Being nominated as a Supreme Court Justice is no small thing, and it doesn't always go as planned. With this week's confirmation of Justice Gorsuch, Josh and Chuck take a look at the process of getting named to America's highest court.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. There's Charles W. Chuck Bryant, and there's Jerry over there, and this is Stuff You Should Know. I object. To what? I don't know. I don't think you object in front of the Supreme Court. I think they strike you down with lightning if you talk out of turn.
Yeah, did they even – geez, I'd love to see one of those hearings. Yeah. Did they even call them hearings? Magic hour? I don't know. Yeah, they do call them hearings. I'm almost positive. It's like shrouded in secrecy though, right? You never – No. They don't show that stuff on TV, do they? Like C-Span? No. No. But they do have – like if you listen to Nina Totenberg, she's a great Supreme Court reporter. Yeah. And it's all just – it's not televised. And I guess it is just traditional reporting – reporters that are allowed in there. Yeah. But it's not closed to the press or anything. It's not like a FISA court or anything like that.
It's not the Star Chamber. No. No. It's interesting, though. It is sort of – it does seem sort of secretive, though, because they, like, write these rulings. Sometimes they don't even read them. I saw that Clarence Thomas went seven years without speaking in court. What? Yeah, that's what it said. Where did you see that? In an article about Clarence Thomas. It said he's one of the quietest justices. It said he went at 1.7 years without speaking in court, but apparently writes a lot in his rulings. His briefs. His briefs. Yeah. He writes in his briefs. Yeah, I could see that because I guess when you're in court, you're arguing in front of the Supreme Court.
I think basically, and we'll do like a whole separate Supreme Court episode. Yeah. Right? You agree? Sure. Okay. Somebody mark that down. Right. But you're being peppered with questions from them. And then you're trying to answer the questions to show why your side is right. You're arguing this case. Clarence Thomas. He just sits there and goes, mm-hmm. And intimidates you, yeah. But yeah, part of it is going back, thinking about it, and then writing your opinion on it. Yeah. Very weird job. It is. It's a pretty neat job, too. Yeah. One of the big things about it is it's here in the United States.
If you were on the Supreme Court, it's the highest court in the land. Right. Sure. I guess we should say that. You're there for life. Yeah. It's a life appointment. It's the only, as far as I know, besides working at the DMV, am I right? It's the only for life appointment in the United States government. Yeah, which seems kind of crazy. but it also sort of makes sense because you want a stable Supreme Court. Yeah, you want them focusing on cases, not what's going on, whether they need to be elected again or campaigned. It makes sense once you kind of put your head to it. Plus it also kind of dovetails with the way that they're viewed here in this country, and I'm sure abroad too, that they are this panel of highly learned legal scholars.
Yeah. Yeah. Just basically like, I don't know. I'm sure there's something in Star Wars that resembles this, you know? Oh. The Jedi Council. Oh, man. I'm always afraid to say anything about Star Wars. You know, the Jedi Council that Jar Jar Binks was on. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. We won't hear anything about that. How could we? Right. So this was written by our old buddy, Ed Grabianowski. Yes. Should we tell everybody? The Grabster? Should we reveal the big reveal? Do we have an announcement? I think so. All right, go ahead. Oh, you're letting me do it? Yeah. So everybody, you may not know this because we tried to stretch out Grabster articles as much as we could, but they were starting to get thin.
Yeah. Grabster wasn't really writing for the site any longer. Well, we said, enough of this. We need them. Yeah. We need them bad. So we did a little wheeling, tad bit of dealing, and Grabster is going to be writing, again, specifically topics that we are requesting. Yeah, it's pretty great. You and I were both so excited. Stoked, I think, is the word. Yeah. So anyway, we love Ed, and a big shout out to him and to Buffalo, New York. Yeah, and their wings. And their football team. Sure. Why not? So anyway, Ed wrote this, and it's a great article. So like you said, I think we kind of dove into it really quickly, but if you're not in the United States, you might be saying, what's the Supreme Court?
Although I think you probably know. Like you said, they are the highest court. And they're the third branch of our government. And they are specifically there to kind of keep everyone in check and to say, like, you know, you may be the president, but you're not a dictator because you still have to answer to the Supreme Court at the end of the day. You can't run amok. Yeah. And we're going to make sure that we – and this is ideally – we're going to make sure that we review everything in a legal way and we're going to get to ideology. You can't escape that, of course. But Supreme Court justices are supposed to rule on law and specifically these days at least how it relates to the Constitution.
Yeah. And that's a – it wasn't their initial – they weren't created to say like go defend the Constitution. Right. And the Supreme Court said, well, can we sew some patches or bedazzle our robes? And the framers said, sure, we don't care. So they went out and defended the Constitution. It actually is very vague. The judicial branch or the Supreme Court is created in the Constitution. But all it says is that they are there to – that its power shall, quote, extend to all cases in law and equity arising under this Constitution. That's it. It's the only thing it mentions about the Supreme Court and its power.
So ever since the Constitution was written and ratified, the Supreme Court has kind of been this evolving thing. Or it was evolving for a while. Now it's pretty well set into its role and what it's meant to do. What evolves and changes are, like you said, the ideology and the personalities of the people sitting on the court. Yeah, and their word is the final word. There is no court that can overturn or review even their decisions. And they review – they have about 5,000 cases submitted every year and can only review about 100 to 150, which I thought was kind of a lot actually. 150? Sure. Yeah, I was not expecting that.
And they specifically try now, like we said, and focus on the Constitution or usually cases that have been appealed from lower federal courts. You know, they work their way up the food chain. Or, and I think they probably love these, treason, cases involving treason or disputes with other countries or ambassadors, kind of like, you know, the high stakes stuff. Sure. Imagine being an ambassador and getting dragged in front of the Supreme Court for something you did. being. Or your kid did. Yeah, probably. Those little snot-nosed brats. Ambassador kids. So like I was saying, the Constitution is pretty vague about what the Supreme Court is meant to do.
And it wasn't even out of the gate that they realized that they were supposed to really kind of examine laws in respect to the Constitution. That started in an 1803 case, Marbury versus Madison. Big one. And it was, yeah, it was a landmark watershed case. Both kinds. And ironically, the court found that it didn't have the power to satisfy the petitions of the petitioners. Yeah. I think James Madison, or no, Stefan Marbury was suing James Madison because James Madison had said, we'll give you these commissions. And then he was taken out of office or he phased out of office and the commissions were forfeited.
And the Supreme Court said, you know, we thought we had the power to do this, but it turns out we don't constitutionally. So sorry. And it was the first time that the Supreme Court had ever examined something through the lens of the Constitution and that set the precedent from then on. Yeah, and they serve, well, they serve kind of however long they want to or if they die, obviously. Yeah. But they average about 14 years. Or if they retire, they average retirement age of 71. But they can serve super long. I know that one justice served for 35 years. Yeah. And, you know, if you nominate a young judge, which is kind of more of the trend these days when you're thinking politically, like, you know, we want someone in there for our team, so pick a young one.
Right. then they can have tremendous sway in how things go in this country. Year after year after year after year. Yeah. Yeah, because the reason why they have so much sway is, like, the stuff that they're ruling on is constitutional in nature. And here in the United States, if it's constitutional, if it's guaranteed by the Constitution, protected by the Constitution, outlawed by the Constitution, whatever, However, the Supreme Court measures the law against the Constitution. Like you said, that's the law of the land. From that point on, any law similar to what the Supreme Court just ruled on, it's immediately null and void.
Like it's done. Ed uses a really good example in this. He said like if Maine bans anti-war signs from people's front yards and the Supreme Court rules that that law is unconstitutional, well, if Rhode Island has a similar law or California has a similar law, those laws are immediately illegal, I guess. Right. And it's not like Rhode Island is going to bring their case and then California is going to try their case. Once they rule, it's done. It's been ruled on. That's right. By the SC. Yeah, and there are nine justices. Right now there are eight, which we're going to get into. And obviously having an odd number means you can break a tie.
So with eight, you can have a tie. And when you do have a tie, they've actually thought about this, believe it or not, they arm wrestle. I'm kidding, of course. They don't arm wrestle. But what happens is the lower court decision is what's called passively upheld, which means that for that case only, it's upheld. But it's not like the Supreme Court didn't rule on it, and it doesn't create that nationwide legal precedent forever and ever. Yeah. It's passive aggressive. And someone could, you know, once they get that ninth person, they could bring up a similar case, not the same one, but a similar one if they want to have that precedent set.
Right. And the Supreme Court can be like, let's try it again. Yeah. But yeah, for a case to be decided definitively, all you need is a simple majority, five to four. And a lot of cases these days in the United States have like five to four decisions. Oh, yeah. Which is the fact that that's a pattern and that's a routine really kind of shows you how just close to the center that ideologically the bench is. Yeah. And that all it would take was one or two votes that you can really rely on one way or the other. It's going to be super liberal or it'll be super conservative. Yeah, and these days it's – I mean sometimes you'll get surprises on ideology.
Like, oh, we thought this person would vote this way or that way. But generally you've got kind of the four on the left, the four on the right, or you did before Scalia died. And I think Kennedy is sort of the swing vote, right? Yeah. Generally speaking, of course. Right. It used to be Sandra Day O'Connor. Right. But when they say, oh, we were surprised we thought they were going to vote this way, that's putting it about as mildly as you can. What? Surprise? Yeah, yeah. Outrage? Oh, I wasn't expecting that. Fiddle DD. Yeah, and I looked up some of the – I mean, we'll get to this later, but some of the appointees throughout history have been made by like a conservative appoints a conservative, and then they might grow a little more liberal over time or the other way around.
And they're always like, they're so upset. Right. Like, you know, I thought this is what we were getting. But to me, that's how it should be. You know, like that means probably that that judge is deciding cases based on merit. Right. And not like I'm just dug in and entrenched in one ideology. Yes. Which is exactly what you want from a Supreme Court justice. Should we take a break? Yeah, let's take a break. All right. We're talking about appointments. So we'll get to that right after this. We'll see you next time. a lab, a lecture hall, and science museum in your pocket. TikTok is where wonder is shared, where curiosity turns into discovery, and where millions learn something new every day.
Experience the beloved Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible. Get ready to be transported to the world of Harry Potter in a captivating production that features hundreds of unique voices and immersive sound design that brings the wizarding world vividly to life in Dolby Atmos. Also featuring an electrifying new musical score, Harry Potter The Full Cast Audio Editions presents the iconic series as a truly spellbinding listening event for the whole family. It features a spectacular A-list cast, including Hugh Laurie as Albus Dumbledore, Matthew McFadden as Voldemort, Riz Ahmed as Severus Snape, and many more.
The adventure will surround you. You'll hear footsteps echoing off the walls of Hogwarts and the whoosh of a golden snitch as it darts past your ear. It's a spellbinding experience for longtime Harry Potter fans and a delightful new way to introduce the stories to a new generation. The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, is available now with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter. It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before. Listen on Audible. Go to audible.com slash HP1 and start listening today. All right. How's this work? Appointing?
Yeah. So remember, the Constitution is when their Supreme Court do it, I'm done, I'm out. Right. I'm going to take a nap. So appointments, it's all just made up, right? There's no qualifications. There's no requirements. you or I could be nominated to be on the Supreme Court. Yeah, technically you're totally right. If a president was like, I want to figure out the fastest way to ruin my political career, I've got it. Josh and Chuck, as one. That'd be a good way to do it. Because, again, here in this country, people treat Supreme Court nominations like a religion. Yeah. It's a big, big deal. Not even to get someone through the process.
just to nominate somebody can bring so much blowback from your party, from the voters, from the opposing party, from everybody that you really want to think it through. It's not a haphazard thing. But as far as starting the whole thing off, you have a list of qualified candidates. I think every single Supreme Court justice in history has been a lawyer at least. But lately, almost all of them, the only person on the Supreme Court now who isn't a judge is Elena Kagan. But the trend is most of them are federal judges who are called up to the bigs. Yeah, and a lot of them have even served as clerks on the Supreme Court.
Right. So what they're looking for with all that is experience. Yeah, and for the last 150 years, not only have they been attorneys, but they didn't go to the strip mall. Although, was it O'Connor? Well, she didn't go to a strip mall law school, but she was a strip mall lawyer, I think. Yeah. At first. Yeah. But they have all graduated from an accredited, legit university. Not like Dr. Nick, who graduated from the Upstairs Medical Clinic. Is that what it was called? I think it was Tijuana Upstairs Medical Clinic. A lot of these justices before their Supreme Court appointment have been involved in politics.
Some of them have been governors. Some of them have been in Congress. There was even one former president, one Howard Taft. Howard Taft is actually a great story. He hated being president, hated it, loved being a Supreme Court justice. I could see that. He sat on the bench. It groaned. Anyway, I'm home. This is great. The bench groaned. Yeah. I know that for a little while there were people, there were rumblings that Obama might be in line for a Supreme Court appointment. Wow. Had the election gone a different way. Yeah. Which would have been – I could see that. I could too. But obviously that's not going to happen.
No, I don't see Trump appointing Obama. No. All right. So once this nomination goes through – and the president, it used to be like a very – I don't know about solitary. Probably they're a little closed circle. But now, like you said, they get a list that's culled from a group of very smart people that are trying to firmly entrench their own ideologies, basically. So they're going to choose from that list, the candidate, and nominate them officially. And the Senate then will hold hearings. And just recently, we've seen this going on. This is happening right now with Gorsuch. Yeah, and the whole thing would have started with Gorsuch getting a phone call from the press saying, hey, I want you to want me on the Supreme Court.
Yeah. And Gorsuch was like, I don't know what you're saying. He's like, you're going to be on the Supreme Court and hung up. Right. That was it. And then, yeah, the name gets released to the press and the Senate says, all right, let's get busy. Let's get to work. And this whole hive, beehive of activity just starts kicking up around this one poor sap who accepted the nomination and now has everyone from the Justice Department to congressional aides putting on latex gloves and going right up their rectum to try to see what they can find in this person's past. Yeah, and not only what they can find in their past, but really grilling them on maybe where he or she might lie ideologically.
Like, how would you rule in this case that it has happened? How would you feel about this case? Right. And I was watching a news network the other day talking about how Gorsuch did such a masterful job of, like, dodging. Deflecting it? Yeah, about, like, not going on record with how they lean. Right. And that's tradition. Well, yeah, apparently they like the one thing that you're supposed to do up there is not give anything away. No, because it's a big dance. And if they say, yeah, Joe Biden back in I think the 80s call it a kabuki dance. And Elena Kagan called it a vapid and hollow charade because the senators are trying to ping you down one way or another on your views on gun control, abortion.
All of these hot-button issues that the Supreme Court has either ruled on, may rule on in the future, may overturn at some point, that really split the country ideologically. And the point of these Senate hearings is basically for the nominee to sit there and not give up anything. Because if they did do that, then they would have to recuse themselves from that case for having gone on the public record stating their position. Well, yeah, and it's the opposition party's job to sit there and sigh and rub their temples and say, well, it just seems like you don't want to go on record for anything.
Right. And they never get to respond, duh. Yeah. It's a Senate hearing for Supreme Court justice. This is what always happens. It's really funny that they play that up. It's so weird. Like the senators act like they just can't believe what's going on, even though this has been happening for decades now. Yeah. It's just a big, I don't know about a charade. But I think part of it is to see how well they can hold up to the grilling, too. I think that's part of it as well. But the group that probably plays the biggest role in kind of rooting out what the nominee's politics are are the aides in the Justice Department and whatever they leak to the media.
Right. Because you wouldn't find anything out about, say, like Gorsuch from those two days of hearings. Right. No one found anything out about him. If that's all you know about that guy was those two days of hearings, you didn't read anything else about it, you'd have no idea what his positions were. You'd just be like, that guy's got one of the better haircuts I've ever seen in my life. That's all you would get from it. But the media tends to report on it, and they kind of fulfill the role that the Senate fails at every single time. And it'll be things like Harriet Myers was nominated by George W.
Bush. And he just got immediate blowback for it. It was a terrible nomination. But one of the things somebody found was that she had contributed some money back in 1988, like a good 15-something years before, to Al Gore's presidential campaign. That was the smoking gun. They find little stuff like that, and they try to put it all together to create a picture so that the senators can ask them about stuff or whatever, or the media can paint a picture one way or another, and everyone can try to divine how they're going to rule. Now, did Harriet Myers actually go through the Senate hearings? No, she withdrew.
Well, that's what will happen a lot of times. If there is a skeleton in their closet, sometimes they won't accept the nomination. Not even for that reason. And sometimes they won't accept the nomination because they're like, no, man, I know it. I don't want to go through all that. I'm fine just being on my federal circuit here. Right. But sometimes they'll withdraw if they know that they won't make it through that and they don't want that drug out in public. And sometimes the president will withdraw that nomination to avoid that kind of embarrassment, too. Right. Like Clarence Thomas, I don't know how they missed that or if they did.
He famously allegedly sexually harassed Anita Hill. Right. And I don't know if that didn't come to light until the hearings or if. That's what my guess was. Really? I think they started the hearings and they were still doing investigations and they hadn't gotten to Anita Hill yet. He would have not made it today, I don't think, in today's climate. No, that was nuts. But what's ironic about it is that he wouldn't make it in today's climate with our awareness and understanding of sexual harassment. But those hearings, his Supreme Court confirmation hearings were what exposed the world to sexual harassment.
The concept of it that we understand today is rooted in that moment, in those three days where Anita Hill stood up and was like, this is messed up and I'm going to share it. And Clarence Thomas famously called the whole thing a high-tech lynching. Yeah. And then after all this, so he was about to be voted on. There was debate in the Senate, which we'll get to this process in a second. After this came to light, they sent it back to the committee hearings. Yeah. So he took a huge step backward in the confirmation process. Had to go through three days of Anita Hill's testimony. And then after that, the Senate still said, all right, cool.
We'll confirm you. Yeah. And he was so upset, he said, I'm not going to talk for seven years. Right. I'll show you. So by and large, though, the vast majority of appointee submissions, what would you call them, nominations, are appointed. Right. Oh, I think it's something like there have been 161 nominations and 124 have been confirmed. I think there's only been 36 rejections. And so the rest are withdrawals. Or there's one very recent one that I think is the first in history. Obama's nomination of Merrick Garland that just didn't even get heard. Yeah. Which is very much an unusual step that was taken in the process.
Yeah. I mean, this just happened. Everyone saw it happen. Obama was in his last year of his presidency. And so Republican senators basically said, not only are we not going to vote on it, we're not going to hold hearings. Some of them refused to even talk to the guy. They just basically took their ball and went home. Right. So we're not going to do anything. Yeah. Which received a lot of blowback from people already frustrated with the notion that maybe these people work for them and they should do their jobs. And that is one of their jobs is to at least have hearings and take a vote. And everyone dug in and he went without hearings, went without a vote.
Yeah. And I don't know what he's doing now. I guess he just kept his regular job. Oh, yeah. I'm sure. I don't think you lose your job and quit and move and everything, go on the trail. No, he – yeah. But I think more to the point, it's got to affect your reputation, you know what I'm saying? Even if it was no fault of his own, it's still like a black mark on his history at least. Well, it was a big deal because this was – it's kind of tough to pin down someone's political ideology as a judge. They have a few ways of doing it. There's something called the Martin Quinn score for Supreme Court justices, and they compare how they vote relative to one another.
And then there's something else called the Judicial Commons Space Score, which measures their ideology based on the ideology of their appointing presidents and home state senators. And then I think this was from Washington Post. I read an article that they're basically trying to suss out how liberal is Garland. Right. He was super centrist, wasn't he? Well, they said in the end that they looked at all those scores. And then they did one more where they basically looked at the law clerks that they hired. Because generally you're going to hire clerks that agree with you and clerks who want to work for judges whom they agree with.
Right. And they looked at what the clerks' political donations where they were. So what's this guy's score? They said that he was center left in the end. Sure. Would have definitely swung the court more to the left. But at the time, you know, it was sort of a showdown. It was like for the Republicans, they're like, do we let Garland go through because he's sort of center left? Or do we take a chance that Hillary wins this election and goes whole hog left to someone that's way more liberal? Right. And in the end, they dug in and, well, everyone knows what happened. Yeah. And I read both sides of this.
Like, obviously, the liberals and the Democrats were just going crazy over it. They're like, this is the audacity of not doing this, right? Because the Republicans were saying, well, it's an election year, so we don't want to put a Supreme Court nominee on the Supreme Court for life during an election year, right? And the Democrats said, you're crazy. There's been like eight or nine Supreme Court justices who were confirmed on an election year. That's a terrible argument. But apparently that was when the, I think the government wasn't split, right? There wasn't like the executive and Congress were in the same party.
The same party was in power for like seven or eight of those confirmations to have gone through. So both sides actually had legitimate arguments, but it definitely seemed like a dereliction of duty from the outside looking in. Well, what it did, too, is it set up the Gorsuch situation now, which is Democrats are delaying the vote. And I think by the time this comes out, they will have voted. I would guess so, because usually I think McConnell said by April 2nd he'd be confirmed was his estimate. Yeah. Well, they delayed it one more week a couple of days ago. OK. But regardless, it's imminent if it hasn't just happened.
And so they set up the situation now where Democrats are dug in and they're like, don't expect any votes from us to confirm. And then the Republicans are saying, well, if you do that, though, we don't need a simple – we just need a simple majority. We can use what's called the nuclear option. Which we talked about in the filibusters episode, I think. Yeah. So the Democrats would filibuster. Then they would use a nuclear option, which means they can kind of rewrite the rules and confirm with a simple majority. And then there's a fear that if that happens, that will just be the norm going forward.
Yeah, that they'll use that for everything. And on the one hand, it will definitely be the Democrats' fault because they used the nuclear option first. Right. But they used it for a bunch of Obama appointees back in, I think, 2013 or 15. And they said specifically this does not apply to Supreme Court nominees. Right. Now the pendulum is swinging the other way. The Republicans are in control. If they use the nuclear option for the Supreme Court nominees, that'll just be like there'll be nothing off limits any longer. And yeah, there will be no filibuster power in the Senate any longer. Yeah, it really underscores just how ugly things have gotten.
Yeah, it's pretty ugly these days in Washington. It is. And we should say, we'll take a break in a second, Chuck, but we keep talking about the Senate. The House has nothing to do with this, actually. Is that why they're pouty? Yeah, a little bit. It's strictly the president appoints and the Senate holds committee hearings and then debate and then votes. And then the person is either confirmed or rejected, almost exclusively confirmed. Right. And if they are rejected, they can be submitted again. but it usually doesn't make sense to unless something big has happened that makes the president think that they can get confirmed.
Right. Which happened, I think, with Andrew Jackson. Is that right? Yeah. In the 18... 1836. Yeah. He had a guy named Roger Caney, who I'd never heard of before, who he submitted. Guy got rejected. And then there were elections that changed the complexion of the Senate. Yeah. That was much friendlier to Jackson. So he did it again. He brought him in with a baseball hat on. He said, how about this guy instead? Fake mustache. And George W. Bush did the same thing too, but his guy, John Roberts, didn't get rejected. But he nominated Roberts twice in the same month for two different seats. Oh, that's right.
And the second time he got confirmed. So there's a lot of politicking that goes on behind this. A lot of thought goes into it, not surprisingly. And we'll talk about all that stuff right after this. The universe is full of mysteries. Black holes, quantum physics, galaxies. On TikTok, millions of people are learning more about the universe around them every day. Scientists break down complex theories, demonstrate experiments, and connect dots between the cosmos and our daily lives. One scroll might reveal the concepts on the fabric of space-time, the next an optical illusion. It's discovery on a massive scale, where millions learn something new every day.
Experience the beloved Harry Potter stories like you've never heard them before on Audible. Get ready to be transported to the world of Harry Potter in a captivating production that features hundreds of unique voices and immersive sound design that brings the wizarding world vividly to life in Dolby Atmos. Also featuring an electrifying new musical score, Harry Potter, the full cast audio editions presents the iconic series as a truly spellbinding listening event for the whole family. It features a spectacular A-list cast, including Hugh Laurie as Albus Dumbledore, Matthew McFadden as Voldemort, Riz Ahmed as Severus Snape, and many more.
The adventure will surround you. You'll hear footsteps echoing off the walls of Hogwarts and the whoosh of a golden snitch as it darts past your ear. It's a spellbinding experience for longtime Harry Potter fans and a delightful new way to introduce the stories to a new generation. The first story in the series, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, is available now with new audiobooks in the series releasing every month thereafter. It's Harry Potter like you've never heard it before. Listen on Audible. Go to audible.com slash HP1 and start listening today. So, Chuck, this is not, again, this isn't taken lightly.
It is a hollow and vapid charade and a kabuki dance, and it's ridiculous in a lot of ways. But the end result is really, really important, and that is that you have a Supreme Court justice who's one of nine voices that create the law of the land here in the United States and that they're on there for life. So everyone, again, takes it extremely seriously. And there's a lot of things to be considered when a president is even picking a nominee from that list that they have. Yeah, even though we said there are no rules for qualifications, there's a long history. that's kind of become accepted as qualifications, which we've talked about, an attorney, generally a federal court judge.
So once that is kind of sussed out, we talked about ideology a lot. And you're not going to find, as Ed points out, the perfect fit where someone agrees with everything that you agree with as president. But what you want is someone who, by and large, will side with your side. I mean, let's be honest. A good fella. Yeah. You know? Sure. He's like us. But again, it's not going to be a perfect fit. Yeah, but you also want someone who probably has a good chance of getting confirmed. That's a big point, right? So there's a lot of factors that go into that selection, right? So obviously, if you are a conservative president, especially like a deeply socially conservative president, you're going to try to find somebody who's a pretty socially conservative ideologue, right?
Yeah. And that'll be your pick. But you may want to stop yourself and think about this first. Let's think about this. Who's in control of the Senate? Yeah. That's a big one. Sure. If it's the opposition party, well, then you may want to consider somebody who's maybe a little closer to the center because your person might get rejected. And if you're just an outside observer saying, well, who cares? They'll get rejected. Pick somebody else. You said you have a list. Go to the next person, right? Right. There's a lot of political ramifications for this, right? So if you are a president and you're picking a pretty radical nominee, it can make you look bad, especially if you're not that popular of a president.
Yeah, and it can also have a lot of bearing on midterm elections and how the public views the direction the country is going as a whole. Yeah, because if the Senate goes along with your radical person and the public's not down with that person, that's going to be a negation on the ballot. Like you're not going to look good at all because of this Supreme Court nominee pick. Yeah, whoever just left, whether it was a retiree or in the case of Scalia, someone who just died suddenly, the outgoing justice is going to play a large part. And again, depending on what party's in office, what party holds the Senate, on who gets the replacement.
Can you get somebody pushed through? And if you can't, it's not going to look very good on you as the president. Yeah, and basically with Gorsuch, I looked him up as far as where he might sit or is predicted to sit. He's pretty right from what I saw. Yeah, obviously he's pretty right, but they said that he would right now, at least this is from all the studying done from those different methodologies that I talked about earlier. They said he would sit second to the right next to Thomas, the silent Clarence Thomas. Right. who apparently is the furthest right at this point. Yeah. And then, you know, it goes all the way through down to Sonia Sotomayor, who's the furthest to the left.
Gotcha. And then Mr. Kennedy in the middle. Man, what a powerful dude he is. Yeah, really. To be the swing vote. He gets gift baskets all the time. Yeah, he probably. Muffin baskets. Yeah, he has muffins every morning. And, you know, depending on, and people forecast this, like, way in advance. I'm like, it's not just Supreme Court justices. It's appointing judges all throughout the system in the United States. Republicans have had a tactic for years now that's really paid off for them, where they have really worked hard to appoint as many judges, conservative-leaning judges throughout the system, and staunchly tried to oppose any liberal appointments.
And you get those lower courts. I mean, people don't pay a lot of attention a lot of times. to these lower court appointments. And it's made a big difference, you know? Oh, yeah? Oh, yeah. Over time, sure, if you've got that many more bullets in the chamber. Just as far as conservative rulings? Yeah, just all over the country. If you have more of your people in place in lower courts, there are going to be more clerks that work for them that are conservative. And then eventually they rise up, and you're probably going to have a better chance of getting a Supreme Court nominee. appointed who was conservative.
It's an incubator. Yeah. That's a good way to look at it. The farm system. Sure. They probably love that terminology. Yeah. Well, you were saying Sotomayor is farthest to the left and Thomas is farthest to the right. Right now, that's what they say. Yeah. And I think you were saying earlier too that depending on who's being replaced, that makes a decision on who's picked as well too. Sure. Right? Yeah. Because if you're replacing a far right seat with a far left nominee, you're going to get some serious pushback from the right or vice versa. Yeah. And that's why this election that we just went through was so important because there are some aging members of the Supreme Court.
And if you get to a point, like Nixon got to a point for Supreme Court justices. Yeah, and they turned on him like a pack of jackals. Yeah, three of them did. I'm sure that's what Nixon thought. Yeah, and this is kind of a pretty good demonstration of how Supreme Court nominees, they're appointed or they're nominated by presidents, but they are in no way meant to be beholden to presidents. They should not be. They're not doing their job if they're ruling in line with what they think the president wants to hear. Yeah, and I guess that goes back to why they're in there for life. Like they probably do feel, I mean, they still have their ideologies, but they probably do feel like, all right, I'm in here.
They can't take me out. There's probably some mechanism to take them out if they do something really bad. It's impeachment. It's the exact same process that you would get rid of a president with where the House impeaches the person and then the Senate votes to convict or not. And then they're removed. It's only been threatened twice. One of them was a Nixon appointee. Oh, really? interesting but I was looking like I said at Garland and I kind of started digging into history and in the modern era Antonin Scalia is rated as the number one most conservative justice in the modern era is that right?
see because I have Thomas further right than him and that Gorsuch would be even further right than Scalia I didn't create that that's a WAPO created well I didn't create this either we have conflicting sources well this was Stanford University and the University of Chicago Northwestern and Harvard yeah but it was based on it just depends on what they use let's just say they're both super conservative but I mean one of the things they looked at and they like to look at is campaign contributions either by like I said clerks or by them and they said based Based on Gorsuch's campaign contributions, they said that he would be more conservative than 87% of all other federal judges.
Yeah. That's pretty conservative. Rehnquist was supposedly number two. They don't have Thomas. They have Thomas at number seven on my list. Wow. I don't know about that. They have him on the furthest right right now, at least in the sitting justices. Well, and then there's people, like I said, over time that might change a bit. John Paul Stevens was the guy that was in there for 35 years, and apparently he became more liberal over time. And then Burton was very conservative, but he ruled against segregation. It's like you kind of never know. David Sauter became – he was a Bush appointee, and I think he was one of those that conservatives were really mad at.
They were like, you're not nearly as conservative as we thought. Sauter. They would have never picked you. Yeah, and I mean, you just can never tell. You can't tell. And the whole point is that makes a good justice. That's what you want. You don't want to be able to look at them and be like, oh, this is how they're going to vote and be right every time. You want to be surprised because if you can just point to a Supreme Court justice and say this is how they're going to vote, they're doing a terrible job. They're voting ideologically, not on the merits of the case. Yeah, it sounds funny to say that you want a Supreme Court justice like you never know what they're going to do.
An unpredictable one. Like Clarence Thomas. He didn't speak for seven years. Who knew? Right. I did not see that coming. Sandra Day O'Connor. She wrote a penny farthing to work every day. Right. He didn't know that. Yeah. Judge Rehnquist had a huge heroin problem. Oh, you got anything else? Yeah. One of the things that Harriet Myers was criticized for, the Harriet Myers nomination by George W. Bush, was that somebody had dug up that she had called George W. Bush cool at one point. Oh, really? And that was used against her. Well, they were worried that she would be beholden to him or feel beholden to him.
Because he was so cool. Cool. Interesting. Oh, actually, we didn't cover this. I think it's pretty interesting. Arthur Goldberg, appointment of John F. Kennedy. He was Jewish, and he took his oath on the Hebrew Bible and on the traditional official court Bible, which is the Christian Bible. And he signed that because everyone has signed it. And he said, you know, I just want to – I'm not going to make a big deal out of this. Even though I'm Jewish, I'll sign the Christian Bible just to kind of maintain that continuity. Right. But when he was – he said it was really neat when he was sitting at his bench for the first time.
he opened up the drawer and there was a copy of the Constitution. He said it was a dog-eared copy of the Constitution that actually belonged and it was signed by who? Oliver Wendell Holmes. Pretty neat. It was just in that drawer. He calls him that old Yankee from Olympus. No idea what that means, but it meant something to Goldberg. I'll tell you that. He said he was looking for a notepad. He thought that was pretty awesome. Well, I do too. It is pretty awesome. And if you think Supreme Court nominations are awesome, you should go look them up. There's plenty of stuff out there. It's pretty fun to watch.
If you go back through old articles, every nomination cycle or whatever pattern it follows has people griping about how you can't tell anything about this nominee. Yeah. And they never say, well, it's like that for all nominees. Anyway, take a trip down memory lane. You'll amuse yourself. You can also type in the word Supreme Court in the search bar at HowStuffWorks. And since I said Supreme Court, it's time for listener mail. I'm going to call this Georgia Connection to Trail of Tears. Hey, guys. I enjoyed the episodes on Trail of Tears, which I literally just finished. I live in Calhoun, Georgia, which is home to the new Echetoa.
Echetoa. She says, yeah, she says Echeta. Oh, even even serious, sir. And I think that's right. Historic site. It is home to the print shop where the first English-language Cherokee newspaper was printed. The home of Samuel Wosta, among other things. It's a beautiful and fascinating place. I think all North Georgia kids have gone on a field trip there at least once. There are also road signs that drive past every time I drive to and from my mother's house indicating that I am actually driving where the Cherokee marched from their homes. Very sobering. The home of Chief Van is also nearby. I didn't know that.
I'm going to have to go see that stuff. Yeah, because it's not too far. I enjoy your history episodes because the way you explain history in layman's terms and make it interesting to someone like me who couldn't quite stay awake in history class in school. I believe learning about history is important to help prevent society from repeating big, shameful, costly mistakes. Thanks for the work you do and all the stuff we should know. Have a blessed day. That is from Tiffany Waits. and Tiffany if you don't listen to Stuff You Missed in History Class from our colleagues Tracy and Holly you should check that out too sounds like it would be right up our alley who was it?
Tiffany Waits thanks a lot Tiffany we appreciate you writing in and if you want to be like her and get in touch with us to tell us some cool stuff you can tweet to us at SYSK Podcast or Josh Clark you can hang out with us on facebook.com slash charleswchuckbryant or stuff you should know you can send us an email to stuffpodcast at HowStuffWorks.com. And as always, join us at our home on the web, StuffYouShouldKnow.com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why season five of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP.
Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed.
It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.
com to shop now. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.