Main Topic: Harvard University is facing a lawsuit from six students, including Shabos Kestenbaum, for allegedly failing to protect Jewish students from anti-Semitism on campus.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of the Daily Wire.
Georgia Howe
And I'm Georgia Howe, co-host of Morning Wire.
John Bickley
This is an extra edition of Morning Wire.
Georgia Howe
Today, we're talking about Harvard University, America's first and most prestigious university, coming under intense scrutiny amid reports of escalating anti-Semitism on campus.
John Bickley
And now, a group of Harvard students are suing the school for what they say is discrimination and a failure to protect Jewish students.
Georgia Howe
Joining us now is Shabos Kestenbaum, a graduate student at Harvard who has filed a lawsuit against the university along with five other students.
Shabos Kestenbaum
Thank you so much for having me.
John Bickley
First of all, give us some background on yourself and your relationship to Harvard.
Shabos Kestenbaum
So I'm a second-year Harvard graduate student. I studied theology and public policy. What drew me to the university was its stellar academic reputation and the opportunities to really explore and engage intellectually.
Georgia Howe
And then, of course, when you actually started at Harvard about two years ago, you realized quite quickly that it was really an institution that had serious and fundamental issues related to anti-Semitism.
Shabos Kestenbaum
Right. And now you're one of six students suing the university for discrimination and a refusal to protect Jewish students. That's your claim. What did you experience on the campus after the October 7th Hamas attack on Israel?
So I wouldn't even say what we experienced began after October 7th. A lot of it was before and a lot of it was actually during October 7th. We had 34 student groups, in some cases, jump out of bed in their pajamas to draft an emergency statement declaring that Jews are to be blamed for their own murder.
Georgia Howe
And that's what began this series of unthinkable, constant, and incredibly difficult instances of anti-Semitism, where you felt that the university was not protecting you, and where you felt your own classmates were engaged in anti-Semitism.
Shabos Kestenbaum
So I'll just give you a couple of examples. We now have, as a normal reality, students yelling at us to globalize the Intifada on our way to classrooms.
Georgia Howe
The Intifada of course was one of the most difficult periods for Jewish people since the Holocaust when buses and hospitals and nursing homes were blown up and innocent Jewish civilians were killed for no other crime than being Jewish.
Shabos Kestenbaum
And so we have classmates who say that we need to globalize it, we need to do it again. We've had students yell, free Palestine from the river to the sea, of course, referencing the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, which of course encompasses all of Israel.
Georgia Howe
Again, another call for Jewish genocide.
Shabos Kestenbaum
We've had students post on social media that they proudly identify with Hamas or Hezbollah or the Houthis, proudly saying that if that's what makes them terrorists, then they're glad to be called terrorists.
John Bickley
So it's really just been one instance after instance, one allegation after the next of pervasive and systemic anti-Semitism.
Shabos Kestenbaum
And what's worse is Harvard knew about this and knows about it and has done nothing to speak out and condemn this and tell Jewish students what they're going to do to protect them.
Georgia Howe
Now, President Claudine Gay became really the focal point of the Harvard response. And for good reason, she was the president. She's now resigned after massive pressure.
Shabos Kestenbaum
Why are you suing the school even after she's resigned?
I've had people ask me, Gay is gone. You won. Why the lawsuit? And I think for anyone who reads the lawsuit, and I encourage everyone to do so, you walk away with the sense of this is much bigger than one person.
Georgia Howe
These issues started before Claudine Gay, and unfortunately, unless Harvard does something about it, it will continue after Claudine Gay.
Shabos Kestenbaum
So she was a great representation of the failures of Harvard to deal with anti-Semitism, but she is not the only representation of that.
John Bickley
And when she resigned, did she say it was because of her failure to deal with anti-Semitism?
Shabos Kestenbaum
In fact, she blamed these, quote, outside demagogues. She blamed conservative activists, sort of giving a nice wink for people to blame the Zionists and blame the Jews.
Georgia Howe
As far as the claims in the lawsuit, you're making the case that there's a double standard held by Harvard in relation to Jewish students. What are some examples of that double standard on campus and in school policies?
Shabos Kestenbaum
Yeah, so as explained in the lawsuit, all incoming students have mandatory Title IX training, this anti-discrimination training, and that includes the idea that fatphobia can be disciplinary action.
Georgia Howe
It includes the idea that referring to someone by the wrong gender pronoun can be grounds for disciplinary action.
Shabos Kestenbaum
Yet there's no training for anti-Semitism, yet there's no training for disciplinary actions for someone engaged in anti-Semitism.
John Bickley
And we know that Harvard has a record, quite rightfully, I would say, of disciplining students engaged in other types of hatred and discrimination.
Shabos Kestenbaum
So, for example, when a group of students or admitted students were engaged in racist posts on their private social media, Harvard rescinded their acceptances because they made a stand that racism is never tolerated.
Georgia Howe
Last year, when there was a homophobic incident, within 24 hours, it was condemned and the student was expelled.
Shabos Kestenbaum
When we have Jewish students who are facing anti-Semitism almost on a daily basis, there is no immediate condemnation and there's certainly no disciplinary action.
John Bickley
So I think the double standard is pretty obvious and it's pretty out there in the open.
Shabos Kestenbaum
Harvard has not really made any efforts to pretend otherwise.
Georgia Howe
Now, in terms of the root of the discrimination, a lot of people are seeing this as stemming really in part from DEI diversity equity and inclusion programs.
Shabos Kestenbaum
DEI creates this binary system of oppressor and oppressed and that something that Harvard has really fed into, this insidious ideology.
John Bickley
So I'll give you a really good example. Marshall Gantz, who's a current professor at Harvard Kennedy School, was found to have discriminated against three or four Jewish students.
Shabos Kestenbaum
And he was in direct violation of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act. And not only was he not disciplined, but he was actually given an award a couple of months later, and he's still on the faculty and he's still teaching.
Georgia Howe
I don't see how that could have played out if he had found to have discriminated against any other minority group.
Shabos Kestenbaum
But because this ideology of oppressor and oppressed has given Jews the unfortunate mischaracterization of whiteness, I think a lot of the overt antisemitism and the lack of action can probably be explained as due to this characterization of whiteness.
John Bickley
All right, final question. What are you asking for in your lawsuit? What kind of damages or what do you hope to achieve in the end through this legal action?
Shabos Kestenbaum
I think what we're trying to achieve is twofold. The first is immediate and practical, and that's tuition reimbursements.
Georgia Howe
When we enrolled at Harvard, we engaged in a contract. We told them that we would give them our tuition, and in exchange, they would provide both an education and a minimal degree of protection and safety, and they've reneged on their end of the deal.
Shabos Kestenbaum
We certainly have not had a proper education, considering that classes have been disrupted, that we have to be constantly looking over our shoulder as it pertains to anti-Semitism.
John Bickley
And then the second part, which is more fundamental, perhaps, is to force Harvard to implement and enforce their own school policies, but also their obligations, their federal obligations under Title VI, which is something that, objectively speaking, they have yet to do.
Shabos Kestenbaum
They have not enforced the laws already on the books. And that's what this lawsuit does. It forces Harvard to protect Jewish students and really all students by making sure that they follow through on the laws and policies they have to enforce anyways.
Georgia Howe
We didn't want to do this. We wanted Harvard to work with us. We wanted there to be a credible partner. And unfortunately, that just wasn't the case.
Shabos Kestenbaum
They made it abundantly clear. Either they were unable or unwilling to engage in meaningful dialogue and perhaps more importantly, meaningful action.
John Bickley
Well, Shabos, thank you so much for talking with us. And we're certainly watching with interest to see how this case goes.
Shabos Kestenbaum
Thanks again. Take care.
Georgia Howe
That was Harvard graduate student Shabos Kestenbaum, and this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.