Main Topic: The California bill that makes the state a sanctuary for minors seeking gender-affirming care without parental consent, and other news stories.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
This episode is brought to you by LifeLock. Between two-factor authentication, strong passwords, and a VPN, you try to be in control of how your info is protected. But many other places also have it, and they might not be as careful. That's why LifeLock monitors hundreds of millions of data points a second for threats. If your identity is stolen, they'll fix it. Guaranteed or your money back. Save up to 40% your first year. Visit LifeLock.com slash podcast for 40% off. Terms apply.
Short pause
A controversial bill just signed in California makes the state a sanctuary for children to get so-called gender-affirming care, potentially without parental consent. We break down the specifics of the bill.
Georgia Howe
I'm Daily Wire Editor-in-Chief John Bickley with Georgia Howe. It's Wednesday, October 5th, and this is Morning Wire.
John Bickley
Democrats sound the alarm as more and more Black and Latino men abandon the party. They're not getting their message to the ground in the way they should.
Georgia Howe
And an uproar in academia after a veteran professor is fired by NYU after students complain his organic chemistry class was too hard. Ultimately, what this is going to do is affect the quality of pre-med students or medical doctors that you get, and it's going to affect all of our health.
John Bickley
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. Stay tuned. We have the news you need to know.
Short pause
Do you like to be the first to know about trendy news and current events? If so, you got to get the Daily Wire Plus app. Not only will you receive mobile notifications whenever something's happening, but you'll also have access to the best commentary to break it all down.
Georgia Howe
Download the Daily Wire Plus app and keep up with the facts no matter where your day takes you.
John Bickley
California Governor Gavin Newsom signed a bill last week making California a sanctuary state for child gender transitions. The law aims to give all young people access to gender medicine with or without parental consent.
Georgia Howe
The law will likely face legal pushback from neighboring states that have tightened restrictions on transition procedures for minors.
John Bickley
Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraida Lordi is here with the details for us. So, Maraida, tell us about this bill.
Maraida Lordi
Hi, Georgia. Sure. So Governor Newsom signed this bill on Thursday. It passed the California legislature in late August. As John said, this bill is designed to make California a sanctuary for minors who might be otherwise restricted from getting gender treatment, either by other state laws or their own parents.
Georgia Howe
Those treatments could include puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, or gender reassignment surgery.
Maraida Lordi
The law restricts California officials and health providers from cooperating with out-of-state authorities who attempt to obtain documentation of these procedures happening in California.
John Bickley
Specifically, the law prohibits health care providers from releasing medical information about children receiving gender health services in response to a criminal or civil action from a state where such services are restricted.
Maraida Lordi
The bill also bans police from arresting or extraditing someone for providing gender health services to a child based on another state's restrictions.
John Bickley
Also, it prohibits California officials from enforcing another state's order that a child be removed from parents who allow the child to receive gender health services.
Maraida Lordi
Probably the most controversial aspect of this law is that it authorizes a court to take temporary custody of children whose parents don't support them undergoing gender treatment.
Jay Richards
What SB 107 does, which has now been signed by Governor Newsom, is it basically grants California courts custody temporarily over any minors that end up in the state of California.
Maraida Lordi
So if a 16-year-old girl wants to get on cross-sex hormones, she from Arkansas if she can find her way to California, she can actually do that without the parents' consent.
Jay Richards
In fact, doctors under this rule are obligated not even to disclose to the parents what they're doing.
Maraida Lordi
But the teens don't actually have to be in California. Out-of-state teens can also access telemedicine online.
Jay Richards
If they can connect with a gender clinic or a doctor that will prescribe, it would be cross-sex hormones or puberty blockers that can actually do that.
Maraida Lordi
That may be the thing in this law that actually gets California in trouble because that sounds very much like interstate commerce.
Jay Richards
I mean, this seems to violate the kind of full faith and credit clause to the Constitution, which basically means that states are going to recognize the laws of other states.
Maraida Lordi
And normally that's what happens if a parent kidnaps a child. But in this case, both with respect to abortion, as you say, and with respect to these so-called gender-affirming care, California is actually working to undermine the laws of states that have contrary laws.
John Bickley
Well, what is he saying about it?
Maraida Lordi
Well, Newsom appears to be aware that critics will say this law erodes parents' rights, and he's actually been tailoring his messaging to counter that.
Jay Richards
In a statement, he said, quote, "Parents know what's best for their kids, and they should be able to make decisions around the health of their children without fear. We must take a stand for parental choice."
Maraida Lordi
He also called the law a win for equality.
Jay Richards
But critics are saying this law does the exact opposite because it strips parents of the right to object to those procedures for their kids.
John Bickley
Now, is it actually legal for California to implement laws that are geared towards undermining other states' laws?
Maraida Lordi
Well, that's a big question. Federal law says states must recognize other states' laws when residents travel, so it's likely that other states will file suits.
Jay Richards
California has also established itself as a sanctuary state for abortion, which could face similar lawsuits.
Maraida Lordi
So it'll be interesting to see how both of those laws fare in the courts.
John Bickley
Well, like you said, it's going to be interesting to see how these laws hold up in court. Maraid, thanks for reporting.
Georgia Howe
That was Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraida Lordi.
Short pause
John Bickley
Prominent voices on the left are expressing concern this week that Democrats could see a loss of support among Black and Latino voters in the upcoming midterms that are now just five short weeks away.
Georgia Howe
On MSNBC, Joe Scarborough and Al Sharpton both conceded that the Democrats' messaging is failing to resonate with a demographic group who until very recently have been stalwarts of America's oldest political party.
John Bickley
Here to discuss is columnist David Marcus. So, Dave, what do Scarborough, Sharpton, and others think is behind this apparent exodus from the party?
David Marcus
Morning. Broadly speaking, what Democrats and those on the left are mainly saying, publicly at least, is that this is a messaging problem, which might be the oldest and lamest explanation in the history of politics.
Georgia Howe
Sharpton got a bit deeper in saying that the problem was specifically with Latino and black men, which was telling, and it's true.
John Bickley
Polls show us that where Democrats are bleeding minority voters is with men.
David Marcus
And there's reason to believe that the reasons for that go beyond messaging into substance and policy.
Georgia Howe
And the concern throughout is how we're connecting the face to the message.
John Bickley
The Democratic Party and President Biden does have some things they could be using that they done that has benefited clearly Black and Latinos but it not connected
David Marcus
What are some of the issues then where Republicans have been able to make inroads? Is it a specific set or more in line with the concerns of voters on a whole?
Georgia Howe
It's interesting. Vox had an article about Latino voters last week, and they tweeted it out saying basically, Latino voters are very much like the average voter.
John Bickley
And the Black vote, especially among men, has trended that way too, albeit more slowly.
David Marcus
Look, inflation doesn't know color. To the extent that crime does, it is disproportionately deleterious to some minority communities.
Georgia Howe
Even the border crisis is resonating.
John Bickley
So it does seem like Democrats are operating under a set of assumptions about these voters that might have been true once but just aren't anymore.
David Marcus
In regard to crime and the border, these are both issues where Democrats have sought to appease Black and Latino voters, respectively, with softer, lax policies on crime and immigration.
Georgia Howe
Is there a reason to believe this isn't working?
David Marcus
Yes, absolutely. From the beginning of the defund the police movement, polls showed that black voters were vehemently against it for good reason.
John Bickley
They're very often the victims of this crime.
David Marcus
And similarly with the southern border, having reported from there, most of the border agents I met were Hispanic.
Georgia Howe
The Hispanic voters I met wanted a strong border.
David Marcus
Cassie Garcia, Maya Flores, and Irene Anandarez Jackson are three wives of border agents running as Republicans for Congress very much on a platform of securing the border.
Georgia Howe
These issues have become much more complex for Democrats than they once were.
John Bickley
Sharpton also mentioned that there is a flux here, that as minority voters moved into the GOP camp, suburban white voters, especially women, are moving toward Democrats.
David Marcus
What does this trend bode, not just for the midterm, but 2024?
Georgia Howe
In the short term, it could be something of a wash.
John Bickley
It does appear now that the abortion issue has jacked up voter enthusiasm among suburban women.
David Marcus
You take a state like Pennsylvania, could Democrat John Fetterman get a bump from the burbs? Sure.
Georgia Howe
But Republican Mehmet Oz could see an equal and opposite effect with urban voters on crime.
John Bickley
Longer term, Republicans will love this trade.
David Marcus
Minority voters, specifically Hispanic voters, are a fast-growing segment of the electorate.
Georgia Howe
Suburban, college-educated women just are not.
John Bickley
This is a positive realignment for the GOP.
David Marcus
And frankly, it's why you see Democrats very concerned about it.
Georgia Howe
Yeah, it makes sense.
John Bickley
While the economy and abortion have been at the top of the messaging for both of the parties this year, the culture wars have also loomed over it with battles over gender and sex education in Florida and other places.
Georgia Howe
How will this play out among minority voters?
David Marcus
Pew has a new poll of Hispanic voters, and they asked if they thought greater social acceptance of transgender people is good for society.
John Bickley
Only 36 percent said yes.
David Marcus
Now, that's in line with voters as a whole, but falls far short of the percentage of Democrats overall, which was 59 percent saying yes.
Georgia Howe
This idea that minority voters will automatically eat up so-called social justice issues, it doesn't seem to actually be the case.
John Bickley
Well, some very fascinating and significant trends we're watching here.
David Marcus
Thank you for joining us today.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for having me.
John Bickley
That was Daily Wire contributor David Marcus.
Short pause
A veteran professor at NYU has been fired after students complained his tests were too difficult. The firing sparked fierce debate about the rising power of students over educators and the ability of schools to hold firm standards.
Georgia Howe
Here to give us the details is Daily Wire's Charlotte Pence Bond. So, Charlotte, walk us through what happened here.
Charlotte Pence Bond
So the professor at issue is Dr. Maitland Jones Jr. He's been teaching organic chemistry for decades, first at Princeton and then seemed to be at New York University on contract.
John Bickley
He been the recipient of multiple teaching awards and even authored a textbook.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The issue began when NYU students were coming back to campus last spring when the pandemic restrictions were lifted at which time 82 of his 350 students signed a petition saying that his class was too difficult and their low grades were not fair.
Georgia Howe
Jones says he felt that his guidelines were sufficient, but university deans insisted that steps be taken to appease the students.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The school permitted the students to drop the course retroactively to protect their GPAs.
John Bickley
The chemistry department's chairman said it was a one-time exception granted to students by the dean of the college.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The decision prompted significant backlash from Jones's peers in the chemistry department and many students who were outraged by the moves to appease the unhappy students.
Georgia Howe
One chemistry professor at the school accused the deans of trying to make the students happy because they wanted people to apply to NYU.
Charlotte Pence Bond
But then before the fall semester started, Jones's contract was ended.
John Bickley
Now, what were the students' exact complaints about Professor Jones' class?
Charlotte Pence Bond
They had several specific accusations. And in the petition, they said, "We are very concerned about our scores and find that they are not an accurate reflection of the time and effort put into this class."
Georgia Howe
The petition also said, "We urge you to realize that a class with such a high percentage of withdrawals and low grades has failed to make students' learning and well-being a priority and reflects poorly on the chemistry department as well as the institution as a whole."
Charlotte Pence Bond
The students told The Times that they never intended to get Jones fired, nor did they request that, but that was unfortunately the outcome.
John Bickley
So the students felt their grades did not reflect the effort they put into the course.
Charlotte Pence Bond
What did Professor Jones say?
Georgia Howe
He acknowledged that the pandemic made things hard, but he suggested that the students themselves were also part of the issue.
Charlotte Pence Bond
Jones told the New York Times that he has observed a decline in students' ability to focus starting about 10 years ago.
John Bickley
He said grades were dropping even when he made his tests easier and that COVID made the problem worse.
Charlotte Pence Bond
He said it wasn't just that they didn't study after the pandemic, but they didn't appear to even know how to do so.
John Bickley
Another key issue here is that the course, Organic Chemistry, is actually designed to be a weed-out course.
Charlotte Pence Bond
Many of the students enrolled are trying to be doctors, and medical schools look at students' grades in organic chemistry to see if they have what it takes to be good doctors.
Georgia Howe
They depend on universities to rigorously filter out unprepared students.
John Bickley
So the course is purposefully intense and has been that way for decades.
Charlotte Pence Bond
Jones said he doesn't want to be rehired because he was going to retire soon, but he's concerned about the precedent that this sets.
Georgia Howe
And of course, a bigger concern is that as schools seek to appease students, the academic rigor at these institutions will decrease.
Charlotte Pence Bond
As one fellow professor who commented on the Times piece put it, "doing poorly in a class should be a reason not to go into certain fields."
Georgia Howe
A student who can't hack organic chemistry does not belong in medical school.
Charlotte Pence Bond
A student who can't hack calculus shouldn't go into engineering.
John Bickley
Those courses should not be simplified for their sake.
Georgia Howe
Right. Well, I'll say there's no amount of effort that would make me a safe engineer.
Charlotte Pence Bond
So I can agree with that.
John Bickley
Charlotte, thanks for reporting.
Georgia Howe
That was Daily Wire's Charlotte Pence Bond.
Short pause
John Bickley
Another story we're tracking this week. Twitter's value closed at more than 22% higher on Tuesday after Elon Musk reversed course and said he would agree to purchase the company at his original offer price of $54.20 a share.
Georgia Howe
Sources told CNBC the deal could be finalized as soon as Friday.
John Bickley
Thanks for listening to Morning Wire. We created this show to bring more balance to the national conversation.
Georgia Howe
If you love our show and you stand with our mission, please consider subscribing, leaving us a five-star rating, and most importantly, sharing our podcast with a friend.
John Bickley
Thanks for waking up with us. We'll be back this afternoon with more of the news you need to know.