Main Topic: The conversation revolves around the insurance industry, specifically the challenges of recruiting and retaining talent, and the importance of creating a positive and supportive work environment.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Doug Benz, co-founder of New Buffalo Insurance (with his incredible wife, Liz Benz), is one of my personal favorite people in the insurance industry.
One of the things that I enjoy about Doug is he always has one eye on the future while staying true to his professional insurance agent roots.
I loved this conversation and I'm sure you will too...
Episode Highlights:
Key Quotes:
Resources Mentioned:
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
Hello everyone and welcome back to the show. Today we have a tremendous episode for you, a conversation with Doug Benz, one of my favorite people in the insurance industry, one of my favorite people in general. We talk about how we first met, getting to know Doug and his wife Liz. We talk about the, we'll call it a mastermind or meetup that Doug calls the business meeting, which is done in New York City. We talk about the insurance industry. We talk about life. I mean, it's just absolutely tremendous. And Doug's just such a quality professional. I mean, absolutely killing it at New Buffalo Insurance.
The agency is the founder and CEO of, as well as working with the Big Eye Board, being part of killing commercial, attending different industry events, and just has so much knowledge and so much experience. I love talking to Doug. I love his perspective on the industry. I feel like he has a very real, very honest perspective. And just every chance I get to talk to Doug is a pleasure. And he actually had me out to speak at a local Western New York Big Eye event or Western New York insurance event. I'm not really sure. But it was about 60 people. It was awesome. Sorry, it was about 30 people. It was absolutely awesome, small batch.
We had a tremendous time, great conversation. And just it's things like that, that bring us together these in-person things. I love podcasting. I love video. I love all the stuff that we do here in the digital space. But when you can share air with somebody, when you can really spend time with them and get to know them, it's on a whole nother level. And I take that chance every opportunity that I have with Doug and Liz and any of the organizations that he's a part of. So happy to share this episode with you. Before we get there, guys, if you love the podcast, you're going to love the blog. Go to findingpeak.
com. That's findingpeak.com. Go to findingpeak.com. Insert your email, and every Friday you get a new article delivered. It's about the emotional, psychological, physical aspects of life and how we put ourselves in peak performance in order to dominate. And I think you'll love that. It's absolutely free. And also want to give a big shout out to Tivly, T-I-V-L-Y.com, T-I-V-L-Y.com, T-I-V-L-Y.com. If you want to grow your business, go to T-I-V-L-Y.com. If you want to grow your business, go to T-I-V-L-Y.com today. All right, let's get on to the man, the myth, the legend, Doug Benz.
Doug Benz
The falling into it kind of thing is very similar to what most people's story is in our industry. You fall into it or you're born into it. You stumble into it like you're looking for a job and somehow you sort of stumble into it. It's just funny how it grabs a hold of some people. Not everybody, but a lot of people. You see some of the people who work in our space and their story is almost exactly the same. I did this and this and I took a job and all of a sudden it got in me. Once it's in you, you develop an arcane set of skills and knowledge that is completely useless anywhere else in the world. You're just like, where else would I go? I don't know anything else. I've been here for too long.
Ryan Hanley
It is funny. You got into it because of marriage, right? Was that really your introduction to the whole thing?
Doug Benz
I honestly was just picking a new career out of a hat almost. I looked around at some guys I knew that were doing this and it seemed like they were doing pretty well. I was hung up on this idea of something that had residual income, where you could build up all these clients. Then every time it renewed or came around annually, you got paid again. So I was like, whatever, I'll just do this. It was pretty random. I'll get a license and give it a try.
Ryan Hanley
Keep showing up until something good happens.
Doug Benz
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
It's surprising to me. Surprising might not be the wrong word because I know the reason why, but the fact that our industry struggles to recruit people is interesting. I was asked to do an AMA, an ask me anything kind of thing for a lecture. We use lecture as our agency management system and they were having an event. They said, can you be at this event? I couldn't, I had another obligation, but I said I can zoom in. Instead of doing a whole song and dance, why don't we do an AMA? Collect a whole bunch of questions or we can ask questions on the fly. It ended up working out really well. One of the questions someone in the audience asked was, you seemingly don't have a hard time recruiting.
Why is that? What could we be doing differently? My advice was like, stop being boring. There's a reason that the brands in our industry are so boring. I don't understand why. Look at Progressive. That's not a boring brand. They make it fun. They make it funny. We can internally not love their business practices, but people love it. They get engaged. They think, oh, I'm working for Progressive. You think about how we market our agencies, our carriers, our MGAs, or wholesalers. It is just so boring. If people just knew what this career could actually do for them from a skills perspective, from a knowledge perspective, from a purpose and meaning perspective, from a pure monetary lifestyle creation perspective, they would never become financial advisors.
You look at financial advisors, you would laugh at that career versus why so many people want to become financial advisors. Insurance sales is such an opportunity. It's like a secret business.
Doug Benz
Yeah. It almost really is. I think for a long time, it was controlled by families and people outside those families didn't really know how much money you could make doing it or what it was really all about or how it worked. Now we have this aggregation and these big guys that you didn't have too long ago. It is a really good business, but we don't market it too well. It's getting better. There are still the two sides. There are those old school agencies that operate in a way that maybe make you or me cringe in terms of the culture and the way they compensate and sort of treat people or view the whole operation. Then there are folks that are just forward thinking and know that to retain good talent in this day and age, you kind of got to make it fun. You got to have a nice place to work where it's sort of family first and there's some flexibility and maybe you order lunch and shit like that.
Ryan Hanley
I think more than that, because I think family first works great if you're local. I think one of the biggest changes that I see starting to happen, or at least more people are talking about it, is agency brand. We never focused on brand. It would be Ben's Insurance of Buffalo, LLC, and it was just about you. There was no brand. I was talking to someone the other day, a producer, and we're kind of getting back into a hiring phase here. First conversation, she was a CSR we're looking to hire. She said, we used to have to take phone calls and sometimes do outbound calls. I said, that's great, that's a good thing. We do cross selling and stuff. She said, our sales philosophy was our principal said, just use my name and everything will be fine. That was the whole sales philosophy. Never taught her how to sell, never taught question answer Chris Voss, all the stuff that we talk about. It's bananas. His sales guidance to this woman was just drop my name and everything will be fine. That is crazy. That guy thinks he's got a brand.
Doug Benz
At least he thinks he does.
Ryan Hanley
I honestly believe that the circles that we run in, you, me, the people that are on the show, that are friends, it feels like there's a lot of us, but there's not that many of us. There's maybe a couple thousand agents or agencies that are run in a more progressive, forward-leaning manner. It's why you hear people like Billy Vanjura, who I love, always bitching about the same people being on podcasts. It's like, Billy, it's because there's not many people doing things out there that are that exciting. Not trying to be a jerk, but most agencies in most towns in most of this country, that's how they act.
Whoever the white male patriarch is at the top of the heap, his name, his last name, is the marketing strategy. We've been here for 30 years. I was talking to one yesterday at the Buffalo I Day. What are you doing about hiring? How much is somebody? Kind of casually talking about how much do you pay people in your office? This guy is complaining about he can't keep anybody. It's the same thing, name on the door with his dad's. They're in a weird part of town that's changed a lot over probably 50 or 60 years, but they're still there. They're paying people like minimum wage. They're mind blown when we started talking about compensation a little bit.
I can't keep anybody and it's this nightmare. People are still so stuck in this thing where they've got these dungeon offices, paying people like nothing and treating them like they're lucky to have a job. It's not gonna fly.
Doug Benz
I completely agree. There's this meme that goes around from Mad Men. The young girl who works there has this moment where she's crying because he doesn't say thank you. He goes on this rant. He's like, you get a paycheck every other week. You should be thanking me for that. Every business owner watches that and goes, yes, please just do your job. Stop fucking around. Why does every employee feel like on a quarterly basis they need to go crazy for some reason? At the same time, that Mad Men style, your paycheck, you should thank me because you have a job, that doesn't exist today. With knowledge work, with remote work, with the leftists in our government paying people to stay home and have babies, there are a lot of ways to make enough money to survive.
$14 an hour to come in and make cold calls is not attractive. People have no tolerance for a miserable situation at any cost. You can't grow while simultaneously trying to maximize your personal take-home income out of the agency. You see this a lot. An agency will sit at one table and talk about how they're amazing at EBITDA and all this financial gobbledygook and they make all this money that they pull out of the agency and it's hyper-maximized for their own personal benefit. Then they'll sit at another table and go, how do we get leads? Hey Doug, how do we get leads? I don't understand. Why doesn't anyone want to work for me?
You can't milk your agency for every frigging dollar for your own pocket and then wonder why you're not growing. It doesn't work that way. It doesn't mean you can't make a good living, but you have to put something back into the business.
Ryan Hanley
That's a really good point. I'll even say I'm guilty of this. I've come six years now and I feel like I've come to a good equilibrium. When I started this agency and we started rocking and rolling, it was the first time I ever really felt like I had much money to spend on anything. It was like, okay, let's take a trip. Let's do this. Let's do that. I never done this before. It kind of got to a little point where I was like, okay, enough. I got it out of my system. Now I got to be a little bit more disciplined and pay attention and get a little bit back to normal because it's easy to do that.
Doug Benz
What you just described to me is healthy and fair. It's very stressful and difficult owning an agency regardless of shape, size, what you're going after. I don't care if you're one person or a hundred people. I don't care if you're local, national, regional. It doesn't matter. I don't care if it's niche or generalist. It is very difficult doing this job. People look at you, and we've talked about this. Things happen in your agency and people turn and look at you like, Hey Doug, what's the answer? You're the only one that's got the answer. I'm like, I don't really know. The pressure that comes with that, and you're paying people, it's a lot.
I think rewarding yourself occasionally is something you absolutely need to do. The agency owner that I'm referencing is the person who has all their cars there, the country club membership is there, everything is milked out of the agency. Then they wonder why they don't have money to pay people. It's because you've created a lifestyle business, which is fine, but you can't grow that way. That's the dichotomy that I try to pin for people, especially when I'm doing my keynotes. I'm interested in this for you. The lifestyle agency is the Holy Grail. You're making whatever your number is to be happy.
You're doing the minimal amount of work necessary to maintain that. But you're probably not growing. Maybe you're flat. How do you mentally, because I'm always out over my skis pushing because that's where we have to be right now. I fantasize on a daily basis about what it would be like to have a local agency with a hundred or so clients that paid me enough that I could live my life. Where do you fall on that? How do you manage that thought process? I know you want to grow, but at the same time, you've got this family that you want to spend time with. You got Liz. How do you manage that? I know it's hard.
I feel right now like looking towards the next five years, something's got to change a little bit because there's a lot of times that you feel like your hair's on fire. We got a pretty good staff here, but I also don't want to beat them down or grind them into the ground. You feel ground down sometimes. It's easy to justify taking the trip you want to take because you can. Longer term, I don't want to just grind and grind and keel over at my desk. Somebody was telling me this week that their husband is buddies with these accountants at some big firm. It was such a crazy year, they were working seven days a week, 12 hours a day.
Two dudes in this office had heart attacks at the end of March. I don't want to be that guy. I do not want to die at my desk. It is a challenge to try to take the next step. I feel like we built something, we are growing, but it's a lot of hard work. Working with Liz is also interesting. For 60 or 70% of the time we were married, we never worked together. Then I started this and I was like, please, will you come help? She's like, yeah. So we've been with these partners after not having anything like that previously. It's a lot on both of us. She gets some mom guilt if she can't get out of here to pick the kids up because she's working on something.
Some harmony in the home life and the work life is a priority for me right now. Trying to find the next step, how you can continue to grow, but also just not be the only person that can answer a bunch of questions and feel like on a Friday at five o'clock you just went 10 rounds with Muhammad Ali.
Ryan Hanley
This last year I've struggled with this particular issue quite a bit. Now I'm a single dad and I don't wake up with my kids in my house every day, which was one of my favorite things. The time that I'm with them, I want to maximize that time. At the same time, I'm trying to grow this agency in a way that there's no clear path on how to do it. Managing a relationship with a parent company that now owns us outright, I have goals that I have to hit or I sold my company for free, which would make me want to become murderous. That can't happen. You have to make trade-offs and it's very difficult. I basically broke up with a woman that I was seeing who I liked and we had good times together because between work and my kids, I literally don't have the mental space for a female.
I can still go on a date with her, but the idea of, hey, what are we doing this weekend? That concept would be so overwhelming to me. I'd be like, I have five meetings today. The fourth meeting is a make or break partnership meeting. We're behind on this. My kids have baseball practice. I also have to make sure I have the right school clothes because tomorrow's a dress up day. Now I've got to think about my plans for the weekend. How do you do that? It's not like when you're 25 and you can just go have a blast all weekend and do whatever and roll out of bed and go to work on Monday. This is the real deal.
Doug Benz
There's a book by a guy named Derek Sivers. He wrote a couple of books. He's very smart. It's called Hell Yes or No. I have not dialed in this mental model yet, but I will. I'm trying to say to myself, and I tend to write and create things to remind myself of them, this idea of you're either hell yes on something or it's a no. There's no in between. There's no I probably should. If it's a probably should, it's a no. My kid has a sports game or a dance recital or they're giving a presentation. That's a hell yes. I'm going to that. But this meeting that I'm kind of like, I guess I could take it or leave it, that gets a no. That frees up the space. I'm not trying to pretend like I have this dialed in. I'm still working on this. By it being hell yes or no, all the no's free you up for the hell yeses. There's nothing worse than, man, I would freaking love to do insert thing, but I got all these meetings that I don't really care about, but I've already scheduled them. Now you don't do the thing you really want to do in exchange for five things that you're mad about but feel like you should. You're just getting owned by other people in that situation.
Ryan Hanley
I want to talk about the business meeting. We did this really fun thing that was put on by Doug and Liz and it was tremendous. It was like a 15 couple, I think I was the only person who wasn't a couple. 15 kind of agent with significant other event down in New York City. We just had an absolutely tremendous time. It was a wonderful group. It was basically like a day and a half-ish. A couple people said it, and I agree with them, this is the future of events. Talk me through where this idea came from. It was a big deal to put it on, and you did a fantastic job. What was the impetus for this? Why did you decide to even do something like this?
Doug Benz
It was kind of random a little bit. It's not part of some grandmaster scheme. I always feel like that's a little lame, like I should have some really big idea that this is some part of something. But it wasn't. I was at a lot of events and have developed a really nice crew of friends in the business all around the country. A couple common things I would hear people say, oh, you're from Buffalo, do you spend a ton of time in New York City? The answer is, yeah, sure, I love to go down to New York, but it's at the opposite end of the state, it's quite a distance. If you're talking to somebody from Montana or Oklahoma, they think Buffalo and New York City is like a 20 minute train ride.
That led into conversations. A lot of answers you get, you know, I do all this traveling, I've been to all these things, but I've never been to New York City. Or I went to New York City once when I was a kid for a Yankees game. I've never been to New York. I'm like, we've got all of these people who are really out front in our industry, and they've never been to New York. I love New York. In this post-COVID world, New York was where it started and hit so hard. The city is kind of continuing to struggle back a little bit. I was like, let's just take a field trip to New York. I thought one day is pretty easy for people.
It's not like you got to go for three days or four days. I'll make it quick in and out. I'm the ultimate ADD boy. Sometimes when I go to these things and I'm in a hotel ballroom all day, I can get antsy. I can get a little anxious or struggle to stay focused. As we all know, even though there's a lot of amazing content, especially if you haven't been exposed to it previously or if you just started an agency, the sidebars are where the magic happens too. I thought this would be a chance to do that. It'd be kind of fun to just go to New York and take a little field trip and go to a couple of meetings.
I was beating my head against the wall. I had some things, I won't tell you what the failures were, but I had a few things I was trying to do and it wasn't really coming together. I thought I had a little juice here and I was getting a little down because I wasn't getting anywhere trying to pull this thing together. I'm on this Big I New York board. I was chatting with Lisa Lounsbury, who's the Big I CEO here in New York. She was like, hey, what do you want to do? Who do you want to talk to?
She's like, "I know a lot of people down there." So we kind of spitballed a couple ideas together, and she's like, "I can introduce you to this person. I can introduce you to that person." And she did, and they were super responsive and excited about it.
So we ended up doing it on March 2nd, a Thursday. We all met on Wednesday, the day before. You and I had a drink at the hotel. You were the first person I saw. We went to Lloyd's America on Park Ave and met with their CEO. We had a really cool Q&A, he gave a little presentation, and we talked about a lot of different things changing and forces in the market. Then we grabbed lunch and went down to InsureTech New York on West 23rd Street. We saw what they're doing there, talked to some people in their accelerator about what they're working on. I thought it was a great conversation to have because, as we know, a lot of InsureTech can equal "no agent" for a lot of people. So to have that conversation with those guys, inject that perspective, and frame that mindset, I thought was very cool.
And then, you're in New York, right? So you got to get dressed up and have dinner, kind of Frank Sinatra style, a little decked out. So that was it. Some people hung out for the weekend, which was nice. But I'll tell you, I never thought going into it that the field trip idea would have so much impact. I've heard that from a number of people now, and I hear other people that I don't even know are talking about it. It's gaining a little bit of traction, this field trip idea. That makes me feel good.
Ryan Hanley
[To audience] What's up guys? Sorry to take you away from the episode, but as you know, we do not run ads on this show. In exchange for that, I need your help. If you're loving this episode, if you enjoy this podcast, whether you're watching on YouTube or listening on your favorite podcast platform, I would love for you to subscribe, share, comment if you're on YouTube, leave a rating and review if you're on Spotify or Apple iTunes. This helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in. We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in, men and women who've done incredible things, sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales, the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business.
But they all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. So as I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show. Subscribe if you're not subscribed. I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. Or if you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating and review of this show. I love you for listening to this show, and I hope you enjoy listening as much as I do creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
Yeah, no, I thought it was tremendous. I had such a good time. I agree with you. It was built for side conversations. That to me is a very magical insight that you had. While you may be inspired watching someone on the main stage tell their story, the conversations you remember are often the ones had in between the sessions, at the bar, at breakfast, coffee, or on a little walking excursion. Those are the conversations that sold my business. That's really where the first time I ever even considered selling the business happened. I had considered taking more investment, but I had never considered selling it until I had a side conversation at an event. It was a happy hour conversation after the conference you spoke at, right? Life-changing.
I think the fact that you were able to facilitate that throughout an entire day was special. There were these things we did at InsureTech New York, but there were all these moments baked in between, whether intentionally or unintentionally. You'd be walking down a sidewalk and you'd walk a block with one person talking to them, then naturally that would morph and you'd be standing next to somebody else and walk a block with them. All the different personalities. That was a special event. I thought you did a tremendous job. I hope you guys think about doing it again.
Doug Benz
I appreciate that. If you and a lot of other people hadn't made a lot of effort to get there, it would have been just me and my wife having dinner in New York. It was special because people showed up. I know people made getting babysitters and shuffling schedules around. It was not the easiest or cheapest thing for folks to do. I appreciated that so much. When I tossed it out there, the response was like, "Yes, I'll be there."
Ryan Hanley
That's also the beauty of our industry. I have found this to be true over the course of my career, and I think you and I have talked about it before. The friendships you make, even if you don't talk to those people every day, they're lasting. There were a few people there I hadn't met before, which is great, but a lot of the people that came were people I've been friends with for a long time. You don't see someone for a year or a year and a half in person, even if you communicate online, and it just snaps right back. You get right into this groove. You appreciate these people and what they do. The industry is incredibly supportive.
One thing I think was funny, and I haven't shared this or even talked about it, I just wrote it down in my phone while listening to the InsureTech New York guys. Non-retail agent, non-independent agent insurtech people get excited about the wackiest stuff. They'll be like, "We got this pet insurance insurtech startup here," and everyone's eyes are glazing over. Pet insurance. And they're like, "We're doing something really cool with embedded dog collar insurance." And you're like, "Oh God." They say, "You don't understand the dog collar market. We just raised $30 million." And we're like, "What are you talking about?" These guys are all jacked up about embedded dog collar. Then they'll be like, "Yeah, they got pre-seed angel, $30 million at a $100 million valuation." You're like, "What the fuck?" Who are the people giving these people money? It's just so crazy. Nothing against it, I get it, it's just funny.
Doug Benz
It is a trip. I think it's that much more important to have our voice in there, though, because sometimes, God bless these guys, it's such wackiness. If you talk to somebody on the ground about this... I also felt bad, and I'm not going to name his name, but for the cyber insurance guy. One of the three insurtechs did their thing, and one of them was a guy that had a new cyber startup. I don't think he was really aware of who was in the room or the expertise or breadth of awareness in the room. He starts talking about this thing, and you could tell immediately no one cared because there are 10 bazillion cyber startups out there. They all do some sort of product. "We have a bot that scans their website and comes back with a report." Someone raised their hand and said, "So it's basically like this one, this one, and this one?" And he's like, "Well, no, it's different because we got..." And you're like, "So it's basically the same."
I feel bad because that guy paid probably a couple hundred thousand dollars to get an MBA somewhere, which taught him to do a regression analysis. That regression analysis came out with the same findings that every other cyber startup has come out with: companies need cyber insurance. So he starts this company, and it's exactly the same. At this point, what is the delineation between all the cyber companies? There's no difference. They all do a little report thing. They all have the same insuring agreements. The same underwriting requirements. You got to have two-factor and all this other stuff. It's all the same. They're like, "Wait, you're a company that actually needs cyber? Nah, we're not interested. We don't write cyber policies for the companies that actually need them. We write cyber policies for the companies that don't need them because we don't want to pay any claims. Specializing cyber policies for contractors. That's what we're going after." So he doesn't have a website or an email address? We want that account. That's what we want. And hey, how does he feel about $25,000 a year? I feel pretty good.
Ryan Hanley
So on that note, what's working for you, man? What's your big secret? What's the little secret sauce that's got you cranking right now? Is it the Kellen Commercial stuff? Is it just your process? Is it the networking, relationships? What's got you cooking?
Doug Benz
Kellen Commercial continues to be a great influence on us. We have a new producer here, Noah, who came from the car world. He went through the whole process with all the modules, and it was a really great training to get him up and moving. That's some nice energy in the office. We're working together, and I'm trying to get him moving. I feel like you're always trying to shake the bushes a little more on prospecting and just be disciplined about the prospecting you want to do.
It's the usual mix. We have a pretty good network of referrals going. We have some really good referral partners, like payroll folks who take over a pay-as-you-go work comp from Paychex, who bring us in to handle that for them. That's a valuable one. The social stuff is a pretty consistent inbound draw. It feels like the world is returning to a better spot, I hope, because the economy is still concerning. But last year, we had people that are always buying buildings or doing stuff, movers and shakers that felt like they were doing no moving and no shaking. It seems like that's coming back a little bit more. Our people are doing stuff, and they need insurance for it.
We're always trying to prospect a little more. We just brought on a VA for a telemarketing campaign. Hopefully that brings some good stuff. I don't know, it's a little bit of a weird time, but it feels good. We're writing some business. We're swamped with trying to re-quote stuff way more than you would normally be, but we're figuring it out. I'm excited about this year. Last year was the one year since we started that it was just like, "What is going on?" In terms of new business, it was awful compared to the years prior. It feels like we're back on track this year a little bit, but there's a little bit of scariness out there. I'm not gonna lie.
I have this list going on my desk that I'm just writing down of stuff that we've lost. In personal lines, it's leaving. We had one today, a small welding company. This guy called and said, "I just got my renewal bill. Just shit-can this thing. I'm barely working at all anyway." We've had a steady stream of small guys that are going out of business. But at the same time, I feel like it's leveled out by the big guys that are growing. One little contractor throws in the towel, and the bigger contractor buys two trucks. It's basically premium positive if that happens in one day. That's what it feels like right now, which is weird.
Ryan Hanley
I'd say that philosophically, we're seeing the same exact thing in what we are doing. I hate that because obviously that's the leftist's plan: grow big business and put all the little guys out of business through taxes. Our state is the worst at that. That being said, I feel like the challenges of the moment also create opportunities. I think there's a lot of agents, a lot of businesses, a lot of small business owners in general. I think you even see this in some of the big guys. They're in holding patterns. What is the economy going to do? What are interest rates going to do? What's going to happen with the market? It's a hardening market. Let's batten down the hatches.
To me, that creates the biggest opportunity for us to either shorten the gap to our competitors or extend it, depending on where we fall in our current evolution. If you can be the loudest voice in a time when everyone else is scared, you get to own the narrative. If people have been following along with any of my social, they'll see that I've been putting out content like a crazy man. We're gearing up. I've been doing it personally, and a lot of that is tests and different stuff. We're going to be hiring, so a lot of those videos are sharing part of it. It's like a daily diary for myself. It holds me accountable and captures the different thoughts I have. It's part of my method of healing. But the other side of it is recruiting. I want people to understand what the philosophy and methodology is.
On the other side, what we're going to be doing at Rogue is taking what I learned doing a lot of the individual stuff on my personal channels and applying it to Rogue in terms of the tactics and strategies. I think that if you can get out ahead of people right now, especially using marketing in some form, whatever your preferred form is—it could be a physical newsletter, it could be calling, whatever—if you can add value, give people guidance, give them support, just be positive during this time when small businesses are struggling right now.
Any political leader or economic commentator who goes on any platform and tries to pretend like things aren't bad right now—this is a line I use on Twitter all the time and it gets me in trouble—I'm like, "This person doesn't buy their own groceries." If you have the balls to go onto a public forum and make any kind of comment that inflation is not currently a problem, you are either selling something or you're an idiot. You certainly don't buy your own groceries. I'm a single guy that somehow manages to pay for a week in groceries. I don't understand how I do that. I don't even have that much stuff. I couldn't imagine what your freaking grocery bill is. It's got to be like $10,000.
Doug Benz
Everything's through the roof too, man. Just what it was like a minute ago. It's crazy how every week, Liz does a shop and she's like, "Man, it was amazing because this was up or that was up." Something just a week ago, milk was whatever four bucks, now it's $4.50 or something. I think everybody sees it. Everybody in our local communities, the size businesses that most of the people who listen to this show work on—if they write commercial, middle market, and small business—they all see it. They're all feeling it. The cost of their materials is going up. The cost of their inventory is going up. Their employees are more expensive. Payroll. Taxes are going up all over the place. Everybody feels it, and I think everybody's scared.
I think that creates an opportunity because people's antennas go up. Maybe they're open to new opportunities, maybe situations that haven't been productive to them. But also, they're just looking for someone to anchor them to the fact that they're not fucked. If you can live in a place of positivity and be that thing, even if you're just talking to yourself, that's powerful. This is why I don't mind talking head inspirational videos on social media. I know some people think they're trite or whatever, but to me, if I can just get a little blast of positivity, that feels like a good thing. If you need to jump on social and just want to do a quick walking video—I know you do them sometimes. You did them when you had that big snowstorm, right? You stood out and said, "Hey, look, things are shitty, but we're here to help. Let me help you. If you need help, reach out. This is how you get home." That stuff now is more meaningful than ever because what it says is, "Look, Doug might not have all the answers, but shit, he's out there." I now know that at least there's somebody out there who can help me. That feels very important.
Ryan Hanley
That is the beauty of social, to try and fill social with some positivity. It's a great mission. Your stuff looks good. I noticed a little change in flavor, some edgier titles and stuff that grab your eye. It looks really good. We're trying. I like what you're doing. You got to be there and you got to let people know. I'm a firm believer that sometimes in this job, you really feel more like a counselor than anything. I had this guy recently where the sign blew off his building. The carrier said, "Wow, the supports might have had some wear and tear there." It was a little back and forth, but it's all working out in the end. He was really pissed off and angry. Just trying to say the right thing, like, "Okay, relax for a minute. Let us take a look." Or just listening to these people sometimes. Telling them it's going to be okay. It's going to work out. "Stay sane for a minute on me, please."
Doug Benz
I've been working on my team, helping train them on my personal inbound sales philosophy. It's probably not much different than any sales philosophy, but the first step of the process is really two parts. You literally just ask, "How can I help?" and then shut up and let them talk. At the end, you confirm whatever they said, and you go, "Don't worry, I got you." You just ask an open-ended question. At the end, when they're done bitching and barfing whatever their problems are—big or small, wide ranging—when they get to the end, you just go, "Hey, don't worry, I got you," or "We got you." Even though you're talking to them on the phone, you can almost feel a little bit of tension come out of their body because that's all they really wanted. They wanted somebody to tell them everything was going to be okay. They wanted somebody to tell them they're safe.
Obviously, you have to make good on that, and that's the job. But just letting people know... That's why I think more than ever, positivity on social sharing matters. I have a whole group of people that I talk to and comment with. They share positivity stuff all the time. We'll even talk about once in a while how people will make fun of you. Some of my buddies here locally, not being jerks, just good-natured, will be like, "Oh, another meme or whatever." And I'm like, "Look, me hitting share on my Instagram story of that positive message—I don't need you to give a shit about it. That was for me. That was me saying this piece of positivity just helped me today. It kept me from going into the dark corners that we can go in when we're losing accounts, or the bank account isn't as flush as we think it should be, or an employee is giving us a hard time about something and we don't know how to handle it."
You can go into dark holes. I think those little bits of positivity can go a long way if you take them in. I'll give Liz some credit. When I'm freaking out about something, she'll be like, "Where's the opportunity?" To just shift your mind like that when you're going into those dark places is so necessary because let's face it, this is tough. There's a lot of stuff. You got relationships with carriers, you got employees, you got your brand, you got all these different dimensions. All the back office accounting. There's so much to do here beyond just going out and taking care of customers, which is what you really want to do. Any one of those things is really enough to tweak you at any given time. "Oh my god, I got all these agency bills. I gotta make sure I pay those. I'm down to the wire. Oh my god, my employee's pissed off. Oh my god, this carrier I haven't written anything with all year is up my ass right now." It's easy to get yourself really tuned up. You got to reinforce that positivity constantly.
Ryan Hanley
I know that. That's one of the reasons why I started posting the workout videos, which I also get made fun of. 100%. You're over 400 on the deadlifts, bro.
Doug Benz
Yeah, 425. 425 is my max. I only got that once, but 425 is my max right now. Actually, today is deadlift day. It's the next thing I'm doing after this. I'm really excited. I try to deadlift once every 10 days. That's my rhythm.
Ryan Hanley
The point was not... I get made fun of a lot because people say it's thirst traps. If anyone understands the thirst trap, let's just say this: I didn't originally start posting them as thirst traps, but they don't hurt the single game. Let's just put it that way. But it wasn't the original purpose. I am now aware of it.
Doug Benz
Perfectly.
Ryan Hanley
The whole point was that if I am not physically active at a fairly strenuous level, my brain can get dark. I start thinking negatively about myself. I start thinking negatively about where I am, my future. "You don't have discipline." I go down this rabbit hole of self-defeatism. I started saying that posting is my way of holding myself accountable because I can go back in. I mostly only post days I do work out—I do work out almost every day. But I can now see my progress. People don't care, but I can go back and see my form a year ago versus my form today on a pull or a lift. That keeps me positive. It's about staying in that positive frame of mind versus allowing ourselves to spiral into negativity where nothing good happens. I love what Liz said. "Where's the opportunity?" That's brilliant. You're lucky to have a partner who supports you that way.
Doug Benz
I am. I'm very grateful for her. I'm a lucky dude.
Ryan Hanley
I appreciate about you that discipline and that mindset. I am striving for that right now in my life too. I'm trying to get fit. It's hard. The fact that you have that discipline and you know that clarity comes from that and you don't fall off track—I admire that because it's not easy. When you get into that rhythm, you feel so good. It's like a drug. But at the same time, you're being pulled to be this lazy ass. If you go and do it, it is everything that you need to be good in this life in terms of clearing your head and feeling good and getting that rush. But it's so easy to just be like, "I don't want to get off the couch."
Doug Benz
I completely get it. Two things there. One, I think the key is not to... What I've learned about myself, especially with the exercising stuff but really anything that involves discipline, is that you're going to fuck up. Truth is, I haven't worked out. I've walked. I try to on days that I'm not going to get a workout, I try to walk at least two miles. I fucking hate running, so I don't run. But I haven't done anything more than walk for the last two days in a row, and I'm starting to get a little crazy. It's just because of life and work and kids and all those kinds of things.
One of the things I'll leave you with, and I want to be respectful of your time and the audience's time, is that I really try to work five hours during the work day. Out of the eight-hour work day, I'm only going to work, work, work five hours. Not because I'm getting 10 hours a day in, but I'll have like an hour in the morning, probably have two hours at night, and then I'm trying to do five-ish hours, maybe a little more. I'm still getting that extra time in. But what I've done is said, "I'm not getting to the gym at 6pm. It's not happening for me." For me, the best time to get to the gym is sometime between noon and 4pm. That's when my body is the most dialed in and ready to exercise. Plus, I usually need a break then anyways.
Ryan Hanley
So if I'm cranking all morning, I need a break in the early afternoon. So what I've just said to myself is, instead of saying, "Geez, I'm missing two hours of work between commute and workout and commute back," I just tell myself, this is part of my work day. I can't make a good decision on a really tough business meeting or a tough strategy or dealing with a tough issue if my brain is not optimized, if I'm not firing on all cylinders. And part of my cylinders is working out.
So I've just basically said, it's part of my work. Me doing this exercise is part of me being the best version of myself at work. When I started telling myself that, I stopped feeling the guilt for going and working out in the middle of the day. I have a really important business meeting this afternoon because we're recording this in the morning. So I'm going to go get my work in now. I'm going to get all jacked up. And this afternoon, this mother doesn't know what's going to happen to him when I show up at this meeting, because I'm going to be coming in like a rocket ship.
And that to me, out of this entire day, if I crush that meeting, nothing else could happen in this day. And that was a very productive day. That's kind of how I started thinking about it. So dude, anytime you have a question about workout shit, this is what I love to talk about. So you just text me or call me.
But dude, I'm so happy for your success. I'm so happy that you and the way you are in your methodology is starting to spread out to the broader insurance industry. I obviously think the world of you and Liz. I think you guys are dear friends and happy to support you. I can't believe this hasn't happened sooner. I'm so happy that we finally had a chance to talk on the podcast.
Doug Benz
Yeah, me too. It's a great honor to be on. We love you back, buddy. You were one of the first people I met in this business. Another agent, another owner outside of Buffalo or something when we started. We were saying that in New York, but it really sticks in my mind. It was like day one. It was a trip to Albany and we met you. Thinking back about where we've come in that time...
I love that benchmark to think back. I mean, we didn't even have a customer yet. We were just talking, and here we are. So it's awesome. Thanks for having me on. I appreciate it so much.
Ryan Hanley
Absolutely. Go crush it, man. You got some good stuff lined up. I'll talk to you.
Doug Benz
All right, buddy. Be good.
Ryan Hanley
All right. Be good. Later.
Doug Benz
See you.
Ryan Hanley
See you.
End of interview
[Announcer]: We use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One-Call Closed System eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclosed.com. That's masteroftheclosed.com. Do it today.