Corporate personhood is an ancient legal custom tracing back to Roman law, whereby a corporation is legally considered a person.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. Everybody knows Shaq, but off camera, He's just a regular guy. People never believe me when I say I'm just like them. I take out the trash, do dishes, and I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or OSA.
And a lot of adults with obesity also struggle with moderate to severe OSA. You know those scary breathing interruptions during sleep? The loud snoring, choking, and daytime fatigue? I knew I had to talk to my doctor. Don't sleep on the symptoms. Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. of your friends won't know about so you can wow them at the next cocktail party right the next kid's birthday party any kind of party yeah that's very succinct chuck um chuck let's talk about legal fiction okay okay you you want me to talk about yeah you're not talking about john grisham no no who no sorry that was um cryton that died right i think john grisham is alive and well yes and he's an attorney and a novelist.
Right, yeah, and he's pretty good too. But no, we're not talking about Grisham's work. We're talking about, it's actually a legal term that's used basically to describe any time a court says something is true that's not true, just for the sake of moving things along, keeping things tidier. It's kind of like if you and I were having a conversation, Chuck, and I said, you know, my right jab is a million times better than yours, and we were kind of debating that, rather than stopping and saying, that's hyperbole, I don't agree with that, you're just going to kind of nod, and we're going to stick to the meat of it, right?
Or we should punch each other. We could find out. That's one way to find out, yeah. Although, as everyone knows, we're not big fighters. No, I would miss your face. That's how bad I am. It would be clumsy. Well, let me give you an example of legal fiction specifically. There's this thing called a renunciation of a legacy. Have you heard of this? No. So basically, let's say I find out that I'm in your will. Okay. And I'm just like, that Chuck, he's far too generous. I can't accept this. You know, maybe if I take myself out of his will, he will go ahead and give that money to the poor or orphans or something like that.
Okay. The thing is, is you're sticking to your guns. I'm in your will. You love me. You want to leave me some money. Right. There's something I can do. I can renounce that legacy. Okay. I go to the court and the court says, okay, you're dead. You have – Chuck has outlived you. Okay. As far as this will is concerned, I've pre-deceased you, which means that any claim I could have is null and void since I'm no longer alive. Right. See what I'm saying? I do. That's legal fiction. Right. As far as that will is concerned, I'm dead. You're still alive. Interesting. Isn't that interesting? It is. There's another piece of legal fiction called...
Corporate personhood? That's right. Yes. This is the meat of what we're talking about here. Corporate personhood is exactly what it sounds like. There is a legal custom, not just in the U.S., but it dates back to the Romans, I believe. The ancient Romans. Not today's Romans. Right. The original Romans. Right. Where a corporation, which is really just a pool of investors' money that's taken together and used to conduct business. Right. It's considered an actual artificial person under the law. Yeah. This kind of blew me away. Me too. To be honest. Yeah. There's this guy named Tom Hartman who I heard years ago on NPR talking about this.
And he wrote this great book. And it's worth a read. I can't remember what it's called right now. I've got it written down on one of my notes that I can't find. But he turned me on to this. He has this radio show out west, and he is very much against corporate personhood. A lot of people are. Here's why. Corporations, if you treat them as a person, well, our punitive legal system, Chuck, that keeps us from, you know, stabbing old ladies for their purses or, you know, just walking into grocery stores and opening up cash registers. Right. There's a little thing called prison. Sure. There's also a thing called the gas chamber, the electric chair, the hangman's gallows.
There is punishment out there for our actions. And this punishment is designed to keep us from crossing that line from upstanding citizen to anarchistic criminal. Right. And so we don't do things in large part because there's prison. There's consequences. Right. If not, I would be hitting old ladies over the head every day. Who wouldn't? Exactly. Prison keeps our society intact. Right. I'm joking, of course. It's as clear as that. So with a corporation, you have to kind of look at it since it's an artificial person. You have to look at it as a superhuman person too. Right. It doesn't need food.
It doesn't need water. You can't put it in prison. It doesn't feel pain. Right? It has no lifespan. Can't die. It's limitless. As long as those shares are out there and it's making a profit, a corporation can live indefinitely. So this is why it's kind of a sticky discussion. This is why people like Tom Hartman are very much against corporate personhood. Right. And the whole thing actually – this has been going on for a while. Jefferson, Thomas Jefferson, was very much an advocate of putting lifespan limits, restrictions, including lifespan limits on corporations in the Constitution. And he failed.
Yeah, he failed. On each count. Yeah. So actually we almost had a constitutional provision that said corporations can only last this long and there's this limitation because Jefferson in his usual capacity saw far into the future and all the problems that this random aspect of American society or global society will have. He was a pretty insightful dude, and he was absolutely right. We've run into some serious problems with the concept of corporate personhood. Right. Right. And I know the 14th Amendment is kind of where it all comes together. Yeah. Actually, the irony of the whole thing is that rather than being restricted by the Constitution, corporations were actually protected by the Constitution.
Right. As artificial people under the 14th Amendment, which I know you pointed out the last word of the 14th Amendment, equal rights protection under the law to every person. Every person. That is a very significant word. Right. Because, of course, corporations are artificial persons. Right. Right. So in very rapid succession, that was, I think, 1868 when that was ratified, the 14th Amendment, very quickly a court case came to the Supreme Court for a decision that had to do with applying that to corporations. Right. Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad. Yeah, and if you think about it, basically applying a constitutional amendment that protected freed slaves, newly freed slaves, and trying to get it to apply to corporations, isn't that the pinnacle of tastelessness?
Yeah, I think so. Yeah, well, 19th century robber barons weren't above anything. And one of the things they did was in that case, the Union Pacific case, they finally applied it. The Supreme Court, I can't remember who was at the head at the time, basically said, you know what? We realize what this case is saying. And ultimately what the case did was it upheld the longstanding custom that it was up to a state to tax and to charter corporations. And that's still going on today. Like as President-elect Obama excruciatingly pointed out in I think the second debate, Delaware is a big haven for credit card companies, which is where the vice president-elect hails from.
Because of the tax benefits, correct? Yeah, it's set up in a certain way so that credit card companies benefit the most from that state. Same with Florida is a tax haven for I think real estate businesses or something like that. Right. I think Florida doesn't have an income tax. Is that right? No, they don't have that either. They don't have an income tax. Yeah, no. They just operate on borrowed time. Right. I'm moving to Florida. Yeah, same here, buddy. So in this case, Santa Clara versus Southern Pacific, Union Pacific, one of the two. Southern. Southern Pacific. Thank you. That was established.
But here is where everything just gets totally hinky. I know, and I couldn't believe this. This is crazy. This is crazy. Yeah. The court reporter for the Supreme Court wrote a little head note, which is exactly what it sounds like. It's a note at the head of the briefs of the ruling, and it said court decides that under the 14th Amendment, corporations are afforded equal protection under the law. And that was it. Right. But where it gets hinky, as you say, is that the chief justice did not say this. No. He actually wrote a personal note that was uncovered later on that said that the court specifically did not rule on that.
Right. They knew that that's what the case came down to. It was just written down. They weren't prepared to do that. Right, just written down by the court reporter. By the court reporter, who turned out to be – I believe an ex-president. Ex-railroad president. Ex-railroad president, which I – is that a step back to go to court reporter? Apparently not. There's a long tradition of high finance of huge industry putting their own people into public government. As somebody said recently, Paulson's from Goldman Sachs and so is Kashkari. Somebody said recently there is a revolving door between private and public service.
Right. Very linked. And apparently this has been going on for a very long time. Well, it worked in this case. It did because since it was a head note, it wasn't law, but it did set precedent. Right. And I don't understand how that works, to be honest. Well, somebody can say, look, it's written right here. And you can use it as part of your argument. And they did. I think two years later, there was another case. I think another railroad case or something. They pointed to it. And the Supreme Court finally ruled and said, yes, corporations have equal protection under the law as artificial persons.
Because this schmuck wrote it down. Because he wrote it down at the head note of a ruling that had nothing to do with it. Yeah, I had no idea that the court reporter was such a position of power. Well, apparently no one else did either. But, yeah, so that's how we've gotten to the point where corporations have the same protection as you. Chuck, the cops can't just come into your house and start looking around in the hopes that they find something incriminating. No. Because you're a person and you're protected under, I think, the Fourth Amendment from unreasonable search and seizure. Yeah. So, too, are corporations.
Right. Yeah. There was a case in the 70s where OSHA inspectors, you know, they could just walk into a corporate headquarters business, something like that. Right, for inspection. Yeah, looking for violations, that kind of thing. Somebody sued that corporations enjoy the same protection under the law in the Fourth Amendment and won. Right. So now if you want to find violations, you have to make an appointment with a manager, the store, one of the corporate officers. Right. And I don't think this applies for food restaurant inspections because I used to work in restaurants. And I remember we were always caught very much off guard when the health inspector showed up.
Yeah, yeah. I don't know why that would be any different, but yeah. Well, maybe it just will take a restaurant to file a suit for it to happen. Maybe so, maybe so. There's also a really sterling example that I love. Nike. Yeah. Nike. As we all know, as is common knowledge now, Nike was running some really abusive corporate practices overseas in their factories. It's one word for them, definitely. In the 90s, this is not widely known. I mean a certain subversive section of society understood this. Right, people that did their homework. Right. Most people didn't really walk around going, oh, Nike runs sweatshops over in, I think, Malaysia.
One MIT student actually managed to break it into the public view. And I can't remember. Do you remember when this was, when Nike would allow you to have anything you want stitched on their shoes? Yeah, which I don't remember that. But it was in 2001. You could get something stitched, a personal message or whatever your name. Something, yeah. Yeah, and this guy from MIT wanted the word sweatshop embroidered on his Nikes. Yeah, and they said no. They said no. So he forwarded the email around, and in a very short order, it got picked up by some of the major news services. And people started investigating Nike's practices more and more.
Right. Well, Nike started this huge PR blitz. Right. Where they said, no, that's absolutely not true. This is completely unfounded. We treat all of our employees very well. I mean, just lie after lie after lie. Yeah. Finally, somebody went to Malaysia or some of these countries, these developing countries where Nike was running these sweatshops and filmed the practices. Right. Somebody made a pretty decent documentary out of it. I can't remember what it was called, but apparently the living conditions were important. Factory workers were living in shantytowns next to the factory and their roofs were made of discarded soles.
Right. Like the stuff they used for the soles of the Nike. You know, it's just really bad business practices. So finally Nike is forced to say, okay, fine. Well, a man sued them. That's right. Thank you, Chuck. A lawsuit was brought by a man in California in 1998. And what was Nike's defense? Nike's defense was, and this is just unbelievable, was that because they are granted the same rights as people, they are allowed to lie. Yep. Under the Fourth Amendment? First. First. Freedom of speech. Yeah. Yeah. So they're false advertising you can't be sued for it because you're allowed to lie. because you're a corporation and an artificial person.
Yeah. It didn't really hold water, though. It didn't. But no one ever ruled on it. Well, it's because they settled. Nike settled. Smartly. Yeah. And so they, I think, shelled out like $15 million or something like that. Actually, just $1.5 million unless your decimal point was off. It's terrible. Well, it did go to some sort of labor protection group. But $1.5 million, yeah, that's not a lot. It's not a lot of protection. Although they will buy a couple of houses in Malaysia, I imagine. But the fact is it's still – the jury is still out on whether or not a corporation can lie. But that's how this whole thing has been established over time.
It's been kind of whittled away and added to and taken from. Right. The, I guess, happy ending to this story is Nike was finally put in such a bad light that they wrote a lengthy report on the working conditions of their factories. all of them. Right. And basically, you know, self-reported that they were mistreating their workers overseas and clean up their acts. Yeah, I believe so. Yeah. Freedom of speech goes both ways. And in our litigious society, it's good to have good lawyers if corporations have the same rights as you. It's a shame it took that kind of action, though, for Nike to realize that, you know, the greed that was going on.
Agreed. That's just my opinion. No, I agree with you. I don't know who wouldn't. Well, thanks for listening. Go tell everybody that all corporations have the same constitutional protections as you. Just do it. Exactly. And if they don't now, they soon will. Well, you can read all about corporations having the same rights as you by just typing in a few magic keywords in our search bar at HowStuffWorks.com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Let us know what you think. Send an email to podcast at howstuffworks.com. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different.
That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. You buy insurance for peace of mind, but the policies you trust often cause the biggest financial shocks. Every year, millions of claims are denied because people's policies quietly excluded what happened.
Insurers know every detail. Policyholders rarely do. So for just 27 cents a day, my policy advocate reads your policies and explains in plain language where you're vulnerable. They don't sell insurance. They give you the same understanding insurers have had for decades. Before you trust your policy to protect you, let My Policy Advocate tell you what it really says. Go to MyPolicyAdvocate.com. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.