The government loves to mark just about any information as secret, which wouldn’t be a big deal if it wasn’t so contrary to running a healthy democracy.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees.
Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know. A production of iHeartRadio. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh, and there's Chuck, and there's Jerry over there. On the down low. And this is Stuff You Should Know. The podcast. The top secret edition. Yes, exactly what you should know is decided by us. That's right. We give clearance, Clarence.
Oh, that's a good one. I wouldn't have put that one together, but it's great. Thanks. So, Chuck, we're talking about classified information, top secret information. A lot of people call it by, especially if you're 12 years old or younger. But it's actually a real thing. It's like a real designation, top secret. Yeah. Which, by the way, I went back and watched that movie again for the first time in years. It's fun. And it is hilarious. Yeah. I just made an airplane reference, and top secret is the same guy. This is Zuckers, right? Zuckers, yep. I think they worked with somebody different that time.
I'm not sure in what capacity, but the Zuckers were involved for sure. Val Kilmer, that documentary on him is fantastic, by the way. I've heard. I have not yet to watch it. We just got through Made. Have you seen Made? Haven't seen Made. Wowee. Even after it ends, you're just like, I wonder what bad thing is going to happen to her next. I know something bad is going to her. It really wears you down like that, for sure. But it's good. It's worth watching. Well, since we're on it with TV Rex, before we get going, I've been watching Station Eleven, and it's one of my favorite shows in years. Station Eleven, what's it on?
HBO. It is from a novel, a post-apocalyptic virus, actually, pandemic. Very topical. Weirdly, but it's more on the order of like 99% of the Earth died. But it's not the road. It's more interesting, more hopeful and artistic. Cool. I'll check it out. Did you ever see the leftovers, I think is what they were called? Well, what's funny is we're watching that too. We just started that because we were in that groove. Yeah. And we never saw the leftovers. And I heard it was really good kind of and even got better through the years. Yeah. I envy you. I wish I could see the leftovers again for the first time.
It's that good. Oh, boy. I'm really excited, Ned. It's very good. All right. Now we should get to it because this is dense. So we're talking about clay. Yes, it is super dense. I mean, we asked some help from Ed Grabinowski, the grabster, and he turned into James Michener novel. It is so dense. Every paragraph is really dense. And it's inevitable. Like, just researching this one, there's so much to just go and read and so many rabbit holes to go down. Because what we're talking about is really, like, simple concept on its face. Like there are secrets that like any government would not want other governments or other people or sometimes even their own people to know.
It would just make the functioning of that government that much harder. It might make the country vulnerable to attack. There's a lot of reasons why you would not want to share all of your business. So you want to classify information based on how damaging it could be to national security. And then you just decide who has clearance to see that those various classifications of information. That's it. That's classified information. But in practice, in reality, it's such a behemoth concept that is so fraught with problems, that is so often completely and utterly anti-democratic. And then it's just so bureaucratically layered that it is extremely, it's an extremely dense topic.
I just wanted to make sure we added a good extra three minutes onto this episode with that. Well, I think, you know, the good news is the history can be condensed really easily into they had state secrets back in ancient times, too. But back then it was a lot easier to keep secrets because there was no technology and there was no bureaucracy generally. So if the autocratic or semi-autocratic leader said it was a secret, then it was a secret, and that was kind of the end of it. Things changed because of technology and because of bureaucracy and because of the development of nuclear weapons. When there was truly something so kind of world-ending at stake that things needed to be ratcheted up.
And this all started with a series of acts and even more so a series of presidential executive orders over the years to really sort of put these executive orders in place to vaguely say who can know what and how we're going to do it. And then the acts come into play to say how are we going to punish people who do it the wrong way or don't do it. Yeah, and it's like you said, the executive orders are where the kind of classification and how things are classified, how they become declassified, how that got all sorted out. But Congress has largely been left to figure out how to punish people who transgress against those sharing that information.
And that whole thing started with the Defense Secrets Act of 1911, appropriately, which evolved into the Espionage Act. But you use a word that I think is really important and really describes one of the big problems with the classification system in the United States, which is it's vague. The descriptions, the explanations, the rules are very vague and nebulous. And so there's a lot of room for objectivity. And there's a lot of room to just say, I don't really know what this is, so I'm just going to put it on the highest possible level of secrecy that I can. Yeah, this is interesting because I think the vagueness is definitely a problem that leads to part of the bigger problem with classification and overclassification, which we're going to talk a lot about.
But I also think that in a lot of cases, like this vagueness, like this is one area where human, what was the word you used? Error? Objectivity. Where human subjectivity kind of has to come into play. and this is jumping ahead a little bit but like as far as you know what to classify as something like the way they decide that is how bad will it hurt america is it grave danger um what was the second one um sort of like medium grave yeah and then just danger ho-hum danger and that's and it's you know people have complained that like well that's not really spelled out but i don't know if you can codify that to a T, like of how dangerous something is.
I don't know. I believe that human subjectivity has to come into play. I'm not defending over classification, but I don't know if this is one of those things that can be bureaucracized and legislated to the nth degree. Right. Well, that's ironic because the whole reason this exists like this is because of bureaucracy, you know? Yes. But you make a good point, and I think that is ultimately the reason, the driving force behind keeping things vague, because you couldn't possibly describe every situation and say, well, if this happens, then it would cause grave danger and you want to make it top secret, et cetera.
Right. But like you said, the Espionage Act in 1917 was brought upon by the advent of World War one. And this basically, like they already sort of from the 1911 version had the vague terms that said, you know, you can't provide this information related to national defense to people who shouldn't have it. Started out vague. But this is where the teeth came in as far as punishment goes. It was during wartime. So it was super harsh. Yeah. Remember, we talked before about Eugene Debs, who was the socialist candidate for president in the, I can't remember what election, but around World War I. And he ran his campaign from prison because he was put in prison for basically denouncing the U.
S. war effort during World War I. And you could not speak out against the United States military, the United States itself, the United States Constitution. You couldn't say anything critical about it. Or you could be put in prison. And people were put in prison because of it. And they walk that stuff back, the First Amendment violations back. But the The point is, is a big part of it was it grew out of this idea that if you share state secrets, you can be seriously, harshly punished like the Julius and Ethel Rosenbergs were. They were actually put to death under the Espionage Act, and it's still around today.
Chelsea Manning, reality winner, Edward Snowden, all of them were prosecuted under the Espionage Act of 1917, which basically says if you share any classified information, you can be severely punished and lose years of your life in prison or, again, ultimately put to death. I'm not sure if that's still on the books, but it very well may be. So we should also talk about this other sort of precursor to what we have today, the system we have today, which was in 1869. And this addresses the technology kind of for the first time. The War Department, they brought out General Order No. 35. So cute back then, No.
35. Right. Fledgling. What they basically said, hey, there are cameras now that exist. So you can't be in a fort and take pictures of the fort or above the fort or around the fort. Like no pictures basically anymore. And so they're acknowledging technology for the first time. And the other big thing was this is a peacetime move. So it's the first time like we weren't at war and sort of putting these rules into place. Yeah, because there were rules about that kind of thing, like even dating back to the Revolutionary Army and the Continental Congress about this stuff. But that was a peacetime one, and that was significant because the classification system is a peacetime and now largely civilian system.
But it found its roots in the military, quite rightfully. I mean, even still today, even people who are highly critical of the American classified information system say it should basically be kept to military maneuvers, maybe State Department negotiations. And even then, it should be a very short time. But the general consensus is, yes, you would not want anyone understanding or knowing what your military was doing, basically. Right. The first time that they sort of, or at least somebody, started to say the word overclassification and the fact that they needed a sort of a tiered system was Brigadier General Arthur Murray, who was chief of artillery at the time.
he wrote a letter to the Secretary of War that basically said, listen, all we've got is this one classification. It's confidential. And they're stamping everything confidential, even if it shouldn't be confidential. And that just, you know, if everything is being stamped this way, then it loses its meaning. So we have to, and they didn't call it overclassification at the time, really. I think that was just sort of the first person to mention this. But he said, what we really need is a tiered system of how classified it should be. And they're already doing this in Britain. They have their four-tiered system, For Your Eyes Only.
For British Eyes Only. Moonraker, Live and Let Die, and Goldmember? No. Goldmember. Goldfinger. Goldmember was a good one. No, For Your Eyes Only is the actual classification. Then you have For the Information of Commissioned Officers Only, For Official Use Only, and Not for Publication. And the chiefs of staff said, you know what? I think it's a great idea. This four-tiered system is probably something we should use, but not the way you're doing it. We need to be able to kind of make this up as we go, too. It seems way too tea and crumpets to us. We need to come up with something else. Well, I think too rigid.
It sounds like they wanted to be able to decide, be a little nimble with how they classified things as they went. Yeah, because the system they initially came up with was to just basically put at the preface of, say, like a manual or a document that says this is only for, you know, this division or this armed services or this type of officer or this whatever. And then it should not be given to anybody else beyond them. And you could conceivably just do that for every single document. But the problem is this was stuff that they were talking about in 1907, and America was still fairly small federal government-wise.
I mean, it was growing big time after the Civil War, but compared to today, like, the bureaucracy was just nothing like it is. And so you could conceivably do that in the armed forces. But as things grew and the bureaucracy grew and the government grew, it just became impossible to come up with this kind of thing for every single document. and much easier to just say, this is this category, this is that category, and this is that category. Right. And there was, we should mention as a little sidebar, there was even one debate for a short time where they were coming up with the different classification levels where they wondered if they should even make up words.
There weren't words. Right. I guess to make it even more confidential or confusing. But then they said, oh, wait a minute, this is more confusing to us even. Right. And we don't want someone, you know, high on the totem pole, which really means low. Very nice. Not understanding what this word even means and then making a mistake because of that. Yeah. So, like, let's use real words. Private piles, like, red turtle doesn't sound very important. I'm sure I can tell everybody about that. That's right. When you say private pile, do you mean gomer pile or full metal jacket? Take your pick. Okay. I can see you both doing that.
Should we take a break? Yeah, let's. All right, we'll take a break and we'll talk about the atomic age and how that played in right after this. Our listeners love puzzles, paradoxes, and hidden patterns almost as much as we do. On TikTok, those fascinations come to life. People are breaking down physics, exploring geology, and explaining why the world works the way it does. You'll see impressive experiments, explanations that finally make sense, and connections you didn't expect. It's like having a lab, a lecture hall, and science museum in your pocket. TikTok is where wonder is shared, where curiosity turns into discovery, and where millions learn something new every day.
Imagine a vacation where everything's taken care of. Virgin Voyages all-in-voyage pricing includes over $1,000 in value, with Wi-Fi, 20-plus dining options, group fitness classes, and entertainment all included. That's right. It's luxury without the hidden charges. These are kid-free cruises built for adults where wellness, nightlife, and unforgettable experiences come together. Set sail this winter from Miami for week-long Caribbean escapes to Grand Cayman, Jamaica, Puerto Rico, or the Dominican Republic. Plus, soak up sun at their exclusive beach club in Bimini. And in 2025 and 2026, they're going even further.
Think Aruba, St. Lucia, and even new routes from New York, L.A., and Seattle aboard their newest ship, Brilliant Lady. With themed sailings, music, and parties all year long, there's never a dull moment on board. It's no wonder they're award-winning. Again, book now at virginvoyages.com or contact your travel advisor. We've all had the experience of calling a business and just wanting to talk to a real person. Not an automated voice pretending to be human, an actual person who can listen and understand and offer help. That's exactly what you can do with Ruby. Ruby is the virtual receptionist company that takes care of your callers when you're unavailable in the middle of something or simply don't want to pick up.
That's right. They can answer, screen, transfer calls. They can take messages, collect payments, book appointments, and more, all while making the people you serve feel special. Best of all, it can help you be more productive. For example, 9 out of 10 lawyers who use Ruby log more billable hours per day than the national average. And other professionals like plumbers and technicians win more customers while being able to stay focused on the job. But whatever kind of small business you run, Ruby is built to save you time, earn you more customers or clients, and make meaningful connections with the people you serve.
It's available 24-7, 365 days a year, and 100% based in the U.S. See why more than 15,000 small businesses use Ruby. Visit ruby.com, or better yet, call them at 844-900-R-U-B-Y. Experience the beloved Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible. Get ready to be transported to the world of Harry Potter in a captivating production that features hundreds of unique voices and immersive sound design that brings the wizarding world vividly to life in Dolby Atmos. Also featuring an electrifying new musical score, Harry Potter, the full cast audio editions, presents the iconic series as a truly spellbinding listening event for the whole family.
It features a spectacular A-list cast, including Hugh Laurie as Albus Dumbledore, Matthew McFadden as Voldemort, Riz Ahmed as Severus Snape, and many more. The adventure will surround you. You'll hear footsteps echoing off the walls of Hogwarts and the whoosh of a golden snitch as it darts past your ear. It's a spellbinding experience for longtime Harry Potter fans and a delightful new way to introduce the stories to a new generation. The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, is available now with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter. It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before.
Listen on Audible. Go to audible.com slash HP1 and start listening today. Okay, Chuck, so it was all just kind of willy-nilly, and the armed forces of America were figuring out how to set up their own classification system. And it was actually supported and codified, starting with one of those executive orders that came from President Franklin Roosevelt in 1940 with EO 8381. And it basically said, everything the military is doing is right. They've got some great terms over there. We've got some secret. We've got restricted. We've got confidential. Let's keep going with that. And it just kind of was, it was mainly coming out of the military, and the military was figuring it out.
But then, like you said, the atomic age came along, and the stakes became exponentially higher. Because we had different countries conceivably working on an atomic weapon, the likes of which had never been seen, the destructiveness of which had never been seen. ever in the history of humanity. And like it just, things got real. And the need for secrecy got real so much so that even before the Manhattan Project started, the scientists that were working on atomic research were keeping their research secret to themselves, like by their own consensus. Like they're like the public, we have to be careful publishing papers about this.
Yeah, I think that's interesting that they just sort of knew to shut up about it, Even, I would imagine, within their own families, it was probably back in the day where they were like, Daddy doesn't talk about what he does at work kind of stuff. And finally, when the Manhattan Project, the Manahatta Project, excuse me, officially got going, there was a dude, one lone man, General Leslie Groves, that kind of controlled the set of rules for secrecy. and things got a little more codified at that point through him basically saying, you know, I'm going to use whatever means I have under the law and even outside the law to make sure this stuff stays a secret.
But it wasn't until these executive orders started rolling in. I think they called stuff like restricted data and stuff like that, former restricted data, which actually was the progenitor of what would become declassification. But it, you know, it was still a little willy-nilly in that it took these executive orders and eventually Congress to really make this stuff law. And at the time, even within the Manhattan Project, it was still like this one guy saying, here, we got to keep it a secret or I'm going to do something bad to you. He was like the ultimate project manager. He was the sole person on the planet who understood everything that was going on with the Manhattan Project.
Even the top scientists didn't fully have like the entire picture. Only Leslie Groves did. He wouldn't let some of like the top physicists working on the bomb talk to each other about their work. There was a tremendous amount of compartmentalization. Mail was read and censored. There's just tons of stuff that this guy was basically saying, we have to do these extreme measures to keep this under wraps. And once we enter the atomic age, you can't go back. So that his ideas about the secrecy needed and the measures you needed to take to protect atomic secrets eventually became the inspiration for how America's classified information system was created.
He created it inadvertently. He just basically came up with such a great, tight set of rules that when the Atomic Energy Act of 1946 was created and they took basically atomic research and put it to like a government-funded civilian research from the military, they said basically everything Groves was doing, we're just going to keep doing that and codify it. Yeah. And you know how I mentioned that he kind of inadvertently created declassification with the former restricted data. He also inadvertently created the derivative classified designation, which is basically if part of this project we're working on is classified, then it's all classified.
Right. And, you know, we'll get into the different layers of classification later, but it was like, you know, this whole thing is a big secret. It's not just you can't talk about this one thing and everything else is just, you know, whatever. Talk about it in the country club. It's no big deal. Right, right. And so after that, so you've got Congress setting the punishment for sharing state secrets, and then you've got Leslie Groves coming up with the kind of the framework for how to carry out a classified information system and protect information, And then you've got the presidents, a succession of presidents, starting with Roosevelt and then picked up by Truman in 1951, issuing executive orders that really kind of spell out how these classification systems are meant to work.
And Truman had a top secret, the top secret category in 1951. And then the big one was Executive Order 10290, which was also issued in 1951 that said, hey, it's not just the military who has secrets that they need to keep. Basically, all of the executive branch needs to be able to create secret and top secret information classifications. And he extended that power to classify information to basically every agency there was, including like the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Education, to say, nope, this is classified. This can't be released. Yeah, they had to walk that back a couple of years later a little bit because people were worried that it was too broad and that too many people were classifying things and had access to it.
So they reduced the number of agencies in 1953 with another executive order. And then what we ended up with was top secret, secret, confidential, and restricted. And should we talk a little bit about what you sent over, like how it literally works in practice? Yeah, I think that's a good spot for it. All right. So if you get a document and you, you know, let's say one day you get your, through a FOIA request, which we'll talk about later, Freedom of Information Act, you get your hands on a document and it says, you know, it might have the title right there with the letter U saying that it's unclassified at this point.
But that's just the title. Yeah, within the document, you're going to have different paragraphs are going to have designations. Like one might say secret, one might say confidential, one might say top secret. And this whole thing rolls up to its initial top classification. So if part of it is top secret, then all of it is top secret. But I guess the deal is, is for future declassification, they want those sub-designations in there. Is that right? Yeah, to make it easier for the person, you know, sending the document out for a FOIA request to black out, you know, any paragraphs that are secret or top secret or confidential.
Because part of me is like, if it all rolls up to top secret, if one part is top secret, then what's the point of even subcategorizing it? But that does make sense. So, in this case, so you said that they might have the letter U next to the title. In that case, they're saying you can acknowledge the existence of this document and the title of this document, but the document itself is considered top secret. So no one would be able to see it without a top secret clearance. Right. And then depending on what agency you're with, they also have different terms. I think the State Department says sensitive but unclassified.
The DOD and Homeland Security might use for official use only. And I guess the Parks Department says it'd be a whole lot cooler if you didn't mention this. Is that from Parks and Rec? No, it's from my brain just now. Oh, I liked it a lot, Chuck. I like it even more now. It was off the cuff, my friend. So those ones you just said, sensitive but unclassified, these basically made-up ones, those are to keep people like you and me from being able to see this stuff. Which is a big problem, as we'll see, with classified information and over-classification, is that the public is basically looped out by this whole thing.
But they have a stamp that says no dopes. Right. No grass. Oh, forget it. So one of the other things that we should say is that you talked about derivative classification, which we'll talk more about in a second. There's also original classification. And original classification says this new thing that we're talking about. Let's say somebody comes up with a new gun, right? somebody along the way will say, we don't want anybody to know about this gun. We certainly don't want to know how it works. So I'm going to deem this gun top secret. There's only a handful of people in the country who can do that.
And it sounds like a lot, but when you really step back and think about it, it's not that many. 2,200 federal officials, typically who work in the executive branch, can declare something originally classified. That's just original classification. Yeah, and just quickly by the numbers, that's 2,200 people can classify, and this is 2015 numbers, but more than 4 million people have security clearances, including 1.3 million with top secret clearance. Right. So, those people, those other 4 million people who can see classified information, they're the ones usually who make derivative classifications.
So when they come along and they say they're tasked with creating a handbook or an instruction manual on using that new gun that just got a top-secret classification, when they're making that manual, because they're talking about a top-secret gun, that manual is top-secret. Yes. That's a derivative classification. Now, let's say you're emailing your coworker about the progress on the manual. That email is top secret because you're talking about a manual that's top secret because it's talking about the thing that was this gun that was originally deemed top secret. Now, if you're talking about millions of people with access to secret and top secret information, and they're all talking to one another trying to make all this stuff work, you can see how quickly that derivative classified information can explode exponentially.
And in fact, it actually has over the years. Yeah, I mean, I guess we could go through the – are you talking about the overclassification numbers? Yeah. Yeah, so the security – the Information Security Oversight Office reported six years ago that cabinet-level agencies alone – this is not the military. Right. Right? Right. Classified more than 55 million documents. And then the Public Interest Declassification Board estimates that the intelligence community just by themselves classifies multiple petabytes of data every year, which is about – a petabyte is about 86 billion pages. Billion pages of either text or, you know, Ed points out a lot of that could be photographs and videos.
But point is, lots and lots and lots and lots and lots of stuff. Yes. And that's just the classification. There's an entire other process for declassifying, and that can be pretty nebulous too. Supposedly nowadays, if somebody doesn't get a hold of this, and very few people are authorized to declassify stuff. Apparently, the president can declassify anything at any time. But there's procedures for other agency heads to declassify stuff. If they don't get a hold of a document and decide to declassify it, after 10 years, if it's not that big of a deal, It can automatically be declassified. If it's very sensitive, and again, none of this is defined.
They're not saying like, you know, really sensitive, like the My Lai Massacre documents. That kind of stuff you want to hang on to for 25 years. So, there's like a system involved or in place, but it's not a very good system. And even still, you're saying like, what is the stuff that can just be automatically declassified after 10 years? should it even be classified in the first place, which is something we'll talk about too. Yeah. And the whole thing with the 25 years is like, what they're basically saying is, we want to wait long enough to where a lot of the people may be dead. Yeah. A lot of the, maybe the statute of limitations could be up for any crime.
Yeah. Or maybe people hopefully have just gotten over to enough to where they're not super mad about something. Right. It's really interesting. All this comes out of And shockingly, the last executive order on this kind of thing was from President Obama, which was in 2009, Executive Order 13,526 replaced all previous orders as far as classification goes. And I'm shocked that it wasn't thrown out and redone. It was a little shocking, isn't it? Yeah, I was just – I guess no one told the last president that Obama had the last word on that. Right. Yeah, I'm not sure how that got through. But that is when it moved things into top secret, secret, and confidential.
And then that's when it talked about whether it was grave damage, serious damage, or damage, and stuff like that. So that's sort of the last word on it. We also should mention there is a level above top secret called sensitive compartmented information. Yeah. And this is when you're within, if you have top secret clearance, they're like, yeah, but you can't even know this. Only people, these very few people that deal with this thing specifically can even know this. Right. That is an SCI designation. Sure. And that makes total sense. And it's a very general Leslie Grove's idea, compartmentalization of information.
So that if you have top secret clearance and you're in the Department of Energy, they're like, no, you can't have access to this top secret weapons information. It has nothing to do with your job. You can have all access to the top secret information about the Department of Energy's new, like, cold nuclear fusion reactor that we're secretly building. But no, you can't see this new gun design, which makes a lot of sense. But it really just kind of goes to show you how compartmentalized this classified information is. even in the echelons of top secret clearance. Yeah, and within that Obama order, there are eight types of information that can be classified.
I don't know if we need to go through all these, do we? No, not necessarily, but they generally all make sense to me, though. Like, there's not anywhere I'm like, oh, this one doesn't matter. It's like military stuff, weapon stuff, foreign government stuff. Yeah, vulnerability of infrastructures, just things you would not want an enemy to understand, which it makes sense. And yet this executive order, it may have cleaned up the process some, but it hasn't helped, it seems like. Should we take another break? Yeah, let's. All right, I'm in agreement on that, by the way. I don't want to keep people in suspense.
And then we're going to come back and talk about what some of the problems are with overclassification. And there's a lot of them. The universe is full of mysteries. Black holes, quantum physics, galaxies. On TikTok, millions of people are learning more about the universe around them every day. Scientists break down complex theories, demonstrate experiments, and connect dots between the cosmos and our daily lives. One scroll might reveal the concepts on the fabric of space-time, the next an optical illusion. It's discovery on a massive scale, where millions learn something new every day. Imagine a vacation where everything's taken care of.
Virgin Voyage's all-in-voyage pricing includes over $1,000 in value, with Wi-Fi, 20-plus dining options, group fitness classes, and entertainment all included. That's right. It's luxury without the hidden charges. These are kid-free cruises built for adults, where wellness, nightlife, and unforgettable experiences come together, Set sail this winter from Miami for week-long Caribbean escapes to Grand Cayman, Jamaica, Puerto Rico, or the Dominican Republic. Plus, soak up sun at their exclusive beach club in Bimini. And in 2025 and 2026, they're going even further. Think Aruba, St. Lucia, and even new routes from New York, L.
A., and Seattle aboard their newest ship, Brilliant Lady. With themed sailings, music, and parties all year long, there's never a dull moment on board. It's no wonder they're award-winning. Again, book now at virginvoyages.com. or contact your travel advisor. We've all had the experience of calling a business and just wanting to talk to a real person, not an automated voice pretending to be human, an actual person who can listen and understand and offer help. That's exactly what you can do with Ruby. Ruby is the virtual receptionist company that takes care of your callers when you're unavailable in the middle of something or simply don't want to pick up.
That's right. They can answer, screen, transfer calls. They can take messages, collect payments, book appointments, and more, all while making the people you serve feel special. Best of all, it can help you be more productive. For example, 9 out of 10 lawyers who use Ruby log more billable hours per day than the national average. And other professionals like plumbers and technicians win more customers while being able to stay focused on the job. But whatever kind of small business you run, Ruby is built to save you time, earn you more customers or clients, and make meaningful connections with the people you serve.
It's available 24-7, 365 days a year, and 100% based in the U.S. See why more than 15,000 small businesses use Ruby. Visit ruby.com, or better yet, call them at 844-900-R-U-B-Y. Experience the beloved Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible. Get ready to be transported to the world of Harry Potter in a captivating production that features hundreds of unique voices and immersive sound design that brings the wizarding world vividly to life in Dolby Atmos. Also featuring an electrifying new musical score, Harry Potter The Full Cast Audio Editions presents the iconic series as a truly spellbinding listening event for the whole family.
It features a spectacular A-list cast, including Hugh Laurie as Albus Dumbledore, Matthew McFadden as Voldemort, Riz Ahmed as Severus Snape, and many more. The adventure will surround you. You'll hear footsteps echoing off the walls of Hogwarts and the whoosh of a golden snitch as it darts past your ear. It's a spellbinding experience for longtime Harry Potter fans and a delightful new way to introduce the stories to a new generation. The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, is available now with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter. It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before.
Listen on Audible. Go to audible.com slash HP1 and start listening today. All right. So overclassification is a thing. We talked about how many documents are classified each year, how many petabytes and billions and billions of pages of information and video and photos are classified. And there is a worry that's obviously been around for a long time that people are, and there's a lot of reasons and costs for overclassification, but one of the big reasons is that I think a lot of people don't want to be on the hook for it, so they'll just default to classifying something. And one of the things the Obama order did was you had to have your name on if you classified it.
So at least they knew who it was and they could go back to when it came to challenging that classification. Right, which makes sense. That's good. They added some kind of accountability to it. Right, but what are some of these costs? Well, one of the big ones is corruption. Like if you keep secrets and you classify everything, like it's really fun to go look for examples of absurd overclassification. There's apparently some facetious plot to overthrow Santa Claus, and some report on it was classified. They routinely classify menus at state dinner banquets. Just stuff that does not need to be classified.
It reveals just how, if everything is classified, it makes it really easy to classify, which means that you can cover up just about anything by classifying it. And so, it's a real breeding ground for corruption. Of course. It's a real breeding ground for authoritarianism as well. Yeah. Because if you're allowed to do what you want and then cover it all up and make secrets and keep those secrets and hide what you're doing, essentially, then that's just a breeding ground. That's a petri dish for authoritarianism. Well, I saw another really interesting explanation about how it can breed authoritarianism from the outside, too, from a guy named Sean Holman.
He was a professor at Mount Royal University in Calgary. And he basically said, when you have a government that has overtly has a mountain of secrets that the public knows about, it creates uncertainty. And so people look for certainty, even if it's not truthful. They want it. They seek it out. So anybody can come along and make up whatever they want about what the government's really doing or filling in the blanks in the public's knowledge. And people will hunger for that and listen to what that person's saying. And that can breed authoritarianism as well. Yeah, and, you know, another thing we failed to mention and his problem with overclassification is they went so far with the Manhattan Project that Russia was tipped off because all of a sudden there was no science, no scientific papers coming out.
And Russia was like, that can also be a bad thing because they were like all of a sudden, or the Soviet Union, I guess, was like, hmm, this is very interesting. They're actually, it's been very quiet over there lately. So my spidey sense is going off. They haven't used the word Adam in quite some time. Another thing is that it hinders research, of course. We talked about the science. Science should be shared. And I know that people on, I know firsthand, the people on the Manhattan Project were frustrated by Groves and the fact that they couldn't even share stuff with other science departments.
Yeah, like he just banned them from speaking to one of them and finally relented and let Oppenheimer hold like weekly symposiums trying to hammer out problems that were just intractable. But even still, they were closely watched. And it was a difficult research climate from what I can tell. Sure. And it's also a challenge when you're an agency like the CIA and you're not sharing information and things like 9-11 happen possibly because agencies aren't sharing information or that they're not sharing that there were no weapons of mass destruction and we end up in war. So sharing of information between agencies is something that needs to happen more, I think.
Yes, that was also a big problem on 9-11. I remember seeing on a few documentaries that came around the 20th anniversary this past September, where there was like real knowledge about a couple of the hijackers being in the United States and that they were a problem and we should be keeping tabs on them. And the information was just not properly passed along. And I think the 9-11 commission settled on the idea that had this overclassification not hindered information sharing, there's a possibility that 9-11 would have been thwarted before it could have been carried out. Sure. leaks is another big one because, you know, when you control the information and have all the information kept secret, you can also leak out bits of that information to wield as a weapon against a political enemy.
And that, you know, we've seen that happen time and time again. Yeah, like Valerie Plame, right? With Dick Cheney, when he outed her to punish her husband for criticizing the Iraq war. Yeah, I think some of the Obama executive order is to protect whistleblowers too. If I'm not mistaken. Yeah, and also to protect people who say this document is being overclassified. When they bring it up to their superior, they should not be punished for that. Right, and I think the executive order even encourages people to not protest, but to question the classification of your superiors and to be allowed to bring that up.
Yeah, you're supposed to be like, that's way off. You really screwed that one up. There's one other thing, Chuck, too, about leaks is that overclassification in a climate where we're prosecuting leakers and whistleblowers like never before. That if we are classifying things that somebody would feel morally obligated to put their own self at risk to release to the public. Right. Should that stuff be classified? Should we be classifying that? And the answer is probably not, that it's probably being covered up is what the classification is being used for. And yet, under the letter of the law, because this is classified information, the Espionage Act says that you can be prosecuted and spend years in jail for following your conscience.
Yeah. That's another problem with leaks and overclassification. classification. Yeah. And, you know, to fight over classification is, you know, I guess Ed points it out very kind of plainly, like as an, as a president, you're kind of in a no-win situation if one of your big mandates is to make a lot less things classified. Like you might win over, you know, some, some freedom of information enthusiasts, but as a general, yeah, as a general rule, you're not going to do yourselves any political favors by going in there and being like, hey, you know what we need to do is declassify a lot of stuff and not classify nearly as many things.
You're also going to upset the intelligence community greatly, I would assume. Oh, yeah. Well, that's a big part of it. So, but some people have said, okay, well, there's got to be some stuff we can do. Time limits is a big one. Yeah. There's a guy named Erwin Griswold, who I found in 1989 Washington Post op-ed he wrote. He was the guy who prosecuted the Pentagon Papers. on behalf of the government. So he prosecuted, like, to that time, the biggest leak of government secrets ever. And he came around years later and said, we're way overclassifying. He basically said, like, there may be some basis for short-term classification while plans are being made or negotiations are going on, but apart from details of weapons systems, there is very rarely any real risk to current national security from the publication of facts relating to transactions in the past, even the fairly recent past.
So to put a time limit, But especially a short time limit on classified material, that would help a lot. Yeah, I mean, is he also the guy that said, if you know a lot about this system, then it's pretty clear that a lot of these classifications are to cover up embarrassments? Yeah, he's one and the same. So that's not good. That's like, oh, boy, this doesn't look good. So let's just classify it. And depending on who you talk to, estimates are anywhere from 10% to 90% of classified information can be put in the overclassified bucket. Yeah, and one of the things that he's saying and that that statistic says is that a lot of the reason classified material is classified is to loop the public out, either because Congress is being fed a load of BS by some lobbyists that don't want public input about what they're telling Congress.
Right. Or there's a real concern that a lot of federal agencies can protect or do protect some of the corporations that they regulate from public scrutiny. That could be a really big issue too, right? Oh, for sure. Like I think the FCC in the early 2000s said that they weren't going to allow reports about outages among wireless carriers to be made public out of a fear of it being a threat to national security. Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of that stuff. The other one with the Department of Agriculture protecting, I guess it depends on who you talk to if you want to think it's protecting, but food producers, if they introduce a foodborne illness into the food supply, they might not allow that information on who it was to be released as a protective measure.
And that's when it gets a little dicey. That and the FCC is like, I don't know. I mean, these are big public companies and you're talking about the public good, but you're throwing like a shield around it. And maybe that's not the best thing to do. And even still, you can take it to an even more extreme degree and right up to the CIA's doorstep and say, I've seen people argue that you, by looping the American public out about the secret torture program, the ghost prisons program, it kept the public from being able to hold the debate on whether this is something we want America to be doing or not.
And that's a huge part of it, Chuck. I mean, like the basis of democracy is the public being looped in and then the government carrying out the wishes of the public. If you're looping the public out, then that's just the government operating and deciding on your behalf without any input from you whatsoever because you're being completely kept in the dark. That is a huge basis of the classification system in America, sadly. Oh, yeah. I mean, the agencies in the military, I think, firmly believe that the public is better off if they don't have any knowledge of this stuff. Yeah. And any opinion on what we're doing behind closed doors.
Yeah. And I mean, they're like, what, do you want to know we're waterboarding people? And I think a lot of people would say, yeah, I would have liked to have known that so I could voted whoever was supporting that right out of office because I don't support waterboarding even terrorists. No one was given that opportunity. The public, even the people who agreed with it, weren't given the opportunity to debate the merits of it in public because everyone was kept in the dark. And you might think, okay, well, I actually do agree with waterboarding terrorists. Well, that was something the CIA kept that you agreed with.
What about all the other things that are kept secret that you don't agree with that is being kept out of your ability to debate? Yeah. Yeah. The quick movie recommendation on that note, the new Paul Schrader movie, The Card Counter, fantastic. Oh, yeah? Won't give away too much, but Oscar Isaacs plays a sort of a very solitary gambler, poker player, who is haunted by his past as a former prison guard at Abu Ghraib. Oh, wow. Okay, I'll check that out. And, you know, Paul Schrader is still making this really, really, he's still being Paul Schrader. So tough, challenging, hardcore movies. What else has he done?
He wrote Taxi Driver. He also made a movie called Hardcore back in, I think, the 80s. It's always just very grisly stuff. And he also did Meet Me in St. Louis. Like the last movie he did before this one was First Reformed, the Ethan Hawke movie where he played the priest. I don't know if you saw that. I guess I haven't seen any of his movies. I saw Taxi Driver. I thought that was lighthearted and fun. He used to write more movies, and now he directs quite a bit. But he also wrote, I mean, he wrote Last Temptation of Christ. Oh, wow. This guy's good. Raging Bull, American Gigolo, stuff like that.
Love his stuff. Yeah. You know Paul Schrader. You just don't know him. I gotcha. Anyway, great movie recommendation. But we were talking about secret prisons, and it felt relevant. So, I mean, there's like a lot of things that people say, okay, you know, here's some fixes we can do. But it seems like it all kind of comes down to, Chuck, putting time limits on classified material and really raising the bar for what qualifies as a classified material or not. And then in conjunction with that, making the act of classifying material accountable. Like saying, like, if you over classify, you're in trouble.
Like there's something, you're doing your job wrong and you're going to get fired and replaced. Those three things seem to kind of be the bottom line. And there seems to be almost no movement whatsoever on it. Yeah, and I think the other two that could be pretty impactful is make declassification a real thing. Sort of like a practice and less like, well, someone has to submit a FOIA request or really bug us. And then within that system, I mean, we could do an episode on FOIA requests because if they don't want you to find out something, they can sandbag you for years. They can put you off. They can release a document that is like 98% of it is redacted and go like, here, here's a bunch of adjectives.
So, you know, I think making that real would help. But I don't know if anyone's going to have the guts to kind of stand up to this stuff because it's not a very electable position, you know? Well, my friend, I'm going to do you one better. We actually have done an episode on FOIA. Did we? I'm going to double check, but I believe we did. I know we've talked about it extensively. We have. We probably did. Yeah. So, you know. We don't even have to do that. We can just go back and listen to, yep, how FOIA works. Okay. Well, in my defense, in April, everyone, it'll be 14 years. That's true. And this was from like four or five years ago.
So don't feel bad. I thought you were going to say like last week. Right. You got anything else? I got nothing else. This is a good one. Yeah, agreed. Well, thanks to the Grabster and to all the people who wrote the articles that we use for research here. And if you want to know more about overclassification, seriously, if this struck you as at all interesting, There's a whole world out there of debate about what should be classified and what shouldn't and how to fix this that you might find interesting. And since I said you might find it interesting, it's time for listener mail. I'm going to call this court reporter.
Oh, I like this one. This is a good one. This is a little lengthy, but I cut it down some. Hey, guys, I'm sitting at my desk in the courthouse in North L.A. County and just finished listening to Unsung Heroes of the Court. And I am still beaming. I am a court reporter stenographer. I went to court reporting straight out of high school after taking a speed running class, just like Chuck. I learned about court reporting from a career day speaker that spoke to our class and knew immediately that this was the job for me. I learned how to type on an old manual typewriter in seventh grade. Took typing every year because it was an easy A.
By the time I graduated, I could type 65 words per minute. A couple of years later, I got my California court reporting license at the age of 19. I turned 55 next month. so 35 plus years later I'm still loving my career we court reporters are truly unsung heroes in the courtroom, I often compare my job to a wedding photographer once everything is said and done, the transcript we create is all that remains and we're fairly invisible so make sure you have a good one our steno machines are incredibly high tech equipped with bluetooth communication for real time simultaneous transcription to laptops, ipads and the internet, we can access the transcript immediately for readback and clarification for the record, which is extremely useful to assist the lawyers, parties, the judge, and juries.
That said, we are in desperate need of more court reporters, guys. Tech schools lost their luster in an era where everyone felt the need to have a college degree. But just like bailiffs that we cherish, in our own courthouses, court reporting school doesn't require a college degree. It just requires hard work and a dedication to your profession. And nerves of steel. That's right. I have never regretted my career choice, and I thank you, Josh, Chuck, and Livia. Livia's first shout-out. Yeah. For highlighting we court reporters and the crucial role we play in the courtroom. That is from Linda Davidson, L.
A. Superior, court official court reporter, and proud of it. Very nice. Thank you, Linda. That was a great email. I appreciate that one big time. That was a great idea for an episode, too, Chuck. It turned out to be pretty good. And we heard from, I haven't heard from a bailiff yet, but we've heard from actually just a couple of court reporters. No, sketch artists. That's right. They're quiet. Yeah, they're quiet. Oh, but get this. I was watching, oh, what case? I think the Ghislaine Maxwell case. And clearly the sketch artist who had drawn that Tom Brady one that went viral, she was producing sketches for, I think, NBC's National News.
Oh, it's funny. I recognized her style. I was just looking at the one for the Elizabeth Holmes case this morning. And now when I see those, I'm like, okay, nice work. Looks good. Yeah, right. Well, thanks again, Linda. If you want to be like Linda and get in touch with us, you can send us an email to stuffpodcasts at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Here with one last reminder to keep you off the naughty list this holiday season, stuff your stockings, your pantry, your gift closet, anywhere you can with Duracell batteries, because there's nothing worse than opening a gift on Christmas morning and realizing you don't have batteries for it. Duracell batteries are the only battery brand with Power Boost ingredients, which are a unique blend of nickel and lithium designed for long-lasting power.
So, stock up on your AA's and your AAA's so you'll be A-OK for the holidays. Choose the only battery brand with Power Boost ingredients. Choose Duracell. We're always digging into the hidden truths behind everyday things, but what about the hidden truths behind your health? At QuestHealth.com, you can get valuable insights into your hormone health, heart health, and more. Buy a test online. Visit a nearby Quest location for sample collection. Get fast results. So if you're curious about your levels or just want to establish a baseline, Quest has a test for that. Visit questhealth.com and buy your own lab tests today.
And for a limited time, save on select tests with code STUFF10 at checkout. Terms apply. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row.
That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian Bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.