Episode Summary
The podcast episode features a conversation between the host and Caitlin Egger, Director of Education and Development at Quantum Assurance International. The main topic of discussion is the use of online leads in growing an insurance agency, with a focus on the benefits and strategies for success.
Key Points
Participants
Takeaways
Additional Insights
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Katlyn Eggar, Director of Education Development for Quantum Assurance Internations stops by the podcast for EPIC conversation on all things crushing online leads to rapidly grow an independent insurance agency. Get more: https://ryanhanley.com/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
[Intro music fades] In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home... Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. Today we have a very dynamic guest, someone who I think you're going to absolutely adore this conversation. It's Caitlin Egger, the Director of Education and Development at Quantum Assurance International.
We've actually had one of Caitlin's counterparts on the show, Jeff Shee, who is one of the founders of Quantum. And you probably heard Quantum's name tossed around. Caitlin was interviewed by Cass and, you know, Quantum is making a big splash in the independent channel as they build out their network of agents and do some really dynamic things.
Why I wanted to have Caitlin on is she made a comment on Cass's podcast: buying leads online is more predictable than referrals. I just love that concept. Whether you agree with it or it makes your skin crawl, either way, you can't deny that it is a perspective. I think it's worth exploring. I was very excited to have Caitlin on the show. She absolutely crushed it. You're going to take something away from this episode. So super happy to have her on.
Before we get there, I want to give a big shout out to my people at Better Agency, betteragency.io. You got to check them out. I'm telling you, they are just like I predicted Tarmica. I've been telling you about Tarmica for six months, seven months, since January. And obviously Tarmica is taking the world over. The exact same thing is about to happen with Better Agency. This is insurance agency owners building technology to push our industry forward. These are game-changing, equalizing technologies. I use Better Agency. I absolutely love it.
So go check out Better Agency. If you're looking for a CRM, if you're looking for a tool that's more plug and play, that you don't have to be a rocket ninja automation warrior in order to use. If you're looking for something that's already got copy built in, campaigns built in, a sales pipeline, a service pipeline, a renewal pipeline — this thing captures notes, tasks, attachments. It captures phone calls, text messages, all your emails. It is the most dynamic system that is also easy to use. Go to betteragency.io today, get a demo. Even if you're not ready right now, at least go get that demo. Tell them Hanley sent you.
All right, let's get on to Caitlin Eggert. So, okay. So you are traveling again. You're in some other place. I don't know anybody during COVID that travels as much as you do.
Caitlin Egger
Well, we're in our van. It's pretty germ free in there. There's no COVID in there as far as we know.
Ryan Hanley
As far as you know. Depends on who you talk to. There's COVID everywhere.
Caitlin Egger
Right. So we were working — we had never tried working from home before. We sent our sales teams to work from home back in March and we were working from our home offices. We'll definitely get back to the place where we're back in the call centers on a regular basis. But it works so well. Since we're still in that limbo time where some people are working from home, some people are in the office, we've just been getting out and about, going out and seeing people where they're at instead of flying them in or putting anybody on a plane. It's worked out well for us. And the kids — they've got their school books with them. It's been great.
Ryan Hanley
So you're in the van driving around and then you just live out of a hotel?
Caitlin Egger
Yes, but it's only been like 10 days. I wouldn't say it's permanent. We still have a home base in Texas.
Ryan Hanley
Did you think about going RV?
Caitlin Egger
We joke about it. But we bring our nanny with us, so she's got to have her own space and all that good stuff. Hotel rooms are a little bit easier for bringing the whole crew. I think we're getting good at it. I packed a little bit less this time around. We were trying to go a little bit more reasonable with what we're packing every trip. I try to bring everything but the kitchen sink with me when we go.
Ryan Hanley
How old are your kids?
Caitlin Egger
Five and six.
Ryan Hanley
Oh yeah. Mine are six and four. The interesting thing about that age is COVID doesn't mean anything to them. They just completely adapt. They're like, "Oh, this is okay. This is the new world. Fine. We're good." They're flexible.
Caitlin Egger
Yeah. I definitely see — and there's no judgment on parenting — but the parents who have gone a little COVID crazy and had their kids in bubbles, they can't see other kids, they're alone all the time. When you finally interact with one of those kids, those kids are bananas. But the kids that have been allowed to see other humans and interact with them a little bit, they could care less.
Ryan Hanley
Can we talk about how awkward it is to set up playdates for the kiddos right now? Everyone is on this whole spectrum. There are the people that are like, "Oh, we don't do playgrounds right now. We'll do a picnic, but if we're six feet apart, maybe." And then you have the people that are like, "Hey, want to go to the trampoline park and bring the kids?" So you start out like, "Does Helen want to do a Zoom playdate with Karis and bring her dolls and talk toys?" And then later, "Hey, do you guys want to do a picnic? We'll bring a kickball." It's so funny.
Caitlin Egger
I completely agree. We kind of started that way and then now we're just like, look, we don't even believe in COVID. I mean, I believe in it, it's a joke. But as far as — unless you show up at my house with COVID snot dripping out of your nose, I'm basically just going to assume that you wouldn't come over if you didn't think you were at least okay.
Ryan Hanley
This whole thing has been a roller coaster. Back in March and April, I felt like the whole country was on the same page. Unity. If you're walking in the park, you nod. We were walking the golf course across from our neighborhood back in April and a couple was coming in the opposite direction. The lady sneezed and I'm like, "It's okay, probably allergies." And she's like, "Oh my gosh, I'm so sorry, thank you." Everybody was on the same page. Now I feel like we're in this interesting space where everybody's on a different page and you have no idea what the person you're talking to is comfortable with. So we've been doing a lot of air elbow bumps.
Caitlin Egger
That's a Texas reaction. In New York, they would have been like, "Kick them out, put them in jail, bubble them, bubble wrap them. Six feet apart."
Ryan Hanley
Brand them right on the forehead. "Sneezer in public." Run them down. That's how it would have happened here. People are bananas up here. And the other part is, because of how crazy some people up here are, there are the crazies on the other way too that are still walking into convenience stores with no mask on. Can we talk about the gas stations for a minute? I'm glad they're open, but it's not clean. Just bring your hand sanitizer, try not to touch anything.
Caitlin Egger
I'm not afraid of COVID for myself. I'm afraid for my kids. If I were 65 and had a pre-existing condition, I'd be scared as hell. In general, I completely get the "just throw a mask on." I don't love it. I actually hate it. I hate wearing a mask. I don't like that I can't see people's faces. You have to learn to smile with your eyes because that's all people can see. But at the same point, put the frigging mask on. It's a stupid mask. You walk in the store, put the mask on, wear it in the store, and leave. I think it's crazy that there are still these grumpy old fat white dudes rolling into the store like, "I ain't putting my mask on. Screw you." Come on.
What's funny is when you're on a road trip, you stop in a lot of different gas stations in different states. There's definitely a difference. You can definitely tell where you are based on whether the cashier has a mask on or not. I feel like it's been so hard for families and moms to figure out what to do. How do we take care of our family, our high risk loved ones, but we don't want our kids in a bubble? It's really hard because there are all these unknowns, these huge decisions. At the end of the day, we want what's best for our kids and for grandma and grandpa and the loved ones in our life. I definitely think it is harder for people that live really close to their grandparents or someone that is high risk. While the stats for children overall are not as frightening as for some adults, there are kids that have immune system issues. I certainly have compassion for all the moms out there no matter where they are on that spectrum. It's been really tricky figuring this whole thing out, hasn't it?
Ryan Hanley
I agree. I think that is a perfect segue into the topic I wanted to discuss with you. I had heard your name before, and then you were on Cass's podcast, which was awesome. I thought it was a great show. I was really taking in what you said. When we had a chance to talk a little bit, you had even said it wasn't why you went on the show, but it's kind of where you went. I wanted to take that conversation even further, which was the idea of buying leads or just growing your business via leads.
This is a huge bugaboo for me. David Carothers is going to have to take a drink or make fun of me because I use this analogy too much, but my philosophy in life, particularly when it comes to growing a business, is the Bruce Lee model: be like water. Fill the cup that's in front of you. I think we get so dogmatic on certain ideas that we allow ourselves to be boxed in. We allow our business to stagnate at the expense of doing something that we view as below us.
In our industry, particularly on the independent side, coming from Allstate, coming from the captive side, for you and Quantum having this captive legacy culture, it's just part of the deal. It's part of the business. This is what you do to grow. On the independent side, it's like, "You're a loser. Oh, you buy leads? You have to buy leads?" That's like a scarlet letter you wear around a conference. I built my book of business way back when on NetQuote. A dollar a lead.
Caitlin Egger
I remember that. I'm getting flashbacks now.
Ryan Hanley
Yes. You'd get in when NetQuote added text messages. That's when it really took off for me because I had a phone that actually did text messages. When the text would come through, I could get to that person first. I don't even talk about that anymore, but I got a lot of my escape velocity from that. I harassed my family, I wrote my family. And then after that, who do you write? So I'm doing all the standard stuff. NetQuote was a big part of that.
So I look at today and I'm like, "Oh my gosh, it's a decade later and people are still acting like online leads are somehow less valuable?" Folks, I just wrote a homeowner's account today from a bought online lead. It took me an hour. An hour. The lead came in and an hour later I had a bound policy from a bought lead. I paid $7 for the lead and an hour later I'd signed a $1,300 homeowner's policy. This is a real way to grow your business.
Caitlin Egger
What's interesting is I don't think it's just independents that think internet leads might be beneath them. I see it on the captive side every day. There are a lot of reasons for it. If you think back to how agents used to build their business before internet leads — if you're buying an agency from your dad, your uncle, your grandpa, and you have this legacy agency, no way they built their success on internet leads. They were out there getting to know people in their community. Your dad was probably showing up when somebody had a claim and being there. They passed on that personal touch and that care for people in their community. It became this standard of quality because of how it used to work.
But I think you can do both. I don't think your agency has to stop networking. I don't think you have to stop showing up for your referrals or stop working those mortgage broker relationships. But we have this sea of opportunity in front of us right now that's working. You can get in front of quality clients. You can position your agency where clients are doing their shopping and really have the best of both worlds. It's all about the systems in your agency and having a process for being able to navigate two very different conversations.
The conversation with a referral because your buddy sent them over and said, "Hey man, call this guy. He's really good," is a completely different conversation than reaching out to somebody who came to you because they Googled "insurance Chantilly, Virginia." You're asking your team to be flexible and you've got to have a strategy in place. At the end of the day, it's about meeting our clients where they're at.
Ryan, if you don't mind sharing — what about your family? Do you guys buy any products online? Do you shop online for clothes, school stuff?
Ryan Hanley
Like most people, there's a heavy stream of Amazon boxes that arrives at my house. What's interesting to me about this part of the conversation is it comes back to something that is the core differentiator, I believe, in our industry. I believe there are two types of agents. There are business owners and there are agent owners. Agent owners just like to write insurance. For them, a referral comes in. It's great. They can buddy them up. "Beat them at golf the other day. He refers me some business, bro." You put their insurance package together. It's already sold because your referral. You kind of just walk through the coverages, show them the price. "Here's what it is. Great. Give me your credit card. Done. I'm an insurance agent." That's amazing. That's an awesome way to do business. Except you can't really grow in anything more than a slightly linear path on that methodology.
So what happens is the next thing agents do is like, "Okay, I'm going to be growth focused. I'm going to go after mortgage broker referrals." That's a great path. You can grow. GNN has grown that way. Grant Botma, Nick Ayers, a lot of people have grown that way. But you have to reach out. That's level two. You still are at the discretion of those loan officers thinking about you, sending you referrals. There's all kinds of things you can do, but it's still a teed up lead.
The online lead — I'll just take this guy that I just wrote today — you got to sell them. You have to talk to them. You have to get to know them a little bit on the phone. They don't know you from Adam or Eve. You actually have to talk to them on the phone and say, "Here's what my agency does. Here's why you should think about working with us versus someone else. Here's why I gave you this policy." You have to justify the premium that you're quoting them. I think that level of sales — when agencies hit a certain size or agencies of a certain disposition, they just do not want to be bothered with that. They just don't want to do it. It feels beneath them to have to explain why they're offering a certain premium to someone. They just want the person to take it.
Caitlin Egger
I think there's a difference in strategy here. When you're working the referrals and the mortgage brokers, and that's great, if you're seeing results from that, keep doing it. That's awesome. Don't let that fall by the wayside. But that's a little bit more of an organic flow to where your sales are coming from. Someone reaches out because you are top of mind. You can live a lifestyle where insurance is what you do. It's a part of who you are. You're talking about it on social media. You're reaching out to your buddies. You go to some networking events, you golf, you make sure you're introducing yourself to the mortgage brokers in your network. But that should grow organically as a compliment to the actual business processes that are already occurring within your agency.
Working your digital marketing leads and having a predictable flow of internet leads coming in — that's your bedrock foundation. That's what sets the motivation for your team, the momentum for your team, the culture for your team so that they're just clipping along at a pace. It's not about "internet leads are beneath us." What's beneath us is sitting around tapping our fingers, waiting for the phone to ring. That's what's beneath us. You can shift the whole mindset and culture in your agency by giving your producers what they want. That's having a warm lead in front of them and someone to talk to. If you can get a live person on the phone, that's half the battle right there. It's all about increasing their at-bats.
When you do that, it starts to take shape. It takes a little bit of time to figure out. But when you do, now you have this predictable flow coming into your agency. You can really crack open this conversation, start looking at the data, start figuring out how many you need to buy for which person, what the close ratios are, how much you have to invest to get the premium that you need. But the referrals are still happening because it's organic. You're still talking on social media. You're still engaging people that you come across on an everyday basis, whether it's online or in person right now. You're still getting referrals, but you're not crossing your fingers, holding your breath, hoping that this mortgage broker relationship is going to work out.
Because you know what? That mortgage broker that has a huge office and 40 brokers and you're like, "Oh my gosh, this relationship is amazing and they're going to send us so much business" — what happens when one of your producers, something goes wrong, you lose that relationship? Or you didn't do anything wrong, you did an awesome job, but their brother opened up an agency around the corner and now that person is getting all of their referrals? Work them. Get to know people. Make sure you're top of mind and that they look at you as being the go-to person for their referral business. But we can't bank on that. It's not as predictable. It's not as steady and consistent and predictable as we like to tell ourselves that it is. Just because it's a great client, just because it's a great quality lead, just because it's high retention, just because it's less expensive, doesn't mean that we're not missing profit and revenue opportunities in other areas.
Ryan Hanley
I completely agree. COVID has made me reevaluate my strategy in a lot of ways, just from the nature of the shakeup. I've kind of taken a two-prong approach to growing my agency. I use David Caruthers' Killing Commercial method. I go after the middle market, working with comp. I went and got my Certified Workers Comp Advisor designation from the Workers Comp Institute just because I wanted everything I could get. I believe that's a really solid way to bring in the type of businesses that I want to work with, businesses that'll appreciate the advisor relationship.
The other side of it is I have an incredibly deep belief that a base of personal lines is important to the longevity, sustainability, and keeping your beta down. You don't want huge swings in your agency. You want predictable income, predictable growth. So what I'm doing is backfilling my work — cold calling, doing content marketing outreach to these middle market accounts — with personal accounts. How do you get personal accounts when you're a startup agency? You get personal accounts by testing different lead providers. What I found just a couple weeks into doing this is if you have a straightforward process that gets a hold of the people quickly and delivers value, they choose you. It's really wild. All this "it's so difficult to get ahold of these people" — not really. I haven't found it difficult to get ahold of people. You have to be responsive. You can't call them back two days later.
Lead comes in, CRM hits them with a couple of messages saying, "Hey, we're working on it. We'll be in touch really soon." You get back to them with an introductory quote. You call them on the phone. You talk about the quote. You revise it. And then you close the business. This isn't rocket science to me. There's no reason that person can't be a good account just because someone filled out a form somewhere online. I hate that idea. We all shop online for everything else. There's nothing wrong with a client going online to Google "cheap insurance Winston Salem." That's just what they've been trained to do by all the ads out there. Our job is to give them a reason to stop their insurance shopping journey today.
Caitlin Egger
Yeah. It's a tall order. We have to up our game. We're talking about taking this conversation next level. This is a more intricate conversation than just working with a referral that already has some trust in you because they heard about you locally or through someone that they know. You're already a little bit ahead because they've at least heard positive things about you. There's some social proof there that's on your side. But you don't have to lean on that like a crutch because you're already an amazing agent. You're already providing a ton of value. You just have to go in casually confident and show up and be ready to clip along at their pace.
You have to be on fire and on point because you only have a couple of seconds to capture their attention. You can't sound like the kind of salespeople that don't have a likable personality over the phone. You got to sound casually confident, like they've reached the right person and you're going to be able to take care of them. But not like, "Oh, this person's just calling to sell me something." Nobody likes getting those telemarketing calls where someone's like, "You've won a free cruise." There's certainly a technique to what that conversation needs to sound like. It's about being real and authentic and not sounding super over salesy. Be somebody that they want to talk to on the phone.
Ryan Hanley
I think the idea of casually confident is really important. Caruthers talks about this all the time in his stuff — they can smell your premium. They can smell that all you want is the business. They can smell it in your voice. They can hear it. And immediately it turns people off. But if you can talk to them in a way that shows them, "Look, I would love to work with you. Here's what my process is. Here's what my product is. But if you decide that I'm not for you, that's fine with me," even though you want to sell as many as you can — if you give that air off to them, they don't feel like you're putting them into a corner. I think that's what turns off a lot of the people who first approach you.
In this case, we're talking about online leads. These people don't have trust in you. They filled out a form. You're the one that approached them. There's no connection yet. If you try to box them into a corner early, they immediately have their guard up. They think you have some sort of ulterior motive. If you can approach them in a way that says, "Look, this is the option. It's the option I would give you. Everything that I've done says to me that this is going to be really good for you long term, but I need you to take a step towards me too. Do you have to want this?" That seems to draw them in a little bit versus "Here's what it is, take it or leave it."
Caitlin Egger
What I hear producers do most often is they get that person on the phone and they're like, "Hey, I got your request. Can I give you a quote for your insurance?" The person says, "Sure." "Okay, so what kind of car you got? It's a Toyota Highlander. Let me verify some information. I work with seven carriers. I'm going to be able to shop this for you." I don't know if any of this sounds familiar, but I hear this often because it's what our gut tells us we're supposed to say. We're just winging it. What we actually have to say to be successful feels a little counterintuitive at first.
We can't start by saying, "I'm an independent agent and I'm with Value Insurance and I work with this many carriers and I'm going to shop you." Start by making it about them first. They've never heard of Value Insurance Agency, right? That's not one of your strong points. So if they ask you, "Oh, who are you again? Where are you calling from?" That's the right time to introduce your agency. But don't start with something that just isn't going to land or hit home. Start by making it all about them.
The way that you pull off the things that you just mentioned, Ryan, about not coming on too strong, is start asking them questions about them. Who doesn't like to talk about themselves? "Who are you insured with right now? Oh my gosh, tell me about that. Your rate went up. Tell me what happened." Now you're having an organic conversation. You're not trying to fill that first two minutes with everything about you and how many carriers you have and how you're going to shop them. It makes it a little bit easier to get a conversation going. The question that I try to start with in any of these types of conversations is: "So what's going on? You filled out a form somewhere. What's going on? Why'd you do that?"
Ryan Hanley
And I just try to keep it as open and as generic as I can and let them go. Because they may have filled out a form for homeowners insurance, but really they're going, "Man, my car insurance goes up every year. My agent is this, or I'm getting divorced from my wife, or I had a really bad claim." You have no idea what's actually going on. You just know that they had intent. So if your first thing is, "Let me give you a quote," they're going to say, just like you said, "Sure."
Where if your first question can kind of catch them off guard... The way I start these conversations when I get an inbound lead—I picked this up when I was doing a lot of content marketing and I had a lot of inbound content, people were calling me off the internet because of my website. Now the Murray Group reaps all that benefit. You're welcome, Shorty.
I would just say, "Hey, my name's Ryan. I'm the owner of Rogue Risk. What's going on? Why'd you fill out the form?" And now you'll hear them pause for a second, because that's not what they're expecting. They're expecting you to go, "Okay, how many cars? What's the VIN number of your car? What price do I need to be there?" That's what they're expecting. When you just ask them what's going on, they'll go, "Well, my rate's gone up three years in a row." "Okay. Why is that?" "Well, I had a really bad claim." "Oh, okay."
So now in your head, you can actually be a value provider. "Well, what did the claim look like?" "Well, I had this $1,200 claim." "Why'd you put a $1,200 homeowners claim in? Who told you to do that?" You know what I mean? Now you can start to drill into what actually is their motivation. By the time you get to the end of that conversation, one, you most likely have all the info that you need. With RealtyTrack and Redfin and Zillow, you don't need to ask them how old their home is. If you're still asking someone, "How old is your home?" you're wasting time. And you sound like... those questions, even though the carriers still want to know that information and need to know it to a certain extent, you should not be asking people that information. In my opinion, you should not be asking them that. It's all there.
So while they're talking, I'm like, "Okay, 22 Johnson Road." Bang. I'm looking at it. "So you had a $1,200 claim. It looks like you have a flat roof. Is that true?" "Yeah." "Okay. Is that a rubber roof?" "Yeah." "Okay. Good." Boom, boom. You're just verifying what's on RealtyTrack or whatever. Once I see that a couple of pieces of information are the same, I know I'm close enough that I don't need to ask them any of the other bullshit questions about their home. "Do you have a dog?" Yes or no, if that matters to some of your carriers. And then it actually sounds like a real conversation. I think that completely throws people off guard. A pattern interrupt of their classic experience.
Caitlin Egger
Right. You can retrain the client surrounding what they expect out of their insurance shopping experience. I'm glad we're talking about this because some of the things that I hear most often are things like, "Oh, I tried internet leads, but nobody picked up the phone," or, "I bought a bunch of them and I quoted a ton, but none of them closed," or, "I'm not going to go that route because there was this agency that came into town and they were selling all this business and we found it was all state minimum. It all fell off the books."
There definitely has to be a strategy around it. And what you just hit the nail on the head—the sales conversation has to be a client-focused, value-based conversation where you're asking meaningful questions and you're selling with a purpose. So before you think about buying internet leads again, before you think about giving it another go, there are a couple of things that have to fall into line first. The first one is what your conversation is going to sound like. Start before you invest in the leads, thinking about it like a sales engineer. Sales engineer this conversation. Call a buddy and role play it with them. Say, "Here's what I'm thinking the best technique is." Refine it.
I'm the Director of Education and Development at Quantum. So it's my job to write our sales processes and our top pass and our scripts and capture what's working for us on the front lines every day through our direct channel, through our agency channels. That helps automate the sales onboarding process for the people that are showing up for our clients, making our company great every day. Selling with Purpose is our hallmark Quantum sales process that walks our agents through exactly how to begin this conversation. You have to start by making that instant connection that you spoke to, Ryan, so that you can overcome objections to the quote.
It all starts with having the right mindset. Go into that call assuming that person is not going to want to talk to you. Don't go into the call assuming they're like, "Oh, hey Ryan, you're the owner at Rogue Risk. Oh my gosh, I'm so glad you called me today." They don't care that you own the business. I actually had that happen one time and I was like, "Oh my gosh, I think I'm being secret shopped."
You have to plan out what the sales conversation is going to look like and have a plan for how you're going to drive a client-focused buying experience from the very first 30 seconds of the call all the way through the close. You can actually create a buying experience for the client that empowers them to end their shopping journey today. You can one-call close this car and home bundle for this family by doing a total risk review for their family right there on the phone live without hanging up. And you can end the call with a great client, just like you did.
So you've got to go into it with a plan. And I suggest practicing first. If internet leads, you tried them before and they didn't work for you, or this is a new process for your agency, you can go into it on the cheap. You can start by cutting your teeth on this. You don't have to go in day one and dump $10,000 into this. I'm definitely not spending $10,000. Don't start there. Because before you play in the major leagues, you practice. There's a ladder.
This is a harder conversation. You want your team to be prepared so that they can get their confidence up. That looks like whoever is the sales leader in your agency—for a lot of our listeners, it's probably the agency owner. That's great if that's you and you don't have a sales manager right now. You should be in front of your team coaching, role playing, creating that coaching culture of feedback within your agency on a daily basis. So if internet leads are new to you, try to carve out some time where you're learning to sell them yourself first. Or if you have a sales manager, your sales manager has some time where they're figuring out this sales conversation first. Once you or your sales manager has a great close ratio on internet leads, now you can start training your team on it and start unleashing that lead source to your sales force.
Ease into it. Learn it yourself first. Because let me tell you, this is a fun conversation. Once you're like, "Man, I've never seen our quote volume. I've never seen close ratios like this. I've never been able to drive business like this before. We just brought a ton of clients. I just bundled. They're all multi-line." You're excited about it. Now you have a reason for your team to be excited about it. So have a plan and start there. You're starting with maybe some cheaper aged leads. You can get really good at talking people into getting a quote with you. Then you're going into it really strong at your at-bats. Then you can start dabbling with some more expensive lead sources.
I think sometimes we're so worried that internet leads won't work that we try to buy the most expensive leads first. Then because we're still cutting our teeth on it, we don't end up making enough money on that batch of leads to just keep throwing money at it. So we pull back and we stop and we go back to what we know, which is the client referrals and the referrals.
I think another important point is you need to have some sort of automation system for this to work. It doesn't have to be super sophisticated, but you definitely need some way that when that lead comes in, there needs to be an immediate touch. I use Better Agency. Everyone who's listening probably knows I use Better Agency. I think it's a phenomenal tool. When a lead comes in, they immediately get an email and a text from me. The email basically outlines their expectations: "We've received your information. Someone is working on your account right now. If we have enough information to provide you with an introductory quote, you will receive a video breakdown and proposal in your email within an hour. If not, we'll be reaching out to you either way. Thank you." The text message just sets the expectation that we're efforting. You didn't just put your information into the ether and it's gone. There are real people behind us. The text message simply says, "Hey, thanks. We got your request. Check your email. It breaks down the process." That's it. That's all the text message says.
Then have a couple days of that broken out where you're hitting them again, hitting them again. Just to say, "Hey, we never got ahold of you. We never did this." Because it takes multiple times. I think people feel like if they don't pick up the phone on the first try, "Oh my God, it's a bad lead." When I worked for TrustedChoice.com, we recorded all these calls that would go to agents. The agent would pick up the phone and immediately try to disqualify the lead. "Oh, you only want renter's insurance? Oh, you're 24? I really only have Progressive and it's probably going to be like $30,000. Is that okay with you? No. Okay. Bye." Or if they did get an inbound lead, they would never call the person back or they would just email them back and be like, "They never got back to me." It's like, you need to email them seven times maybe.
Ryan Hanley
I love producers like that because it creates low-hanging fruit for our million-dollar producers over at Quantum. You're just warming them up.
The good news is, I feel like this is what I love about the independent channel, especially the last five or six years. The game has really been stepped up. I think in general, everyone is way more open. What that has done is shown people, "Hey, look, you can be so many things." I would like to consider myself a middle-market whale hunter because this morning I was working on a $200,000 premium account that I have two carriers positioning against each other for this proposal. And then I'm also writing an internet lead for a $1,300 homeowners policy. My reason for saying that is Carruthers always says you have to be a Swiss Army knife.
You need to be good at a couple of things, but they can be different things. You can be that macho whale killer and write some homeowners insurance or auto insurance through internet leads too. You can do both those things. I think it's completely okay. Ultimately, I think it's a smart decision. One, it keeps you fresh. It spreads out your book of business so that if a certain part takes a hit or something happens, you have some sustainability. And it's just more business. Why sit around during the day and look at Ben Shapiro videos on Facebook when you could be closing a homeowners account?
Caitlin Egger
You know what the number one most motivating thing is for a frontline sales producer, a sales agent that's writing business? We think it's time off. We think it's bonuses. We think, "We're going to give you your kid's birthday." That's awesome. But you know what the number one most motivating thing is for our sales team? Writing a policy. Writing business. Have you ever seen them more excited, jumping up and down? If you come to one of our call centers, we're hooting and hollering, the music is blasting. There's nothing more exciting than writing business because that's what salespeople are here to do. That's where they get their adrenaline.
Create an environment for them where that happens for them day in and day out. You're going to see their energy go up. You're going to see that momentum build in your agency. Sales is a mindset game. You have to have that momentum where that snowball is rolling downhill and it's just getting bigger and bigger and more energy. You're going to see the culture in your agency become more fast-paced. You can have that music going, have everybody at their standup desk. One thing that works for us is an open layout. Your salespeople aren't in individual little offices where you're like, "Hey, go make 300 phone calls," and they go in their office and it's terrible. You can have them out on an open sales floor with music, with stuff on the TV screens, cranking through the dials, rocking it together as a team, having fun.
This doesn't have to be, "Hey guys, I really need you to grit your teeth and rip this bandaid and just do this for the agency." You can make this super fun and totally transform what the day-to-day life looks like in your agency, where they come in and they have clients to talk to. That's what's going to be most motivating for them. When you see that happen, this is one of those big, massive action steps that you can take that has that ripple effect that we all want. We're all looking for, "What's that big step that I can make where everything else is going to fall into place?"
If you can figure out this digital lead marketing game, not only has the culture in your insurance office shifted to a different kind of sales office with that faster pace and that energy, now you have predictability into the numbers. You're able to back-dial it to come up with a strategy for the numbers that you want to hit. And you see a difference in your recruiting efforts. I talk to agents all the time that are like, "I've got these ads out. It's just so hard to recruit people. I'm not sure how to find the top talent." When you have these success stories that you can get in front of candidates, you say, "Our agency operates a little bit differently than the one down the road because you're going to have warm leads. You're going to have clients that reached out that want to talk to you." That's a whole different recruiting conversation than, "Hey man, I'm looking for somebody with grit because we go door to door here."
I've been door to door several times. It's a great method. It works. Don't stop doing that if you're a commercial producer. But it does make it a little bit harder to recruit people because then you're only finding people that are like, "Yeah, I'm all for that. Let's go door to door." Right now, you're opening yourself up to all this talent that could really rock it on the phone.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I agree with you wholeheartedly. I imagine the Quantum salesforce kind of like Jordan Belfort, Wolf of Wall Street, up there banging himself in the head with the thing and screaming into the microphone, everyone losing their mind.
Caitlin Egger
It's so funny. We have a really diverse team. So many fun personalities. Most recently, you can check out our LinkedIn, Quantum Assurance. One of our producers just this week hit $500,000 in premium in less than her first six months with our company. She's just this awesome young woman who gives it her all for her clients every single day. She's not a pushy salesperson. She doesn't have that aggressive sales conversation by any means. But she's casually confident, she's prepared, and she shows up for her clients. She doesn't just give them a halfway presentation. She doesn't say, "Thanks for giving me all that information. I'm going to work up your quotes and call you back." She stays on the line with them until she gets them taken care of. We're talking quality business. We're talking bundles. We're talking great clients. She does amazing, but she doesn't have this stereotypical Wolf of Wall Street feel at all. Total opposite.
I'm just so proud of her because she uses the resources we give her. We have an amazing education program at Quantum. Selling with Purpose really works. She puts her resources to work and she studies them and she doesn't turn it off. She is trending to be a million-dollar producer in her first year at Quantum. And she's not the only one. We can totally change our expectation of what an internet lead conversation has to look like.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I think that's great. Two other things I'd like to say. One, you don't have to work for the bundle every time. Sometimes solving someone's problem is enough in the first conversation to start the relationship. If their issue is they're just getting crushed on their auto insurance and that's the problem they need solved, and wrapping their brain around bringing their home in is just too much, you can solve their auto problem there. Solve their auto problem and then come back. This is what a good CRM, good note-taking, good process, good cross-selling is all about. You can notate the system and say, "A month from now, I want to circle back with you. Let's talk about bringing your home in. It'll probably save you money across the board. But today, I'm just glad we got your auto taken care of." They're going to be so happy because you didn't shove the home down their throat too. Some people can take in the whole conversation. Some just want you to solve their problem.
The other thing is, you can turn a lead into... A lead comes in from online and a lot of people go, "They're buying leads, but what's their attention span? It's probably shitty." Well, it can be just like anything else. If you treat them like real people and not online leads, it can be the same as every other piece of business because you set expectations. You onboarded them. You talked them through what to expect. You helped them understand your service process. You got them all the information they needed to move forward with their life. You saved them money. Maybe you sent them some messages during their policy period about your agency or about their insurance program. You cross-sold them. You asked them for referrals, a Google review. Now come renewal time, they're not shopping anymore because no one likes to shop.
The way I've always approached this is, if someone's shopping online, it means they're lost. They're like a lost child walking the streets of New York with no real idea of where to go. It's why they keep trying every store that they walk into, because they're just trying to figure out where do I belong. If you can show them what it's like to work with your agency—a really good process, a good product, you care about what's actually wrong with the problem they're trying to solve—and then you treat them well after the sale, they're not going to shop anymore. No one enjoys shopping for insurance. It sucks. It's terrible. You think they're just going to be like, "I had a tremendous experience. I have a great price, great product. The people I work with are awesome. I'm just going to go shop for insurance again this year." Nobody does that. They just want to have a great enough experience that they don't have to worry about it anymore so they can take a back seat. It's totally opposite for us. We can talk insurance all day. This is our hobby. This is what we do. One of the top things on my list for what's most fun. We can't expect that out of our clients.
Caitlin Egger
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
Well, we could talk about this all day. I want to be respectful of your time. I appreciate you coming on the show. I think what you guys at Quantum are doing is really shaking up the industry in a very positive way. I know different people have different feelings about these big sales-focused agencies when they come into our space. I'm sure you've gotten some of that feedback because I know how agents think. But I love when a driven group of people come into this space that have a distinct path, that have a philosophy. It forces all of us to rethink. Regardless if anyone actually believes anything that we said, I'm positive that if they listened to this whole episode, it at least got them to start thinking about how they operate their agency.
Maybe they said, "I listened to all of it. I believe it all, but it's still not for me." No problem. What's good is that we're having these conversations and putting out into the open that there is this way of helping grow a business that isn't negative. It has negative connotations, but it isn't actually negative. It can be very positive. Not negative at all for your client, if you're showing up with quality and if they can tell that you care.
Caitlin Egger
That's why Quantum was born. We're really helping fill this need in the agency space where someone can bring their agency on board to Quantum and immerse themselves in this ecosystem. We say, "We believe in the agency model. We believe in you and what your teams are already doing. We're here to help you level it up." We help you figure out how to have that mega startup. We're probably six million dollars in internet lead experience of working with thousands of internet leads over the past 10 years, trying to crack this code of what that conversation should sound like. That really helps our agents hit the ground running so that we can take the mystery out of how to scale our agencies and start seeing results that we've never seen before. Then you see your agency and your lifestyle benefit, but also your teams, because you're making it easier for them to do what they're passionate about.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I think it's great. Thanks for coming on the show. I wish you guys nothing but the best and I look forward to the next time we can connect. This was a blast. Stay safe and healthy.
[To audience] Hey guys, wasn't that just a tremendous episode? I loved talking to Caitlin. She's just dynamic. What they're doing over at Quantum is really amazing stuff. Whether that's the way you want to build your agency or not, it doesn't matter. What matters is that you know other ways that people are thinking about our business. You can always take little pieces and plug them in where they make sense for what you're trying to build. That's the beauty of an independent agency.
I just want to say thank you for listening to this show. I love you for listening to this show. It means so much to me. I love putting these podcast episodes together. If you enjoy this show, I would just ask that you tell one friend. Just tell somebody, "Hey, maybe you want to listen to this show." It just helps our audience grow. If you're feeling super froggy, hop on over to iTunes, leave us a rating and review there. That just helps more people find our show, helps more people get in the ecosystem, which is what this is all about. Sharing ideas. Introducing people.
All right, enough of me. Let's get on to the brilliant, the brilliant Brock Berrigan running this off.
Music plays
Brock Berrigan
[Singing] You go fuck yourself with your fat fucking ass. Thank you. Do you want to have a few drinks and smoke a joint, Bubbles? Yes. Yes. Take it! Take it! Take it! Take it! Do you want to have a few drinks and smoke a joint, Bubbles? Yes.
Advertisement
Narrator
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not with the One Call Close System. You'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff. No endless follow-ups. Just results. Fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying "yes" more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today.