Main Topic: The U.S. service academies are facing a crisis due to the implementation of left-leaning policies and curricula, which some observers believe is hurting the preparedness of the military.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Upbeat music fades out, and the host, John Bickley, speaks
John Bickley
Welcome to this extra edition of Morning Wire. I'm Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley, and I'm joined by my co-host Georgia Howe. It's Sunday, January 14th, and today we're talking about the U.S. service academies.
Georgia Howe
That's right, John. The U.S. service academies are producing a shrinking share of officers while embracing more left-leaning policies. We're joined today by Bruce Fleming, a former professor at the U.S. Naval Academy and author of Saving Our Service Academies. Bruce, thanks so much for coming on.
Bruce Fleming
Thanks for having me on, John.
John Bickley
Bruce, let's start with your background. You come from a liberal background, but you've also been a professor at the Naval Academy for 36 years. Can you describe your experience and how it's shaped your views on the service academies?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, I'm from a true blue liberal background. I have a master's from the University of Chicago and a PhD from Vanderbilt. I taught for five years outside of the United States. And in 1987, I was offered the job at Annapolis, and I was thrilled to come because I admired the Naval Academy. I have learned some things about it since 1987, but that's certainly the attitude that I had when I came in.
Georgia Howe
That's fascinating. Your most recent book is focused on what you call corruption and rot inside the military service academies. Can you describe the significant changes you've seen in the academies over your career?
Bruce Fleming
Well, it's not only during my career, which actually is year 36. Things began to change for the service academies after World War II. Up until that point, it was basically true that if you wanted to become, in this case, a naval officer, you had to go to Annapolis. So what happened after World War II was that ROTC was beefed up exponentially, and officer candidate school was used to a much greater degree. So the percentage of officers produced by the service academies has dropped radically. It used to be close to 100%. Now at Annapolis, for example, it's fewer than one in five. About the same thing is true of West Point.
So about 18%. So that's one thing that's changed. They've dropped in relevance, first of all. And the second thing that's changed is that colleges outside of the service academies got really, really expensive, whereas the service academies, of course, are paid for by taxpayer money. And each student, I guess you could say, gets a scholarship. We don't put it like that. The cost to taxpayers of one Naval Academy or West Point graduate is about half a million dollars. That's about four times more than what an ROTC officer costs. So they're expensive. We don't really need them. We could get just the same amount of officers by beefing up ROTC.
John Bickley
That's a fascinating point. You've also written about the impact of women being admitted to the service academies. Can you describe how that's changed the culture and the way the academies operate?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, the service academies were forced by Congress to accept women. In Annapolis, it was 1976. The first women graduated in 1980. So women arrived. And this was dealt with really badly, incredibly badly. I've talked to women from the first several years, and it was a disaster for them because nothing was done to make the situation more acceptable to them. But now, it's close to half female in recent classes.
Georgia Howe
That's a significant change. You've also written about the introduction of majors and the way the classroom component has changed. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, until 1936, in fact, the service academies didn't give a bachelor's degree. They were just training for the services. The Naval Academy started in 1845 because it became clear that the Navy the ships they were on were so complex that they couldn't just learn as apprentices. So it was realized that they needed to have a classroom component, and that was introduced. But the classroom component now is essentially identical to what they can get anywhere else. So you would think that we have all of the developments coming from the outside world. The kick is that the institutions have not gotten flexible.
Institutions outside of the service academy since the 60s basically have given up on being in the position of what we usually call in loco parentis, acting as the parents to the kids, telling them what to do. You know, sex is not patrolled and so on. At the service academies, at the Naval Academy in specific, to start with this, sex is patrolled. They're not even supposed to hold hands on the 338 acres of what's called our yard. So that's ridiculous. They live in the same dormitory. There are almost as many girls as boys. Out gays are no longer thrown out. And yet they're punished for normal interactions.
The control is becoming more absolute.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point. You've also written about the culture wars taking place at the service academies. Can you describe what you mean by that and how it's affecting the academies?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, the thing about the service academies is related to what I just said, which is that they're run by the military that has not just the usual administrative power that you see at civilian colleges and institutions, but the UCMJ, the Uniform Code of Military Justice. All the students are actually in the military, in the Navy at Annapolis, of course, and in the Army at West Point, in Air Force at Colorado Springs, and so on. So the administration, instead of just, you know, wagging their fingers at them, they can actually punish them with legal means. So the culture wars take the usual form at Annapolis, but they're much stronger.
For example, the subtitle of my book is My Battle With and For the United States Naval Academy to Make Thinking Officers. So the battle for is I want it to be what it says it is, which it isn't. But the battle with is that I started writing things about what was actually going on at the service academies at Annapolis close to 20 years ago. And the administration responded not the way they should have responded to what was ostensibly a tenured professor writing for outlets like the Washington Post for mainstream publications. They started punishing me. It started with an angry letter from the then superintendent saying it wasn't professional for professors to write articles.
And it escalated from there through official letters of reprimand, loss of pay. I was finally fired in 2018. I was reinstated in 2019 retroactively.
Georgia Howe
Wow, that's a really interesting story. You've also written about the impact of affirmative action and the way it's being implemented at the service academies. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, I was on the admissions board and discovered that what we were doing was racist. If an applicant self-identified as African-American, he or she was held to a much lower bar. And then we have this gets a little technical but each service academy has a prep school where they can send people who meet no bars whatsoever and then they declare them remediated and they send them to Annapolis. So I thought that was racist and I thought it was illegal. I mean, the Supreme Court, as you're aware, has just killed affirmative action for civilian colleges, but it's made an exception, a specific exception for the service academies. So we can continue to let in students based on race.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point. You've also written about the impact of the sexual assault training wave and the way it's being implemented at the service academies. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, the Obama administration defined Title IX as a way to punish men who women had said had assaulted them. And assault was very broad. It was, you know, the men might have thought it was consensual sex. But if the woman decided even months later that she felt pressure or she didn't do it willingly or she thought about it and it wasn't a good idea and so on. The man could be slapped with all sorts of punishments. At the service academies, they can actually be thrown in jail with military punishments. It's not a slap on the wrist.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point. You've also written about the current kerfluffle, if you want, of what's called DEI, diversity, equity, and inclusion. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, it means proactively looking for ways to hire people who are members of what's sometimes called marginalized groups, which means, of course, non-white people to begin with. Women are not the flavor of the month either. They were 20 years ago. Everything was about inclusivity for women, but that's kind of fallen off the front burner. So now it's non-white people and it's non-straight sexualities. It sounds good to say, oh, we're opening up to other groups, but that means that you're not letting in people who probably had higher predictors. So it's the same old toxic stew of race, gender, and sexuality, only it's imposed with this greater force.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point. You've also written about the impact of these policies on the military as a whole. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, these culture wars are bad for the service academies. They're bad for the military. It's not just the service academies. It's the military as a whole. It really is going down the wrong path with this stuff. And I'm trying to say, wait, wait, talk about this. Let's talk about look. I have talked between 3 and 4 students. Hundreds of them have sat in the big red chair in my office and told me what they think of the place. They're all almost to a person. They're disillusioned. And I know what the problems are. Who doesn't know what the problems are? The answer is the administration.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point. You've also written about the need for the military to change its culture and become more open to discussion and dissent. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, the military has got to change. It's about keeping the CO happy and up the chain to the point where the superintendent of the Naval Academy doesn't know what's going on. There's a joke that says that when you become an admiral, you never eat a bad meal and you never hear the truth because there are all these layers, all these buffer layers of subordinate officers who are, each one is afraid to tell unpleasant truths to the level above it. And I say, look, I never told students what to think. My goal was to show them how to think because when they graduate and go into the service, as they climb the ranks, they're going to be in positions where they, the buck stops with them and they have to make decisions. So they have to look at all the data. They have to be able to justify what they do. They can't just go with their gut instinct, although obviously in the middle of battle with the bullets flying, that's pretty much all you have left. But you can train your gut instinct to listen to what the other side is saying. And that's exactly what the Naval Academy and increasingly the military refuses to do.
John Bickley
That's a really interesting point. You've also written about the need for the military to become more open to dissent and discussion. Can you describe that?
Bruce Fleming
Yeah, the solution is, you know, put down the pitchforks and let's talk about this. You're saying we're going down the wrong path. Do you believe there's a path back? Do you actually see that happening? What's the mechanism for that? Well, the mechanism for it happening at Annapolis would have been for them to get off of my back and let professors do their jobs at Annapolis. Of course, there is a problem here. You say, basically, what do I want to do about it? The more noise I make, the more possible it is that some of the officers who are in there will begin to echo me. I don't know whether it's going to change Harvard, but if you start again to go back to the ripples if you work the ripples from big to small rather than small to big if we can change the service academy so that they are actually what they say they are and encourage open discussion in the military so that junior officers are not afraid of taking unwelcome information to their superiors which currently in my experience and talking with former students, they are. The brass don't want to hear what they don't want to hear. We would have not only stronger service academies, but a more effective military.
Georgia Howe
That's a really interesting point. Bruce, thank you so much for talking with us today.
Bruce Fleming
Thanks a whole lot.
John Bickley
That was Bruce Fleming, former professor at the U.S. Naval Academy and author of Saving Our Service Academies. And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.