" Sure animals talk in their own way, with chirps and grunts and the like, but only humans can form words. It is this, some evolutionary psychologists contend, that is what truly separates us from the rest of the species on the planet. But why us?"
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Everybody knows Shaq, but off camera, he's just a regular guy.
People never believe me when I say I'm just like them. I take out the trash, do dishes, and I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or OSA. And a lot of adults with obesity also struggle with moderate to severe OSA. You know those scary breathing interruptions during sleep? The loud snoring, choking, and daytime fatigue? I knew I had to talk to my doctor. Don't sleep on the symptoms. Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.
com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. With me, as always, is Charles W. Chuck Bryant. and that makes this Stuff You Should Know. Is your seat okay? Frank the chair is letting me down again. Yeah. He'll do that. What a jerk. He recently fell in with a bad crowd. Yeah. I suspect he might be on drugs. I do too from the way he's making me sit. Yeah. So I'll lean forward. He's become unreliable. Who is it that messes with him? I don't know. Somebody who has no idea how to sit in a chair properly. That's what you need to get next, not just your own mic cover, but your own chair. Yeah, I think it's that Strickland guy from Tech Stuff.
It would be very cool if you had it lower down from the ceiling, like it was stored up there. Yeah. And it'd hang like the Sword of Damocles over everybody else's head while they were recording. I would love that. We'll look into that. All right. Chuck. Yes. Have you ever heard of a little place called the Massachusetts Institute of Technology? Yeah, sure. Good school. Okay. Go eggheads. So MIT is like the hotbed, the center of the linguistics field, among many other fields. I didn't know that. Yeah. Noam Chomsky is there. Oh, well, that'll make sense then. And there's another guy whose name escapes me right now, but he recently made some headlines because he, I guess, got a grant and had his house wired with fisheye cameras.
Awesome. In every room with really high-tech audio equipment too. And from the moment his newborn son came home to the age of five, this guy recorded 90,000 hours. Wow. The whole five years of this kid's life in an effort to see how language acquisition develops in children. That's pretty cool. And this child specifically. It is very cool. There's a really clumsily titled Fast Company article called, MIT Scientist Captures 90,000 Hours of Video of His Son's First Words, Graphs It. Comma what? Graphs It. And then he graphs it, yeah. That's so clumsily titled this. The editor was like, I'm going home.
Yeah, exactly. But anyway, there's some video and some audio clips in there where you can hear this condensed, like over five years or over like a six-month period or something like that. That's cool. Like the kid going from like gaga to water. Yeah. You can hear it like evolve. Interesting. Did they learn anything from that? I don't know if they have quite yet. And plus, I mean, like this is one child. Yeah, sure. But it's at the very least very, very interesting. Yeah. But the idea that you can learn something about the evolution of language in human beings from language acquisition in children is a hotly contested idea.
It is. You wrote what I think is a very fine article. Thanks. You did a good job with this. How did language evolve? It was a shorty. You were talking about, though, not how we acquire language skills as kids, but as a species. How did humans acquire language? Because we're the only ones that can say things like this. Yeah. But you go to great lengths to point out that we're not the only ones that communicate. True. I wouldn't say great lengths. It was sort of a clumsy intro, to be honest. It was like two or three sentences. Sure. Animals communicate. Well, no, it is very true. I think it was a good thing to start off with because humans can often be very homocentric.
True. You know? Yeah, yeah. So you say birds chirp, porpoises go eee, right? Yeah. They are communicating. We're the only ones who can verbalize. That's right. Right? Yes. We talk words. And we don't know exactly how this evolved, for sure, because there's a problem when it comes to things like evolution. There's not a ton of evidence a lot of times. I know. Like hard evidence. I read this one guy's paper. There's a lot of papers on this. Yeah, this is a really – first of all, I want you to just be very quiet. Do you hear that off in the distance? That explosion? Yes. We're standing in the midst of a minefield.
Linguistics is a minefield. And they love, like, linguistics people really love language and talking about it. And putting down people who disagree with them. Yeah, true. So we should tread lightly here. We should. But one guy's paper that I read today, some university paper, he said that ideally, if we're going to study something like these neurological changes that happen in the brain, we would have a large number of petrified whole brains representing lots of species over lots of time. Right. But we don't have that. No. Unfortunately. There are big gaps. Yeah. And even not taking into account gaps, we don't have fossilized brains.
Yeah. The closest thing we have is a fossilized skull, which we can analyze and be like, well, there is kind of room for a big enough brain maybe for language. Yeah, what's that called? Cranial endocasting? Nice. I think so. That's a good term for it. And people won't even know if I'm wrong. Right. What they do have a little bit of evidence on is that the shape of our vocal tract wasn't until about 100,000 years ago, wasn't even able to make the vocalizations of the modern speech sounds. Oh, yeah? So it wasn't even possible, although that doesn't necessarily mean there wasn't language because it just could have been a much more primitive version of what evolved.
Of grunts? Yeah, exactly. And I did see someone, even though I saw this as poo-pooed by most people, some people think that spoken language evolved from sign language and that our modern gestures are a holdover from that, which I thought was interesting. But most people go, no, that's not true. I ran into another one. And what you're talking about for everybody listening is called a proto-language. Yeah. And evidence of a proto-language supports one theory, which we'll talk about in a minute. But one idea for a proto-language was that we started talking using onomatopoeia. Oh, really? Which would make snap, crackle, and pop like the oldest words on Earth, you know?
Yeah. But, well, I guess we should probably get into it now. There are basically two competing theories for how we acquire language as a species, right? Yeah, and I like both of them. I noticed at the end you're like, why can't we all just get along as far as linguistics goes? Because I'm not a linguist, and so I'm not going to sit here and poopoo and argue because I'm not smart enough. I don't know enough about it. Okay. But the first, Josh, is that we adapted to survive so we learned how to speak. Right. And that's kind of the simplest way to say it. The example I gave in here is – and then we'll talk about who are the leaders in this whole category that believe this.
But Tuk Tuk's hunting on the range, on the plains, on the savannah. Yeah. And Tuk Tuk, thunder scares away the deer. So Tuk Tuk goes hungry. Right. So then later on, Tuk Tuk has already maybe learned to grunt about, like, the deer being nearby to his buddy. Who's his friend? Did we ever name a friend? Oh, Mort. Morty. Yeah. So he's already learned how to tell Morty that deer nearby. So shut up. Right. Because Morty talks too much. He talks incessantly. Yeah. So now all of a sudden he learns that thunder and bad weather might scare deer away, so he goes hungry. So he learns, now I've got to learn what bad weather looks like coming in and how to tell Morty, hey, pick up the pace, dude, because bad weather's coming and we don't want to go hungry again.
So that was just one of the stepping stones in evolving speech. Right, and it's kind of like the idea behind it is that the speech evolved out of combinations of these things like you're saying. Yeah. So you put them together and all of a sudden, huh, that makes a lot of sense. I'm able to describe some larger portion of the world around us. Yeah, and if things got more complex, the language had to as they learned more things. Right, like we settled down and agriculture would have had a huge impact on something like that. Yeah, and keeping children alive, apparently. Like once we settled in villages, a lot of people think that language really took a leap forward because we had to keep the species alive by protecting the kids.
Huh. I guess also the idea that you could warn somebody about something, right? Sure. That isn't necessarily just something you could point at. Right. And be like, you know, let's get out of here through gesture. Right. Something maybe further away, something that you couldn't see right then. And that would lead directly to a trait that led to survival, which is the whole basis of natural selection. Exactly. Which means that people who could do that would be able to go reproduce and that trait would survive and be passed along. And I imagine reproduction in all needed its own language as well.
Right. You know what I'm saying? Hey, mama. Although in Quest for Fire, it pretty much just happened. I haven't seen that in so long I think that was the first movie I ever saw in Showtime Yeah, there wasn't a lot of words going on It was like, you know, the ladies are down by the river Bending over, filling up water buckets Or, you know, water pods And man comes along and just, you know, takes care of business Gotcha Is that an ancient phrase, takes care of business? TCB, yeah So I remember Quest for Fire and another movie were out on Showtime at about the same time. This movie is called Caveman.
And it starred Ringo Starr. Is that his picture that is in this article? Yeah. Don't you like my caption? Yeah. I couldn't tell just by looking at it. But yeah, the caption, I think, is what gave it away. These were the old days where I would like, the highlight of my week was writing really clever picture captions to articles. I would go home and say, look at this one, Emily. It's pretty good. Someone might get this joke. So there's a production still from Caveman of Ringo Starr standing there, and the caption is, This caveman gets by with a little help from his friends. Beautiful. Matt, guest producer, Matt, he's never did that.
Yeah. So that's adaptation theory that basically we figured out that we could survive better and more robustly by talking to one another, and language evolved and fits and starts through there, right? Yeah. Gradually, I should say. Gradually. Yes. And that's Steven Pinker, who's a great dude. Yeah, Pinker and Bloom and their paper, Natural Language and Natural Selection. I mean, there are a lot of people who agree with them and have written, quote, unquote, the book on this since then. Yeah, or several books. Yeah. It's a very dense subject. Yeah. Makes my mind melt a little bit. And Pinker and Bloom basically say, this is the case.
It makes sense. This is just standard Darwinian natural selection. What's the problem? Get your mother-loving ears on because your big-time radio DJ's got news. PayPal lets you choose how you want to pay for all the stuff. With PayPal, I can pay in-store, pay online, or pay over time. What's that? You want this translated into song? I hope you're sitting down. You can pay your own way. You keep those ears on, you hear? Don't just pay, baby. PayPal. Learn more at PayPal.com. And now, Superhuman Shack. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or OSA.
In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at don'tsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. I don't have a problem with it. Why doesn't everybody just get on board? Well, because there's another competing theory, and there are all sorts of sub-theories, but these are the two big daddies. And this is Noam Chomsky and evolutionary biologist Stephen Jay Gould.
And they think that it was a spandrel or an acceptation. So you know what a spandrel is? Well, in biology or for real? In architecture. Yeah. Please explain. Okay. Well, Stephen Jay Gould coined the term spandrel, as you point out in the article. Yeah. And it's just perfect, actually, in this application because a spandrel, architecturally speaking, is this triangular area that inevitably is created when you put two arch domes next to one another at right angles. And it looks like, if you're looking at it, it looks like purposeful design, like ornamentation. Sure. But it's actually a byproduct you can't get around.
And that's what a spandrel is, as far as Gould is concerned. It's the product of another evolutionary process, right? Yeah. And language, supposedly, was, as far as Gould and Chomsky are concerned, just kind of came about as a result of other stuff, specifically tool making. Yeah. Darwin calls it pre-adaptation and later became acceptation. Which one do you like more, pre-adaptation or acceptation? Acceptation is a little hard to say, so I'm going to go with pre-adaptation. It sounds so important, though. It does, actually. But a quick example of that, and this is the one most often cited, is that there's a theory out there that bird feathers were originally meant to keep birds warm, and flying came about after that as a spandrel.
Makes sense. Sure. What's the problem? Exactly. So you said that our brains adapted to where we could, they got larger to where we could make tools and things. Right. And language came about because of a result of that. And this isn't just kind of, I mean, it's not like they're like, well, we can run so we can talk. There's specific areas of the brain that are associated with both tool making and tool use and language. Right. And there's actually two. There's Broca's area and there's Wernicke's area. And Broca's area was named after a French neurosurgeon named Paul Broca. And in 1861, he described a patient named Tan.
And Tan wasn't the guy's real name. No one knew his real name. Was he Tan? He was. The only thing, the only syllable he could pronounce that he could form was Tan. Oh, okay. So they're like, well, that's your name, pal. And after he died, Broca opened up his skull and looked at his brain and found a huge lesion on the area now named Broca's area. Okay. And that's come to be associated with speech production. The weird thing about Tan is he could understand spoken language. If you're like, Tan, you look kind of tan. I think maybe you should stay out of the sun. He could know to stay out of the sun.
There wasn't anything wrong with him other than he could not produce speech. Boy, I bet he was really ticked off with his name then. If all he can say is tan, they're like, we'll just call you tan. And in his head, he was probably like, no. Right, yeah. It's Ignatius. Anything but tan. Yeah, I mean, I imagine the guy probably was like, you know, half mad by the time he died. Just out of frustration. Well, stroke patients, you know, my grandfather had a stroke and tried to speak. In his head, he was saying words, but it would come out as gobbledygook, and he would get really frustrated. It was very sad.
So now, that was your grandfather? Yeah. So what it sounds like your grandfather had a problem with was his Wernicke's area. Yeah. And that was named after a German neurosurgeon who found that his patients who could speak, but they weren't making any sense, had lesions on the area now known as Wernicke's area. So if you put the two together, Broca's area, which is involved in speech production, and Wernicke's area, which is involved with speech comprehension, language comprehension, you have normally talking people like us. Yes. And we first saw Wernicke's area. I think it was Ricky Wernicke.
Wasn't that the guy? Wernicke's area and Broca's area. And the temporal, parietal, and occipital lobes of the brain physically connected for the first time in Homo habilis or habilis. So wait, what's that called where you examine skulls to see if there was probably some brain there? I believe that is called cranial endocasting. Nice. I think so. So they think that this would make a lot of sense if homohobelis was the first one to talk because they also often associate homohobelis as the first one to use tools. Right. This is in question, I found. Oh, really? Recently, it's come under question that possibly the oldest tools, the Aldewan tools, which are like scrapers, hammers, I think.
Brain crushers. Right. Basically just stone tools that are used to like skin meat off a bone. They're like 2.3 million years old. They think that they might be slightly older than Homo habilis. Wow. Then the other problem with linking language in humans and Homo habilis is we're not 100% sure we're on habilis' same tree. Oh, really? Yeah. But nonetheless, Homo habilis does have the cute nickname, a handyman. I've never heard that either. Because he's supposedly the first tool users. That makes sense. Yeah. It's better than Bob the Builder. Yeah. But there's still that link right there between tool use and language.
Right. Which they think makes him and her much more advanced than the Australopithecus, who came before Homo habilis. Right. So the whole reason why this is important is because they're trying to nail down where language first came about. Right. And if you subscribe to Gould and Chomsky, it just – all of a sudden it was there and people were talking to each other. Yeah, it was like one mutation happened and then all of a sudden people were able to speak. Yeah, and they were like, oh, man, I've been wanting to get some stuff off my chest for generations. Right. If you listen to Pinker and Bloom, or you know what?
I feel bad for Bloom. If you listen to Bloom and Pinker. Sure. I mean, we know about that, don't we? Yeah. If you listen to Bloom and Pinker, then it took a very long time for language to evolve gradually by putting combinations together. The thing is, Gould, before he died, said, you know what? There is not nearly enough time for language to evolve. Right. And what's more, if there was some sort of gradual evolution of language, then chimps should show some sort of propensity toward language. Well, they do, though. They do, but apparently not in any way that any linguist who's sane would call actual language the beginnings of language.
Right. It's communication, but not actual language. Right, like you mentioned at the beginning of the article. Sure. But Bloom and Pinker point out, so chimps and humans diverged about six million years ago. Right. That's 300,000 generations for language to evolve. That's plenty of time, they say. Sure. And Gould from Beyond the Graves says, no, it's not. Is he dead? Yeah. Okay. Well, you know what Pinker actually said about that in his defense was, look at the hyrax, H-Y-R-A-X. It is because people say, well, we share 98% of the DNA. The hyrax shares 98% of the DNA with the African elephant.
And if you look at a hyrax, it looks like a large rat. Oh, yeah. It looks nothing like an elephant. So he's like, just because you share all that DNA doesn't mean that you're going to evolve the exact same way. Yeah. So that makes sense. Yeah. And some people pose, and I sort of agree, that they're not mutually exclusive. Yes. You don't have to have one without the other. it may have been acceptation, and then from that point, it may have very much been a matter of natural selection because the better you were at communicating, the better you were at surviving. Right. I like that idea. I do too.
I don't think that, though, if you put Steven Pinker and Noam Chomsky in the same room, that they would be like, you know, this works together. Sure. I think they're tracing it back to the origin point, the moment where it began, either it began to evolve or it just appeared as a result of an incredibly sophisticated machine that just started performing another function as a result of its sophistication. And it's all kind of conjecture anyway. But there's still support. There's support for different ones like brain plasticity, neuroplasticity. The fact that our brains can be restructured and reorganized supports the idea that language evolved gradually, right?
And it just started to build and build and build. and possibly that's how our brains became larger. Right. It's like the chicken and the egg thing. But people also say like if large brain equals things like speech, then why don't like whales and things like that with much larger brains have things like speech? That's another great argument too. And then mirror neurons kind of lend support to the idea that it's just a spandrel of brain function because tool making and speech both use the same areas. Right? Oh, yeah. And then tool making lights up when you watch somebody use tools and when you're using tools yourself in the Broca's area.
Interesting. Yeah. Our old friends, the mirror neurons. Yeah. They're back. You got anything else? I bet you do. There's a lot of scribbling over there. Oh, yeah. So one of Chomsky's big points is that language is innate, which makes it biological, not cultural. is universal grammar, which is like if he always says that if a Martian anthropologist came down and studied all human languages, he would reasonably conclude that all of that information is based on an internal structure rather than culture, basically. And the key to universal grammar supposedly is recursion, which is like me saying, like, I'm going to go to the store, the one down the street, the one that has the really good hot dogs.
I'll be back in a little bit. It's adding phrases within phrases. Right. There's no other communication in any animal species that would include this, which makes that human. And supposedly all human languages contain recursion, except there's a challenger now called Paraha. What's that? It's Amazonian. There's like 500 people who speak it. Really? 501, including the one MIT-trained linguist who studied it for 30 years and is the only one who knows it, who's now saying they don't have recursion, so universal grammar is wrong. Therefore, Chomsky's whole thing is wrong. There's a pretty cool article on Chronicle of Higher Education that's worth reading called Angry Words.
Are they trying to save that language? That's a big deal right now is disappearing languages. I don't think – I think these people are – as far as I got from the article, they seem like they are fine. There's not that many of them, but they're not being encroached upon any further. I think they're protected. Interesting. And they're just kind of living out their existence and doing their thing. Actually, Noam Chomsky is in the bushes behind them with the blowgun. With the blowgun. Nice. Get your mother-loving ears on because your big-time radio DJ's got news. PayPal lets you choose how you want to pay for all the stuff.
With PayPal, I can pay in-store, pay online, or pay over time. What's that? You want this translated into song? I hope you're sitting down. You can pay your own way. You keep those ears on, you hear? Don't just pay, baby. PayPal. Learn more at PayPal.com. Everybody knows Shaq, but off camera, he's just a regular guy. People never believe me when I say I'm just like them. I take out the trash, do dishes, and I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea or OSA. And a lot of adults with obesity also struggle with moderate to severe OSA. You know those scary breathing interruptions during sleep?
The loud snoring, choking, and daytime fatigue? I knew I had to talk to my doctor. Don't sleep on the symptoms. Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Well, that's all I got. That's good stuff. This could have been like 10 hours long. Yeah, easy. For linguists out there, they're like, oh, what a broad overview. That's exactly what this is. They're like, bleh. If you want to learn more and you want to see this picture of Ringo Starr dressed as a caveman, you should read the article written by one Charles W. Bryant called How Did Language Evolve?
Type that into the search bar at HowStuffWorks.com and it will bring it up. And I said search bar, so it's time for listening to me. Josh, I'm going to call this We Saved Another Life. apparently again uh hey guys and jerry i thought i would let's say hey matt since matt's here today yeah hey matt uh i thought i would tell you a little about how your podcast has quite literally saved and changed my life i'm 17 and live in a small town of galesburg illinois but consider myself a citizen of the world uh from when i was six months young 10 years after ghostbusters Nice. Exactly. My family and I have traveled back and forth from Illinois to Barcelona, Spain every two years.
Cool. This last time back in the U.S., I fell in love with your podcast and have listened almost religiously every morning for almost three years. Then one day, my faith was solidified. While listening and walking my dog, Cheepy, across the street, I should probably see away walking. This guy is really hitting all the points here. I love this guy. walking with headphones is a dangerous thing. If one of you died because of a headphone walking incident, I would never forgive myself. Back to the story. A car was, unbeknownst to me, hurtling down the street at me. I started crossing when all of a sudden, buzz, how flies work, had just begun.
Remember the loud buzz? It really flipped me out, and I jumped backwards just as the car flew by me. Oh, no, it was from the fly, remember? Help me. Oh, that's right. Yeah. And he said that scared him enough to jump back and didn't even see the car. Wow. So we saved this dude and Chibi, which is pretty exciting. Yeah. That was a while ago, but recently, actually two days ago, you have changed the course of the rest of my life. After listening to the sauna and Viking podcasts, I have fallen in love with Scandinavia, so much so that I'm going to be a foreign exchange student in Finland for the entirety of next year.
That's awesome. So we inspired Noah to go to Finland because of the sauna and Viking cast. Enjoy the lily. So much love and many thanks. And that's from Noah F. F. Nice. Noah Finster Finkelstein. That's his name now. It is. Thanks for that, Noah. We're glad you're alive. We hope you have a very good time in Finland. And we're glad Cheapy's doing well, too. I bet Noah never comes back. Like in a sinister way? No, I bet he loves it so much that he's like, I'm here. Nice. Until winter hits. Exactly. If you, we always love hearing how we've saved your life or enriched your life or something like that.
We want to hear about it. You can tweet to us at SYSK Podcast. You can join us on Facebook, facebook.com slash stuffyoushouldknow. and you can email us directly just between us and like five other people who are included on the email at stuffpodcasts at discovery.com. Be sure to check out our new video podcast, Stuff from the Future. Join HowStuffWorks staff as we explore the most promising and perplexing possibilities of tomorrow. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Support for the show comes from Public, the investing platform for those who take it seriously. On Public, you can build a multi-asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto, and now generated assets, which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index with AI. It all starts with your prompt, from renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% year over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work.
It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and lets you backtest it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast. Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing, Inc. Member FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors, LLC. SEC Registered Advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool.
Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice. Complete disclosures available at public.com slash disclosures. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.