Main Topic: Former President Trump's mounting legal cases and the potential for convictions in 2024.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Overall, the podcast episode provides a detailed analysis of Trump's legal cases and the potential for convictions in 2024. McCarthy's expertise as a former federal prosecutor provides valuable insight into the legal issues at play, and his predictions for the outcome of the cases are thought-provoking and informative.
Sound of a news theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm Editor-in-Chief John Bickley, and I'm joined by my co-host Georgia Howe. It's Sunday, December 10th, and this is an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for tuning in, John.
John Bickley
Today, we're talking about former President Trump's mounting legal cases, both civil and criminal. Joining us now is former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy. Andy, thanks for joining us.
Andy McCarthy
Yeah, sure.
John Bickley
So late Friday, a judge ruled against former President Trump's claim of presidential immunity in his 2020 election interference case. Where does that leave his defense?
Andy McCarthy
Well, it's the most important issue that he raises because his objective is delay. And while there is a preference in federal law to not allow appeals prior to trial, in most federal cases, you try the whole case in the lower court, and then the whole case goes up on appeal to the circuit appellate court, and then finally to the Supreme Court.
Georgia Howe
[interrupting] But can you explain what this immunity claim is all about?
Andy McCarthy
Sure. The claim that was ruled on on Friday by Judge Tanya Chutkin was such a claim that Trump was advancing an immunity claim saying that because the activities that are the focus of his election interference trial were, as he argues, within the ambit of his presidential responsibilities, he has immunity from prosecution for those.
John Bickley
And what was Judge Chutkin's ruling on this claim?
Andy McCarthy
Judge Chutkin rejected that claim. I think it was to be expected that she would. The Supreme Court has never ruled on the question of whether a former president has immunity from prosecution, criminal prosecution, for official actions in connection with the presidency.
Georgia Howe
[asking a follow-up] But what about the Nixon versus Fitzgerald case?
Andy McCarthy
Ah, yes. The Supreme Court did rule in a case called Nixon versus Fitzgerald that a president does have immunity from civil suit for his official actions. But that was a very deeply divided case. And the court strongly suggested that had the issue been criminal liability rather than civil liability, the court would have come out differently.
John Bickley
[summarizing] So, Judge Chutkin applied that reasoning to this case, which does raise the question that wasn't before the court, the question of criminal liability. And she said he does not have immunity from prosecution.
Andy McCarthy
That's right. Now, Judge Chutkin also rejected Trump's claim that the indictment violates his First Amendment rights to free speech, which he used to question the validity of the election.
Georgia Howe
[asking a question] Did you think that was a valid ruling?
Andy McCarthy
Yeah, I thought so. And I happen to have some familiarity with this issue. In fact, she relied pretty heavily on the Second Circuit's appellate opinion in New York, arising out of my prosecution in the 90s against the Blind Sheikh and other jihadists who raised this question of whether their prosecution for seditious conspiracy was in effect a criminalization of speech.
John Bickley
[asking a follow-up] And what's the doctrine of law that's triggered by this?
Andy McCarthy
The idea that you are allowed as a prosecutor to use speech as proof of crimes. As far as the law is concerned, that doesn't criminalize the speech itself because you're not saying that the words that were used, the utterance of them is a crime. You're using the words that were uttered as evidence of other crimes.
Georgia Howe
[clarifying] So, in this case, Trump is charged with fraud, obstruction, and a civil rights violation. And what Judge Chutkin ruled was that the government is not saying that his act of speaking, for example, on the ellipse was itself a crime, but it is evidence of the crimes that are charged in the case.
Andy McCarthy
That's right.
John Bickley
[moving on to another topic] Now, also on Friday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit ruled against Trump in another lawsuit that accuses him of allegedly inciting the J6 riots. This one was brought by Democratic lawmakers and police officers. Where do these decisions leave Trump now?
Andy McCarthy
Well, the one in the civil case is an important ruling, but it's not a final ruling. And the court was very equivocal. This is a three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals. What they essentially said was that at this premature stage of the proceedings where we haven't had a trial, we haven't even had a motion to dismiss the case yet, they can't say definitively whether the actions that Trump is accused of, whether they should be considered official acts of the presidency or private acts that are outside the ambit of his executive responsibilities.
Georgia Howe
[asking a question] Do you see Trump being convicted in these D.C. courtrooms?
Andy McCarthy
I think it's a very high likelihood that he will be convicted. And I say that as somebody who does not think it's a valid case. I think the election interference case has a lot of legal problems. I don't believe, for example, the fraud on the government counts. I don't believe that they are applicable to the kind of behavior Trump is accused of.
John Bickley
[summarizing] So, what exactly amounts to corrupt obstruction under the statute that Jack Smith the prosecutor has charged is a vexing question. And the D Circuit has had a lot of trouble with it.
Andy McCarthy
That's right. And the civil rights statute that Smith has charged is basically a 19th century statute that was designed to attack the Ku Klux Klan for preventing people from voting through physical intimidation. I don't think the current Supreme Court would indulge its being applied to what Trump is accused of doing, which is arguing that because of various changes in voting rules that were done in the states in the lead up to the 2020 election, hundreds of thousands of those votes should, maybe millions of those votes should have been invalidated.
Georgia Howe
[asking a question] Last week, we covered special counsel Jack Smith's requests for info on all the people who interacted with former President Trump's Twitter account. What did you make of this really sweeping request and the fact that a judge actually granted it?
Andy McCarthy
I think that unfortunately what you have seen a lot from Washington, which is why the Justice Department plants its flag in the District of Columbia when it has investigations that could be run from various different jurisdictions. They're in Washington because the court is very friendly to the Justice Department there and pretty much gives them what they want.
John Bickley
[asking a follow-up] And what do you foresee happening this next year in 2024 with these major Trump cases? Do you see convictions coming this year? Is there jail time coming? What should we expect?
Andy McCarthy
Yeah. So the reason that the immunity issue in the D.C. election interference case is so important is Trump's strategy is delay. What he's trying to do is get an issue that he can, even if he loses with Judge Chutkin, that gives him a chance to get up to the Court of Appeals where she could lose control over the schedule.
Georgia Howe
[asking a question] And what's the timeline looking like for this trial?
Andy McCarthy
The trial is now scheduled for March 4th, but if the case gets taken by the Supreme Court, the chance of it being tried prior to the 2024 election to me is remote. Judge Chutkin knows that Trump wants to delay this. That's the reason that she put the immunity issue on a fast track, even though the other pretrial motions are still being submitted and argued at this point, she forced them to litigate the one that could be appealed on a very fast track so she could issue a ruling on December 1st.
John Bickley
[summarizing] So, what do you think is going to happen in 2024 with these major Trump cases?
Andy McCarthy
I think there's a very good chance that this election interference case will go to trial. And even though legally, I don't think it's as strong a case as the Florida documents case, the Mar-a-Lago case, I don't think the Mar-a-Lago documents case, because of the complexities of classified information issues, I don't think that's going to get to trial prior to the election.
Georgia Howe
[asking a question] And what about the potential for jail time?
Andy McCarthy
And there's a very good chance that the sentencing guidelines, because these are serious felony charges, would call for a sentence of imprisonment. And then you get into the whole matter of when does Trump get sentenced? And if he does get sentenced and it's a jail sentence, does the judge grant him bail pending appeal.
John Bickley
[concluding] Well, it's going to be a wild ride. Yeah, I'm afraid so.
Andy McCarthy
Thanks a lot.
John Bickley
That was former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy, and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.