In the Watermelon episode, Chuck and Josh stumbled into a bit of little-known history about why artificial banana flavor doesn’t taste like bananas. Turns out it does; it just tastes like a banana you’ve probably never eaten.
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Hey, and welcome to The Short Stuff. I'm Josh.
There's Chuck. We're the Banana Splits, and this is Short Stuff. Let's go. I thought you were going to say, we're bananas for banana flavoring. I should have. I think we should retake this whole thing, frankly. Nah, yours is better. No, no way. Not by a million years. Yours was better than mine. this is a good episode hats off to you for putting it together thank you but the hats really come off to a few a handful of astute listeners Chuck because I had no idea about this until in our watermelon episode if you'll remember you started talking about how just far off like banana candy flavor is from actual banana taste and I was like you're absolutely right They just missed the mark so badly.
But after we talked about that, we didn't realize we'd accidentally stumbled into kind of like an overlooked history of at least flavor science, if not pop culture, that some of our listeners wrote in and said, guys, guys, get this. That banana flavoring actually is really dead on to a banana that we don't eat anymore. It was created back at a time when there was this banana that's not around any longer was popular. And that's why it seems weird to us because it doesn't taste like the bananas we eat today. And I just started tearing out my clothing and shaking my head left and right. I was like, got to get a short stuff out as fast as possible about this.
Delirium set in when you heard there was an OB. That's right. An OGB. That's right. And that banana, my friends, is called, is it Michelle? The Gros Michel, G-R-O-S-M-I-C-H-E-L. That was a banana grown in the mid, the beginning of the mid-19th century by a coffee grower in Jamaica. And we would, you know, Big Mike would be his name here in the States, but it was Gros Michel. And this stuff was great for sending around the world because it grew in little tight bunches. It was very thick skinned. It was very slow to ripen after you picked it off. And so it was really good as a shipping fruit until disaster struck.
Isn't that right? Yeah. So I think in the 1870s, around then, the Gros Michel-like became the dominant banana. And that lasted all the way until the 1950s when something called a Panama disease or banana wilt, which is a fungal disease that attacks banana plants. And it's caused by a fungus called Fusarium oxysporum formus specialis cubense. I think you just aroused to the dead or something. I think you did too. Look out behind you, Chuck. Yeah. This particular soil-dwelling fungus really munches down on banana crops. And so after 70 years of market dominance, the Gros Michel went basically extinct in less than a decade because this banana wilt just took a hold and spread through the banana crops like wildfire.
Yeah, which is a problem when you have a monoculture, when you have all these identical, essentially, plants and you have a fungus that attacks it, you're going to have no more bananas or any sort of monoculture. So, like you said, within 10 years, it's gone. It went from the OB to the no-B. And everyone said, we got to get a new banana. We invented the Cavendish, and that's what we eat today. It's another monoculture, so if something else comes along, that's trouble. But the Cavendish is resistant to Panama disease, and so far, so good. The Cavendish is doing pretty well. Yes, but they've identified a couple of diseases the Cavendish is not resistant to.
And so if those diseases ever took hold, we'd have the same problem all over again. So the banana growing industry does not learn lessons very well. And that Cavendish is, if you are eating a banana today, basically anywhere in the world, there is genuinely a 99% chance that that banana is a Cavendish. because not only is the Cavendish the most widely grown variety that supplies the world's bananas, the Cavendishes that are grown are actually clones of one another because it's really, really hard to get a banana to get sexy with another banana. Sure. So they use clones. They take rhizomes from one plant, plant that, grow another plant, and so those plants are clones of one another, meaning they're not very genetically dissimilar.
They're pretty much identical. And that means that if you have a disease that can take out one of those plants, it can take out all of those plants. And so the Cavendish, like you said, is in the same position that the Gros Michel is. We've just lucked out by it not happening yet. That's right. So the top banana is gone. Second banana is now dominant. And I think that's time for a break before I think of another bad pun. And we'll be right back. Well, now, when you're on the road, driving in your truck, why not learn a thing or two from Josh and Chuck? It's Stuff You Should Know. Stuff You Should Know.
All right. Get your mother-loving ears on because your big-time radio DJ's got news. PayPal lets you choose how you want to pay for all the stuff. With PayPal, I can pay in-store, pay online, or pay over time. What's that? You want this translated into song? I hope you're sitting down. You can pay your own way. You keep those ears on, you hear? Don't just pay, baby. PayPal. Learn more at PayPal.com. Ten athletes will face the toughest job interview in fitness that will push past physical and mental breaking points. You are the fittest of the fit. Only one of you will leave here with an iFit contract for $250,000.
This is when mindset comes in. Someone will be eliminated. Pressure is coming down. This is Trainer Games. Watch it on Prime Video starting January 8th. All righty. So now we're at the part where we talk about banana candy. And everything from now or laters. I'm sorry, now and laters. I always said now or laters when I was a kid. I did too. Now and laters, which is really, that's a huge sea change now that I think about it. Yeah, because they're saying like, you start chewing now. And you're going to be chewing them later still, too, because they don't go away very fast. Or runts or Necco wafers, any of that stuff.
You've probably eaten it and said, this really doesn't taste like a banana. And like you mentioned in the beginning, it's because it doesn't taste like a Cavendish. Apparently, it does taste like a Grosse Michel, and there is a very nuanced story to why. Yeah, because the gist of the story, the legend as it goes, is that they created this banana flavoring to mimic the dominant banana at the time, the Grosse Michel. The Grosse Michel went extinct, but this banana flavoring carried on. And so to those of us alive today who've never had a Grosse Michel, it seems weird and foreign. But it's not like the chemists, like, extracted Grosse Michel and then injected it into candy, and then that's where banana flavoring came from.
It's like you said, the whole thing was a lot more nuanced than that. And in fact, they developed this artificial banana flavor and then tinkered with it to make it mimic the Grosse Michel, which, as we'll see, they apparently did pretty well. Yeah, so there was a, believe it or not, there's a banana flavoring researcher. I think just general researcher, but an author named Nadia Rubenstein, who did a lot of research on this, on this story. And traced the development of the banana flavoring back to 1912 by these New Jersey chemists, the, I guess, the Fritz brothers? Sure. Fritzscher. Fritzscher?
It's like Fritz and Nietzsche mixed together. S-C-H-E. It's kind of a weird name. Friche. But they said that. Friche. Friche. The Friche brothers. But they were from New Jersey, so they didn't take any guff, and they didn't want anybody poking around their banana synthesizing operation. But Nadia Rubenstein found out that they did isolate from real bananas, and that they had to have been Grosse Michel because that was, again, the top banana. Right. So you'd say, well, then the story is true. They took Gros Michel essence and put it into candies. Still not quite right because it gets a little more convoluted than that because what they extracted from the Gros Michel and identified as basically banana essence is a chemical compound called amyl acetate.
And it's not just found in bananas. It's found in other fruits. And it's actually one of the other fruits that it's really kind of predominant in is pears. And Rubenstein found from a research that depending on the company you were buying from and the decade it was, amyl acetate would be marketed in their catalogs either as banana essence or pear essence. And that over the years, it eventually just kind of evened out into a generic fruity essence. Because it depends a lot on the power of suggestion and the nose or tongue of the beholder, what fruit it evokes. Yeah, and this is, I think, where it gets super cool.
Because if you live in the UK, you probably eat a little more pear than banana, or at least historically or culturally, that's sort of the deal, than you might here in the United States. I think Americans eat, what, like 130 bananas a year or something like that? That's everyone around the world. Oh, that's everybody? That's how much bananas we eat. But the UK is big on their pears and pear-flavored things. So if you take the very same exact vial of that, what's it called again? Amylacetate. Amylacetate. You stick it under the nose. First of all, you say, get that beer pint out of your hand so you can smell something for a change.
And they say, right. And you put that vial under the nose of someone from the UK. They'll say, taste like pear. And that's what we think about the Brits. Put that same vial under an American. First of all, you smack the cheap light beer out of the American's hand. Okay. And you put that under their nose, and they'll say, it tastes like a banana. And it's the same thing. Right. It's the same vial. It all depends on what you've been exposed to. Remember we were talking about, like, gray candy having banana flavor, if you'd even be able to recognize this banana flavor? Like, I was right in a really roundabout way, which I love.
Super love that kind of thing. because you have to basically tell people, this is banana candy, this flavor, it's banana flavor. And the thing is, though, is they really did kind of nail the taste of Grosse Michel with this amyl acetate because upon later inspection, food science and flavoring science has gotten exponentially more sophisticated than it was back in 1912 when the Fritschi brothers were working. And they found that Gros Michel bananas had more of a related compound called isoamyl acetate than the Cavendish does. And that because of this kind of thicker concentration of amyl acetate in this banana flavoring, it evokes the Gros Michel way more than it does the Cavendish.
And like you said, beyond just food scientists, there is a banana grower in Hawaii that does grow that top banana, the OG banana, the Grosse Michel. And they went out, you know, the BBC interviewed this guy and he was like, well, what does the Grosse Michel taste like? He said, it tastes like that fake banana flavor. Yeah. It tastes like a runt, basically. Yeah. And he said, you know, when I first tasted it, it made me think of banana flavoring. So I want to get my hands on one of those Grosse Michels. I want to go to Hawaii and check this thing out. Yeah, same here. Next time we're in Hawaii, Chuck, I'll bring you back some Grosse Michels.
Because they're great for shipping. That's right. You just drop one in the mail. Yeah, I will. I'll put some stamps on it and send it to you. You got anything else about Grosse Michels or banana flavoring? No, I thought this was super interesting. Me too. I loved it. So thanks to all the listeners who wrote in to let us know about this. wonderful little story. And in the meantime, everybody's short stuff is out. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.