Main Topic: The BBC Global News Podcast discusses a proposed peace plan for Gaza, announced by US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
President Trump unveiled a wide-ranging Gaza peace plan on Monday and won cautious backing from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who warned he was still ready to "finish the job" against Hamas.
The Global News Podcast brings you the breaking news you need to hear, as it happens. Listen for the latest headlines and current affairs from around the world. Politics, economics, climate, business, technology, health – we cover it all with expert analysis and insight. Get the news that matters, delivered twice a day on weekdays and daily at weekends, plus special bonus episodes reacting to urgent breaking stories. Follow or subscribe now and never miss a moment. Get in touch: [email protected]
Andrew Peach
This is the Global News Podcast from the BBC World Service. I'm Andrew Peach.
[21 Hours GMT on Monday the 29th of September] This is a special edition with the news that President Trump and the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have agreed a peace plan for Gaza.
I hope that we're going to have a deal for peace. I have a feeling that we're going to have a positive answer.
If Hamas rejects your plan, Mr. President, then Israel will finish the job. This can be done the easy way or it can be done the hard way.
Benjamin Netanyahu
[standing alongside President Trump] If a proposal was not accepted the U.S. would back Israel's response.
Andrew Peach
I hope that we going to have a deal for peace And if Hamas rejects the deal which is always possible they the only one left Everyone else has accepted it But I have a feeling that we going to have a positive answer But if not as you know Bibi you have more full backing to do what you would have to do Everyone understands that the ultimate result must be the elimination of any danger posed in the region And the danger is caused by Hamas.
Benjamin Netanyahu
[after two years of war in Gaza] If Hamas rejects your plan, Mr. President, or if they supposedly accept it and then basically do everything to counter it, then Israel will finish the job by itself. This can be done the easy way or it can be done the hard way, but it will be done.
We prefer the easy way, but it has to be done. All these goals must be achieved because we didn't fight this horrible fight, sacrifice the finest of our young men, to have Hamas stay in Gaza and threaten us again and again and again with these horrific massacres.
[he didn't trust Gaza to be left in the hands of the Palestinian Authority] And he said Israel would never accept a Palestinian state alongside Israel. That would be an outcome that, after October 7th, would reward terrorists, undermine security, and endanger Israel's very existence.
As for the Palestinian Authority, I appreciate your firm position that the PA could have no role whatsoever in Gaza without undergoing a radical and genuine transformation. It won't come as a surprise to you that the vast majority of Israelis have no faith that the PA Leopard will change its spots.
But rather than wait for this miraculous transformation, your plan provides a practical and realistic path forward for Gaza in the coming years, in which Gaza will be administered neither by Hamas nor the Palestinian Authority, but by those committed to a genuine peace with Israel.
Andrew Peach
To bring you some reaction, the French President Emmanuel Macron has hailed Mr Trump's commitment to ending the conflict. Italy says it's ready to play its part in enforcing the proposal. The Islamic Jihad Group has said the announcement holds the recipe to blow up the Middle East.
Our Middle East analyst, Sebastian Usher, is with me. Sebastian, listening to the two men in the White House, has Israel's position shifted significantly?
Sebastian Usher
I think that you probably can say that this meets most of what he wants from an end to the conflict. I mean, there are two obstacles in a way that have been big stumbling blocks from his perspective before. One was about accepting a ceasefire that would not allow Israel, if he felt it necessary, to continue fighting in Gaza against Hamas and other factions when that ceasefire came to an end.
Now, he said himself when he was on the podium with President Trump that that condition has essentially, with the others that had been set, had been met by this. because this does seem in some sense to go against what he's been wanting up until now, saying that the 72 hours if this happens according to this mechanism in which all the hostages would be released would also mean an immediate end to the war But at the same time Hamas would have had to accept within the conditions of this plan their surrender Hamas' total surrender, essentially.
Its demilitarisation, handing over all its arms, all its other arms being destroyed, and that its members would either essentially be de-radicalised and could perhaps stay in Gaza or if they accepted that they would no longer bear arms and would no longer stage any militant actions, any terrorist actions, then they could be given amnesty and go into exile and that they would play no role whatsoever in any future of Gaza or Palestine as a whole.
So that is essentially surrender from the perspective of Hamas. Now, you could say that the way that the conflict has gone does give Israel very much militarily the upper hand. There's no doubt that Hamas is a shadow of what it was. So it's down in a sense to its leaders, I think, inside Gaza who are still fighting, whether they want to continue with what would in a sense perhaps be a last stand, but will continue to have a very, very heavy cost for Palestinian civilians if they did so, rather than surrender on paper now.
We don't know where that's going. I think they'll be playing for time, as we've had before, with Hamas essentially giving a kind of guarded positive, but with conditions that they feel still need to be met in this. as you heard there, as we heard, essentially both Mr. Trump and Mr. Netanyahu, as they have before, so if Hamas doesn't accept this, then President Trump will stand fully behind Mr. Netanyahu, whatever action he then takes.
And Mr. Netanyahu said there's an easy way and there's a hard way to do this. So I think, you know, this brings the Palestinians to an extent inside Gaza, of the civilians, it brings them into play to an extent. Do they still believe that what Hamas is doing has any real positive end result that could be achieved, in which case the lives that many of them could still lose if this isn't signed up to would have some meaning?
Or had they reached a stage where they think that's no longer the case and that Hamas, along with Israel, which is of course, continuing with its offence, particularly in Gaza City, have to be held responsible for any continuing loss of civilian life. This is a big quandary for Hamas.
Andrew Peach
So what does this mean for the remaining hostages held by Hamas that are believed to be alive in Gaza? My colleague Paul Henley has been getting reaction from Yehuda Cohen, the father of 20-year-old Nimrod Cohen, an Israeli soldier who was captured on the 7th of October.
Yehuda Cohen
Well, it's progress, but we are kind of in a limbo, kind of out of hell. But let's see if we'll go into heaven. Meaning, first thing, if Hamas will accept it. Second thing, if Netanyahu could pull it through with his current government, which is very right extreme racist government.
But you spoke to NewsHour last week when you were talking about Netanyahu's speech to the UN General Assembly in New York, and you were absolutely pessimistic about a deal. Things have turned around.
As I said then, first of all, I must admit, in his speech and his interview after that with Fox News, everything was no, no, no, no, no. As I said then Netanyahu needs to be forced on a deal And we know that between those smiles and those hugging Trump actually forced this deal on Netanyahu Remember that he forced Netanyahu to apologize to the Prime Minister of Qatar.
Trump is kind of forcing Netanyahu this deal while he's hugging him. So Netanyahu needs to pull it through his government. His government is very extreme, very right extreme.
I heard that Parliament member, Knesset member Gantz is again willing to help. The main problem is seeing that Hamas will accept it and we know that it was with agreement with Qatar, with Turkey, with Egypt. We need to hear a final answer from Hamas.
We need to see when is it going to start? These 72 hours. When those 72 hours are going to start? And that's crucial to you, isn't it? Because if Hamas does not accept everything about this plan immediately, your son is in mortal danger.
Andrew Peach
Exactly. This is the thing. And again, it's new. It's just now. As you heard the press conference by Trump and Netanyahu, I heard the same thing. And let's see what will be the next step, which is Hamas' answer. Time will tell.
Rushdie Abu Alouf
Well, officially, they have just received the proposal from the Qataris and the Egyptians, and they promised to study it. That's what they have told both the mediators.
Earlier today, I spoke to Hamas figure in Doha. He was like, very unlikely that Hamas would accept something that they have rejected many times before.
And he said all of the previous offers was like much better than this one. And he was talking about three main issues for Hamas, saying that we would not accept any agreement that not guarantee ending the war and withdrawing all of Israeli forces from Gaza.
And most important is that Hamas will not give up their weapon unless there is a Palestinian state created.
But we have managed to speak to one of the field commanders in Al-Qasim Brigades in Gaza a couple of days ago. And he said that they have received a message from the overall now commander, called Izzeddin al-Haddad.
He's in charge of Hamas military and everything in Gaza, who told them that we are preparing for the last battle. He said that they are preparing 5,000 militants. They called up from all around Gaza Strip, including 2,000 people who are from the elite unit, and they prepared 500 suicide bombers, as he said.
Andrew Peach
Well, that's it from this special edition of the Global News Podcast. There's more online at bbc.com slash news. And our regular edition with all of today's global stories will be available to download later.
This edition was mixed by Daniel Fox. The producer was Stephanie Tillotson. The editor is Karen Martin. I'm Andrew Peach. Thanks for listening. And until next time, goodbye.