Main Topic: The Lawfare Effort Against Donald Trump
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of the Daily Wire, and I'm joined today by my co-host Georgia Howe.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for tuning in, everyone. Today, we're discussing the latest developments in the lawfare effort against Donald Trump. Joining us now is former federal prosecutor Andy McCarthy.
Andy McCarthy
Thanks for having me on the show.
John Bickley
The NFL is back, and FanDuel's got everything you need to play your game. From same-game parlays to live betting. Right now, new customers bet $5 and get $300 in bonus bets if you win. 21-plus in president select states. 18-plus in Kentucky and Wyoming. Must be first online real money waging. $5 deposit required. Bonus issued is non-withdrawable bonus bets that expire seven days after receipt. Restrictions apply. See full terms at FanDuel.com slash sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.
Music transitions to a brief pause
Alright, let's dive into the story. Special Counsel Jack Smith has revised the federal charges against Donald Trump, responding to the Supreme Court's ruling on presidential immunity. Andy, can you walk us through what we just witnessed here?
Andy McCarthy
I think what we've witnessed is probably, from a prosecutor's standpoint, the cleanest and most efficient way to deal with the Supreme Court's opinion in the immunity case. Remember that when the court decided the immunity decision on July 1st, which held that the president has absolute immunity for core executive actions and at the very least presumptive immunity for everything he does within the ambit of his executive power.
Georgia Howe
So, what exactly did Smith do with the revised indictment?
Andy McCarthy
Well, I think what he did is take out some of the allegations that can't stand after the Supreme Court opinion. He hasn't taken out any counts, like he hasn't taken out any charges, but there are certain aspects of the evidence that can withstand the Supreme Court opinion and had to go. So he pared them down.
John Bickley
That makes sense. And you mentioned the Supreme Court's opinion. Can you break down what that means for Trump's case?
Andy McCarthy
Not just his official duties, but his duties at the core of his Article 2 constitutional executive power. And just to be clear about that, what the Supreme Court mainly did in the immunity decision was lay out principles for the lower courts to apply in making immunity determinations. The one place where they parted company with that approach was in addressing the allegations in the indictment that accused Trump of using his control of the Justice Department to further the schemes that are charged in the indictment.
Georgia Howe
So, where does that leave things now? What are the next steps for this case?
Andy McCarthy
I would break that into two if we could. The first thing that everybody is most concerned about, and I think rightly so, is what's the impact on the election? We're seven weeks to go. We're going to have a new president on January 25th, whether it's Trump or Harris. So I think this is really a big nothing because what people need to retain as they think about this is that the first thing that Judge Chutkin has to do, no matter when it's done, is examine the charging instrument, which is now the superseding indictment, to determine which allegations get immunity and which don't.
John Bickley
That's a lot to unpack. Can you simplify it for us?
Andy McCarthy
Whatever she decides about that, immunity is one of the few issues in federal criminal law that a litigant is allowed or a defendant is allowed to appeal pre-trial. So whatever she decides, even if she leans in Jack Smith's direction, Trump is going to be able to appeal that to the D.C. Circuit and then ultimately to the Supreme Court. So that issue has to be decided first.
Georgia Howe
And what about the appeals process? Does this end up in the hands of the Supreme Court again?
Andy McCarthy
Yeah, it'll end up in the hands of the Supreme Court again. And I think a second issue will end up in the hands of the Supreme Court, which is the question of whether Jack Smith has been properly appointed under the Constitution.
John Bickley
That's a big issue. Can you explain why that matters?
Andy McCarthy
So, the Florida case, the Mar-a-Lago documents case, was dismissed by Judge Aileen Cannon in what I thought was a scholarly 93-page opinion. She has found that Smith was not qualified to be special counsel because to wield the kind of power a special counsel has, you have to have one of two conditions. Either you have to be appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate, which Smith was not, or you have to have a position that's created by an act of Congress, a statute.
Georgia Howe
And what about the other cases against Trump? Where do we stand with those?
Andy McCarthy
Well, the Atlanta case is a clown show. I mean, it's basically at the moment it's in complete suspense because you'll also have immunity litigation in that connection. But before you can even get to that, there's a big litigation under state law regarding whether Fannie Willis, the prosecutor, has to be disqualified from the case.
John Bickley
That's a lot to keep track of. Can you summarize the current state of the lawfare campaign against Trump?
Andy McCarthy
I think the picture you painted here is that there will be immediate appeals from Trump's team. If this is allowed to move forward, this appeals process, does this end up in the hands of the Supreme Court again? Yeah, it'll end up in the hands of the Supreme Court again.
Georgia Howe
Andy, thank you so much for talking with us.
Andy McCarthy
My pleasure.
John Bickley
That was Andy McCarthy, and this has been a special episode of Morning Wire.
Theme music fades back in