Like most 16th-century French peasants, Martin Guerre’s life seemed likely to be lost to history. But a strange series of events took place that would so cement the legend surrounding him that we’re talking about him still today, 450 years later.
Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
No summary for this episode yet.
This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different. That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees.
Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member FDIC. Welcome to Stuff You Should Know. A production of iHeartRadio. Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark, and there's Charles W. Chuck Bryant, and this is Stuff You Should Know featuring Yeri. That's right. Interesting history a dish. Yes, man. I remember hearing this story back as an undergrad. Okay. A hot, sexy undergrad.
Mm-hmm. Boy, were you. In learning my history. Yeah. I can't remember what class. It must have been a European history class. But this book just always stuck with me. The Return of Martin Gare by Natalie Zeman Davis. Did you read it back then? Yeah, yeah. It was assigned as part of the class. It was a great, great book. But did you read it? Yes. Okay. I was a very eager, hot, sexy, undergrad history major. Well, I mean, that's why I majored in English, because I like to read. So anytime I assigned a reading assignment, I was like, great, I can do that. Yeah, that was one reason I chose history is because I really enjoyed reading history stuff.
So I was like, well, if that's what we're going to be sitting around doing, let's do it. I don't know what I'll do with it afterward with that degree, but we'll roll the dice and find out. You envisioned a future career where two lunkheads with no previous broadcast experience could become, dare I say, noteworthy by talking into a can. Yeah. Yeah, I was gambling on lucking out to an astounding degree. Yeah, me too, sort of. Isn't that weird? Yeah. It's funny how life works. Well, it all worked out and here we are all these years later to tell the story of Martin, is it pronounced Gere? I've always pronounced it Martin Gere.
Gere? We're talking, we're going to go to 16th century France, so it's probably Martin Gere. Martin Gere. Okay. But we're not going to say it like that. But not Richard Gare. No. Which is ironic. Yeah. Because Richard Gare was the lead in the movie Summersbee. Yes, and? Which was, see, look at your improv skills. Yes, and-ing me. Right. It was sort of a, not necessarily a remake, but an adaptation on the story of Martin Gare and the movie that starred Gerard Depardieu from the early 1980s. Yes, and? I think that's it. Oh, okay. No, but is how we end. Yeah. Had you heard this story before, the story of Martin Gare?
Yeah, a little bit. I certainly didn't know it like I know it now, but I did see the movie Summersbee back then. I knew it was kind of based on that. And, you know, there have been other versions of stories like this. I mean, not the least of which is a story told in animation form about a man, young man off to war named Armin Tanzarian. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I didn't even put two and two together. Sure, when Principal Skinner took someone's identity during the war. And it's sort of a common story, but this is, I think, the OG. Yeah. Thanks for that, too, because we would have gotten myriad emails telling us what utter failures we are in life for missing that Simpsons reference.
Yeah, that was his name, right? Armin Tanzarian? Totally. Man, can you imagine how fun the writer's room was that day trying to come up with what his real name would be? That's right. You know, I've said it before, I'll say it again, that's Matt Groening's least favorite Simpsons episode, or it was at the time, years ago. Yeah. Oh, I loved it. For some reason, he hated that one. I don't know why. Huh. All right. I love it, too. That's good. So we're talking about a man named Martin Garry who was like born a peasant in 16th century France in the Languedoc region in this like little area just above Spain, just below Toulouse, if that makes sense for you.
And like typically, Chuck, when people live and die in areas like this, unless they do something spectacularly interesting or noteworthy or important, they just kind of get lost to history. Sure. And this guy Martin Garret actually didn't do anything spectacularly interesting or important or noteworthy. And yet we're still talking about him like 450-ish years, more than that, later. Because his life, something happened to his life that was so interesting that it's worth doing an entire podcast episode about all these years later. Agreed. He was born in Spain to a Basque family and pretty quickly as a toddler was brought over to France to, how would you pronounce that?
Artigat? Or Artigat? Or is it got? I think got. Okay. Yeah, because cake is gato and it begins with G. Oh, look at you. All right. So Artigat. And his family got there and they got to work pretty quickly, setting themselves up in different trades like farming, eventually tile making and merchanting. Nice. And did okay. Like, they didn't have any kind of money, but they worked hard and sort of rose through that lower tiered status to the point where they could marry off young Martin to another family, the DeRoll's family, who, you know, I think Dave Ruse, our buddy who put this together for us, he said that they were well off.
But I think they were well off for their lower class, though, right? Yeah, they were up and coming, he puts it. And I think they were peasant farmers figuring out how to enter the merchant class, which at the time was the very beginning of the middle class. Okay. All right. Well, that makes sense then. Yeah. So, they were working their way up into the middle class. So, it was like kind of a coup, I take it, for the Gare family to marry off Martin to Bertrand de Rawls. When they were young. Because their family was a little better off. But, yeah, they were really young. Apparently, later on, Bertrand recalled that they were married at age like 9 or 10.
Apparently, that doesn't add up. And that was probably more like 13 or 14. So, you know, that's fine. Right. Still very young, but this is the 16th century after all. So, they got married. And, you know, when you get married back then, you want to start having babies pretty quickly. And they had a hard time having babies because for the first eight years of their marriage, they did not consummate their marriage. And no one knows exactly why. There were rumors maybe that Martin wasn't or Martine just wasn't into it. They were 13 after all. So maybe, you know, they were normal children who kind of thought that wasn't the thing to do yet.
I don't know. Or he was like, how do I work this? He just sounded like David Byrne in Once in a Lifetime. Right. some people blamed it on a witch's curse. They eventually consulted with a wise woman who said, go to these series of masses at church, because mass is always guaranteed to make you Randy, and eat a special cake that would sort of get him going downstairs. And apparently it worked. Because they had a baby. They had a little son. Like right afterward. It was a cake made of fireplace ashes I saw. But, you know, they're in the early 20s at this point, by the way. Yeah. Like the appropriate age for that kind of thing.
Right. It makes you wonder, though, like, was it self-imposed and, like, he was able to feel like this curse or whatever was lifted off of him from eating that cake. But regardless, it happened, like, almost immediately Bertrand got pregnant and they had a son named Sanxi who was the same name of Martin's father. So Martin said, hey, this is really amazing. I've really turned a new corner in life. I'm really interested to see what life brings me now. And just got back to work now with a son and wife, right? Yeah, but here's the thing, and I think there's really no other way to describe Martin.
Everything I read, basically, it sounds like he was a real a-hole. Yes, that was the impression I had, too. He was not a nice guy. He was not a nice husband. I didn't see anything necessarily about overt abuse, but he just seemed like a real jerk sort of to his family and around town. And he was kind of looking to get out of town, and his father accused him of stealing grain from the family stores and then selling it for a profit, which was not cool, even if it's your own family. It's probably more uncool that it's your own family. Never trust family, Chuck. Never trust family. That's on the shirt.
But instead of saying, like, wait a minute, I want to defend myself, he just took off. And he's like, sorry, wife and young son, but I don't really like you guys that much anyway, so I'm out of here. I see him as like an early 20s Gen Xer. It's like, whatever, man. Right. I can't deal with this at all. I'm out of here. Uh-huh. And you get the impression that he was just looking for a reason to leave. And he did. He got it. He didn't defend himself, which I mean, in 16th century France or Basque culture, that is something you would want to do if your honor was being impugned. That was one of the few currencies you had.
So you would want to defend yourself. So I think it says a lot about somebody at that time who didn't even bother defending himself. He just left. And he left his wife and child without providing for them in any way. Like, sure, they had, like, his, you know, inheritance, his money, his share of whatever the family owned. But he didn't, like, set them up in any way before he left. He just put down his plowshare, put down his tile-making tongs, and just left. That's right. He ended up in Spain. He went back to Spain, settled in B-U-R-G-O-S, Burgos. Sure. And became a servant for a noble family.
And they noticed, like, hey, dude, you're a pretty good fencer. You're good with a sword. Right. We should get you armied up. So he joined the Spanish army, who was at war with France at the time. And he fought for five years before. And this is a very key detail, I think, before we go into our first break, that he was hitting the leg with a bullet and had his leg amputated. Yes. So we'll take a break. Hang on to that. Put a pin in it. And we'll be right back. La, la, la, la, la, la, la, la, la. La, la, la, la, la. The headlines can be overwhelming these days because there's so much happening.
It can make us feel helpless, like what can we really do to make a difference? For people in places like Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, you can make a difference with a gift to the International Rescue Committee right now. Everyone deserves the safety and security of home, but right now, conflict and disaster have forced millions of families into temporary shelters without basic supplies and an urgent need of aid. With your help, the IRC is on the ground in more than 40 countries delivering food, clean water, shelter, and medical care where it's needed most. The IRC has spent over 90 years helping people whose lives have been upended by crisis, often responding within just 72 hours when emergencies strike.
And every day, IRC teams help families find safety, rebuild their communities, and recover hope for the future. And that support matters more than ever. So give now at rescue.org slash rebuild and help make a life-changing difference for refugee families rebuilding their lives. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell. And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP.
Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all, the early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward. Yeah, and this season, the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference. So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet, with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees.
Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member F-D-I-C. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed.
It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.
com to shop now. So let's zero in on Bertrand for a little while, shall we? The wife, if you don't remember, is Bertrand. Yes, Bertrand de Roles, who became married to Martine Gare at maybe age 9 to 14, depending on who you ask. Yes, seemed like a savvy young woman. Yes, now this is new. We got to say this. So, like, Natalie Zeman Davis, you mentioned that film, The Return of Martin Gare, starring Gerard Depardieu, that Summersbee was partly based on, right? Correct. She was the consultant on that, the historical consultant on that film. And she was so put off by the retelling of this story that she published her book two years afterward.
Oh, okay. Part of that book, part of her big contribution, she made tons of contributions to the historical record, turned up a lot of great documents and everything. But subjectively, her big contribution was completely altering the way people saw Bertrand. Yeah. Up to this point, she was a loyal, chaste, devoted wife who would end up being duped, you could say, as we'll see very soon. And under Natalie Zeman Davis' reading of her, she was a very shrewd woman who figured out how to navigate within the confines of a male-dominated middle-aged French society. Yeah, and one of the first things that we can bring up to sort of support this, and I kind of like this narrative a lot, by the way, is the fact that she got married when she was, let's say, 13.
Just meet there in the middle. and, you know, he had, Martine had problems, you know, having sex for eight years. And so she was, it speculated from Davis at least that she was kind of like, hey, this isn't so bad. I don't want to be doing that anyway, especially with this kid who's a jerk. And I don't want to have a kid. I'm 13 years old. So by the time, you know, he's got four sisters. I really love them. He's, you know, his family seems to be doing okay. my family's doing okay at the time that was a big deal and so the fact that she had to wait till she was in her early 20s to finally uh to you know i i expect to lose her virginity to martin and then have this kid wasn't so bad after all yeah because she could have asked for the marriage to be annulled after three years passed without it being consummated sure by under french law at the time i think french Catholic law.
And she didn't. So, yeah, that definitely substantiates Zimon Davis's claim that she was just kind of rolling with it. She was like, okay, I'm kind of happy with this. And she didn't try and get married when he left either. There were a lot of strict laws about remarrying, like if the husband disappears or something. You had to have proof of death with witnesses and all that stuff. And she was basically like, hey, I'm kind of a widow here. his uncle Pierre is married to my mom now they're taking really good care of me got a lot of help with my baby so I'm pretty cool to just chill here yeah so in this reading she's saying Natalie Zeman Davis is saying like she didn't have a choice like again under French Catholic law at the time it says not even when a husband has been absent 20 years or more can a wife remarry unless she has proof of his death.
And it's got to be like irrefutable proof that this person has died, that her husband's died. She didn't have the irrefutable proof, but she didn't also, she didn't like go like take lovers. She didn't ask to have an exception made for her. And so it painted her image among the townsfolk and among her family that she was a chaste, devoted wife who was just going to wait for her lousy husband for as long as it took. and then also Chuck on the converse side of that, that just goes to show you just how fully and selfishly Martin abandoned her, knowing full well that she couldn't remarry because she wouldn't have any proof of his death.
So he left her in limbo like even more. It wasn't even like a, I'm leaving, good luck with your life, you do what you want with it. It was, I'm leaving, you have to stick around and wait until I decide to come back if ever. That's right. So things are going along like this. She's living her life. Again, has plenty of help with her baby. And then one day in town at a hostel, a man wanders in and says, hi, I'm Martine Gare. And I'm back, everybody. Like, check it out. It's been a while. The innkeeper says, you know, oh, my God, your wife, Bertrand, and your son, it's so exciting to be reunited.
And he breaks down crying. and everyone, of course, in town comes running up to see who this person is, including his wife. And they all went, huh, you look a little different, Martin. I think that's how they initially approached it. Well, because he did. Apparently he'd gotten shorter, heavier. His nose had changed. His lip wasn't as droopy. He, let's read that. There's a description from later court records that would happen of what Martin Gare supposedly looked like. Can I read this? Please. Martin Gare was taller and darker than this man who showed up. He was a man thin in body and legs, a little bent, carrying his head between his shoulders, the chin cleft like Huey Lewis, a little thrust forward, whose lower lip drooped a little.
having small teeth, a large and flattened nose, an ulcer on his face, and a scar on his right eyebrow. This person was short, thick-set, strong of body, having a heavy leg, does not have a flat nose, nor is bent, nor has any of said scars. So, an entirely different-looking person showed up and was like, hey, everybody, remember me? Martin Gare. Right. And it's important to note here that no one in town knew that Martin had lost his leg in the war. Yeah. So that was obviously would have been the biggest red flag. But this guy comes back, and he doesn't look like him, but he knows all the stories.
He's saying like, hey, remember when we did this? And he would hang out with the townspeople, and he'd say, God, remember that time we did that? And this great time we had over here doing this? And everyone's just like, oh, my gosh. like he knows all the stories. It doesn't look like him. But you know what? This guy's kind of fun and awesome and nice. Yeah. And I don't know what happened to him in the war, but like we'll take him. Yes. So eight years had passed and he apparently physically changed drastically, but also most notably, his personality had changed distinctly for the better. He was a charmer now.
And like you said, he remembered all of these stories. So everybody said, let's see where this goes basically. Yeah, and there's another key move here we need to point out. Right away, he didn't just go back to the family farm and to the family house with everyone. He said, you know what? I have the pox. I'm not feeling so great. So let me stay here at the hostel for a little bit and recover, which turned out to be a very sort of savvy key move. Yes. One of the other things that he did, too, that definitely convinced Bertrand and others who were there, he said, by the way, I'm going to stay here and recover.
until I'm done with this pox. But can you go fetch my white stockings, my white hose from this particular drawer in this particular chest where I left them eight years ago? And she went back and went to that particular chest and drawer and found his white socks were there just as she remembered him leaving them there eight years ago. So like that and a bunch of other stuff that he seemed to remember that only Martin would know really convinced everybody that, nope, this is Martin. He's a little different, But we like him even more now, and we're going to get along with him just fine. And Bertrand also was like, and the other thing is, when you left, you were not very interested in sex from me.
Right. And you seem to be really into that now. And so I'll take that as well. And in fact, I will give birth to two daughters in return. Sadly, only one of them survived infancy. And her name was, is it Bernard or Bernarda? Bernard. Okay. I didn't know that could be a little girl's name back then. I think when you add an E on the end, it girls it up. Okay. But you don't pronounce E? No. No, it's all just for looks. Okay. All right. So to catch up, he's back in town. Everyone likes the new and improved Martine Gere. He has another daughter, and he's having sex with his wife. And everything's going great until who becomes his main foil gets involved, and that would be his uncle Pierre.
And remember, so Pierre Gare, he's another main character in this. He, by this time, after Martin left, married Bertrand's mother. So now he's Bertrand's uncle-in-law and father-in-law, or stepfather. Uncle dad. Uncle-in-law and stepfather, that's right. And at first, he welcomed this new, improved Martin back with open arms. He was credulous at first, and then he won him over with some memories, the new Martin did. And so, Pierre said, okay, let's go with it. And everybody was kind of going along and getting along. And then I guess one day, Martin said, hey, by the way, Pierre, you remember my inheritance, my part of the land and my part of the wealth that I left behind?
that you've been managing. Well, I know you made a bunch of money off of it. I feel like that's my money. So can I have my money, Pierre? Can I please? And Pierre didn't like that idea at all. And it's not clear whether he just didn't like that idea or whether he didn't like that idea because he didn't think this was Martin after all. And this guy was overstepping his bounds. I don't know. But one of the things that he did was assemble his sons to try to beat Martin to death on the road and had it not been for Bertrand throwing herself on top of Martine's body, they probably would have succeeded in murdering him.
Yeah, I mean, it's interesting. I fill in a little bit of the narrative blanks just as someone who's into movies and literature and stuff. It seems to me like Pierre was kind of like, hey, everyone seems to like this guy, so I'm not going to be the one to stand in the way. Who am I to rock the boat? He didn't want to rock the boat. until this money thing came up. And Martin actually took him to court. And that's when things really changed. And that's when Pierre started talking to anyone who would listen and saying, you know what? He's Basque and he doesn't understand these Basque phrases. This dude was a great fencer.
This guy's no fencer. He's not even into it at all. He doesn't look anything like his son. And I think this guy is a fraud. And it's interesting that the town, like, it seems to be, and we'll get to the court case, but it seemed to be almost divided whether or not people said, no, we think it's him and it's all good. And people have said, no, I think he is a fraud. And it just goes to show sort of the power of those stories. Because at the time in 16th century France, how else would you explain something like, you know, hey, remember that time we went and pushed over that cow and I did a dance on him on his belly?
Right. Like, you know, that's a powerful thing back then when you don't have photographs and any other kind of shared recollection that you can easily point to. So, you know, he fooled a lot of people. Yeah, he definitely did. I wonder how much he was playing on people's propensity to not want to admit a mistake or that they were wrong. Yeah, that plays into it, I'm sure. It's got to. But like you said, the town was divided and it was divided between Pierre Gare and then this new Martin. And very crucially, on the side of this new Martin was Bertrand. She threw, she cast her lot with him and said, no, this man is Martin Gare.
I will, anyone who is mad enough to say otherwise, I will make him die. Yeah. Which is a weird way to create a death threat, but it was. It was a death threat nonetheless. But this was despite Bertrand's mother, who was Pierre's wife, coming to her and being like, look, you need to get with Pierre here. He's on the side of right. And she still said no. So Pierre also, he had, there were people who backed him up, like the shoemaker, right? Yeah, there was a little matter of the fact, and this was in Summersby too, that he came back from the war with a different foot size. That's a big change. That's a very drastic change.
It is. And technically he did come back with a different foot size. but in a radically different way. Well, yeah, because everything changed in 1559. He'd been back a few years at this point, and a Spanish soldier wanders through town and heard about this story of Martin Guerre and said, hey, wait a minute, I knew that guy during the war, and he's only got one leg. And it's like that's when it's like Mike Brady throwing the briefcase in the courtroom. Wow. Just a hush falls over the crowd. Yeah. And he said, no, this, in fact, is an imposter, an interloper. And I believe he is Arnaud Dutille.
And he is a Spanish man of ill repute. Yes. So, Pierre, like, got word out to nearby villages and confirmed this, that it probably was a guy named Arnaud Dutille, who was from a town about 30 miles away called Sajas, S-A-J-A-S, I think. I think probably you're right. That's about a day or two of travel from Artigat. So it's far enough away, but close enough that you could get, you could confirm or deny whether somebody was someone from that town, right? Yeah. This guy, you know, he's a bit of a roughhouser. He drank a lot and he gambled and he bedded down with sex workers and had a big appetite.
I mean, Gerard Depardieu played this guy, for God's sake. So that kind of tells you all you need to know. All right. And so this guy all of a sudden is seemingly found out. But the story is that he went off, joined the French army, this Arnaud guy. And the question is, like, did he meet Martine on the battlefield? What we ended up finding out much later is that a couple of old friends of Martine actually mistook him for Martine initially. And then we're like, you look just like our friend. this guy back in small-town France who's actually got a pretty good doubt, not dowry, but pretty good prospects monetarily waiting for him back home, and this pretty good-looking wife.
And all of a sudden, the wheels start turning in Arnaud's mind. Right. It's not clear whether those two ended up becoming accomplices or else if he was just able to kind of like work info out of them over time. But that does seem to be, I think he later admitted that's where he got the idea. He's like, how much do I look like him? Right, exactly. Oh, spinning image, man. Oh, goodness. He also was like really, really clever in that like he stayed behind at that hostel. Like he first appeared at the hostel rather than showing up in town. That was a big one. He stayed behind with the pox. I made scare quotes.
So he could gather more information just slowly but surely. He just seemed like the type who could get something out of you without you realizing it because you were just having a good time hanging out with him. Right. Like, I wonder if he was like, yeah, because remember that time we pushed over that cow? And the guy was like, oh, you mean the horse that time when we did this? He's like, oh, yeah, that was totally it. Totally. I was so drunk, I remember being a cow. And everybody starts laughing. Right. But you didn't drink much back then. Well, I drank on the side. You didn't know. It was secret.
Right. I was also on the pills. That was German. Yeah, you're really all over Europe right now. So, and this is where Natalie Zeman Davis comes in. Like, it's clear that this guy was really good at getting information from people without them realizing that he was extracting information. Using that information with his very, very good memory to lull you into a sense of security or trust for him that he was, to overcome your instincts against trusting that he was who he said he was. But that no amount of preparation and research in the 16th century setting could have helped him get away with this so thoroughly without the help of Bertrand.
That's Natalie Zeman Davis's, like, her thesis is, like, there's no way that Bertrand was a dupe, that she wasn't complicit. And that, you know, she probably, it's tough to blame her because her life improved dramatically after this guy showed up. Yeah, I mean, if she would have caused a stink like Pierre did early on as the wife, it would have been a much, much different deal, I think, than her completely defending him. And Dave points out we're never going to know. Like, he's in the town going to the pub, and he's talking with people about the stories. But she's with him as wife, full time, behind closed doors.
And we'll never know what went on there. But in my mind, in the movie version, there's a scene at some point where she goes, hey, listen, I know you're not him, but it's okay. Because you're actually a nice guy, and I can make this work. Yeah. I think that Jodie Foster's famous line is, hey, bubs, let's cut the S. Misa chica may. Nay type ho now. That was really good. I haven't seen Nell in so long. I never have. I'm just putting my impression together from previews I saw like 25 years ago, I think. Yeah, I don't think it was a very good movie or maybe I'm misremembering or maybe I'm remembering exactly right.
We have to watch it. Oh, boy. I want to watch this instead. So this whole idea that Bertrand is complicit, it's a new idea. It's a modern take. For centuries, she was, in the storytelling, she was duped. Like, that's how good and wily this Arnaud Dutille was at being an imposter. He duped the man's wife. That's how good he was. And when you hear that, and then you hear Natalie Zeman Davis' take, you're like, that's a pretty ridiculous idea. But that's how it was. And as we'll see, Bertrand was never persecuted or prosecuted for her role in it. She got out of it as well. Should we take a break?
Yeah, let's. All right, we'll take our last break, and we'll talk about the first trial of Martin Gare right after this. The headlines can be overwhelming these days because there's so much happening. It can make us feel helpless, like what can we really do to make a difference? For people in places like Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, you can make a difference with a gift to the International Rescue Committee right now. Everyone deserves the safety and security of home, But right now, conflict and disaster have forced millions of families into temporary shelters without basic supplies and an urgent need of aid.
With your help, the IRC is on the ground in more than 40 countries delivering food, clean water, shelter, and medical care where it's needed most. The IRC has spent over 90 years helping people whose lives have been upended by crisis, often responding within just 72 hours when emergencies strike. And every day, IRC teams help families find safety, rebuild their communities, and recover hope for the future. And that support matters more than ever. So give now at rescue.org slash rebuild and help make a life-changing difference for refugee families rebuilding their lives. You know, everyone living with a rare autoimmune condition has their own story to tell.
And that's why in Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, a Ruby Studio production, in partnership with Argenix, you'll hear powerful, real-life perspectives. That's right. This podcast explores stories of what life is really like with MG or CIDP. Host Martine Hackett sits down with people who faced it all, the early signs and symptoms, the search for answers, and the strength it takes to keep moving forward. Yeah, and this season, the stories go even deeper, showing us what resilience truly looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and the communities that make all the difference.
So listen to Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet, with no fees or minimums on checking accounts and no overdraft fees. Just ask the Capital One Bank Guy. It's pretty much all he talks about, in a good way. He'd also tell you that this podcast is his favorite podcast, too. Thanks, Capital One Bank Guy. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank. Capital One N-A, member F-D-I-C. Attention parents and grandparents.
If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market. Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together.
And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait. Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. All right. The first trial, I said of Martin Gare, but we're going to call it the first trial of Arnaud. He was put on trial in a town called R-I-E-U-X. Rue. Rue. Rue. Rue. Rue. He was put on trial specifically for stealing another man's identity, adultery, taking his property.
and Dave points out very aptly that this is like in the 16th century how do you prove something like this you could give a memory test but you know we already know he has a great memory and kind of did his homework you could get villagers up there to testify which they certainly did but they're biased you could compare them physically which they did but it seems like that didn't matter much because some people knew Like, for sure, he had different foot size. And also, they didn't, you know, have the kind of photographs and handwriting comps and stuff like that. It was a lot easier to get away with something like this back then.
Plus, also, for just about everybody who said, oh, no, his nose was long and flat. Right. Others would say, no, no, it was short and pointy. Like this guy. Right, exactly. Plus, I mean, you've got no fingerprinting, no DNA tests, not even, like, standardized stuff like driver's licenses or passports. There weren't even like wagon licenses at the time. So there really wasn't any way, but to hear as many people as possible and then just thoughtfully kind of sort through their testimony. And that first trial at Ryu, Martin Gare at a time, or I should say Arnaud Dutille, at a time when a lot of people would have shrunk at the challenge.
Yeah. rose to the challenge. Maybe more than anybody ever living would have. Like, this guy defended his honor as much as the real Martin Gare would have. Probably more, actually, as we'll see, as we saw. The other thing I wanted to bring up, too, is like, I would say so much of this was impacted solely on the fact that a lot of people like this guy. Yeah. You know? And they like the new Martin, and they're not going to go in there in 16th century France and cause a big stink. They're going to say, no, I think it's him. He knew this story, and he's got that. I remember that nose. And what's the foot size anyway?
Those feet can change sizes, right? What do we even know about that? Yeah, this is what this guy said. So he cross-examined witnesses against him. And for that shoemaker in particular, he said, this man is a drinking companion of Pierre Guerre. Right. Let him show his records about the size of my feet. Right. He also confronted a man who was his uncle from Sahas, who was Arnaud Dutille's uncle, who said, yeah, that's Arnaud Dutille who's cross-examining me right now. He said, I've never seen this man before in my life, and he's my uncle. Why can't he produce other members of my family that say so?
That's what a confidence person does. A pecan man is, like, so adamant in their beliefs that that's what they use to trick you. Yes, and again, it wasn't just him. Bertrand was saying, this man is my husband. I would rather suffer a thousand cruel deaths than say otherwise. His sisters did too, right? Yes, that was a big one. So, all four of Martin Gare's sisters came and testified at this trial that, nope, this is our brother. Like, he's our brother. I don't know what else we can say. And yet, despite the testimony in favor of him, the judge in Ryu said, no, I think you're an imposter and I'm going to find you guilty.
That's right. pay to a public apology in a ceremony, pay your wife 2,000 francs, and this one other little tidbit, we're going to behead you and corner you. And he went, oh, how about we, is there such a thing as appealing to a higher court? And they said, well, unfortunately there is. And so now we will talk about the second trial. Yeah. This was like to the appellate court, this group of like the finest legal minds in France. They were called the, what were they called, Chuck Hollen? The Parliament, the Criminal Chamber of the Parliament of Toulouse. Okay. So, they were basically, like I said, the finest legal minds in France who were coming together to hear this story that was pretty much sweeping the, not just the nation, but like this part of Europe.
Yeah. That there's this guy who's being called an imposter who's defending himself, and this whole town is split about whether he is who he says he is. And one of the judges in the case was Jean de Corras, who went on to actually write the first and earliest account of this case. He actually wrote two of them. He wrote a sequel that delved a little more into Arnaud Dutille's life. But the people who came together to hear this case basically got an even better version of what had happened in Ryu. That's right. And another example here early on in this trial of Bertrand being very savvy with her moves because she was basically like, hey, listen, I'm not going to say that this man is an imposter.
I think he is my husband. But if he's not, he sure fooled me. Right, exactly. Not my fault. Yeah. He also, so this is another thing too. So the judges really wanted this guy to be the real guy. Yeah. De Coros says that they put more weight to the affirmative testimony because— Oh, they wanted him to be Martin? Yeah. Okay. They wanted him to be that. Yeah, they wanted him to not be an imposter. Gotcha. So, they put more weight into affirmative testimony because they felt that it was more positive than, say, like negative testimony, which was destructive, which makes sense in a legal, like a certain way legally.
But more than that, the affirmative testimony also affirmed this marriage and this family and this household that was already intact and that didn't want to be split apart. It's not like Bertrand was saying, this man is not my husband. She's saying, he is my husband. Please leave us alone. Yeah, yeah. Judges wanted to support that. And Arnaud de Til gave them heaping mountains fulls of stuff to go ahead and go along with this. And he actually, he stood up to all this testimony, did it again. He survived all these memory tests. Bertrand hung in there. He got so good, Chuck, that he on the stand said, I just want you to know I forgive you for having to testify against me.
I know you don't want to, but I forgive you. I don't hold it against you, dear wife. That's how much I love you. And those judges were like, swoon. I wish I was Bertrand. And he actually, he won them over, Chuck. And they were about to rule in his favor that he was Martin Gare. And everybody just shut up about it from now on. Except there was a twist that happened, huh? Yeah. And this would be great for an ad break, but we've already done it. So we'll just say very simply, a man walks in with a wooden leg. in the movie version. I'm sure in the movie version, it didn't happen quite like that. But the real Martin Gere, please stood up.
And all of a sudden, there he was. He's back. The real deal. No one knows why he came back exactly. The speculation is that he heard about this story because it traveled, like you said, kind of throughout this region of Europe. And that he was like, wait a minute. I'm a jerk and I'm not going to let this stand. Right. So he showed up like at almost the last minute that he could have. I'm sure if he showed up later they would have reopened the case but they hadn't yet ruled but they were about to rule in Arnaud's favor. Like the gavel is up in the movie version. And this guy shows up and says wait I'm the real Martin Gare.
Basically. And they treated him like he was potentially an imposter first too. They took him into custody. They questioned him separately and they questioned him and they questioned our node on the same old memories. And both of them responded like equally well. So the judges are like, oh my God, what is going on here? They'd never had a case like this before. But the thing that I think clinched everything is when he came to the court, when he was presented in court, his family all recognized him. His sisters all said, oh my God, we were wrong. This guy is our real brother. And then Bertrand said, And she gulped very heavily, was maybe heard to say under her breath, well, I guess the jig is up, and threw herself at the feet of Martin Gare and said, I have been duped.
I'm so sorry. I can't believe that this imposter got me, but I was fooled. Please forgive me. Yeah, I was desperate. I wanted my husband back. And this guy tricked me. And I was willing to overlook the differences because I wanted you back so bad, my dear Martin. And it's really interesting. He said he was not, well, two things. First of all, during all this, Arnaud was like, he kept up that con man thing and like went on the attack against Martin. You know, like you're the imposter in a big, big way, which really helped. But then Martin was basically, you know, as far as Bertrand goes, he said, leave, and this is a shortened quote, but leave aside these tears.
The wife ought to know her husband. No one is to blame but you. Yeah. So he wasn't having it. No, he was not having it. And the judges even said, well, hey, man, maybe have a little heart. Like, you're the one who left her eight years ago. Yeah, exactly. And Martin said, silence. That is not a crime. And the judges were like, that's true. It's not a crime. So you just go ahead and keep being a jerk. But we just wanted to put one on your wife's behalf. But she got off. She did not. The judges did not rule against her. they determined that she had been duped and that the entire blame was squarely on the shoulders of Arnaud Dutille, who would now, yes, be sentenced to death.
Right. And not only was she let off, but they were very kind to the daughter that she had with Martine initially, because technically, as far as the law was concerned, that would make her a bastard. Or not Martine, but Arnaud, right? Right. Yes. I'm all confused. That would make her a bastard, which meant she couldn't get inheritance and stuff like that. But they said no at the time. She thought it was her husband, so we're going to make an exception here. So they really did her a couple of favors. But when it came to Arnaud, they really didn't know what to sentence because they had never done anything like this before.
So they said, well, I guess let's kind of go with what the other people were saying. Let's kill you, but we'll just hang you and burn your body. We won't quarter you and behead you. Right, right. I also saw that he was sentenced to be hanged while barefoot and bareheaded. And I cannot for the life of me find what the problem was with that. I think it was just an insult maybe, but. Probably, like see his face. Yeah, I guess. But also you see his ugly feet too. Yeah, well, his feet that are smaller now. And maybe it's also more you need to look upon the people that you have betrayed. Right. Yeah, that's a good one.
That's good. So his sentence was carried out in Artigat, and they actually built the gallows in front of Martin Gare's house. Yeah. Just to give him like a really great view of the whole thing or something like that. He could keep working until the last minute making tiles and then come out and be like, all right, let's go. Right. And Arnode was marched through town, and he finally now, he was like, okay, I'm just going to take full credit for this and admitted everything, didn't he? Yeah. But you guys like me, right? Right. But he's like, I got you guys so good. Yeah, pretty much. He commended the judges for their work.
He walked through town with the noose around his neck because they made him carry his own noose around his neck. And I think at the end, appealed to Martin, like, hey, be nice to your wife, dude. Like, I fooled her. She's a woman of honor. Like, don't take this out on her. Which is pretty great because he could have, out of spite or out of whatever, he could have, like, outed her or even not said anything. But he, from to the very end, he declared that she had no idea and had nothing to do with it. And if you go through, you know, Natalie Zeman Davis' lens, that was a really loving gesture and it reminds you of like these two were probably like deeply in love with one another.
Yeah. And also like it's no short it's no small thing even like in the time of very high infant mortality rates Chuck that they lost a child together and that surely bonded them even further. So like the loss that was created at the return of Martin Gare this marriage this actual happy but imposter and illegitimate marriage was torn apart by the legitimate version, but how legitimate was it? You know what I'm saying? If it was that unhappy. Like this man, the real man, managed to interlope into something even more real than what he had created with his own wife. Yeah, that's a very confusing statement, but I totally get it.
And it also makes it really sad that Arnaud was executed and I'm sure Bertrand had to watch and pretend like she was happy about it. Yeah, no one really knows what happened in the end to Bertrand and Martine, the real Martine. Not a lot of details, but they do know that there were three more sons. But, you know, I don't necessarily means, I don't think that necessarily means they reconciled and were happy. This was the 16th century. He could have forced himself upon her by all I know. I guess, but they did stay together. And I'm sure he could have gotten a divorce even in Catholic French law at the time.
but that so his the illegitimate daughter arnaud and bertrand's daughter she went to live with the very uncle that arnaud had said he had never seen him in his life on the stand oh really yeah that's that's who went and took care of her and chuck our version of the movie ends i think with um little bernard growing up a little bit and saying uh uncle can you tell me about my dad and the uncle and Bernard start walking back to the house from the barn and the uncle says, kid, you wouldn't believe it if I tried. That's great. Don't you think? Perfect ending. Okay, yeah. So since Chuck said perfect ending, I think that means that it's time for listener mail.
You know what? In lieu of listener mail, we do this a couple of times a year when we rarely ask for support in helping to spread the word. even here in year 13. We still want to grow the Stuff You Should Know audience and make sure people are tuning in. So tell a friend or a neighbor or a family member about Stuff You Should Know, if you would. And review and rate us on iTunes, because that always helps. iTunes, Spotify, wherever you find podcasts. Wherever you find podcasts. We always appreciate it. This is the show that grew very organically because of this kind of thing many years ago. And we don't ask for it much, but we continue to count on that for growth.
Yes. So thank you to everybody who's ever rated or reviewed us. And thank you just for listening too. We appreciate you guys listening, even if you don't lift a finger. Amen. Well, since Chuck said amen, that's the end of this episode, which I think I've already done. I'm losing my mind. And if you want to get in touch with us, you can send us an email to stuffpodcast at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio. For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows. Living with an autoimmune condition isn't easy, and every journey is different.
That's why Season 5 of Untold Stories, Life with a Severe Autoimmune Condition, from Ruby Studio and Argenix, shares powerful firsthand stories from people with conditions like MG and CIDP. Hosted by Martine Hackett, these conversations dive into what resilience really looks like through setbacks, breakthroughs, and finding strength in community. Listen on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Attention parents and grandparents. If you're looking for a gift that's more than just a toy, give them something that inspires confidence and adventure all year long. Give them a Guardian bike, the easiest, safest, and number one kid's bike on the market.
Yeah, with USA-made kid-specific frames and patented safety technology, kids are learning to ride in just one day with no training wheels needed. It's why Guardian is America's favorite kid's bike and the New York Times and Wirecutter's top pick three years in a row. That's right. My daughter has a Guardian bike, and she loves it, and that thing was really easy to put together. And get this, this holiday season, Guardian is offering their biggest deal of the year, over 40% in savings on all bikes, plus $100 in free accessories. Guardian Bikes have become one of the most sought-after gifts of the season, and inventory is going fast, so don't wait.
Join over a half a million families who've discovered the magic of Guardian. Visit guardianbikes.com to shop now. In Orlando, meetings reach another level, thanks to a growing list of award-winning restaurants, a world-class convention center, a great hotel community, easy access through the airport, and, of course, the weather. Andrew Moyes, VP of Fan Expo HQ, had this to say about Orlando. Luxury hotels, Michelin restaurants, easy access through the airport, all those key things feed into the proper executive experience. And while you may know Orlando for its attractions, industries like healthcare, aerospace, and advanced manufacturing make it a hub for cutting-edge businesses.
And that's what makes Orlando unbelievably real. Learn more at OrlandoForBusiness.com. Toyota-thon is on. So stop by your local Toyota dealer for incredible year-end deals on the cars, trucks, and SUVs known for their legendary reliability. Like the stylish and efficient Camry. The ready for anything RAV4. Or check out a rough and rugged Tacoma or Tundra. All with great financing and lease options available to qualified customers. Visit buyatoyota.com to find out more. Toyota. Let's go places. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.