Intellectual property sounds as dry as can be, but it’s actually very interesting. It’s at the heart of the global economy and the center of a dispute over what should belong to the people who create things, from poetry to pharmaceuticals.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeartRadio. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh, and there's Chuck and Jerry's here. And this is the Don't Turn It Off. It's actually more interesting than it sounds edition. Yeah. Can I just right off the bat shout out Livia? This was a, I don't know. It's not the most fun topic, but she really dug in, and it's great.
Yeah. Yeah, she's amazing at it, actually. And this is— Yeah. She figured it out. Like, there is something interesting in intellectual property, and she found it. So— Agreed. Kudos. IP. Yeah, we are talking about intellectual property today. Everybody's heard that term. You have to have been living under a rock to not heard it. But we'll still tell you what we're talking about because we're those kind of people. I'm just teasing everybody. We're not talking about the great book, The Yellow River by I.P. Freely? No. No? Okay. No. Or a building by I.M. Pei? Nothing like that. Although that would fall under, I'm sure, some sort of intellectual property protection.
Intellectual property is basically the fruit of your mental labor. It can be an invention. It can be a slogan. Yeah. Screenplay? Song? Yeah. It can be a movie you wrote. It could be a way to do business, like business methods. It's gotten so crazy now that types of strains of certain kinds of bacteria can be protected. You mean algorithm? Yeah, that's another one. Like, it just keeps going and going. But anything that you can imagine, it doesn't even have to be a tangible thing. Like, an algorithm is not tangible. Even when you put it down into code, it's not tangible. It's an idea that you can make a computer use to do really neat tricks with, but it's intangible.
And again, Coke is it. It's a slogan. That's not at all tangible. And yet it's treated in most developed countries in the world or most industrialized countries in the world as the same thing as a property, like your car or your house or your wedding ring. Like it's protected. And the way that it's protected is in really weird ways. Intellectual property and intellectual property law are a very unique animal. But what they all boil down to, Chuck, is that if you get some sort of protection for your slogan, for your invention, for the screenplay you wrote, the government says that's yours. You are the only person who has any claim to it for X number of years.
And congratulations on the thing you came up with using your creativity. And the whole purpose of having protection for intellectual property is to spur creativity, to spur discovery, to spur invention, to get it going. Because if you incentivize that, if you say, hey, if you come up with this screenplay, we're going to make it so that no one else can just come along and make the movie that you wrote that's yours. It's going to make you want to keep pursuing a career of writing screenplays. But if you wrote a screenplay and you wrote it and it just didn't belong to you from the moment you finished the last sentence and anybody could come along and make the movie and not give you a dime for your creativity, for your labor, you probably wouldn't do that.
And so the public domain, the cultural public domain would suffer as a result. We wouldn't have movies. We wouldn't have algorithms. We wouldn't have Coke is it, amazing slogans like that. We would be culturally bereft if it were not for intellectual property protection. And yet it is one of the most insidious legal protections around today because it's been so thoroughly perverted from its original intent. Wow. It's been a while since you had one of those. I feel pretty strongly about IP. Here's a stat that Livia found for us, which I think is pretty interesting as far as like how big IP is.
And I think that this is from the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. And things have been ticking up as far as IP and how valuable it is and how, you know, how much people are registering IP and buying up IP since the 90s. And the USPTO said by 2019, since a few years old, that IP intensive industries accounted for 41% of the US gross domestic product. That's crazy. And 33% of all employment was IP based. Yeah. That's startling. We used to invent things. We used to make machines. We used to develop airplanes and cars and stuff like that. But now we invent ideas. Although we still invent stuff too.
Sure, of course. But for the most part, that really kind of goes to show you, like, we have come to say, like, no, we're trading in ideas, and those things are very valuable, and you can build an entire industry around certain kinds of ideas, which is pretty nuts if you think about it. Totally. So if you're talking about U.S. law, there are four kinds of IP that law covers. We've talked about some of these here and there. I think we did a whole episode on patents, didn't we? Well, if we haven't, we will. Patents are granted by the government, and everyone kind of knows what a patent is. I think that's when you invent an idea or a process or a design, and you can get different kinds of patents.
You can get design patents or utility patents, things like that. If you're like – if you invented the Reebok pump mechanism for the Reebok shoe that we talked about, you would get maybe a design patent and a utility patent that says no one else can put another pump in a shoe, that kind of thing. So it has to be novel, which is the real key, useful and non-obvious if it qualifies. And you're generally, it depends, but you're going to get about 20 years out of that patent. And you've got to pay for it to get it. And it's not cheap to get a patent. You have to pay an attorney to do all the legwork, and that's never cheap.
Right. The next one, Chuck, is trademarks, which everybody knows what a trademark is, especially if you grew up in the second half of the 20th century. That's when trademarks were everywhere and kind of what we wore on our T-shirts and stuff, right? Coke is it. Who didn't have that T-shirt? That's right. Or a Bud Light T-shirt with Spuds McKenzie surfing on it. I had a Spuds McKenzie shirt. So trademark is basically a brand name, can be a slogan, and it is something that you specifically associate with a specific company or a specific brand. And you actually don't even have to trademark or register your trademark.
Just from using, you know, the Spuds McKenzie drawing that you see everywhere or used to, you're exercising your right to use that trademark. And you can actually enforce action against infringement on it. So if you haven't registered something, you'll see the TM. That means that, hey, this is our trademark. Don't mess with it. We haven't gone to the trouble of registering it. A registered trademark is that R, capital R in a circle. That means that they actually did go to the trouble of registering it, and you really better not mess with them. Yeah, like an example is when you've seen court cases plenty of times where you'll see a company go in and say, here are 150 examples of where we've used this over the years.
That's people trying to argue that that's their trademark because they didn't copyright it or they didn't trademark it. That's why McDonald's had a legitimate case against McDowell's. Right. Oh, man. Great movie. There is also copyrights. That's another big one. I think everybody's pretty familiar with that. But that screenplay that you wrote or the computer program that you came up with that you coded, it's essentially a creative work. And you as the copyright owner, you as the creator, have the sole right to do as you please with that, to turn that software into something that you sell over and over and over again.
turn that screenplay into a movie. Like it's totally up to you and nobody else can do it while you hold that copyright. And copyrights are the ones that last the longest. I don't know if we said trademarks never run out, right? We didn't say it. As long as you're using it as a trademark, your exclusivity never runs out. With patents, like you said, I think 20 years. With copyrights, it's 70 plus years after creation typically. I think it's 70 years after the death of the creator. Right, that's plus. The whole creator's life is ensconced in that plus symbol. All right, okay, I got you. And we'll talk about that later.
That came from 1978. As far as screenplays and stuff, I think you can get a copyright, but the WGA has registration methods. You can register your script, but you don't even have to do that stuff. But you would be wise to because then you would have to, if you haven't, you would have to prove that it was your idea first and someone didn't rip it off. Yeah, there's that other way to do it, which is mail it to yourself in a sealed envelope. Does that work? I don't know, but it seems like if you don't have to go to the trouble of registering it, that would help your claim quite a bit. Yeah, the poor person's copyright.
I've heard that before. Sure. And what else? We've got trade secrets, and that's recipes, strategies, customer information, which is big, any kind of process, like industrial process, that you don't want another competitor to know about. And I don't think you need to register these either. No. And I meant to look up whether or not that's an actual downside, because then you would have to disclose things. No. Oh, if you registered it, that might be why you don't have to register it. Because I don't know if we said it or not, one of the reasons that patents are so beneficial is because you have to disclose exactly how that thing works so that after your patent runs out, somebody can come along and make the same thing from your patent.
Trade secrets, yeah, you would not want to do that because they never run out, just like trademarks. They're your secrets for as long as you actively work to keep them secret, like you make employees and sign NDAs. Remember that episode? That was a good one. Yeah. Or you keep the recipe to Kentucky Fried Chicken's original chicken, like, under lock and key with armed guards standing outside. That would be a pretty good demonstration of actively protecting your trade secrets. Yeah. They don't need to register it. They have guns. Exactly. Where this all started is pretty interesting. We'll kind of quickly go through the history.
It could go back as far as ancient Greece. But as far as IP, as we think of it today, you can point to 1421 in the Republic of Florence. And June 19th of that year, when the government said, hey, Filippo Brunelleschi. Nope. Brunelleschi. Ski, ski. Remember? Is it really? It's K sound with a C-H in Italian. Filippo Brunelleschi. There you go. Okay. I'm doing the accent, you guys. We heard from Italians that said, keep doing it. There you go. Filippo was an architect and had a patent for a technique to move marble over a barge. And they said, hey, this was really smart. And you should make money off this and only you.
And that kind of kicked the whole thing off. And over the next, you know, 100 years or so, governments across Europe started sort of doing the same things and getting together these ideas that you should be able to patent and own processes and ideas, including the Venetian patent statute of 1474, which said, hey, it's up to us and our government can grant you a 10-year monopoly on the use of a technology that you have made up. And if you violate it, you can get fined or you can get like a public citation. Yeah. And again, like by using government power to protect people's inventions and ideas helps spur creativity and discovery and new inventions.
And it wasn't just the Venetians who figured this out. About 150 years later, England said, hey, we're going to pass our statute of monopolies. And it basically said that if you have a new invention, you have a monopoly to it for a certain period of time. Very similar to what we have now for patents. But what's interesting about that is that that actually rolled back even more draconian law where basically the king could hand out patents or sell patents to whoever they wanted. And you could get a patent on vinegar. So like the existing stuff, if you were a friend with the king, you could be the sole producer of vinegar if the king gave you a patent for vinegar.
and the parliament said this is actually stifling progress and discovery. We're going to say this is limited to new inventions and for a limited period of time, which were two really good kind of points to add to that whole idea. Well, and it prevented, you know, they were definitely getting kickbacks or just outright selling stuff. Right. The king was. Yeah, the king was. So here in the U.S., our Constitution's patent and copyright clause gives Congress the power to, quote, promote the progress of science and useful arts by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries.
This was, I think, passed. I think the first patent was in 1790, granted to one Samuel Hopkins, who was producing, had a method of producing potash. And they're like, hey, congratulations. You are patent number one. He said, wow, gee, that's amazing. I've never been first at anything. That's right. And then he tripped on his shoelaces. That's right. He was first on the Internet commenting all the time, but no one counts that. So this whole thing, if you stop and think about it, it's all legal fiction. Like the government is saying you have a monopoly on it, but there's no actual concrete anything going on here.
They're just saying nobody else can use this thing that you came up with. We're the government. We're saying so. But the whole concept of protecting intellectual property actually is rooted. It has a philosophical basis. There's a few different justifications for it. The first came from, well, I don't know if it's the first, but the first in this list came from Hegel, the German philosopher, who said that intellectual property is an extension of you. Like if you go out and you buy some seeds and you buy some land and you grow crops from those seeds on that land, those are your crops. You mixed your labor with your own resources and created something and that's yours.
Why would it be any different for your ideas? You used your resources, say schooling or inspiration, and you used your brain power to turn it into an idea or a thought that you could tell other people. I can't do that, but, you know, other people can, according to Hegel. Why would you not own that as well, just as you would those crops? Now, what's the difference between that and Lockean? Lockean is, there's actually not a lot of difference, to tell you the truth. Okay. So that's just another, you know, similar school of thought from another philosopher. Yeah. An earlier philosopher, too, by a couple hundred years, I think.
But it's essentially the same thing from what I can tell. Well, there's also utilitarian, which means you're incentivized to create something, which is what you've been talking about. And the fact that, you know, no one's going to spend a lot of time doing this stuff. It's all about money. If you don't have the incentive eventually of fortune, then you're not going to spend your time doing it probably. And I understand the difference now if I kind of may correct myself. Locke was the one who is essentially saying you just like mixing seeds with land and growing crops, you same thing with your thoughts.
Hegel was saying like you own your thoughts just as much as you own your body. You own your thoughts and that they're your thoughts and they should belong to you. So there's definitely a distinction between the two. I was confused as happens sometimes. So let's take a break. Good idea. All right. We'll be right back. 250 years ago, the United States Postal Service made a promise to bind the nation, connecting families, friends, and businesses near and far. That's right. And during the holidays, that promise is more important than ever because it's about more than just gifts and cards. It's the peace of mind knowing your love will arrive reliably and affordably.
That's why they're building a better network to meet your needs this season, working around the clock to ensure timely deliveries, offering easy and affordable ways to ship, and providing everything you need to make your season full of holiday cheer, from stamps to packages. So this holiday season, trust the United States Postal Service to carry your most precious deliveries. Visit usps.com slash holidays to find tools and tips to help you ship with confidence. The United States Postal Service, delivering since 1775. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell.
And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP. Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all. The early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward. Yeah, and this season the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference.
So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row.
That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it. and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. All right, we're back, everyone, and we're here to talk about some criticisms of the whole concept of IP.
And things have really changed a lot since the Internet age and the tech boom as far as IP goes. Things really, really ramped up and took off. And there is a legal philosopher named Samir Chopra, and Livia found this article in Aeon, and basically said that, you know, kind of grouping all this stuff together, and it's not just Chopra, like other critics will argue the same thing. If you say trademarks and copyrights and patents and trade secrets and everything is all the same thing, which is IP, it really just sort of diminishes each one's specific purpose because they all have a specific purpose.
And calling it just intellectual property, you know, like using the word property even, makes it sound like you're a thief, that you're taking something tangible when in fact it still exists. Like if you download a song for free, you're not taking that song from the artist, you're just getting that song for free and that song still exists and the artist still owns it. Yeah, that was a big part of Chopra's point that calling it intellectual property theft or crime makes it a moral thing. Whereas if you just call it copyright infringement, it sounds like a bureaucratic issue. You know what I mean?
Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. And that that's unfair semantically to kind of put it all together. But even more so, they don't all really relate to one another as easily as you would think by being all lumped together under one term. And so, like, most legal protection, probably all legal protection of intellectual property around the world, they say, well, there's actually, we'll put some limitations on here. One of the big ones is that there's a time limitation on it. And again, the reason why is because there's a very difficult balance that's being struck here. One is that you want to foster discovery.
You want to incentivize people to go out and invent new things and come up with new ideas because everyone benefits from that. But at the same time, you don't want to incentivize it so much that you actually disincentivize it by giving people too long of a monopoly. So you give them 20 years for a patent or something, which works out because, you know, think about it. Think about if the first mobile phone had like a 70-year patent, where we'd be right now. You know? So 20 years seems fair, I guess, in that context. Well, also that gives you, that's basically saying like, you got this amount of time to do something with it.
Mm-hmm. Yeah, good point. Or somebody else is going to do it or should do it. For sure. There's also, like with copyright law as well, there's like fair use, like we talked about in the MAD episode, how parody is allowed or you can comment on it, that there are some exceptions to the rule. It's not just like ironclad. And for good reason, because again, this is a very difficult balance to strike. Yeah, and we've had our struggles with that over the year. In our own show, when we're doing an episode on something where it would be like hip-hop or something or record scratching, like those really lend themselves to plain examples.
And we've never been super clear on the actual law. We could probably get away with it, but different companies we've worked for over the years had different tolerances for just getting, you know, even having to suffer through the hassle legally of seeing if it's okay to do that. But we've always just not done it generally. Yeah, I mean, we have a few times. Like I think at the disco episode we did, but we were clearly commenting on the stuff. We weren't just using it for fun. Yeah, and there's also a time limit that we were never sure. Like you can play so many seconds and you have to comment on it.
It's nuts. And Jerry was always the fun killer. You know, mom had to come in and say, guys, you can't do that. And not a great position for Jerry to be in. No, but a natural one. it felt right. The other thing we should talk about is the cost to consumers, which is there are people that say, and of course, this is when we're going to talk about pharmaceuticals, because that's a big part of IP. But there's an economist named Dean Baker and others who say, like, you know, the effect of this IP law is really making the 1% just even more rich. and there's a transfer of wealth to the tune of about a trillion dollars a year, largely because of pharmaceutical companies.
They're a big chunk of that trillion dollars when you grant a monopoly on a drug, and sometimes even the government funds that to help make it happen, but then this one company has this drug and they can charge whatever they want for it, and then all of a sudden there's a trillion dollars being put in this rich person's pocket and then transferring it to another rich person's pocket. Well, yeah. And the trillion dollars he calculated is that's the amount we pay a year beyond what we should be paying. Yeah, like higher price pharmaceuticals mainly. Yeah, that's a really good, easy example. He calculated they make up about 385 billion of that trillion.
Of the trillion. But there's also other stuff too. There's like types of fertilizer and types of seed that are patented that because they own a patent, and if you want this life-saving medicine and you want this one kind of seed, you have to pay whatever price we want because we're the only ones who can sell it because we have a government-sanctioned monopoly that all of that adds up to about a trillion dollars more a year that we're paying. And like I said, the pharmaceutical companies in particular are an easy target, but the reason they're an easy target is because they demonstrate so thoroughly the problems with intellectual property protections.
And that is, like you were saying, they make ridiculous amounts of money. They charge whatever they want to charge because they're the only ones making this drug for X number of years, like 20 years or something like that, right? And then to add insult to injury, they have tons of government funding. In the United States, the National Institutes of Health kick in $40 billion for research. And I think the pharmaceutical industry total spends about another $90 billion. That's a lot of money on research. But they found that in 2020, the 10 largest pharmaceutical makers spent more on selling and marketing existing drugs than they did on research for new drugs.
They also spent $747 billion between, I think, 2001 and 2020 in stock buybacks and dividends. Stock buybacks are not the worst thing in the world. There's definitely worse things you could do with your corporate cash. You're essentially paying back loans that investors gave you. Nothing inherently wrong with stock buybacks. But pharmaceutical industry, it's a different example. And one of the things they could be doing with that extra money rather than upping their share price is pouring it into more and more research and development because there's a lot of diseases that still need to be cured.
And they're instead spending it on ads that you see on like nightly news. Yeah, true. That is why there are some people out there, and Livia found this one guy from Columbia University, an economist named Joseph Stiglitz, great name, that said what we should be doing is giving out big cash prizes for a new discovery, a new pharmaceutical discovery that's like a game changer. And instead of spending your money on advertising and marketing or on, like, drugs for balding and erectile dysfunction, not saying that those aren't issues. I don't want to diminish anyone's problems with any of those things, to be clear.
But a cure for cancer would be better. I think we can all agree. or, you know, drugs to treat malaria when developing countries are being ignored because they're concentrating on something like a cure for baldness. So, like, let's give a cash prize instead of a monopoly and say, hey, we'll give you – I mean, I'm just throwing out numbers. This wasn't from Stiglitz. But we'll give you $500 million if you come up with a cure for cancer. And then that's just a cash award given to your company. And then it's open source and any pharmaceutical company in the world can make this stuff and get it out there super fast and competitively speaking, probably cheaper.
Yes. And if they threw out that $500 million figure, the pharmaceutical industry would be like, huh. Yeah. I meant $500 million. That's lunch. So Stiglitz. I knew that was low. You're like Dr. Evil. $500 million. Totally. So Stiglitz was saying like you don't want to just do away with the patent and trademark protection. Like you want to keep that because it does incentivize research in other areas. What he was saying is identify the really terrible diseases that don't have a financial incentive to have research and development money thrown at them. Like malaria. It's one of the top 10 killers in the world, but it kills people in less developed, lower income countries who don't have the money to spend on that kind of drug.
So malaria is allowed to run rampant. What Stiglitz is saying is governments can get together or the U.S. could do it alone and say, we'll give you $500 billion for a cure for malaria. And then the other stuff you guys keep going, you know, and doing and making your money off of. But how about an extra $500 billion? Nothing to sneeze at. So it's a good idea. But I think there's a flaw in it too, Chuck. And that is that if the U.S. government did this and made it open source like he's suggesting, like you said, then the rest of the world would benefit from the U.S. government funding. We'd become the drug research funders for the world.
The rest of the world would become free riders who would just get the recipe for free because the U.S. government handed out that prize to the company that created it or discovered it. Yeah, you'd have to get together and sign a pact with like most of the major countries of the world or something. Yeah. That they all do the same. Okay. I don't know. I mean, it would have to be a global push because that's, and in fact, that kind of segues into our next section, which is the globalist world that we live in. It becomes a little sticky because IP law, I think, generally just covers the country that you're in.
I think when you get a patent, you have to get it in different countries if you want to sell it in different places. And there's a long, long history of countries not respecting IP law from other countries and stealing stuff. China's a big one. And in the case of China, sometimes it's, hey, why don't you give me, we'll let you do business in China. You know how many people we have over here? We'll let you do business here if you open source your stuff only to us. Right. You have to partner with the Chinese business who will have full access to your intellectual property if you want access. Or they'll just steal it, which also happens.
That's a big one. There was an operation that was funded and supported by China's government between 2019 and 2022 where Chinese hackers stole trillions of dollars worth of intellectual property from just 30 companies. Just took it. They had everything to create pharmaceuticals, create guided missile systems. Like, just, they got everything. And there's not a lot you can do about that. Like, there's basically nothing you can do about those things now. China has those now. And the big argument against that is that if China can just steal ideas, it doesn't have to spend tons of money on research and development.
So that means that it can make those products cheaper than the people whose idea it was and did spend that money on research and development and price the legitimate owner right out of the market. And that is about as unfair competition as you can possibly ever encounter. Yeah, but it's also something that has been going on forever. It's not new. China's not the first country to do this. Livia points out that when economies are emerging, and especially during, like, tech booms, and they're catching up to richer countries, then they will steal ideas. I mean, everything from, I mean, it happens all the time and has for decades.
Like, the lawsuit guitars. Like, Japan made knockoffs of, like, Gibson and Fender guitars in the 70s and 80s and sold a ton of them, and they were really good guitars. And I think there may be a short stuff in there about the lawsuit era. But it's always happened. Even in the United States, we did the same thing. And from the very beginning of our copyright law in the 18th century, we very much explicitly exempted foreign works from protection. So we could go out and steal things like the power loom and stuff like that. Yeah, those two Carnegie Endowment guys are saying, like, this is just part of the trajectory that developing economies hit upon at some point in time.
It's just way easier to steal the ideas and use those to grow your economy. But they said that trajectory also usually includes more strictly enforced IP protections on the other side of that development. And apparently China's starting to show signs of that, that they're taking IP protection a little more seriously, at least according to the Carnegie Endowment people. But yeah, that's one of the reasons why we're in a trade war with China is because of hacks like that. Should we take a break? Yeah, let's. Hacks like that was almost the name of our show. Nice. We'll be right back. 250 years ago, the United States Postal Service made a promise to bind the nation, connecting families, friends, and businesses near and far.
That's right. And during the holidays, that promise is more important than ever because it's about more than just gifts and cards. It's the peace of mind knowing your love will arrive reliably and affordably. That's why they're building a better network to meet your needs this season, working around the clock to ensure timely deliveries, offering easy and affordable ways to ship, and providing everything you need to make your season full of holiday cheer, from stamps to packages. So this holiday season, trust the United States Postal Service to carry your most precious deliveries. Visit usps.com slash holidays to find tools and tips to help you ship with confidence.
The United States Postal Service, delivering since 1775. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell. And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP. Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all, the early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward. Yeah, and this season, the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference.
So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. attention parents and grandparents if you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long give them a guardian bike the easiest safest and number one kids bike on the market yeah with usa made kids specific frames and patented safety technology kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kids bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row.
That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike and she loves it. And that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought after gifts of the season and inventory is going fast. So don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. Man, I'm still cracked up about hacks like that. So one of the things about intellectual property protection is that it is kind of grown in lockstep as American industry has, because as American industry grows and comes up with more and more valuable intellectual property, they like to go to the government and say, hey, why don't you guys come up with stricter and stricter laws, giving us longer and longer monopolies to those ideas, to that intellectual property?
It's basically the snake starting to eat its tail, where the government has now become Charles I and the corporations are like all of Charles I's friends getting patents on vinegar and stuff like that. It's not quite that egregious, but it's the same contours, the same idea, basically, where incredibly wealthy people are given unfair, anti-competitive advantage over, say, startups or people who have even better ideas through these monopolies. Contour is one of my words, like cellar door. It's not a combination, but Oh, yeah. Yeah, the word contour just, I don't know. It's velvety to me. Heck likes that.
So, like you were saying, copyright law, like, it's just sort of extended over the years as far as how long you could own these ideas. In 1790, when we first started out, it was 14 years. You could renew for another 14. and then, you know, over the ensuing, like, a couple of hundred years, basically, it just grew and grew and grew until 1998 with the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. That's when the 70 years after the person's death was put in place, or if you're a corporation, 95 years from the original publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is less. A little confusing, but it makes sense if you think about it.
Yeah, and that actually brought the United States into line with international agreement on copyright limitations in time frames. I think it was lower than other countries, what other countries were at. But regardless, people just kind of smelled a rat and snuck around. Actually, ironically, sussed out a mouse. It's all frequently called the Mickey Mouse Protection Act because around that time, Disney was supposedly in danger of losing the rights to Steamboat Willie version of Mickey Mouse in 2023. And they were lobbying very hard to make that not happen, to get the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act passed, which was successful.
But I've also read that Disney wasn't quite behind it, like people say. and that even if Steamboat Willie does come into public domain this year, I don't think he did. But even if he did, just that specific version of Mickey would be in the public domain. And the Mickey that we know and love will probably never be in the public domain because not only does he have copyright protection, Disney also uses him like a slogan or like a brand name. Right, took his it. So it's like he has trademark protection and trademark protection never runs out as long as you keep using it. So Mickey will probably never enter the public domain, even if Steamboat Willie did.
I didn't see that he did, though. I don't know. I don't think so. But this just occurred to me that with every year we do our show, we can look for a Halloween podcast story from a year later in history. Yeah, that's why we ended up doing Philip K. Dick a couple years ago, because he finally started to come into the public domain. I love it. And by the way, people that wrote in that either had ideas or wrote their own stories, I haven't looked yet, but I saved those emails and we're going to take a look at those. All right. The next thing we should talk about is in 1998, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which basically, the way I understand it is that it covered the Internet such that it created a way for someone to say, hey, you're using my thing on your website.
Go take it down. I want to officially register that you are taking my stuff. And as long as they take it down, then they are not penalized. Right. That was a kind of a big deal because it allowed the Internet to start to flourish and it kept people who ran social media sites or YouTube or something like that from worrying that they were going to get their pants suit off and allowed for the spread and really kind of boosted the economy quite a bit, as you can imagine. Sure. One of the problems, though, with these long protections, and sometimes in some cases like trademarks, like limitless protection, is that so 70 years beyond the lifespan of the creator, that is a long time.
Yeah. As you can tell from like the Halloween stories we pick, like sometimes we have no idea what they're talking about because the language they're using is English and you understand that they're English words. But the context is so old that it doesn't really make sense. It's like, remember that one thing about how I thought the guy was reading tea leaves or something like that to see who was coming in? Right, we were totally wrong. Yeah. And yeah. So that's a really good example of one of the problems of it, because when we use those stories, we are building on them. We're taking the we're taking them and putting our own spin on them.
We're making silly voices. Yes, exactly. But we're creating something new using that original work as a building block. And that's one of the purposes of creating protections for creative stuff so that eventually it will spread out into the public domain and people can do new amazing things with them. The problem is if it's 70 plus years before you can do that, it's not as easy to make new ideas from as it would be if it were 20 years old or 10. Yeah. This one I understand in a way because, like, how many great films have we gotten based on the works of Shakespeare, which is – Livia points out that – who was it?
Jennifer Jenkins, director of Duke University Center for the Study of the Public Domain. That's pretty specific. That's an argument that Jennifer Jenkins makes, which is, like, we wouldn't have, you know, these great adaptations of the works of Shakespeare's films and stuff like that, which is true. but I also can see a world where, like, come up with a new idea, you know? Well, supposedly, it might have been Shakespeare who said it. There are no new ideas, nothing new under the sun. Like, all the ideas have been essentially come up with, and everything else is just basically a remix of it. Yeah, what was it?
There's like seven real movie plots, essentially, or seven dramatic. I can't remember how many it is, but there is an argument to be made that there are really only seven different stories that you can tell. But I get what you— And everything else is a version of those. Yes, and we don't protect those specific seven ideas. We would be totally messed if we did. Right, right, right. The protections are more nuanced than that. It's like how that story develops, what the characters are doing in it. That's what's protected. And so in that sense, yes, you are coming up with a new idea rather than just remixing a Shakespeare play.
And I agree with you. I have the same that same kind of quibble with that the idea that you can't that is too long to remix stuff, even though we do that every Halloween. The Internet is very tricky, though, because on one hand, you want like the idea of like the paywall. You want people to hear your stuff and see your stuff. But if you are, and Livia is a great example, if you're like a reporter in the South Sudan covering something very important to you, you want everyone that you can think of to find this and discover it. But you also, like, it costs money for you to be there and to be on the ground in the South Sudan for a year doing this intensive reporting.
Like, a company needs to be paying you to do that and to fly there and to stay there and per diem and all that stuff. and they're not doing the goodness of their heart. So they may say, well, we've got to put this behind a paywall because we've got to make money. Yeah, and when the Internet came along in the beginning, it followed a hacker ethos, which was that it should be free and open to everybody. Information is now easy as pie to disseminate, and it should all be free and unfettered. And we actually see that that colliding with what you were just talking about, how someone's reporting is valuable and is worth money.
And colliding with the idea that information should be free on the Internet with Canada right now, where Canada passed a law that says that if you are like a social media aggregator, news aggregator, you have to pay the creator of that news some form of compensation for aggregating that news because you're making money off of it, but you're just taking their work for free. Right. And Canada is in a real pickle right now because Google and Facebook said, okay, well, we're just not going to be available in Canada anymore because we're not going to pay that. And what's Canada going to do? So that seems like that fair – it's very ironic.
The free internet in the form of the most profitable, most expensive and valuable companies in the world is crushing the journalistic value that's brought by people who create news and come up with articles that those companies make their money off of. It's a terrible jam. It really is. And over the years, of course, we've had sort of activist crusaders like Aaron Swartz, who in 2011 was indicted for downloading one of our favorite websites, JSTOR, J-S-T-O-R database. What does that stand for, actually? I don't even know. I can't even possibly come up with anything on this short of notice, Chuck.
Believe me. But anyway, Schwartz downloaded millions of academic articles from the JSTOR database, which is behind a paywall. And the idea, you know, presumably was that he was going to share those. And he even had a manifesto, the Guerrilla Open Access Manifesto, where he's like, there's a moral imperative to have these academic articles available to the world and to someone who might not have the money in the global south, these institutions that can't pay for these journals, maybe. Like, we should get it out there. And JSTOR did not press charges, but U.S. attorneys came after him, and he took his own life at the age of 26 in 2013 before the trial started.
Yeah, U.S. attorneys Carmen Ortiz and Stephen Heyman really aggressively pursued charges against him. And it's kind of explained that he was the scapegoat in the post-Wikileaks world. They were seeking to make an example out of him. And, yeah, he took his life at 26. And, like, a real luminary was lost. Especially if you stop and consider what he was doing. And especially if you stop and consider that JSTOR was like, you gave the articles back. We're not going to press charges. Right. And if you want to know, like, a little peek behind what Aaron Schwartz was doing, if you're like, that's a weird thing to die over.
Scientific journal articles? Who cares? There's an amazing article from Priceonomics that Alec Mayasi wrote in 2013 called Why Is Science Behind a Paywall? And everyone should read that because it's about the scientific journal publishing racket that is basically keeping science in the hands of just the wealthiest universities in the world and out of everybody else's hands because they make tons of money off of it. even though science is supposed to be spread everywhere far and wide so people can try new things based on those findings. Because money is the root of all evil, right? There's an article that I think Dean Baker wrote as IP the root of all evil.
Oh, interesting. That's who we were talking about earlier. So enforcing this stuff, especially on the Internet, has been very tricky over recent years. When you talk about websites like BitTorrent and Napster back in the day, LimeWire is what I use. Remember LimeWire? Mm-hmm. And what was the other one with the Y? Hmm. I can't remember, but yes. I don't know. Someone will write in and let us know. But Napster, if you don't know about that and you're pretty young and you were a kid when that happened, that was sort of one of the first free music downloading sites, and it was all over the news at the time because it devastated the music industry in a lot of ways, and a lawsuit shut them down in 2001.
But this was a case where the world and the Internet and the music industry pivoted eventually when things like Spotify and Pandora came along and said, hey, we can't police this. You cannot shut down people trading music online. The genie has left the bottle. It's too late. But why don't we get together and at least we'll start these services where people can sign up and they can pay for this stuff because we think people will do that. They may not buy your records anymore, but they'll pay $10 a month or whatever for unlimited music, and then we'll give you a tiny little piece of it. And they said, all right, I guess that's the best we can do.
This is a stat Livia found. In 2022, inflation-adjusted dollars. Revenue from, and this is just music sales, like selling a CD or whatever at the time. In 1999, it was almost $26 billion, which was the peak. went all the way down to $8.3 billion in 2014 and 2015, and is back up as of a couple of years ago to about $16 billion, which is still a little less than half, I guess, of the peak, largely because of paid subscriptions and stuff like that. But that's a huge decline, and the only reason music, like if you complain about the price of concert tickets, it's because you stopped paying for recorded music.
Like, that's, there's a direct line you can draw between musicians having to make money somehow and you stealing their music. That's the thing, dude. It's not necessarily the musicians making that money. Like, there's huge companies that make most of the money on a ticket these days. And that's a... Oh, like a concert ticket? Yeah, that's why ticket sales and prices are so jacked. Like, you can go on to Ticketmaster or something like that, and the show won't be sold out. And yet they're suddenly at scalper prices for some reason. It makes no sense. It's a total racket. And that's the reason why it's a racket is because, again, like you said, they stopped making as much money off of recorded music, so they figured out how to make as much money as they could off of live music.
Where before, that was the artist's piece, the live thing. Like the record company got the record money. You go off and do your tour. We don't care. Have as much fun as you like. And when the record company's pie was removed by Napster, completely just shattered, they moved over to live. And now they have a stranglehold on ticket prices, which is awful. Yeah. I mean, back in the day, ticket prices were low because you toured to support the album sales. Yeah. You put out a record. You go on a big tour. You charge like $8 to $15. And you sold merch. You got some merch money, and you sold a ton of records.
Once the record thing went away, they had to make money. And then all the other, you know, of course, you know, not knocking them because we work with these people, but promoters and venues, and they all take a big piece. Public service announcement, if you'll allow, really quickly. Please. When you go to buy a Stuff You Should Know live ticket, please, please, please only go and make sure you're looking at your computer screen. make sure you're going to the venue only. Because when you type in stuff you should know, live Boston, the first thing that pops up might be a scalper site. And you might not realize it's a scalper site because they don't look like, you know, shady guys in leather jackets on the corner anymore.
It looks like, oh, this is just the place where you buy the tickets to Josh and Chuck's show. And we had a few people that wrote in and said like, hey, I just paid $200 for this ticket, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, you went to a scalper site? And they said, no, I didn't. And I said, I guarantee you did because our tickets are not more than like whatever, like $35 or something. So just people should know that. We never have a chance to say that. So please don't buy scalper tickets unless you just can't get a ticket and you're loaded and don't care. Yeah, and that's the original price is $35.
And then there's, you know, whatever fees the venue puts on it. And then once you get out of away from the venue, it just keeps going. More and more people put more and more egregious fees on it. So I think the best thing to do is to either, if you can go to the box office and buy them directly, that is far and away your cheapest. That's as close as you're going to get to face value. And if you can't do that, look for pre-sales. We always have pre-sales, a couple of days of pre-sales first, where that has the least amount of fees attached to it. There's the fewest cooks in the kitchen at that point.
And then after that, in regular sales, when it just turns into the Wild West. Yeah. I mean, we love these live shows, but I got to say once my eyes were really open once we started doing it as to how it all worked. It's really, really upsetting. It's kind of like, oh, okay. Yeah, because we can't do anything about it. It's like, oh, are you guys going to sell the tickets yourselves then? No, we can't. We can't possibly do that. You have to deal with the people that you have to deal with. And there are some that are better than others. There's promoters and ticket sellers that are aware that there is a lot of terribleness to their industry, and they're trying to do the opposite.
And you can seek them out, but they're not in every city. You're eventually going to run into having to work with people that you don't want to work with, and that's just part of being on tour. That's right. And this all started because of Napster and me talking about Napster. That's right. I don't know how to close that loop other than to say, I don't know. We could just end the episode. I mean, I got nothing else. Okay, I got nothing else either. If you want to know more about intellectual property protection, there's a lot of really interesting, if not kind of dry articles out there about it.
And since I said dry, it's time for Listener Mail. It's time for Chuck. this is I just thought a pretty cool little tidbit from Nicole Adrian hey guys wanted to say thanks for the show love listening while I drive and learning something new and you always infuse some laughter into my day I just listened to the episode on the Manhattan Grid it's an oldie but a goodie and there's a gal who grew up in the shadows of New York City on Long Island spent quite a lot of time there and hold it near and dear to my heart one thing you missed out on though was a little explanation on Broadway you mentioned that it does not stay consistent with a grid And here's the thing.
The reasoning for this is because it was a deer run that indigenous people used to hunt prior to the Dutch coming in and colonizing the island. There are also some really interesting studies and maps that were created to assess what plants were native to the island before it became a concrete jungle. So Broadway, like that little diagonal thing, was a deer run, and it became a road eventually, I guess. That's very cool. Pretty cool. Anyway, thanks for the opportunity to learn. Would love to hear an episode on the High Line. It's got a great history. And that, again, is from Nicole Adrion. Thanks, Nicole.
We love learning stuff we didn't know about. Thanks for taking the time to write in and tell us. And if you want to be like Nicole and just be super cool with some great info, you can send us an email to stuffpodcasts at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. We'll see you next time. 24-7, 365 days a year, and is 100% based in the U.S. See how it works at ruby.com, or better yet, give them a call at 844-900-R-U-B-Y. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different.
That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market.
Yeah, with USA-made kids-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kids' bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this. This holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait.
Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.