Unless you were raised alone in a basement (in which case you may be the subject of one), you probably grew up on fairy tales. That's appropriate because they may be humanity's greatest psychic projection screen.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Experience the beloved Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible.
Harry Potter, the full cast audio editions, presents the iconic series as a truly spellbinding listening event for the whole family, with a spectacular A-list cast including Hugh Laurie as Albus Dumbledore, Matthew McFadden as Voldemort, and many more. The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, is available now with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter. It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before. Listen on Audible. Go to audible.com slash HP1 and start listening today. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast.
I'm Josh Clark. There's Charles W. Chuck Bryant. There's Noel. He's back. He's actually sitting in for this one. And that makes this stuff you should know. Yeah, we left a trail of breadcrumbs. Or pebbles, depending on what part of the episode we're talking about. That's my favorite one now. That and the juniper tree are my favorite. Hansel and Gretel. Yep. And the juniper tree. Yes. Yeah, and we should say this is a two-parter. You should have already previously listened to one. And we probably should have put this one out first and then done the other one. Yeah, but hey. But whatever. Whatevs.
We just think this is a nice... I really enjoyed these two, actually. I think you can make the case that we did it in the right order because now people have thought about fairy tales and have gelled and bathed in them for like the last day or so. And now they're ready to understand what's been haunting them. But where did they come from? Right. What's the deal? And we're going to tell you what's the deal. This is... I really did enjoy these though. This kind of reignited my, kind of brought up a lot of stuff. Oh, yeah? Did you find yourself weeping? Not weeping, just kind of like remembering childhood.
And I don't know, I enjoyed it. I guess I didn't read that many fairy tales. It reminded me that fairy tales are... Awful? No, they're not awful. They're just very... Dark? Yes, but I appreciate that part. I think it's more just that... Have you ever seen a picture of a human being without a face? Yeah, sure. I think that's kind of how I think of fairy tales. Okay. They're blank. They're anonymous. They're flat. I think I've actually run into that term a lot in researching for this episode. Well, there's certainly not a lot of character development and stuff like that. No, and that's part of their charm, their allure.
But it's also like, you know, that's the memory I formed of them. is like, wow, I'm used to characters or psychology is lacking as well. Like people do stuff for almost no apparent reason whatsoever. And a lot of it's horrible stuff. Yeah. And that's actually kind of set the stage for fairy tales to be told and retold and retold and interpreted and analyzed. And I think that's what makes them so enduring is that they are, they're so minimalist that they just survive because humans will change and update and will go from wearing bell bottoms and macrame vests to wearing like silver jumpsuits, which are in right now.
Yeah. But ultimately, we're still like very similar to what we were, you know, 60,000 years ago. Yeah. And I think fairy tales reflect that. Well said. Thanks, man. And also, I can say that because from what I understand, despite the fact that there is serious study of fairy tales. No one really has any definitive say over what they are. Like, try to define what a fairy tale is, Chuck. It's a story usually encompassing like a moral or ethical lesson. Right, but isn't that a fable? It's all being fantastical elements. Sure, okay. That often had dark undertones or overtones. That's actually a pretty great definition.
But it does raise some questions. It's like, what is the difference between a fairy tale and a fable or a fairy tale and a nursery rhyme? You know, what's the what is it specifically about fairy tales? I think it's all I think they're all very similar and it's all part of folklore. Yeah. So if you listened, I think in February this year we did one on folklore. So it ties in heavily with that. For sure. And also we didn't I don't know why we just defined fairy tale because we never defined what vocal fry was apparently. I feel like we did. Yeah, we got some complaints like, you never said what it was, but we demonstrated it over and over.
Yeah, and we said it's like a flat, creaky way of speaking. Yeah, I don't know. I feel like we got the point across. Yeah. Okay, so fairy tales. Yes. Specifically, when you think of fairy tales, you might think of Disney, but if you give it a little more thought, you're probably going to come up with the Brothers Grimm. Yeah. Matt Damon and Heath Ledger. Right. RIP. Yeah, for real. Yeah, Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm. And, of course, there are, well, let's just go ahead and say there's a couple of types of fairy tales. There's the oral tale. Yeah, the oral tale, which is, and the Grimm brothers kind of exist between the two worlds.
But one is the oral world, which we talked about in folklore, the age-old tradition of passing stories down. via mouth parts over and over and over, changing them, adding some spice, just like telling a joke or a ghost story or something like that. Right, exactly. And fairy tales specifically, as far as they went with oral tales, are typically associated with women, and typically associated with women undertaking domestic chores. Yeah. That that's typically where they were passed down. And so you've got the oral tale. Well, which makes sense, though. So when I read this, I was like, why are there so many fairy tales that have women at the loom or spinning stuff?
Because apparently that's where they were told. Exactly. It makes sense now. Yeah. It's like, hey, I'm bored out of my mind here spinning this straw into gold. Let me eat some peyote and make up a story. Right. And you sit there and listen. There's also the literary fairy tale, which appears to be there's a handful of people like Charles Perrault or Charles Perrault. Right. And then there's also Hans Christian Andersen, very famously. And these people are reputed as having created many fairy tales, and those are called literary fairy tales. Yeah, like they were original authors and made these up.
Right. That's apparently a total misattribution. Like, for example, Little Red Riding Hood, right, is a great example. That's typically attributed to Charles Peralt in, I think, the 17th or 16th century. Not Charles Keralt. No. Charles Peralt, his ancestor. And Charles Peralt, he was very famous, as famous as Hans Christian Andersen was, for writing down fairy tales into collections and just being delightful, right? And he was great. And at the end of every one of his, there was a moral to the story. Yeah. Yeah. But people tend to think they either, if he didn't come up with it, it was originated right before then.
But we found an article that was from, it covered a 2009 study carried out by a cultural anthropologist who basically went to some biologists and said, hey, you guys know how you trace species and create the tree of life, the taxonomy of biology? Yeah. Can you do that with Little Red Riding Hood? And they said, man, you are one crazy lady. You are one whacked out hep cat. Actually, it may have been a man, Dr. Jamie Tarani. It was a man. Yeah. And still is probably. I mean, it's only been six years. You never know. So Dr. Tarani went to some biologists and figured out how to apply the same methods to the story, Little Red Riding Hood.
And he found that not only was it not just like a few years older than Perrault's version, it was as much as 2,600 years old, basically. Yeah, they found variations in China and Iran and the Middle East. They found some, you know, I've heard of Aesop's fables. Another person. They found some of those from 6th century B.C. So basically what they're saying is maybe nobody made these up. Well, someone at some point did. At least as far as Little Red Riding Hood goes. Yeah. That there's some common ancestor that predates 2,600 years before the present. And it's a very widespread tale. Yeah. Not only did Dr.
Tehrani trace the lineage back to 600 BCE, he found that you could take these tales all around the world and lump them into groups, just a handful of groups. and that places as disparate as Iran and Nigeria and Europe all were in the same group, whereas Japan and Burma and China were in their own group. Right. But they all kind of bear this resemblance where there is a lion or a tiger or a wolf who is posing as something else in order to get the drop on someone else. Yeah, and it's usually a little girl, but I think in Iran it was a little boy. Yeah. So details change. Again, simple folklore, I think.
But the structure, the skeleton of the story is still very much the same, traceable back 2,600 years. So that kind of answers the question that I don't know if we raised or not yet. Who owns or who came up with fairy tales? But humans did. That's the best answer you could possibly come up with is humans came up with it. And over the years, like you said, people embellish it. People add. People subtract. and the Grimm brothers did exactly that same thing. All right, let's talk a little bit about these Grimm bros. Jacob and Wilhelm, did I already say that? They were born in Germany. You said Jakob in part one, which I appreciated.
Jakob and Wilhelm. Jacob was born in 1785, Wilhelm just a year later, and they were kind of rich kids. Their dad was a lawyer, and they had some money. Sure. Their original house, if you look at it, it's funny. It looks like, I mean, it's a total Bavarian gingerbread house. Sweet. And they grew up in Germany, and when they were 10 years old, their dad died of pneumonia. And all of a sudden, they didn't have the kind of dough that they were used to having. No, they didn't. Which was not good and a little scary. I don't get the sense that they were dirt poor or anything, because they still had some relatives that had some cash.
Well, plus also, I mean, they made it all the way through law school in honor of their father. So, I mean, that wasn't free even back then. Yeah, I think their aunt paid for school. They graduated, each graduated at the top of their class in, I guess, what would be considered high school. And then their auntie paid for law school. And it wasn't long after law school that they got into the, I was about to say writing. They did write. They were editors, for sure. The collecting and editing and writing business. They were what's called philologists. Curating is the word I meant. Right. And they were also – they considered themselves and were considered linguists as well.
And by the way, they were Hessians, which means that they were from the same place as the Headless Horseman from the Sleepy Hollow legend. Really? He was a Hessian mercenary. I don't remember that. Yeah. So anyway, they graduated from law school during this period called German Romanticism, which is basically this idea that years before, in the mists of history, the Germanic people were very interesting. They had a very good grasp on things. And a lot of this was passed down through oral folklore. Sure. and that this stuff was disappearing thanks to industrialization. So you get the idea that there's a little bit of nervousness, at least among the intellectual people of Germany at the time, that this cultural history was drying up very quickly.
And there was a movement to collect this oral knowledge before it disappeared. And that's what the Grimm brothers were doing when they set about collecting these stories. Although they weren't very honest about it, at least at first. Yeah, we know them now as just simply the Grimm Brothers fairy tales. Yeah. But the original collection was called Nursery and Household Tales or Die Kinder und Hausmärchen. Nice. In German. Man, your German is... It's coming back. And there were 86 stories originally in the collection. And by the way, big shout to the article from the New Yorker, Once Upon a Time.
Yeah. Allure of the Fairy Tale by Joan... Acosella? Yes, very nice. I think that's it. Yeah, she wrote a great article. And that's largely the basis of our podcast, by the way. That's right. So thanks for that. But 86 original stories. And like you said, originally they, in the forward, in the introduction, they were like, this is all German all the time. Basically, word for word, we went around to the peasantry and collected this, was it Marchen or Marken? For what? Tails. The German for tails. Is it Marchen or Marken? Hausmärchen. Märchen. That's the umlaut at work, by the way. So they went around to the Volk, the peasantry, and collected the Märchen from them.
Yeah. It didn't change a word. Specifically, they said they had a primary source, a woman named Dorothea Viman, and she was a peasant in a village near them. But it turns out that all of this, again, was folklore, which I can't fault them too much because that was their business. No, but they did. They trumped it up to be a little more folksy than it was. Well, they bald-facedly lied in the introduction, in the first edition, which was published in two volumes in 1812 and 1815, right? And so this nursery and household tales became known as Grimm's Fairy Tales. And at first, it was definitely a much more of an intellectual pursuit.
There are lots of footnotes. Yeah. They tried to make it seem like they were just collecting and preserving this German folk knowledge and all that. But it turns out that they did have that primary source and that woman, but she was pretty far from a peasant. Apparently, she was the wife of a tailor, which was part of the merchant class, not the peasant class. Yeah, and she was just one source. They relied on friends and family and relatives. Other collections of folk tales and fairy tales that they just lifted. And we're not suggesting they were thieves. This was a common thing to do. It was, but again, they bald-facedly lied in the introduction and preface, which is funny.
But, yeah, they were trying to adopt an aura for their project that they wanted it to have. Sure. That it didn't necessarily have. Well, yeah, and I don't think we mentioned there one source wasn't even of German descent. She was a French Huguenot. Yeah, so they even kind of trumped that up. Right, which means that a lot of the stuff, like Red Riding Cap, is a ripoff of Charles Perrault's Little Red Riding Hood. Yes. Or an adaptation, whatever you want to call it. But again, this is in the midst of this German romanticism where German culture was trying to be promoted and celebrated and preserved.
Um, so all of this stuff was very much painted as German, even though not necessarily any of it was German in origin, but it was far more ancient than even the French that they were lifting it from. That's right. Um, all right, here, let's take a little break and let's come back and let's talk a little bit more about these, uh, Grimm brothers. Okay. Thank you. growing revenue over 20% year over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and lets you backtest it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks.
Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast. Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing, Inc. Member FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors, LLC. SEC Registered Advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice. Complete disclosures available at public.
com slash disclosures. Hey, everybody. We want to talk to you about Squarespace. And in particular, if you have a great idea that you want to sell on the web, Well, Squarespace makes it easy to sell access to content on your websites. That's right. You can do online courses. You can do blogs, videos, memberships. You can even earn recurring revenue by gating your content behind a paywall. Simply set the price and choose whether to charge a one-time fee or a subscription for access. That's right. And you can get your content discovered fast with integrated SEO tools. Every Squarespace website is optimized to be indexed with meta descriptions and auto-generated sitemap and more.
so you show up more often to more people in global search engine results. Just go to squarespace.com slash stuff and you can get a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use our offer code stuff, S-T-U-F-F, to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or a domain. And we're back. And Chuck, before we get back to it, I want to shout out to guest producer Noel, who is responsible for the fairy tale themed jingle, this episode and the first one, too. Yeah, we asked and he was like, too easy. I'll do it with my eyes closed. Yeah, while I'm asleep. And he did. With an alligator chasing me.
That's right. So thanks, Noel. It's awesome. All right, these Grimm brothers. They were tight. They were really close with each other. They were. They worked really close with each other. They were buddies, from what I can tell. And apparently, for most of their career, they worked at desks facing each other, that classic writing partner. Kind of like we are now. Yes. Even though it's one desk. Right. And we only sit here to record. Yeah, I guess there is some similarity here and there, sure. We're making magic, and they were, too. I think that's the similarity, right? Sure. Jakob was a difficult introvert, and Wilhelm was pretty laid back.
Wilhelm would eventually get married because he was more outgoing and had four kids, whereas Jakob stayed a bachelor his whole life. Right. And they were tight. They worked as librarians together for a lot of their career. And like you said, they were philologists. It's a tough word to say. It is. They worked on most things, I think, eight things together. Jakob wrote 21 books on his own. Wilhelm 14 and they were I mean one of them wrote a book on grammar one of them wrote like a history book they were smart dudes but their life's work aside from the fairy tales ended up being they seemed to be sort of obsessed with making a German dictionary complete like writing a dictionary yeah they made it to F I believe before they died and then some other people came along and said we're going to carry on this work and finish it And it was completed, but it was a massive project.
Oh, yeah. I mean, like for decades, they worked up just to get through F. Right. And I think who died first? I believe Wilhelm, the younger one, died first. And Jakob carried the dictionary on for four more years, even after his death. Yeah. But Jakob said, OK, I'm done with the fairy tales. I'm going to move on to other stuff. And Wilhelm actually edited that thing for 45 years. Wow. It went through seven editions. Oh, the fairy tale thing, yeah. Yes, the Nursery and Household Tales, the Grimm Fairy Tales book. Yeah, I thought you were on the dictionary. I'm sorry, I switched. It went from, I guess, 1812 to, yeah, 1857 was when he released the last edition.
And they were very different books by the time the first edition and the last edition came out. And even between the first and second editions, they were tremendously different books because the Grimm brothers decided that their book wasn't selling like they thought it would, e.g. hotcakes. Yeah, if you listen to the previous episode, it was originally much darker and aimed at adults and was poorly reviewed and didn't sell well. Right. And for grammarians listening by e.g., I'm an example, not that is. I would have said I.e. had I meant that. But they decided that if they could just kind of alter their book just a tiny bit, it would sell a lot better.
So they went through and took out all the sex, basically. Yeah. And tradition of modern Americans, take out the sex, pump up the violence. Right. But these are like early 19th century Germans doing this. Yeah. And I guess it's that same thing. And here, Chuck, I have a question. Yes. And it's a rhetorical question. But so, you know how nursery rhymes are just or fairy tales are just weird. They're very weird. Sure. There's a lot of random things that just seem really out of context. Like talking eggs that break. Right, but also like really horrific violence for a children's story and all that.
Yeah. Oh, yeah. I think that this is the point where that weirdness sets in. Because they went through and they took these same tales and they altered them just slightly for children. Yeah. But it went from these are stories for adults meant to be told from one adult to another, not for kids. Yeah. to let's adapt these for kids. And in that adaptation, that weirdness set in that's still there today. Yeah. I think that's when it happened. That wasn't even a rhetorical question. That was just a statement. Thank you. You're putting it out there. Had I ended in upspeak, though, I could have made the case that it was rhetorical.
So in the very next edition out of the seven, they went ahead and after the bad sales and stuff, And like I said, they sanitized it and geared it to kids. But they also dropped that stuff from the intro, all the lies in the intro. And I'm like, I guess you're like, why did we even do that? Yeah. You know, they're like, we're sorry, everybody. That was just dumb on our parts. It was Wilhelm. Jakob's like, or Wilhelm's like, no, it's Jakob. And it just goes back and forth for like eight pages. So in the previous podcast, we mentioned Rapunzel, how that was, how Rapunzel, basically the lady in question got pregnant after having sex.
Rapunzel. Yeah, so they would whitewash that kind of stuff. They would sanitize the sexier parts. Right, they just took out the fact that she got pregnant and didn't mention what the prince and she were doing. Right. They just left it up to the parents to imagine and the kids to just be dummies and not know what they were talking about. Right. But like we said, too, the violence stayed and in some cases even got worse. like when Hansel and well, the violence got worse but they also did sanitize it a little bit just to make it a little more palatable like in Hansel and Gretel in the previous show we mentioned that it was a stepmother, an evil stepmother which we'll talk about later as a recurring motif that took the children out in the woods to abandon them in the original version it was both a real mother and a real father and they were like, alright you know what, that's really bad.
So let's at least make it an evil stepmother that the dad tries to battle and say, no, don't do this. Right, but eventually gives into. Gives into and the kids are still taken out in the woods to die. Right. But it's just a little bit more like, okay, well, it's not the real parents because that's just horrific. So the violence is still there, but they've taken away a little bit of the psychological terror by replacing the mother. Slightly. With a stepmother. Right. and yeah I think that that's a I guess that is something of a cleansing process as far as editing goes but the violence is still in there and it seems very weird especially today when you look back at this and think like they were reading this to kids but there's a very smart woman named A.
S. Byatt who's a children's author herself but also an expert on children's books and she wrote the introduction to a collection I think actually an edition of the Grimm's Fairy Tales by Maria Tatar, who's basically the foremost expert on fairy tales working today. Yeah, is Zypes not around anymore? He's retired. Because of that guy. He's still available for comment for sure, but Tatar seems to be the, she's taken up the mantle from him. Yeah. And in this edition, A.S. Byatt writes in the introduction of it that, yes, this violence seems weird, but if you step back and think of it as 17th and 18th century Tom and Jerry cartoons, it becomes way more understandable and at the same time way more acceptable as well.
Like, think about all the horrible things that Jerry did to Tom. Yeah. And what you're looking at is the same exact stuff. Yeah. In a fairy tale. So it's not quite as odd as you would think. Yeah. And as far as the historical motif or the motif of the evil stepmom, there's a historical realism there that someone else pointed out that at the time, you know, women died in childbirth a lot. Right. And so oftentimes there was a widow or a widower left with kids that they would bring in a stepmother and resources could be scarce. So you'll see this recurring motif over and over, this evil stepmother who basically is competing for both the affections and food of their little children that they inherited that they don't like.
Right, exactly. So that's why you see it pop up over and over and over is because that's kind of what happens sometimes. Yeah, and that's the socio-historical interpretation of fairy tales, which basically takes fairy tales largely on their face. I mean, like if you have a talking egg or something like that, you're not going to be like, well, obviously in the 12th century, eggs talked. But there were a lot of there's a lot of context and background that that I think people imbue with a lot more fancifulness than need be. For example, like the presence of wicked stepmothers throughout or in the case of Hansel and Gretel, a child abandonment.
Like if you look back at the 14th century during famines and plagues, I think it was the Black Death in particular that just leveled Europe. A lot of people abandoned their children because they just couldn't feed them any longer. So this wasn't like so outlandish that it only belongs in fairy tale. It might have been like a fairly approachable theme that people talked about to kind of hash out the feelings of collective societal guilt. Yeah. The fact that child abandonment was rampant, you know? Absolutely. I think the socio-historical interpretation is probably my favorite. Can we talk about the juniper tree real quick?
I love this one. So, like we said, in fairy tales, there's incest, there's cannibalism, there's murder, there's torture, there's buried alive. There are all kinds of things that can happen. And the juniper tree, maybe, well, I don't know, maybe the worst one of them all. So in this case, we have an evil stepmother, of course, who hates her stepchild, who is a boy. So she comes home and says, hey, you want an apple? And the boy says, sure. Let me lean in there and get one. And it's a trunk, and she slams the trunk down and cuts his head off. Yeah. And that's just the beginning. So she's like, all right, probably not a wise move.
Let me put the kid in a chair. Let me stick this head back on his neck and wrap a scarf around it. And just here, open his eyes here and put a little smile on his face. And then her real daughter comes in, not a stepdaughter. Right. Her favorite real daughter. Yes. And is like, he looks all weird. Why is he just sitting there like adult? She says, I don't know. Go slap him and bring him around a bit. Boxes the ear, I think, is what she told her. Did she really? Yeah. So she boxes his ear. His head falls off. And by the way, the little girl, which makes it even more horrific what you're about to say, loved the little boy.
Oh, yeah. Even though it was a stepbrother. Even though in the mom's eyes they were rivals for these scarce resources. Yeah. Little girl loves a little boy. So go ahead. So she knocks his head off and the mom's like, you knocked your brother's head off. But you know what? We're going to just keep this quiet between us and you won't get in any trouble. Let's just cook him into a stew and feed him to your father. Yes. Or stepfather in this case. And the little girl's like beside herself with like guilt and shame and horror at the fact that she or the thought that she killed her beloved stepbrother.
Yeah. But she goes along with it because this is what her mom's saying. and the father comes home and he eats the stew and actually it's black pudding. Yeah. Not sure what that is, but the father eats it and he's like, this is all for me. Yeah, then he had a little misogyny and greed on the end. Yeah. Because he's like, no one else in this family is going to eat this. Yeah. But me. It's pretty nuts. And in the end, the little girl takes the boy's bones and buries him by the juniper tree and he's reborn as a bird and ends up killing the wicked stepmother. and then comes back to life as the boy.
So it all works out in the end for the boy, but it's pretty nuts as far as these stories go. That has it all. Do you want to talk about how children played butcher with each other? Yes. This one's very short, and we should point out many of these are very short. Like Little Red Riding Hood was only four pages long. I think Rapunzel was only two or three. But that also in and of itself was the work of the Grimm brothers. they would embellish this stuff tremendously and often double it in size. Double it from a few paragraphs to a couple of pages. Right. So it's still short. And by the way, if you want to read a really neat analysis of the juniper tree, read Ernest Parkin's analysis on words and edgeways.
Yeah? Yeah, it's pretty cool. He finds a lot of neat symbolism in it. All right, here's how children played butcher with each other. It's a great title. A man once slaughtered a pig while his children were looking on. When they started playing in the afternoon, one child said to the other, You be the little pig, and I'll be the butcher. Whereupon he took an open blade and thrust it into his brother's neck. Their mother, who was upstairs in a room bathing the youngest child in a tub, heard the cries of her other child, quickly ran downstairs, and when she saw what had happened, drew the knife out of the child's neck, and in a rage, thrust it into the heart of the child who had been the butcher.
Then she rushed back to the house to see what her other child was doing in the tub, But in the meantime, it had drowned in the bath. Wow. The woman was so horrified that she fell into a state of utter despair, refused to be consoled by the servants, and hanged herself. When her husband returned home from the fields and saw this, he was so distraught that he died shortly thereafter. The end. That's like the episode of Dragnet where they have a pot party and the parents forget their child is in the bath and it drowns. Was that on Dragnet? Mm-hmm. Wow. So, you know, of course I'm laughing because, I mean, you can't take that seriously, right?
if you watch Dragnet, you can. Well, no, I mean that story. It's just so over the top and weird and violent and dark. Right. And stuff just happens. Like, again, there's almost no psychology to these things. People just do stuff. Well, supposedly, I think Wilhelm Grimm said specifically about that one, like, no, the clear lesson here is, it's like, don't play with knives and things. Which is, and that's a good point. And I don't know if we've even said that. Like the predominant theory for why these things even exist is as far as being taught to children goes, they are lessons. They're tales on how to grow up, how to avoid strangers.
Sure. Stay away from knives. Stay away from, I guess, witches. Like don't eat houses made of gingerbread. Just good life lessons, that kind of stuff. Yeah. There's sexual predators out there. Yeah, which we'll talk about. But let's take another break. You ready for it? Yes. Okay. Thank you. year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and lets you backtest it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's.
Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast. Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing, Inc. Member FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors, LLC. SEC Registered Advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice. Complete disclosures available at public.com slash disclosures. Toyotathon is on and right now your local Toyota dealer is celebrating with can't miss year-end deals on the vehicles that built Toyota's reputation for legendary reliability.
Discover the stylish and efficient Camry and Corolla, both available with all-wheel drive. Or go with a RAV4 or Grand Highlander. Versatile, adventurous, and ready to take you and your family wherever the road leads. Need muscle? Take it up a notch with a Tacoma or Tundra. Built tough and always ready for the long haul. And no matter which Toyota you choose, you'll find smart financing and lease options available to qualified customers, making it easier than ever to get behind the wheel of the Toyota you've been waiting for. But don't wait. These year-end savings won't last. Shop the entire Toyota lineup and find a great deal today on buyatoyota.
com. Toyota, let's go places. So, Chuck, you said that there are sexual predators out there. Sure. Little Red Riding Hood in particular. If you read it, especially if you read the Grimm version and not the Charles Perrault version, it's like everything comes out great in the end. She's saved. Yeah. You can read between the lines a little bit. And that's the key, though. These fairy tales, even after they became sanitized through seven editions, even after they became Disney-fied, there's still this underlying thread, the theme, the central theme, the message. Look out for sexual predators. Don't cut your brother's head off with a knife.
They can't be expunged, and the stories still remain the same. It's so woven into the fabric of them, and I think that's one of the things that makes them interesting. But alternately, something else I ran across, and I think that A.S. Byatt article, was the idea that they don't have any designs on you. Right. They're not trying to teach you a lesson necessarily in and of themselves. They just are what they are. Right. Maybe the person telling you that fairy tale wants you to learn that lesson. The fairy tale in and of itself couldn't care less whether you learned that lesson or not. It's just, here's a snapshot of what happened in 1217 to this little boy who played with knives with his brother.
Learn it or don't, we don't care. Yeah, but what was Zipes' first name? Jack. Jack Zipes. He may still be. You said he's retired now? Yeah, he worked at the University of Minnesota as a comparative literature professor and German professor. Golden Gophers. Yeah. And he, for many, many years, was the preeminent fairy tale dude. He was where you would go. He turns up all over the place in this research. But he said, though, that there usually is, like, a comeuppance. Like, he says, whoever is a tyrant, a witch, an evil brother or mother who wants her own daughter dead, they will always be punished.
There will always be justice. Yeah. And usually that characters that are of humble origins go on to have, like, great success. It's like the poor maiden marries the prince in the end in most cases. It's true. But not always. Or the king who wants to have an incestuous relationship with his daughter ends up getting killed or something like that. Yeah, in that case, I believe his wife was dying and he said, I will only remarry if I can find someone as beautiful as you. And it turns out that's my daughter. Right. What was that one called? Furs of many or something like that? I think it was called The Creep King.
Yeah. But that's a recurring theme, actually. It's a very ancient one. It falls under the Cinderella story, which apparently, so there's a, I don't know if we mentioned it or not, but there's a folklore cataloging device, like cataloging convention. And I think Cinderella stories, which is the persecuted heroine, is number 510A. Really? Yeah, for real. It's the Arne Thompson Uther classification. 510A, persecuted heroine, Cinderella stories. The Uther pin dragon? Mm-hmm. Yeah. And that's another, Cinderella's another one. There was one woman in particular who collected 385 different versions of the Cinderella story from around the world.
And I think they've identified as many as 15. So Cinderella's another very, very ancient one as well. Yeah. And the one that you recounted about the king who wants to marry his daughter, that particular one's from Greece. Yeah, I think that was called All Kinds of Fur, which is a weird title. Right, but it's all hyphenated like that's her name or something, I think. That's very creepy. So we were talking about sanitizing it, and Joan Acosella comes to the Grimm's defense saying, you can't really fault these guys for changing this stuff because, again, it doesn't really belong to anybody. They belong to the ages, and the Grimm's just put their stamp on it.
Yeah. And then also, if you just take an oral tradition and faithfully write it down, it's going to be virtually unreadable. So they definitely stylized it. They added some more prose, and they made it a lot more memorable, and it became a beloved book. It's a UNESCO book, Memory of the World, I think, collection. So it's a very well-beloved book. But some people say, you know, why should the Grimms be the only ones to be able to change fairy tales? Why does it have to end with them? Right. Maybe it's time to rewrite them some. Well, isn't that what Tartar? Zipes. Zipes, that's his position. No, no, no.
But I thought the woman who, Tartar, is that her name? Yeah. Isn't that what she's done? Didn't she release a new version in 2005? She released an annotated version, but she didn't rewrite them. What Zipes is saying is like, here's the basic story. Go rewrite it as your own. Yes. There have been some feminist collections that are rewritten stories. Yeah, like why is every girl defenseless and needs a man to rescue her from poverty or danger? Right, and that's a feminist interpretation of a lot of the fairy tales. Some people say, if you look a little further, like, yes, all the ones that Disney picked and all the most popular ones are very much patriarchally slanted.
to where it is a damsel in distress, there's a prince that has to come help her, and she's helpless until he comes along, and then whatever. But if you look a little further, there are other ones where there are resourceful heroines. And think of Hansel and Gretel. Gretel tricks the witch and kills her all by herself without the help of Hansel, who's being fattened up by himself, right? Yeah, and I'm sure Walt Disney himself was just like, man, they love this stuff. Like, of course I'm going to keep it. They're eating it up. Yeah. But you can also look at Hollywood, too, as a means of taking these classic fairy tales and rewriting the Grimm versions.
Like, there's a huge, I don't want to call it a movement, but there's like a trend, I guess. Trend. To taking these things that were Disney-fied versions of the stories and restoring them back even to their pre-grim darker roots. Just making them dark again. Their grimmer roots? Their grimmer pre-grim roots, yeah. Have you ever seen Freeway with Reese Witherspoon? Oh, yeah. That was Little Red Riding Hood. Little Red Riding Hood. Yeah, that was pretty good movie. And if you're a feminist, I guarantee you appreciate that version of Little Red Riding Hood because she takes no guff. No guff. And comes out on top.
And at no point in the show. Isn't that Kiefer Sutherland? Yeah. Yeah. And Brooke Shields is his wife, and she, like, it's crazy. It's a neat, neat movie. But that's a good example of a rewriting of a classic fairy tale. Like, no, it doesn't have to end with the Grimm's. Totally. In The Company of Wolves, wasn't that a? That was a re-write of, or a redo of Little Red Riding Hood, too. A little more of a horror, though, right? I think so. I didn't see it. I didn't either. I think that was Neil Jordan, right? Crying Game, Neil Jordan? Oh, yeah, like one of his early movies. Yeah. Yeah. So we have to talk a little bit about the Nazis here because the Nazis were big on co-opting things for their own purposes.
And one of the things they co-opted were Grimm's fairy tales. And since World War Two, there's been a big I don't know about big again. Maybe it was just a trend. But there were folks who said that, you know, when you look at these, they're talking about German nationalism and discipline and violence and obedience and order. obedience and i think the grim brothers were like yeah it's totally nationalism we were all about germany but but we died like decades before hitler was even born yeah like i don't think they would have appreciated that it was co-opted by the nazis and hitler saying like put these in schools this is awesome right like read this stuff put them in boy scout rooms everywhere that's funny so um the the allies came in and occupied germany and one of the things they said was like, you guys can't teach this Grimm book anymore and banned it in a lot of towns around Germany.
It became very political. Because it was very much associated with the Third Reich. And one of the reasons why is because the Third Reich said, go teach this to young German kids to make sure that they know they're German and that they will triumph over the Allied wolf. Because they're all little Red Riding Hood. That's right. Little Nazi kids. That's right. So, again, people make the case like, you can't really hang that on the Grimm brothers. They didn't foresee Nazism. And this German nationalism in and of itself isn't necessarily inherently evil. And if you put it in the context of German romanticism, most countries in Europe were undergoing nationalist fever.
Yeah. You know? There was some anti-Semitism, though, in some of the tales. Yeah, and that can't be gotten around either. Yeah, one was called The Jew and the Brambles, where the protagonist torments a Jewish person by making him dance on a thicket of thorns. calls him a dirty dog. And then there's, I mean, there's various, I think it said three, basically, of the 200 tales had Jewish characters, and they were never, like, favorable. Yeah, the other two reference the Jewish stereotype of being stingy with money or something like that. Yeah, the good bargain. And a lot of people are like, well, let's just expunge those, too.
And some people have from their collections. I think that's the other thing, too, is you can, And the Grimm's kind of set a precedent for you can take these tails and cleanse them if you want or do whatever you want to them. Like they belong to the ages. Well, and that's then comes in the people who posit whether or not that's good for us. Should we sanitize it? Should we not? W.H. Alden, I love this. He described the people who sanitize him as the Society for the Scientific Diet, the Association of Positive Parents, Positivist Parents, the League for the Promotion of Worthwhile Leisure, or the Cooperative Camp of Prudent Progressives.
That is so WHR. He couldn't just leave it at one description. No way. So he clearly wasn't in favor of it. Some people think it's good for us. A man named Bruno Bettelheim. Great name. Bruno Bettelheim? Mm-hmm. Yeah, it totally is. Sounds like a Bond villain or something. Yeah. In 1976, he had a book called The Uses of Enchantment, and he was very Freudian in nature. Oh, yeah. And that he basically says that we all, all these kids have these unconscious desires and these books help what, like these repressed desires come out, help them deal with them? Yeah, it helps children deal with their repressed desires.
Like the example of the, so we talked about the socio-historical interpretation of the presence of wicked stepmothers, right? Right. There were lots of stepmothers and they were competing for resources. Bettelheim and the Freudians say, well, no, the stepmothers are there because children love their mother, but they also hate their mother. And this gives them a way to work through that complex combination of emotions where they can hate the wicked stepmother, but they can also love the biological mother who's absent or appears early on and then dies, but who is always very loving and kind. Right.
So they can work that out. That's a great example of it. Yeah, and then you have Zipes, who Jack Zipes says, you know, what it really is is children see the fairy tale as like a counter world, a reflection of their own world. And it allows them to, you know, consider what's going on in that world and then take steps in their own world to reform it and not do those things. Right. Specifically, it teaches children to identify tyrants and people who are power mad and people who hoard money or harm other people because those people almost invariably come to a terrible end in those things, in fairy tales, right?
Yeah. So you've got all these different interpretations. Freudian, Carl Jung got into it. Sociohistorical, feminist interpretation. Jack Zyp's own personal leftist interpretation, right? Yeah. And all of them, although they compete here or there, none of them are wrong and none of them are right. And that, again, is the beauty of fairy tales. It's like a blank white piece of plywood that we project our own thoughts and fears and hopes and ideas onto culture by culture, age by age. Yeah. And Tatar, in her collection, did a pretty smart thing, I think. She actually collected some of the more disturbing ones in the back of the book under the title Tales for Adults.
Basically, read these first on your own. Right. See if you want to read them to your kid. Yeah. Don't front load it with the juniper tree. Right. You know? And actually, Joan Acacela says that you should take an X-Acto knife and just cut the juniper tree out of your collection. Oh, who said that? I thought that was pretty funny. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I don't know. If your kid's got a strong fortitude. It's up to the parents, but it wasn't always up to the parents. There was a big movement in the mid-20th century for realism among children's books. And the Grimm's were first on the chopping block there.
Instead, it was replaced by, like, Judy Goes to the Firehouse, as Akasella says. Right. Like, think about it. It's like a total 50s children's book. Yeah. Like, see Dick and Jane run. Yeah. You know? And it was, I guess, Maurice Sendak with Where the Wild Things Are who said, yeah, we're not doing that anymore. He brought the cool back to children's books. He definitely did. Yeah. I haven't read many children's books lately, but I think there's a lot of – You read Daddy Sat on a Duck, right? Yeah. I did read that one. Lots of fart jokes in that one. Yeah. That was written by one of our listeners even.
Highly recommended. It is. It's very good. But I think these days there's a mix of things going on. So realism, fanciful stuff, stories. I know, well, this is more of a young adult novel, but Colin Malloy of the Decemberist wrote a three-part children's novels, like big, big books. Oh, yeah. About this fantastical world in Oregon, this forest in Oregon where I can't, I've bought them all. I can't wait to read them. Yeah. It's cool, man. Yeah, I think he's, that's more the tradition of the, like Lion, Witch, and the Wardrobe. Right, that's what I thought of when you said that. I wanted to say Avalon.
It's not the name. Narnia. Narnia. Yeah. I have no idea where children's books are these days either. I wonder, though, what it reflects about society at large, whatever phase children's books are, whether it's realism or fancifulness. You know? Yeah. Like when you're in an economic downturn, is realism or fantasy the one that steps in? Yeah. I would guess fantasy because people want escapism then. I was way into that stuff. I wasn't into, like, Hobbit and Lord of the Rings and stuff like that, but I love Maurice Sendak. Really? And Dr. Seuss and stuff that was really kind of out there. I love Dr.
Seuss. I found out that it's not every boy read Ramona Quimby books. I thought it was unisex. Apparently not. Yeah, I read some Judy Blume. Yeah, of course. And I did read the first couple of the chronic what calls of Narnia. Did you ever see that skit? No. It was one of the Saturday Night Live shorts. They were doing, Chris Parnell and Sandberg were doing a rap. The Chronic What? Cools of Narnia. No, I didn't see that one. It's like a very weird, misplaced what. Did you see Mr. Show's coming back on Netflix? Yeah, well, as close as we're going to get to Mr. Show. I don't think they can call it Mr.
Show. No, they're calling it With, like, W slash Bob and David. Bob and David. I can't wait, man. I saw a couple of clips, and it looks like it's going to be as good as it ever was. I'm pretty psyched. Me too. Before we leave you, since we're talking about fairy tales, we thought it'd be appropriate to mention that two of our horror fiction contest submitters are published. One's published again. Jay McMurray published The Dreamings of Leonard J.M. Leaper. And you can check that out at TatePublishing.com. Not Leaper? No, Leaper. Oh, okay. And then also you can find Patrick Scott. He wrote Play, I believe, which was in Meat for T magazine.
And you can find information about that at meet4tea.com. Since I said meet4tea, it's time for Listener Mint. I wish it was time for us to meet for tea. No, M-E-A-T. Yeah. Okay. Kidding. I'm going to call this a little bit more on vocal fry. We got a lot of response from this one. I think it's second in controversy only to homelessness. Yeah, a lot of ladies wrote in, women that were very appreciative. A lot of men wrote in. Who were not appreciative. Many were, too. Yeah, many were, but a lot of dudes wrote in. I think they're part of the men's movement. It was divided like you would expect, but there were men who wrote in to support us.
There were women who wrote in to criticize Vocal Fry that agreed with Naomi Wolf. Yeah, and I just want to clear up. I don't mean all old white men are awful. I don't, you don't even need to say that. If you're not one of the ones that are doing these things, then great. Who cares? Yeah, I know. You don't need to defend the ones who are. Nope. All right. Here we go. Hey, guys, just want to say thanks so much for your recently, for recently tackling some very charged gender issues in the most mature but non-apologist of ways. I like how this email is going so far. Whether it be female, puberty, vocal fry, or your excellent double duo with the Stuff You Miss in History class crew and Listener Mail, you nailed what I consider to be the best way to handle the ubiquitous double standards that women find themselves held to.
State that it is unequivocally wrong, then calmly and rationally pick apart why. You are not trying to start a gender war, though I'm sure there are those out there who will take it as such. Let's see, beginning of this email. But you meticulously undercut the arguments and unconscious justifications that allow these attitudes to endure. For underneath all the truths by consensus and familial and cultural norms, very little remains to give weight to these perspectives. And I believe that both genders are, albeit slowly, shedding them thanks to the efforts of you and many others on this path. Very well said, right?
Yeah, for real. This is the road to equality, dudes. I threw that in there. And I cannot say how much I appreciate your proper championing of it. We are all persons, no matter our gender, and should be respected as such, free as much as possible of worthless generalizations. Also, as a side note, I was once upon a time a linguist and very much agree with your handling of sociolinguistics. A linguist's... Sorry, Chuck. Is that because I said like... Linguistist? Linguistinator or something weird? Linguistinator. A linguist's most fundamental tenet is that no use of language to communicate is wrong and thus linguistic evolution should be no more surprising than that of pop music or fashion.
Yeah, the prescriptivists are just screaming at their iPods right now. Ideas and perspectives change, and language by its nature will rise to meet it. Cheers. That is from David, a longtime Stuff You Should Know fan. Thanks a lot, David. That was a very kind email. Very well said. Representative, I would say about half of the emails that we got about Vocal Fry. The other half, if you want to get in touch with us, you can tweet to us at SYSK Podcast. You can join us on Facebook.com slash StuffYouShouldKnow. You can send us an email to StuffPodcast at HowStuffWorks.com. And as always, join us at our home on the web, StuffYouShouldKnow.
com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Toyotathon is on. So stop by your local Toyota dealer for incredible year-end deals on the cars, trucks, and SUVs known for their legendary reliability. Like the stylish and efficient Camry, the ready-for-anything RAV4, or check out a rough-and-rugged Tacoma or Tundra. All with great financing and lease options available to qualified customers. Visit BuyAToyota.com to find out more. Toyota, let's go places. Support for the show comes from Public, the investing platform for those who take it seriously. On Public, you can build a multi-asset portfolio of stocks, bonds, options, crypto, and now generated assets, which allow you to turn any idea into an investable index with AI.
It all starts with your prompt. From renewable energy companies with high free cash flow to semiconductor suppliers growing revenue over 20% year over year, you can literally type any prompt and put the AI to work. It screens thousands of stocks, builds a one-of-a-kind index, and let you backtest it against the S&P 500. Then you can invest in a few clicks. Generated assets are like EFTs with infinite possibilities, completely customizable and based on your thesis, not someone else's. Go to public.com slash podcast and earn an uncapped 1% bonus when you transfer your portfolio. That's public.com slash podcast.
Paid for by Public Investing. Brokerage services by Open to the Public Investing, Inc. Member FINRA SIPC. Advisory services by Public Advisors, LLC. SEC registered advisor. Generated assets is an interactive analysis tool. Output is for informational purposes only and is not investment recommendation or advice. Complete disclosures available at public.com slash disclosures. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.