Main Topic: The importance of discerning truth from lies on social media platforms, particularly in the context of recent global events such as the conflict between Israel and Hamas, and the invasion of Ukraine by Russia.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Theme music fades out
John Bickley
Welcome to Morning Wire, I'm John Bickley, Editor-in-Chief of The Daily Wire.
Georgia Howe
And I'm Georgia Howe.
John Bickley
Today, we're talking about something that's really important, especially in the midst of all the chaos we're seeing in the world right now.
Georgia Howe
That's right. With conflicts like Israel's conflict with Hamas and Russia's invasion of Ukraine, it's more important than ever to be able to discern truth from lies on social media platforms.
John Bickley
And one of the places where misinformation is really targeting younger and more vulnerable audiences is TikTok.
Georgia Howe
That's right. So, we're joined today by an expert on identifying online influence operations and combating fake social media accounts.
John Bickley
Rafi Mendelson is the Vice President at Syabra, a social threat intelligence platform that works with governments and private companies to track conversations on social media and detect disinformation.
Rafi Mendelson
Welcome to Morning Wire, John and Georgia. I'm happy to be here.
John Bickley
So, Rafi, what does Syabra do, exactly?
Rafi Mendelson
We're a social threat intelligence platform. We work with governments and private companies to track conversations on social media, all publicly available information, and to be able to detect disinformation and threats across social media by analyzing the behavior of profiles and especially identifying fake accounts, bots, that exist across social media.
Georgia Howe
That sounds incredibly difficult to do. How do you figure out whether or not something is a fake account?
Rafi Mendelson
It's incredibly difficult, which is why no one else has really done it. The co-founders of the company come from the information warfare units of the Israeli Defense Force. And so this is the area that they worked in. And then five years ago when they created Syabra, they specifically set out to create a platform that is designed to analyze and identify the behaviors of malicious actors and so that we can see what's going on.
Georgia Howe
So, for example, you've worked with the U.S. State Department to identify foreign interference with elections. You work with large companies to track stock price manipulation or impersonations of companies or CEOs. And so you feel your platform uses machine learning algorithms to be able to detect the behaviors of accounts.
Rafi Mendelson
That's right. We don't look at content, right, where we analyze content for sentiment, but we don't say, oh, John has posted that the sky is red and actually he's not correct. What we're looking at is hundreds, between six to eight hundred different behavioral parameters to say, you know, is John behaving like an authentic person online? Are you posting 23 of the 24 hours of the day? Oh, okay, that's something that might flag up in our algorithms that allows us to say with confidence that this is an inauthentic profile.
Georgia Howe
Since October 7th, the Hamas attacks, what types of inauthentic behavior are you seeing and where is it coming from?
Rafi Mendelson
Wow. So since the 7th, as you can imagine, as a company, we've tracked times of war. We were very closely monitoring Russian bot networks when they invaded Ukraine. We monitor the US 2024 elections. We're finding a lot of fake accounts. This is what we do as a company. So when October the 7th happened, we started focusing our technology on this topic of conversation. And what we saw in terms of the scale of the fake accounts, the sophistication of the influence campaigns that were being run, the planning that went into this...
John Bickley
[interrupting] Rafi, can you tell us more about the scale of this? You mentioned that one in four conversations around the conflict were fake accounts in the first two days.
Rafi Mendelson
That's right. In the first two days, on the 7th and 8th of October, we identified that one in four, 25% of the conversation around the conflict had fake accounts. It was driven by fake accounts. And so as any war starts or as any global event starts nowadays, we go towards social media, right? We go to social media to see the news, to see the breaking news. We do as a population generally, journalists do, politicians do themselves. And one in four accounts involved in this conversation in the first two days was a fake account.
Georgia Howe
Is there a particular platform or platforms where this is particularly bad, rampant?
Rafi Mendelson
Well, we see it across all the main platforms. And I think the best way to think about it is that if you're a malicious actor, you're going to go where the eyeballs are. TikTok, because of the nature of video content and the way that you engage around you know different types of content and it tracks how long you spend how long you're engaging in one video or another and then it serves you more of the videos that it thinks that you like and with this kind of conflict even from the first day the amount of horrifying videos that were being shared around you know that is prone to abuse on X, on Twitter we see there are lots of fake accounts rife there but equally on you know on Facebook and Instagram we also see a really troubling activity there as well.
John Bickley
Do you feel like you've made progress in terms of weeding out some of this? Are things getting better or worse on this issue?
Rafi Mendelson
I wish that we could say that it's getting better. But unfortunately, I think we are still behind as a society, politicians being able to understand the true scale of what's happening here. There is a conversation to be had about free speech on social media, what people can say, how they say it, that's a conversation. But at Syabra, what we are particularly focused on is at least understanding who we are speaking to is actually a real person and not a bot or a troll or fake account.
Georgia Howe
In terms of individuals and how they operate online, do you have advice on how to recognize inauthentic behavior?
Rafi Mendelson
Absolutely. I think for the average consumer of social media I think the advice would definitely be to take another moment understand what you're seeing especially when some of these images and videos that we're seeing are so emotive and takes our breath away some of them in such a negative way. It's easy to be swept up by that. But taking a moment to really look at what we're seeing, but also as well, not just the content, but the profile itself. And then maybe take that time to go onto the profile. Or was this account created a week ago? Is it posting every few minutes? Is the behavior that it's showing authentic or inauthentic?
John Bickley
Final question, specifically about the war in Israel. What are some of the false narratives you saw coming out after the Hamas attack?
Rafi Mendelson
One of them in the very early days was a false narrative about the compassion and humanity that was being shown by the terrorists towards the hostages. And that was being pumped out in English. But another false narrative that we saw being pushed out by thousands of fake accounts was the accusation that the imagery of Israeli deaths were actually created using AI and that Israel had utilized AI-generated images following the Hamas attack.
Georgia Howe
Rafi, thank you so much for talking with us. That was Syabra Vice President Rafi Mendelson.
John Bickley
And this has been an extra edition of Morning Wire.