Impeachment is does not necessarily mean a president is removed from office. But it could. It's a fascinating procedure that has been crafted and shaped over the years because of a lack of detail in its initial definition. Listen in today to learn all about the weird and wacky process of impeachment.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Get your mother-loving ears on because your big-time radio DJ's got news. PayPal lets you choose how you want to pay for all the stuff. With PayPal, I can pay in-store, pay online, or pay over time. What's that? You want this translated into song? I hope you're sitting down. You can pay your own way. You keep those ears on, you hear? Don't just pay, baby. PayPal. Learn more at PayPal.com. In Orlando, meetings reach another level. Thanks to a growing list of award-winning restaurants, a world-class convention center, a great hotel community, easy access through the airport, and of course, the weather.
Andrew Moyes, VP of Fan Expo HQ, had this to say about Orlando. Luxury hotels, Michelin restaurants, easy access through the airport, all those key things feed into the proper executive experience. And while you may know Orlando for its attractions, industries like healthcare, aerospace, and advanced manufacturing make it a hub for cutting-edge businesses. And that's what makes Orlando unbelievably real. Learn more at OrlandoForBusiness.com. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. There's Charles W. Chuck Bryant. There's Jerry over there.
And this is business, baby. Stuff you should know on impeachment. Yeah. Guilty. How are you doing? First, let's get the pleasantries out of the way. I'm doing well, and I want to give a shout-out at the head here because just yesterday in real time, I went over to my in-law's house for my grandmother-in-law's 97th birthday. Happy birthday, Mary. Happy birthday, Mary. The lead general of the Stuff You Should Know Army. No, you're not on Facebook, so every year I put a happy birthday on the Stuff You Should Know page and have everyone chime in from where they are because she literally sits there.
And reads through like 600 comments from all over the world. Oh, that's cool. And it is like one of the best things for her. That's really great. It's really neat. So anyway, we're over there and my father-in-law, Steve, who is the best dude, comes up to me and says, How about a show on impeachment? Yeah? And he didn't recommend. He knows better. He doesn't recommend shows, topics. And he went, how about one on impeachment? I went, wow, Steve, that's a great idea. I said, why haven't we done that yet? Because it's relevant, as we will see at the end of our show today. We'll talk about kind of what's going on in today's terms.
and it's just a really weird, vaguely written, as it turns out, strange act, American style. I'm not exactly sure how they do it in other countries, but the way we do it is weird. I think it's just about as weird in other countries because it was adopted either from the British or from the Americans, and we adopted it from the British. Yeah, it seems to have been understood in Great Britain, but the framers of the Constitution didn't bother to ask what anybody meant. They just kind of borrowed it. So anyway, big shout out to Steve. All right, Steve. Good idea. For this idea. It's the summer of Steve.
It's winter. Although he's from Ohio, but now he's in Georgia, so it is like summer for him. I'm sure. All right, so Chuck, let's get down to this. Let's get down to impeachment. Are we going in the Wayback Machine right off the bat here? Do you want to go back to 1868? You want to start there? Well, you know I do. Okay. Well, let's get in the Wayback Machine then. Because you know I loved me the spring of 1868. It was a good one. It sure was. That's funny you say that. There's this really great short story from the 50s or 60s. I think it's like a horror short story called The Vintage Season.
It's about these future travelers who, in the future, you can travel through time and find the perfect spring or the perfect whatever. Oh, interesting. It's pretty good. Check it out. All right. Well, now let's get in the Wayback Machine. All right. Let's fire it up. Okay. So, remember, we're invisible. We can do anything. I know. I just booped Edmund Ross on the nose. Yeah, I just took off my shoes. Everyone's like, what's that on my nose and what's that in my nose? Right. So there's this dude, that dude you just bopped on the nose, Edmund Ross. Senator. He's a senator, actually. And he's kind of new.
What is this? This is May of 1868. Just the previous July, he was appointed to his seat as the senator, the junior senator of Kansas. He had, like, some experience in newspapers. That was his jam. No real political experience. And now all of the entire Senate is wondering, what is this guy going to do? We're right in the middle of an impeachment trial. Actually, the impeachment hearing of President Andrew Johnson, who is the successor of Abraham Lincoln, right? That's right. And so by December after the assassination of Lincoln in April of 65, his own party was turning against him and saying, hey, we want to get this guy out of here.
So let's – we haven't tried this impeachment thing on a president yet, and we're kind of eager to. Yeah, and you can make the case that he was kind of set up. His own party turned on him. Totally set up. But the Republicans hated him out of the gate. The Republicans were the ones who were pushing Reconstruction and really wanted the South to pay for seceding and for the Civil War. And Johnson was from Tennessee and wasn't having that. He vetoed a bill that would have given basic civil rights to black Americans. He was against the 14th Amendment. He decided it should be up to the states to figure out how they wanted to handle the post-slavery laws.
regardless of what effect that had on the former slaves. So it wasn't very well liked by the abolitionist Republicans, and they wanted to get rid of him. And the way that they did was to set up this new law, which was patently unconstitutional. It was called the, what was it called? The You Can't Fire That Dude Law. Yeah, that's basically the gist of it. The Tenure Act, I believe, is the Tenure of Office Act. So, you know, when when a president comes in and they appoint like cabinet members or, you know, a Supreme Court judge or something, they can pick the person. But the Senate has to either confirm them or say, no, not this one.
Right. Right. So the Senate has confirmation powers in the president's ability to hire. The Constitution even says it in there. The Constitution doesn't say anything about firing those appointees. And so it had long been that the president could fire whoever of their appointees he wanted to, right? So what the radical Republicans did was pass a bill that said, if you hire somebody, if you appoint somebody, we get to confirm them. If you try to remove somebody, we have to approve that as well. And again, it just flew in the face of the Constitution as we know it. And the right away, Andrew Johnson fired his secretary of war, Edwin Stanton, and he was impeached right out of the gate.
That reminds me of when earlier this year when Jared Kushner was taking his first big tour of the White House after the election. Remember when he met all the Obama employees and was like, oh, so like how many of these people are going to be staying on? And they're like, nobody. This wasn't a corporate takeover, you realize. It's not how government works. He's like, oh, yeah, sure. Well, yeah. No, I didn't hear about that. It was pretty funny. Like he just bought a company. He's like, oh, how many people are going to be staying around? Oh, my. Yeah. So now Andrew Johnson is impeached. He's broken a law that Congress had just passed, and they've impeached him.
So what's going on? Well, here's the deal. At the time, they – and it's kind of like this now to a certain degree, but everybody knew how everyone was going to vote ahead of time except for him. So basically – Except for Ross, right? Yeah, basically everybody knew the outcome, what the outcome was going to be, except for Ross, meaning that he was the deciding vote. Like it was that slim of a margin. And so that's why he was so nervous. He was just sitting there apparently just shredding this paper up as they were going around the room and everyone was saying guilty or not guilty because you need two-thirds of the Senate vote or a supermajority to enact this impeachment.
So he was just sitting there and no one knew what was going to happen. He stood up. He said he thought later on that he were facing death and he said, not guilty. And everyone sighed. And this article points out they don't know if it was a sigh of relief or upset, probably both, depending on which side of the aisle you're on. Yeah, the whole thing's recounted really well in this book called Impeached by the historian David O. Stewart, which I think where this guy got this. But he does a good job getting to the heart of the matter, which was this guy, Edmund Ross, was from that moment on celebrated as this hero, this constitutional hero.
He stood up and said, you know what? I'm not going to let the Constitution be railroaded because you guys don't like Andrew Johnson. And he's been kind of honored as that since then. And I've read a couple articles that are like, hmm, actually, he was just looking out for himself. Johnson was his benefactor. He had basically appointed him, and he had a lot of favoritism with him. And this new guy who would have come in, I think Benjamin Ward, would not have carried on the same thing. But regardless, if you are a constitutionalist, this guy is your hero because he did save the Constitution with that one vote.
That's right. So what took place was an impeachment proceeding, and that one was awfully close. That was the first impeachment proceeding of a U.S. president, but that would not be the last. There's been two more presidents, three total, that have faced down the impeachment gun, and there have been varying results. But as yet, there has never been a president that was successfully convicted once they've been impeached. because impeachment is not conviction. It's a couple of different things. You want to take a break and then get into it? Yeah, because I don't want to confuse people right off the bat here any more than we need to.
I think it's a little late for that. So we'll go gather our thoughts, take a little podcast or potty break. Be back right after this. If you want to know, then you're in luck. Just listen up to Josh and Chuck. Stuff you should know. Get your mother-loving ears on because your big-time radio DJ's got news. PayPal lets you choose how you want to pay for all the stuff. With PayPal, I can pay in-store, pay online, or pay over time. What's that? You want this translated into song? I hope you're sitting down. You can pay your own way. You keep those ears on, you hear? Don't just pay, baby. PayPal. Learn more at PayPal.
com. The universe is full of mysteries. Black holes, quantum physics, galaxies. On TikTok, millions of people are learning more about the universe around them every day. Scientists break down complex theories, demonstrate experiments, and connect dots between the cosmos and our daily lives. One scroll might reveal the concepts on the fabric of space-time, the next an optical illusion. It's discovery on a massive scale where millions learn something new every day. Stuff you should know. Stuff you should know. All right, should we talk about French and Latin real quick? Yes. Because the roots of words are always fun to talk about.
The French word impertire means to prevent, related to the English word impede, and both originally derived from the Latin term empedicare. Man, your French is just so romantic. And that means to fetter. So basically what impeachment root-wise means is to put a stop to movement of something. In this case, and not always the president, as we'll see, any elected official? Any federal? Civil officer is what they finally landed on. Okay. But yeah, like a federal official, somebody who is appointed by the president, the president, the vice president, judges typically, but not senators or congresspeople.
They can just be run out of town on a bale of hay. Yeah, basically, yeah. Man, once you see that bale of hay coming, and you know that it tolls for thee. You know the tar is right behind it. That's a bad day for you. All right, so the origins of impeachment, though, pre-United States. So we're talking British legal history here. There's a dude named TFT Plunkett Plucknett. Interesting. Plucknett. He's a 1940s historian. I guess so. I could have sworn it was Plunkett. So TFT Plucknett says that 14th century parliament was the first time impeachment came about. And during that time, there were a couple of different cases over like an 11 year period that had a pretty big shift from one to the next that would kind of frame how impeachment works.
Right. So at the time back then in the 14th century, right? Yeah. The king could appoint, there were all manner of positions that the king could appoint. And once you were appointed by the king, that was it. You only answered to the king. You could do anything you wanted. And as long as you had the king's favor, there was nothing anyone could do. So at one point, and I'm not sure how they took it upon themselves, but this article says that it grew out of a trial of Roger Mortimer, who was convicted and executed for arranging the murder of King Edward II. Yeah, that counts. And then Chief Justice Willoughby, who was accused of corruption and tried.
These two guys were like high appointed officials and they were removed from office. And the way that they were removed was basically the parliament got involved. So this idea of impeaching people grew out of the notion that, wait a minute, Parliament, and specifically the House of Commons, which is if you take Parliament and Congress in the United States, the House of Lords is like the Senate and the House of Commons is like the House of Representatives, right? The House of Commons were the ones who would take it upon themselves to say, this person is bad and we're going to get rid of them. We're going to act as their jury and try them and remove them from their appointed position.
And King, there's nothing you can do about it because we're the ones who hold the purse strings, really. So you better go along with this. And this idea of impeaching was huge. It was revolutionary in Great Britain. And it was equally revolutionary in the founding of the United States, too, because if you'll remember, the United States was founded at a time where Americans were very, very wary of kings pushing them around. And in the Constitution is this role, this office of the presidency, which is a very strong executive ruler, a king almost. And there's a legal scholar, Cass Sunstein, who wrote this great article about all this, about impeachment.
And he says a lot of historians agree that the Constitution probably wouldn't have been ratified if these few words about impeachment hadn't been added into the Constitution to give Americans the power to remove a corrupt president from office. Yeah, I mean, they it was almost I mean, it ended up being very important, but it was almost an afterthought in how they went about it. Because up front, they weren't saying, hey, we need to really like make sure we include this impeachment thing in here. They're worried about framing the U.S. Constitution. And then at the end, Ben Franklin very famously said, hey, you know, without impeachment, you know what?
You know what? The only other thing we can do is, is if we get a bad president is shoot him in the head. And they went, oh, well, that won't do bully, bully to that. So maybe we should write something down. I know we're all tired. We've been working on this document for 30, 45 minutes. They had fatigue. And so they ended up saying over, what, 180 words. I think it was actually less than that. I don't know where this guy came up with that. Yeah. All right. Well, seven sentences. No, it's even less than that. Really? Yeah. Oh, good Lord. I counted four run-on sentences, two of which included colons.
But, I mean, it's a sentence, four sentences, and 103 words says Microsoft Word. Really? Yeah. Well, they didn't have Microsoft Word back then, so. Right. All right, so regardless of how long it was, it was short. Right. And it was, here's the thing, it was written in a very vague language, which ended up being very troublesome, because they weren't quite sure. I think they didn't want to hem themselves in too much is my feeling on exactly what it would take to start this process. So initially they called it, was it George Mason called it maladministration? Right. In other words, just being a bad president.
Yeah, and they took that out. Well, there was a couple of reasons why they said, no, this is a little it's a little vague. But later constitutional scholars have interpreted the fact that it was suggested and removed that the framers of the Constitution didn't consider not being a very good president as a reason to be removed from office. Right. James Madison at the very least said this is just really unclear as to what this can even mean. Sure. So maladministration comes out. They hit upon, and I'm not sure if they hit upon it right out of the gate or if it came later, but they hit upon bribery and treason, which there's no issues with that.
Everyone knows what bribery is. Everyone knows what treason is. It's pretty clear. But they still are saying, no, this isn't – it's still not quite there. James Mason spoke up again. He said, you can really screw with the democracy of America even without taking bribes, even without committing a statutory treasonous act. So maybe we need to add something. So that's when he came up with maladministration and said, no, no, that's stupid. But then they came up with something else. Yeah, he finally said, because, again, they didn't want to be hemmed in too much, But they also didn't want to be so specific with just bribery and treason that that was the only thing that you could use impeachment for.
So he finally said, all right, good God, it's late. What about high crimes and misdemeanors? And then went, oh, perfect. Yeah, that's great. No one even knows what it means. It'll be perfect. What's funny is no one now knows what it means, but apparently it was quite clear what it meant at the time. Oh, really? Yeah. Yeah. Supposedly a high crime, it doesn't mean like, oh, my God, that's such a huge crime. Or, oh, I'm super stoned. Right. Yeah. They did grow hemp, by the way. Yes. But a high crime or a high misdemeanor is a type of crime that can only be committed by a high person, a.k.a. an elected or federal official.
Yeah, but that's what the high part means. It's still just a crime or a misdemeanor. Like, I think it's still vague. So, okay, so later scholars have interpreted high crimes and misdemeanors to mean it's a crime or a misdemeanor that is carried out and can only be carried out by somebody in an elected position. So it's a betrayal of the public trust that an elected or federal official is given, okay? And that the crimes part that throws people off, a high crime can be – it doesn't have to be an actual crime. Okay? So you can be impeached for a high crime that if you go and read the U.S. Code is not actually a federal crime.
Right. You're not breaking the law. But you could still be impeached for it even though it's not an actual crime. And then conversely, an actual crime isn't necessarily an impeachable offense. That what the framers were trying to get at here was that the president or the vice president or whoever was being impeached had betrayed the public trust, had used their elected position, their high position in a way that was – that rendered them unfit to serve any longer. They could not be trusted any longer. They had proven themselves a lech, a terrible person, and had discharged their duties as president in a malodorous way.
Said the guy whose shoes are off in Congress. They cleared the room, man, pretty quick. Nice work. It's like Elizabeth Warren taking to the podium. Right, when she takes her shoes off. People clear out of there. She's had, like, onions for lunch. That lady will just eat a whole onion raw. Have you ever seen it? It's amazing. Where did I see that recently? A whole onion raw? No, it was like a movie or something. Oh, I know what it was. The movie, the kid was hung over, and the parent comes in the next morning, and they're like, here, eat this onion, trust me. And the kid starts to eat the onion, and they're like, just kidding.
crap. What movie was that? I can't remember what movie it was. Back to the Future 2. Yeah, that was it. Okay. When Marty's Hangover. That was the full name. Back to the Future 2, Marty's Hangover. Colon, the onion. So here's the deal, though. It's one of two things, though, when it comes to impeachment. It's either literally a crime, but it doesn't have to be. And if it's not a crime, literally, then it's probably something political going on in that it is they feel that it is subverting the office of the president. Right. That's the general interpretation. But again, I mean, like they didn't say high crimes and demeanor or high crimes and misdemeanors and asterisks.
Right. And then define that. Right. So it's open to interpretation. Yes. And it still is today, which is why unless you are a president or a vice president have been actually caught accepting bribes or committing treason, there's a lot of wiggle room for you to get out of this. Yeah. And impeachment doesn't send you to jail like you can then be tried for treason. And that would continue to jail. Yeah. It specifically says in the Constitution that this is strictly to remove the person from office, possibly to prevent them from ever holding federal office again. Right. But that you have to leave it to the regular courts to try and punish them if it's an actual crime separately.
That's different. But it's weird because the impeachment process, as we'll see, is very much like a kangaroo court trial, basically. Well, let's go ahead and talk about it. Okay. So if you're impeached, if you're a president and you do something that enough people in the House of Representatives find unsavory, you may find yourself facing impeachment. Usually that means the people in the House of Representatives are in a different political party than your own, usually. Yes. You would have to be pretty bad for your own party to be the ones who drew up the articles of impeachment to start, right?
Correct. So with the articles of impeachment, it can be introduced typically these days, from what I understand, there's a judiciary committee in the House, and they will be responsible for drumming up the articles of impeachment and then introducing them to the House as a whole. But an individual representative can come up with articles of impeachment himself or herself and introduce it on the House floor to be voted one way or another, which just happened actually at the beginning of December. Yes. A lone representative, Al King, I think from Texas, introduced articles of impeachment and it got voted down.
So you can do it yourself as just a lone dude or dude-ess, but normally it's the Judiciary Committee, I think because the parties tend to try to keep a stranglehold on stuff like that. Yeah, and even with this case, the Democrats were like, easy, easy, Al. Right. Just settle down. We're going to get there. But Al was like, I hate him so much. Too early. Too early, Al. Stand down. So as Al Stoksoff, but the process continues apparently under more normal circumstances. But he was a great example that any representative can introduce articles of impeachment. And an article of impeachment, Chuck, is like presidents who have been impeached have had, I believe, Johnson too, but definitely Nixon and Clinton.
And now Trump, he wasn't impeached, but he's had articles of impeachment brought up against him, which is significant in and of itself. Because what it's saying is we are accusing this president of this crime. And each crime or each betrayal of office, whatever you want to call it, each high crime and misdemeanor or each actual crime, it gets its own article of impeachment. So very frequently a president will be impeached with multiple articles of impeachment and the House is forced to vote on each one. Yeah. So so if you if you have like five, that means there's five chances that that president can be impeached depending on the evidence.
And so each impeachment, each article of impeachment is going to say, this is what the president did. Here's all the evidence that backs up us saying this. And House, what do you think? And then the House will vote on it. That was Al Green, by the way, not Al King. Oh, sorry. It was legendary soul singer Al Green. It was Al Green? It wasn't Al King? His name is Al Green, yeah. But it wasn't legendary soul singer Al Green. Right, sure. So if the vote gets the majority, then the president is officially impeached to that point. Yeah, and it's just a simple majority, 51%. Yeah, in the House. And basically that means it's like a criminal indictment, if we're going to be comparing it to the civilian legal standard.
So you are officially accused of this wrongdoing, which could mean you could be removed from office officially if the House is voted with a simple majority. But it's not over because then what happens is it moves over to the Senate. And at that point, that's where you need the two-thirds majority, another to finish the prosecution. And here's the thing is they didn't – And like I said, it was a very kind of short insert as far as how to go about this. So there aren't any like hard and fast rules. So whenever this has happened, they're kind of just like, all right, how do you want to do this? Right.
We're not going to have prosecutors. We're going to have what we call managers, which is a weird word for sure. But they're going to act as prosecutors and they're going to be called to argue the case before the Senate. And these are members of the House who are managing the impeachment proceedings in the Senate on behalf of the House. Correct. Because the House has said, we the House think this president should be removed. And now we're going to send some of our members to argue this case. Yes. And the Senate is essentially the jury at this point in the proceedings. Right. But they're the jury and they're also the ones who are making up the rules.
They're in charge of that as well. Which is very strange. It is. You want to hear something kind of fun? Yeah. My uncle was a manager for Clinton's impeachment trial. No. Bob Barr is your uncle? No, not Bob Barr. There are several managers. My uncle, Ed Bryant. Really? Yeah, I've talked about him before. He was a Republican congressman from Tennessee, and he was one of the managers because he was an attorney and a former Army judge advocate general. Mm-hmm. Judge advocate general? Is that what he was? Mm-hmm. Jag. Was he a jag? Well, that's what it stands for. I know, but I can't remember now.
Maybe I'm just thinking of the TV show. But he held the legal position in the Army and then was one of the Navy, I think, or the Jags, right? Oh, I don't know. He was in the Army, though. Okay, go ahead. But he was one of the managers in the Clinton impeachment trial. That is fascinating. And I got to say, Uncle Ed and I are politically divergent, but he's a good dude and an honest, kind man. I can say that for sure. So I was always proud of him as a person, even though he didn't like see eye to eye politically. But he was he's such a good guy that Monica Lewinsky requested him personally to depose her because he was just regarded as like one of the good guys and one of the like fair, like decent humans.
So he was the guy who deposed Monica Lewinsky for the Clinton impeachment trial. My father's brother. He needs a T-shirt that says that, man. You're right. That's crazy. I know, isn't it? Wow. So how does he feel about it? Because most, I shouldn't say most, a significant number of legal scholars and historians look back at that and the Andrew Johnson one and say those impeachment proceedings never should have happened, never should have passed the House and that they were partisan proceedings. Yeah, I don't know. You know, we're not super in touch anymore. But now that I'm older, I would love to pick his brain a little bit about this.
And I'm sure he would spill it, you know. Conference me in. Yeah, I'll do that. Okay. I'll, like, at the next Christmas, I'll be like, yeah, Uncle Eddie, just hold on a minute. I'm just going to put this phone down next to you. And don't pay attention to that picture of Josh. Right. As his avatar. And I'll be like, did you get my T-shirt I sent you? Yeah, pretty interesting. That's fascinating. I know, right? So, at any rate, the managers are there arguing the case before the Senate, who acts as jury, that are also making up the rules as they go. And two-thirds, like we said a couple of times, you need that two-third Senate vote.
And then at that point, if two-thirds vote guilty, then that's it, man. The president is done. Yeah, and then the vice president takes over, and that's that. You probably can't hold a federal office again after that either, although I don't think it's automatic. Right. So should we take a break? yeah alright let's take a break and we'll talk about we've already talked about Johnson we'll talk a little bit more about Mr. Bill Clinton and President Richard Milhouse Nixon right after this if you wanna know then you're in luck just listen up to Josh and Chuck stuff you should know get your mother loving ears on because you're big time Radio DJ's got news.
PayPal lets you choose how you want to pay for all the stuff. With PayPal, I can pay in-store, pay online, or pay over time. What's that? You want this translated into song? I hope you're sitting down. You can pay your own way. You keep those ears on, you hear? Don't just pay, baby. PayPal. Learn more at PayPal.com. The universe is full of mysteries. Black holes, quantum physics, galaxies. On TikTok, millions of people are learning more about the universe around them every day. Scientists break down complex theories, demonstrate experiments, and connect dots between the cosmos and our daily lives.
One scroll might reveal the concepts on the fabric of space-time, the next an optical illusion. It's discovery on a massive scale, where millions learn something new every day. Stuff you should know Stuff you should know. Okay, Chuck. Yes. So, like you said, we talked about Johnson. He got off. By one vote, man, that must have been so tense. Yeah. And then up next was, so president-wise, we'll find that there are plenty of other people who've been impeached. But in the United States, president-wise, the next president was Richard Milhouse Nixon. Yeah, it was a long break in between. Yeah, over 100 years, like 104 years, I think, something like that.
Yeah. So Nixon is getting his own episode. We're doing a Watergate episode, hopefully in the not-too-distant future. For sure. Such a fascinating case. Yeah, man. So the whole premise of what Nixon was eventually moved out of office for, he didn't actually get impeached. He resigned. But he probably would have been removed from office. He probably would have been impeached. He probably would have been convicted and he would have been removed. But he didn't give him the satisfaction. He resigned. But he he went. This is just in a few weeks. He won the election by an enormous margin. The Electoral College vote was 520 Nixon, 17 McGovern, 17, 520 to 17.
That's the landslide that he won re-election with. And within a few weeks, he was out of office. And it was all because of that Watergate break-in. And it wasn't even necessarily the break-in, which was bad enough that some operatives from the White House broke into Democratic headquarters in the Watergate Hotel and were caught trying to replace the phone tap that they had on the phone. And it turned out that it was traced back to the White House. The president probably had involvement. That's bad enough. But the cover up is what ultimately led to Nixon being railroaded out of out of the White House.
Yeah, for sure. But like you said, the writing was on the wall and he said, well, you know what? I quit. I resign. And everyone went, oh, man, I know we really wanted to impeach you. We brought the bale of hay and everything. I mean, I saw all the president's men again the other day for the first time in a while. So great. Such a good movie. Okay. So Nixon was – he's a pretty instructive example as well. Like he had multiple articles of impeachment against him. One was tax evasion. When he was president, he failed to pay like 400 grand in taxes, which is like 2.6 million today. Yeah. Which that's a substantial amount of money.
Plus he was president when he failed to pay those taxes. Crazy. He didn't get, again, he was never, they didn't get to the point where they voted on the articles of impeachment, but that was one against him. Obstructing justice was one. Using the office to obstruct justice was a big one. He had like a hand-picked CIA task force that was trying to keep the FBI from investigating Watergate. So he had a lot of different articles of impeachment against him, and surely one of them would have stuck and he would have been removed. But then after Nixon, that was 1972, up comes Clinton about 20, I think 26 years later.
Wasn't it 1998? I think, yeah, 97, 98. Okay. Well, it depends on, you know, the whole kit and caboodle was over a couple of years for sure. Right. So Clinton was up next. Yes. And very famously, he did not get impeached because he did bad things in the White House with Monica Lewinsky. He was impeached because he perjured himself. Very famously said, I did not have sexual relations with that woman. That was good. Did Uncle Eddie? I'll bet Uncle Eddie does a good Clinton too. Doubt it. Yeah. I mean, I remember in college and actually just post-college, I remember Bill Clinton looking America in the eye on television and lying to all of us.
Very disappointing. And he was a man in power who used that power to, some people say, take advantage of a younger co-worker. Other people say, you know, it was a consensual relationship. But he was the president and she was a political junkie. Sure. And he also was accused of trying to get her to – she was a witness. Monica Lewinsky was a witness in a sexual harassment case against him by Paula Jones. And he was accused of trying to get her to lie for him as a witness, which is big time obstructing justice, especially if you're president. And so if you look at it in that light, was he having that relationship with Lewinsky to influence her to lie to the jury?
Right. Which makes it doubly worse, somehow triply or quadruply worse even. Yeah. So there was a lot of beef against him. I mean, the stink from that mess affected this most recent election. You know? Oh, yeah, yeah, for sure. Definitely. I mean, like the Clintons have a pretty bad rep still from that among certain parties. Pretty extensive parties, I would say. And earned, you know? Mm-hmm. I mean, I remember being very upset that Bill Clinton lied to my face. Well, that's not why he was – he didn't perjure to the American people. He lied to a grand jury as well under oath. Oh, yeah, but he said the same thing to the grand juries.
He said to our faces. Yeah. But I remember feeling especially let down because he looked me in the eye. Right. You know, like when a president is facing camera and says something very seriously like that, they're talking to you. They're talking to their constituents. Like it's a personal relationship. I remember being just really upset about the whole thing. Well, okay. I don't think I felt quite like that. Oh, really? Yeah, I just assumed he was lying. Really? Yeah, he's president. Oh, man, I believed him. I was much more naive in my younger days. Well, I think it's Sweet Chuck. Yeah. That's Slick Willie, always with the smooth talk.
That's right. Tricky Dick and Slick Willie. We need to stop electing people with those nicknames. No, we're just asking for it. What about Honorable Frank? Why did he ever get elected? He doesn't have any campaign money. So, okay, so Clinton escaped. The vote was 50-50. The Senate vote. Yeah, so he was actually impeached like Andrew Johnson was, and it did come up to vote. The Articles of Impeachment came up to vote. And it was 50-50, which was pretty close to party lines. I think five Republicans, five Democrats voted for impeachment and 10 Republicans voted against. I can't remember, but it was very close to party line.
It was 10 Republicans voted for acquittal, two of which are still there. Susan Collins of Maine, she was a brand new either freshman or sophomore. Wow. And Richard Shelby of Alabama. Wow. Is still there. So they voted against acquittal? They voted for acquittal. Or they voted against impeachment, I should say. Yeah, yeah, they were one of the two of the ten Republicans. So Clinton made it out, and I was reading this really fascinating 538 blog about, I think it's called Will Trump Be Impeached? And it's 538, so they've got all this data and everything to back up what they're saying. So they were saying one of the sure signs that an impeachment is probably not going to go through is like how divided the parties are.
If the parties are – Oh, within themselves? No, no, between the two. Oh, oh, oh. Like if you're probably going to have a party line vote, it's probably people aren't going to defect enough to actually vote for impeachment. Or if they do, they're not going to defect enough to vote for conviction in the Senate. Right. And that was the case of Clinton. Right, right, right. But today it would take Republican senators to say – to get together and say, hey, maybe we can get this guy out of here and get Pence in there. And commit, what's it called, on a ship? Mutiny? Commit mutiny. Yeah, with the introduction of Pence out of nowhere, it definitely seemed like that was plan B from the party all along.
Right. I would not be at all surprised if that actually happened. I don't think very many people would be surprised if that happened. But I saw in that same 538 blog, there's a betting odds website that they cited that gave even odds that Trump would not finish out his full four-year term, which is pretty significant, you know, 50-50 chance. Yeah. That's crazy. Yeah, my call from the beginning was that he would not finish out his four-year term because he would resign. He would not allow himself to be impeached. I don't think so either. Is that he would resign and claim to be a victim of the political system and basically say, I told you all along it was the swamp.
I couldn't drain it. Now I'm a victim of it. Man. So P.T. Barnum played by. Hugh Jackman. Hugh Jackman. Jared from Subway. Jared from Subway. And then now this one. If this goes through, just call me Nostrochukas from now on. Oh, man. That's not bad. I have two T-shirts to buy now. There's a very interesting – and the reason I said that – this was right after he got elected was because I was like, I don't think he really wants to be president for four years. I read that in multiple places that he's not – he doesn't actually enjoy the actual presidency. Yeah, and from what I've heard, he gets very bored with doing the same thing, and politics is certainly not the way he's used to doing business.
I was just like, man, the guy's going to get tired of this after a couple of years and just want to go back to his cushy civilian life and then be a martyr, a political martyr and say, yeah, I couldn't do what I wanted to do. So I'm a victim. So that's Chuck's call. You heard it here first. So so if so, Trump hasn't been impeached yet, but they they've already brought it up. It sounds like, although it kind of waxed and waned in early December, all of the, especially the left-leaning news outlets were like impeachment. People are actually talking about impeachment. It's probably going to happen now.
And then if you look like a week later, all of those articles are gone. They just moved on to something else, right? Which is pretty ridiculous, but the status quo these days. So who knows what's going to happen with Trump? But the chances of him actually being impeached and convicted are extraordinarily low because he's president. Right. That's just such an enormous thing to remove a president from office. Yeah. What's not quite as enormous is to remove a federal judge, which is why out of the 60 people in the United States who have ever been impeached, I think it's even more than 60 and convicted, which is down to 15.
All of those, I believe, were federal judges. Correct. They were, you know, you name it. They were DUI drunks or drunk in court or tax evaders or accepted bribes or purged themselves. Like, yeah, federal judges have sort of carried the mantle for impeachment, you know? Yeah, and in a really weird way, they are laying, their impeachment trials have laid the groundwork for the big ones that you see. Yeah, the precedent? Yeah, I'm sure if you asked your uncle, he would tell you that, yeah, they went back and looked at impeachment trials for federal judges to see what procedures were used and followed and what the rules were.
So the impeachment of federal judges who were drunk on the bench are paving the groundwork for presidents to be impeached with, you know? Yeah. impeached by. And then there was a senator, William Blunt from North Carolina. He was the only senator to ever be impeached. And his trial actually established that senators and representatives couldn't be impeached. They were immune to impeachment because they weren't civil officers. That instead, their own party could run them or their own body. I'm sorry. So if you were a senator, two thirds of the Senate could vote for you to get out of the Senate.
If you were a Representative two-thirds of the House could vote for you to get out of the House. And that's what they did to Blunt. They said, we can't impeach you, but we can use this other thing. And it's basically like a vote of no confidence, which also comes from Parliament as well. Interesting. Yeah. Well, this week in real time, this will already have happened by the time this is released. But I think tomorrow there is a special election within the Democratic Party on who will be the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee. This is going to happen in the midterms. But when Democratic Representative John Conyers stepped down over sexual harassment allegations a couple of weeks ago, they had to hold a special caucus for an election.
It's going to happen tomorrow. And it looks like two people, either Jerry Nadler of New York or Zoe Lofgren of California, are the top two competing for this top spot. And they're both well aware that what that means in this article here, it's called The Battle to Lead Trump's Potential Impeachment. They know what they're – it says they're signing up to be Trump's chief antagonist. But they also said, hey, listen, we're not going to go in there and just start saying impeachment, impeachment. Like if this is ever going to happen, it's got to be the will. We have to feel like it's the will of the American people.
Like we have to feel like there are enough Trump supporters out there that have turned on him because of something he's done. Well, yeah. Or else it'll be like what you said, where you've just proven everything the guy said from the moment he started campaigning. Right. That they're just out to get him from the beginning. And that the elites have it so rigged that even if you do win, they'll just get rid of you. Yeah. I mean, one of them, Nadler, even said there's not much point in impeaching a president and having him acquitted in the Senate because that's what happened with Clinton. And like you said, even Republicans largely look back and say, of course, that was just a big distracting waste of time.
Yeah, that's what I've read as well, is that it's not looked upon as the finest moment in American legal history. Yeah, so we'll know the outcome tomorrow in real time. And both of them are kind of on the same page as far as that goes. They're like, it needs to be something legit worth impeaching a president for that most of the American people would agree with. We're not just out to get him, but if he does something, we're out to get him. Or if we find something that he's already done. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. So, well, there you have it. Yeah, if it turns out that he did obstruct anything, that would be a big deal.
Well. Two of the three presidents who have been impeached had at least articles of impeachment that included obstruction against them. Yeah, but his attorneys are saying – have literally said the president can't be guilty of obstruction of justice because they are justice. That's the most ridiculous legal interpretation I've ever heard in my life. I'm going to go on record as saying that. As saying they're above the law. I am the law. That's what it says. How can I obstruct the law? I'm the law. A crush. at any rate we should probably stop now alright well if you want to know more about impeachment you can type that word into the internet and some really interesting stuff I mean a lot of it is bone dry but people are really into the legal history and constitutional interpretation so you can find some pretty interesting articles all around the internet on stuff like this so just give it a shot see if it's up your alley Yeah, and at the very least, if this does happen to play out over the next couple of years, it's good to know how it all works.
Exactly. Exactly. You can impress your friends. Yeah. It could be like, they're never going to get a super majority, and your friends will be like, what did you just say? I know. What magic word was that? What does this have to do with comic books? So since Chuck said comic books, it's time for listener mail. This is follow-up on cakes. Hey, guys, listen to the episode on cakes. Thought you might like to know a little bit more about the color of red velvet cakes. An experienced amateur baker who has tested several red velvet recipes. And will now mail some down to Josh and Chuck. That's right.
It's true that red velvet cake originally got their color from the chemical reaction of the cocoa vinegar and buttermilk. That is no longer the case. The way cocoa is processed has changed since the recipe was invented. So if you rely on the chemical reaction for the color, you will be sorely disappointed. Your cake will simply be brown, but it will be nothing like the red we have come to expect from red velvet cakes. Originally, red velvet cakes were more of a rust color than the bright red we think of now. The cacao in the cake, cocoa? The tattoo. The tattoo on the cake also is minimal in comparison to a chocolate cake.
Cocoa was originally added to cut the flour, create a silkier, less glutinous texture, rather than create a chocolate cake. Velvet cakes using vinegar. I guess that's where the velvet comes from. Using vinegar as a rising agent has a long tradition in American baking and is not reserved only for red velvet cakes. Also, you mentioned banana bread with some confusion over aged mushy bananas. And a lot of people wrote in about this. I'm just a dummy. I didn't get it. Bananas are softer. It cuts back on the work of the baker. Also, bananas naturally sweeten as they ripe. Yeah, I didn't think about that either.
It makes total sense. I guess they're just so sugary and sweet once they get black like that. You get little fuzzy sweaters on your teeth when you bite into them. They're that sweet. I remember the first time I heard that expression, sweaters on your teeth, and I was like, oh, my God, that's it. Yeah. Nailed it. Blah, blah, blah, baking, baking, baking. Nice. Who was that from? Diana. By the way, she says if you're not adding chocolate chips to your banana nut bread, then you're doing it wrong. Huh. And then she says best wishes from Diana Garten. Thanks a lot, Diana. That's very nice of you.
Please do send us some baked goods. Yes. I'm not joking at all. If you want to send us some baked goods or just say hi or whatever, who cares? You can tweet to us at Josh M. Clark or SYSK Podcast. You can hang out with us on Facebook.com slash Stuff You Should Know or slash Charles W. Chuck Bryant. Send us an email to Stuff Podcast at HowStuffWorks.com. And as always, join us at our home on the web, StuffYouShouldKnow.com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed.
It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian Bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.
com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.