Human experimentation is an age-old practice, dating back to 4 BCE. Listen in as Josh and Chuck give you the low-down on the historic, grisly underbelly of science and medicine -- human experimentation.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. And now, Superhuman Shaq. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or OSA.
In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Sometimes science goes too far. Dark matters, twisted but true. Wednesdays at 10 on Science. Hey and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. Happy New Year too, huh?
Yeah. That's Chuck Bryant, Charles W. Bryant. Baby New Year himself? Yeah. He's always chubby. He? Me? No. Baby New Year Chuck. Yeah, with the ears. Yeah. Poor kid. He always has kind of curly hair, which I'm not impartial to. Yeah, you know, growing up watching the little claymation Happy New Year baby thing, the Baby New Year? Remember with the huge ears? Huh. Oh, that's what I was just talking about. Yeah. That was like the little claymation. Like Rudolph? Yeah, but there was one for New Year's, and it was the baby that had the huge ears. When he took his hat off, his ears would pop out, and everyone would chastise him.
What did it sound like when he took his ears out? Was it like that? That's kind of what it sounded like, actually. But I always felt bad because I thought it was a cute little claymation baby. Yeah. Was that the crux of it, that he just had big ears and everybody laughed at him? Yeah, I can't remember how it ended. He finally found a home or something. I don't know. Good, because there's nothing sadder than a homeless baby on New Year's. Yeah, with big ears. Chuck. Josh. Have you ever heard of Herophilus? I have. Okay. You want to talk a bit about Herophilus? Sure. Journey back to 4th century B.
C., or as you like to say, B.C.E. Yeah. The new B.C. Right. he's known as the father of anatomy. Yeah, and one of the ways that he became known as the father of anatomy was by dissecting, vivisecting live human beings. Yes. Live, well, I was about to say live cadaver, but a cadaver is dead. Sure. Live human patients dissecting for science. Right, and I believe they were criminals, right? Many times, yes. So we're talking about human experimentation. We're basing this on an article written by the fine, esteemed writer Robert Lamb. And he starts out page zero with this account of Herophilus cutting through the eyeball of a guy who is strapped to a table.
And I guess something's stuffed in his mouth to muffle the screams. But his eyeball is being dissected in front of a group of surgeons by Herophilus. Can I read this one line? Yeah, please do. Once more, the master pot's flesh enters the bloody maze of arteries and muscle. I know. We should have gotten RL in here to read it himself. Yeah, that's good stuff. So, yeah, apparently this guy that Robert's writing about, this victim, was one of more than 600 that were vivisected at the hands of Herophilus over the course of his lifetime, right? Yes, for alive prisoners. Yeah, so that's kind of sickening.
It is horrific. Right. But it was apparently par for the course, right? Yeah, at the time, sure. So all these people, why would you dissect a live person or vivisect a live person? I think it's dissect if it's dead and vivisect if they're alive. Is it? I believe so. Well, I mean, there's reasons for it. You wouldn't want to justify it, but they were doing that because sometimes you just need a human to perform an experiment on. and sometimes a cadaver doesn't do the job, and before there were scruples, they would do it on a live person instead of like an animal test. Right. Apparently back in Herophilus' age also they thought that air was carried in the circulatory system rather than blood, which is weird because if you vivisect a person, blood comes out.
Sure. Although I imagine air does too since you can't see it. They're like, oh, it's air. This is just something. And this guy's the father of anatomy? He is. Come on. Here's the big ironic twist. All of his writings, all the notes he took, all the scholarly works he created based on the deaths or the intolerable pain experienced by these 600 people were all lost. Yeah. When the Library of Alexandria burned in 272 A.D. This is rapidly devolving into a sound effect show. Yeah. Should we tell people what that is? Sure. Jerry got us a little gift for Christmas, a little sound machine. And the funny thing is that she asked us to keep it on the DL, and we just told it 100,000 people.
Yeah. Yeah. The other funny thing is that she actually said we could use it. I thought she was going to say, well, here, but you can never use this. Right. Yeah, and she encouraged us to use it as well. Right. So, Chuck, the idea of somebody writhing under the knife while a guy like Hierophilus or anybody else with a sharp object cuts his eyeball open to examine the nerves inside, is a pretty horrific idea. Indeed. And the problem is, is this kind of thing didn't end in AD 272. No, it continued on. Apparently, history is littered with human experimentation. Yes, so much so that there were body snatching problems in the 19th century because medical schools needed bodies.
Right. You couldn't, in the 19th century, by the 19th century, you couldn't vivisect anybody. You weren't supposed to. Sure. And also, because of the puritanical ideals, you couldn't do any kind of dissection on cadavers. You're right. Now, of course, you can. Right. Which is a good move. Yeah. Because, like you said, there was a lot of grave robbing going on to supply the medical schools who still needed this knowledge and wanted it and were willing to pay grave robbers for it. Yeah, big time. Do you remember back in 1989 when they found some bones, actually 9,800 bones in the basement of Medical College of Georgia?
Really? Yeah. Did not know that. Yeah. They dated back to the 19th century, and they were linked to robbed graves. Wow. Yeah. That's crazy. Isn't it? It is. So that's if you're dealing with cadavers. If you wanted to experiment on a live living thing, then you would now have to go the route of chimps and rabbits and mice, rats. Right, which actually what we've done from what I understand is with human experimentation, we've put lower – I'm making air quotes here – lower species in between us and initial discovery. Right? Yeah, the problem was back in the day, though, they did the same thing, but they considered lower species other humans.
Specifically convicts. Yeah, or poor and destitute, diseased. Exactly. But convicts, for sure. Convicts have pretty much always gotten it pretty bad as far as human experimentation goes. But, yeah, so these days we do put rabbits and rats and chimps and macaques in between us and, you know, not knowing what a drug will do or something like that. But really, ultimately, it still ends up to humans. Sure. And one of the reasons why is because, you know, you can't – we don't even know whether or not animals experience happiness. You know, do they – how can we figure out if they're hallucinating? Yeah, sure.
They can't help self-report. Yeah, you've got to ask questions every now and then. Right. And then also, I mean, if you're doing – if you're making a drug for humans, you eventually have to find out exactly what it does to a human. Right. It's not going to have the same effect on a rat, although it will probably be close. Yeah, and we'll get into that in a minute. All right. Should we talk about some of the horrific things that have happened throughout our history, Josh? Well, don't forget the – hold on. There's another route you could take. Oh, yeah. I know it. Self-experimentation. Yes. Your living self experimenting on yourself.
Which, I mean, there have been some famous examples of this. Yes, famously Pierre and Marie Curie earned a Nobel Prize in physics for radiation research. Yeah. And they did this by taping radium salts to their skin and seeing what happened. Right. So that's one way to do it. Another guy who famously tried his research out on himself is Albert Hoffman. Oh, really? The guy who created LSD. Right. And apparently he had a diary where he writes about his bike ride home after injecting himself with LSD. And he had no bike. I hope it. Oh, right. No, he had a bike, but he was like, wow, nothing is real.
Yeah. And I really feel like listening to Pink Floyd right now. Yeah. The yet-to-be-discovered Pink Floyd. The yet-to-be-born, I think, even. Oh, yeah. So, Chuck, self-experimentation has its own flaws, right? Of course. If you're vivisecting an eyeball and you do it to yourself, you can't do that more than once. No. You probably wouldn't even do it that one time. Yeah. So, really, there is a lot to be gained from vivisecting human beings. We don't do it. And one of the reasons why is because it's horrific. So, yes, let's talk about some of the horrific human experiments that litter history. J.
Marion Sims. Does that name ring a bell? No. That is considered to be the father of gynecology. Oh, yeah, J. Marion Sims. Sims. And he even became the president of the AMA in 1876. Right. But he developed experimental surgeries by testing them on African slaves many times without anesthesia. Yeah. Dark side for sure, man. Yeah, I would definitely call that a dark side. Yeah, he gets lauded probably in many circles still today. He does. Apparently, that was, we think of the Nazis especially, and we'll talk about them in a minute, but the U.S. has a really shady history of human experimentation.
A guy named Dr. Leo Stanley injected prisoners at San Quentin with animal testes to slow or reverse aging, which did not work out. Yeah. 1906. Yeah. Cholera experiments in the Philippines conducted by us. Uh-huh. 1915, pellagra experiments in Mississippi. Right. And then apparently, we were talking about how prisoners have always gotten a bad rap. Up until the 1970s in the United States, pretty much all pharmaceuticals were tested on convicts. Yeah. So you did not want to break a law. No. I wonder, you know how people harken back to like the golden age when there was less crime and less violence and all that?
Sure. I wonder how much of it had to do with the fact that if you went to prison, like you would be experimented on. Yeah. I wonder if you know that though. It probably wasn't widely reported until you get to prison. Then you're like, oh, oops. Yeah, that's, yeah. Had I known. Right. But I imagine recidivism rates, that's a bonehead word, were pretty low. Yeah, you're probably right. So, Chuck, you know also the United States was huge into compulsory sterilization, right? I did not know that. The eugenics movement. Oh, okay. So between, I guess, the early 1900s, the first decade of the 20th century, up until the 70s, I think maybe even 1981, 64,000 people in the United States were sterilized against their will.
Wow. Like epileptics, the mentally handicapped, the blind, deaf, mutes, schizophrenics, and Native Americans. Right. Against their will, sometimes unknowingly. Unbelievable. Yeah, which that's not necessarily an experiment because you know exactly what's going to happen. The person is going to be sterilized. Yeah, true. But if you look at it as eugenics, it is kind of a larger experiment to basically create a great race. Right. And then the eugenics, the popularity, I mean, it was well known. This was going on. This was in a secret government program. Right, like MKUltra. Right, and there was public support for it until World War II, which remember, actually, can you remember to the future?
Yes. When we talk about mercenaries. Right, right. World War II changed everything, right? It did. Yeah, the Nazis really led the way when it comes to human experimentation. As everyone knows, against the Jews, gypsies, anyone they felt like targeting, they would do things like freezing them to research hypothermia. That actually became huge later. Their hypothermia research is really used still. Yeah, and we'll get into the ethics of that. They put them in compression chambers to test the effects of high-altitude flight. It doesn't get much worse than that. And sterilization experiments as well, like the U.
S. was doing. They would use phosphorus, incendiary phosphorus devices to figure out how to treat phosphorus burns. Japan was another country. Yeah. Their Unit 731, very famous unit, reportedly killed more than 10,000 Chinese, Korean, and Russian POWs. Yeah. to develop biological weapons and test the stuff out on them, basically. Right. So the Nazis in particular faced the music at Nuremberg, right? Oh, yeah. And there was this part to the Nuremberg trials called the doctor's trials. And I think a bunch of the guys, like 17 were convicted, and most of them I think were hanged. Really? Yeah. And a lot of these guys' cases were, we didn't break any laws.
There's no lawful outline of what to do when you're experimenting on a human. And a lot of this stuff followed the same kind of protocol that we had before the war, right? Right. Which is just horrendous, but in a lot of cases it was actually true, right? Sure. So one of the results of the Nuremberg trial was the Nuremberg Code, where the international community said, all right, we need to outline some guidelines for human experimentation. Right. And I think there's like 10 points to it, 10 large overviews to human experimentation guidelines. And it focuses on reducing fear and pain and discomfort in the experiment subjects.
They can't be coerced. It has to be willing. They have to be informed. What's this covered by? What's that under? Do you know? Like what document or organization that's under? I don't. Probably the UN. Okay. I would think the UN would have something to do with that. Yeah, you would think so. But yes, but it's very famous. It's called the Nuremberg Code, right? And it solves the moral quandary. Did you ever see extreme measures, Gene Hackman, Hugh Grant? Yeah, yeah. All right, so you know, and I think they're in a sewer somehow. Gene Hackman's like, if you had to kill one to save a million, wouldn't you have to do it?
And so the Nuremberg Code solves that. And the answer, by the way, is no, you wouldn't kill one. Yeah, that's the age-old question, though. Right. Kill one to save many. Which is a very utilitarian view of looking at things like, yes, you kill one person to save a million. Of course you do. But we, as an international collective, have decided that you don't do that. One person's life is worth as much as a million people's potential lives. Right. So that brings us to the real quandary, though, with human experimentation is what do you do with this information that is gained from these awful, awful experiments?
Right. But a lot of detractors will say that to use this information supports human experimentation. Right. But then another way of looking at it is to propose, like kind of do a thought experiment of, all right, let's say that you are, you walk in on one of these experiments and you say your death is inevitable. And it's going to be a painful, horrible death. But you can choose whether or not this data that results from your death is suppressed or used. Right. Which one do you want? And then most people would say, well, if I'm going to die anyway, I would want this data to be used. That's the argument the other side uses.
Yeah, the U.S. cut a little deal, though, with U-731. I know. We have such a shady history. Like we used Nazi scientists to get us to the moon. Well, this was particularly to keep it from falling into the wrong hands. So we thought, hey, rather than give that to the Russians, Unit 731, let's cut a deal where the officers responsible for this get immunity from prosecution and war crimes, and we get the data, and we'll even give you a little stipend on the side. We'll give you some money. Yeah. Way to come up with those biological weapons. Nicely done. Right. Like we said, the Nazi hypothermia experiments, which are pretty brutal.
Apparently, they would put you in an icy vat of water with a thermometer in your rectum. And they found that most people died, went unconscious and died when their body temperature hit 77 degrees Fahrenheit, right? Yeah, it's such useful information. No, the useful information came in they were looking for ways to revive people suffering from hypothermia because the Germans were losing so many people on the eastern front in Germany that they actually did figure out ways of quickly reviving people suffering from hypothermia. So post-war hypothermia researchers are like, dude, these people, as ghastly as these experiments are, they figured out how to revive people suffering from hypothermia.
We need that information. Right. So I think with that, I guess that group leading the charge, Nazi data has been used in a lot of ways, but then it should be cited, I think, was the compromise that they came up with. Yeah, and it actually worked the other way, too. Jewish doctors would later study victims of starvation in the ghetto, in the Warsaw ghetto. Right, yeah. And they used that to aid in the study of hunger-associated disease. Right. So they found a way to use it, at least. Right. And so we were talking also about how the U.S. has a nice, long history of horrible stuff, like the Tuskegee experiments.
You want to talk about that? Yes. A 40-year study of syphilis began in 1932, and they used African Americans who sought treatment for this disease, and they basically straight up lied and deceived them, thinking they were being treated. Right. They actually didn't use any kind of medical intervention because they wanted to watch the progression of syphilis. Yeah, they wanted to see it get worse, and so they could chart everything out, and they had no idea. And then I guess finally in 1994, no, 1997, the U.S. issues a public apology for this. And there's still some people alive who were experimented on.
Unbelievable. Yeah. And we documented the LSD experiments that unsuspecting Americans were dosed in the MKUltra project. We did a whole show on that, didn't we? Yeah. That was a good one. Of course. Yeah, it was like our best one. Didn't we? Did you forget? Well, it was a long time ago, man. Yeah, well, you were kind of out of it, if you remember the beginning of that one. Was I? Yeah. Oh, that's right. Yeah. We did a little role-playing. So, Chuck, there was kind of a huge sea change in the way that human experimentation was looked at and carried out when the FDA was established in the 30s. Sure.
All of a sudden, there were review boards and panels. The universities kind of stepped in and said, all right, we play a big role in this. we're going to start establishing stricter oversight of human experimentation. And that's kind of the course that we've followed since then, right? Yeah, they're called drug trials. Drug trials, exactly. Do you know any human guinea pigs? No, I've never done it. But, you know, phase one drug trials is usually where you'll get the most folks because you need healthy individuals. Right, who are willing to risk their health for money. And basically what they're doing in these phase one trials are, you know, when you see these commercials that rattle off 100 side effects that are positively frightening, they get these from giving these medications to people and seeing what happens, basically.
Right, yeah. Robert Lamb put it really well. He said that if your bottle of medication says that it might result in bowel control problems or suicidal thoughts, you can bet that someone received a paycheck for experiencing them at some point. Yeah, exactly. How else would they know? Yeah. So that's phase one. And phase two deals with dosing and efficiency. And phase three enlists actual patients who need this treatment. Right. Not healthy people. And people who volunteer for phase one clinical trials are handsomely paid, depending on the risk involved. That's one of the problems. Yeah. And, I mean, it's kind of like a vacation.
You're fed and you're put up maybe in a hotel or the hospital room has, like, a video game console. You watch movies or whatever. and they just shoot you full of something and then come in like every 15 minutes or hour or whatever and say, you know, like, have you seen that leprechaun you were talking to earlier again? You know, that kind of stuff. But that's one of the problems is that some of these folks bounce from experiment to experiment and, you know, kind of make a half-assed living off of this. Right. I guess you can. I mean, especially if you're dedicated. He talks about, Lamb talks about an article in The New Yorker that is about, it's called guinea pigging, I believe.
And it's about a soap culture of clinical drug trial participants who have their own publications that show what upcoming drug trials are in the pipeline and how much they're going to pay and that kind of stuff. So there's a concern that these people are kind of hooked on this lifestyle. Right. My thing is to each his own. Sure. You know? Yeah, I mean, if there are no laws being broken and they're getting paid and they're willing to do this instead of going to get a job delivering pizzas, then, you know, good on you. Frankly, if they can get my pizza to me and stay safe, not harm other people, and deliver a delicious pizza still, I don't care if they're in the midst of a drug trial right then.
Here's another thing I didn't know that I thought was interesting in this article, is that they kind of put the pedal to the metal when it comes to these trials because a U.S. drug patent only lasts for 20 years. And so if you're hung up for a decade in research and testing, which can happen, then they don't start it over once you get it approved. You've got only 10 years left to make serious money. Right. So they speed these things along. They do. Now, if you're running it through a university, they generally have – Well, universities have a reputation for being total sticklers when it comes to institutional review boards, right?
Right. So as a result, I think that a lot of drug companies have found that if you run it instead through a private organization that does the clinical trials for you, then all of a sudden you can walk around a lot of these ethical guidelines or safe conditions. And yet again, outsourcing to private contractors for money, it's the way to get around things. exactly it's awful so that's medical experimentation there's a really cool article it's slightly outside of the How Stuff Works voice Robert Lamb put his all into it he put his Lamb stamp on it at the very least you gotta read page zero and I defy you to just read page zero for those of you out there page zero is really page one that's the insider lingo here Chuck and I have worked here for more than two years and we've still never figured out why they call it page zero.
I have no idea. So if you want to read page zero of how human experimentation works, you can type in human experimentation in the handy search bar at howstuffworks.com. And I guess you can say that that leads us to listener mail. Yes, Josh, this is about narco states. I remember narco states. I'm going to call it narco state email. Okay. This is from Christer, who I actually had to write Krister back and say, are you a boy or a girl? Because I'd never heard that name, and Krister's a dude. So Krister says, I currently live in Juarez, Mexico. What? Yeah, exactly, because we covered Juarez pretty thoroughly.
Yeah. It is sad to stand out as a dangerous narco zone rather than being recognized for a decent achievement. But things here are indeed pretty crazy. Murders are super high, and I've tragically lost some friends throughout the year. As if this wasn't enough, Even the government is messing with us, as I had an experience last July. My parents happened to own a clothing shop, and we were asked by some federal agents to give out a big amount of money, $250,000 to be exact. Just because, of course, my family refused to do so, a week later, they came with an order to close and empty my parents' shop and locked up my dad.
We gave a smaller amount just so he was released, and we thought it would just end there. But to our surprise, a month later, we were surrounded by about 20 agents holding an apprehension order to take both of my parents, charging them for supposedly commercializing pirated clothing, which was a trumped-up charge. Good Lord. I know. I was left alone with my three younger brothers for more than three months until the agent on top agreed to let them out of prison for $50,000, and the case was closed. It was a sick experience, and thank God it was finally over. throughout those three months of grief, you guys were right there with me, and you were a nice distraction from my awful situation at a time that was clearly troubling, and I want to thank you for that.
It probably doesn't mean the same to you guys, but it was helpful in some way for me. I no longer want to live in this place, and I'm just looking forward to moving to the U.S. as soon as possible. I'll bet. I know. So we just wanted to share this and say Merry Christmas. So we had some angry people write in, by the way, about me saying we should just drop the borders and let anyone in. And I just want to say to those folks, think about people like Krister here who are just dying to get to the United States because of stuff like this. And the U.S. represents something great to them, and we shouldn't forget that.
Yeah. So I'm on my high horse, and now I'm getting off of it. Thanks, Chuck. Do we have a horse effect? No? Let's see. We've got something close to it, and that would be... Weird. If you have an email about escaping certain death, being extorted by the Mexican military, or any kind of unjust story, right? Sure. Yeah. You can send it in an email to stuffpodcast at... Wait. Happy New Year, everybody. Yeah, happy new year. Be safe. Krister, we're glad you're alive. Yes. We're glad everybody who made it through 2009 made it through 2009. Yes. At HowStuffWorks.com For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.
com. Want more HowStuffWorks? Check out our blogs on the HowStuffWorks.com homepage. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kids-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kids' bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together.
And get this. This holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.