Main Topic: The homeless crisis in San Francisco, California, and the failure of the city's $160 million Permanent Supportive Housing program.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Georgia Howe
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm Georgia Howe with Daily Wire editor-in-chief John Bickley. It's May 14th, and this is your Saturday edition.
John Bickley
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. We have the news you need to know.
Georgia Howe
San Francisco invested $160 million to shelter the homeless in hotels. A new investigation into the program reveals shocking conditions and a trail of death.
John Bickley
It doesn't deal with the root problem, which is untreated mental illness and addiction.
Georgia Howe
I'm joined now by Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraid Elordi. Maraid, what's going on here?
Maraid Elordi
Yeah, so this investigation by the San Francisco Chronicle found that San Francisco's homeless program, a $160 million program called Permanent Supportive Housing, has devolved into chaos, crime, and death.
Georgia Howe
The way it works is that the city's Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing pays nonprofit groups to provide rooms and aid to about 6,000 homeless people in about 70 hotels.
Maraid Elordi
But because of lack of oversight from the city government and neglect of the hotels, the formerly homeless residents have dealt with horrific situations like unsanitary living conditions.
Georgia Howe
For example, there are reports of severe rodent infestations, violence, and frequent overdose deaths.
Maraid Elordi
And overdosing was much more common in these hotels than on the streets. Many of the residents exposed to these conditions are disabled.
Georgia Howe
The idea behind the program is to provide people with free housing until they're ready to live more independently.
Maraid Elordi
But it's unclear whether these conditions are actually better than life on the streets.
Georgia Howe
The government tracked 515 tenants who exited the program and found that fully a quarter died while in the program.
Maraid Elordi
Another 21% chose to return to the streets. Only about a quarter ended up in stable living situations, usually with friends or family, some in another taxpayer-subsidized building.
Georgia Howe
Michael Schellenberger is a California gubernatorial candidate who is running on the platform of solving the homeless crisis.
Maraid Elordi
Here's what he had to say about the program.
Michael Schellenberger
What we know works, in fact, the only thing that works and has performed well in study after study for really decades, is what's called contingency management, which is basically giving people a reward of their own room or some other reward.
Georgia Howe
So how did the journalists at the San Francisco Chronicle describe life in these hotels?
Maraid Elordi
They basically said that the conditions in the majority of these buildings are entirely unsafe, due in part to the nonprofits failing to maintain the buildings, but also because of the actions of some residents.
Georgia Howe
For example, the sinks and appliances have been ripped from the wall. Fecal matter has been found clogging sinks and mattresses have been set on fire.
Maraid Elordi
One resident reported sleeping in a tent in the room due to the rodents.
Georgia Howe
When residents die, their bodies sometimes aren't discovered until their room begins to smell.
Maraid Elordi
The maintenance issues are not trivial either.
Georgia Howe
One 57-year-old wheelchair-bound man lived on an upper floor of one of the hotels, and he said that he missed several chemotherapy treatments when the elevator broke and he was unable to leave his room for weeks.
Maraid Elordi
One resident interviewed said that there is no hope in these living situations.
Georgia Howe
So how have city officials responded to these concerns?
Maraid Elordi
Well, Mayor London Breed has admitted that people should not have to live in these conditions, but she blamed the nonprofits who run the program.
Georgia Howe
She has supported accountability measures for the program, but to date, none have been enforced.
Maraid Elordi
Now, are there any proposed solutions to the city's current approach?
Georgia Howe
There are a few, yeah.
Maraid Elordi
Other cities do something called a scattered site approach, where homeless people use vouchers to rent apartments and case managers help them get on the right track.
Georgia Howe
San Francisco has also invested in a much higher quality building for homeless people with medical issues called the Kelly Cullen Community.
Maraid Elordi
So the city wants to invest more money in these higher quality buildings with services?
Georgia Howe
Yes, but from the data, it's unclear whether that will help.
Maraid Elordi
The Department of Homelessness and Support of Housing, which is responsible for implementing these programs, debuted in 2016.
Georgia Howe
And since that time, the homeless population in the city has shot up by 56 percent.
Maraid Elordi
About two-thirds of Californians now say the homeless crisis is the state's biggest problem.
Georgia Howe
Right. It's becoming an issue across California, not just San Francisco.
Maraid Elordi
Thanks so much for reporting.
Georgia Howe
That was Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraid Elordi.
Commercial break
Welcome back to Morning Wire. California might be changing its mind on nuclear power.
John Bickley
Despite a series of rolling blackouts in the state, California is set to shut down its last nuclear power plant.
Georgia Howe
But now the governor is signaling that he might be rethinking shuttering, the key source of energy for the state.
John Bickley
And tens of thousands of Americans are packing up and leaving big cities. What's driving the urban exodus?
Georgia Howe
And which cities are suffering the biggest losses?
John Bickley
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. We have the news you need to know.
Commercial break
Georgia Howe
This show is sponsored by Alto IRA. Cryptocurrency may represent the future of money, but what about taxes?
John Bickley
With an Alto Crypto IRA, you can trade crypto like Bitcoin and avoid or defer the taxes.
Georgia Howe
With secure trading 24-7 through Alto's integration with Coinbase and over 150 coins available, Alto IRA has you covered.
John Bickley
Open an Alto Crypto IRA with as little as $10. Just go to altoira.com slash wire.
Georgia Howe
That's A-L-T-O-I-R-A dot com slash wire.
Commercial break
Nearly half of all the homeless people in America live in California.
John Bickley
A recent investigation in San Francisco shows that policies meant to fight the problem are failing.
Georgia Howe
In the 20-teens, San Francisco expanded a housing program where homeless individuals were placed in hotels around the city.
John Bickley
A recent investigation into the program revealed shocking conditions and prompted calls for accountability.
Georgia Howe
Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraid Elordi is here with the details for us.
Maraid Elordi
So, Maraid, what's going on here? What did this investigation find?
Yeah, so this investigation by the San Francisco Chronicle found that San Francisco's homeless program, a $160 million program called Permanent Supportive Housing, has devolved into chaos, crime, and death.
Georgia Howe
The way it works is that the city's Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing pays nonprofit groups to provide rooms and aid to about 6,000 homeless people in about 70 hotels.
Maraid Elordi
But because of lack of oversight from the city government and neglect of the hotels, the formerly homeless residents have dealt with horrific situations like unsanitary living conditions.
Georgia Howe
For example, there are reports of severe rodent infestations, violence, and frequent overdose deaths.
Maraid Elordi
And overdosing was much more common in these hotels than on the streets. Many of the residents exposed to these conditions are disabled.
Georgia Howe
The idea behind the program is to provide people with free housing until they're ready to live more independently.
Maraid Elordi
But it's unclear whether these conditions are actually better than life on the streets.
Georgia Howe
The government tracked 515 tenants who exited the program and found that fully a quarter died while in the program.
Maraid Elordi
Another 21% chose to return to the streets. Only about a quarter ended up in stable living situations, usually with friends or family, some in another taxpayer-subsidized building.
Georgia Howe
Michael Schellenberger is a California gubernatorial candidate who is running on the platform of solving the homeless crisis.
Maraid Elordi
Here's what he had to say about the program.
Michael Schellenberger
What we know works, in fact, the only thing that works and has performed well in study after study for really decades, is what's called contingency management, which is basically giving people a reward of their own room or some other reward.
Georgia Howe
So how did the journalists at the San Francisco Chronicle describe life in these hotels?
Maraid Elordi
They basically said that the conditions in the majority of these buildings are entirely unsafe, due in part to the nonprofits failing to maintain the buildings, but also because of the actions of some residents.
Georgia Howe
For example, the sinks and appliances have been ripped from the wall. Fecal matter has been found clogging sinks and mattresses have been set on fire.
Maraid Elordi
One resident reported sleeping in a tent in the room due to the rodents.
Georgia Howe
When residents die, their bodies sometimes aren't discovered until their room begins to smell.
Maraid Elordi
The maintenance issues are not trivial either.
Georgia Howe
One 57-year-old wheelchair-bound man lived on an upper floor of one of the hotels, and he said that he missed several chemotherapy treatments when the elevator broke and he was unable to leave his room for weeks.
Maraid Elordi
One resident interviewed said that there is no hope in these living situations.
Georgia Howe
So how have city officials responded to these concerns?
Maraid Elordi
Well, Mayor London Breed has admitted that people should not have to live in these conditions, but she blamed the nonprofits who run the program.
Georgia Howe
She has supported accountability measures for the program, but to date, none have been enforced.
Maraid Elordi
Now, are there any proposed solutions to the city's current approach?
Georgia Howe
There are a few, yeah.
Maraid Elordi
Other cities do something called a scattered site approach, where homeless people use vouchers to rent apartments and case managers help them get on the right track.
Georgia Howe
San Francisco has also invested in a much higher quality building for homeless people with medical issues called the Kelly Cullen Community.
Maraid Elordi
So the city wants to invest more money in these higher quality buildings with services?
Georgia Howe
Yes, but from the data, it's unclear whether that will help.
Maraid Elordi
The Department of Homelessness and Support of Housing, which is responsible for implementing these programs, debuted in 2016.
Georgia Howe
And since that time, the homeless population in the city has shot up by 56 percent.
Maraid Elordi
About two-thirds of Californians now say the homeless crisis is the state's biggest problem.
Georgia Howe
Right. It's becoming an issue across California, not just San Francisco.
Maraid Elordi
Thanks so much for reporting.
Georgia Howe
That was Daily Wire investigative reporter Maraid Elordi.
Commercial break
Welcome back to Morning Wire. California might be changing its mind on nuclear power.
John Bickley
Despite a series of rolling blackouts in the state, California is set to shut down its last nuclear power plant.
Georgia Howe
But now the governor is signaling that he might be rethinking shuttering, the key source of energy for the state.
John Bickley
And tens of thousands of Americans are packing up and leaving big cities. What's driving the urban exodus?
Georgia Howe
And which cities are suffering the biggest losses?
John Bickley
Thanks for waking up with Morning Wire. We have the news you need to know.
Commercial break
Georgia Howe
This show is sponsored by Good Ranchers. You know what you need this summer? You need new burgers.
John Bickley
How about American Wagyu burgers from Good Ranchers?
Georgia Howe
Good Ranchers American Wagyu is raised here in the States and produces the rich and buttery Wagyu texture that you crave.
John Bickley
Visit GoodRanchers.com slash wire to get a box of amazing American meat and get two pounds of free American Wagyu burgers and free shipping added to your order.
Georgia Howe
Just use code wire at GoodRanchers.com slash wire.
John Bickley
Good Ranchers American meat delivered.
Commercial break
Georgia Howe
As California's need for energy continues to rise, Governor Gavin Newsom is now reconsidering whether or not to close the state's last remaining nuclear power plant.
John Bickley
Here to tell us more is Daily Wire's Charlotte Pence Bond.
Charlotte Pence Bond
All right, Charlotte, we have what appears to be a reversal here on nuclear power in California. What are we seeing from the governor?
Yeah, what's happening here is that California's last remaining nuclear power plant was set to close by 2025.
Georgia Howe
But now Governor Newsom seems to be getting cold feet.
Charlotte Pence Bond
He told a local TV station that he is in support of, quoting here, keeping all options on the table to ensure the state has a reliable grid heading into the summer.
Georgia Howe
The plant in question is Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, and it's owned by Pacific Gas and Electric, or PG&E, which was planning to shut down the plant by 2025.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The plant created about 6% of California's power last year.
Georgia Howe
In 2016 PG reached an agreement with environment organizations and its union workers to stop its nuclear work after its licenses for nuclear reactors end in 2024 and 2025
Charlotte Pence Bond
But Newsom is shifting the goalposts a little bit.
Georgia Howe
He said he's looking into trying to get federal funds up to $6 billion that are directed at helping save nuclear reactors that are facing shutdowns.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The Biden administration announced this funding in April.
Georgia Howe
Newsom said state authorities could determine later on whether or not they want to go forward with that as a possibility.
Charlotte Pence Bond
A spokesperson for Newsom told The Times that he still supports shutting down the plant eventually.
Georgia Howe
Does Newsom actually have the authority to keep it open?
Charlotte Pence Bond
So technically, Newsom doesn't actually make the call since he doesn't own the plant.
Georgia Howe
The Biden administration's guidance, quote, directs owners or operators of nuclear power reactors that are expected to shut down due to economic circumstances on how to apply for funding to avoid premature closure.
Charlotte Pence Bond
So it sounds like PG&E has to actually apply for the funds itself.
Georgia Howe
But it looks like PG&E might go for it.
Charlotte Pence Bond
A spokesperson for PG&E, Suzanne Hosen, told me in an email, quoting again, PG&E is committed to California's clean energy future.
Georgia Howe
We are always open to considering all options to ensure continued safe, reliable, and clean energy delivery to our customers.
Charlotte Pence Bond
I spoke to Katie Tubb at the Heritage Foundation about all of this, and she had doubts it would actually stay open.
Georgia Howe
It is very, very hard at this point to turn this battleship around.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The first reactor is scheduled to close in 2024, the second in 2025.
Georgia Howe
There's a process to actually getting beyond those dates.
Charlotte Pence Bond
When they made this agreement with the environmental community, labor unions, they said, let us just run the plants till their scheduled closure date.
Georgia Howe
We will pull back our license renewal request.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The Public Utility Commission in California accepted that arrangement in 2018.
Georgia Howe
So you have all of these kind of legal agreements in place that would have to be unwound.
Charlotte Pence Bond
Also, there's a question as to whether the plant qualifies for the federal funds.
Georgia Howe
Last fall, Congress passed the infrastructure bill.
Charlotte Pence Bond
And in that package, there is a $6 billion nuclear credit program.
Georgia Howe
Basically, the idea is to subsidize nuclear power plants that are struggling economically.
Charlotte Pence Bond
I don't think the Diablo Canyon plant will actually qualify for that program because the plant isn't closing for economic reasons, it's closing for political reasons.
Georgia Howe
Now, you said the nuclear power plant provided 6% of the state's energy last year.
Charlotte Pence Bond
How much could nuclear impact things going forward?
Georgia Howe
It could have a massive impact.
Charlotte Pence Bond
In 2020, nuclear energy made up more than 9% of the state's total power mix.
Georgia Howe
And for Diablo Canyon specifically, it's significant.
Charlotte Pence Bond
The two reactors at the plant create a total of 18,000 gigawatt hours of electricity each year, which PG&E says is enough energy to power 3 million northern and central Californians.
Georgia Howe
And nuclear energy makes up almost as much as all other renewable energy sources combined in the U.S.
Charlotte Pence Bond
So this isn't just a California issue.
Georgia Howe
States across the country are looking to create renewable energy and do it in a climate-friendly way.
Charlotte Pence Bond
So nuclear could be an option that multiple sides to this debate can get on board with.
Georgia Howe
Well, Charlotte, thanks so much for reporting.
Charlotte Pence Bond
That was Daily Wire's Charlotte Pence Bond.
Commercial break
Georgia Howe
The latest census data shows a massive urban migration out of major U.S. cities, suggesting Americans are rethinking how and where they want to live.
John Bickley
Here to explore some of the factors driving this significant demographic shift is Daily Wire culture reporter Megan Basham.
Megan Basham
So, Megan, what are the big factors causing cities to shrink?
Well, you know obviously politics plays a big role in this and we'll get to that in just a second.
Georgia Howe
But arguably, the most significant factor here is technology.
Megan Basham
So COVID really ramped up the change in the way we work, even before that many jobs were shifting to some sort of remote arrangement.
Georgia Howe
Workers no longer obviously need to live near their office.
Megan Basham
That option provided a lot of people with the opportunity to move further afield of the biggest metro areas where rents tend to be, you know, we all know pretty high and often the school quality is very low.
Georgia Howe
From 2020 to 2021, LA lost 176,000 people.
Megan Basham
San Francisco lost 116,000. Chicago, 91,000, San Jose, Boston, Miami, D.C. They were all down tens of thousands of residents.
Georgia Howe
And then you have sort of the granddaddy of all this movement, and that's New York, which lost almost 328,000 residents.
Megan Basham
Yeah, and these are cities that also gain influxes of immigrants from other countries who usually offset those leaving.
Georgia Howe
Now, there was obviously less migration during the pandemic, so that was affecting those numbers as well.
Megan Basham
But still to have those net losses in the hundreds of thousands is just hugely significant.
Georgia Howe
Yeah, it really is.
Megan Basham
But hasn't movement out of cities been a common story for a long time now?
Georgia Howe
I feel like I remember stories like this maybe a decade ago.
Megan Basham
What's changed here?
Georgia Howe
Well, you know, that's true.
Megan Basham
But I think what we're seeing now is that same trend sort of on steroids.
Georgia Howe
One consultant in the home building industry, for example, told The Economist that the changes they're seeing, And keep in mind, their business depends on seeing those shifts accurately.
Megan Basham
They said this is unlike anything they've seen in decades.
Georgia Howe
Are there any other issues at play here?
Megan Basham
Well, yeah, you have to say that there are because while a lot of those big urban centers lost population, not all of them did.
Georgia Howe
And that's where I think those local policies come into play.
Megan Basham
So to give you one example, a UCLA survey looked at why people are leaving Los Angeles County.
Georgia Howe
And it found that the biggest issues are the high housing prices, homelessness, rising crime, and health concerns.
Megan Basham
Businesses, they're also feeling the effects of those policies.
Georgia Howe
So as they're leaving for areas with friendlier tax and regulation policies, they're offering more opportunities in smaller cities as well.
Megan Basham
So you're really seeing this self-reinforcing cycle.
Georgia Howe
So COVID and politics are the biggest influences.
Megan Basham
Anything else driving this?
Georgia Howe
Yes, there is one more big category, and that's the degree to which these numbers are being impacted not by movement, but by a lack of new arrivals.
Megan Basham
And by that, I don't mean immigration. I mean babies.
Georgia Howe
So as we all know, Americans are having fewer children, and that is especially true for city dwellers.
Megan Basham
So we're hearing from some demographers that cities are going to become the playground of rich, childless professionals.
Georgia Howe
Well, the drop in birth rate is having an impact on many of the stories we covered.
Megan Basham
This is obviously no exception.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for bringing us this story, Megan.
Megan Basham
That was Daily Wire culture reporter, Megan Basham.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for listening to Morning Wire.
John Bickley
We created this show to bring more balance to the national conversation.
Georgia Howe
If you love our show and you stand with our mission, please consider subscribing, leaving us a five-star rating, and most importantly, sharing our podcast with a friend.
John Bickley
That's all the time we've got this morning.
Georgia Howe
Thanks for waking up with us.
John Bickley
We'll be back tomorrow with the news you need to know.