The main topic of this podcast episode is Andy Samberg, a comedian and actor, being interviewed by Amy Poehler. The episode is a conversation between the two friends, covering various topics such as Andy's childhood, his experiences with the Lonely Island, and his current projects.
Key points from the episode include:
Takeaways from the episode include:
Overall, the episode is a lighthearted and entertaining conversation between two friends, covering a range of topics and offering insights into Andy's life and career.
Amy Poehler
This episode is brought to you by Nordic Naturals. Did you know that only 20% of Americans get enough omega-3s from their diet? Discover the power of omega-3 with Nordic Naturals, the number one selling omega-3 brand in the U.S. Nordic Naturals has omega-3 and more products to support your whole family, including kids and pets. Use promo code Amy for 15% off at nordic.com. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of Good Hang. I'm very excited about my guest, my dear friend, the lovely, the sweet, the juicy and talented Andy Samberg. We are going to talk about so many good things today. We're going to talk about him being a California kid and growing up in the Bay Area. We're going to talk about the Lonely Island writing process, what it was like in those late nights making those digital shorts. We're going to discuss how ASMR is always a little pervy, but somehow we like it. And we're going to just get into it like we always do here. We even have one gotcha question. So listen for that.
But in the meantime, I'm going to start my episode like I always do by checking in with someone who knows Andy and wants to talk well behind his back and give me a question to ask. Joining me now is the great Seth Meyers. Seth, where are you? How are you? Can you hear me?
Music transition
This episode of Good Hang is presented by Walmart School Supplies. We all remember getting them. I remember Trapper Keepers and so many colored pens, but now I'm sure there's a million more things to get. Thankfully, Walmart has essential back to school supplies starting at 25 cents, plus all the latest tech starting at $9. Who knew? Hello Kitty pencil cases, Nintendo notebooks, food-shaped racers, Chromebooks, keyboards, and more at low Walmart prices. They even have Lilo and Stitch headphones. Who knew? Shop walmart.com to score their favorite back-to-school tech and supplies.
I'm so grateful that you did that podcast. Thank you so much, Seth. It was nice to have you here in the studio. And it's nice to talk to you. Where are you right now?
Seth Meyers
I'm in my little New York City studio.
Amy Poehler
Oh, you have your own little studio.
Seth Meyers
Yeah. And I'm realizing I'm not hearing you through my headphones, so I'm going to take them off. This is nice. I also think my hair looks its best right after I take off the headphone.
Amy Poehler
Speaking of weird hair, we've got a guest with a great head of hair today.
Seth Meyers
Great head of hair. And probably, you know, certainly he's... You know what? We're going to be a couple of fogies and say he had weird hair when he first showed up on the scene.
Amy Poehler
People loved that hair. It was incredible hair. It was a magnet for good times. Both him and you, I feel like I've seen a million versions of SNL bed head.
Seth Meyers
One thing that comes to mind with Andy that I do want to talk to him about is his relationship to sleep because he loves sleep.
Amy Poehler
Loves sleep.
Seth Meyers
He wrote an update feature once and he couldn't decide if he was going to call it "The Kid Who Just Woke Up" or "Bedhead Jones." I feel like we've seen him so often just kind of being so exhausted. And I think he found a perfect soulmate because I think they're a couple of little nocturnal meerkats. His beautiful wife, Joanna, is a musician. And as far as I can tell, that means you get up at 7 p.m.
Amy Poehler
There's no good harp inspirations happening before noon.
Seth Meyers
No, you know how hard those harpists party. They party. They harp all night. They party harp, as you like to say.
Amy Poehler
Wow. Very good. Okay. So Andy Samberg, you guys have a very special relationship. For people that don't know, what is your relationship like?
Seth Meyers
Well, I would like to use it as the jumping off point for what I want you to ask him about. I have a very fraternal relationship with him. And I don't think I'm alone. I think Andy's friendships are very fraternal with people. I don't quite know where that comes from. I know he is a younger brother. And I think he's sort of a quintessential America's younger brother. The minute we all laid eyes on him, he felt like a younger brother to us in a way that was very endearing. I want to know how his real life as a younger brother informed who he was. Two older sisters. What was the feedback he was getting from them? Were they delighted by him? Were they a good audience? Were his parents a good audience? Because as older siblings, you and I know that the younger siblings get a much easier audience.
Amy Poehler
Free ride in life.
Seth Meyers
Free ride. Everything is easier. But with that said, Andy does nothing the easy way. I've always said he showed up and I thought, oh my God, this guy is so sophomoric. And then I realize now that he has a PhD in sophomore comedy. Nobody approaches what they do with more integrity and intelligence than he does. But I'm very curious about his younger brother DNA and what he thinks it adds to his approach to things.
Amy Poehler
It's a great question because you're right. I think he's a juxtaposition between feeling very loose and goofy. But when we've all had the chance to work with him, he's very serious when he works.
Seth Meyers
Yeah, and I would say he's almost never, he's very opposed to taking the first idea. He really wants to dig through them all before he moves forward with something. I think our improv bones sometimes are very enamored with the first ideas. And those guys are like, no, let's not take the easy way out. And it certainly shows in their work.
And then a couple of things. This is me just talking behind his back. We were trying to schedule a Lonely Island podcast today. And when we found out he was doing this instead, he said, "Blame Seth." This is what he said on the text chain about doing Good Hang. "Blame Seth. She's his friend." So somehow it's my fault that he's doing your podcast because you and I are friends, not because he's friends with you.
Amy Poehler
There is nothing I love more in your podcast than hearing the scheduling and how it never works. It's awful. It gives me such agita. I love a good schedule. I love a good system. And when I hear the way people don't know that they're recording, it makes me... They're like, "And everyone's showing up and they're like, it's today." I just love it. I want to know everything about it. The amount like a cup of coffee can completely change their personalities. They would not have lasted in pioneer times. They're like, "Oh, ah, ah."
Seth Meyers
Also, just for fun, you know he hates my dog, Sandberg.
Amy Poehler
Yeah, that's a running... I was going to say joke, but it feels real.
Seth Meyers
No, he really hates my dog. So you don't have to do this, but I invite you to say I asked Seth for a question, but he couldn't talk today because his dog just died. And just see if he has any reaction. But you have to play it real.
Amy Poehler
He has been stressing to me a lot recently. He likes dogs. It's just my dog. When did that start, by the way? Why does he hate Frisbee?
Seth Meyers
We met Frisbee when Frisbee was like, we'd had Frisbee for two weeks. And he just immediately said, "That dog looks like a rat." And he has not come off at once. I think we put Frisbee in his lap. And he went, and she just fell on the floor.
Amy Poehler
I love him so much, Polar.
Seth Meyers
I know. He is... It's a... You can hear all about it on my episode of Good Hang. But I love being friends with people. He's a different kind of friend. He just really feels like a brother. And I'm just so lucky.
Amy Poehler
Oh, here we go. Oh, Waterworks Jones. Here he goes. But look at this. Look what we have in my podcast studio. We're not making people wait. I have it too, but I have my logo on it just in case.
Seth Meyers
Oh, you see that? You know, it's fun. We call these Seth's tissues now.
Amy Poehler
Alright, love you Seth. Thank you so much for doing this.
Seth Meyers
Love you. Give him my love too.
Amy Poehler
I will. Okay, see you soon. Bye, bud.
Music transition
This episode is brought to you by Volkswagen. Ever look at something and think, "Wow, must be nice"? Yeah, same. But here's the thing. The 2025 Volkswagen Tiguan makes all that really nice stuff totally within reach. It's got that elevated look, a seriously luxe interior with features like massaging front seats and real wood accents. Because let's be honest, nice things shouldn't just be for people named Chadwick. Visit VW.com to learn more about the 2025 Volkswagen Tiguan.
Music transition
Hi, Andy.
Andy Samberg
Hi, Amy.
Amy Poehler
Thank you for doing this.
Andy Samberg
Please. Come on. As soon as they said you were doing one, I was like, well, I'll be on that.
Amy Poehler
I was thinking about today, getting ready for today. And it was a really good feeling. First of all, because I love doing the show. But I was just like, the fact that I get to just hang out with you and talk to you. You are the kind of person that when I think about what I would talk about with you, it just feels very nice and very relaxed.
Andy Samberg
I could not be more with you. I know it's not going to be... There's no gotchas. Not a lot of push.
Amy Poehler
Well, maybe one gotcha.
Andy Samberg
Hit me with one gotcha today.
Amy Poehler
Okay, I'll get one gotcha.
Andy Samberg
Whatever gotcha you ask, I have to answer. Is that the rule?
Amy Poehler
Okay, yeah. One gotcha.
Andy Samberg
Oh my God, I can't believe I'm on the hook for a gotcha. Andy Samberg. Oh no. What can you see? I have a tiny stain.
Amy Poehler
Oh my God, a stain. But you said you would have to.
Andy Samberg
I jokingly, half jokingly said if you can see a stain, you have to run in here like Dustin Hoffman at the end of The Graduate.
Amy Poehler
For listeners listening, there was a little bit of a stain. Okay, so Andy's taking his shirt off. This is a thing he does where he goes, "Oh, there's a stain," and then he takes his shirt off.
Andy Samberg
Oh, have I been hitting the gym? Alright, I forgot. Thank you, ladies. There's two women who came in here. Thanks, guys. Who were on Andy's stain. Those are my sisters.
Amy Poehler
Oh my God, it's so funny that you're talking about your sisters because that's what I wanted to start with.
Andy Samberg
Oh, perfect. Are we started? Are we commenced?
Amy Poehler
Yeah, we've commenced. Wonderful. Because I don't think a lot of people know that you are the younger brother of two older sisters.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
And in many ways, you give off little brother vibes.
Andy Samberg
Thank you. Thank you. You like that.
Amy Poehler
I do like it. Okay. What do you like about that description of you?
Andy Samberg
It just is me. So it makes sense to me. When I feel seen and people are like, "You have little brother vibes," I'm like, "You're correct."
Amy Poehler
What are your sisters like and what kind of dynamic is in your family?
Andy Samberg
Eldest sister very extroverted, middle sister introverted. A great relationship with both of them. I loved growing up with them. A very goofy, silly sibling vibe. And now we all have kids and are adults and it's insane.
Amy Poehler
What are the pros of being a little brother to two sisters, to two young women?
Andy Samberg
You don't get beat up. Which is great. So many of my dude friends are like, "Oh man, my brother used to beat my ass." Not in a properly abusive way, but they'll be like, "I was always a little scared he was going to sock me or something." And I'm just like, "Yeah, I never had to deal with that at all." Also, I've talked about this before, but in my life, I have found when I meet other guys that have older sisters, we immediately get along. There's just a different level of ease for me with that energy.
Amy Poehler
Who do you know that has older sisters?
Andy Samberg
Matt Murray Panther.
Amy Poehler
Matt Murray Panther, a great SNL writer who we love. You're absolutely right. He has the vibe of someone who's been taken gentle care of.
Andy Samberg
Yes. And likes women. Truly. I grew up with a lot of girls who were just my friends in a very easy way. And it didn't have to be like, "Are we going to hook up?" I feel like a lot of my guy friends back then, if they didn't have sisters, for some reason, it was more of a thing.
Amy Poehler
Did you have, were you friends with your sisters' friends?
Andy Samberg
Oh, yeah.
Amy Poehler
You were in love with them?
Andy Samberg
I was. And also friends. But when you're younger and they're in the house and they're all so pretty, and they're laughing and throwing their arm around you like, "You're so silly," and I'm just like, "I'll marry you right now." And you're 11 and you wanted to just marry them. And they're all being nice and they're like, "Well, that's Daryl's brother, so we have to be nice."
Amy Poehler
For people who don't know you or where you're from, where did you grow up? Tell us about your fam.
Andy Samberg
Grew up in Berkeley, California. Bay all day. My parents are both from New York. They moved out to Northern California in summer of 70. They missed Summer of Love by a year. Maybe on purpose.
Amy Poehler
I think it's interesting because you and the Lonely Island bandmates, Jorma Taccone and Akiva Schaffer, both have East Coast hippie parents that came out here.
Andy Samberg
Yes. All of us do. And we found each other. It is strange. We're all Northern California raised by New York parents.
Amy Poehler
Why did your parents move out here? Why do you think?
Andy Samberg
I think it was just happening out here. It was kind of the summer of runoff, I guess. There was a huge migration of quote unquote, let's say hippies. I know that's probably the wrong word to use at this point.
Amy Poehler
What word would you use?
Andy Samberg
My dad had long hair and was like, "I'm getting out of here. Me and Margie, we're heading west." It definitely was that kind of energy. But it was also like, "We got nothing going on. We heard there's people having some comfortable places to sleep out on the West Coast." So I think it just brought them out here. And once you get here, it's hard to go back because it's so laid back and mellow.
Amy Poehler
I loved your episode of Finding Your Roots.
Andy Samberg
Oh.
Amy Poehler
For people that didn't see it, you were looking, hoping to help your mom find her birth father.
Andy Samberg
Both parents. My mom was adopted.
Amy Poehler
By the way, after I did that show, I watched it with Jorm and Mari in New York because I was doing press. When it aired, it showed my mom's adoption agency that she was adopted from, and it's the place from "Three Identical Strangers." So we were like, that's why we could never find the records and find anything about it, because they disappeared.
No way.
Andy Samberg
Yes. So that's where my mom was adopted from. Not a great rep.
Amy Poehler
Whoa.
Andy Samberg
The back story is I have sort of avoided doing stuff like that. But then they asked and it is a super great, reputable show. I asked my mom, I was like, "There's a chance if I do this, they could figure out who your birth parents are. Do you want me to do it knowing I might be on TV finding out some horrible thing about our family history and what her origin was?" And she was just like, "It would be worth it to me. I still want to know." So I did it and they just smashed it. She came with me the day that we shot it. When we walked in, they were all like, "There she is." They were all starstruck by her because they knew what they were about to drop on her was going to change her life. It was this amazing team of people. What came out of it was they found out who both her parents were and now we're in touch with both sides of her family.
Amy Poehler
No way.
Andy Samberg
She has four half-siblings on her father's side and then a couple first cousins still with us and their families on her mother's side. The craziest thing about it, that's like from a movie, I get chills still talking about it. Once she connected with both sides of the families, they both, unbeknownst to each other, went looking through her biological parents' old stuff they still had. And they both found the same photograph of the two of them together. They both had the picture of them together from their brief time together.
Amy Poehler
Oh, no. That makes me want to cry.
Andy Samberg
Isn't that crazy? They had a brief relationship and then a baby that they gave up for adoption. We don't know if her father even knew. They went on to marry other people and have other kids. But they kept the same picture from a date in San Francisco. Another crazy thing was that they had met in the Bay Area, and then my mom moved there. There was something that wanted her to come back. There were so many weird, trippy things about it.
Amy Poehler
I love that kind of stuff. That feels like life has some kind of grand design.
Andy Samberg
It was really beautiful. And she was so happy. And now we have, "Oh yeah, we all look like our grandparents."
Amy Poehler
I remember that your grandfather, the big reveal was that you're Italian.
Andy Samberg
Yes, exactly. Did I tell you the story that I went back to Brooklyn? I was shooting Brooklyn Nine-Nine at the time, and all the crew and everyone knew I was doing it. I came back in on Monday because we did it over the weekend. All the camera guys and the crew guys were like, "So?" And I was like, "I'm a quarter Sicilian." And they all went, "Hey!" Every part of it was from a movie. It was so awesome and wonderful. They're like, "Ah, welcome, paisan!"
Amy Poehler
Do you feel different knowing that?
Andy Samberg
I do feel a little different. We always were like, there's something that's not just... But yeah, it was crazy. And for my mom, especially, she was at this time probably 75, 76 years old. She had given up. She was like, "I'm going to go my whole life not ever knowing."
Amy Poehler
Oh, Andy, that's awesome. That's an amazing story. And that idea, the idea that they both kept the photos, is very deep. It feels like their future selves planted that photo. That's real time travel shit.
Andy Samberg
I've thought about it a lot because it's so special and it does feel written. The only thing I can... If I have a few theories, one is they thought maybe someday this exact thing would happen and they wanted her to find them. If he did know about her. And if not, it's just that maybe they both really enjoyed their time together. You don't wipe your old relationships from social media. You keep them because they were special to you at that time.
Amy Poehler
You mentioned Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Jake, and now I'm realizing Jake Peralta is an Italian name. He's half Jewish, half Italian. It was like a prophecy. Mike and Dan foresaw it. For those who don't know, Mike Schur, who is also a guest on Good Hang, along with Dan Goor, created the show. I think it might be interesting for people to know our conversation that we had before the show. You've spoken about it before, but you left SNL when? What year did you leave?
Andy Samberg
I want to say 2012.
Amy Poehler
So you were about four years ahead of me in the trajectory of being on the show and leaving it. You were approached by them to do this show and we had a conversation about it. What do you remember from that time?
Andy Samberg
The starting point for me was when I did a guest week on Parks, which was one of the most delightful weeks of my life. I remember very vividly having a conversation with you that week where I was like, "Everyone's so nice, everyone's so funny, the writing's good." And I remember your quote exactly was, "It's a good life, Sandberg." I held on to that very tightly. Then when they asked me about it, I called you again to be like, "I should, right?" Because going into it, I hadn't been thinking I wanted to do a TV show, having just done seven years of a TV show.
Amy Poehler
Which I'm sure crossed your mind when it came up too.
Andy Samberg
Yeah. But truthfully, having seen Parks and loved it so much and seen it work so much, and then had the experience of working on it and feeling that warmth and happiness of working on it, it really informed my choice. Mike, as we know, has his rule that he tells everyone before he works with them: the only rule is no assholes. Everyone you work with will be thoughtful and kind and engaged. Life is too short basically. I was like, "That sounds good to me."
Amy Poehler
Do you remember me calling you?
Andy Samberg
Yeah, okay. I do. I want to know your side.
Amy Poehler
I remember because there's this moment when you leave SNL or any job and you just think, "Well, I guess I'm jumping off a cliff. I guess I'm done." But there's a lot of people at the station that have also left and they kind of go, "Hey, welcome. There's a lot more out there." That's what I felt like that conversation was with me and you. Yes, there's so many opportunities. And if it's a Mike Schur, Dan Goor opportunity, I would take it because it is going to be one of the best experiences of your life.
Andy Samberg
Did it prove to be. Absolutely. And by the way, it's a gift that keeps giving. It just moved to Netflix in the US and it's been there internationally. I took a family trip to Europe a couple years ago. Because of the Netflix part of it, everywhere I went, I was like, "Jake Peralta." I was just telling Fred this too. I felt like I was on Friends. I was like, "Oh my God, the show is actually really big and people really watch it." Kids love it and families watch it together, which was such a part of my experience growing up, watching good quality sitcoms together as a family. Just being able to think that I did something that is that for people is really gratifying. It was amazing. I'm still really close with everyone I worked with there and loved it so much. Everything you told me would happen, happened.
Amy Poehler
It's such a good show. And exactly that, you feel like there was a sense of family. Can you tell me, when you think about the deeply funny moments with Andre Braugher, who I love. I'm so sorry for his passing and his loss. When you think about what you and Andre, how you guys laughed together, what was that dynamic like behind the scenes?
Andy Samberg
God. He's so good in the show. He's so poised. He's such a good actor. But he was playful and fun. He was. And just a good person. So deeply moral and kind and pleasant and smart. We all absolutely loved him. I miss him a lot. Our dynamic worked immediately. It's one of those things where you're just like, "Okay, this is kismet." Mike and Goor cast him from a meeting. They just did a Zoom or something with him and they were like, "Yeah."
Amy Poehler
It's probably pre-Zoom.
Andy Samberg
Yeah, it was probably a Skype. It was a disgusting ass Skype. We used to have to do this thing called Skype. With a Y in it. Mike's talked about this a lot too. We showed up for the first table read before we'd even shot the pilot. He walked in and we had a very pleasant hello. Then we started reading it. As soon as we started reading it, the first scene is he comes out and I'm goofing with him and being a dummy and he's being stoic. It just... You know how it is sometimes with creative stuff where you're like, "I don't care how this came to be. It's working and I'm so happy, so grateful." From that moment forward, the only thing me and him had to even talk about creatively was in the beginning, he didn't trust himself to do comedy because he came so strictly from drama and Juilliard. Five or six times we would do a more serious topic on the show and he would flip that switch and everyone would be like, "Oh my God, what is Andre doing here? He's so good. He should be drama. He's the best." But then he would do his Captain Holt stuff and it was the funniest thing in the show.
Amy Poehler
It's so interesting you bring up Juilliard. For people, it's a shorthand for a different way of training. I think there's something very cool, even if you're not an actor or performer in general, when you start working more and more, you're like, "Oh, everybody has a different way of working. We all got here a different road." We come from a very similar sketch background where we're burning through ideas. As a performer, you and I like to keep it pretty loose until it feels ready. That really can unnerve other people.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
It took me a long time to realize that that wasn't someone else's process.
Andy Samberg
We would do a fun run or whatever. We took that from you guys too. We took a lot from Parks. Let's be real.
Amy Poehler
Well, we took it from The Office. So a fun run was kind of a... Once you have it scripted, then it's like, "Okay, have fun with it. Try different things." We would do that occasionally. We would do it more when we had a guest who was really known for improv. We let Manzoukas cook, for example.
Andy Samberg
The difference between you and I, you're a much more seasoned performer, in my opinion. I always felt that way. I feel like I have gotten so much better and have such a better understanding of acting having done Brooklyn. For me, that was acting school. I even remember another conversation I had with you when Brooklyn started. Texting you and being like, "Is it hard for you to memorize all this?" And you went, "Now it is." And I was like, "God, she was so cocky about it." Then like two or three years in, if someone had asked me, I'd be like, "Yeah, I can do it in my sleep."
Amy Poehler
You got it. It was a muscle. And then when you stop, it atrophies.
Andy Samberg
It does. That's why I'm doing this podcast. I literally can't memorize anything anymore.
Amy Poehler
It's so hard to memorize now. I know that sounds so stupid, but I always say to people, think about when you give a speech and you're in front of people and you have to memorize that speech. Now imagine 40 to 50 people standing, watching you do it, drinking coffee, being like, "Get this speech right. Please get the speech right." You're not at a wedding and it's not fun. It's a job and everyone's like, "Please get it right. I'm tired and it's almost lunch." Also, a long day or a long week. You're talking about at least 10 to 12 people that are actively holding something heavy.
Andy Samberg
That's right. They're holding something heavy. You see people's legs start shaking and you're like, "I got to get this line." That would be like if you gave a wedding toast that you had to memorize and all of your family were holding giant rocks. You didn't get it right. Oh man, Uncle Gary just had a knee surgery. I got to get this thing done. And when you don't get it right, they all put the rocks down and they're like, "I guess we'll try it again."
Amy Poehler
I can't get it right. No, but we would burn through just like you, a lot of pages a day and you had to kind of just figure it out. But I would say having worked with you at SNL and we had a really fun time when me and Maya were working on our fun show, Baking It.
Andy Samberg
Oh my God, Baking It. I loved it.
Amy Poehler
I will say, Andy, I think people don't know this about you. You're pretty meticulous when you work.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
It's different than I think people would assume.
Andy Samberg
That was actually where I was starting to very slowly walk towards about Brooklyn. For me, I would prefer having, and it was good for Andre too, like three to five alts that are very specific. Not that we're just like, "What are we going to come up with?"
But where I'm like, I work with the writer on set. We had the raddest staff. They were so funny. And it would be like, anytime you get to a scene where we all feel like, you know that thing where you just feel you're like, this joke's just halfway there.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
And you might quickly scramble. And then we would write out a bunch of alts, say it to each other, know that it's it. And so like make it official one at a time as opposed to like, it's the sauce, you know, we're all like the soup.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
And then the other thing about me that I would agree with you is very meticulous is editing. You're very meticulous about editing and you get very serious when it comes to music.
Amy Poehler
I do. Like, you know, I remember us recording what I thought was kind of a goofball song. And I remember being like, oops, like Andy Scott. and he's gotten quiet and serious. And it was like, right, of course, because you're a professional. And it is, it is. I mean, halfway, I don't know what I am. I just love it.
Andy Samberg
Yeah, you love it. And you want it to be good.
Amy Poehler
I do want it to be good. I want it to sound good. And I will say that you and Yorma and Akiva, the members of Lonely Island, like you guys came in, in a way, to that show that was super interesting because you were your own island, literally, that you came in together with your own system that then had to kind of fit into the bigger SNL system.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
And those early days, like you talk about it so well on your podcast, which I'm obsessed with. Thank you for being on it also.
Andy Samberg
Oh, my God, I love it. And it's hilarious. And I love how no one knows when you're recording. And a lot of times you guys don't show up.
Amy Poehler
Yeah, it's a mess. It's a mess. Definitely check that out. That's my favorite part. But you're going through all of the digital shorts. You're going through them one by one. And I love that I forget because it's like childbirth. Like it all goes away, the pain part.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
I forget the grind of each one that you guys had. And so you guys were really into the grind.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
Do you remain into that grind?
Andy Samberg
Are you asking if I stay on my grind? But you want to talk about that early grind?
Amy Poehler
Yes. That's interesting. I don't think people would assume that from you. I mean, do I have the rise and grind mentality? No. My memory of you three was constantly being tired.
Andy Samberg
Yep.
Amy Poehler
Constantly wanting it to be better and better and better. What is your relationship to perfectionism or continuing to tweak and make things better?
Andy Samberg
I think SNL was a struggle for us in that sense because that's not the name of the game there. But because we did pre-taped stuff and it was videos we could edit, we did get closer to it than a lot of people at that time especially would have been allowed to.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
Again though, I would watch people like you and Fred and Bill and Wig and Maya and like so many of our peers who were like, in my opinion on a performance level, the sell was how amazing you guys were live and the feeling of like, oh, anything could happen in this moment, whether or not it was true, because you guys are all precise as hell too. But the electricity of that was the thing that I felt like I didn't always have live, but that we could make work in a pre-tape with the correct editing and the right concepts. You know what I mean?
Amy Poehler
I do. I mean, I would argue it's both and, because I think that you do have a looseness as a performer that relaxes people.
Andy Samberg
Sure.
Amy Poehler
And you just have to have it. And I think that's what's interesting about you as a performer is like, I do think there's a precision that's important to you, but you don't see it when you're performing. So that is hard to balance. And it's just like, because you're right. There was, I mean, I remember learning from Will Ferrell, like watching and being like, oh, in this show, if you're having fun and you're relaxed, people relax and have fun.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
It is just, and I mean, there's nothing harder than someone saying like, just relax.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
But it was true. If you could kind of zone out and kind of act like life is a dream.
Andy Samberg
And you belong there.
Amy Poehler
And you belong there. Fake it till you make it.
Andy Samberg
Yep. It would work. And the people that couldn't do that had a really hard time.
Amy Poehler
Definitely. But I knew that you could do both. You could do that and then you would go and edit for – and you and Keev and you would love yourself. We were zombies.
Andy Samberg
And you were zombies and you were so tired. We were so tired. We also like – I mean, I talk about this a lot, which was my dream was always to be on SNL. And then we got it, which was insane. Like, I would have been good doing one season and getting fired knowing I actually got to try doing the one thing I wanted. And then first season, it went good.
Amy Poehler
Right.
Andy Samberg
You know, which was really unexpected. Like, we'd been doing fine the first half of that first season. You were there.
Amy Poehler
Yep.
Andy Samberg
We were, like, figuring it out. I was figuring out how to present myself live and I had done stand-up but like what's the angle, how do you ingratiate the audience to you. And then that one video just went bonkers and it was like oh shit, okay, we arrived quote-unquote early for how the show usually works in my opinion. And then because of that we were lucky but also we immediately put insane pressure on ourselves because we were like, well, now we have to do things that do that. Like making the Narnia one was partly because it was a good sketch, but also just pure luck. Like the fact that it was the moment that people were like, there's this thing called YouTube. And the moment that people wanted to be like, SNL had this pre-tape and it looked like they shot it on their own. And that's interesting to us now. And like, whatever the hell confluence of things made it become a news story. I mean, when you are lucky enough, like us, to work long enough, you just keep making stuff that you think is good and that you want to watch. And then every now and again, it all kind of comes together for things that are out of your control, right?
Amy Poehler
Totally. So much of it is timing and being in the right place.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
Like you said, and having the right people around you and being in the right era of SNL and all of that stuff. Having the right head writer who's supporting you and being a certain age where you're not whatever, or too old or too young to handle it, all that stuff.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
But I would say, what is that? There's like some quote, like luck and preparation is the preparation. Hold on, let me look at my name. Is the cure for hemorrhoids.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
What is it like luck is the preparation? You know what I'm talking about. It's time plus, no, preparation plus luck is success or something? Preparation. I feel like Wayne Gretzky definitely said it. Or it's, who said it? Luck, here we go. No, it was the Roman philosopher Seneca. Luck is when preparation meets opportunity, dude. That's what it is.
Andy Samberg
I've always called Seneca the Gretzky light.
Amy Poehler
I added the dude. Luck is when preparation meets opportunity. That is true. That what it was. Sorry, what is it again? It was luck is when preparation meets opportunity. So you had been let see if we can memorize it. We're going to Garth and Cat it. Luck is when preparation meets opportunity, dude.
Andy Samberg
Dude.
Amy Poehler
Thank you. Oh, Seneca. Oh, Seneca, you crazy bitch. Just like, dude.
Andy Samberg
Okay.
Amy Poehler
He's like, guys, gather around. Dig on this. Dude, dude, dude, dude, dude, dude. I got it. I got it. I got it. It was like, what? You don't even know. People are going to say this. Senegal. But that is an example of that. You guys were ready. You had been working together for a really long time. And look, similarly with, I mean, I say this all the time, which is there is no better feeling than having some people in your corner at a place like SNL or anywhere.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
Where to do almost anything, whether it's be on SNL or it's like go through hard times in your life. Or like if you have a few people that can stand around you, like you can get through anything. You just need one or two. And the fact that you guys had each other. It was a dream.
Andy Samberg
Yeah. I mean, how many folks were you friends with when you got hired?
Amy Poehler
Well, I was really – I mean, Tina basically was, like, so instrumental in getting me hired. And Dratch was there. And so Tina and Dratch and I started together. And, like, they were – and I knew Horatio. And I knew a lot of people kind of – but Tina and Dratch and I had known each other at that point, you know, for 10 years and started together. And that was huge. It makes a huge difference. To have – yeah. And – I can't imagine coming in there totally alone.
Andy Samberg
I agree. And so many warriors came through and just kind of blazed a trail. Or didn't and did really well doing other things elsewhere.
Amy Poehler
Yeah, that's true. Because it's a very specific thing.
Ad break
I do want to talk about Lazy Sunday for a second. I know you guys have talked about it a ton on your podcast, but I'll just tell you that, you know, that was part of a bigger Christmas show that a lot of people, and listen to Andy's podcast because they break it down beautifully, that episode. It's probably my favorite episode I've ever been on because Jack Black was the host. And it was 2004. And that was five, five, 2005, my bad. And it was, for me, far enough away from 9-11, which is when I started, which was like, we'll never laugh again. And not too close to me, you know, being pregnant and leaving. It was just like, for me in the sweet spot of finally feeling like I knew what I was doing.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
And I can remember that moment. I remember being on the floor watching that thing and exactly what you said. It was as if the audience felt, you could feel them going, this is a new fun thing. We like these.
Andy Samberg
Yeah, yeah.
Amy Poehler
We want more of them. It was wild to feel that.
Andy Samberg
It was life-changing for me. I mean, it was, again, I can't stress how much we were not expecting that to be the reaction.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
We were just trying to get things on the show.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
We were so green, so new. I mean, we had not had an insane amount of experience before we got the show either. Like, you had had a full show that I watched and loved, P.S. I had seen you doing, like, UCB shows and knew who you were. There's a lot of people I think who get SNL, especially then that had like really, I mean, think about like when Wig got hired. Wig's audition had like five fully formed Groundlings characters. It was incredible. That just, and Feral too, where you're just like, oh, they're ready for SNL, period. Like they have been bred to, they're like Lionel Messi of SNL, you know, where like from a child, they were like, this is my path that I'm doing.
I mean, Will is an anomaly. He was like, I'm going to decide to be the funniest person on earth. But for me, I was like, I had done stand-up on and off, and we had made videos, which at that time didn't directly translate. We didn't get hired to do them. It was more just like we had fun at the movie awards writing with a bunch of SNL people and Fallon and people, and they were like, come play, come hang out, and da-da-da. And we were like, okay. And then that one, we had done the one with Forte with the lettuce, and then that was Lazy Sunday was the second one. And then it was like getting shot out of a cannon.
Amy Poehler
And do you remember where you were when you got the call that you got the show and did Akiva and Jorma get the call at the same time or did someone get it first?
Andy Samberg
I got it first. They flew me out, didn't tell me, but I flew with Bill and he knew because Marcy Klein had told him he got it and he knew I got it. He couldn't tell you?
Amy Poehler
He couldn't tell me and he didn't tell me. Bless his heart.
Andy Samberg
Bless his heart. Because I understand. I would be afraid that I'd get fired if I told you or something.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
We sat together on the plane.
Amy Poehler
Dude, you're going to. He probably was like, this is great, right? And you were like, I guess.
Andy Samberg
He loves recounting it. Because we sat together on the plane and had drinks. And I was like, I wonder what's going to happen. And he's like, I know what's going to happen. You fucking got it, dude.
Amy Poehler
So he did tell you.
Andy Samberg
No, he didn't.
Amy Poehler
Okay.
Andy Samberg
But he could have. I'm saying he likes to talk about how he could have.
Amy Poehler
Okay. But anyway.
Andy Samberg
So then we got there and I had a meeting with Lorne because you have a meeting with Lorne. And Lorne didn't tell me.
Amy Poehler
No, he never hires or fires anybody.
Andy Samberg
No. So I walked out of his office and I think it was like Jen or maybe Shookus or people like that were there. And they were like, so? And I was like, I don't know. They're like, you got the show. Like they were the ones who told me. And then we went to a dinner.
Amy Poehler
That's what Lorne told me. We're going to have a dinner after this, so you should come. And I was like, okay, so I guess I'm still in the mix. And then they were like, no, you got the show.
Andy Samberg
And so on the drive from 30 Rock to that dinner, I called my parents. And we were all like crying and stuff.
Amy Poehler
They were?
Andy Samberg
Oh, my God. I mean, since I was eight, that was what I wanted to do.
Amy Poehler
Andy.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
That's so cool.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
And then what was the stress? Codependently, I would be immediately stressed about Akiva and Jorma.
Andy Samberg
Yes. They told them early the next week. It was like a weekend. So we didn't have to wait too long. But they had made a deal that if one of them got hired and not the other, that they wouldn't take it.
Amy Poehler
Really?
Andy Samberg
Yeah. That not two out of three of us would leave.
Amy Poehler
Oh.
Andy Samberg
But that if one of us got it, go with God.
Amy Poehler
Oh, wow. Oh, that's so sweet.
Andy Samberg
Okay. We spent a lot of time together, sleepless writing nights.
Amy Poehler
Yes. You have an interesting relationship with sleep.
Andy Samberg
I do. And I love talking to people about sleep.
Amy Poehler
Okay. Oh, yes. Tell me your relationship to sleep.
Andy Samberg
I love sleep. Until I had children, I would go to bed very, very late. I'm like textbook night owl. And when I worked at SNL, it was my dream job schedule as well because I would go to bed at like four in the morning and sleep until like two, three in the afternoon. And then I started dating a musician who had the exact same schedule and it was like perfect. And so I've only ever had one job that like catered exactly to my preferred sleep schedule. And even now, like I love making movies and I love making the show and stuff like that. But you have to get up crazy early like a normal person who has a normal job.
Amy Poehler
Right.
Andy Samberg
Because most jobs start early and most people that are adults get up early.
Amy Poehler
Right.
Andy Samberg
So it's been a hard adjustment.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
And now the kids, I mean, you know.
Amy Poehler
Well, you mentioned your wife, the great Joanna Newsom, incredible musician.
Andy Samberg
Yay.
Amy Poehler
I mean, I remember, I kind of remember, I felt like I was around during the courtship. I remember specifically one night walking you home. We were all out at a bar and talking about how I just started dating her and you were awesome about it. You were head over heels right away.
Andy Samberg
I was gone, yeah.
Amy Poehler
And you remain. Like, you guys are really, like, what, you know, you've been together now for 17 or 18 years. That's a long time, Andy Samberg, relationship. I mean, you've called her your best friend, basically.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
Say more about that.
Andy Samberg
I'm just lucky. What's it like to be with your best friend? It's fun.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
It's really fun. It's like obviously having kids changes things because your responsibilities shift, your sleep schedule, but obviously a million other things. But it still feels like anytime there's a pocket of time where it's just us, it still feels like we're getting away with something, like we're having a sleepover and it's fun and there's no one I would rather be hanging out with and chatting with. And it's amazing. I feel really lucky to get to share my life with her.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
But yeah, I remember that walk with you and talking about it and you going, I don't know, Samberg, I got a good feeling about this one. I always remember things you say, Amy.
Amy Poehler
I mean, you guys were deeply, very quickly, like twinkly. And you both have this thing that I think is really, like I respect in both of you is like you're artists. You take your art seriously and you liked that about each other.
Andy Samberg
Definitely.
Amy Poehler
You really respected each other, really. Like you were – there's a difference between being like a fan of someone's work and like really respecting what they do. It's very different. I think a lot of people understood that from my perspective. I think some people at first were like, she likes that stuff that he does? But the truth is she does and did. Like her and her siblings are goofballs together and love comedy.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
And it just – I couldn't believe my luck that that was the case.
Andy Samberg
I feel like the mutual respect is the reason when you have a lot of years behind you, that's the thing that keeps couples together.
Amy Poehler
Yeah. Have you ever heard of that? He's a famous therapist. Do you watch couples therapy?
Andy Samberg
I don't.
Amy Poehler
Oh, my God, dude. Should we watch it right now?
Andy Samberg
Yeah. Let's shut this down.
Amy Poehler
I just finished Andor.
Andy Samberg
Oh.
Amy Poehler
And or.
Andy Samberg
Yeah, bro.
Amy Poehler
It was good.
Andy Samberg
I'm sure it was. I watched The Last of Us. This is the exact opposite of Andor.
Amy Poehler
I watched Love on the Spectrum.
Andy Samberg
I love Love on the Spectrum.
Amy Poehler
So hard.
Andy Samberg
Oh, I cry so hard.
Amy Poehler
You and I like to cry.
Andy Samberg
We do like to cry.
Amy Poehler
We love crying. You know who else loves to cry? Seth Meyers.
Andy Samberg
Seth Meyers does love to cry.
Amy Poehler
We got to cry here. And Seth Meyers was the person that I asked to ask you a question.
Andy Samberg
Oh.
Amy Poehler
So earlier before you came in, I was Zooming with Seth Meyers, who, you know, you guys have a very, oh, by the way, dude, have you heard that Frisbee died?
Andy Samberg
Don't even play because I'll be so happy. I will never back off that. That dog sucks.
Amy Poehler
Dude and I know this is like I know this is a good vibes cast so I don't even want to bring that energy.
Andy Samberg
You're right I shouldn't have mentioned that dog that dog is like a rat carcass.
Amy Poehler
Seth wanted me to pretend that he died.
Andy Samberg
I am trying to figure out what something special I can do when Frisbee does finally pass on.
Amy Poehler
You should do like a memorial video that's about how much that dog sucked.
Andy Samberg
Pretty funny. Pretty funny.
Amy Poehler
But Seth, you know like your relationship is really fraternal and really supportive. I hear it on your podcast, I've seen it in real time. And his question was the one I asked you because he wanted to know about the little brother of it all, like what it was like being you know having sisters and being a little brother. But in many ways, I would say the dynamic between the two of you is like older brother, younger brother.
Andy Samberg
I would agree.
Amy Poehler
Yes. Right? But also because Seth likes to be in charge and in control.
Andy Samberg
Right.
Amy Poehler
And I do not.
Andy Samberg
You don't?
Amy Poehler
I like to be in control of what I make but not of the situation.
Andy Samberg
Yeah, that's right.
Amy Poehler
Yeah. That's right. I mean, I can if I need to be. But the fun of it for me is not that.
Andy Samberg
Right.
Amy Poehler
The fun of it always for me. I mean, I was like the diffuser in my family, you know, and youngest and get attention through being silly and making jokes and making people laugh and finding my spot that way. And, you know, it changes as it becomes your job.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
But I feel like also like Seth's persona is I know what's going on and I'm going to put everyone at ease. And mine is like, you don't know what's going to happen, maybe.
Andy Samberg
Totally like you don't know what's gonna happen yeah you might be like not what you're expecting a little bit that's my hope anyway yeah
Amy Poehler
Do you have you ever taken like your enneagram test do you know your number you're taking the enneagram wait this is different from the thing that me and you texted about what were we or maybe i've texted you to make you take it i'm obsessed with it it's like one numbers one to nine yeah we did text about it what did you what was your number am i allowed to look at my phone and look at our old texts what did we get because i made you take it Did I make everyone all of Lonely Island take it?
Andy Samberg
I think that I had the same one as Tina and Seth is what you said.
Amy Poehler
Okay, that's right. You were a three, the achiever.
Andy Samberg
Fuck, that sounds so sexy.
Amy Poehler
Right? I mean, congrats. But that's what I mean is the three isn't always the peacemaker. The three is like, but the three is, we really will cut all this out. because there's truly. Do you know what I'm talking about?
Andy Samberg
Oh, yeah, yeah.
Amy Poehler
This is three. You were a three. You said this is three. Does this resonate? And you were like, hell yeah. And I said you're eight all day. Because I'm an eight challenger. And three is the achiever. So three is like, can be like, you like to hear good job.
Andy Samberg
I do like to hear good job. Good boy. Good boy, good job.
Amy Poehler
Yeah, your three is so big. You know what's, and that's what she said. You know what's small is your four, which is interesting.
Andy Samberg
I wish so bad you'd been like, yo, dinky little dick. Like, hey, that was good, Hank.
Amy Poehler
Oh, my God. I was laughing. Sorry, it's just what I heard. We were just in the office before we came in watching the Bash Brothers again because they're shrinky dinky.
Andy Samberg
My name is Mork, and I eat pork with a fork, but I'm not a jork, but I'll jork it. I'll jork it out the pork. I'll jork it out the pork. I feel very proud of that.
Amy Poehler
God, I'd love that. I love it. Because Noah should have had the Bash Brothers on his orc. The Bash Brothers. So many dumb, I mean, you love dumb fun shit.
Andy Samberg
Oh, my God, yes. Me and Keeve did that knowing it was for no one. And we just loved making it so much.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
Like our friends that we grew up with were like, you guys made a whole visual poem rap album about the Bash Brothers? And we're like, yeah.
Amy Poehler
And you know, podcasters, we are talking about sports, which is exciting. And for people who don't know, Bash Brothers were Mark McGuire, Jose Canseco.
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
Very rumored at the time to be doing a lot of steroids.
Andy Samberg
Oh, yeah.
Amy Poehler
And like, but it was like such an 80s rivalry. And you guys just dressed up like them and wrote a million songs about it. It was so fun.
Andy Samberg
It was so fun. By the way, the dream of that one was, I think there was a player on the actual Oakland A's when it came out who like used it as his walk-up music.
Amy Poehler
Oh, wow.
Andy Samberg
And they like would play Let's Bash at the stadium at the Oakland Coliseum before they, you know, they're gone now. You know this. You're a sports nut.
Amy Poehler
Yeah. Well, I remember when that happened. But, and I got to tell you, like, and I texted you about it the other day, like still crushing it. Still, you guys still crushing. Like the Anxiety Short was so good on the 50th.
Andy Samberg
Thanks.
Amy Poehler
Such a funny and moving. Funny and moving, which, you know, the fact that you had, you sung about how everyone had nervous diarrhea before they did every sketch on SNL.
Andy Samberg
If these pipes could talk.
Amy Poehler
If these pipes could talk. Incredible. Incredible. What was it on the dolly when you were, when you were, were you moving or was the camera moving on that moment?
Andy Samberg
I was moving. That was a Mike Diva shot. He's a director there now who we're buddies with. That was his idea. And I was, when he showed me that back, I was like, Ooh, that's a good shot.
Amy Poehler
So good.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
And then Sushi Glory Hole. Imagine that.
[Singing] Andy Samberg: Where are you going? Sushi glory hole imagine that Instead of strange you be getting a snack High and fish no doubt Hey where you going Hear a sound So f good
Thank you. I mean, like, every song you guys make is a bop, is a song you want to listen to regardless of the comedy. But, like, Andy.
Andy Samberg
That one, yeah.
Amy Poehler
So good. And I just, like, you've made so many good ones. But I just want to remind everybody, like, you've been doing it for 20 years.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
Sushi, like so good.
Andy Samberg
Thanks. So stupid. So stupid.
Amy Poehler
Perfect.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
A little bit dirty. Fantastic outfits. So good. Great POV and attitude. They came with it. Was it any more fun? I mean, you talked about this on the podcast, but does it get any easier to make them now or is it harder to make them now?
Andy Samberg
Both.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
The technical aspect is easier because we've done so many.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
Coming up with something we find interesting and funny becomes more difficult because we've done so many. But that was one in particular where we had written – Akiva had came up with the phrase Sushi Glory Hole. I can't believe I'm treating this so seriously. We should treat this like actors on acting. So when Akiva first said Sushi Glory Hole –
Amy Poehler
Then what did God say when he met you at the pearly gates?
Andy Samberg
At that point, we were just channeling. We giggled and I was like yeah, we're not gonna do that. And then he kept saying it and I couldn't tell if he was doing it as a bit like we should do that or if he actually wanted to do it. So then after a while I was like you know what, fuck it, let's try it. And we did a whole other version on a different beat and we hadn't come up yet with the idea of "hear us out" over and over again. So then we were like we kind of let it sit because we were like it's okay, it just feels like AI doing a Lonely Island song or something. You know what I mean? Where it's like, we're rapping and it's this and it's about a thing that you wouldn't rap about.
And we were like, yeah, I guess so. And then a couple of days later, because we just decided to go in the studio a lot at that time, he came in and played a different song he had heard on the radio. I can't remember which one it was, but it inspired him. It was like a more modern song, something with ASAP Rocky and some people on it. And we were like, oh, let's try it to a beat like that. And we did. And then because we switched the beat, it inspired the "hear us out" thing. And then once we did that, once we started doing the laugh, which is the right laugh, which you know when you're in a room writing something.
We were like, uh-oh, it's the laugh. We're having that laugh where we know we are officially into this idea.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
Not just like this will be professional and technically up to snuff.
Amy Poehler
Right.
Andy Samberg
Where you're like, Ooh, I now like this for sure.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
You're like, Oh, we got to do it.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
And then it was like, yeah, now we got to do it. And it opened it up for us.
Amy Poehler
That's a good example of you guys. Like you don't, you want to keep going back. And I mean, Seth mentioned this when we were talking earlier is like, there's like the improv bones version where like, sometimes we romanticize the first idea and you guys don't do that. You're like this isn't ready yet, this isn't right yet. Like you like yes, but if it's the best, if it's really funny the first time we don't fuck with it.
Andy Samberg
Yeah. What was the fastest song you ever wrote? Fastest digital short you like came up with and did like like oh from the minute you thought of it till you did it was super fast it just came out.
Amy Poehler
A lot of them were like that when we were working at the show because the schedule is crazy.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
So like Lazy Sunday, once we had the idea, wrote in a couple hours.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
Natalie's rap, same thing.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
Shireani, we wrote in like under an hour. It takes a long time to come up with the idea. And then sometimes it doesn't. Sometimes you're in the shower at home and you have a full idea and you come in and you go, I have an idea. And then you just write it and it happens. Sometimes you have your dick in the box in the shower and then you come in and you're like, So let's do it on the show. Dig in a Box was Jorm's idea. And it was, it took us a long time to decide what to write about because that was an assignment. It was like, Justin wants to do a song. Think of an idea to do a song with him. So we had met with him and we knew that we all had grown up listening to hip hop and R&B in the early 90s.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
And so we were like, maybe something in that area. And then it was like, okay, but what's the premise? And then we struggled for a couple hours trying to think of something. And then when Jorm said that, we were like, oh, okay, go.
Andy Samberg
There's so many digital shorts that I watch that I'm sad I'm not in. And here's my gotcha question.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
Oh, here it comes. I'm going to put my gotcha glasses on. Why aren't I in them?
Amy Poehler
I feel like I didn't get asked to be in enough digital shorts.
Andy Samberg
I agree. What did I do?
Amy Poehler
I don't know. Is it? My brain has a theory. What is it?
And maybe it's just protecting me. You were already doing Update. Let's start there. That's my theory: you guys shot a lot of stuff on Fridays, and we would have to read Update jokes on Friday. I feel there were times where it was very like, "We need someone quick to do this thing," and I was not availed. But there's so many shorts where I'm like, damn, I wish I could be in that.
Andy Samberg
I also wish that. You don't understand. I also think, Amy, like, it's a good lesson learned for me and for anyone in any field. I think we often were like, "We don't want to bother her." I can't believe it, but it's true. I mean, you were in like 10 sketches every week and Update. I'm such a fan of those shorts so much. And I definitely watch them sometimes. Sometimes I'm like, man, I wish I was in them. So I guess what I was hoping is like, maybe we could do some kind of Zemeckis style... put you back in them.
Amy Poehler
Put me back.
Andy Samberg
Full Gump. We'll just do some de-aging.
Amy Poehler
Oh, my God. And we'll go back. Wait, so can I gotcha question back?
Andy Samberg
Yeah, gotcha question back.
Amy Poehler
These are not gotcha questions.
Andy Samberg
I know, and mine is not a gotcha question. Gotcha back. Can you think... which ones are the most? Name, I can name five. I wish I was in so bad.
Amy Poehler
Oh, my God. Dick in a Box, for sure.
Andy Samberg
Right, of course. I mean, of course.
Amy Poehler
Dear Sister. I was like, ha, I fucking love that one.
Andy Samberg
But dude, that shoot sucked. And it did suck. It was all night. We were at the Flatotel till like six in the morning.
Amy Poehler
I know. I remember.
Andy Samberg
That's another reason where I'm like, we're not going to ask Amy to come do that. She's like...
Amy Poehler
I wish I knew. You know, and like, also, for every one of those, there was like five that we did at Flatotel till four in the morning that were so bad. And I love you guys talking about them. And you got to be honest. If it works, it works. If it doesn't, it does not. I mean, that's what's so funny about the stuff that we do: nobody remembers the 10-to-1 versions of things that were just stinkers.
Andy Samberg
Always. Crazy stuff. Stuff where I was mad that it would get cut and then I would go back and be like, oh, my God, there's nothing here. I was just running on fumes. Why was I so mad? It was just because it was literally as much as like, "I exist too. I want to be on the show too."
Amy Poehler
Emily Spivey and I wrote a scene one night that we thought was so funny. It was just about these two giant trucks, like truck drivers, who would come up next to each other and keep telling the other one to "Honk it." Yes. And it was like, "Honk it. Honk it." And just telling the other one to honk it. And we were like, oh, we were dying. And we turned it in at like 8:45 AM and Shoemaker was like, "We're not doing 'Honk It.'" And we were like, "What? We already made t-shirts." He was like, "We can't produce 'Honk It.' We can't get two giant... you know, we can't get two cabs. And also, like, you guys, we have like 35 sketches over and you turn this in at 8:45." And it's like, we were like, "Justice for 'Honk It!'" We were still so mad.
Andy Samberg
Just to be clear, you're not gonna let us read "Honk It"? Okay, okay, noted. Looking forward to having an employer that supports "Honk It." Fucking noted. Looking forward in the future to working with someone who understands "Honk It" and what it means to us.
Amy Poehler
Oh my god. Speaking of what we watch and listen to, yes. I asked my guests now: what are you watching, listening to, doing that's making you laugh? Making me laugh. Making you feel good, making you check out. What are you, like, how do you...?
Andy Samberg
Oh, well, this is loaded, but I saw the new *Naked Gun*.
Amy Poehler
Oh, okay. Talk about it because it looks so good.
Andy Samberg
It's really funny. Okay, so directed by Akiva. Obviously, it's directed by Akiva and co-written by Akiva, and he's my bestie. But I wouldn't say it if it wasn't true. It's really fucking funny. It's just the people I've talked to that have come and watched screenings so far have kind of a similar reaction, which is it's just all jokes.
Amy Poehler
Yeah.
Andy Samberg
It's been so long since something new got made that was just purely trying to make me laugh. And it's in that style, but it's also updated. And Liam's amazing. And Pam's amazing. And Akiva did a great job. The writers with him did a great job. Dan and Doug. I mean, it's just joyful. It feels really fun.
Amy Poehler
How important was like *Naked Gun* and *Airplane* to you growing up?
Andy Samberg
Big.
Amy Poehler
Same. All the surrealistic, dumb, cartoony, live-action stuff I loved. Monty Python, those, Pee-wee, later *Strangers with Candy*. Things like that where you bend the world and make it be whatever you want it to be. We all watched *Hollywood Shuffle* and *I'm Gonna Git You Sucka* and all those movies. Anything like that where you could actually have a giant thing fall through frame and no one will acknowledge it or something.
Andy Samberg
I remember the character on *Naked Gun* that was really tall that was always out of frame.
Amy Poehler
Yes. And you never saw the top of him.
Andy Samberg
Oh my God, it's my favorite joke.
Amy Poehler
Are you going to say the same joke? Is it the banana?
Andy Samberg
Yes.
Amy Poehler
It's my favorite joke. Oh my God, let's watch it. Ever. "And there'll be plenty of time to do it too. Get something in the side of your mouth, Al. No, no, no. The other side." It's like half a banana. Half a banana. It's hanging. Can you imagine half? And no one reacts. "Thank you, Al."
Andy Samberg
And then talking about new projects, *Digman!* is coming back.
Amy Poehler
Yes.
Andy Samberg
That is... you created that, right?
Amy Poehler
Yeah. With Neil Campbell.
Andy Samberg
Tell... like, during the pandemic, it was like, we were all bound to the home. And I was like, I've had this idea for a really long time. And I'd been talking to him about it. He's a writer on, was a writer on *Brooklyn Nine-Nine* and a bunch of other stuff. And we had been kind of wanting to make it forever. It's basically like shitty Indiana Jones, the animated show.
Amy Poehler
Right.
Andy Samberg
And the show is so fun. And what a cast. Mitra.
Amy Poehler
Yeah, Mitra's the best.
Andy Samberg
Meadows, Timmy Robinson. It's a really good group. And it's just like, if you like jokes and goof-ass comedy, it really scratches the itch. You do a lot of animated stuff. You like it?
Amy Poehler
I love it. I love it. Growing up, I loved it. The first time I got asked to do a voice in an animated movie, I was just like, yes. Where do I go?
Andy Samberg
Do your kids ever watch your stuff and do they hear your voice?
Amy Poehler
My daughter watched a couple of the *Hotel Transylvanias* and liked them.
Andy Samberg
Yeah.
Amy Poehler
Did she recognize your voice in them? Kind of. Yeah. It's cool. My kids are not to a place yet where they like that I'm in the thing.
Andy Samberg
No, my children don't like to watch.
Amy Poehler
Do they ever get to that point?
Andy Samberg
Not really.
Amy Poehler
What about it? Can you imagine? Think of your mom and then think of watching your mom do...
Andy Samberg
But everyone likes *Inside Out*.
Amy Poehler
*Inside Out*, but... By the way, congrats on all your success. Congrats on all your success. *Inside Out 2*. Congrats on your success. I heard it crested to a billion?
Andy Samberg
Oh, really? You got points?
Amy Poehler
But have we been in an animated movie together? I don't think so.
Andy Samberg
We might have been. For how much we do a lot of animated movies, you and I... for how... I'm just saying, Amy, generally speaking, for how much I... I mean, I'm speaking on your behalf, how much we love each other and our friends, I don't think we have actually done that much together.
Amy Poehler
You know, you're so right. That's fucked up. I mean, I put it in my contract.
Andy Samberg
You know, yeah. Understood.
Amy Poehler
Wait, *Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs*? I got fired from that.
Andy Samberg
What? Oh, yeah. I was the original gal in *Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs*.
Amy Poehler
What the fuck? And I was fired because I did not do a good job and they had the audacity to replace me.
Andy Samberg
I hardly, hardly believe that. No, we have not been in an animated movie together. That's so funny. Even right, we have not done enough stuff together. I'm even trying to think of like at the show. To me, if you asked me to pick the things that stood out the most to me of me and you being together on stage at SNL, the two that immediately come to my mind are the Palin rap.
Amy Poehler
Yes.
Andy Samberg
And "I'm No Angel."
Amy Poehler
Wow. Two pregnancy, peak pregnancy performances. But both all-timers. I mean, I remember asking for your help when we were writing that Palin rap and you gave me some nuggets, including the having her hubby come out there.
Andy Samberg
Oh, was that my idea?
Amy Poehler
I think you gave me that idea of him coming out. That makes me feel better. I was saying we were talking about it on ours and I was saying I felt bad because I gave you some line that was like kind of a tricky rhyme scheme, but wasn't a laugh. And then I was like, why did I do that? So there's like so much something between us that needs to go between. It was that line. I feel like because Sudeikis came out as Todd.
Andy Samberg
Todd, yeah. Andy, I love you so much.
Amy Poehler
I love you, buddy. Thank you so much for doing this. It was an absolute pleasure.
Andy Samberg
It was such a pleasure. Like I said at the very beginning of this, the fact that I was getting to talk to you today was just like so calming. I wasn't the least bit stressed. I never am when I'm with you.
Amy Poehler
That's so nice to say. I love spending time with you.
Andy Samberg
You too, buddy. And I will say, not to keep hitting it over and over, it's still not an old thing for me to hear you say nice things about my comedy. I really enjoy your comedy. It makes me feel good and happy because you are one of the people I have aspired to and looked up to. And I love you so much and I love your comedy so much.
Amy Poehler
Thanks, buddy. You're the best. Oh, I wanted to just show you this pen before we wrapped. I found this on the desk today and it is one of those crinkle pens. Have you seen it?
Andy Samberg
Oh, boy. Do you know what it is? Is it going to collapse when I flip the switch?
Amy Poehler
No. Just give her a little twist on the top.
Sound of a crinkling pen
Andy Samberg
Are we edging on ASMR right here?
Amy Poehler
Yeah, that's exactly what we've been doing. Does that sound nice? Is this nice? Is that what ASMR people ask?
Andy Samberg
Yeah, I think.
Amy Poehler
Isn't it so funny? It's so pervy. ASMR is so pervy.
Andy Samberg
Don't.
Amy Poehler
Yeah. How dirty do we get on this podcast?
Andy Samberg
Very, very, very pervy.
Amy Poehler
No matter what you do, don't masturbate to this sound. You better not. You better not. Don't you dare masturbate, you dirty. Even though it probably feels so good.
Andy Samberg
I hope you're wearing Bose noise-canceling headphones. But be careful, because someone could walk in and you won't hear them.
Amy Poehler
If you start doing that, I'm going to use my hairbrush. I'm going to brush your hair really hard. I hope I don't accidentally click my long nails on the window pane.
Andy Samberg
On the window pane.
Amy Poehler
All right. All right. We did it. We did it. Cool pen. Thank you, Andy. That was really, really fun. That was such a good hang. And I felt like we went all over the place in a good way. And I'm so happy you did it. So thank you.
Pause
You know, Andy brought up a lot of digital shorts. And I guess for this polar plunge, I just wanted to remind you to check out "Shy Ronnie" again. One of my favorites. If you haven't watched it lately, the digital short "Shy Ronnie" with Rihanna. And that is how she pronounces her name. It's so funny. I just feel like the character and the look, it's just wig work at its best. It's a beautiful ginger wig and a really funny idea. And it's a really good song, like all of the songs that The Lonely Island makes. So that would be what I'm going to be watching this week to laugh. And in the meantime, keep laughing. I don't know how to end these. They just get harder and harder.
Andy Samberg
That's what she said.
Amy Poehler
Okay, bye.
Outro music begins
Narrator
You've been listening to *Good Hang*. The executive producers for this show are Bill Simmons, Jenna Weiss-Berman, and me, Amy Poehler. The show is produced by The Ringer and Paper Kite. For The Ringer, production by Jack Wilson, Kat Spillane, Kaya McMullen, and Alea Zanaris. For Paper Kite, production by Sam Green, Joel Lovell, and Jenna Weiss-Berman. Original music by Amy Miles.
Ad break begins
This episode is brought to you by Happy Egg. Happiness is important, right? Everyone has different things that make them happy. It's your work in life to find out what that is. Everyone deserves some happiness. And it's just the same for the humble chicken, because a happy hen makes a happy egg. That's why Happy Egg partners with family farms across the Midwest to raise hens outdoors with plenty of room to play, scratch, and spread their wings. And the eggs they lay are delicious. You can see and taste the proof yourself in the rich orange yolk. Crack open happy today. Find Happy Egg near you at happyegg.com slash Amy.
This episode is brought to you by Welch's Fruit Snacks. Listen up, everyone. Sharpen those pencils, get out those lunchboxes, and stock up on snacks because it's back to school time. And we know, we parents know, finding the balance of snacks you trust and snacks that your kids love is hard. And that's where Welch's fruit snacks come in. They aren't just delicious. They're made with real whole fruit. And your kids need snacks so they can feed their brains for learning. Find Welch's fruit snacks in stores nationwide. Go back to school with Welch's fruit snacks.