In this episode, Josh and Chuck discuss the history, practices and controversies of lotteries.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. And now, Superhuman Shaq. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or OSA.
In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. Josh Clark, Chuck Bryant, Stuff You Should Know. What do you think? Good. Does it sound like a current affair or one of those topics?
shows hard copy remember that yeah are they still around i think some of them are thankfully i don't watch television at 4 30 p.m no you have a job i wouldn't know yeah uh here in uh georgia we had this thing called the hope grant i think we still do i think so we're like if you keep a b plus average or more uh in high school if you graduate with a b plus average and you can maintain it through college you get a free ride to a state school and that's funded by the lottery yeah that It came along after I was there. It started actually when I went to college. I think it was the first year. And there have been tons and tons of studies done on who's going to college.
And it's generally white, upper-middle-class kids who are benefiting from the HOPE scholarship. And then it's poor minorities who are playing the lotto and, in effect, putting white kids through college whose parents could otherwise pay for it. Yeah. A lot of people have called it a tax on the poor, the anti-Robin Hood, take from the poor and give to the rich. Should we talk about some stats? Sure. Should we get that out of the way? Yeah. I've got a few for you, Josh. There is one study in California where they have shown that the racial and household income lines match up with how California is divided.
Oh, yeah? Sure. Has that been disputed at all? Yeah. People are saying they're cooking the books. Oh, really? They'll ask questions like, have you played the lottery in the last month? But they don't say, have you bought 15 scratch-off tickets per day for the past month? Yeah, that's a good point. So they don't really dive in there. I was reading a story, I think, from CBS News, Texas in 2007. They found that blacks and Hispanics play the lottery twice as much as whites do, regardless of class. Yes, and scratch-off tickets are apparently the crack cocaine of lottery in Texas. is the first state to offer a $50 scratch-off ticket.
Holy cow. You pay $50 to buy this thing. Have you ever gone on a little scratch-off bender? No. I have before, and when you get in the grips of it, you might as well be huffing ether. There is no way out. Well, Massachusetts, one-third of the calls to the Gambling Addiction Hotline are from lottery players. Really? Yeah. I don't play it. I'm surprised it's just a third, actually. Yeah? It's like alcoholism and beer. You can buy beer. You can buy liquor. And in a lot of states, you have to buy it from a state store. This is the same thing. These are state-run vice operations, basically. Yeah, pretty much.
And people have a real problem with them. But the state's just making so much cash off of these things that they aren't really doing a whole lot about it. Yeah, and here's the other thing before we get on with just what the lottery is. We should talk about a little more malfeasance. apparently not very much money at all is going to K-12 education. Oh, yeah? Most lotteries go toward education. Right. But college? Yeah. It's all going to college. They said that less than 1% in half of the states that play the lottery go to K-12. Really? And the other hinky thing is they sell it to you as a benefit for education, like all over the marketing.
But the legislation now in many states are starting to kind of use it for whatever they want according to their budget. Like in Missouri when it started, I think it was like 52% was supposed to go toward education. And now it's like 30% and they use it for budget shortfalls and whatever they need. Wow. They'll just rewrite the law. How grim. I know. That's really grim, especially when you consider all the people who are just blowing cash on scratch-off tickets or lotto tickets and have like real gambling problems. Yeah. Huh. So that's the controversy. And actually, this problem goes back pretty far, right?
To the 16th century, I believe. Yeah. Florence? Firenze? Oh, was it Italy? Yeah, that's where the lotto comes from. And I think the term lotto is based on lots, like drawing lots, game of chance, luck. Yes. Right? And so the first lotto that anybody is aware of where there was a cash prize given out was the Lotto di Firenze. You want to say it? Lotto di Firenze? Nice. Thank you. And that was, again, in the 16th century in Italy. And in the U.S., we've always had something of a little bit of a fever for the lotto, haven't we? Yeah, apparently the colony of Virginia was founded by raised money from lotteries.
Nice. And there were 200 lotteries permitted between 1744 and the Revolutionary War that funded roads, libraries, colleges, bridges, churches. Yeah, a lot of them were for civic projects, right? Yeah. Yeah. And Princeton and Columbia Universities were built on lotto money. Yeah. Did you know that? I did in Latin. I can't remember what it is in Latin, but the crest for Princeton translates to, Daddy needs a new pair of shoes. And there's some dice on this shield. Cool. I know if you have 15 grand, you can go to eBay and buy a lottery ticket with George Washington's signature on it. Sweet. Pretty cool, huh?
Yeah. So I had no idea that lotteries were this entrenched in the founding of our country. All right. Well, they kind of fell out of favor. I imagine probably in part because of the temperance movement in the 19th century. Temperance. And then in the 20th century, about the mid-20th century, lotto fever could not be suppressed. Inoculations ran out and everybody was like, give me some tickets. And New Hampshire led the way in 1964 with its first state-run lottery. of the 20th century. I mean, I don't play the lottery myself at all, but I definitely see the irresistible lure of a dollar winning you millions of dollars.
I don't know, man. Let's just get this out of the way. Would you want to win the lottery honestly? And if so, what's the minimum amount you would have to win to not just blow it? I'm going to say no. I wouldn't want to either. Because stress and anxiety and complications, I want to make my life, keep it as simple as possible, and that would just complicate everything. Oh, it definitely would. And all kinds of jerks come out of the woodwork. Yeah, I think you're kind of like, I don't have an uncle from Venezuela. Or do I? Right, exactly. Well, I guess it's possible this guy wouldn't be saying he was my uncle, so I could hear some money.
I should invest in his coffee bean field. Right, exactly. Or get some Nigerian general out of trouble via email. Sure. So, Chuck, I would not necessarily want to win the lotto either unless it was such a vast amount that I couldn't possibly run through it. And I'd probably go off and travel or do whatever. Yeah, I'm also one of those jerk-offs who thinks that working for your money is kind of the thing to do. Chuck works hard for his money. I would feel like – I think I would be very unfulfilled if someone just gave me a pile of cash. Right, yeah. And that's an excellent point too because if you think about it, let's say you did win a million dollars.
Let's say you won $10 million, and we'll get into how that trickles down to almost nothing by the time it gets into your pocket. But let's say you won $10 million, and after a couple of years, you've blown through it, right? Yeah. You've done nothing to earn that money. Right. So therefore, you could never get it back. It was just blind luck. Yeah. If you make $10 million writing a book or writing a movie or in business or in real estate, you can make that back again, actually, if you blow it all. Right. Because you've done something for it. You've used your own wits and skill. But with lotto, no.
It's just a trip to Easy Street that turns out to be hell. Well, that's why it appeals to so many people except for the hell part. Yeah. You know? And that's why people see it as a tax on the poor because it's like here, even the scratch-off tickets, you know, just a chance to win like a couple hundred bucks. Right. It's kind of sad. At the same time, though, you have to add a little perspective to it. You and I don't really play the lotto. Like I said, I've done some scratch-off benders here and there, but nothing more than $5 or $10, right? I've gotten the occasional Powerball. Okay, all right.
I'll admit that, but rarely. But consider this. You and I are upper-middle class, white guys, age 18 to 49. Pretty much the entire country is based on whatever we want. All of the focus groups, all the studies, all of the pharmaceutical tests, they're based on us. Right. Right? Like we have it so ridiculously easy that I think it's entirely possible that we're blinded to why people play the lottery. If you simply don't have a leg up, if there's nothing you can do, if you're being kept down economically, socially or whatever, there is this promise of I could really use a couple extra million bucks and I don't care if some jackass does come out of the woodwork and says he's my uncle.
Like I think it's easy to criticize people who play the lottery as stupid. Right. Right? But at the same time, I think that reveals a misunderstanding of where somebody's coming from. And then, of course, there are just some jackasses who play the lottery because they're bored or people who do have a gambling problem. But I think that there is some promise of a lottery, and I think that the state preys upon that through their lotteries. Yeah, I mean it's easy for us to sit here and say, well, if you'd spend $2,500 a year on scratch-off tickets, if you had invested that, in a Roth IRA, then you could potentially have a retirement account.
And it's just, just shut up. Yeah, I've been poor, man. And I can tell you the poor mentality is tough to break out of. Yes, I was poor at one point myself. Yeah, it sucks. And I was a lottery scratch-off fiend. Yeah. Not true. Yeah. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One bank guy. It's pretty much all he talks about in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too. Thanks, Capital One Bank guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.
com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member F-D-I-C. Our listeners love puzzles, paradoxes, and hidden patterns almost as much as we do. On TikTok, those fascinations come to life. People are breaking down physics, exploring geology, and explaining why the world works the way it does. You'll see impressive experiments, explanations that finally make sense, and connections you didn't expect. It's like having a lab, a lecture hall, and science museum in your pocket. TikTok is where wonder is shared, where curiosity turns into discovery, and where millions learn something new every day. So, all right, dude, we really, usually our tirades come toward the end.
For some reason, we front-loaded this one with it. Let's talk about how lotteries work. Yes, Josh. If you are playing a game with 50 balls, let's say 50 ping pong balls, and each one of those has the number, your odds of winning is about 16 million to one. If they just add one ball to that. So 51 balls. 51 balls. It shoots up to about 76 million to one. Right. That's the real reason I don't play. That is a fantastic calculation you just did there. But, and I don't mean to criticize you, a surprisingly simple one actually, right? Yes. So if you have six numbers that you have to pick out of 50 balls, your initial chance is 50 to 6, or it's like, I think, 8.
3 to 1, right? Right. And you can go on down the line. After one ball is picked, you have a 49 to 5 chance and so on and so on. So if you take each of these and multiply them, that's where you get that 16 million to 1 chance. Yeah, because they don't play lotteries with one ball. If they did, then what would that be, a one-to-one chance? Especially if it was just one number and they told you ahead of time? The winning number is going to be six. I'd play that lottery. So, yeah, you've also got Power Balls, right, which are multi-state lotteries where everybody joins together. And the most common one is you have to pick five numbers from a set of 50 balls.
So use that calculation I just said. But then you also have to pick one Powerball number out of 36. So now you multiply that original calculation by 36, and you're up to 76.275 million to one chance. Yeah, and like I said, that's why I don't play the lottery for real. I would never, ever, ever win it, so I'd rather spend that dollar on whatever. Cigarettes, vodka, beef jerky, anything. Sure. Yeah. Chuck. Josh. Have you ever noticed that when you, say, win $10 million, what you actually end up with is like $2.5 million? Doesn't that just tick you off? Yeah, well, it depends. You're talking about you can choose either a lump sum payment or pay me out over the next, whatever, 25 years, I think it usually is.
Yeah, it looks like from this article, the best one to go with, if you're patient, is the series of annual payments. or annuity? I disagree. Okay. Explain. Well, I mean, I would think you could make, you get about a 5% interest return that way. And I think if you have half a brain, you can get a better return than that by investing that money. And also I think if you die, doesn't that, it's not like they start paying your next of kin or anything, right? No, they do. Everywhere? Oh yeah. A lot of windfall becomes part of your estate. Oh, it does? Uh-huh. Okay. And actually, since you bring that up, there's a little bit of advice.
If you ever do win a major lottery or any lotto, first thing you want to do is sign the ticket because it's a bearer instrument and whoever has it and turns it in is the winner. So you want to sign it. The next thing you want to do is go talk to a lawyer. Before you go in to turn in your ticket, go get a lawyer. Yeah, you don't want to be standing on the stage with the big check without having an accountant and a lawyer by your side. Right, and a lawyer is going to set up a trust and a state, all sorts of other stuff, and then you go in and you claim your winnings. And the lawyer is going to take a chunk.
The lawyer is going to take a chunk, but not as much as Uncle Sam, huh? Yeah, well, that's just the case with everything. Of course, Uncle Sam is going to take a ton, about 28% in federal taxes. Unless you win millions of dollars, then it's going to shoot up to 39%, which is the highest tax bracket. Yep, and then add state and locals, and you'll get about half of your money. And then if you choose a lump sum, you get less anyway. So like you said, a $10 million lump sum payment after taxes would be about two and a half mil. Right. But you're done. That's the way I would want to do it. You are done.
With the annuitized payments, right, you're basically getting – you start, I think, at what, 1%? Yeah, and it goes up a little bit each year. It's up a tenth of a percent each year. Right. So you start off, if you win $10 million, you start off with $250K, and then the last payment turns out to be $500K. Right. And you get this check every year. Yeah. And the way that this is paid for, the lottery is not just like, oh, we're sitting on this pile of cash. No, they couldn't do that. What they do, actually, is they deal with bond agents, bond brokers, and they buy zero-coupon bonds, right? Uh-huh.
So, like, you have a set price that you're paying for on that day, and in one year or ten years or whatever, this thing's going to be worth a specified amount of money. Right. So, like, in ten years, if you bought a $260 bond, I'm sorry, 25 years, that would be about $1,000. Right. That's how that works. And what the lotto does is they contact about usually seven bond dealers to find out who has the best rates. and they purchase a package of 25 bonds to cover your payout. And then once the bond matures, they get the money, they transfer it to you, and you get a check. Done. Done. Pretty interesting.
And that usually ends up costing them this package of bonds about half of the jackpot, which is about what you get when you get a lump sum. So it doesn't really matter to them either way. Yeah, I think they said about 80% of the people choose the lump sum. I'm not surprised by that at all. Yeah. And Georgia, actually, I know there's other states too, has one of those win for life deals where there is no lump sum. You get like $50,000 a year for 30 years or something like that, and that's the prize. There's no wiggle room in how you accept it. Yeah, other states give you a choice. No, no, no. Win for life is a specific game.
Oh, it is. Okay. Yeah, so like if you play win for life, that's your prize. Well, some states don't give you a choice. They're like we give out lump sum or we give out annuitized. Or you can choose, but when you choose, you have to choose when you buy the lotto ticket. Yeah, I think New York, you've got to choose when you buy it, but most other states, once you've won it, they let you choose. Yeah. Pretty cool. Yeah. Chuck, did you know there's two types of lotto machines? I do now. I did too. I did before. Yeah. I think all I've ever seen is the AirMix machine. Same here. I think that's what they use on Channel 2 Action News.
I know that dude, by the way. Do you? What's his name? John Crow. Yeah. He's an old friend of mine from TV production. Wow. And he was picked as the lottery guy. Wow. He looks really good in a dress. You mean dressed up, sure. Yeah, yeah. He's a nice guy. Yeah. And he's a nice guy using air mix machine. Right. And that is the one where you see the ping pong balls floating around in the air. It's like magic. Yeah. And then they open the little door and one at a time the little ping pong ball slides up the chute. Always visible. That's key. You can never have a ping pong ball go through a tube that you can't see through.
That's bad news. It is. It doesn't inspire confidence. And you'll also notice that all lotto drawings are live. Yeah, true. Which is kind of a big thing, too. Very important. I mean, you suspect they're live. I guess if you don't believe that the moon landing was real, you probably aren't buying that the lotto drawings are live. Yeah, we should mention a couple of other security measures. In Oregon, it's actually overseen by the state police, and the detective attends each drawing. Right. I thought that was pretty cool. Balls are usually weighed ahead of time. Why? Before and after. Why? Are we going to talk about Pennsylvania?
Let's do it. All right. The triple six fix. Yeah. Is what it's called. John Travolta. In 1980. John Travolta? Was it a movie? I can't remember. I think it was. What's he got to do with it then? He was in a movie about it. Oh, okay. I think it was loosely based on that. I don't think it was like a depiction of that. Yeah. Famously in 1980, the Pennsylvania Lottery was rigged by a masterminded, not well, because he got caught, by a guy named Nick Perry. He was the John Crow of Pennsylvania at the time. He was the announcer. And he got together with an art director and said, hey, dude, can you figure out a way to weight these balls except for three of them?
Or I'm sorry, two of them, four and six. Right. And that way we know that only combinations of four and six will come up, and I think there's eight combinations and a triple-digit drawing. And they did it. But they got greedy and got caught. Was the art director named Phoebe Buffay? No. Was she in the Travolta movie? Yeah. His name was Joseph Bach, and he was pinched along with Perry and then some other people they had in on the scam. Nice heist lingo. No. So basically they ended up – the cops were alerted to the fact that there was a very skewed amount of numbers bought for six and four. And when it came up 666 and they had all these people clamoring for winnings, they went, we should look into this.
I think that just the fact that it came up 666 alone should have raised a few eyebrows, right? That's the number of the beast, Josh. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. The universe is full of mysteries. Black holes, quantum physics, galaxies.
On TikTok, millions of people are learning more about the universe around them every day. Scientists break down complex theories, demonstrate experiments, and connect dots between the cosmos and our daily lives. One scroll might reveal the concepts on the fabric of space-time, the next an optical illusion. It's discovery on a massive scale, where millions learn something new every day. And so they were tried and convicted, And Perry, I think some of the other guys sold him out. And he went to jail just for a couple of years. Then the halfway house. And then he was on probation. So not a very big deal for him.
I guess not. Did he get to keep the money? No, no. They got all that back. Oh, okay. So, yeah. They were using an air mix machine. And since then, air mix machines are still used, obviously. They use them. Your buddy uses it on the news. It's not his machine. Oh, it isn't? No. Okay. He doesn't take it home and polish it at night before bed? No, but we could get a scam together with him. We should try it. Oh, Chuck. Did I just blow it? Yeah. Anyway, the other type of lotto machine that's generally used, that's viewed as more secure, largely because of that 1980 scam, is the Gravity Pick lotto machine, right?
Yeah. How does that thing work? Well, it uses kind of rubbery balls that are heavy. Right. With two paddles that spin in opposite directions that mix the balls, right? There's no air involved. There's no ping pong balls. There's no wading the balls. And other than that, it's virtually the same thing as an air pick ball. This is an optical sensor, so it's high tech. And then, bam, six numbers, one after the other. Right. And if you pick them, you won. I imagine, like I said, I don't play. I don't even want to win. But I imagine that's a very surreal moment when you look down at your ticket because there's all those numbers.
I'll bet it's really difficult for your brain to really see that and accept that that's what it's seeing. When I worked in New Jersey at the restaurant, that's really the only time I ever played that much. We'd pool our money, the waiters would, and we'd buy like 100 tickets. You'd throw in $5 and I'll agree to split it and buy the restaurant and burn it down if we want. That kind of thing. Was that Mexicali? No, no, this is in New Jersey. Oh, okay. At the store. Nice. Is that it? Yeah, that's it. Well, if you want to read about lottos, and we also have an article called How to Play the Lottery, Tips and Guidelines.
It's pretty in-depth, isn't it? I didn't read that one. Did you read it? Oh, it is in-depth, dude. Are there tips? Yeah. What kind of tips could there be? Well, there's like wheeling, tracking, like basically paying attention to numbers, how different people do them. Pooling is one thing. how many members there should be in a pool. If it's a private pool, no more than 15. If it's a large commercial pool, no more than 100. Make sure that the people who are organizing it are reputable, etc., etc. I bet that could get messy. Look at these spreadsheets. Holy cow. Yeah. So if you are interested in playing the lotto and you want some tips and tricks...
We won't judge you. No. You can type in lotteries on howstuffworks.com in the handy search bar. And there you will also find, in my experience, the first time I've ever seen the phrase, hotter than a $2 pistol used in an article on the site. You'll find that by typing lottery in the handy search bar at HowStuffWorks.com, which brings us, of course, to listener mail. Yes, indeed, Herr Clark. I'm just going to call this, I can't believe this happened, email. This is from Ben and Megan, and they said this. My wife and I married in Las Vegas recently in one of those amazing Las Vegas chapels. It wasn't a tequila-inspired spur-of-the-moment sort of thing.
We planned it for several months, and you guys actually played a part in our evening. Oh, yeah. You remember this one? Yeah. I can't believe this. To explain, before we left, I had crafted a perfect wedding night playlist on my iPod. I've also added several of your podcasts to listen to on the flight because he's a big tall guy and he hates to fly. So apparently we helped that. After the ceremony... What? What does him being tall have to do with hating to fly? Well, he says he gets real uncomfortable in the seat and our podcast helps him forget his step. So he's not afraid of flying because he's tall or anything like that.
No. I got you. I'm just kidding. Sorry. So after the ceremony and dinner, we retreated to our luxe suite in the Trump Hotel, ordered a bottle of champagne. Nice. Queued up the playlist on my iPod and plugged into the room stereo and slipped into the in-room jacuzzi. First up, Al Green, then Solomon Burke, Cat Power, Elvis Costello, and then Josh and Chuck introducing the Stuff You Should Know podcast. It's not any worse than Cat Power. Yeah, that's true. I hadn't realized the shuffle feature would shuffle everything on the iPod, not only the songs. Just in case you were wondering, we actually let it play.
and that's a story of how you two took part in our wedding night. I believe that makes us your official Stuff You Should Know podcast newlyweds. P.S. Was it good for you? That's awesome. That's from Ben and Megan. The only way that story could be better is if they conceived during one of our podcasts. Right. Yeah. And it was the show on like lobotomies. Yeah. In Utah, we'd have legal claim on that baby. Oh, really? Yeah. Dang. If you have an awesome wedding night story. No, actually, you guys just keep that to yourself. agreed. Yeah. If you have a story about winning the lottery and how it either uplifted your life, ruined your life, or made you cognizant of the phrase hotter than a $2 pistol, put in an email and send it to stuffpodcast at howstuffworks.
com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit howstuffworks.com. Want more HowStuffWorks? Check out our blogs on the HowStuffWorks.com homepage. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful first-hand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community.
Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kids-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kids' bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row.
That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.