Main Topic: The podcast episode is a discussion between Kara Swisher and Will Hurd, a former CIA officer and Republican candidate for president, on various topics including his presidential campaign, the Republican Party's stance on abortion, the use of AI in politics, and the legal troubles of former President Donald Trump.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Kara Swisher
Not all journalism is the same. Take The Guardian. Our coverage has something unique. Fierce independence. Nobody owns us or tells us what we can and can't say. So we're free to report the whole picture. We connect what's happening in Washington to the rest of the globe. Expose corruption wherever we find it. And give fresh perspective on everything. From wellness and soccer to culture, the climate and more. Read, watch and listen to The Guardian for free at theguardian.com.
AI agents are getting pretty impressive. You might not even realize you're listening to one right now. We work 24-7 to resolve customer inquiries. No hold music, no canned answers, no frustration. Visit sierra.ai to learn more.
Hi, everyone. This is Pivot from New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network. I'm Kara Swisher. We're closing out a second week of Scott Free August. It's been a very enjoyable month so far. And my co-host today is former CIA officer and more recently a Texas congressman. He is currently a Republican candidate for president. Please welcome Will Hurd.
Will Hurd
Hi, Will. What's up, everybody?
Kara Swisher
Hey, Kara. Thanks for having me on. How are you doing?
Will Hurd
I'm doing wonderful. I'm glad Scott takes off for August so I get this opportunity.
Kara Swisher
Yeah, I know. The person who brought us together is Alyssa Farah, said you like Pivot and you have a lot to say. Apparently, you're running for president. We're going to talk about that and more. How are you doing otherwise? How's the campaign going?
Will Hurd
Look, it's exciting. I have to say, I just hired a new person and he's a huge super fan of yours. So much so that when we were last in Iowa, he rented us a Kia Sorento. And he's like, "You're going to be able to talk about this on the podcast."
Kara Swisher
I love the Kia Sorento. Did you hear what happened to my Kia Sorento?
Will Hurd
No, I do not know the story.
Kara Swisher
It got crushed by a tree in Washington during the storms.
Will Hurd
Oh, really? Your old haunts.
Kara Swisher
Yes, a tree fell on it. We'll see how it survives. I'm going to get another one, obviously.
Will Hurd
Well, I'm glad you weren't in the tree.
Kara Swisher
I was not in the tree. I went in the car. No, the Bolt survived. We moved the Bolt just the night before, and it would have also gotten crushed. But thank God the Bolt survived. So I have two unsexy cars that I think are very—I'm trying to bring sexy back to Bolts and Sorrentos.
Will Hurd
If anybody can do it, you can.
Kara Swisher
I can do it. So I want to talk about a lot of things, but how is your campaign going? Have you gotten more votes than Conor Roy yet?
Will Hurd
God, I don't even know. I don't even know the reference.
Kara Swisher
Oh, it's *Succession*. Oh, my God.
Will Hurd
You know what? Look, I've only seen a few episodes. Look, here's the thing. I'm a dark horse candidate. I recognize that. But what has been fascinating is every week we're getting better. I talk about how we're a startup. The way a startup works—look, you've forgotten more about startups than most people know—is have a good product market fit. We know who our customers are and who our customers aren't. And it's about growing at the right times. My most immediate issue is making sure I meet the requirements to get on the debate stage. And we're getting really close to that.
Kara Swisher
How close are you? It's like $40,000?
Will Hurd
It's $40,000.
Kara Swisher
I'll give you money. I gave money to Christie, so I'll give money to you to get you on.
Will Hurd
Well, look, I appreciate that.
Kara Swisher
Just $5, so don't feel that honored.
Will Hurd
Hey, $5 counts towards that $40,000. But look, it's been fun. It's been exciting. The message is slowly resonating. The goal is not to peak next week. The goal is to peak between Thanksgiving and Christmas. And guess what? I think America deserves a sane conservative party so that we can have a competition of ideas. And that's why we're doing it.
Kara Swisher
So talk about that a tiny bit. You were just appearing at a gathering, and you got booed. I thought you handled it rather well. You said, "Donald Trump is running to stay out of prison. And if we elect—I know, I know, I know. Listen, I know the truth. The truth is hard." What was that like? This was a group of Trump supporters. And obviously, you're not running for vice president like some of the people are because you're not going to get it. Just FYI. You've been critical, not quite as loud as Christie, or more colorfully as Christie. Talk a little bit about why you did that and how you handled that, because it's tough when a crowd's booing you like that.
Will Hurd
First and foremost, I've never bent the knee to Donald Trump. I've been that way since the very beginning. And I'm the only person in this race that can claim that title. Going in, this was a Lincoln Day dinner in Iowa. There were about 2,000 people, a lot of party activists. I knew that some people were not going to like my message. Ultimately, what I said was, "Donald Trump is not running for president to make America great. Donald Trump is not running for president to represent the people who voted for him in 2016 or 2020. Donald Trump is running for president to stay out of prison." And several people booed. But what was fascinating and what I was not expecting was that a lot of people clapped, and there were more people that sat with their hands folded and quiet. My message was to those folks that know that that is true and saying that it's okay. If we're afraid to tell the truth, even when telling the truth is uncomfortable, then we're never going to get out of this morass that we are currently in.
Kara Swisher
I would assume it was different in the room, but there was heavy booing. How do you deal with that? You handle it well. You're like, "Well, fine. You don't have to agree with me, but I'm telling you the truth," essentially.
Will Hurd
Look, we knew it was going to happen. When it started booing, it's like, "Hey, how do you calm the crowd down in order to finish?" It was at the end of my speech, so it was just calmly walk off. It's not a fun experience. But I go back to when I was a kid. I had messed up teeth until I was in high school. I had a speech impediment until I was in high school. My head has been this size since I was four years old. My mom—that's a fact. I had a big head and I wore a size 14 shoe. Back then, to get a shoe over 12, it was only red and it was big. And it wasn't cool back then to have red shoes. I'm half black, half white. I've gotten made fun of, I've gotten picked on a lot. So I have a thick skin, but knowing and thinking through what your options are when something like that happens. Guess what? I'd do it again. What happened was when I was at the airport the next day, people walked by and whispered, "Hey, thanks for being honest." I was at Walmart yesterday and some people came up and they're like, "Hey, Hurd, thank you for being honest."
Kara Swisher
Do you think it's resonating?
Will Hurd
It is. Slowly but surely, people are starting to see that. If more people—look, I've said this so many times. I'm not a political scientist. However, I have run and won some really tough elections. You don't win by kissing your opponent's butt. Why are these other Republicans doing this? Why is that?
Kara Swisher
Look, they're afraid of Donald Trump. They're afraid of his voters.
Will Hurd
And I'm sorry, if you can't stand up to Donald Trump, how are you going to be able to have a conversation and a debate with the current president of the United States? How are you going to be in a position with Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, dealing with President Lopez Obrador in Mexico? If you're afraid to speak the truth when we all know it, then I'm sorry, you're not fit to be president.
Kara Swisher
Do any of them believe? I will say that these are intelligent people. I go back to January 6th. I knew all of my colleagues. There were probably 15 people that actually thought the election was unfair. But everybody else knew that it was solid. So I don't understand why they're doing that. Anybody who thinks maybe they thought Donald Trump was going to pull out, be like, "Oh, these legal issues are too much. I got to back out." Or maybe he was going to have a heart attack. But why they're doing it, I don't know. It's not a winning strategy. And clones never win, especially when the original is still in.
Will Hurd
I think they thought he had shame, and he doesn't. That's the thing. They thought he'd call out. In any case, we have a lot to talk about today. Today, we'll talk about the special election in Ohio, which was a big sign for these people, I would imagine. What results mean for the GOP's campaign strategy. We'll also talk about Donald Trump's Twitter account and why special counsel Jack Smith got a search warrant for it, among other things. But first, we've been starting pretty much every show asking about *Barbie*. It's just crossed the billion-dollar mark. And message to Scott Galloway on vacation: That's a billion dollars from the woke people. You're welcome. Have you seen it?
Kara Swisher
I have. I've seen them both. I love movies. My wife, I'm recently married. We're in Q3 of marriage. Q3. Campaign's a startup. I'm in Q3 of marriage. The love fun is up and to the right. Romance. You love the romance. Hugely romantic, Will. She has probably seen 400 movies in her entire life. 398 of them have been with me. I love movies. So we saw *Oppenheimer* and *Barbie* on the weekend it came out. Thought they were both excellent movies. Anybody who's criticizing *Barbie* for empowerment is like, come on. It's about empowerment. You should be supportive of it. And it was funny. The concept was interesting.
I thought Michael Cera's character was pretty funny. I had never known that there was another—Alan, yeah. I didn't know there was an Alan doll. And working in the history of it was great. And *Oppenheimer*, I thought, look, I've read a lot of books on nuclear fission. Partly because of my involvement in artificial intelligence. I think AI and nuclear fission have some equivalent. Controlled, you have something amazing. Uncontrolled, you have something destructive. But I didn't know all the history about Oppenheimer after World War II. So I appreciated that frame. So, yeah, loved both.
Will Hurd
What were your thoughts?
Kara Swisher
Yeah, what were your thoughts? I loved it. I loved it. I think people, it's either just fun for people and then you can just take it away like that. I think it made fun of everybody. It made fun of feminism, made fun of men's movements. It made fun of just everybody, and just ridiculousness. But it was funny. It was lovely. You can take away anything you want from it. It was lovely. And *Oppenheimer* was substantive, a little long, but really good. Let me ask you a question, though. It's the 100th day of the writer's strike. And obviously, you have been a more tech-oriented congressman. How do you look at where they are? It's 100 days. There's obviously AI is a very big part of it.
Will Hurd
Sure. Look, I just put out a video about this. One of the issues, and I can't speak to the streaming residuals and all these issues. I'm of the opinion that if you have frames for something, just adapt them and edit them for the new thing. So I can't give you an authoritative or thoughtful issue there. But on one issue, facial rights. It's real simple. My face is my face. And guess what? Warner Brothers doesn't get to bring back Heath Ledger to play the Joker in *Batman 17*. Or new actors can't be AI models of old actors. And why should everybody care? Look, I know it's easy to kick Hollywood, depending on where you are. But guess what? I love movies, man. I love movies. Our culture, our soft power matters. Our culture, our music, our films, our TV shows, all that stuff has led to the greatness of America. But if a studio could do something like that with Heath Ledger, then guess what? They're going to screw my next door neighbor if it was beneficial. So I think one of the issues is around facial rights.
Kara Swisher
Which is what it is. It's kind of interesting because as we record this, the FEC is expected to vote on a ban on deepfakes in campaign ads. The ban would prevent candidates and political parties from deliberately misrepresenting their opponents with the use of AI. AI has already played a big role in the 2024 presidential election. When Joe Biden announced he would seek re-election, the RNC released a video made with AI depicting a dystopian future. Both the Trump campaign and the DeSantis campaign have produced videos using AI. And you yourself have struggled with it. An AI video was made altering your appearance on *The View* to suggest a guest told you to "shut the hell up." Here's what I think is important.
Will Hurd
[Audio clip plays] "Donald Trump is a threat to our national security. Oh, brother, please. We all know that the country and the world was more secure under Trump. So please just shut the hell up with a talking point for dummies."
Kara Swisher
They could have, but they didn't. They clapped. They clapped. That was not one where I got booed. That was definitely one where they clapped. Look, Donald Trump is a threat to our national security. So you've placed AI at the forefront of your campaign. Should the FEC be regulating this, or who should if you were still in Congress? And will banning candidates and parties, not just Hollywood, from using AI help when everyday citizens can create misleading material as well?
Will Hurd
Sure. So the FEC has their clear roles and guidance on political advertising. Being narrow on political advertisement and things that can and cannot do, I think that is fine within the FEC's purview. When it comes to broader deepfakes in our systems, talking about the why, what systems and what critical infrastructure these should not be allowed, how platforms should be using deepfake detection. The reality is there are a number of companies that are working on how you detect deepfakes, and they're all pretty good. Making sure that if I share something on Twitter, or whatever it's called today, that that photo was doctored or that video was doctored, and something more than just basic editing. The technology exists. And I think there should be a conversation about how those platforms deploy that.
Kara Swisher
Do you worry about it as a candidate and a longtime politician? Is it something that will become so deceptive that it's impossible to know who's telling the truth?
Will Hurd
So I've had millions of dollars of negative advertising dropped on my head. Whether someone lies in a mail piece that's coming to someone's door, or they lie in a video, the concepts are ultimately the same. But it requires us to be able to educate and have a way to hit back. I think when it comes to political advertising, the ability for super PACs and outside interests to incredibly juice this to potentially have an overwhelming opposition. So a million people thought I got booed on stage, which in that case, because I know how it positively helped me in Iowa, I'm okay with it. But these are difficult issues to deal with.
What I think Congress should be doing, in a broader sense, let's start with saying AI needs to follow the law. We have a lot of rules on civil liberties and civil rights. Let's make sure those apply. Let's not have a carve out for AI. What we know about social media now, we would not have carved it out of the Communications Decency Act a couple of decades ago. Young women, because of images they're seeing, are leading them to cutting themselves. That's not acceptable. And this probably would not have happened if the same rules that radio and TV had at the time would have applied. That may not be enough, but it's a start.
Kara Swisher
Is Congress as up to speed as they need to be? You were one of the—I'm trying to think, I could name Ken Buck has gotten pretty good, David Cicilline, who's left, was good. In the House, in the Senate, obviously, there's quite a few: Klobuchar, Warner, Bennet. There's some. I'm trying to think on the Republican side. My homie from Nashville.
Will Hurd
Marsha? Senator Blackburn.
Kara Swisher
Sometimes. I agree. I agree. She understands. She understands. There's probably disagreements on other things, but she understands.
Will Hurd
Here's what I would say. She never misses an opportunity to politicize it when she could be sensible. That's all I'm saying. It's like, just talk about the danger and you don't have to then throw in a "And by the way, Hillary Clinton's emails." But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
These are the views of Kara Swisher, not the co-host. No, I'm joking. I'm joking. You know what I mean. It's a serious enough issue that we don't need to muck it up with stupid partisanship. Let's focus on the things we agree on. I've always said way more unites us than divides us. I will say this. I was pretty shocked by the hearings that Blumenthal and Josh Hawley are doing. Look, if you wanted to find complete opposites, it's Blumenthal and Hawley. And they're asking some of the right questions. Now, can that turn into execution? That's the real question.
Will Hurd
That's what I mean. Yeah. You have to be nonpartisan on this stuff. But here is the problem. Why do we not have a privacy standard in the United States? Why is Europe—I'm going to tell you. I know. Why is Europe 24 to 36 months ahead of us when it comes to regulation on technologies? We should be the one driving the world. The reason is behind closed doors, all outside groups and supporters say, "Yeah, we should have a privacy law." But then behind closed doors, the financial community says something very different, and retailers come in and say something very different. That's what prevents a privacy standard from happening. Those two organizations and members of Congress are unwilling, they're not smart enough on these issues to come in and say, "Hey, here's the decision I'm going to make. And here's a side I'm going to come down on." So I think AI is early enough in it being an issue that we could potentially have some regulations.
Kara Swisher
OK. All right. We'll see. Well, speaking of which, Dianne Feinstein is back home after a brief hospital visit following a fall. A spokesperson said the fall was "minor" and that all of her scans were clear. Just weeks ago, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell froze during a press conference. And Donald Trump and Joe Biden are 77 and 80 respectively. A lot of these people do not understand tech, and I'm not going to focus just on tech. What is your take on these aging representatives? Should there be a maximum age to serve? And if we leave the decisions to the politicians themselves, do we hurt constituents?
Will Hurd
Well, look, so—
Kara Swisher
How old are you? You're how old?
Will Hurd
I'm 45. I turn 46 next week. And I left. I walked away. I had been asked, "Do I support term limits?" And I said early on, I don't. I was like, because guess what? Vote somebody out. And I always said, you don't have to die or be defeated to leave Congress. And I walked away. The 2020 election would have been my biggest win and biggest victory. Publicly traded companies force CEOs to walk out at a certain time. So I can make an argument for. I also think it's slightly self-indulgent for me to be like, "Yeah, these people are too old." I think it's for the next generation to actually take. If I'm president and Congress put something on my desk, of course I would sign it.
If I was still in Congress, I would probably vote for it. So we should be looking at whether there is a disproportional advantage for incumbents to stay in office. And I think maybe looking at that. But age is going to be an issue. I do not wish Senator McConnell any ill will. I'm glad they're all doing better. But yes, I think people that do not have an understanding of these issues and people that are making decisions about the future need to be the ones living in that future. Age is going to be an issue, especially in the 2024 election. My father is 90. We lost my mother this year. I think the best person to comment on this was Jimmy Carter.
Jimmy Carter said, "I've been 80 and I've been president, and you can't do both at the same time." So this is going to be an issue. It's going to be a big issue.
Kara Swisher
All right. Let's get to our first big story. Abortion rights activists won a decisive victory in Ohio this week. In a special election, voters rejected a Republican-backed measure known as Issue One, which would have made it harder to change the state constitution. It would have shifted it from a simple majority of 50% to 60%. This November, an amendment to enshrine abortion rights in that constitution will be on the ballot. They were trying to avoid that, although they tried to make it broader. This was a landslide defeat. The resolution lost by a 57% to 43% margin. The voter turnout was incredibly high, higher than the midterm election, I believe. There have been six other statewide abortion-related ballot initiatives since Roe versus Wade was overturned, and every one so far, abortion rights have won. There's going to be more efforts, and this seems to work. So what do you think the message is here for your party?
Will Hurd
Well, look, the message is this is going to continue to be an issue. And it obviously is not a winning issue. I'm pro-life, but I also think there's a lot of agreement with exceptions. I'm for exceptions, and most people think that abortion shouldn't happen after 15 weeks unless there's a life of the mother issue. So I think that's an area we can all cooperate on. I also believe that if you are a state that has these serious restrictions, you need to make sure it's clear that when it comes to the life of the mother, there have been some examples here in Texas where a woman was forced to carry a basically dead child. I can't fathom the mental anguish of that. But if you are going to be a state that has these laws, then your maternal health in that state needs to be first class. Neonatal health needs to be first class. The fact that in many parts of the country, if you're a black woman that has a child, the maternal death rates are worse than in some developing worlds. To me, it's 2023 and the greatest country on the planet. When women are pregnant, they should not have an increased likelihood for death. This is where some of the messaging and where the party should ultimately be.
Kara Swisher
So you said that if Congress put a 15-week ban on your desk as president, you would sign it. You added that if states are restricting this, those states could also have the best neonatal health, best maternity health care. They don't do that. They're very zeroed in on six weeks, six weeks, and they don't care about the born babies or the mothers that are carrying these children. How do you win in this situation? It's both cruel and also cruel to the people that are involved in it, story after story after story. It's a losing issue, a political issue, too.
Will Hurd
Well, I think you don't win. That's what Ohio and Kansas and even Montana suggest. What was fascinating to me before this Ohio vote, there were several polls that said, "Oh, this is going to be close. This is going to be tight." All the senior Republicans in the state thought this was going to turn out. And this was an ass-kicking, pardon my language. So for me, let's start looking at what voters are actually saying and not looking at the polling. Ohio is—everybody still kind of thinks of it as a swing state. It's a red state. All the senior leaders are Republicans. And you got to remind that Trump won Ohio. So this is an issue. Why go down this lemming-like, the tyranny of the minority in this case? They aren't listening to voters. They may be running the state, but the voters don't seem to think they are. And why take away voters' rights?
Kara Swisher
To me, it's like abortion rights people seem to be broadly in favor of much looser ones for sure. And they keep doing this. What's within the GOP that will not stop in this? It's a suicide march in a lot of ways, politically.
Will Hurd
There's also an issue here about overreach for government. People are getting frustrated with that. Book bannings. People are getting frustrated with book bannings, whether you're a Republican governor in Florida or a Democratic governor in California telling businesses what they can and can't think or what they can or can't support. People are getting frustrated by that. And I think there's another vein there. A lot of stuff I talk about is the vision of the Republican Party I want to see, the vision of the Republican Party that I subscribe to. This issue about local control is something that Republicans have gotten really far away from. When you look at some of the numbers and why these ballot initiatives fail, it's because there are a lot of people that are conservative leaning that are like, "Hey, this is not the government's responsibility or role in here. So stay out of it."
Kara Swisher
Right. Stay out of it. So if it's not a winning issue—abortion is not a winning issue for the GOP. It clearly isn't. They're taking a lot of lumps for it. Can the party realize that and pivot? Or are you captive of these much more, I would say, cruel people because of the impact? People aren't listening to voters, what voters say. There's not one poll that says voters do not want some level of abortion rights.
Will Hurd
Look, I would say when a guy like Mike Pence is able to say, "Hey, 15 weeks makes sense," and nobody's going to question Mike Pence's conservative evangelical roots. When he can say that and it gets applause at a conservative crowd, I think maybe that isn't—I don't know if I'd consider that a pivot. But I think that's a sign that there's something potentially different or where we can find some areas of agreement.
Kara Swisher
So is that going to happen? You've got a very short amount of time.
Will Hurd
Look, I can't speak to that. The fact that I can tell you what I say and what I talk to people and people appreciate the perspective. What everybody else is going to be focused on doing, that's up to them. Where the broader party ends up on this issue, I don't know. I always talk about pro-life. You should care about life. It's fine. I got to stop talking about all the times I got booed. One of the first times I had a crowd really upset with me is because I said I was against the death penalty. And this was a Republican primary electorate. I'm like, "Well, if you're pro-life, you should be pro-life all the way through. You should care about kids in cages on the border. You should care about life at all times." For me, being ideologically consistent is one of the more important things. And that's how the party can continue to grow in larger groups of voters.
Kara Swisher
Do you think this is something they'll pull? Because they seem to be doubling down on book bans, attacking trans people, and strict, ridiculously cruel and strict abortion laws. Seems like a prescription for loss all over the place. And then you'll get exactly what you don't want.
Will Hurd
Sure. Look, here's it's real simple. Donald Trump. What I can make an argument is the authoritarian wing of the Republican Party is a loser. He hasn't won since 2016. We lost the House in 2018. And in 2020, we lost the Senate and the White House. The lesson of 2020 was real simple: Don't be a jerk and don't be a socialist. The reason Joe Biden won with absolutely no coattails was because people like Donald Trump's a jerk. But all this other stuff, the defund the police and defund ICE and all that kind of stuff, people are like, "No, no, no. We're not having that." That's why people voted for Joe Biden for president and a Republican as a member of Congress. So yeah, I would agree with your concept. But the way the Republican Party—and again, I know you like President Biden, but there's a lot of Democrats that don't. And there's a real opportunity. There's a real opportunity for a Republican. And everybody's like, "Well, Will, how do you have the GOP be palatable to independents and conservative Democrats?" Guess what?
Don't be a jerk. Don't be a racist. Don't be a homophobe. Don't be a misogynist. Seems pretty hard.
Kara Swisher
It seems pretty hard. I really do hope you're getting through.
Will Hurd
Listen, you'd be surprised who I vote for. I vote for a lot of different people. I do like reasonable people. I was very out front liking Biden when everyone else was in love with Beto, who I thought was a man boy, a silly man boy. But in any case, and some people too liberal in many ways.
Kara Swisher
Anyway, well, let's go on a quick break. When we come back, we'll talk about the latest on the Trump indictments, how the company formerly known as Twitter got involved. We're going to keep calling it Twitter, by the way.
Ad Break
Well, we're back for our second big story, the latest news of former President Donald Trump's legal troubles, of which there's more coming up next week, apparently. First off, the government apparently obtained a search warrant for this past January for data and records related to at real Donald Trump Twitter account. Twitter was reportedly barred from even telling Trump about the warrant. The company missed the deadline to produce the records and ended up paying a $350,000 fine for that delay. That's not so weird to me. Twitter was always slow in terms of giving things over the government. But what do you think they were looking for, Will? Here are some theories someone sent me. One, to see he had secret accounts. Two, to see what devices he was posting from. Three, to see the DMs on main and secret accounts. And four, to see drafts of tweets or perhaps even tweets that Twitter refused to post or that he refused to post, which is interesting. How do you feel about this?
Will Hurd
Look, so I think this is the prosecutors trying to better understand his intentions. My understanding of Donald Trump's habits is I don't think he's a big texter or emailer. He would always print stuff out and write stuff on with a Sharpie. The draft texts may show his ability and how he was trying to coordinate. And it supports this narrative of intent, but also conspiracy. It's funny, Bill Barr always reminds people, the conspiracy starts when you agree to do it. It's not that you were successful in it. So I think there will be some evidence to suggest coordination with some of those other groups. January 6th started with Donald Trump putting a tweet out. To me, all of these cases are serious. I've spent a little bit more time focusing on the classified document one, partly because I spent a decade as an undercover officer in the CIA overseas collecting intelligence.
Kara Swisher
So how do you look at that?
Will Hurd
There are two questions I would love Donald Trump to ask. And if I got on the debate stage, I would ask these questions. Why did he want to keep those documents? When he was told, "You got classified stuff, you need to turn it back." Just turn it back. We would not be in this situation if he'd given them back. Why was he holding them? Well, they're his. They're his beautiful paper. You had your golf shirts in it. I get it. But there's another reason for those specific documents. Why do you give some back, but not all of them? Why were you holding those? Two, the Secret Service's responsibility is to protect Donald Trump and his family.
It is not to protect documents or classified information. That is Donald Trump's responsibility. The fact that Donald Trump willingly knew he had classified documents in an unsecure environment, what did he do in order to protect access to them? To vet employees? He's never explained. We all know the Russians and the Chinese are sophisticated and trying to get access to them. Whether they got access to them or not, I can't speak to that. I have not seen evidence that was the case, but that doesn't mean it wasn't potential. Explain why you had access to those things that talked about our capabilities with our overhead architecture, our satellites.
Kara Swisher
Because you were in the middle of that in your job.
Will Hurd
I was in the middle of it. Look, I'm the only person in this race that's been shot at, chased, tried to be blown up, been in places that were overrun by folks. And it's a slap in the face to the thousands of men and women who are putting themselves in harm's way every single day and every single night for us to be safe and to enjoy the freedoms we enjoy. To me, that part is outrageous.
Kara Swisher
Why do you think he did it? And why do you think he didn't protect them and handed it over to the pool guy, essentially?
Will Hurd
I think he didn't protect them because he didn't value the importance of this. I think he was incapable of understanding the importance of the materials he had. I just think he's deficient in that.
Kara Swisher
Or he didn't care about putting people in danger.
Will Hurd
Yeah. And it's a hubris to think, "Oh, nothing's going to happen to this." But why he wanted them, I don't know. Look, he wanted them. I'm not a Donald Trump psychologist. But we know the one example of when he shared some of the war plans. He wanted to brag. If he's bragging to the author of his staffer's biography, who else is he bragging to? That's why he had them. He had them for props. To me, that's unforgivable. That means you're unfit for office. We should all be horrified, especially at a time when our adversaries are laughing. The Chinese government is laughing. The Russians are thankful all of this stuff is happening. And our allies are horrified.
Kara Swisher
Horrified, yeah.
Will Hurd
Horrified. The Chinese were just hacking the Japanese too. They're hacking the United States government. You've seen the stats about the zero-day attacks that have happened in the last year. All the new ones were from the Chinese to the defense industrial base. The Chinese are trying to surpass us as a global superpower. This is not my opinion, it's what they say about themselves. They're going to do that by being a leader in a number of advanced technologies, and they're showing a level of aggression at all levels, from diplomacy to cyber attacks. And we're having debates about whether we should ban books or have classified documents in your loo.
Kara Swisher
Right. And the answer to both those questions is no. Let's get on to the next topic. So let me say the indictments besides this one that are coming. There is the one in Georgia, where the DA in Atlanta is expected to present her findings from an investigation into Trump's alleged election interference. She does have tape of him saying it, which seems to be a problem for him. Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis is reportedly aiming for conspiracy and racketeering. They have very broad racketeering laws in Georgia. Just a reminder, there are three other criminal cases: the January 6th and 2020 election inquiry, the classified documents case — and I agree, it's incredibly depressing and heinous — and the Manhattan hush money case, which everyone's forgotten about at this point.
86% of Republicans in a CBS poll believe these indictments and investigations have political motives to disrupt Trump's campaign. I talked to Frank earlier in the week, and he said the polls go up when these things happen. This fourth one, he said, will put him over the top. But it's putting him over the top with people who are a small minority and not able to make the presidency. Perhaps you don't even want them to be president. So that's a good thing. Obviously, you don't. How positive is this for Trump and how ultimately negative is it? Because I think it's ultimately negative.
Will Hurd
So I think this — again, I'm not a lawyer — the Georgia case is one of the clearest issues because we have the call. We all heard the phone call of Donald Trump asking a state employee to commit a crime that he knew was a crime. That's pretty clear to me. Here is where polling is a snapshot in time. It's a very narrow insight. Would most Republicans think Joe Biden and everybody associated with him hate Donald Trump? Yeah, of course. Would they think there's some political activism here? I can see why they say that. But is that going to translate 25 weeks from now into them voting for Donald Trump? Ultimately, when you juxtapose national polling with some of the state polling, Donald Trump is probably going to get 30% of the Republican primary voters, no matter what. Their rider dies. They're going with him. They got the hats. They got the T-shirts. No matter what happens.
Kara Swisher
They're like Taylor Swift fans, but really rancid.
Will Hurd
But go ahead.
Kara Swisher
I don't know if she'd appreciate being compared. She would beat him in elections. Barbie and T. Swift are keeping the economy going.
Will Hurd
That's right. $1 billion, that's crazy.
Kara Swisher
It's the feminists. Girl power is keeping everyone going.
Will Hurd
For me, this is what I always ask people. Let's do this thought experiment. Who is the independent or conservative Democrat that voted for Joe Biden in 2020 and then in 2024 is like, "You know what? Donald J. Trump's my guy"? That doesn't exist. All the polling that shows Trump is tight — he's old, but I guess I can't — for that group of people, I'm going to hold my nose. This is what I keep telling Republicans. If the GOP nominates Donald Trump as our nominee, we are willingly giving four more years to Joe Biden. And by the way, I don't mean this in a derogatory way. He literally campaigned from his basement and he still beats you. Come on.
Kara Swisher
You notice he's not saying much. He's biking around and sitting on the beach. Every time he says nothing, his polls go up. Biden said nothing. It makes no sense.
Will Hurd
Ultimately, I also think the path — all of these court cases, no one is above the law. For those that want to criticize and bring up Hunter Biden, the person who's going to prosecute that case is someone who's been indicted like 90 times? That makes no sense if that's something you care about. The pathway is there are a lot of Republicans that once we start getting into the winter, people start paying attention to the election and are going to say, "I voted for Donald Trump twice, but he's got too much baggage and we need to look somewhere else." Also, the fact that Ron DeSantis has basically stumbled and is faltering. If your name is not Trump, I think your chances are pretty much equal in this Republican primary.
Kara Swisher
That's what you're hoping for. Can I say very briefly, because we've got to get going, but why do you think DeSantis has stumbled so much?
Will Hurd
I think, as you know, I think he's charmless.
Kara Swisher
Do you remember when Obama said Hillary Clinton was "likable enough"? Remember that? It worked, no matter how you slice it. I think he's unlikable enough. I've always thought he's charmless and strange.
Will Hurd
That's a good title for his book.
Kara Swisher
The wife, I would possibly take a look. The wife is charming, but not him.
Will Hurd
Look, when you're more interested in fighting my friends in the LGBTQ community than you are Vladimir Putin, we got a problem. When you think Cinderella is a bigger national security threat than a president storing documents in his bathroom, then we have a problem. There's no upside to slavery. If you want to come in and defend it and be like, "I didn't write it, it's not my fault," that's not leadership. Change the phrase to be like, "Listen, that was not our intention. I'm going to call everybody back."
Kara Swisher
He doubles down.
Will Hurd
Fix that wording. It's that simple. Then you hire a guy, a known neo-Nazi — or let me not be hyperbolic, I think he was an anti-Semite — and he knew that in advance. Then all the anti-LGBTQ stuff. That's called a pattern. I think those are all the reasons he's failing. Oh, and Republicans don't like authority trying to concentrate power in the hands of the few and telling businesses how they can and cannot think.
Kara Swisher
So that's it. So everybody's got a chance if Trump stumbles at some point or the penny suddenly drops with everybody.
Will Hurd
Yeah, or it's taken.
Kara Swisher
That's our thesis. I do think you're right. I think everyone has a chance. I think it'll be interesting to see who pulls forward. But I think Trump is going to stumble. Ultimately, he doesn't want to spend the rest of his life in prison. So we'll see. This is my calculation: He's got to win, which he's not going to do unless something incredible happens. So he's got to hope a Republican who'll give him a pardon wins, which is not a certainty. It's pretty much just Vivek and that guy, whatever he is, and DeSantis. Nobody else. Everyone else is like, "Pardon? Probably not." Or he's going to jail. It may be at Mar-a-Lago with a bracelet on his leg, but he's not going anywhere. He could make a fake presidential office at Mar-a-Lago and pretend he's president the rest of his life. That's the best choice for him. Anyway, Will, we've got one more quick break. We'll be back for predictions. Do you have a good prediction?
Will Hurd
We'll see.
Ad Break
Kara Swisher
2024 NBA champions are my San Antonio Spurs because of Wemby.
Will Hurd
And number three. Why is it sports with you people? Luntz was talking about the Orioles, but go ahead. Move along. Move along. That cat, the Harvard professor that took all that metal out of the ocean because he thought it was going to prove extraterrestrial life. I don't think the final analysis is going to be clear that was it.
Kara Swisher
You don't believe in UFOs?
Will Hurd
I didn't say that. I just think those pebbles he got out of the ocean are not going to be the definitive case that there's something else.
Kara Swisher
It's time for the aliens to show up now. Just about now. Like, "Okay, that's enough humanity. We've been watching you and we're tired."
Will Hurd
My big brother is a big Star Trek fan. I forget which Star Trek it was, but they're talking about the history of the world and it was like there was world peace on Earth when aliens showed up.
Kara Swisher
That's right. Because we all band together to hate something else. It's called First Contact. There was a whole movie about it. Great movie. Arrival is another good one. We need a first contact. Either it's got to be a simulation that we realize and it's over and some teenagers are getting sick of us, or aliens need to get here immediately. What would you say if you're president? What would you say to the aliens if they showed up? What would be your first message as President Will Hurd?
Will Hurd
I'd be like, "Let's work together. Let's find — I'm going to say what I always say — we can find way more to unite us than divide us."
Kara Swisher
What if they want to eat us?
Will Hurd
Well, then if they want to eat us, be like, "Let's hope these —"
Kara Swisher
"To Serve Man." It's a cookbook.
Will Hurd
Yeah. "I don't know if y'all have nuclear weapons where you come from, but we can shoot ours into space."
Kara Swisher
That was the plot of Independence Day, I think. Anyway, what's your prediction?
Will Hurd
Yeah. I think the writers and Hollywood strikes are going to possibly go on to January 15th, at least.
Kara Swisher
I thought several people were thinking October 14th, maybe, but certainly not. Now that it's August, they're all on vacation.
Will Hurd
What's the specific date? How are you able to —?
Kara Swisher
Because they have to really ruin next summer for them if they don't get working by January. I think everyone will feel the pressure by then. I think writers and actors will be out of work and they can only do so many cameos, the actors, which is what a lot of them are doing right now to make money. They can do ads and cameos pretty much, or not very — I don't even think they can do ads. So I think the financial pressure on writers — it's a hundred days today. I think it's real. And I think yelling at Bob Iger saying he makes too much money is just not going to work after a while. Ultimately it doesn't work. So I think they'll have to come to an agreement. And I think the studios, that's when the studios really have pressure because they're doing well because they're saving money right now. It's good for their bottom line. There's plenty of content, but if they really go to January, they'll have problems with summer kind of thing. So we'll see. That's when they'll push. What's your sports prediction?
Will Hurd
I don't have any.
Kara Swisher
I don't watch sports, Will Hurd. I'm the only lesbian in America who hates sports, which is the way it is. I'm sorry. I hate it. I have sporty sons. They both are very athletic. I have to go to all these events, and I hate every one of them. If I look at my phone, my sons clock it and say, "Put down your phone." So it's hell. And now my third son, who is only one and a half, seems to like sports, which is a real problem. So, you know, I do me. I really don't like sports. I don't even like Megan Rapinoe kicking. I like Megan Rapinoe, by the way, as opposed to — and by the way, Megan Rapinoe, good for you with an amazing career, even if you didn't make that last kick.
Astonishing athlete. I still didn't watch it. It doesn't matter. Anyway, and she's a lesbian. You think I would, but I don't. In any case, there we have it. Will, thank you so much. I love people being on the debate stage. You're a highly intelligent person who should be talking about issues like AI and reasonability, I guess, being reasonable. And you're sort of the nicer Chris Christie, essentially. I think he's effective. He keeps going. He's good. He's a former prosecutor, so he should be. I do think people need to be able to debate on the stage, especially the Republican Party, and bring people to their senses.
Because I do like divided government myself and I like lots of points of view. So I really do hope you give him a dollar. I am going to go do that right now.
Will Hurd
You said $5. You said you'd give him $5.
Kara Swisher
They give him $1, you give $5. I gave Christie $5, I'll give you $5. Do not make me give Vivek Ramaswamy anything. There's things I'd like to give him we're not supposed to say. Anyway, I will read us out and thank you so much and good luck with your campaign. Today's show was produced by Lara Naiman and Taylor Griffin. Ernie Enderdot engineered this episode. Make sure you subscribe to the show wherever you listen to podcasts. Thanks for listening to Pivot from New York Magazine and Vox Media. We'll be back next week for another breakdown of all things tech and business with some new, fresh people, including Don Lemon is coming on next week. So that should be interesting. Thank you so much, Will. Thanks for coming.
Will Hurd
Thanks for having me on. Thank you.