In this third episode of Stuff You Should Know's health care reform series, Josh and Chuck -- and special guest Molly Edmonds -- sort through the myths, rumors and truths behind President Obama's proposed health care plan.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. And now, Superhuman Shaq. I keep telling them not to say that. I'm no superhuman. Believe it or not, I struggle with moderate obstructive sleep apnea, or OSA.
In adults with obesity, moderate to severe OSA is a condition where breathing is interrupted during sleep, with loud snoring, choking, gasping for air, and even daytime fatigue. Let's just say it can sound a lot like this. Sound familiar? Learn more at dontsleeponosa.com. This information is provided by Lilly, a medicine company. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. With me, as always, is Charles W. Bryant. and with Charles W. Bryant and I is our colleague and health care reform guru, Molly Edmonds.
I think it would be and me, Josh. I knew she was going to say that. Yeah. Saw that coming. Yeah. Well, she's not the first person to do that. Molly, you can send an email to stuffpodcast at healthstuffworks.com. Yeah, send an email, Molly. Thank you. I'm here to keep you on track on all things grammatical and health care reform related. And health care reform. Anything else? That's good. That's it for now. That's enough, right? Perfect. So for those of you just joining us, you should probably go back and listen to the first two podcasts that we released in this special Stuff You Should Know Healthcare Reform Suite.
And this is number three of four. Yes. We talked about what's wrong with healthcare in the U.S. in the first one, right? A lot. We talked about Obama's proposal, just straight up facts. And then this one we're going to talk about myths. Yes. Both from the left and the right. So, you know, those of you who are Bill O'Reilly fans, you can sit down and have a mug of beer with people who are fans of NPR, say. Right. If you're a libertarian, you're just sorry. You're out. Just go do whatever it is you guys do. Nice, Chuck. So let's get started, kids. You want to? Yes. Sure. I think one of the things that people keep maybe weekly throwing out is that the U.
S. can't really afford to tackle health care reform right now. Myth. That's a myth. Are we doing that? Should we have some sort of ding? These are all myths, actually. Molly says it's a myth, and I agree with her. Well, you know, the thing about it is, you may not be able to afford a new TV, right? Right. But if you had an old TV and it was a tremendously bad value, I mean, if you were just paying way more for that TV than it was worth. Like, had to get it repaired a lot and that kind of thing? Yeah. I mean, then you've got to do something about it, because you're not getting a good deal on your TV.
Sometimes it's smarter to buy the new TV. Yeah, and that is the position we are in right now with health care reform, is we pay way too much money and get way too little care for what we have. So just if you like a good deal, I think you should be behind health care reform. So let's recap real quick. The U.S. is spending about $2.4 trillion a year on health care. That makes up a sixth of the gross domestic product, and that's more than we spend on defense, right? At the same time, we're not getting as much value out of it. So they say. Right. but we are entrenched in two wars in the economies in the toilet, you're saying still we should do something about it now.
How are we going to pay for it? That's another common criticism we keep hearing is how are we going to pay for this? Well, I think the specifics still need to be worked out, but I think that it's important to remember that the president has pledged that it will be deficit neutral. It's not going to add a penny to the deficit in the first 10 years that it is in action, nor after that. So, you know, it's something that we could possibly say is a myth just because we don't know exactly how we'll pay for it. But take them with a grain of salt. Yeah, I liked your point you made in here that the people are afraid that the insured are going to be paying for the uninsured.
That already happens. Oh, yeah. I mean, there's an estimate that families are paying about $1,000 more in their premiums just because people who are uninsured still show up and go to the hospital. Yeah, and they get treated. And an individual pays about $400 more. And so doctors and hospitals likely ship those costs to us because, I mean, they've got to get paid for it somehow. Sure. And they know insurance companies will pay. So let's flesh that out a little more. Say an uninsured worker, a day laborer, gets hurt on the job. The boss comes and drops him off at the ER. The ER, by federal mandate, has to treat that man, stabilize him, fix his wound, whatever, right?
He walks away. He doesn't pay. He doesn't have any insurance, and possibly he's here illegally, say. So what you're saying is the hospitals will end up charging more for patients that have insurance. They'll charge the insurance companies more. And then the insurance companies turn around and charge more for people who have insurance. They charge more in premiums, right? And then that's the way that there's a tax, an invisible tax for the uninsured that covers the uninsured that's in place right now. Right. That's the thinking that came up with these numbers, that we are already paying for people who show up without insurance.
And so if these people then had insurance, if this plan works and we can get everyone insured, then that would kind of cease that. We're hoping that it would control the cost a little bit, yeah. That would be great. So this is a $1 trillion proposal over 10 years, right? So clearly just making sure everyone has insurance in and of itself is going to be very expensive, right? is it a myth then that there won't be higher taxes for people who say make a quarter of a million dollars or more a year? I think that it's impossible to say what we'll actually have in place, but that is the president's current preference is that we tax people who make more than $250,000 a year.
Okay. And then I noticed a point that the president and people like Nancy Pelosi have made is that those people had been getting a lot of breaks over the previous eight years. What? And so they think that this is going to sort of balance that out. Without getting too political about it. That's what's being said, sure. Chuck can't help himself. They're going to start about libertarians. That's what Nancy Pelosi said, not me. So, guys, let's lighten the mood a little bit. Let's talk about death panels. Let's bring a little comedy into this one. This is probably the most pervasive myth, I would say, about health care reform.
And arguably the most asinine, wouldn't you say? I don't know. I think if you are told that you might be put to death, you're going to take it pretty seriously. Yeah, you will take it seriously. But I'm saying the, I guess the thought process behind that interpretation of the House bill about end-of-life counseling. That's what it's about, right? Yeah. So basically in the House bill it says Medicaid or Medicare can be reimbursed for voluntary end-of-life counseling, right? It doesn't say anything about the patient signing a resuscitation order or do not resuscitate order or anything like that.
It has nothing to do with actually terminating a patient's life, right? That's the way they made it sound, though. Like they would stick the pen in grandma's hand and, like, put it on the line, and if she just falls asleep and it scratches across the line. Sure, then all of a sudden there's a do not resuscitate order, and it's one less old person we have to worry about getting an organ transplant for because she voluntarily said, I don't want it. It is a myth. And not only is it a myth, it is a career ruiner too if you speak out too much. You guys heard about Betsy McCoy? Yeah, Jon Stewart. Was that the lady he killed?
He eviscerated her, yeah. Have you seen that, Molly? Yes. It's pretty rough. She's the one that came up with the term death panel, right? Yeah. Am I wrong there? I believe. Or is she just the one who's spreading around? If she didn't coin it, she gets credit for coining it. She was so vociferous about it, right? But you know what? Here's the thing. without pointing fingers at who came up with it. Right. No one wants to die, right? I would say most people would agree with that. Most people don't want to die, and they also probably don't want to spend a lot of time thinking about how they're going to die.
Right. And so the fact that we're even bringing this conversation up just makes it uncomfortable for some people. Right. The fact of the matter is that we probably all have in our head that we'd like to die maybe peacefully at home. And the fact of the matter is now, most people die in a hospital or a nursing facility. You said 80%, whereas 86% would prefer not to die there, yet 80% are dying there. So what we're trying to do is to respect, well, I shouldn't say we, it's not me trying to do this, but what these bills are trying to do is to make sure that if you do have a wish about how you die or who makes the decisions at that time when you maybe can't speak for yourself, that those wishes are respected.
The AARP has come out in support of this because the fact of the matter is that even if we don't like to talk about it, it's going to happen. let's have the conversation and if you have the conversation have it paid for by medicaid and medicare right but you don't have to have the conversation if you don't want it's completely voluntary and even if you have it you're not going to leave that meeting with a living will necessarily or um you know a dnr order you're going to leave just knowing what your options are right that i said i wasn't going to put my opinion in but that sounds like a really good idea to me sure it is and also um stewart uh pointed out on in that interview that uh you can just as easily come out of it with a resuscitate at any cost order.
So it's not just specifically about DNR. Why they call it death panel. They should have called it life no matter what panel. Because the death panel scares the tar out of the elderly. I know, that's exactly right. I think that was one of the most odious things that come out of this health care reform debate was the death panel. I mean, it was specifically geared to scare the elderly. But, you know, they already have enough things to worry about. I mean, I think that some of the elderly's fears about this bill are found when you hear there's going to be cuts to Medicare and that there might be incidences of euthanasia, which this is not true.
The death panel thing, not true, but there will be cuts to Medicare. You can't get around that. Sure. Let's talk about that because that's something that you raise in this article, that it won't affect Medicare is a myth, right? It's a promise that the president has made in terms of benefits, that if you are a Medicare recipient, that you will still have the same benefits that you've always had. Right. The fact of the matter is a large part of the funding for these proposals will likely come from Medicare because the way that Medicare operates now is probably unsustainable. So by making these cuts and incentivizing doctors to be more efficient in the way they treat patients.
We're talking about bundling services. Bundling service. So actually, Chuck and I spoke to Dr. Michael Roizen, who's the chief wellness officer at the Cleveland Clinic in, appropriately enough, Cleveland, Ohio. And he's also the co-author of the You, the Owner's Manual book series. And he talked about bundling services, and it's based around what's called accountable organizations. It's like a group that's in charge of the health of an individual patient, right? Here's what he had to say about that. So I like accountable organizations, meaning that someone pays, if you will, whether it's myself or the Cleveland Clinic where I work, pays for my health care and I don't have to worry about it.
and they get a set amount of money whether I need 16 tooth extractions and four, if you will, revisions or four total hips, two total hips, two total knees, or whether I need none. And the goal of them, of those organizations, would be then to keep me healthy so that I don't need any major technology procedures, teach me how to brush my teeth and floss so I need no teeth extractions, right? So that's what I mean by pay for accountable outcomes. So if you couldn't tell, Dr. Roizen's very hip on prevention rather than preventative care. Right. And he's also on board with accountable organizations.
And he's also evidently on board with tooth extraction. He is. It's a good example. Sixteen teeth. Well, I mean, anybody can approach a tooth extraction, right? But the point is there has to be a group that is in charge of the health care of the individual, right? And then that way you can hold that group accountable. You're paying that group, and you say, keep this person well. And if they do need treatment, this is your pool of money that you have to extract from it, right? Like so many teeth. Now, here's the problem. And this is where I think a lot of the fear comes about is what happens when that money runs out?
Can doctors be trusted to say, we're going to still keep treating you, or are they going to try to skinch on that? I mean, is that a real fear? I think it's valid. You know, we would like to think that doctors become much more efficient. There's evidence that there is a lot of waste in the Medicare system. And ideally how this will work is doctors will say, yes, we will become more efficient with this pool of money we have. But, you know, you just never know what case is going to come up that you can't treat a person with that pool of money with. So, Molly, you just brought up another point is rationing health care, right?
That's another huge fear among, you know, not just the elderly, but anybody. Like, if this bundling of payments goes beyond just Medicare and it becomes a standard, I guess one of the ways it would become a standard would be to have some sort of panel that approves medical procedures, right? Right. And there are some panels in these bills, but they do not approve medical procedures. Let's talk about those. These cost-effectiveness panels are just meant to come in and decide which treatments are effective. There's no evidence that they would come in and say, you can only do this because it's cheap.
It might be helpful to compare really quickly how Britain rations health care. Let's do it. Okay, so they've got this committee called, ironically enough, NICE. That stands for National Institute of Health and Clinical Excellence, and then they're under the NHS, which is their big public system. Right. So let's say that there's a drug that costs $15,000, and it's going to improve your standard of life from a 0.5 to a 0.7. They look at everyone's standard of life from a 0 to a 1. And it's worth saying that everyone's quality of life is considered important, whether you're a 77-year-old woman or a 12-year-old boy.
Huzzah. So it's going to improve your standard of life from 0.5 to 0.7, 0.2, and it's going to help you live 15 years longer. Okay, that's been proven in a study. So 0.2 times 15 is 3, so they get a multiplier. And then, so that's what they call three qualies, quality-adjusted life year. So they're saying your quality of life has been adjusted for these three years. Wow. It's like a multiplier. So then they're going to divide the total cost of the drug by the multiplier and get a cost per year amount. In this case, if the drug is $15,000 and your QALY is three, the drug costs $5,000 a year, and that's the number on which the NICE would approve or not approve the drug.
And NICE basically approves anything, basically anything that's about $45,000 a year or below. Are we going to base our system on that? No, that's not in the bill. When people talk about rationing health care, Britain says, yes, we have rationed health care, and that's how they do it. And there's nothing like that in any of these proposals. Let's talk some more about, actually, before we do that, I want to bring up another point that worries me, and that is that these panels that approve medical procedures could lead to a stifling of innovation, right? Is that a possibility? Well, I don't think so because if you look, I mean, even if you talk about Britain, it's not like Britain's way behind us on medical innovation.
In some countries, they've been able to do a lot more with a lot less. Right. So isn't that sort of the true definition of innovation? I think so. I think you basically have to prove that it works. I mean, we may not allow people to say, this pill will take you to Mars if it won't. Right. But – What if they said, this pill is dynamite? Would they have to prove that? Well, do they mean dynamite like explosive or just dynamite like awesome? Awesome. Okay. I mean, they definitely want to prove something that was explosive in my opinion. Sure. That's more – But I'm no doctor. The ATF, right? Yeah.
Than the FDA? Yeah. So I think it's just making people prove the quality. One of the problems so far is that we have a lot of care that we don't necessarily know if it works, but it's really expensive. Right. And this is just ensuring that people have to prove that it works. And instead of spending all this money on marketing their drugs, drug companies might have to spend more money on research and development, which I think we can argue would benefit a patient more than marketing. Sure. Boy, last time I was in the doctor, the pharmaceutical people came through there. Have you ever been to the doctor when that happened?
Did they walk in and go, we got some dynamite pills? No. Well, who knows what happened behind the doors, but there were literally like seven of them. They were spaced out like every five or ten minutes, and they came walking in with their suitcase that you know is just full of drugs. They went in the back, and then they came out, and then the next dude would go in. Sure, and then the doctor finally comes out after the last one leaves, and his little reflector is all skewed. He's like, next. Doctor, feel good. Yeah. So is that how it goes down, Molly? Is that a myth or a truth? You know, I don't want to comment on Dr.
Feelgood's personal life. Yeah, and we can't get into pharma too much. That's a whole different deal. That's a different thing, but I think it's important. Well, no, it's left out almost entirely, isn't it? Big pharma hasn't been made a part of this almost at all. It's not a part of health care reform. Well, this might be a way to make them more accountable. Right. It's these panels that will evaluate cost-effectiveness of treatments. But let's reemphasize again that these panels are not designed to say to you, you can't have this drug. Right. It's just saying, we think this drug is the most cost effective.
Why don't you try that before trying one that is more experimental, may not work as well, so on and so forth. It's not designed to get between a doctor and a patient. Okay. Good. And I guess the last point that I keep hearing about rationing health care, it's very delicate, but there's a lot of people who say, you know, we kind of need to ration health care. You pointed out that health care is already rationed by the health insurance companies, right? You know, by annual limits or lifetime maximums for care and by denying coverage to people with preexisting conditions. But I think this whole idea that we may need rationed care is kind of based on an idea that the average patient abuses this health care infrastructure, right?
that there's so much available and we have so little conception of value to actually what we're taking advantage of that we'll say, no, no, I want the MRI and that kind of thing. I think we touched on that in the first one, didn't we? I think that's fair for both sides to say. The patient probably wants more care and more care because we have a lot of people who know what's out there for them to take advantage of. And then I'm sure you also touched on that doctors are paid for every service they provide to a patient. And so there's incentives on both sides for doctors. And it keeps sending the patient in for the same thing, even if it's not working.
Exactly. Because it makes you feel better. So Medicare, with this bundling, is going to be sort of the testing ground for trying to do this within our system as a whole. That's the ideal. I don't know how it will shake out in the end. Right. So can you say definitively whether rationing health care is, number one, a myth or a truth that it's going to happen? Well, if we take Britton's definition of what rationed health care is in terms of a panel making a choice whether you can or cannot have this drug, then no, there's nothing in these bills that would do that. Whether eventually there would be fewer services and fewer of these people going in and getting every single service they asked for, then it's possible.
That might decrease. But that could be a good thing. It could. It could be, and ultimately you could make the point that this is very similar to government prohibitions on drug use or something, or you have to be a certain age to buy tobacco or to buy alcohol. That's pretty much arbitrary. And this is actually a little more focused, saying, no, we have this huge infrastructure. You guys are costing us $2.4 trillion a year, a lot of it unnecessary. So you could argue the point that maybe somebody does need to step in and say, you can't do this because that's stupid. That's true. But then on the other hand, you've got someone who takes nine tests, and the 10th one would have been the one that worked.
And if they feel in any way that they didn't get that 10th test because they already got nine, then that's where people start to get worried. Is there any mechanism to sue the pants off of the person who denied you that 10th test? Well, that would, currently we've got the whole medical malpractice thing. Right, but if it wasn't a physician, if it was a government panel or something like that. Oh, could you sue the government? Yeah. Hmm, could get very hinky. I mean, you know, some of the decisions that the NICE panel makes are controversial. I mean, they deny a lot of really expensive cancer treatments, and as a result, Britain has worse cancer survival rates than the U.
S. does. Whether someone has tried to sue, I don't think so. Because you can pay in England, right? Our colleague Lee Dempsey pointed out yesterday that you can actually pay for better care. That was awful. What was that? Everyone, I just want to apologize to Lee for Chuck's terrible, terrible impression of his British accent. He's actually not from England. He's from a small island that's not been yet named. Manoa. And they have a very odd accent there. So, guys, I don't know a good way to put this. Let's talk about abortion. Is it a myth? That's a great icebreaker, by the way, for your next dinner party, Josh.
I'm having deja vu. You should keep that in your crawl. Let's talk about abortion. You know, that's how a lot of episodes of Stuff Mom Never Told You start out, if anyone's interested. Or Krista and I just go, let's talk about abortion. Really? So we highly recommend you go listen to that podcast. But women's issues, it's a big thing. And, you know, obviously people who want women to have the right to an abortion would like to see abortion be a necessary benefit included by the government. What these bills provide is the government to come in and say these are things that insurance plans have to cover to be considered valid insurance plans.
Right. The minimum coverage. Right. So there's a big debate about a lot of things to be covered, like mental health. How much will that be covered? Abortion is the big one that is dicey because no, you know, no anti-abortion person wants to pay for someone else's abortion. Right. So how the House has compromised on this is that health providers can choose whether to provide it. It doesn't necessarily have to be one of these essential benefits, but it can be. And if you do get an abortion, the thinking is that you would pay not with these public subsidies that are available to people, but you'd have to pay out of pocket for that unless it was one of the abortions that's defined as, you know, in the gray zone, the rape sort of abortion.
Right. I saw the Senate Finance Committee bill as it stands now prohibits funding. except in cases of rape, incest, or endangerment to the woman's life. Right. And that's the plan that a lot of Congress people, for example, have. The government already currently pays for abortions under those qualifications. And also the Finance Committee bill, which was just released yesterday, but you said it's not the final version, right? It's his mark, so it'll still go through the Senate Finance Committee. It's the chairman's mark. On abortion, they continue to say that the bill would prevent abortion coverage from being included in a minimum benefits package.
and in the health insurance exchanges where you shop for the coverage. But the plans in exchange could include they could offer abortion coverage as long as no government subsidies pay for it. Instead, the coverage would be funded through member payments, which are segregated from the federal money. Right. So that's what the Finance Committee says. Yeah, so that's consistent with how the House had it as well. Is it? And basically the thinking is that any given area, you should be able to choose one plan that has abortion covered and one plan that doesn't. But they would be, I saw this in your article too, they would be the same plan except one covers abortion and one doesn't.
Right. Okay. But everything else is the same. Yeah. Okay. And they'd be the same price, I imagine, right? I would think so, yeah. What, for the total plan? The total bill? If you're in the marketplace, those insurance marketplaces we were talking about, you should have a choice of a plan that has abortion and a choice of a plan that doesn't. So you'd have like a premium abortion pro plus and then... Premium, no abortion plus plans right next to each other. And they should be the same cost just to give people a choice. I thought you were talking about the total bill. No, no. Because the Senate finance bill is about $150 billion cheaper.
Do you remember how when we went into the marketplace and we were looking at all those insurance letters there? Yeah, I get it now. So you can be pro-choice choice. You can have the choice to have the plan that has the choice. You just blew my mind. Wow, my mind is melting all over the table. All right, guys, can we talk about something that President Obama loves to say? It's usually the first thing he kicks off with. If you like your insurance plan, you can keep that plan. Yes. Molly Edmund says that that is not necessarily true if you start looking down the road and read between the lines, right?
You know, the thing is when Obama went out this summer and did his town halls, I think that if he had a nickel for every time he told people that if you like your plan, you can keep it, he would have enough to fund health care reform. Right. But I think if you were paying attention to the speech he made, the famous speech to Congress, you will notice that that phrase did not appear in the speech because I think he's realized that he can't promise people that their plan will stay exactly the same under these reforms. He's saying you can keep it, though, not necessarily that it would be the exact same plan that you're keeping.
Well, but that was how he was sort of pitching it. If you like your doctor, you can have your doctor. And the fact of the matter is that your plan is going to change already to build in these consumer protections. So that's a great change. You know, you won't be able to be dropped by your insurance company. They can't discriminate for pre-existing conditions. Right. And then your plan will have about five years probably to come up to speed with all these other plans. It'll be grandfathered into that minimum set of benefits we were talking about. But, you know, in that marketplace, when they start competing for all these uninsured customers, we don't know what current plans will have to do to stay financially viable.
Right. They may have to slash services. They may have to slash services. We have. That kind of stuff happens anyway, though. Your insurance plan probably isn't the same today as it was five years ago without all this government competition. That's true. And the thing is, if you don't know how your plans change over the five years, you may not notice how your plan changes when this happens to you. Right. Yeah, I don't know. Well, first of all, I didn't have insurance five years ago, but I couldn't tell you what it looked like last year. Right. You know? You were living in the mountains. I was living in my car.
Okay. I mean, the only way you're going to know is if you go to the doctor and all of a sudden they don't accept your insurance or if something that used to be covered isn't covered anymore. But that's just so speculative right now that it's impossible to say one way or the other whether things will be the same or not. I think a lot of this from what I'm reading is like the outlines in place, but who knows how all this is going to shake out. Sometimes you have to wonder if we have to believe the best about people or the worst about people. Well, that I think is what it comes down to. I keep running across – you mentioned that this whole thing is a Rorschach test or the public option is a Rorschach test.
And really what it comes down to is can you trust doctors to not skinch on health care when they're being paid in bundles? Is that a word? Skinch? Skinch, yeah. Okay. Yeah. If it's not, it is now, pal. You said it twice. I love it. Yeah. Can you trust that the government panels won't stifle innovation? Right. It does come down to you. the insurance company so much where they can't stay in business. Sure. Can you trust Obama that this isn't really a plan to ultimately create a single-payer system? Right. And can you trust individuals to take it upon themselves, too, like Dr. Roizen is a big advocate of, to take on preventative care?
Yeah. The burden for health is on the patient as much as it is the doctor. Right. I don't think that mindset is clear to a bunch of Americans. No. But I think that that's what they're using as an excuse. I mean, someone who would be against a big public option or really subsidized health I would say, this person got themselves into this mess because they smoked or they're overweight or so on. And so looking at just what the mistakes a one person made is like not seeing the forest for the trees. So all these pieces are working together in a way that we can't isolate blame at anyone. But that's what this discussion has turned into, saying that, you know, the worst is going to happen about these people.
Agreed. And actually, when we spoke to Roizen, if I can bring him back again, he said that apparently, basically, us not caring at all about our health is costing this country more than any other sector of health care spending. He put it like this. Seventy-five percent of all health care costs are caused by chronic disease that is caused by four factors. tobacco, food choices and portion size, physical inactivity, and stress. So we can reinvigorate primary care by paying physicians to teach these things because what gets paid for gets done and what gets done gets taught well. So in fact, we have a tremendous opportunity of paying physicians to do this and saving a huge amount of money.
In fact, if all we do is a program, and I'll go to the exact bill, it's called S1640, Take Back Your Health, that does this for five diseases, coronary artery disease, type 2 diabetes, metabolic syndrome, breast cancer, and prostate cancer, we save, after paying for it, we save $1.9 trillion over 10 years. so clearly uh as roison pointed out molly you are right i mean it comes it in very large part comes down to us changing our perception about our own health and taking responsibility for it right let's do one last one you guys mind since we're not doing listener mail okay let's do it are we moving towards a socialized country this one no well do you know the definition of a Socialized country?
Chuck, go. I do not. Josh, go. State-owned and operated industry. That's right. Yeah. So not only is the government paying your bills, they're hiring your doctors and running your hospitals. Right. So that's what Britain does. And then there's also fear of a single-payer system, which Obama has a few choice quotes that people like to pull up saying that he would like a single-payer system. Right. That's what Canada has, where all the bills just go straight to the government, no questions asked. And Taiwan, right? Doesn't Taiwan? Actually, let's say that because we're going to talk about health care systems from around the world in the next one.
Most countries have some form of single payer. But whether we've been promised a uniquely American system because we are a uniquely American country. It's probably too late at this point, don't you think? Even if we wanted to switch to socialized medicine, we couldn't do it now. I think you could over the course of several decades. Fifty, a hundred years maybe. Yeah. But we're certainly not there with these proposals. There's no need to fear. these specific bills as any sort of move towards single-payer or socialized medicine. I think one of the concerns, though, is that this public option will eventually run the other insurance companies out of business, and then we'll have a de facto single-payer system because the only man left standing will be the public option, right?
Is that one of the fears, the concerns? That is a concern. the public option is so in the air right now that it would be hard for us to make any sort of conclusion about whether that's a myth or not the thing that just came out this week the Senate Finance Committee one that's going to get all marked up, that went for co-ops so how will a co-op work in this system versus what would a public plan be so that right now is such a shadowy thing that I think we should avoid speculating on it agreed, we don't want to stir up any more fears, the whole point of this podcast was to allay them pretty much, right?
Or at least say, no, you're right. You should be scared out of your mind. Here's my guess. I don't think they could do anything to put every insurance company out of business. No. That's what I think. Yeah. I think the one out of all these- Call me in 10 years. If there are no more private insurance companies in America, then I'll buy you a beer. Really? Yeah. Anyone out there, I heard you. Yeah. Of course, I'll be dead in 10 years. Yeah, you will be. Because they'll have rationed your health care. Exactly. You face the death panel. I know. No, I want to live. But you signed, sorry. Guys, that's about it, right?
You got any more myths you want to cover? Oh, I know one. Uh-oh. Illegal immigrants. Yeah. Oh, you thought you were getting away without talking about this, huh? No, this is a big one. As I saw, actually, in the House bill, it basically says, actually it does say, if you're born in the United States and you're not covered, you're automatically covered. Does that amount to covering illegal immigrants? Now, not necessarily the people who are, you know, that same day laborer who went into the ER, right? We're not talking about him necessarily, but the children of illegal immigrants would be covered under that language, right?
Right. So, I mean, that is technically correct, that illegal immigrants would be covered? Well, no, their children would be covered. Right. But they themselves, the children would be considered illegal. No, they would. No. If you're born on American soil, you're an American. Excellent point, Molly. There's no law that says that, but it's generally thought that if you're born on American soil, you're an American citizen. Okay. So technically, it wouldn't cover illegal immigrants. Does it in any other way? Well, the way it was explained to me is that illegal immigrants would not be able to receive any sort of subsidies because there'd be too much need for proof about where they were born and where all their paperwork would have to be in order to get these subsidies.
Right. But it's possible they would be able to enter the exchange and buy insurance because they would be, you know, subject. I mean, there's nothing that would keep them out of the marketplace per se. And if they want to pay, then welcome to the game. Yeah. Well, but some people aren't ready to say welcome to the game. Right. Molly, I am looking forward to your second career as a diplomat. I know, seriously. Thank you again for coming in. And we'll see you next time when we cover another one of your articles, which is health care systems around the world and how they compare to the U.S. Dr. Roizen's going to be back.
Yes. So will Chuck's goatee? We'll talk about different countries. People are already emailing saying, what about us in Canada and England and Norway? Chuck's been responding with pipe down. We're going to get to you, all right? Keep your pants on. If you're looking for a place to move, I think that that podcast will be really helpful. Okay. In the meantime, you can basically take advantage of Molly Edmund's giant sponge-like brain and learn everything you need to know about health care reform by typing health care reform in the handy search bar at HowStuffWorks.com. And by the way, if you want to send us an email praising us, condemning us, telling us that we're in favor of illegal immigration, whatever, just send it to StuffPodcast at HowStuffWorks.
com. For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit HowStuffWorks.com. Want more HowStuffWorks? Check out our blogs on the HowStuffWorks.com homepage. Brought to you by the reinvented 2012 Camry. It's ready. Are you? Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community.
Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet, with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human