bunch of different places. I'm super interested in the way that you think about business in general because you are very introspective. You take time. It doesn't ever seem from the outside like you're just shooting from the hip. It seems like you think about things quite a bit, which is wonderful. So give me a little prognostication. Here you are, angel investor, entrepreneur extraordinaire, sitting on top of the mountain. What do you see coming down the pipe? Do you see market consolidation? Do you see rate increases? Do you see new product lines, new technology? There's no right or wrong answer here. I'm just interested. You've gone through some experiences that others have not, especially at a relatively young age. Most people don't sell until they're way older. Looking at this next episode of your life and your career, what do you see coming?
Matt Naimoli
One thing you mentioned—remind me to come back to this afterwards. I've probably had a dozen or so agencies reach out and ask, "Why did you sell? Tell me a little bit more about that. It doesn't seem like you would ever want to do that at your stage." I want to come back to that and talk about it because I don't want there to be a misconception, but I also think there's an educational moment there for people.
To answer your question, I think there's going to be—and this has been something that people have been talking about for a long time—even though there's been 4,000 M&A transactions in the last X number of years, a ton of transactions and recently a lot of large transactions, I think that's going to continue. For a variety of reasons. One, technology improvements are going to really help the agencies that are able to adopt that technology. Someone like yourself is going to benefit from that for sure. There are a lot of people that are going to benefit from that. There are a lot of people that will never even hear about it, know how to implement it, and certainly not adopt it. I think those companies are going to feel like they're falling behind quickly, and the best way to get out of that is to sell.
More from a retirement standpoint, I think there are a lot of people that are entering their age of retirement in the next three years. You're going to have a lot more people saying, "I don't have a succession plan. I don't have kids that want to take this over, nor do I want to really give it. It's not a legacy business for me." So you're going to see a lot of those people sell. I do think that the landscape we live in right now is going to cause people to question things. Some people might say, "I'm so glad I'm in this business because I feel somewhat recession proof," and they might not want to exit. But there's going to be some who look at it and say, "I really do think I need to take chips off the table at this stage of my life." They'll look into it, be more educated about what it could look like, and then potentially move forward.
On one end, I think there's going to be a lot more M&A. I don't think that's going to slow down. I do think multiples in the next five years are going to shift. They have to come down slightly. On the technology side, I want to come back to what we talked about earlier. Companies that are going to help agencies like yours get better and quicker and faster will win. There's going to be a lot more of those companies that succeed in the short term. But I don't know if there's going to be as much private equity on the sidelines available to invest in a ton of different companies. The last 10 years has been so easy to start a company and get funding. I think that's going to be more and more challenging. It's going to be interesting who the actual entrants are in the space—if they've had prior success versus just some random person trying to get in.
Market consolidation—I don't think in five years there will be any direct writers in the sense of the age-old direct writer. Look at any of them, they're all making moves. Nationwide's move is the clearest and most obvious. They're taking a traditional long-term captive market and going completely independent. Liberty Mutual and all their sales agents are now able to sell multiple lines, multiple products, multiple carriers, albeit at a smaller commission. They're able to access a lot of different markets. I think the direct carriers are realizing that their future is limited if they don't expand and offer through a different channel. It might also be opportunistic, saying, "Wow, all this has happened and yet there's still a lot of markets here in the independent channel. We need to go ahead and capture that." I do think there's going to be a shift even more so. Allstate has taken that path for the last five to ten years. I don't know if someone like State Farm, Geico, or Progressive would ever do that. But I wouldn't be surprised about anything now moving forward.
Ryan Hanley
What I think is interesting is the carriers starting their own insurance agencies. You look at Progressive, they have their own commercial insurance agency. Geico's sending out emails to agents about starting local Geico offices. What has been incredible—and this was a drum that I was banging back in the very early Agency Nation days—is that you just can't beat a human. You can't beat the human. There are different iterations of having a human involved that I think are more advantageous than others, but having a human involved is the only way to date to keep your retention at a level where you can consistently be profitable.
Finding ways to optimize your agencies is a necessity. If this pandemic does not teach you anything about working inside of and with systems that allow you flexibility and adaptability, then it almost feels like you deserve to experience the pain that you're feeling. If you allow this to happen, this has to be the warning bell that siloed systems, rack servers, and offices are no longer viable. The fact that people are down to 20% productivity working from home—I feel bad that they're going through that. However, there is this dark part of me that says, "We've been telling you for years that you have to be able to do this, and you just laughed because you didn't need to." Obviously, you don't want a pandemic or something awful like this to cause people to feel this amount of pain. I'm talking specifically about agents having to work from home and outside their systems. But at the same time, this is not the first time. Rick Morgan was talking about this back in the 80s in his mailed newsletter. Steve Anderson too. This isn't a new message. My hope is we finally learn and move forward. Otherwise, you're going to get mowed down.
Matt Naimoli
In general, people want to work with people. There's going to be a subset of the population who say, "You know what, certain types of products and services I just want to purchase and service without any human." But most people want that connection because there's a level of accountability. Especially with something like insurance, they want that accountability. If there's another human that's accountable for what I need and what I'm looking for.
Where I do think technology needs to be adopted by people but does not replace people is on the lead gen side. This is coming from someone who built a referral-based business for 10 years. I fully believe in referrals. On our podcast recently, we interviewed the number one loan officer in the country, Sean Penosian, who is going to do over a billion—he did 980 million in funding last year. He's going to do over a billion this year, over 2,000 loans, and most of it's purchase. All of it is referral. He's not a digital master. There's still tons of room to succeed through straight person-to-person relationship world. I do think that technology has made it an option to grow through leads and acquisition of clients on the front end. Even though it might be a little more costly, it has opened up that opportunity. In the client experience journey, it is making it easier to connect with people on a more consistent basis compared to what it used to be. But if it comes off as a technology connection, people get turned off. It needs to be something that makes people feel more like they're connecting with people.
Ryan Hanley
So you roll into 2019, and we talked a little bit beforehand. There's no way that you're going to sell, right? There's no way you're going to sell rolling into 2019. And then you hit 2019 and everything changes. Talk me through that process. I think it's probably the number one question going through people's minds, especially agencies who operate in a similar ecosystem. They're looking at you guys going, "What the hell changed?" Walk me through that process.
Matt Naimoli
I've had so many conversations in the last few months about that. Some people are kind of like, "Is this something that I should consider?" Other people are saying, "I can't believe you did this. Why would you do this?" But they might look at it the same way we did. Going into 2019, there was a 0% chance we were going to sell. The main reason was Zach and I both felt that selling our business would literally be stopping, retiring, hanging up the boots, and just being a cog in a wheel. I always looked at the image of throwing a bag of money—a duffel bag of money—over my shoulder and walking off into the sunset on a horse. That's really the picture I had of when I sell my business.
But as I said before, we were advised over and over again, "If you guys don't know your worth, you're not worth anything. You've got to know what the market would pay for you to have a real business because you guys have invested 10 years in this. You know it's valuable. You know it's unique. You know people would really want to have you as part of them, but you don't know what your value is. All you've done is delayed gratification to a point where you don't know what that gratification can look like. You don't know what chips actually would look like to take off the table. So it's okay. Go through the process of just the due diligence."
We talked to a lot of different entities. We hired investment bankers to help us navigate because we quickly realized that it was way over our head. The M&A world is complicated. Every single potential buyer and acquirer wants you for different reasons, is looking for different things, and will pay different multiples, but also they'll set up the deal structure completely different. We went into it just saying, "This is going to be an awesome education." Neither one of us felt pressured at all, but we both said at the end of this, we're going to know what we're worth. And maybe in five or 10 years, we'll act on it.
We go through the process. We met with 13 or 14 different buyers—every one of them you'd know the name. We sat down and we had really five major concerns. We agreed that even if we still had one of those five concerns at the end of this due diligence process, we would not sell. Don't care what the value would be. If one of those concerns were not removed, we would not move forward.
The first one was culture, people, process. We're not the best in the world, but we have invested so much in our culture, our people, and our process. We know that it's damn good. If you're going to acquire GNN and you're going to ask us to change any of that—remove people or change people, change salaries, change our process, come in and change our brand and our culture—we're not interested. Immediately those 13 to 14 became seven or eight. Those buyers said, "Do what you do. You're independent. You're exciting. What you're doing is great. We don't want to stop or get in the way."
The second piece was we didn't want to just be employees. Not that there's anything wrong with it, but we are both entrepreneurs at heart. We want to feel aligned long-term with the business that we're involved in. Any of the buyers who were offering all cash offers, although it was exciting, was not interesting because I wasn't looking to exit. I was looking to level up and grow GNN bigger and make it stronger and more exciting to be part of. The companies that would just offer all stock and all cash was less exciting because there was almost a misalignment. Long-term, I wasn't as interested in their growth and success as I would be if there was stock. For me, a big piece of it needed to be in stock of the company that was acquiring us. So that seven or eight companies then became four or five.
The next piece was a major concern. I think a lot of people in my tenure—10 years in the business, a growth trajectory much faster than most, anywhere between 8% growth year over year to 40% growth year over year—that's going to exceed a lot of the standard agencies out there. A big concern I had, and one that I was having a hard time coming over with, was, "Why wouldn't we just hold out for three more years?" We did the forecasting and projections and realized that in three or four years, we're probably going to be double in size. So even if multiples came down from all-time highs in three or four years slightly, we're still going to be much bigger. So why don't we just wait?
And when we realize that all these—most of the acquirers have a structure in their deal that allows for an earn-out period. That essentially allows you to sell your business twice: one up front at an agreed-upon EBITDA multiple, and one in three or four or two or five years at an agreed-upon multiple. It removed that fear completely because you lock down all-time highs up front, and you can lock down an all-time high in three or four years that allows you to realize the growth of your agency down the road.
They set a benchmark and say, "We expect you to achieve 4% EBITDA growth year over year. In three years, you should be here." Every single dollar above that number, we're going to multiply by a big ass number and you can get paid again. That removed that fear immediately because I was like, okay, not only do I get to benefit up front, I get to benefit down the road for realized growth.
Now, the fifth concern was getting the true value up front. I think a lot of people would feel this way because for us, we're growing fast. We're organic. We're investing in marketing and branding and referral partners and our people. We have to have a ton of people because we're a personalized agency and there's a lot of labor associated with new business, especially in personalization and onboarding and servicing. And we're transitioning a lot of books to service centers. So we have a lot of internal costs associated with that. So our value would never be captured up front. We're never going to get a buyer to say, "Yes, your EBITDA might be a million dollars, but we're going to pay you a multiple off of $2 million." I'm not going to give out real numbers, but you know, a million dollars—we're going to pay you off of $2 million because that's what you're truly worth. It's hard to imagine that they would agree to that.
But two or three of the buyers came to the table and said, "We're going to account for that. We recognize you're unique and you're growing fast and you need to staff and hire to account for that growth. So we are going to back out six, seven, eight of your people that are really in place to grow more down the road and build that into your EBITDA. We are going to allow you to take a lot less income." What that allowed us to do—I always looked at it as if we wanted to sell, we needed to prepare for two or three years to make us as profitable as possible. I thought that's what we needed to do. In reality, you need to agree on what your budget and what your framework is going to look like moving forward for the close. And as long as you agree for the close, that EBITDA is magnified. It jumps up and skyrockets because you're agreeing at the close moving forward, we are going to be doing X, Y, and Z. Zach and I take a lot less income. They accounted for a lot of backing out expenses for our team and our marketing. And so it just jacked up what our profitability was, even though on paper, we weren't that profitable.
So long-winded monologue right there, but those were our five major concerns. And every single time one of those concerns was removed because one of the partners across the table was saying, "No, don't worry about that. Here's our solution." We got a little bit more comfortable with the concept. By the end, when we transacted in November of last year, we realized that we were going to be part of someone who was $230 million in revenue—the Hill Group was $230 million in revenue. They want to be $2 billion and they need our help. We want to be part of that. We didn't want to be part of a $2 billion company who already achieved and appreciated their stock and gotten to where they wanted to be. We wanted to be part of a company that needed us to fulfill that long-term vision of 10x growth. And we knew we could help them so much because of what we have done internally with GNN and how we can expand that across the nation. And we found that they removed all of our fears and concerns.
Ryan Hanley
That's awesome, man. I mean, that really is a pretty tremendous story. I think there are very few people who take the time and energy to work through the process the way that you did. What I hope the takeaway is, is obviously some of the lessons, but I think there's two major takeaways. One, you have to—like all things, like my little rant about not preparing for something like working remotely—I think you need to prepare for selling just like you did. I mean, that to me is an enormous lesson. You need to be thinking two, three, four, five years out. And then once you do, you can't just go into it—or it is less advantageous to go into it—thinking to yourself, "I just want to get the biggest number." It's more about thinking, "What are the things that are going to make me happy moving forward after this transaction?" I think people miss that second part because they don't prepare in the first part. And the preparation allows you to move into the next stage in a way that you have some control over.
Man, I think what you guys are doing, what you did, the way you're talking about it, the work you continue to do with Babylon—it's some of the most admirable and important work in our industry. I'm just so glad that we got to share some of it with the audience today.
Matt Naimoli
Well, thanks for letting me share, man. I really appreciate it. I'm only going to share things I'm passionate about and believe in, and also have permission to be wrong down the road. But I'm really excited for the moves we're making and the impact we're having. I'm hopeful that other people will reach out and ask more questions, frankly, because I think that's helped me a lot—asking questions, asking for help. I think that's one of the things that we all should do a little bit more of. So yeah, if anyone has any—I mean, you know this—if anyone has any questions about diving in deeper and asking questions and saying, "Hey, my situation's X and I was wondering about why," I'm very available. If anyone wants to reach out anytime and talk about it, I'm happy to.
Ryan Hanley
Great. Well, thanks so much, man. Everyone listening at home, thank you for listening to the show today, spending time with Matt and I. I wish you guys nothing but the best. Be safe, be healthy, treat each other with kindness. These are difficult times, but we get through them together. So thanks, brother. I appreciate you. Nothing but the best to you and your family.
Matt Naimoli
Right back at you, homie. Thank you.
Outro music begins
Announcer
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close System, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today. Thank you.