Animals have had legal protection from unnecessary harm since the 19th century. Yet what harm is necessary is open to interpretation and animals continue to suffer and die for science and commerce. Should they have the right to freedom from humans?
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. There's Charles W. Chuck Bryant. I'm Jerry, and this is Stuff You Should Know, part two. Yeah. About animals. A rare sweet. Yeah. A good one. And you wrote this for your buddies at Primer. Yeah, yeah. Let's give a little shout out to Primer Stories. So Primer Stories are basically doing for the interactive medium the same thing that podcasts did for radio and TED Talks did for speaking engagements.
Wow. And I wrote an essay for them for season four, and you can check it out at primerstories.com slash S-Y-S-K. Go check it out. It's pretty neat, but it ties into animal rights and humans. But you did put this together, correct? Right. I put together this episode and then I wrote a separate essay based on my research that is different. Nice. I'm Josh Clark and I did my book report on Moby Dick. Yeah. Luckily, the primer dudes, Joe and Tim, kept it from devolving into that. Well, this was fantastic. I just want to say that. Well done. Thanks, man. I appreciate it. So I guess we don't need to set anything up.
If you haven't listened to the one on animal testing. Yeah, stop right here. Yeah, just go do that. Yeah. And then welcome to part two. Yeah. How awkward was that? I thought it was pretty succinct. Oh, okay. Not awkward. So tell me a little bit about your buddy Aristotle. So Aristotle, we mentioned him in the last episode. We're going to say that a lot. Yeah. But Aristotle was one of the first dudes to experiment on animals. I think I called him a big dummy. You did. As a joke. Yeah. Sort of. Yeah. No, he's fine. Yeah. He was a smart dude. He was. But one of the things that he did, not only experimenting on animals, he also came up with a hierarchy of animals.
Based on the souls he anticipated each possessed. He said, kitty cat, pretty good. Dog, much better. What is that? Is it Czechoslovakian? I have no idea. No, I guess it would just be Czech now. Yeah. I don't know what that was. Unless he was from like the 50s. It was not Greco-Roman. Okay. Maybe Albanian. Sure. Okay. So Aristotle the Albanian comes up with this hierarchy. And at the top of the hierarchy, guess who? Humans. Yeah, of course. And humans have all three kinds of souls. The vegetative soul, the sensitive soul, and the rational soul. Yes. We possess all three of those souls. Therefore, we're at the top of the hierarchy of all the organisms on planet Earth.
Below us are animals. And they've got the first two. They've got the vegetative soul and the sensitive soul, which means that they like to lay around and read romance novels. That's right. And then you've got plants, and plants obviously have the vegetative soul. So what he's describing are the different, I guess, life forces that he expected organisms to have. And because of that, there was a hierarchy that was established. And because of that hierarchy that Aristotle came up with, we still view animals in a certain way today. Yeah. Like we still basically follow that same hierarchy that he made 2,500 years ago or so.
Yeah, and the whole kind of point of this episode is kind of based on that, whether or not animals have a soul and where they rank or maybe should rank. Yeah. And I started going down the rabbit hole myself of what a soul is, and a human even. Well, you're not the first to do that. I know, of course. Yeah. What did you come up with? Oh. What did you come up with? Everyone wants to hear, including me and Jerry. Nah, I don't know. I'm still struggling with what I believe, even at my advanced age, and I think I will until the day I die. Probably. And become worm dirt. Right. So that's one indication of what I believe.
Your last words are, oh, no. But that idea of whether or not animals do have souls is nothing new. You point out very astutely that Judeo-Christian-wise, they do not think that animals have souls. No, and even have long held kind of a brutal attitude toward animals, like forget animals. Just kick them in the face. I don't care. That's a little harsh, but the idea that humans have dominion over animals is very much a part of the Judeo-Christian ethic. Yeah, and should have dominion. Yeah, and that animals don't have souls, and that's one reason why humans have dominion. That's right. It turns out the Mormons actually are one of the few groups in the West, religiously speaking, that do believe that animals survive into the afterlife.
Really? Uh-huh. Mormons and then Sikhs, Muslims, Hindus, big time Hindus. Sure. And Jains, Jainists. Uh-huh. They believe that the best way to save your soul is to protect other souls. So you'll see a Janus with a little, they have little brooms, and they'll brush off a seat before they sit on it because they don't want to accidentally sit on any bug and take its life. Boy, that's nice. That's protection of other souls for sure. Not like the cockroach. Right. They'll still kill a cucaracha. Oh, man. I had a funny cockroach incident last night. I laughed, belly laughed for 10 minutes. Did the cockroach laugh?
Well, there was a cockroach in the room at some point that got away. And later on that night, Emily and I were in bed, and I was on my computer, and she was reading or something. And she looked up, and on the ceiling, it was right above her, and she went, oh, there's that cockroach, which I was shocked that she was that laissez-faire about it. Right. I went, why are you not freaking out? I was like, that thing's about to fall on you. And right when I said you, he moved and fell right on her. And it's so funny. Like she shrieked like a small child and jumped off the bed quicker than I've ever seen her move.
Scared my dogs. I jumped and ran, but I didn't shriek, which I just thought was a very interesting dichotomy. And I killed it. And it was just very, very funny that she was just like, oh, there's that cockroach. Like, who are you? You're not the Emily I know. Right, exactly. Like, why aren't you running? Was she super tired or something? She was, but yeah, it's just very strange. I think she learned her lesson that a cockroach on the ceiling is not on the ceiling for long. It means you roll out a bet. Yeah, immediately. So anyway, that's my cockroach story. That's a good one. Judaism, they believe that, well, it's a lot of debate in the Jewish community.
Some scholars say that they do have souls. Yeah, lately they've been saying that. But only here while they're alive and they don't carry it into the afterlife. Big workaround. Yeah. It is. Sure. Pope John Paul II said, yeah, you probably are going to see your little dog in the afterlife, maybe. It's possible. I'm Pope John Paul. Everybody loves me. Would you like my autograph? Right. Me, Gorby, and Ronald Reagan rule the world. During the Enlightenment, things changed a little bit from the religious aspects to more of a science-based or philosophical. and our old buddy Descartes said animals have no internal experience, which is a very cold way of putting it.
Yeah, he called them automatons. Yeah. Kind of famously, actually, and he said that they are capable of responding to pain, but because they don't have any internal experience, they can't actually experience the pain. And therefore, when you are cutting open a live dog and you're seeing it squirm and writhe in agony, it's strictly responding to a stimulus. Right. It's not actually going on. Like when Luke is testing out his new hand. He's poking the different nerves or the artificial nerves or whatever, making the fingers move. Yeah, he's getting poked on the finger, but he doesn't feel that.
It's just a response to a stimuli. Yeah, I guess very much like that. It's the same thing as like with robots, too. Yeah. I mean, that's how essentially Descartes decreed that animals were. And that's something that stuck out to me like throughout researching this whole thing. Humans have long just decreed that things are a certain way. And that those decrees tend to fit whatever the human wants to do to an animal at that time. Of course. Right? Yeah. That idea is sort of the basis was and still kind of is for scientists who experiment on animals. They're trained to detach themselves emotionally and just say, no, this is just a stimuli reaction.
This is not an animal that's actually feeling pain. Right. Dogs don't have internal experience or internal lives, so you can't really feel pain or suffering. Yes, which is not true. Jeremy Bentham was a philosopher in England, correct? Yeah, a big one. And actually, he's still around. They bring his mummified body out for dinners of the guys who run the college. What? Every once a year. And he sits at the head of the table. And his head has actually been separated from his body. And they bring that out, too. It's in a case. It's pretty cool. Holy cow. Yeah, as far as philosophers go, it's pretty neat.
So he had a pretty neat idea, which was, you know what, it's not just about whether you can reason with an animal, but can they suffer? He's the one that kind of brought about this idea of animals suffering in the same way that a human might. Which was a huge change. Sure. It was a big sea change in the way that we saw animals because up to that point, the idea was that animals couldn't suffer. And even if they could suffer, nobody was taking that into account. But they couldn't suffer because they couldn't talk or they couldn't rationalize. And he said, no, I think they can suffer. And he used his philosophic calculus, which takes into account all of the suffering and all of the happiness or pleasure produced by an event.
And you weigh it against one another. And it's really involved, actually. But if you carry out Bentham's calculations, you can take any event, any action, and determine whether it's ethically morally correct or morally repugnant. And he came to the conclusion that experimenting on animals was morally repugnant because animal suffering wasn't taken into account. And he took it into account. And it wasn't just a one-off where he wrote an essay about it. This is a well he went back to a lot. and was kind of an agitator for animal welfare early on. Well, there's a lot of money in it. Right. So moving on to, and I think you make a very good point here, that the protectionism for animals really starts around the time where we made the transition in farming and how we raised and ate animals.
Yeah, because you'd be like, I feel like some beef for dinner. I'm going to go kill old Bessie, our cow. Yeah, and you love Bessie. And your little boy or little girl might cry about Bessie. But then the parents would explain that, you know, we raised Bessie and we loved and cared for Bessie. Right. Treated Bessie very nicely. And the reason Bessie is here is so Bessie can eventually feed us. And we should honor that in every way possible. Right. By using as much of this animal as we can and honor the life that she led. You know? Or if you had a bad parent, they just kind of wheeled that cleaver in your direction and you showed up just as fast.
Yeah, this could be you. Right. But that was a huge sea change when things started to change and industrialization took off and people were no longer connected to the animal on their farm that they ate. It was a sea change in how people, I mean, it directly coincided with how people felt about animals when you could buy something in the store that looked nothing like that animal. Yeah, it's not even called pig. It's called pork or bacon or ham. Yeah. And then not only that, Chuck, something I left out of here that I came across later, this is the same time when people move from the farm to the factory, from rural interactions with animals to urban settings without animals.
This is when people started to keep pets. Yeah. You know, I never realized what you just said there about pork and beef. That never really dawned on me. It's never called pig. That if it said ground cow, instead of ground beef, people would be like, oh. Or veal? Yeah. Some baby cow. Ground baby cow. Yeah. Yeah, that makes total sense. I'm such a dummy that that never occurred to me. It's okay, man. Is that where that came from, calling them different names? I don't know. I'm going to have to look into that. I would guess veal is probably Latin for baby calf or something. I don't think it was a purposeful obfuscation.
I don't know. Could be, though. Would not surprise me. This is before the advent of PR, so I think people were much more innocent and naive back then. Chicken is, sure, but who cares about chicken? I was saying that this is also the time when people began keeping pets around the house. So animals were removed from food production. Yes. And we're starting to see animals not as commodities but as sweet little things that we want to care for and protect and give food to. and let sleep in the bed with us. And it developed this dichotomy of how we view animals today, which is animals are to be protected by humans, but we can also eat them.
It's totally cool. Yeah. And if you step back and look at it, it's so easy to take for granted because that's how almost everybody except for vegans view animals. Right. It's really easy to take it for granted. But if you step back and look at it, it's a very bizarre, contradictory paradigm. Yeah, it's sort of a deal people have made with themselves emotionally, I think. And society is made with itself, too. All right. Well, we're going to take a break and we're going to come back and talk a little bit about the fact that, as of yet, there were still no laws on the books about protecting animals.
This time of year, it's sensory overload everywhere. But one feeling we're all chasing right now is cozy. And Bombas has the socks, slippers, tees, and basically everything you need to get you there. Yeah, and I got to tell you, there's nothing like new socks. It's almost therapeutic. They have sock scientists at Bombas, and they found a way to channel that energy into everything, from slippers with sink and cushioning to satisfyingly weighty tees. And you know, that feeling doesn't stop after one wear. Those things stay comfortable. Yeah, and Bombas is also stepping up their slipper and slide game, too, this season.
They've got new shapes, new styles, fluffy things, suede things, a little something for every foot. If there's one thing Bombas knows, it's feet. That's right. And you know what the best part is? For every pair of Bombas that you purchase, Bombas donates one to someone facing homelessness on your behalf. So anytime you get something cozy, someone else does, too. So head on over to Bombas.com slash S-Y-S-K and use code S-Y-S-K for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash S-Y-S-K, code S-Y-S-K at checkout. The headlines can be overwhelming these days because there's so much happening.
It can make us feel helpless, like what can we really do to make a difference? For people in places like Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, you can make a difference with a gift to the International Rescue Committee right now. Everyone deserves the safety and security of home, but right now, conflict and disaster have forced millions of families into temporary shelters without basic supplies and an urgent need of aid. With your help, the IRC is on the ground in more than 40 countries delivering food, clean water, shelter, and medical care where it's needed most. The IRC has spent over 90 years helping people whose lives have been upended by crisis, often responding within just 72 hours when emergencies strike.
And every day, IRC teams help families find safety, rebuild their communities, and recover hope for the future. And that support matters more than ever. So give now at rescue.org slash rebuild and help make a life-changing difference for refugee families rebuilding their lives. All right, before we left, I teased about the laws of the land. And while things were changing, maybe attitudinally, in England, you point out, in the mid-19th century, it was still legal to beat your horse to death if he was tired or to kill your cow if it didn't produce milk. There were no laws in place. Or like if your dog did something you didn't like, you could kick it to death?
Like, some people did that. Yeah. I think some people are still like that today, but are restrained by laws that developed out of this era, out of the 19th century. Yeah. And where before, there weren't any laws. So if you're an impulsive putz, you could kick a dog to death. Yeah. You know? I can't even go there with those stories that happened today. But that happened even more then. Oh, yeah, of course. That's a very important point, though, is like society as a whole wasn't just beating horses and dogs to death. For the most part, right. I think it was sociopath back then and I think it still is now.
For the most part, people did not do that. And people didn't even like – they didn't necessarily even turn a blind eye to it. I think they did more because there wasn't a lot you could do. But it's probably along the lines of where if you don't agree with spanking your kid. Right. And you see somebody in the store, like, grab their kid and spank them. Yeah. You might want to say something, but at the same time, you probably won't because you don't know if that's a crazy person or whatever. You don't get involved. Yeah. For the most part. Most people don't. I think that was probably very much the same lines, like, where you might see something like that happening, but you weren't going to say anything.
Yeah. I think that was the social status quo at the time. I think you're right. But that said, if the circumstances were right and the act was particularly egregious, someone might say something. There was a guy in 1834 who in the middle of Washington, D.C., beat his cow to death. Yeah. And he was arrested and charged with not beating the cow to death because, again, there was no law protecting that cow. But with creating a public nuisance because he subjected all the passersby to the sight of his cow being beaten to death and people objected to it. So even at the time when there wasn't any legal protection for animals, there was still a line that was drawn.
Yeah, people weren't cool with it. Interesting. So legislatively speaking, it was about the turn of the 19th century in England when Lords Oeskin and Martin got together a bunch of times to try and actually amend the code, the legal code. And one of the first things they tried to outlaw was something called bull baiting. And I imagine bear baiting, which was also a thing. And we'll get to this in a second. It's like Roman gladiator stuff. Yeah, it's when they put a bull or a bear and they chain them to a stake. In a pit. Yeah, and put dogs in there to fight and kill. Yeah, and bulldogs used to be way, way more vicious and aggressive than they are today.
They actually had that stuff bred out of them. Yeah. And they looked a lot different too. Sure. But that's where they got their name from, bulldogs. Bear baiting is still going on in Pakistan. Oh, yeah? Yeah, it's disgusting. There's a big push to stop it now. There's a group called World Animal Protection International, and that's one of their big causes is to stop bear baiting in Pakistan. But I would encourage you not to look that up and look at pictures and stuff, unless you want your heart broken. But it's amazing that in 2016 that's still going on in the world at all. But it is. and then Martin and Martin and Erskine the great comedy duo what is it is because of Rowan and Martin is that where I'm thinking I think so in 1822 they actually were enabled to get the first law passed in the west that made it a criminal act to abuse animals called Martin's Act after Martin and it was the technical name was an act to prevent the cruel and improper treatment of cattle and it was specifically for livestock, and it was a 10-shilling fine, three months in the pokey if you didn't pay the fine.
But what it did was it set a precedent for the future. It was very important. Yeah, it did. Finally, there was a law. Right. There was a law in the books protecting animals. And again, like you said, it was pretty specific. And technically, there had been a law in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. The Puritans had a law in their body of liberties, but apparently it wasn't ever enforced. But this is the first real law. And the fact that parliament was responding to this kind of aroused the public. We talked about in the animal testing episode, the last one, how I think in 1876 there was a law that passed, that was passed, like protecting animals during experimentation, thanks to Charles Darwin.
And that came 50 years after the first animal protection laws in the UK. So there have been niche people, groups, who had been agitating for this, got actually the parliament involved, and then the public became involved. Yeah. Which is usually the opposite. Yeah, true. Usually it's like these groups agitate, get the public involved, and then the public get government to do something. Right. This actually kind of went out of order a little bit. Huh. But the people who were agitating these niche people were usually very interesting people. Like Henry Berg is a really good example. Boy, I love this guy.
Yeah. You talk about an agitator. Yeah. He created the ASPCA, and he was a little rich kid, and he basically said, you know what, I'm going to kind of dedicate my life to walking the streets because one of the things in 1866 when the ASPCA was founded was, In New York, they said, you know what? You have the power to go out and police these things. We're not really enforcing it, but you can do so. And he went, great. I'll do it. Yeah. He was a true believer for sure. Oh, yeah. I think the first instance, as the legend goes, he saw he was a Russian diplomat or a diplomat to Russia, an American diplomat in Russia during the reign of the Tsar still.
He saw a Russian peasant beating his horse, and he threatened to beat the man. Nice. And the guy responded very in a way that Henry Berg was like, oh, I'm going to do this all the time now. He said, yet. He was like, I'm so sorry. Apparently, the guy started crying. He was being talked down to by someone of a higher station. But then when Henry Berg got back to America and tried it, he found that people of the middle or lower classes beneath him socially did not respond the way the Russian peasantry did. They said, this is New York. So he had to kind of. Yeah. Yeah. So he would sometimes actually follow through on his threats and like beat people he saw beating their horses.
I have no problem with that. Yeah. I think most people didn't. But he would also go and break up underground bullfights or underground bull baiting and stuff like that. Underground bullfight would be tough. Two bulls just going at it. And he is buried in Greenwood Cemetery in Brooklyn. If you want to go by and lay some flowers at his grave and pay your respects, I think I might do that next time in New York. Yeah. I mean, even if you're not into animal rights, he was also a huge children's crusader. Yeah. And he very wisely never allowed the children's organizations that he funded and supported to merge with the animal organizations because he knew full well that the little children would take the wheel.
Yeah. And they would very quickly overwhelm the sentiments and the efforts on behalf of the animals. Yeah, it was pretty smart to keep it separate. You've got to keep them separated. You point out in this article very astutely that abusing an animal could be an indicator of violence toward humans. And I know that a lot of serial killers started out killing animals first as their first try. That is, from what I can tell, most likely a pop psychology urban legend. What, that they did that? Well, no, I mean, Jeffrey Dahmer did for sure. Okay, yes, but the idea that it's a predictor of future serial killing.
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's not what I meant. Called the triad of evil. Yeah. Which is bedwetting, harming animals, and setting fires. If you have your kid doing those three things, allegedly, under this triad of evil, you can bet that there's a pretty good chance they're going to grow up to harm humans. I wet the bed. I didn't set harmful fires but I did play with fire a little bit I think this is more like you're intentionally setting fires to harm people or burn down the woods No, I didn't do that and then my dog died and I sat in his dog house for two days and cried That's not harming animals Clearly not I was on the other side of the coin from early on when Huggy Bear died Whether or not that's true That's been used.
Huggy Bear? Yeah, that was my German Shepherd. That's a great name for a dog. Yeah, that was like the first dog that I really bonded with. That was the dude from the streetwise guy from Starsky and Hutch, right? Yeah. Huggy Bear. That's great. Yeah. He was awesome. I get a little sad thinking about him today. Which one? Huggy Bear. Not the TV show guy. I just remember my mom literally came home from work and I was in the doghouse crying. laying down and crying. That is sweet. Yeah, it's very sad. I was such a little wuss. How long was Huggy Bear around? You know, I don't remember. Like your whole life, was he alive when you were born?
Not when I was born. His mom, Daisy, was. And then Daisy died when I was really young, so it didn't have a super big impact. But then Huggy Bear was one of the puppies we kept. How old were you when he died? I want to say I was like eight or nine, maybe. Oh, yeah. That's right there. Tough. Sure. Yeah, first big loss. Man. You know? Yeah. R.I.P. Huggy Bear. Yeah, I appreciate that. Yeah. I'll drink one in your honor tonight, H.P. But anyway, yeah, you're right. It doesn't hold up to scrutiny all the time. But if you're torturing and killing animals, it's not a good sign. No. And the people who have agitated for animal rights have long used this.
Whether it's true or not, people think it's true. So the whole premise for a lot of people has been if a human harms an animal, there's a good chance they're going to harm a human. So if you protect animals and prevent people from harming animals, you're preventing somebody from possibly harming a human down the road. I'm fine with that line of thought. Or you're also, by drawing a line before animals, you're rooting out people who might harm humans down the road. Right. by having them expose themselves as harmers of animals. Yeah. That one's a little morally trickier if harming animals doesn't lead to harming humans.
Right. If you assume that it doesn't treat the person like that. Yeah. Like, oh, you're a serial killer because you just... Set a fire, peed your pants and... Bit the head off a chipmunk. Right. Actually, you'd probably be right if you found a kitty. Maybe. Especially if you did all three at once. At the very least, I wouldn't leave them alone with your child. No. No. So a lot of progress is being made. And by 1907, all the states in the United States had some kind of anti-cruelty law going on. And it started to become just sort of the mindset. Yeah. That was kind of the tradition. Like the states oversaw protection of animals.
Yeah. Until the mid-60s when the federal government got involved and created the Animal Welfare Act. And the Animal Welfare Act, again, this kind of follows that thing where some people agitate for changes to the law, changes to our way of thinking, and get the public aroused. And then the public say Congress or government do something. Yeah. Same thing happened here. Sports Illustrated and Life magazine both came out with articles about how people's family pets are being stolen. Yeah. And used as what are called random sourced animals that are sold to labs. Yes. And that really would get the public going.
Right. Because the idea that Huggy Bear could be stolen from your yard. Yes. Sold to Johns Hopkins University's head trauma center. Unbelievable. And then have his head beaten open with a bat to see what happens. I'm sorry I used Huggy Bear now that I'm making this far through the analogy. It's like 40 years later that still cuts deep. So Snoopy, Snoopy stolen from your yard and experimented on. The idea that this could happen just scared and outraged America. Sure. And it created very quickly the Animal Welfare Act. Yeah, and that originally just protected lab use, but then over the following decades, it really expanded.
And today, it protects all warm-blooded animals in lab experience except three, birds, sadly, the ratus genus rats and the musk genus mice. Right. And not coincidentally, those three make up 95% of research animals in the U.S. Along with the other cold-blooded animals that are used, like fish and reptiles. Sure. So 95% of the animals used in lab experiments are not covered by the Animal Welfare Act. Yeah. But that's not to say that other animals can't be used in animal experiments. It just means that if you do experiment on a guinea pig or a macaque monkey or something like that, you have to follow these guidelines.
Right. But even then, the guidelines are pretty slouchy, actually. They're huge loopholes, and basically they amount to you, especially originally in like 1966. Yeah. You just have to reduce unnecessary suffering. Right. Who's to say what's necessary or unnecessary? Certainly the law didn't. Yeah. And they left it up to the researchers to decide what was necessary or unnecessary. Right. What's crazy is, Chuck, it has been expanded and amended. Yeah. It's also been narrowed. There was an amendment made, I think, in the 70s that extended the protections, which again are loose and almost toothless, to all animals, warm and cold-blooded.
And then in 2002, they dialed it back to what it is now and what it was originally, which are just warm-blooded animals, except rats and mice and the cold-blooded animals. And the birds? And the birds and the bees and the sycamore trees. All right. Well, let's take a break here and we're going to come back and talk about the kind of the two categories for animal protection, animal welfarists and animal rightists. That's what I call them. All right. Right after this. The headlines can be overwhelming these days because there's so much happening. It can make us feel helpless, like what can we really do to make a difference?
For people in places like Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, you can make a difference with a gift to the International Rescue Committee right now. Everyone deserves the safety and security of home, but right now, conflict and disaster have forced millions of families into temporary shelters without basic supplies and an urgent need of aid. With your help, the IRC is on the ground in more than 40 countries delivering food, clean water, shelter, and medical care where it's needed most. The IRC has spent over 90 years helping people whose lives have been upended by crisis, often responding within just 72 hours when emergencies strike.
And every day, IRC teams help families find safety, rebuild their communities, and recover hope for the future. And that support matters more than ever. So give now at rescue.org slash rebuild and help make a life-changing difference for refugee families rebuilding their lives. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell. And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP.
Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all, the early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward. Yeah, and this season, the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference. So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Okay, we're back, Chuck. And you teased the different types of approaches to protecting animals, right? That's right.
There is like a whole contingent of people, and I think most people on the street, if you stopped them, said, do animals deserve protection from harm or suffering? I would guess most people would say yes, and I'm sure there's surveys out there. I didn't find one. Sure. But if you drill a little deeper into it, to adopt a little corporate buzz speak. Low-hanging fruit? Yeah. You would find that there's really kind of two threads to this. And they're based on just how far you feel that protection should go. Right. So the first is animal welfare. And that's the current accepted paradigm of how we approach treating animals, protecting animals.
Yeah, and they generally think, and these are generalizations, but if you're going to fit people into two groups, you've got to do that. They generally think that what we're doing now works pretty well, but we need to enforce it more. We agree with John Locke and Immanuel Kant that you should protect animals from cruelty, but not because they have a moral standing necessarily, but because that is a sign of a bad person that makes us look bad. Right. Which, you know, that's valid. But they balance that out with we treat animals humanely, but we can still use them for food and labor. Right. So animals deserve protection from humans harming them.
Yes. But they're also our property. Like we can do what we want with them so long as there isn't any unjustified suffering. Right. And not suffer needlessly, which you pointed out earlier, but more so here that that's a needlessly. What does that mean? Right. It's very open to interpretation. Yeah, because if you look at what happens to animals in animal experiments, there's, I mean, it runs the gamut. Like everything from withholding food and water to burning skin with blow torches. Yeah, or to making a monkey obese. Right. And making sure they don't exercise so you can study what lap band surgery does.
Right. I mean, there's damaging their brains, maiming them, blinding them, just doing invasive surgical procedures for practice. Yeah. Just the idea of what is justified is extremely subjective. But as a society, we've all generally agreed that, hey, as long as science is being advanced, as long as humanity is being in some way advanced or developed or protected, then it's justified. Or with food. Right. Like, is it those animals don't die of old age? Is it a needless death to eat a cow and kill the cow before it's time? Yeah. And so most people, I think, who believe in the hierarchy of humans at the top of all organisms here on Earth would say, well, yeah, that's a useful use of an animal.
Right. Feeding a human. Right. Right. So that's the idea of animal welfare. Protect them from harm, but yeah, we can eat them. And a good example is making sure a cow has a good life while it's alive. It's not suffering while alive. It's not scared when it dies. Yeah. And then you can eat it. Totally fine. That's the animal welfare view, and that's the generally accepted view in the West. Right. Animal rights or rightists, they think generally that the system we have is flawed and that animals have these rights, or they should have rights, kind of along the same lines that humans do. They should have legal protections, just like we do under the law, and we are a long way from where we need to be when it comes to protecting animals from humans.
Right. The idea of the animal rightists is that animals have an inherent moral value. Right. And the idea behind that is if they have an inherent moral value like humans do, then they deserve legal protections that humans enjoy. Yeah. Which is a radically different approach to protecting animals. Yeah, for sure. And the idea is that, well, it all kind of came from this guy named Peter Singer. And he wrote a book in 1975 called Animal Liberation. And he basically started off the modern animal rights movement, especially the radical version of it. He said in it that if you use Bentham's philosophic calculus, but include animals' right to happiness, not just their suffering.
Yeah, he added a little cherry on top. Right. You just blow the concept of using animals for human means out of the water. Yeah. Like it's just not justifiable. Is an animal a moral agent? And a moral agent is a being that is capable of making decisions based on right or wrong. And moral behavior comes in all sorts of forms. We think of it as like helping a little old lady across the street or not stealing even though you totally could and get away with it. Right. But it's even more, it's even broader than that. And some people say animals do demonstrate moral behavior like loyalty or showing concern for someone that's – or a person that's injured or something like that.
And so therefore, an animal can be a moral agent. Other people say no. An animal can't rationalize. It can't think about the future. It can't want to keep living. Therefore, it couldn't possibly be a moral agent. And Peter Singer really made a lot of waves when he said – He said, well, then if you're going to experiment on animals because they're not moral agents, you might as well go ahead and experiment on people in vegetative states and infants. Yeah. Because they're not moral agents under that definition either. Yeah. He says, you know what else can't rationalize? Your baby. Yeah. So go ahead and do some horrible experiments on your baby.
Yeah. And I'm sure, I mean, the other side of the argument was probably like, oh, he got us. Yeah. Man, he dropped that mic and everything. It's a rubbing in our faces. 1983 another guy came along named Tom Reagan and he wrote a book called The Case for Animal Rights he argued favorably that animals do have moral rights and he had a little thing that he liked to call subjects of a life he said humans and animals are both subjects of a life which means we have, you know, animals have that inner experience that is called having a life like we do Right. So some of them, ones that have higher moral, higher faculties.
Oh, did he divide it up? Yeah. Yeah. It's not all animals in his, his, uh, in his, um, view. It was like ones that are capable of reasoning. Yeah. Because some people say humans are the only rational beings on the planet. Right. And therefore everything else is, is open season. Um, these guys like Tom Reagan said, no, there are certain animals out there that can reason and therefore can be moral agents. Yeah, I mean, when you see behavior of some of these animals, like elephants. Well, then people would be like, that's anthropomorphizing. I know. Anthropomorphizing, burn him. Yeah. You know? You try and burn me.
It can't be proven, so therefore Descartes' ghost exists. Right. And then Tom Reagan also made waves, Chuck, by saying if an animal is a subject of a life, meaning it can think about its own life and want to live, therefore I sound like Miss South Carolina therefore that animal deserves at least one basic freedom which is the freedom from being property which in and of itself would radically alter our relationship, humans relationship with animals so these guys are kind of putting these ideas out there and as we'll see they got some response but it was typically among hardcore animal rights people rather than the general public up to this point.
And then the final dude in the trifecta. The triad of evil. Of evil? Of good. I know. I'm just teasing. Okay. Gary Francione. He was the guy that came along and said, you know what? We need to abolish our domination over animals, period. Outright. It is slavery. Yeah. And we should treat it as such. Right. Get rid of it. Yeah. And he said, we didn't get rid of slavery by making slavery more humane. We got rid of slavery by getting rid of slavery. Right. That's what you do. And he's saying it's the same thing here. Yeah. Pretty radical ideas at the time. Yeah. And radical is a pretty good word because these ideas really caught the attention of some people who did become, I guess, radicalized by them.
Like the animal rights movement has long had a militant arm to it for sure. Yes. It started actually before even Peter Singer's book, Animal Liberation, from 1975. As far back as 1962, there was a group in the UK called the Hunt Saboteurs Association. This is the most polite saboteurs organization name you can come up with. Probably so. They sort of laid the groundwork for the Animal Liberation Front, who got a lot of press, and then another group called the Band of Mercy. The Band of Mercy was named for the Victorian-era British SPCA. Their children's wing. Yeah. Isn't that cute? Yeah. Totally cute.
The Band of Mercy. Mm-hmm. And they were the first people to liberate animals when they broke into a farm that sold guinea pigs to labs and freed six guinea pigs. Yeah, they made off with six. Yep. But, I mean, there were six guinea pigs' lives that otherwise would have been subject to experimentation. So it was a big success. Sure. And they ended up eating the guinea pigs to celebrate. No, they didn't. Actually, the lady who ran the farm, though, she was really shaken up. And she actually shut down her guinea pig selling business because of that. Because she was – I mean, some people had broken into her house at night.
She thought twice. Yeah. She was like, I don't want this to happen again. And I mean, this is, depending on your viewpoint, this is deeply uncool of these people. Like, they used intimidation. They would make death threats. They would make bomb threats. They would threaten people's family. Yeah, they would set fires. People who were running legitimate labs were threatened. People who were legitimately supplying the labs were threatened. Yeah, they would set fires. And then there are other ones where you're just like, yeah, I can kind of get behind that. The point to a lot of these wasn't just to get people to cease their activities or to actually liberate animals.
They were done also to generate publicity. Right. This is a huge aspect of it. These guys were PR masters. They realized that the bigger and the bolder, the more likely it was to get headlines. So groups like the Animal Liberation Front or the Band of Mercy would agitate, go out and do these acts. And then PETA, like more moderate groups that weren't actually doing this, would publicize it and write up press releases and send it out to the press and maybe set up interviews and stuff like that and try to get the word out as much as possible about these. One thing PETA did was they would basically turn people.
Well, sometimes they would send people in undercover to get jobs at these labs so they could make videotapes. And sometimes they would just get in touch with someone there who worked there, turn them basically as a double agent. Right. And say, you will be our person on the inside and you can do these videos for us. Must kill the queen. They got 60 hours worth of audio and video from a lab, cut it down to about a half an hour documentary called Unnecessary Fuss in 1984 and released it. And it was a big deal. Yeah. Like basically experimentation and inhumane treatment on tape for the masses to see.
Oh, beyond. Like it was about as ugly as you could get. It was at the UPenn Head Trauma Center Research Lab. That's probably all you need to say. Pretty much. Baboons were involved and they were researching head trauma. Yeah. So when this came out, it really got the public going. And just like in the 60s with those two articles about people's pets being stolen and used in lab experiments, this led to an amendment to the Animal Welfare Act, directly led to it. And the amendment said that there needed to be committees that oversaw each lab that was carrying out animal experiments. There needed to be the use of pain relievers and anesthesia in experiments.
And there needed to be post-operative care in lab experiments, right? Yeah, and that you couldn't take a single animal and just keep operating on that animal. Okay. Again, all of these things had a very important caveat. That caveat is unless it's necessary. So there was a huge loophole there. If you're testing like pain threshold on a macaque monkey, well, you can't give it pain relievers. You can't give it anesthesia. You need to inflict pain. And well, it's part of the experiment, so it's medically necessary. Or we have to see how one macaque monkey responds to multiple surgeries because we're trying to induce PTSD in that monkey so we can study PTSD drugs, well, that's medically necessary.
And this whole loophole, that huge loophole with the idea that advancing science and human understanding and human welfare, as long as it's necessary, then you can justify anything you do to an animal. Yeah. That's still around, and it's been around for a very long time. Yeah. So this is all culminated in more recent years with a guy, an attorney named Stephen Wise, who, depending on who you are, you might say this guy is crazy or you might say he's amazing. A hero. And a hero. So he's an animal rights attorney, essentially. He wrote a book in 2000 called Rattling the Cage, colon, toward legal rights for animals.
And he basically put forth a very radical idea, which is that some animals, like the elephant or the great ape or the gray parrot, African gray parrot, they actually deserve personhood. They deserve legal protection under the law just as a human being does. Right. And let me – well, he founded in 2007 a group called the Non-Human Rights Project, big N, little H, big R, big P. and it's a legal defense group that basically said, let's find a sympathetic judge somewhere where we can bring up a case and maybe get some precedent set, get something on the books. Yeah, all they have to do is get one case heard, get it denied, and that sets in motion the appeals process where you can work through the higher courts, right?
That's right. And hopefully get some sort of legal ruling, right? Yeah. This guy is sharp. And part of the problem that he's facing right now is as far as law in the United States goes, animals are property. They're strictly property. They're special property, right? Like, for example, if you're beating up your microwave and the neighbors aren't going to call the cops and the cops aren't going to come. No. But if you're beating up your dog, the neighbors are probably going to call the cops and the cops are probably going to come, right? Yes. The thing is, is that animal is still property. And as far as the law goes, property cannot possibly have standing in a court.
And if it doesn't have standing, then that means that the animal can't sue on its own behalf. Yeah. You being the neighbor, you can't sue on the dog's behalf because you're just the neighbor. You have no standing in this dog's welfare either. Yeah. So these animals, any animal, is in legal limbo as far as American courts are concerned. And why is this trying to figure out a way around that? Yeah, he attempted some lawsuits, and his organization did, in New York on behalf of four chimpanzees. And he said, you know what, I'm going to sue on these chimps' behalf. I'm going to try and gain their freedom.
He lost all the cases, got a lot of press. But he did have one heard. And in one of the cases, he even got a judge, or not got a judge, but the judge actually issued a writ of habeas corpus, first time ever for an animal, even though the judge reversed that order that same day. It was like nothing? Yeah. What did I just do? It was a very big deal in the media. I mean, I remember hearing about this guy on the news, and when you wrote this article, it's like, oh, I totally know that guy. Yeah. Yeah, there's a really great Boston Globe profile on him and what he's doing from a year, a couple of years ago that's worth checking out.
Yeah, there's a documentary to release this year called Unlocking the Cage by the legendary D.A. Pennebaker and his wife and partner, Chris, I'm not sure how you pronounce her name, Hedges, perhaps. He's the one that did Dylan's Don't Look Back in 1965 or something. Oh, okay. He's very legendary. The War Room. I don't know if you ever saw that, the political one. What else? Because I know the name. He's a documentary legend. Documentary? Documentarian legend? Documentary legend. Whatever. But he's made this movie about Stephen Wise and his group called Unlocking the Cage. I haven't seen it yet, but it's on the list.
Yeah, he's a pretty interesting guy. something that struck me that I found in my research was he and PETA don't really see eye to eye. They're not working in conjunction. And a few years back PETA brought a case against SeaWorld on behalf of the Orcas and said that it was a violation of the 13th Amendment against slavery. And Stephen Wives was like, what are you doing? He saw that they had very clearly opened the door for the judge to be like, the Constitution doesn't apply to animals because animals aren't people. Yeah. And once that precedent is set like that. Yeah, yeah. Because it's not actually written in law.
Yeah. And there hasn't been that precedent. That really opened the door for it. Luckily, the judge is just like, no, but didn't rule any further. Right. So what Wise is trying to do is to get somebody to set a different precedent, which is, yeah, that actually makes kind of sense. So let's go ahead and run this trial through. Yeah, and it's something that could be possible one day. Like, you know, there have been courts that have ruled where this animal was an heir to an estate, and the court made the animal a temporary ward of the court and endowed this animal with the inheritance. Gave it a nice lunch.
Yeah, and they had to kind of work through that. So he's kind of, he's got a little bit of a leg to stand on in kind of pointing some of these things out. Right, and plus corporations are artificial people under the law. Yeah, we did a whole show on that, right? Right. So, I mean, it's not like this is just totally wacky as far as the law goes. I think the problem is this. The big challenge he's facing is, okay, let's say you're successful, and all of a sudden animals have the same rights under the law that humans do. What's that going to do to the world? And that's a huge question that's raised.
I mean, you can come up with a lot of stuff that would happen automatically. Obviously, medical testing is gone. Yeah. No more zoos, no more circuses, or at least circuses with animals. Right. Yeah, it's just flea circuses, maybe. Just clowns. Right. The creepiest circus of all. Yeah. Obviously, there would be no hunting. Yeah. Veganism would probably just be, that's just what we eat now. Ted Nugent would just drown himself. Yeah, he really would. Yeah. Yeah, Ted Nugent would not like a world where animals had the same rights, now that I think about it. He would not. And like pets, would there be pets any longer?
Yeah. There's actually been changes. I think somewhere in Colorado and definitely somewhere in Rhode Island, if not Rhode Island, the state, they amended the law to include guardian instead of owner. Or in addition to owning. Oh, interesting. Yeah. That's a different thing. It totally is. Like when you're the legal guardian of your younger brother, you're not their owner. No. I mean, you might treat them that way, but. Sure. And then lastly, so we talked about animals being moral agents, right? Yeah. So if you're a moral agent, you also have moral responsibilities in addition to moral protection.
That's another can of worms. Yeah, right. So, like, if an animal kills another animal, are you going to try it and execute it? Yeah. I mean, well, I mean, that kind of happens today. Animals are often put down when they attack other animals. Yeah. Okay. So, yeah, there would be more of the same. Yeah. What's weird is apparently back in the Renaissance and the medieval era, they used to have trials for animals that did something. Kangaroo court? It wasn't. I mean, like, we do it today. Remember Travis the chimp who ripped the woman's face off? Oh, yes. He was summarily executed by police. Yeah.
And I think had he even been captured, they would have put him down. There wouldn't have been a trial. But they used to actually have the trial. And it wasn't because they wanted to give the animal a fair trial. It was for healing the community. Right. To make the humans feel better. so that they could draw this out and make this like an actual issue that was resolved in the execution of the animal. Interesting. Yeah, it's pretty weird. Boy, good one, dude. Yeah. Nice job. Yeah, thanks. You too, buddy. If you want to know more about animal rights, you can type that into the search bar of your favorite search engine.
And since I said search engine, that means it's time for listener mail. Yes, this is the famous part two from earlier this week with Yvonne. And I promised a list of band names and a list of puns from Josh. Because Josh says that he hates puns, despite his somewhat regular use of them. Yeah, again, I take issue with this. If you accidentally make a pun, you're not a punny person. All right, well, let's just go to this list. Poison Ivy episode. Josh, let's stop beating around the bush. Accident. Blood types. Josh, I'm sure I take a bee blood. I'm positive of it. Accident. Hula hoops. Discussing pushing a hula hoop with a stick.
Hang in there and stick with it. Accident. Police dogs. Discussing the current popularity of arson dogs. They're so hot right now. I think that was on purpose. It's possible. I think I remember that one. Chili peppers. Josh, it's ripe for it. Total accident. I don't even think you can include that one. Can he sweat colors? There's this boiling point, I guess, talking about how hot it's been in Atlanta. That's a reach. Yeah, I agree. Strike that one from the record. Spam. Talking about the trouble the maker of Spam had when trying to sell Spam. He was hamstrung by the name Hormel Spicemeat. Again, an accident.
Handwriting analysis. The writings on the wall. I don't even remember that one. I'm not punny, though. I'm not copping to any of these being purposeful. I've got a few more. In casinos, it paid off in aces? Nope. Accident. White-collar crime. This is something that is woven into history of white-collar crime? Total accident. Disgusting a wool transporter keeping wool for his own use. Again, accident. I'm just going to do one more. Pick the best of them, Chuck. This is like a Letterman top ten. Taste and how it works. After saying it makes you wonder how things we can taste, taste. You said chew on that one.
Accident. All right. And now the band names. I'm just going to read through these very quickly. And looking at this list, these are great. So if you're out there looking for a band name. Listen up. Listen up. Toe Thumb. Oh, that's good. Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection. Maybe like a prog band. Maggot Therapy. That's a metal band. The Static Crush. That's total shoegaze. Yeah, or emo. Disruptive Technology. I don't even know. Myotonic Goats. That's a good one. The Tennessee Stiff Legs. Love it. That's a bluegrass band. A Fistful of Neurons. Metal. Force Multiplier. Total Metal. Nazis on Meth. It's Metal.
Oh yeah, Punk. That could be good too. Masters of Plastic. Nerdcore. Colloidal Quantum Dots. Definite Nerdcore. Super Critical Fluid. That's probably Nerdcore too, actually. I guess so. Or a boy band. The Brownie Wise Massacre. That's indie. That's good. Brownie Wise Overdrive. Boy, there were two. Yeah. Snake Detection Theory. I love that one. These are really cracking me up. Extraordinary Rendition. That's like a guy, just like these two guys in Maine that sing at a coffee shop. They do all the classics. Yeah. Yeah. Standards. We're Extraordinary Rendition. Controlled Burn. Not bad. That's a new metal.
Poor Fred Noonan. That's a band that's destined to break up. Poop Fusion. Same. Cooperative Eye Hypothesis. I don't know if that's a good name after all. I might retract that one. Flesh on the Chunks. That's a good one. Or that could be the first album from Poop Fusion. They're like a Zappa-esque band. The horny skin folds. I could see that being like a party rock kind of thing. All right. Is that freedom rock? Yeah, man. Turn it up. Professional mermaid culture. That's not bad. That's very indie, though. Yeah. Like they go to Columbia University or something. You're right, right. And then finally, two more.
Super critical CO2. Not bad. Okay. That's two supercriticals, though. Yeah. And then finally, Frozen Poop Knife. Isn't there... Who did you tell to change their name to Frozen Poop Knife? Oh, I don't know. Oh, Diarrhea Planet. Yeah, and they tweeted back and said, thanks for the idea, never. Did they really? Yeah. No way. Yeah. Wow, did you tell them I'm a fan? No, that's great. Oh, yeah. Those guys are good. Yeah. All right, that's it. That's it, everybody. Thank you, Yvonne, for keeping track of that, man. That's a great list. Yeah, and thank you to the dudes at Primer Stories for posting the essay I wrote.
Go check it out at primerstories.com slash S-Y-S-K. And if you want to hang out with us, you can hang out with us on Twitter at S-Y-S-K Podcast. You can join us on Facebook.com slash Stuff You Should Know. You can send us an email to stuffpodcasts at howstuffworks.com. And as always, join us at our home on the web, stuffyoushouldknow.com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed.
It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.
com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.